基于循环经济的企业运行机制、模式及评价研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
循环经济是倡导与自然环境相和谐的经济发展模式,以实现资源利用的最大化,废物排放的最小化为目标。循环型经济发展模式被认为是从根本上消解长期以来环境与发展之间的尖锐冲突、实现人与自然和谐发展的途径。企业作为经济活动的微观主体,在循环经济中占据着重要的不可替代的地位,是全社会发展循环经济的基础。发展循环经济离不开企业,企业循环经济的发展决定了全社会循环经济建设的成败。因此,研究企业发展循环经济具有重要的理论与现实意义
     本文首先讨论了循环经济的理论基础,主要包括:可持续发展理论、工业生态学理论、系统科学、企业演化论、生产责任延伸制等,这些理论为深入研究企业发展循环经济,构建循环型企业的模式提供了理论支撑。传统体制下企业行为与循环经济下企业行为有着很大的差异:经营目标从追求自身利润最大化转变为经济效益与生态效益相结合,循环经济下企业要自觉地把环境资源价值纳入到生产核算体系中去,作为制定企业决策和衡量企业效益的重要依据,循环经济下企业必须更多地应用减量技术、再利用技术、资源化技术等循环经济的技术,环境质量的改善与循环型企业经济效益的提高是可以同时实现的。循环经济下,资源环境因素被内生化到企业生产函数中,计算资源成本和环境成本条件下的企业行为最优化与传统企业有很大的不同。
     企业发展循环经济具有正的外部性,也面临一些难题:成本上升、技术限制、价格障碍等。发展循环经济,必须充分发挥市场的基础调节作用,政府的引导和监督作用,把各方利益当作连接各主体的重要纽带,建立相应的利益协调机制。本文分析了企业发展循环经济的动力机制,构建了政府、消费者和企业多主体博弈模型。通过分析可以得到以下结论:外部主体的行为选择(政府和消费者的策略)决定企业生产行为的选择;由于消费者对绿色产品和伪绿色产品存在着逆向选择,因此政府必须对消费市场进行干预,政府还可以采取补贴和有效的激励、监督等手段推动企业发展循环经济。
     国外已经形成了企业循环经济成功模式,如杜邦模式和卡伦堡模式,对推动循环型企业的发展具有一定借鉴及指导意义。企业循环经济模式的共同点在于:清洁生产是核心,循环技术是关键,资源循环利用是目标,产业链是纽带。在发展循环经济的过程中,一些企业针对行业特点和企业自身的具体情况,成功地运用清洁生产技术,建立了产业系统中不同工艺流程和不同行业之间横向共生的循环经济模式。根据企业循环产业链形成的动力源、组合方式、联系纽带的不同,循环型企业的发展模式可分为矿产资源导向型、外向辐射主导型、技术创新推动型、企业自我延伸型、再生资源加工型企业五种模式,不同模式发展的侧重点各不相同,论文结合实际案例进行了具体分析。
     企业发展循环经济的核心是推行清洁生产,本文分析了清洁生产理论基础。企业推行清洁生产的动力在于市场竞争的压力、企业相关行为主体的激励与约束,企业推行清洁生产的阻力在于需要高固定资本投入、信息不对称、投资对清洁生产的监督不足,企业推行清洁生产的收益表现在:提高生产力、提升技术、增加出口、提升竞争力。本文还分别对资源节约、产品生态设计、清洁生产与ISO14000管理一体化战略进行了探讨。
     建立一套科学的评价指标体系有利于对企业发展循环经济进行客观的评价,对企业循环经济的发展提供指导,本文深入研究和总结国内外已有的相关评价指标的基础上,构建了企业循环经济的综合评价模型,同时设计出企业综合能力的评价等级,以对企业实行循环经济的状况作出真实、客观、公正的综合评价。最后在对全文进行总结基础上提出企业发展循环经济的发展对策。
Circular economy which promotes to be in harmony with the natural environment is an economic development mode. The goal of this kind of economic development mode is to achieve the maximization of resource utilization and minimize the waste discharge. Circular mode of economic development is considered to be fundamental resolution on the sharp conflict between environment and development for a long time, and it can realize harmonious development between human and nature. As a micro-object in economic activities, enterprise plays an important role, which can not be replaced, in circular economy. Enterprise is the basis of the whole society developing circular economy. Developing circular economy can not be separated from enterprises while the development of circular economy in enterprises determines the result of circular economic constructions on the whole society. Therefore, the research on the development of circular economy in enterprises has important theoretical and practical significance.
     Firstly, the dissertation discusses the theoretical basis for circular economy, including sustainable development theory, theory of industrial ecology, system science, business evolution theory, extension of the production responsibility system and so on. These theories study the development of circular economy for enterprises, and provide a theoretical support for building a circular business mode. There is a great contrast on business behavior between under the traditional system and under the circular economy: the pursuit of business objectives is from maximizing their own profits into combining economic benefits with ecological benefits. Under the condition of circular economy, enterprises should consciously put the value of environmental resources into the system of production accounting. Circular economy is the important basis of establishing decision-making and measuring the benefit of enterprises. Under this kind of economic mode, enterprises must apply such circular economic technologies as reducing technology, reuse technology, resource technology. The improvement of environmental quality and economic efficiency of circular enterprises can be achieved at the same time. Under the circular economy, the factors of resources and environment are put into the production function of enterprises. The behaviors of enterprises are optimized under the condition of computing the cost of resources and environment, so it is quite different from the traditional enterprises.
     The development of circular economy for enterprises not only has positive external characteristics but also face some challenges: rising costs, technical limitations, price barriers and so on. To develop circular economy, we should bring market-based regulation, the guidance and supervision of government into full play, we should regard the interests of all parties as an important link to connect all the main objects, and then establish coordinated mechanisms. This dissertation analyzes the power mechanism of the development of circular economy for enterprises and constructs a multi-objects game model among a government, consumers and businesses. By analyzing the model, the conclusions are as follows: the external behavior of the main choices (the strategy of government and consumers) determines the choices of production behaviors; because there is a pseudo-adverse selection when consumers are facing with green products and fake green products, government has to intervene on the consumer market. The government can also encourage enterprises to develop circular economy by taking some effective means such as subsidies and incentives, monitoring and other means.
     Foreign companies have formed a successful mode of circular economy, such as DuPont mode and Kalumborg mode, there is a certain reference and guide for promoting circular economy of enterprises. The common points of circular economy modes of enterprises are as follows: cleaning production is the core, recycling technology is the key point, recycling of resources is a goal, industry chain is a link. In the process of developing circular economy, some enterprises applied the cleaning production technology successfully aiming at the features of the industry and specific circumstances of themselves, established a horizontal pattern of circular economy between industrial systems and different processes in different sectors of the symbiosis. According to the business circular industrial chain formed by the power source, the combination of methods, different linkage, the types of circular business modes can be divided into five-business modes, including the development of mineral resources-oriented, outward radiation-based, technology-driven innovation, enterprise self-extended and the processing of renewable resources.
     The core of developing circular economy for enterprises is to promote the cleaning production. This dissertation analyzes the theoretical basis of cleaning production. The motivation for enterprises to promote the cleaning production is because of the pressure from market competition, incentive and restraint from the relevant actors in the enterprises. While the resistances for enterprises are high fixed capital investment, asymmetric information, lacking enough investment on the supervision of cleaning production. The benefits for businesses to promote the technology are as follows, increasing productivity, upgrading technology, increasing exports and enhancing competitiveness. In this dissertation, the conservation of resources, products eco-design, cleaning production and the strategy of ISO14000 management integration are also discussed.
     Establishing a science evaluating guideline system is in favor of evaluating circular economy of enterprise objectively and supervising the development of enterprise circular economy. By deeply studying the internal and external relevant evaluating guidelines, the dissertation constructs the comprehensive evaluation mode of enterprise circular economy, and designs the evaluating grade of enterprise comprehensive capability to make true, objective, and fair evaluation on the situation of the enterprise developing circular economy. Finally, it summaries the whole dissertation and presents the measures for enterprise to develop circular economy.
引文
[1] Allen L., Clark J.C. The new reality of mineral development: social and cultural issues in Asia and Pacific nations. Resources Policy, 1999,25(3): 189—196
    
    [2] Alshuwaikhat H.M. Strategic environmental assessment can help solve environmental impact assessment failures in developing countries. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 2005,25(4): 307-317
    [3] Associates P. Eco-Industrial Network: Devising Practical Tools for Success. Canadian conference on Eco-Parks.1998, March 26
    [4] Arrow K.J. The economic implication of learning by doing. Review of Economic Studies, 1962,29(80), 155-173
    [5] Ayres R.U. Metals recycling: economic and environmental implications. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 1997,21(3): 145-173
    [6] Ayres R.U., Jeroen C. J. A theory of economic growth with material/energy resources and dematerialization: interaction of three growth mechanisms. Ecological Economics, 2005, 55(1): 96-118
    [7] Azapagic A., Perdan S. Indicators of sustainable development for industry: a general framework. Process Safety and Environmental Protection, 2000, 78(4): 243-261
    [8] Berg S.V. Sustainable regulatory systems: laws, resources, and values. Utilities Policy, 2000,9(4): 159-170
    [9] Berkel R.V. Integrating the environmental and sustainable development agendas into minerals education. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2000, 8(5): 413-423
    [10] Branscomb L.M. Sustainable cities: safety and security. Technology in Society, 2006, 28(1-2): 225-234
    
    [11] Burnside C. Production function regression, returns to scale, and externalities. Journal of Monetary Economics, 1996, 37(2): 177-201
    
    [12] Cabezas H., Fath B.D. Towards a theory of sustainable systems. Fluid Phase Equilibria, 2002,194-197: 3-14
    [13] Calcott P., Walls M. Can downstream waste disposal policies encourage upstream "Design for environment"? The American Economic Review, 2000,90(2): 233-237
    [14] Camagni R., Capello R., Nijkamp P. Towards sustainable city policy: an economy-environment technology nexus. Ecological Economics, 1998, 24(1): 103-118
    [15] Cantlon J.E., Koenig H.E. Sustainable ecological economies. Ecological Economics, 1999,31(1): 107-121
    [16] Clemen R.A. Byproducts in the packing industry. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1927
    [17] Cote R.P., Smolenaars T. Supporting pillars for industrial ecosystem. Journal of Cleaner Production, 1997, 5,(1-2): 67-74
    
    [18] Coase R.H. The nature of the firm. Economic, 1937,4(16): 386-405
    [19] Dellink R., Bennis M., Verbruggen H. Sustainable economic structures. Ecological Economics, 1999, 29(1): 141-154
    [20] Dobos I., Richter K. An extended production/recycling model with stationary demand and return rates. International Journal of Production Economics, 2004, 90(3): 311-323
    [21] Ehrenfeld J., Gertler N. Industrial ecology in practice: the evolution of interdependence at Kalundborg. Journal of Industrial Ecology, 2008,1(1): 67-79
    [22] Elshkaki A., Voet E.V., Holderbeke M.A., et al. The environmental and economic consequences of the developments of lead stocks in the Dutch economic system. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 2004,42(2): 133-154
    [23] Endress L.H., Roumasset J.A., Zhou T. Sustainable growth with environmental spillovers. Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 2005, 58(4): 527-547
    [24] Faucheux S., Froger G., Noel J.F. What forms of rationality for sustainable development? The Journal of Socio-Economics, 1995,24(1): 169-209
    [25] Frijns J., Vliet B.V. Small-scale industry and cleaner production strategies. World Development, 1999,27(6): 967-983
    [26] Fresner J. Cleaner production as a means for effective environmental management. Journal of Cleaner Production, 1998, 6(3-4): 171-179
    [27] Frosch R.A., Gallopoulos N.E. Strategies for manufacturing. Scientific American, 1989,261(3): 144-152
    [28] Gertler N. Industrial Ecosystems: developing sustainable industrial structures: [M.S. thesis]. Cambridge: Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 1995
    [29] Gibbs D. Industrial symbiosis and eco-industrial development: an introduction. Geography Compass, 2008,2(4): 1138-1154
    [30] Graciela C. What is sustainable development? Land economics, 1997, 73(4): 467-491
    [31] Groth C., Schou P. Growth and non-renewable resources: the different roles of capital and resource taxes. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 2007, 53(1): 80-98
    [32] Gutes M.C. The concept of weak sustainability. Ecological Economics, 1996, 17(3): 147-156
    [33] Haque S.M. Environmental discourse and sustainable development: linkages and limitations. Ethics and the Environment, 2000, 5(1): 3-21
    [34] Hofkes M.W. Modelling sustainable development: an economy-ecology integrated model. Economic Modelling, 1996,13(3): 333-353
    [35] Hu D., Wang R.S.,Yan J.S., et al. A pilot ecological engineering project for municipal solid waste reduction, disinfection, regeneration and industrialization in Guanghan City, China. Ecological Engineering, 1998,11(1-4): 129-138
    [36] Juan M.A. Ecological economics: energy, environment, and society. New York: Oxford Press, 1987
    [37] Kletzan D., Koppl A., Kratena K, et al. Towards sustainable consumption: Economic modelling of mobility and heating for Austria. Ecological Economics, 2006, 57(4): 608-626
    [38] Korhonen J., Wihersaari M. Industrial ecology of a regional energy supply system: the case of the Jyvaskyla region, Finland. Greener Management International, 1999, (26): 57-67
    [39] Korhonen J. Regional industrial ecology: examples from regional economic systems of forest industry and energy supply in Finland. Journal of Environmental Management, 2001,63(4): 367-375
    [40]Lambert,A.D.,Stoop M.L.Processing of discarded household refrigerators:lessons from the Dutch example.Journal of Cleaner Production,2001,9(3):243-252
    [41]Lindhqvist T.Extended Producer Responsibility as a Strategy to Promote Cleaner Production.Proceedings of an invitational expert seminar,Trolleholm Castle,1992,May 4-5
    [42]Lowe E.A.Creating by-product resource exchanges:Strategies for eco-industrial parks.Journal of Cleaner Production,1997,5(1-2):57-65
    [43]Lowe E.A.,Moran S.,Holmen A.A Fieldbook for the Development of Eco-Industrial Parks,Final Report.Oakland:Indigo Development,1996
    [44]Lynn M.Primary resource use and voluntary recycling schemes:Dynamic issues in a global context.Resource and Energy Economics,1995,17(4):341-356
    [45]Masui T,Morita T,Kyogoku J.Analysis of recycling activities using multi-sectoral economic model with material flow.European Journal of Operational Research,2000,122(2):405-415
    [46]Miller G.,Burke J.,McComas C,et al.Advancing pollution prevention and cleaner production-USA's contribution.Journal of Cleaner Production,2008,16(6):665-672
    [47]Mirata M.Experiences from early stages of a national industrial symbiosis programme in the UK:determinants and coordination challenges.Journal of Cleaner Production,2004,12(8-10):967-983
    [48]Moffatt I.,Hanley N.Modelling sustainable development:systems dynamic and input-output approaches.Environmental Modelling & Software,2001,16(6):545-557
    [49]Nakamura S.An inter-industry approach to analyzing economic and environmental effects of the recycling of waste.Ecological Economics,1999,28(1):133-145
    [50]North C.D.,Thomas R.P.The Rise of the western world.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,1973
    [51]Palmer K.,Sigrnan H.,Walls M.The cost of reducing municipal solid waste.Journal of Environmental Economics and Management,1997,33(2):128-150
    [52]Papinniemi J.Creating a model of process innovation for reengineering of business and manufacturing. International Journal of Production Economics, 1999, 60-61: 95-101
    [53] Pento T. Industrial ecology of the paper industry. Water Science and Technology, 1999,40(11-12): 21-24
    [54] Quaddus M.A., Siddique M.A. Modelling sustainable development planning: a multi-criteria decision conferencing approach. Environment International, 2001, 27(2-3): 89-95
    [55] Roe, E.M. Sustainable development and Girardian economics. Ecological Economics, 1996,16(2): 87-93
    [56] Sardar M.N., Islam M.M., Clarke M. Corrigendum to "Making long-term economic growth more sustainable: evaluating the costs and benefits".Ecological Economics, 2004,49(1): 115
    [57] Schnitzer H., Ulgiati S. Less bad is not good enough: approaching zero emissions techniques and systems. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2007, 15(13-14): 1185-1189
    [58] Schwarz E.J., Steininger K.W. Implementing nature's lesson: the industrial recycling network enhancing regional development. Journal of Cleaner Production, 1997, 5(1-2): 47-56
    [59] Shepherd A., Ortolano L. Strategic environmental assessment for sustainable urban development. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 1996,16(4-6): 321-335
    [60] Singh A, Lou H.H., Yaws C.L., et al. Environmental impact assessment of different design schemes of an industrial ecosystem. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 2007, 51(2): 294-313
    [61] Smith C.S., McDonald G.T. Assessing the sustainability of agriculture at the planning stage. Journal of Environmental Management, 1998, 52(1): 15-37
    [62] Smith A. Waste reclaim: turning recycling into economic reality. Plastics, Additives and Compounding, 2001, 3(3): 18-22
    [63] Sonntag V. Sustainability-in light of competitiveness. Ecological Economics, 2000, 34(1): 101-113
    [64] Spangenberg J.H. Environmental space and the prism of sustainability: frameworks for indicators measuring sustainable development.Ecological Indicators,2002,2(3):295-309
    [65]Strothotte T.G.,Wustenhagen R.Structure of sustainable economic value in social entrepreneurial enterprises.Research on Technological Innovation,Management and Policy,2005,9(2):129-140
    [66]Tilman C.,Sandhu R.A model recycling program for Alabama.Resources,Conservation and Recycling 1998,24(3-4):183-190
    [67]Vita G.D.Macroeconomic effects of the recycling of waste derived from imported non-renewable raw materials.Resources Policy,1997,23(4):179-186
    [68]Wallner H.P.,Narodoslawsky M.The concept of sustainable islands:Cleaner production,industrial ecology and the network paradigm as preconditions for regional sustainable development.Fuel and Energy,1994,2(3--4):167-171
    [69]Word commission on environment and development.Our common future.Cambridge:Oxford University Press,1987
    [70]阿兰·兰德尔.资源经济学——从经济角度对自然资源和环境政策的探讨.北京:商务印书馆,1989
    [71]安小会.循环经济系统评价指标体系及其预警系统的分析与设计:[硕士论文].天津理工学院图书馆,2004
    [72]白玉华.广西发展循环经济研究:[硕士论文].广西大学图书馆,2005
    [73]鲍莫尔.福利经济与国家理论.北京:商务印书馆,1982
    [74]蔡永海,循环经济及其生态伦理底蕴.自然辩证法研究,2006(5):10-13
    [75]柴金艳.基于耗散结构理论的循环经济产业链优化.中原工学院学报,2006(6):12-17
    [76]车卉淳.资源耗竭原因的经济学分析.现代经探讨,2002(1):28-34
    [77]陈安宁.资源可持续利用激励机制.自然资源学报,2000(2):107-111
    [78]陈柏福,彭秀丽.试论循环经济的产权制度创新.新疆财经,2006(2):5-9
    [79]陈德敏,李柏楼,陈艳莲.循环经济发展模式中的企业行为分析.经济问题,2003(9):34-36
    [80]陈丽娜.区域循环经济的理论研究与实证分析:[博士论文].武汉理工大学图书馆,2006
    [81]陈秋计.煤炭主产区的生态足迹对比分析.中国煤炭,2006(2):34-36
    [82]陈锐,牛文元.循环经济:21世纪的理想经济模式.中国发展,2002(2):12-17
    [83]陈婷婷.浅谈生态化设计.天津科技,2007(1):47-48
    [84]陈文明.论清洁生产和工业企业管理.环境科学研究,1997(6):11-15
    [85]戴备军.循环经济实用案例.北京:中国环境科学出版社,2006
    [86]戴世明,吕锡武.循环经济的机理分析.南通职业大学学报,2004(18):9-11
    [87]戴维,皮尔斯,杰瑞米.世界无末日——经济学.环境与可持续发展.北京:中国财政出版社,1997
    [88]邓华,段宁.信息产业发展对能源消耗的影响研究初探.科学学与科学技术管理,2004(7):97-100
    [89]丁国勇.我国发展循环经济问题研究:[硕士论文].辽宁师范大学图书馆,2005
    [90]董辉,蔡九菊.一种新型烟气除尘脱硫脱氮一体化技术和装置研究.环境科学与技术,2005(6):70-71
    [91]杜欢政,张旭军.循环经济的理论与实践近期讨论综述.统计研究,2006(2):63-67
    [92]杜世勋,曹利军.循环经济技术范式和企业持续技术创新研究.管理评论,2005(2):37-40
    [93]段宁.清洁生产、生态工业和循环经济.环境科学研究,2001(6):3-7
    [94]冯久田.基于循环经济的生态工业理论研究与实证分析:[博士论文].武汉理工大学图书馆,2005
    [95]冯久田.中国鲁北生态工业模式的实践与发展.循环经济在实践.北京:人民出版社,2005
    [96]冯南平,杨善林.循环经济与产品定价机制改革.宏观经济管理,2006(1):42-44
    [97]冯之俊.循环经济在实践一中国循环经济高端论坛.北京:人民出版社,2005
    [98]冯之浚.论循环经济.中国软科学,2004(10):1-9
    [99]冯之浚.循环经济导论.北京:人民出版社,2004
    [100]高楠.循环经济导向下的企业行为模式选择及运行方案设计:[硕士学位论文].天津:天津财经大学图书馆,2006
    [101]高松.循环经济条件下企业的行为选择与政府激励.当代经理人,2006(5):50-52
    [102]谷永芬,洪娟.基于循环经济的制造业可持续发展系统运行模式研究.工业技 术经济,2007(4):65-68
    [103]顾春梅,郑小勇.绿色消费品市场的博弈分析及发展.科技进步与对策,2002(10):145-147
    [104]郭丕斌.企业进行清洁生产技术创新的影响因素分析.经济管理,2006(7):43-46
    [105]郭亚军,向来生.资源稀缺、企业创新与企业循环经济.技术经济,2006(11):80-82
    [106]郭亚军,向来生.资源稀缺、企业创新与企业循环经济.技术经济,2006(11):80-82
    [107]国家发改委煤炭行业循环经济课题组.煤炭行业发展循环经济的模式与对策.环境资源,2006(1):8-11
    [108]何华兵.中国煤炭企业循环经济发展模式探析.中国矿业,2006(5):28-32
    [109]赫尔曼,戴利.珍惜地球——经济学、生态学、伦理学.北京:商务印书馆,2001
    [110]胡安水.生态价值论视野下的循环经济.山东理工大学学报(社会科学版),2006(4):23-25
    [111]胡敬东,连向东.我国煤炭科技发展现状及展望.煤炭科学技术,2005(1):21-24
    [112]黄敬华.我国循环经济发展模式研究:[硕士学位论文].长春:东北师范大学,2006
    [113]黄少鹏.基于循环经济理念的煤炭生态工业园区建设.中国煤炭,2006(7):16-17
    [114]黄贤金.偱环经济:产业模式与政策体系.南京:南京大学出版社,2004
    [115]黄英娜,张天柱,颜辉武.循环经济产生和发展的经济学基础.环境保护,2004(8):33-35
    [116]黄志鸿.铜工业循环经济发展研究:[硕士学位论文].南昌:江西财经大学,2006
    [117]贾晓冬.浅谈循环经济在煤炭工业中的发展模式.山西能源与节能,2005(2):28-29
    [118]姜进章,文祥.人力作用机制及其政策.学术月刊,1999(12):9-15
    [119]蒋声汉.循环经济在化工行业的实践与思考.化工生产与技术,2005(12):46-48
    [120]金涌,李有润,冯久田.生态工业:原理与运用.北京:清华大学出版社,2003
    [121]金涌,循环经济的工程科学基础.浦东开发,2005(8):57-60
    [122]劳爱乐,耿勇.工业生态学和生态工业园.北京:化学工业出版社,2003
    [123]李彩红.化工行业循环经济的指标体系及效果评价.工业技术经济,2007(4):91-93
    [124]李德水,张为民.“循环经济评价指标体系”研究.统计研究,2006(9):23-26
    [125]李赋屏.广西矿业循环经济发展模式研究:[硕士论文].中国矿业大学图书馆,2005
    [126]李惠,对循环经济的理论研究和实证分析:[硕士论文].电子科技大学图书馆,2004
    [127]李健,邱立成,安小会.面向循环经济的企业绩效评价指标体系研究.中国人口·资源与环境,2004(4):121-125
    [128]李世龙.循环经济运行模式及其制度保障研究:[硕士论文].重庆大学图书馆,2006
    [129]李帅等.我国推行清洁生产的经济学分析.东北大学学报,2001(1):48-50
    [130]李永清,李芬.循环经济对企业行为影响的经济分析.工业技术经济,2006(9):125-126
    [131]李勇,郑垂勇.循环经济:一个理论模型的构建与分析.科技管理研究,2007(1):232-235
    [132]李兆国,齐建国.循环经济理论与实践综述.数量经济技术经济研究,2004(9):145-154
    [133]林积泉,王伯铎.煤炭工业企业循环经济产业链设计与环境效益研究.环境保护,2005(4):55-58
    [134]刘红艳.南非萨索尔公司煤基产业链对中国煤炭企业的启示.煤矿现代化,2002(2):7-9
    [135]刘萌芽,张长元.简论用分配机制驱动循环经济的实现.社会科学,2002(8):20-22
    [136]刘霞.基于循环经济的企业综合能力评价指标体系研究:[硕士论文].南京工业大学图书馆,2005
    [137]刘志淳,冯明,邓胜天.生态型煤矸石综合利用技术.中国环保产业,2003(7):31-34
    [138]陆钟武.企业发展循环经济需注意的几个问题.中国石化,2005(8):21-23
    [139]罗海梅.可持续发展战略下工业生产模式变化趋势的微观分析.生产力研究,2006(9):201-203
    [140]罗宏,孟伟,冉圣宏.生态工业园区一理论与实践.北京:化学工业出版社,2004
    [141]罗杰.帕曼,马越,詹姆斯.麦吉利夫雷.自然资源与环境经济学.北京:中国经济出版社,2002
    [142]罗俊霞,李忠斌.传统经济与循环经济条件下企业行为选择.中南民族大学学报(自然科学版),2005(3):110-112
    [143]罗马俱乐部关于人类困境的研究报告.增长的极限.成都:四川人民出版社,1984
    [144]罗云峰.博弈论教程.北京:清华大学出版社,2007
    [145]马驰,吴焱焱,汤临佳.传统经济和循环经济条件下企业的行为分析.北方经济,2006(9):24-25
    [146]马娜.生产者责任延伸制对环保和贸易的作用.上海标准化,2006(5):18-21
    [147]马云东.煤炭城市可持续发展能力评估方法及应用.辽宁工程大学学报(社会科学版),2002(7):17.19
    [148]毛锋,肖劲松,毛凤霞.循环经济与“双剩余”理论.北京大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2004(6):78-84
    [149]毛玉如,孙启宏,乔琦.焦化企业工业共生模式实证研究.现代化工,2006(2):6-12
    [150]孟晖.氯碱行业实施循环经济的模式介析.中国石油和化工经济分析,2006(18):27-31
    [151]牛桂敏.循环经济评价体系的构建.城市环境与城市生态,2005(4):4-7
    [152]牛文元.循环经济:实现中国可持续发展的理想经济模式.中国科学院院刊,2004(6):408-411
    [153]彭攀,丁丹.循环经济的系统分析.系统科学学报,2006(4):70-72
    [154]平狄克,鲁宾费尔德.微观经济学.北京:中国人民大学出版社,1997
    [155]平煤集团循环经济发展规划,2006
    [156]齐亚彬,贺冰清,王永生.在我国资源领域发展循环经济的重点、方式及行动措施.资源科学,2005(7):112-117
    [157]曲格平.发展循环经济是2l世纪的大趋势.中国环保产业,2001(1):6-7
    [158]沈金生.循环经济外部效应与政府定位.生产力研究,2007(3):12-13
    [159]盛洪.外部性问题和制度创新.管理世界,1995(2):195-201
    [160]石磊,陈吉宁,张天柱.循环经济型生态城市规划框架研究——以贵阳市为例.中国人口·资源环境,2004(3):5-8
    [161]史捍民.企业清洁生产实施指南.北京:化学工业出版社,1997
    [162]史晓燕.基于循环经济的企业绩效评价.西安石油大学学报,2006(2):50-54
    [163]守秋,蔡文灿.循环经济立法研究——模式选择与范围限制.中国人口·资源与环境,2004(6):38-43
    [164]宋国华,夏林.循环经济在河南.郑州:河南科学技术出版社,2006
    [165]宋涛,郑挺国,韩良.两类典型产业生态系统的建模及比较研究.科学学研究,2006(1):444-447
    [166]苏玉娟.循环经济的控制论特征探析.系统科学学报,2006(4):73-75
    [167]唐晓龙,云南省部分企业清洁生产应用实例分析.安全与环境学报,2004(2):66-69
    [168]天冠集团循环经济发展规划,2006
    [169]万鸿飞,周德群,杨政军.可持续发展意义下的生产函数.连云港化工高等专科学校学报,1999(6):34-35
    [170]王春,王丽萍.矿区发展循环经济的模式构建与探索.矿业快报,2006(6):35-38
    [171]王春宏,刘学兵.论发展循环经济与“贫富兼采”.中国国土资源经济,2007(7):12-14
    [172]王海龙,赵光洲.循环经济对资源环境外部性的作用及问题探讨.经济问题探索,2007(2):22-26
    [173]王灵梅,张金屯.火电厂生态工业园生态规划研究.环境保护,2003(12):16-18
    [174]王谦光.公平竞争环境与发展循环经济.上海市经济管理干部学院学报,2006(1):23-25
    [175]王寿兵,王祥荣.产业生态学与生态产业建设战略研究.上海环境科学,2001(3):338-340
    [176]王舜.试论高新技术与循环经济的结合机制.自然辩证法研究,2006(1):24-28
    [177]王万山,自然资源混合市场运行机制.广东商学院学报,2004(5):21-27
    [178]王运敏.我国金属矿产资源开发循环经济的发展方向.金属矿山,2005(9):1-3
    [179]王兆华,武春友.基于交易费用理论的生态工业园中企业共生机理研究.科学学和科学技术管理,2002(8):9-12
    [180]王卓娟.论循环经济条件下企业可持续发展的战略选择——兼论政府规制的政策导向:[硕士论文].首都经济贸易大学图书馆,2006
    [181]温诚锋,梁日忠.循环经济型钢铁企业建设模式研究.长沙理工大学学报,2005(5):9-13
    [182]奚旦立.清洁生产与循环经济.北京:化学工业出版社,2005
    [183]席桂平.生态工业园区内企业共生关系的经济学分析:[硕士论文].河南农业大学图书馆,2004
    [184]席旭东.基于矿区可持续发展的生态产业共生体系构建.矿业安全与环保2006(6):65-69
    [185]夏青,梁钰.面向循环经济的矿产资源开发利用模式.自然资源学报,2006(3):288-292
    [186]向昀,任健.西方经济学界外部性理论研究介评.经济评论,2002(3):58-62
    [187]谢芳,李慧明.日本逆向制造与循环型企业的构建.现代日本经济,2006(5):21-23
    [188]谢芳,李慧明.生产者责任延伸制与企业的循环经济模式.生态经济,2006(6):64-66
    [189]胥树凡.循环经济理念下的再生资源产业.有色金属再生与利用,2004(5):11-15
    [190]徐滨士,刘世参,史佩京.再制造工程和表面工程对循环经济贡献分析.中国表面工程,2006(1):1-6
    [191]徐大立,李广海,赵国杰.基于循环经济的钢铁企业发展模式研究.中国冶金,2006(10):38-41
    [192]中关村国际环保产业促进中心.循环经济国际趋势与中国实践.北京:人民出版社,2005
    [193]杨华峰,张华玲.论循环经济评价指标体系的构建.科学学与科学技术管理,2005(9):123-128
    [194]杨建新.论清洁生产向工业生态学的转变.环境科学进展,1998(6):82-87
    [195]杨雪锋,张卫东.资源减量化、信息替代与经济流程的转变.中国工业经济, 2005(5):5-12
    [196]姚建.环境经济学.成都:西南财经大学出版社,2001
    [197]姚敬劬.矿业纳入循环经济的几种模式.中国矿业,2004(6):5-28
    [198]于江涛.环境污染损失估价的索洛方程方法.中国人口·资源与环境,1998(1):47-52
    [199]豫光金铅循环经济发展规划,2005
    [200]张慧明,王娟.应用烟气脱硫技术控制燃煤工业锅炉二氧化硫污染.电力环境保护,2006(1):8-11
    [201]张凯,崔兆杰.清洁生产理论与方法.北京:科学出版社,2005
    [202]张坤民.可持续发展论.北京:中国环境科学出版社,1997
    [203]张钦礼,朱永刚.循环经济模式下的矿产资源开发.矿业快报,2006(5):1-6
    [204]张青.资源耗竭型企业生命周期问题研究.煤炭经济研究,2005(1):8-12
    [205]张涛.经济持续增长的要素分析.数量经济技术经济研究,2001(4):43-45
    [206]张天柱.从清洁生产到循环经济.中国人口·资源环境,2006(6):169-174
    [207]张维迎.博弈论与信息经济学.上海:上海人民出版,1996
    [208]张卫东,杨雪锋.节约型经济流程的基础与条件.经济学家,2005(5):38-44
    [209]张喜武.矿区可持续发展指标体系:[硕士论文].辽宁工程大学图书馆,2005
    [210]张香亭.提升洁净煤技术发展循环经济.中国煤炭,2005(4):54-56
    [211]张小兰.论循环经济与市场经济之间的关系.生产力研究,2005(4):23-25
    [212]张扬.循环经济概论.长沙:湖南人民出版社,2005
    [213]张宇.沧州区域可持续发展系统研究.地理与地理信息科学,2006(5):34-36
    [214]张云,尚英姿.清洁生产的微观动力机制探析.经济管理,2006(12):45-49
    [215]赵家荣.清洁生产回顾与展望.产业与环境,2003(增刊):13-15
    [216]赵梅中,杨海平.清洁生产主要技术工具简介.资源与发展,2006(3):31-38
    [217]中国铝业河南分公司碳素厂清洁生产审核报,2006
    [218]周国梅,彭昊,曹凤中.循环经济和工业生态效率指标体系.城市环境与城市生态,2003(6):201-203
    [219]周宏春.循环经济的发展模式与经济学分析,http://www.chinaxh.cn.2007.9.7
    [220]周宏春.中国循环经济的发展模式和制度保障.中国废钢铁,2006(6):4-10
    [221]周英南,王雪东,李文霞.清洁生产推进机制的成本分析.大连理工学报(社 会科学版),2005(3):55-57
    [222]朱红伟,刘园.循环经济中政府与市场的作用及其关系探讨.中国发展,2005(1):17-19
    [223]朱铁臻.循环经济的理论基础是生态经济.中国经济时报,2005.04.19
    [224]主沉浮,孙良,魏云鹤.清洁生产的理论与实践.济南:山东大学出版社,2003
    [225]邹方志.循环经济下企业模式分析.财经界,2007(5):290-295
    [226]左红英,杨忠直.企业进化论一企业层面的循环经济研究.生产力研究,2007(5):115-118

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700