群体决策支持系统沟通模式研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
沟通作为人际信息交流与共享的过程,在工作与日常生活中起着基础性的作用,在人们使用群体决策支持系统进行决策的过程中,沟通在很大程度上决定了决策的正确性,群体决策支持系统的沟通模式也逐渐成为近年来研究的一个焦点,信息在沟通过程中的传递形式,信息传递渠道,信息载体的多样性,如何处理信息不对称以及群体思维对决策过程的影响等问题都是沟通模式的研究重点。本文在对比了传统群体决策沟通方式(FTF)与传统以计算机为中介的群体决策(text-CM)的相关研究成果之后,发现群体决策沟通模式是提高决策质量的重要影响因素。群体决策沟通模式是指群体成员使用何种方式来加工信息、考虑备择项和作出选择的过程。在这一过程中,参与者原本获得的信息往往是不对称的,如何使得参与者之间能够获得更好的信息沟通,信息以什么样的结构通过什么样的渠道在参与者之间传递,群体决策过程如何组织,如何消除因为权威专家发言而产生的群体思维,增加参与决策人员对于决策过程的满意度,都是本文研究的问题。
     本文首先用实验针对不同的群体决策沟通模式进行问卷调查和结果分析,得出沟通过程中问题重要存在于信息交换频率较低,成员获得信息不对称等方面。针对群体决策系统中,信息载体单一、散乱的问题,提出了以图尔敏结构模型为载体的信息表达方式,并将之运用在群体决策支持系统的数据模型中。以基于涌现的Multi-agent群体决策支持系统协同框架来协调群体成员之间的沟通与认知,针对群体决策沟通过程中经常存在的信息不对称、群体思维等情况,设计了逻辑合理的决策流程,提出了系统运行的逻辑模型。更引入了以JXTA为框架模型的P2P网络来丰富信息沟通的渠道,较好的解决了信息不对称,群体思维,信息传递形式单一等问题。
     论文的最后总结了系统的优势和需要改进之处。
As a process of information exchange and share, interpersonal communication plays a fundamental role in the work and everyday life. In the process of using group decision support system for decision-making, communication has a large extent determine of the decision-making. The mode of group decision support system of communication is becoming a focus of research in recent years, transfer form of the information in the communication, information transmission channels, the diversity of information carriers, how to deal with asymmetric information, as well as group-thinking of the implications of the decision-making process the mode of communication are the focus of the study.In this paper, comparing the traditional group decision-making mode of communication (FTF) and traditional computer-mediated group decision-making (text-CM) related research, and found that mode of group decision-making communication is to improve the quality of decision-making an important factor. The mode of group decision-making communication refers to the manner in which group members use to process information, to consider alternative options and make choices about the process. Participants in the process of group decision-making tend to have the information asymmetry, but if the members of an over-reliance on a particular information-sharing, it's easy to form groups of thinking. At the decision-making process, members were forced to introduce cognitive to consider the alternative of each item in the controversy. In order to enhance the decision-making effectiveness, but it is not focus on reaching consensus for the purpose, and undermining the satisfaction with the decision-making process.
     In this paper, the experimental group decision-making for different communication patterns questionnaire and the results of analysis resulted in an important communication problem in the process of information exchange exist in the lower frequency, the members of access to information asymmetry and so on. In order to solve the information carrier single, scattered issues in group decision-making system, it put forward a Toulmin structure model as the carrier of information expression. And use the data model in the group decision support systems. It also uses Emerging-based Multi-agent group decision support system for collaborative framework to coordinate communication between group members and awareness of communication for group decision-making process. There is always information asymmetry, group thinking, and so on in the communication of group decision-making process, so the design of logic and rational decision-making process put forward a logical model of the system is running. It also introduced the JXTA and P2P network model as a framework to enrich the communication channels, a better solution to the information asymmetry, group thinking, information transmission form a single and soon.
     At last.Paper concluded the system's strengths and needs improvement.
引文
[1]李向军,李华.AHP中复合判断矩阵的一致性研究[J].西安联合大学学报,2003,10:74-77
    [2]邱菀华.管理决策与应用熵学[M].北京:机械工业出版社,2002
    [3]魏存平.群体决策中的偏好信息集结的理论与应用研究:[博士论文],北京:北京航空航天大学,1999
    [4]Luce R. D.Howard Raifa, Games and Decisions, New York John Wiley &Sons Inc,1957.
    [5]Desanctis G, Gallupe R B.A foundation for the study of group decision support systems. Management Science,1987,33(5):589-608
    [6]郭春香,郭耀煌.一种不同偏好信息下的多目标群决策方法[J].四川工业学院学报,2004,23(1):54-55
    [7]李怀祖.决策理论导引[M].北京:机械工业出版社,1993
    [8]卢相毅,席酉民GDSS:个体偏好公布与认知反馈[J].管理科学学报,1999,1(2):44-46
    [9]杨雷.群体决策理论与应用[M].经济科学出版社,2004
    [10]Mario S. Catatani, Giuseppe F. Clerico, Decision Making Structures, Physica-Verlag,1994
    [11]Zimmermann, H. J. Fuzzy Sets, Decision Making, and Expert Systems, Kluwer Academic Publishers,1987
    [12]张玉峰.决策支持系统[M].武昌:武汉大学出版社,2004
    [13]李伟华.多媒体群体决策支持系统:理论·方法·应用[M].西安:西北工业大学出版社,2001
    [14]黄深泽.一种模糊多属性的群体评价方法[J].科技与管理,2005,2:35-37
    [15]http://www.gmw.cn/01gmrb/1998-11/27/
    [16]王晓敏.多目标最优化和群体决策的若干理论和方法:[博士论文],上海交通大学,1999
    [17]Keeney R L, Kirkwood C W.A Group preference axiomatization with cardinal utility[J].Management Science,1976,23(2):140-145
    [18]Dyer L S, Surlin R K.Group preference aggregation rules based on strength of preference[J].Management Science,1979,25(9):22-34
    [19]周轩伟.群体决策和多目标决策的若干理论与方法:[博士论文],上海大学,2004
    [20]毕鹏程,席酉民,王益谊.群体发展过程中的群体思维演变研究[J].预测,2005,3:1-6
    [21]毕鹏程,席酉民,王益谊.群体思维理论的发展及其实证研究综述[J].管理科学学报,2004,4:75-84
    [22]J.Edward Russo,安宝生,徐联仓著.决策行为分析,北京师范大学出版社,1998
    [23]詹国枢.博弈理论[J].经济,2004,5:1-1
    [24]杨雷,席酉民.群体决策的权力与权力指数[J].系统工程,1996,14(2)
    [25]蒋御柱,张朋柱,张兴学.群体研讨支持系统中的智能可视化研究——共识评价、预测及分析技术[J].管理科学学报,2009.
    [26]钱学森,于景元,戴汝为.一个科学的新领域-开放的复杂巨系统及其方法论[J].自然杂志,1990(1):3-10.
    [27]DeSanctis G, Gallupe R B. A foundation for the study of group decesion support systems[J]. Management Science,1987 (5):589-609.
    [28]Trauth E M, J essup L M. Understanding computer mediated discussions:positivist and interpretive analysis of Group Support Systems use[J]. MIS Quarterly,2000 (1):43-79.
    [29]Connolly T, Routhieaux R L, Schneider S K. On the effectiveness of group brainstorming:test of one underlying cognitive mechanism [J]. Small Group Research,1993:4902503.
    [30]Grise M, Gallupe R B. Information overload:addressing the productivity paradox in Face-to-Face electronic meetings[J]. Journal of Management Information Systems,2000 (3):157-185.
    [31]Chen H, Hsu P, Orwig R, et al. Automatic concept classification of text from electronic meetings [J].Communication of the ACM,1994 (10):56273.
    [32]Gallupe R B, Cooper W H. Brainstorming elect ronically[J]. Sloan Management Review,1993 (1): 27-36.
    [33]Hiltz S R, Turoff M. St ructuring computer mediated communication systems to avoid information overload[J]. Communication of the ACM,1985 (7):680-689.
    [34]程少川,孙景乐,卢明德.群体决策争议的支持模式研究[J].系统工程学报,2001(5):366-370.
    [35]孙景乐,张朋柱.一种互补的研讨框架的设计与实现[J].系统工程学报,2001(5):3602365.
    [36]邱立坤,程葳,龙志祎,等.面向BBS的话题挖掘初探[C]//全国第八届计算语言学联合学术会议,2005.
    [37]Siegel J, Dubrovsky V, Kiesler S1 Group processes in computer-mediated communication 1 Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,1986,37(1):157-187
    [38]McGuire TW, Kiesler S, Siegel J1 Group and computer-mediate discussion effects in risk decisionmakingl Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,1987,52 (5):917-930
    [39]Kiesler S, Sp roull L1 Group decision making and communication technology Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,1992,52 (1):96-123
    [40]Lam S S, Schaubroeck J1 Imp roving group decisions by better pooling information:a comparative advantage of group decision support systems1 Journal of Applied Psychology,2000,85 (4):565-573
    [41]Baltes B B, Dickens M W, Sherman M P1 Computer-mediated communication and group decision making:a meta analysis Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,2002,87(1):156-179
    [42]Stasser G, Titus W1 Pooling of unshared information in group decision making1 Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,1985,48 (6),1467-1478
    [43]Mason R 01 A dialectical app roach to strategic planning Management Science,1969,15:403-414
    [44]Schwenk C R1 Effects of devil's advocacy and dialectical inquiry on decision-making:A meta-analysis1 Organizational behavior and human decision processes,1990,47 (1):79-95
    [45]Valacich J S, Schwenk C1 Devil's Advocacy and dialectical inquiry effects on face2to2 face and computer-mediated group decision making. Organization Behavior and Human Decision Process,1995,63 (2): 158-173
    [46]Dennis J D1 Effects of cognitive ability, task knowledge, information sharing, and conflict on group decision2making effectiveness 1 Small Group Research,1999,11:439-455
    [47]Wang H, Zhang K1 Group decision support system (GDSS) and psychology 1 Journal of Developments in Psychology,1995,3 (3):23-29(王辉,张侃1团体决策支持系统(GDSS)与心理学1心理学动态,1995,3(3):23-29)
    [48]Xi YM, Wang YL, Wang KL, et all An experimental exploration of group size under GDSS environment Decision Making and Decision Support System,1997,7 (2):1-10(席酉民,汪应洛,王刊良等GDSS环境下群体大小的实验研究决策与决策支持系统,1997,7(2):1~10)
    [49]Wang H, Liu Y F, Zhang K1 The effects of group decision support system (GDSS) and group discussion on decision making Acta Psychologica Sinica,2003,35 (2):190-194((王辉,刘艳芳,张侃1团体决策支持系统和团体讨论对团体决策的影响1 心理学报,2003,35(2):190~194)
    [50]Zheng Q Q, Li H1 Comparison between face2to2face and computer-mediated group s on decision2making in idea2generation task1 Acta Psychologica Sinica,2003,35 (4):492-498(郑全全,李宏面对面和计算机群体决策在观点产生上的比较心理学报,2003,35(4):492~498)
    [51]Straus S G, McGrath J E1 Does the medium matter? The interaction of task type and technology on group performance and member reactions1 Journal of App lied Psychology,1994,79 (1):87-97
    [52]冯睿.利用JMF进行多媒体编程[EB/OL]. http://www.javaresearch.org/article/32926.htm.
    [53]实现基于RTP/RTSP的流媒体服务器[EB/OL]. http://www.csee.umbc.edu/pmundur/courses/CMSC691C/lab5-kurose-ross.html.
    [54]jxta探索:双向管道(Bi-directional Pipe)的实现和原理剖析[EB/OL]. http://blog.csdn.net/yanqlv/archive/2004/10/23/jxtal.aspx.
    [55]P2P的Jxta解决之道[EB/OL]. http://www.yesky.com/SoftChannel/72342371961929728/20020330/1604476.shtml.
    [56]吕廷杰.P2P网络模型和C/S网络模型的比较[J].北京邮电学,2005,16(7):23-25.
    [57]P2P技术/P2P编程[EB/OL]. http://www.ppcn.net.
    [58]JXTA[EB/OL].http:blog.csdn.net/nema/archive/2004/08/15/75085.asp.
    [59]p2p点对点对等计算[EB/OL]. http://www.huihoo.com/p2p/index.html.
    [60]钟玉琢,向哲,沈洪.流媒体和视频服务器[M].北京:清华大学出版社.2003.
    [61]方群,王敏,吉逸.基于RTSP/RTP的媒体点播服务器的设计与实现[J].计算机工程与设计,2006,27(1):4-6.
    [62]用Jbuilder9开发媒体播放器[EB/OL]. http://www.yesky.com/SoftChannel/72342371961929728/20040607/1805587_3.shtml.
    [63]流媒体世界[EB/OL]. http://www.lmtw.com.
    [64]Robert Flenner, Michael Abbott, Toufic Boubez, Frank Cohen,Navaneeth Krishnan, Alan Moffet, Rajam Ramamurti, Bilal Siddiqui, Frank Sommers. Java P2P Unleashed[M]. Sams Publishing,2003.
    [65]龙伟,刘志勤.基于JXTA的CMS内容共享[J].兵工自动化,2004,23(6):86-88.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700