我国农产品流通体系效率评价与优化路径
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
随着改革开放的深入和经济的快速发展,我国取得了举世瞩目的成就,已经成为世界第二大经济体,综合国力得到快速提升。我国是世界上人口最多的国家,农业发展对经济发展和社会稳定具有举足轻重的作用,长期以来,我国政府和人民都在努力实现农业生产和流通的现代化转型,但建国以后我国过分注重国家的工业化进程,农业为国家的工业发展提供了大量的资金和原材料,使得农业发展远远落后于工业发展。直到改革开放和家庭联产承包责任制的推广,我国的农业才获得了新的发展机遇。经过多年发展,我国的农产品短缺问题逐步得到解决,农产品结构性过剩问题开始出现,农业发展的矛盾逐步山生产领域转向流通领域,农产品小规模生产与大市场、大流通之间的矛盾成为制约农业发展和农民增收的王要原因,当前的农产品,流通体系无法在现有条件下实现高效效运行。近些年,我国政府十分关注农产品流通产业发展和农产品流通体系优化,将农产品流通新技术、流通模式创新作为优化现有农产品流通体系的突破口。2006年国家发布了《“十一五”时期全国农产品市场体系建设规划》,指出农产品流通体系是沟通农产品生产与农产品消费的桥梁和纽带,是我国农业健康、快速发展的重要保证。随着我国新农村建设的全面推进,要求农产品流通体系高效运行,缩短流通时间,提高流通效率。在这种背景下,如何优化我国现有的农产品流通体系,提高其运行效率,成为我国农业发展中迫切需要解决的问题。
     高效的农产品流通体系可以正确引导农产品生产和消费,缓解我国农产品小生产与大市场之间的矛盾。合理的农产品流通体系可以实现信息的有效传递,实现农产品交易过程中利益的合理分配,在我国现有的农产品流通体系中,农业生产者并没有得到与农产品价格上涨相应的收入增长,各农产品流通环节层层分享农产品利益,导致农产品生产者利益受损。而高效、现代的农产品流通体系,可以减少流通环节,避免流通主体的投机行为,减低农产品消耗,因此,现代农产品流通体系的构建可以促进农业生产方式转变,保护农产品生产者和消费者的利益。完善的农产品流通体系有助于保障农产品质量,过长的流通环节和流通时间增加了农产品质量监控难度,而高效的农产品流通体系可以减少流通环节,节约流通时间,提高对农产品流通的控制力度,实现农产品质量追溯,保证农产品质量。由此可见,对我国现有农产品流通体系进行优化具有重要的现实意义。
     本文通过对国内外农产品流通相关领域研究成果进行总结和评述,找到了我国农产品流通体系优化的方向,对农产产品流通相关理论进行梳理,为本文的分析找到了理论支持。在此基础上,回顾了我国农产品流通的演变历程,介绍了国外农产品流通体系构建与优化的成功经验,为我国对现有农产品流通体系进行优化选择提供了相关实践经验。从流通主体、流通客体、流通载体、流通环境和流通模式等方面出发,阐述了我国农产品流通体系发展现状及我国农产品流通体系中存在的问题。运用数据包络分析法和Malmquist指数分析法对我国农产品流通体系进行了效率评价,实证分析结果显示,我国农产品流通体系总体效率不高,东部和中部地区的效率要高于西部地区,技术因素和管理方式是影响我国农产品流通体系效率的重要原因。通过面板数据回归分析方法,对影响农产品流通体系的具体因素进行了分析,实证分析结果显示,信息化水平,政府投入等因索对我国农产品流通体系影响较大,在以上分析的基础上,从壮大农业专业合作社和大力发展农产品冷链物流等方面提出了优化现有农产品流通体系的突破口,提出了相关的对策建议。
Along with the further reform and opening in China, and the rapid and sustainable developments in the national economic construction, our country has gained the success attract worldwide attention by growing up to the second-largest economy and promoting the comprehensive national power fast. With the largest population in the world, the agricultural developments have played a significant role in both the economical developments and the social stability in China. Our government and people have been working on the modernized repositioning of the production and circulation of the agriculture for a long time. However, after the foundation of PRC. the agriculture has provided sufficient funds and resources to the developments of the national industry which resulted in the developments of the agriculture far behind the developments of the industry, since over attention on the industrialization of our country. Up till the reform and open policy and the promotion of the household contract responsibility system, the development of our agriculture has gained new opportunities. After years of developments, the shortage problem of the agricultural products has been solved step by step and instead the structural surplus problem has begun to emerge. The contradiction of the agricultural developments has gradually shifted from the production field to the circulation field. The contradictions of the relationship among the small production sizes, the huge market and big circulation have become the restriction of the agricultural developments and the increase of the income of the peasants. The current agricultural products circulation system cannot achieve efficient operation under the existing conditions. In recent years, our government had paid great attention on the optimization of the developments for the agricultural products circulation industry and the agricultural products circulation system. The new circulation technologies and innovation in the circulation patterns are believed to be the breakthrough for the optimization of the agricultural products circulation system."The construction planning of the national agricultural product market in the eleventh five-year plan issued in2006, has pointed out that the agricultural products circulation system was the bridge and tie between the production and consumption of the agricultural products, and a very important guarantee for the rapid and healthy developments of the national agriculture. As the comprehensive advancements of the new rural construction in our country, high efficient operational system, shortened circulation time and promoted circulation efficiency in the agricultural products circulation system have become the urgent problems to be solved of the agricultural development in China.
     A highly efficient agricultural products circulation system will guide the production and consumption of the agricultural products correctly, alleviate the contradiction between the small production scale and the big market of the agricultural products in our country, realize the valid information communication and launch an effective string between the production and consumption of the agricultural products. A highly efficient agricultural products circulation system will also make the proper distribution of the interests possible in the transactions of the agricultural products. In the agricultural products circulation system, the producers do not share the increased income corresponding with the rising agricultural product prices and the corresponding interests and benefits are shared in the layers of the agricultural products circulation system which will cause damages to the interests of the producers. However a highly efficient and modern agricultural products circulation system will lower the waste of the agricultural products by cutting the logistic layers and avoiding the speculations of the principal parts of the circulation. Therefore, the construction of a modern agricultural products circulation system will promote the transformation of the agricultural production methods and increase the benefits for both the producers and consumers of the agricultural products. An improved agricultural products circulation system will help guarantee the quality of the agricultural products due to the circulation time, while a highly efficient agricultural products circulation system will save circulation time by cutting the layers in the system, strengthen the monitor and control over the agricultural products circulation caused by the long circulation How, by reducing the links in the circulation flow, so that the quality of the agricultural products can be tracked and guaranteed. So the optimization of the agricultural products circulation system is of significant importance to our country.
     This dissertation discovers the direction to optimize the agricultural products circulation system in China, through the summarization and reviews on the research outcome of the agricultural products circulation in the related fields and overviews of the related theories in both domestic and overseas, which provides theoretical supports to the analysis in the dissertation. Based on the above mentioned points, the circulation evolution of agricultural products in China is reviewed and the construction of the agricultural products circulation system and the successful experiences in optimization both at home and abroad are introduce. The current status and the existing problems in the agricultural products circulation system in our country are explored, including the principal part, objects, environments, carriers, patterns and other aspects of circulation. DEA method and Malmquist index method are applied to evaluate the efficiency of the agricultural products circulation system in China and the results of the empirical analysis show that the overall efficiency in China is not high, but the efficiency in the eastern and middle part of China is better than that in the west due to the technical factors and the managerial styles. By applying the panel data regression analysis on the influential factors in the agricultural products circulation system, the influential factors such as the Informatization level and the governmental investment are proved to have major impacts on the agricultural products circulation system in China. Based on the above analysis, relevant proposals and strategies have been put forward and the breakthrough points to optimize the agricultural products circulation system should be proceeded from the aspects including the expansion of the agricultural professional cooperatives and the development of the cold chain logistics.
引文
[1]王新利,张襄英.构建我国农村物流体系的必要性与可行性.农业现代化研究,2002(7):263-266.
    [2]林玲.对农业产业化中农产品流通体系建设的思考.经济研究导刊,2012(15):164-165
    [3]纪良刚,刘东英.农产品流通的关键问题与解决思路.中国流通经济,2011(7):18-20
    [4]蒋华东.加快建立健全农产品流通体系的思考,2007(10):108-110
    [5]张长厚.发展农产品流通的瓶颈与思考.中国流通经济,2012(4):22-24
    [6]汪旭晖.农产品流通体系现状与优化路径选择.改革,2008(2):83-88
    [7]Jill E. Hobbs,Linda M. Young.Closer Vertical Co-ordination in Agri-food Supply Chains:a Conceptual Framework and Some Preliminary Evidence. Supply Chain Management:An International Journal,2000(3)
    [8]Lambert,Cooper. Issues in Supply Chain Management. Industrial Marketing Management,2000(29):65-83
    [9]Vaughan Higgin.Building Alternative Agri-food Networks Certification Embeddedness and Agri-Environmental Governance. Journal of Rural Studies,2008(1):15-27
    [10]Terry Marsden. Food Supply Chain Approaches:Exploring their Role in Rural Development.European Society of Rural Sociology,2000(10):424-439
    [11]KcvinR.Moore.Trust and Relationship Commitment in Logisties Allianees:A buyers, Perspective. International Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management,1998:24-38
    [12]Barbara Grosh.Contract Farming in Africa:an Application of the New Institutional Economics.Africa Econmics,1994.
    [13]Sinklangley. A Managerial Framework for the Acquisition of Third-Party Logistics Ser vices. Journal of Business Logistics,1997(2)
    [14]Morash. Strategic Logistics Capabilities for Competitive Advantage and Firm Success.Journal of Business Logistics,1996(1):17
    [15]David H. Taylor. Demand Management in Agri-food Supply Chains. The International Journal of Logistics,2006(2):163-186
    [16]Fawcett. Logistics Performance Measurement and Customer Success. Industrial Marketing Management.1998(4):341-357
    [17]Monczka.Purchasing and Supply Chain Management. South-western College Publishing,1998
    [18]Nicholas K. Biotechnology and the Restructuring of the Agricultural Supply Chain.Agbioforum,1998 (2):40-42
    [19]Joha L.kent.Perspectives On The Evolution of Logisties Thought.Journal of Business Logisties,1997(18)
    [20]Natic Miai.Council of Physical Distribution Management.NCPDM comment,1976
    [21]AndrewBlatherwick.The Supply Chain Balancing Stock and Service at a Profit.Logistics Information Management,2001 (6):24-26
    [22]Nigel Poole.Quality Assurance in the Maritime Port Logistics Chain:the Case of Valencia, Spain.Supply Chain Management:An International Journal,1998.
    [23]AndrewP.Feame,NigeID,Poole.Modelling Vegetable Marketing Systems in South EastAsia: Phenomenological in Sights from Vietnam.Supply Chain Management,2003 (5):427-451
    [24]KennethH.Wathae. Relationship Governance in a Supply Chain Network. Journal of Marketing,2004
    [25]Kliebenstein,J.B.andLawrence,J.D.Contracting and Vertieal Coordination in the United States Pork,2002(5):9-12
    [26]Amit Sachan. B.S. Sahay, Dinesh Sharma.Developing Indian Grain Supply Chain Cost Model:a System Dynamics Approach.International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management,2005.
    [27]Dolan,C.Governance and Trade in fresh Vegetables:the Impact of UK Supermarkets.Journal of Development Studies,2000(2):147-176
    [28]Dries,L. the Rapid Rise of Supermarkets in Central and Easter Europe:Implications for the Agri-food Sector and Rural Development.Development poliey Review,2004(5):525-556
    [29]Minot,N.Impact of High-value Agriculture and Modern Marketing Channels on Poverty:An analytical Framework.Interational Food Policy Research,2007
    [30]Reardon,T.The Rise of Supermarkets in Africa,Asia and Latin America.American Journal of Agricultural Economics,2003 (5):114-1146
    [31]Thomas Reardon.Supermarkets and Produce Quality and Safety Standards in Latin America. America Agriculture Economics,2003
    [32]Narasimhan,R.Perpectives on Risk Management in Supply chains.Journal of Operations Management,2009 (2):114-118.
    [33]A.Starbired.Supply Chain Contracts and Food Safety.Choices:Farm Resource Issue,2005 (2)
    [34]Doyon,Maurice.An Overview of the Evolution of Agricultural Cooperatives in Canada. Journal of Agricultural Economics,2002
    [35]Gray,ThomasW. Exploring a Greater Role for Agricultural Cooperatives in Sustaining Rural Living. Rural Cooperatives,2004
    [36]KarinH.Farmers Cooperatives in the 21th Century.The Journals of Rural Cooperatives,1999
    [37]RiehardL.Killmer.Improving Vertical Coordination from Farm-to-plant Using a Cooperative.American Agricultural Economics Association,2003
    [38]Cook,M.The Future of U.S Agricultural Cooperatives.American Journal of Agricultural Economics,1995(5):24-34
    [39]F. Light.Agricultural Cooperatives Have Important Stake in Development of Rural America, farmer Cooperatives,1989(56):14-28.
    [40]MarkManfredo.Agricutural Cooperatives and Risk Management.American Agricultural Economics Association,2003
    [41]马广奇.中国流通经济学的回顾与反思.华东经济管理,2005(3):25-28
    [42]王明东,靳兰香.构筑农村现代流通体系的思考.商业研究,2007(7):142-144
    [43]纪宝成,晏维龙.电子商务下的商品流通.经济理论与经济管理,2000(4):35-40
    [44]李志萌.现代农产品流通体系的构建与完善.江西农业大学学报(社会科学版),2005(1):69-71
    [45]苏日娜.提高我国农产品流通效率的对策研究.科学与管理,2010(1):32-33
    [46]曹利群.农产品流通组织体系的重建.学术月刊,2001(8):30-35
    [47]黄胜忠.农业合作社理论研究述评.商业研究,2009(3):175-78
    [48]龚欣一.我国农业合作社发展面临的主要问题与政策建议.湖南行政学院学报,2012(5):38-41
    [49]黄祖辉,吴克象,金少胜.发达国家现代农产品流通体系变化及启示.福建论坛(经济社会版),2003(04):32-36
    [50]陈娆,杨为民.基于供应链的“农超对接”机理研究.农业经济,2012(1):121-123
    [51]李忠旭,李天来.蔬菜种植户的契约安排与选择的制度分析.农业经济,2011(10):91-93
    [52]徐柏园.公益性:农产品批发市场性质的正本清源.中国流通经济,2011(5):92-97
    [53]张喜才,杨谦.鲜活农产品流通链条关键节点及政府支持研究.北京工商大学学报(社会科学版),2012(2):44-48
    [54]靳明,赵昶.绿色农产品消费意愿和消费行为分析.中国农村经济,2008(5):44-55
    [55]倪学志.我国绿色农产品有效供给研究.农业经济问题,2012(4):18-21
    [56]梁海红.渠道关系视角下中国农产品流通模式优化研究.南方农村,2010(4):81-84
    [57]范力军.国内近期农产品流通模式研究综述.农业科技管理,2011(10):75-77
    [58]曹炫珠.我国农产品流通组织研究.山西财经大学硕士论文,2006(9):34-41
    [59]郭晓利.我国农产品期货市场发展现状与趋势展望.中国流通经济,2009(1):71-74
    [60]杨梦琪.我国农产品期货市场发展浅析.对外经贸,2012(4):114-115
    [61]叶兴庆.积极推进农产品市场体系建设.中国农村经济,2000(8):29-35
    [62]汪腾.我国农产品市场体系发展存在的主要问题及对策探析.特区经济,2011(5):244-245
    [63]高燕,朱信凯,潘勇辉.构建我国农产品批发市场运行模式.中国农村经济,1999(9):30-32
    [64]寇荣,谭向勇.论农产品流通效率的分析框架.中国流通经济,2008(5):12-15
    [65]徐振宇.提升农产品流通效率-促进经济增长方式转变.北京工商大学学报(社会科学版),2007(11):6-9
    [66]崔晓文.农产品市场营销效率与深化农产品流通体制改革.南京经济学院学报,1996(4):14-17。
    [67]张闯,夏春玉,梁守砚.关系交换、治理机制与交易绩效:基于蔬菜流通渠道的比较案例研究.管理世界,2009(8):124-140
    [68]涂洪波.农产品流通现代化评价指标的实证遴选及应用.中国流通经济,2012(6):18-23
    [69]孙剑.我国农产品流通效率测评与演进趋势—基于1998-2009年面板数据的实证分析.中国流通经济,2011(5):21-25
    [70]欧阳小迅,黄福华.我国农产品流通效率的度量及其决定因素:2000—2009.农业技术经济,2011(2):76-84
    [71]张磊,王娜,谭向勇.农产品流通效率的概念界定及评价指标设计.华东经济管理,2011(4):18-21
    [72]赵琛.中国农产品批发市场发展的国际比较.中国商贸,2012(2):28-29
    [73]胡天石.我国农产品批发市场信息化需求与三维发展模式分析.农业现代化研究,2012(9):612-615
    [74]桂琳.社会主义新农村农产品批发市场发展对策.北京农学院学报,2006(4):66-68
    [75]祝俊明.农产品批发市场竞争力研究.天津大学硕士论文,2005(7):27-48
    [76]吕靖烨.我国农产品批发市场建设的问题与策略.农业经济,2007(2):59-61
    [77]王丽丽.新疆农产品批发市场发育环境分析.陕西农业科学,2005(3):150-152
    [78]俞菊生,罗强,张晨,马佳.长三角区域农业合作项目与前景研究.上海农业学报,2012(2):6-10
    [79]区品莹,俞守华.农产品批发市场电子结算系统的设计与实现.农业网络信息,2006(7):46-48
    [80]吴建江.农产品批发市场信息化产品开发策略.通信企业管理,2008(5):64-65
    [81]岑丽阳.论农业产业化与农产品流通体系建设.山西财经大学学报,2011(4):83-84
    [82]邹铁钉,周发明.农产品流通体系的形成因素.现代企业,2007(8):57-58
    [83]林家宏,温思美,罗必良.企业办市场企业管市场市场企业化—“布吉模式”的创新价值及对中国农产品流通体制改革的启示.中国农村经济,1999(9):19-26
    [84]杜辉.城市圈农产品流通体系发展思路探讨—以武汉城市圈为例.广西经济管理干部学院学报,2009(2):87-90
    [85]任博华.中国农产品流通体系的现状及优化建议.北方经贸,2008(10):58-62
    [86]王杜春.如何构建黑龙江农产品现代流通体系.商业时代,2007(3):98-99
    [87]何学平,闫友波.如何构建新型农产品流通体系.中国合作经济,2005(10):37-38
    [88]邹雪丁,王转.基于国际经验的农产品流通模式研究.物流技术,2009(1):20-22
    [89]李晋红.美日农产品流通渠道模式比较及对我国的借鉴.中国合作经济,2005(5):61-62
    [90]丁来强,郑进.论韩国农产品流通体制改革及其启示.农业经济问题,1999(05):58-60
    [91]焦必方,方志权.日本鲜活农产品流通体系.今日农村,2002(6):33-34
    [92]陈淑祥.中西方国家农产品流通比较.重庆工商大学学报,2006(4):19-23
    [93]夏春玉.城市零售流通系统的空间竞争结构及其变化—以日本为例.商业经济与管理,2005(10):3-9
    [94]王杜春,迟凤敏.论农产品现代流通体系建设水平的评价指标.商业研究,2008(9):130-132
    [95]王维.黑龙江省农产品流通体系存在的问题与对策.中国农学通报,2011(6):380-386
    [96]张平,唐立兵.黑龙江省农产品物流发展的现状与对策.现代化农业,2008(2):1-4
    [97]马克思.资本论.上海:三联出版社,2009
    [98]亚当·斯密.国富论.上海:三联出版社,2009
    [99]马歇尔.经济学原理.北京:商务印书馆,1995
    [100]杨小凯.经济学-新兴古典与新古典框架.北京:社会科学文献出版社,2003.
    [101]杨小凯,张永生.新兴古典经济学与超边际分析.北京:社会科学文献出版社,2003
    [102]科斯.企业、市场与法律.上海:三联出版社,1990
    [103]马凤才.农产品流通通道与流通效率研究—基于黑龙江省稻米流通的分析.沈阳农业大学博士论文,2008(6):35-44
    [104]杨青松.农产品流通模式研究—以蔬菜为例.中国社会科学院研究生院博士学位论文,2011(6)29-38
    [105]陈淑祥.中西方国家农产品流通比较.重庆工商大学学报,2006(8):19-23
    [106]赵继海.日本农产品产销动向与农业结构演变的分析.现代日本经济,2002(3):41-44
    [107]曹冰冰.日本农产品物流模式对我国的借鉴.中国商贸,2010(11):157-158
    [108]贾敬敦.中国农产品流通发展产业报告(2012).北京:社会科学文献出版社
    [109]胡勇.加快我国农产品流通主体的建设步伐.安徽科技学院学报,2007(7):62-65
    [110]肖晓.农产品批发市场建设与农民收入的关系研究.长江论坛,2011(6):42-47
    [111]白红玲.浅谈我国农产品流通中的中介组织.甘肃农业,2003(3):20-21
    [112]渠溪.关于我国农产品流通问题的探讨.东方企业文化,2012(1):77
    [113]M. J. Farrell. The Measurement of Productive Efficiency. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society,1957(120A):125-281
    [114]Charnes, A. Cooper, W.W. Rhodes, E. Measuring the Efficiency of Decision Making Units. European Journal of Operational Research,1978(2):429-444.
    [115]Banker, R.D. Charnes, A. Cooper, W.W.Some Models for Estimating Technical and Scale Inefficiencies in Data Envelopment Analysis. Management Science,1984(30):1078-1092.
    [116]Charnes A, Cooper W W, Golary B, et al. Foundation of Data Envelopment Analysis for Pareto-Koopmans Efficient Empirical Production Functions.Journal of Econometrics (Netherlands),1985, 30 (1-2):91-107.
    [117]Fare R, Grosskopf S. A Nonparametric Cost Approach to Scale Efficiency. Journal of Economics, 1985, (87):594-604.
    [118]Charnes A, Cooper W W, Wei Q L. A Semi-infinite Multicriteria Programming Approach to Data Envelopment Analysis with Infinitely Mmany Decision Making Units.Center for Cybernetic Studies Report CCS 511,1986.
    [119]Charnes A, Cooper W W, Wei Q L, et al. Cone ratio Data Envelopment Analysis and Multi-objective Programming. International Journal of Systems Science,1989, (7):1099-1118.
    [120]Sengupta J K. Data Envelopment Analysis for Efficiency Measurement in the Stochastic case. Computers and Operations Research,1987 (14):117-129.
    [121]盛昭瀚,朱乔,吴广谋.DEA理论、方法与应用.北京:科学出版社.1996:2-5
    [122]Cook W D, Kress M, Seiford L.On the Use of Ordinal Data Envelopment Analysis. Journal of the Operational Research Society,1993(2):133-140.
    [123]M. J. Farrell.The Measurement of Productive Efficiency.Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series A (General),1957,120(3):253-290
    [124]Fare R. S. Grosskopf, C. Lovell.The Measurement of Efficiency of Production. Boston:Kluwer-Nijhoff Publishers,1985:185-214
    [125]Varian H. The Nonparametric Approa ch to Production Analysis. Econometrica,1984,(54):579-597
    [126]Caves, D.W.Christensen L.R.&Diewert W.E. Multilateral Compositions of Output, Input and Productivity Using Superlative Index Numbers. Economic Journal,1982 (92):73-86
    [127]Yao Chen, Wade D. Cook, Ning Li, Joe Zhu. Addtive Efficiency Decomposition in Two-stage DEA. European Journal of Operational Reaearch,2009(196):1170-1176
    [128]Sangkyu Rho, Jungnam An. Evaluation the Efficiency of a Two-stage Production Process Using Data Envelopment Analysis. International Transactions in Operational Research.2007(14):395-410
    [129]Levin A, Lin C F, Chu C S.Unit Root Tests in Panel Data:Asymptotic and Finite Sample Properties.Journal of Econometrics,2002(108):1-24
    [130]Im K S,Pesaran M H, Shin Y.Testing for Unit Roots in Heterogeneous Panels.Journal of Econometrics,2003(115):53-74
    [131]Kao C.Spurious Regression and Residual-based Tests for Cointegration in Panel Data.Journal of Econometrics 1999(90):1-44
    [132]McCoskeyS,Kao C.A Residual-based Test for the Null of Cointegratopn in Paneldata. Econometric Reviews,1998(17):157-166
    [133]Alonso-Borrego, C. Symmetrically Normalized Instrumental-variable Estimation Using Panel Data. Journal of Business and Economic Statistics,1999(1),36-49
    [134]金赛美.现代农产品市场体系构建研究.华中农业大学博士论文,2006(5):101-120
    [135]洪玉兰,肖其荣.浅谈我国农产品冷链物流存在的问题及发展建议.物流科技,2010(9):42-44
    [136]卜梅.国内外农产品冷链物流发展比较研究.物流工程与管理,2011(11):33-35
    [137]杨光华,林朝朋,谢小良.生鲜农产品冷链物流模式与对策研究.广东农业科学,2009(6):200-203
    [138]牛小娟.我国农产品冷链物流发展现状及策略研究.科技信息,2011(10):155-156
    [139]王志刚,王启魁,钟倩琳.农产品冷链物流产业的发展现状、存在问题及对策展望.农业展望,2012(4):55-59
    [140]方凯,刘洁.农业合作社发展的国际经验及对我国的启示.广东农业科学,2009(8):310-313
    [141]戎爱萍.关于农业合作社发育的分析.经济问题,2007(7):82-85
    [142]张桂春,赵慧峰,刘秀娟.国外农业合作社发展影响因素分析及对我国的启示.商场现代化,2007(11):157-158
    [143]李昆,傅新红.重释农业合作社存在与发展的内在动因.农村经济,2004(1):16-18
    [144]张颖,孙冬玲.我国农业合作社发展对策探讨.现代商贸工业,2009(6):77-78
    [145]向丽.提升农产品第三方物流增值服务水平的策略研究.黑龙江对外经贸,2011(8):85-87
    [146]王艳.基于增值服务理论的农产品第三方物流研究初探.江苏商论,2008(11):56-58
    [147.]陶学宗,刘德军,杨德旭.农产品第三方物流体系研究.沈阳农业大学学报(社会科学版),2008(7):407-409
    [148]戴惠斌.关于我国发展第三方物流的思考.中国城市经济,2011(6):57-58
    [149]岳鹏飞.我国第三方物流发展对策研究.中国商贸,2010(12):136-137
    [150]李敬.发展农产品第三方物流企业的对策.新乡教育学院学报,2006(6):7-11
    [151]傅一凡,张惠娜.我国农超对接发展现状及展望.现代商贸工业,2012(4):49
    [152]刘晓峰.农超对接模式下农户参与意愿的实证研究.中南财经政法大学学报,2011(9):116-121
    [153]朱磊,仰慧.“农超对接”促进农产品流通现代化的思考.中国证券期货,2011(9):101-102
    [154]顾万荣,李晶,魏湜.对完善我国农超对接工作的思考.农业经济与管理,2011(10):91-96
    [155]陈家涛.农超对接的模式、困境及对策.经济研究导刊,2011(12):202-203

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700