流动性冲击与资产价格波动研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
爆发于2007年的次贷危机是进大21世纪以来影响最为深远的全球性经济事件。危机爆发后,世界主要经济体奉行凯恩斯主义的衣钵,采取向处于破产边缘的金融机构大量注资、大幅降低基准利率、放松信贷和上马大型基建项目等措施。然而,政策干预效果与采取措施初衷相去甚远:一方面实体经济复苏之路并不平坦,美国经济复苏之路仍然非常漫长,欧洲仍然在泥潭中挣扎,日本经济持续低迷,新兴经济体陷入经济增速显著下行的困境;另一方面成熟经济体虚拟资产价格载高歌猛进,随着各国央行资产负债表迅速膨胀,成熟经济体如美国、英国和法国代表性股票指数已接近或超过经济基本面强劲的2000年和2007年水平。这种实体经济与虚拟经济背离现象值得警惕和深思。
     回顾20世纪以来,全球经济所发生的每一次泡沫,如20世纪20年代美国经济、20世纪80年代口本经济、20世纪90年代的墨西哥经济、1997年之前亚洲经济、20世纪末的美国互联网泡沫和21世纪初美国经济的繁荣,每次危机爆发前人们都有充足的理由说“这次不一样”,即经济繁荣可以持续。然而,如果仔细分析每次经济从繁荣走向萧条的过程,每次危机前后都会伴随着“流动性急剧扩张—流动性逆转—流动性短缺”的流动性冲击过程,与其同时存在的是“资产价格急剧上涨—资产价格承压—资产价格暴跌”的资产价格急剧波动现象,验证了罗格夫和雷恩哈特的新著《这次不一样?》中所强调的主旨——“这次没什么不一样”。
     在现有世界经济体系中,大多数经济体对内实行信用货币制度和对外实行有管理浮动汇率制度,始终临保持合适流动性以促进经济持续健康增长和保持资产价格稳定的艰难抉择。因此,对于流动性冲击和资产价格波动的研究,特别是流动性冲击与资产价格波动在不同经济体及不同发展阶段的经验总结不仅能够对本轮经济危机未来演绎过程有更深入理解,而且对于制定合理的宏观经济政策具有十分重要意义。
     本文以“流动性冲击与资产价格波动研究”为题,重点关注“流动性冲击(Shock)→资产价格波动(Volatility)"这一过程,对流动性冲击与资产价格波动间的传导理论机制及相互影响的跨国实践进行全面而系统的研究分析。全文共包括五个重要组成部分:
     第一部分厘清概念和要点。系统梳理流动性、流动性冲击、资产价格、资产价格波动、流动性冲击与资产价格波动等相关理论,对于流动性、流动性冲击和资产价格波动等重要概念予以明确界定并提出计量指标,从而为后续讨论提供明确概念前提。
     第二部分构建理论框架。在对马克思“资本循环理论”分析基础上,基于保埃直达等学者所提出的理念和相关模型,以经济主体资本项目和经常项目核算为起点,分别构建封闭式和开放式经济体之流动性冲击的产生及其影响的理论框架;由货币供求“二分法”过渡至货币数量“二分法”,结合Abel&Bernanke模型的深入挖掘,构建流动性冲击到资产价格波动的一、二阶传导机制理论框架;进一步揭示不同经济发展阶段下的流动性冲击和资产价格波动的传导特征,为后续对相关经济体实证研究作好理论铺垫。
     第三部分为流动性冲击和资产价格波动的国际经验研究。分别对部分代表性发达经济体和新兴经济体之流动性冲击和资产价格波动的实践进行系统性研究:一方面从定性角度对代表性国家特定阶段的流动性冲击和资产价格波动特征进行深入研究,另一方面从定量角度检验流动性冲击和资产价格波动间的相互作用机制。
     第四部分为中国的流动性冲击和资产价格波动研究。重点对中国改革开放以来的流动性冲击和资产价格波动现象予以系统整理,得出中国流动性冲击和资产价格波动特征。
     第五部分为流动性冲击与资产价格波动研究的启示。根据理论分析及总结不同经济体流动性冲击和资产价格波动特征,明确提出货币政策应关注资产价格变化(解决了货币政策是否需要关注资产价格问题),而且应关注主资产价格变化(解决了货币政策应关注哪类资产问题)。同时,根据各国实证结果及中国实际情况,提出当前中国房地产的主资产特征日益明显,并从流动性冲击与资产价格波动角度对中国汇率制度安排、金融创新及金融监管提出相应的对策建议。
The Sub-prime crisis is the most profound global economic event since the beginning of21century. After the outbreak of the crisis, most countries adopted the keynesian and actively took steps, such as capital injection, interest rate cut, easy credit and great construction project launch. However, the results are not as good as we expected. For one thing, it's a long way for the recovery of U.S. economy; Europe is bogged down in struggling against debt crisis, Japan's economy is still weak, and the emerging countries fall into the predicament of significantly downward. For another, the price of virtual assets rise rapidly, because of the quick and powerful propulsion of these policies, the central banks'balance sheet expand rapidly, the representative stock indexes of U.S., British and French have already exceeded or got close to the highest level with solid economic fundamentals in year2000or2007. The inconsistence between the real economy and virtual economy is worth our vigilance and ponder.
     When we review each of the asset bubble since20th century, such as U.S.'s bubble in1920s, Japan's bubble in1980s, Mexico's bubble in year1994, Asian financial crisis in1997, U.S. IT bubble in2000and U.S. bubble before sub-prime crisis in2007. Every time, people seem to have abundant reasons to say that'this is not the same, and economic prosperity can be sustained'before crisis. However, if we analyse the process from boom to bust carefully, every crisis is accompanied by complete process of liquidity shock, at the beginning expanding sharpely, then reversing, and at last falling into great shortage. Meanwhile, every crisis is accompanied by complete process of asset price volatility, at the beginning increasing rapidly, then reversing, and at last collapsing. They all verify'this time is not different', which is the gist of Rogoff and Reinhart's latest book'this time is different?'
     In the recent global economic system, most economies implement credit currency system inside and managed floating exchange rate system outside, and they always have to face the difficulty of keeping the proper level of liquidity to promote economic growth. So, the research on liquidity shock and asset price volatility, especially in different countries and different development periods, not only can help us to have a more in-depth understanding of the development of the recent economic crisis, but also have great significance for the reference of making reasonable macroeconomic policies.
     This paper's title is'the research on liquidity shock and asset price volatility', this paper focuses on the process between liquidity shock and asset price volatility, does comprehensive research on the theoretical mechanism of liquidity shock and asset price volatility and their interaction in different countries. This paper has five important parts.
     The first part, clarification of the concepts and keypoints. This paper introduces the theories of liquidity, liquidity shock, asset price and asset price volatility, liquidity shock and asset price volatility and so on. This paper clearly defines the important concepts and comes up the empirical indicators, which offers a clear conceptual premise for further discussion.
     The second part, establishment of theoretical framework. Based on the analysis of the capital cycle theory of Karl Marx and other latest ideas and theoretical models, this paper chooses the measurement of current and financial accounts as the start point, comes up with the theoretical framework of the production of liquidity shock and its influence. Through the dichotomy of money supply and demand theory, and the dichotomy of quantity theory of money, this paper interagates them with Abel&Bernanke model, then establishes the first and second order transmission mechanism of liquidity shock and asset price volatility. Otherwise, the transmission of different development periods is also contained. This part offers theorical basis for the following discussion of relevant economies.
     The third part, research on the international practice of liquidity shock and assets price volatility. this paper does research on the representatives of the developed and developing countries separately. For one thing, analyzes the transmission mechanism of these contries by qualitative research. For another, test the transmission mechanism of these contries by empirical research.
     The fourth part, research on china's practice of liquidity shock and assets price volatility. This paper focuses on the practice of liquidity shock and assets price volatility since the beginning of reform and opening-up, and sums up the characteristics of liquidity shocks and asset price volatility of China.
     The fifth part, the inspiration from the research on the theory and practice of liquidity shock and assets price volatility. Based on the analysis of theory and practice, this paper sums up the experience and lessons of liquidity shock and assets price volatility, and clearly puts forward that monetary policies should focus on the changes of assets'price, especially the changes of the main assets'price. The former answers the question'whether monetary policies need to focus on assets'price', and the other give the answer to the question'what kind of asset should monetary policies focus on'. According to the empirical results of representative economies and the real situation of china, this paper proposes that it is obvious that the real estate has more and more main asset's characteristics. This paper also puts forward the corresponding suggestions for the exchange rate system arrangement, financial innovation, and financial regulation of china.
引文
[1]Abdourahmane Sarr, Tonny Lybek. Measuring liquidity in financial markets [R]. IMF working paper, No.232,2002.
    [2]Abel, Bernanke. Macroeconomics [M]. Addison Wesley longman, fourth edition,2001.
    [3]Adalid R., Detken C.. Liquidity shocks and asset price boom/bust cycles [R]. ECB Working Paper Series, No.732,2007.
    [4]Adrian, T. and H. Shin. Money, Liquidity and Financial Cycles [R]. Paper presented at the 4th ECB Central Banking Conference on The role of money:Money and monetary policy in the twenty-first century,2006.
    [5]Adrian T., Shin H. Liquidity and financial cycles [R]. BIS working paper, No.256,2008.
    [6]Allen, F., and D. Gale. Bubbles and Crises[J]. The Economic Journal.2000,110(460).
    [7]Amihud Y., H. Mendelson. The effects of beta, bid-ask spread, residual risk, and size on stock returns [J]. Journal of finance,1989, (44).
    [8]Ansgar Belker, Walter Orth, Ralph Setzer Jr.. Sowing the seeds for the subprime crisis:does global liquidity matter for housing and other asset prices? [J]. International economics and economic policy,2008, (5).
    [9]Baks K, Kramer CF. Global liquidity and asset prices:measurement, implications, and spill-overs[R]. IMF Working Papers 99/168,1999.
    [10]Bean, C.. Asset Prices, Financial Imbalances and Monetary Policy. Are Inflation Targets Enough? [R]. Mimeo, Bank of England, London,2003.
    [11]Ben S. Bernanke, Non-Monetary Effects of the Financial Crisis in the Propagation of the Great Depression[J]. American Economic Review,1983,73(3).
    [12]Ben S. Bernanke, Alan S. Blinder. Credit, Money, and Aggregate Demand[R]. NBER Working Paper, No.2534,1988.
    [13]Ben S. Bernanke, Harold James. The Gold Standard, Deflation and Financial Crisis in the Great Depression:An International Comparison [A]. in R.G. Hubbard, ed.,Financial Markets and Financial Crises. Chicago:Universityof Chicago Press for National Bureau of Economic Research,1991.
    [14]Ben S. Bernanke, Cara S. Lown.. The Credit Crunch [R]. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, No.2,1991.
    [15]Ben S. Bernanke, Mark Gertler. Monetary policy and asset price volatility [J]. Federal reserve bank of Kansas city, Economic review,1999,84(4).
    [16]Ben S. Bernanke, Mark Gertler. Should central banks respond to movements in asset prices? [J]. American economic review papers and proceedings,2001.
    [17]Blanchard, Olivier, and Mark Watson. Bubbles,Rational Expectations, and Financial Markets [A]. in P.Wachtel, ed., Crisis in the Economic and Financial Structure.Lexington Books.1982.
    [18]Blinder, Alan and Joseph E. Stiglltz. Money, Credit Constraints, and Economic Activity [J]. American Economic Review,1983.
    [19]Bordo, M., M. Dueker and D. Wheelock. Inflation Shocks and Financial Distress:an Historical Analysis [R]. Fed of St. Louis Working Paper,2000.
    [20]Bordo, M, and O. Jeanne. Boom-Busts in Asset Prices, Economic Instability, and Monetary Policy [R]. NBER Working Paper, No.8966,2002.
    [21]Borio C., P. Lowe. Asset prices, financial and monetary stability:exploring the nexus [R]. BIS working paper, No.114,2002.
    [22]Borio C., Filardo A.. Globalisation and inflation:new cross-country evidence on the global determinants of domestic inflation[R]. BIS Working Papers, No.227,2007.
    [23]Brunner, Karl and Alan H. Meltzer. Money, Debt, and Economic Activity [J]. Journal of Political Economy,1972(80).
    [24]Brunnermeier M. K.. Deciphering the liquidity and credit crunch 2007-08 [J]. Journal of economic perspectives,2009, (1).
    [25]Brunermeier M. K., Pedersen L.H. Market liquidity and funding liquidity [J]. The society for financial studies,2008.
    [26]Carmen M. Reinhart, Kenneth S. Rogoff. This time is different:A panoramic view of eight centuries of financial crises [R]. NBER, No.13882,2008.
    [27]Cassola N., Morana C. Monetary policy and the stock market in the Euro area [J]. Journal of policy modeling,2004, (26).
    [28]Cecchetti S.G., H. Genberg, J. Lipsky, S. Wadhwani. Asset prices and central bank policy [R]. Working paper, Department of economics, The Ohio State University,2000.
    [29]Chengsi Zhang, Hong Pang. Excess liquidity and inflation dynamics in China:1997-2007[J]. China&World economy,2008,16(4).
    [30]ECB. Sectoral money holding:Determinats and recent developments [R]. ECB monthly bulletin,2006.
    [31]Ferguson R. W. Jr. Asset prices and monetary liquidity [R]. To the seventh Deutsche Bundesbank spring conference, Berlin, Germany,2005.
    [32]Fisher Irving. The debt-deflation theory of great depressions [J]. Econometrica,1933, (I).
    [33]Friedman M.. The quantity theory of money-a restatement [M] Studies in the quantity theory of money, University of Chicago press,1956.
    [34]Friedman, M.. The Role of Monetary Policy [J]. American Economic Review,1968.
    [35]Glen J. An introduction to the microstructure of emerging markets [R]. International finance corporation working paper, No.24, SSRN,1994.
    [36]Goodhart, C., B. Hofmann. Asset prices and the conduct of monetary policy [R]. Working paper, London school of economics,2000.
    [37]Hamburner M. J., L. A. Kochin. Money and stock prices:the channels of influences [J]. Journal of finance,1972,27(2).
    [38]Hyman P. Minsky. Stabilizing an Unstable Economy [M].McGraw-Hill Books,2008.
    [39]Hirshleifer Jack. Liquidity, uncertainty, and the accumulation of assets [R]. CORE discussion paper,1968.
    [40]Homa K. E., D. M. Jaffee. The supply of money and common stock prices [J]. Journal of Finance,1971,26(5).
    [41]International Monetary Fund. World economic outlook, Chapter III:Asset prices and the business cycle [R]. Washington,2000.
    [42]J. R. Hicks. Liquidity [J]. The Economic Journal,1962,288(72).
    [43]Kaminsky, Graciela, and Carmen Reinhart. The Twin Crises:The Causes of Banking and Balance-of-Payments Problems [J]. American Economic Review,1999,89(3).
    [44]Keran M. W. Expectations, money and the stock market [J]. Federal reserve bank of St. Louis review,1971,53(1).
    [45]Keynes J. M. A treatise on money [M]. Macmillan Company,1930.
    [46]Keynes J. M. The general theory of employment, interest and money [M]. Macmillan Company,1936.
    [47]Klass Baks, Charles Kramer. Global liquidity and asset prices:measurement, implications, and spillovers [R]. IMF working paper, No.168,1999.
    [48]Kyle A. S. Continuous auctions and insider trading [J]. Econometrica,1985, (53).
    [49]L. J. Christiano, M. Eichenbaum, C. L. Evans. Nominal rigidities and the dynamic effects of a shock to monetary policy [J]. Journal of Political Economy,2005,113(1).
    [50]Lachmann L. M. Uncertainty and liquidity-preference [J]. Economica,1937, (4).
    [51]Leamer EE. Housing and the business cycle [R]. Paper presented at the Annual Economic Symposium organized by the Kansas City Fed in Jackson Hole. Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City, Kansas City,2007.
    [52]Lippman S. A., McCall J. An operational measure of liquidity [J]. The American Economic Review,1986,(76).
    [53]Magnus Saxegaard. Excess liquidity and effectiveness of monetary policy:evidence from Sub-saharan africa [R]. IMF working paper, No.115,2006.
    [54]Marshall D.. Inflation and Asset Returns in a Monetary Economy [J]. Journal of Finance, 1992,47(4).
    [55]Massimb M. N., Phelp B. D. Electronic trading, market structure and liquidity [J]. Financial Analysts Journal,1994.
    [56]Michael D. Bordo, Olivier Jeanne. Boom-busts in asset prices, economic instability, and monetary policy [R]. NBER Working Paper, No.8966,2002.
    [57]Mishkin Frederic S.. The Causes and Propagation of Financial Instability:Lessons for Policymakers [A]. In Maintaining Financial Stability in a Global Economy, a symposium sponsored by the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City, August.1997.
    [58]Mishkin Frederic S.. Housing and the monetary transmission mechanism [R]. NBER Working Paper, No.13518,2007.
    [59]Obstfeld, Maurice. The Logic of Currency Crises [J].Banque de France, Cahiers Economiques et Monetaires, vol.43,1994.
    [60]R. J. Caballero, A. Krishnamurthy. Collective risk management in a fight to quality episode [J]. Journal of finance,2008,63(5).
    [61]Ramon Adalid, Carsten Detken. Liquidity shocks and asset price boom/bust cycles [R]. ECB working paper series, No.732,2007.
    [62]Rasmus Ruffer, Livio Stracca. What is global excess liquidity, and does it matter? [R] ECB working paper series, No.696,2006.
    [63]Reinhart, Carmen M., and Kenneth S. Rogoff. Is the 2007 U.S. Subprime Crisis So Different? An International Historical Comparison[J]. American Economic Review,2008.
    [64]Sebastian Becker. Global liquidity "glut" and asset price inflation [R]. Deutsche bank research,2009.
    [65]Tarun Chordia, Richard Roll, Avanidhar Subrahmanyam. Commonality in liquidity [J]. Journal of Financial Economics,2000,56(1).
    [66]Tarun Chordia, Richard Roll, Avanidhar Subrahmanyam.Market liquidity and trading activity [J]. The Journal of Finance,2001,56(2).
    [67]Taylor, John B. Discretion Versus Policy Rules in Practice[R]. Carnegie Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy, vol.39,1993.
    [68]Taylor, Alan M.. Latin America and Foreign Capital in the Twentieth Century:Economics, Politics, and Institutional Change[A]. in Stephen H. Haber, ed.,Institutions and Latin American Growth, Stanford:Hoover Press,2000.
    [69]Thorsten Polleit, Dieter Gerdesmeier. Measures of excess liquidity [R]. HfB working paper series, No 65,2005.
    [70]Tobin J. Liquidity preference as behavior towards risk [J]. Review of Economic Studies, 1958(25).
    [71]阿米蒂·什莱斯(吴文忠,李丹莉译).新政VS大萧条:被遗忘的人和小[M].北京:中信出版社,2008.
    [72]保埃直达.バブル经济の结构分析[M].东洋经济新报社,1994.
    [73]北京大学中国经济研究中心宏观组.流动性的度量及其与资产价格的关系[J].金融研究,2008(9)
    [74]卜永祥.流动性过剩的特征、成因及调控[J].经济学动态,2007(3)
    [75]卜永祥.我国货币流动性的周期变动及其成因[J].金融研究,1999(8)
    [76]昌忠泽.流动性冲击、货币政策失误与金融危机:对美国金融危机的反思[J].金融研究,2010,361(7).
    [77]成思危,刘骏民.虚拟经济理论与实践[M].天津:南开大学出版社,2003.
    [78]崔光灿.流动性影响资产价格与消费价格的传导机制[J].财经科学,2009(11)
    [79]范从来.论国际资本流动的货币冲击效应[J].经济社会体制比较(双月刊),2003(4).
    [80]范志勇.中国货币政策与汇率政策的协调与替代[J].世界经济,2005(7)
    [81]方平.流动性冲击的传导机制[J].金融论坛,2010(6)
    [82]弗雷德里克·米什金(姜世明译).下一轮伟大的全球化[M].北京:中信出版社,2007.
    [83]管涛.积极应对国际资本流动冲击[R].中国金融四十人论坛内刊,2011.
    [84]哈瑞·丹特(刘念熊译).下一轮经济周期[M].北京:中信出版社,2009.
    [85]哈继铭.全球流动性过剩、资产价格与中国经济的发展[J].中国金融,2007(22)
    [86]何海峰.中国“迷失的货币”[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,2011.
    [87]胡志浩.金融危机中的流动性变化及其管理[J].经济学动态,2009(4)
    [88]黄益平.资本项目开放:时机与路径[R].CF40“双周圆桌”内部研讨会,2012.
    [89]孔丽娜,郑新.拉美国家利率市场化经验及对我国的启示[J].南方金融,2011(4)
    [90]拉斯·特维德(董裕平译).逃不开的经济周期[M].北京:中信出版社,2008.
    [91]莱因哈特,罗格夫(綦相,刘晓峰,刘丽娜译).这次不一样?800年金融荒唐史[M].北京:机械工业出版社,2010.
    [92]李红艳,汪涛.中国股市价格与货币供应量关系的实证研究[J].预测,2000(3).
    [93]李超,周诚君.中国流动性过多与外汇储备累积[J].金融研究,2008(12)
    [94]李晓西,晋予.开放经济条件下我国流动性过剩问题[J].财贸经济,2007(6)
    [95]李宗怡.流动性过剩与资产价格关系的检验[J].改革,2007(7)
    [96]刘波.资本项目可兑换的几个问题[R].CF40“双周圆桌”内部研讨会,2012.
    [97]刘骏民.从虚拟资本到虚拟经济[M].济南:山东人民出版社,1998.
    [98]刘骏民,刘忠江:中国银行体系流动性过剩测度与股票价格波动:1997-2007[J].改革2007(10)
    [99]刘明志.中国的M2/GDP(1980-2000):趋势、水平和影响因素[J].经济研究,2001(3).
    [100]刘志阳.货币政策的股市传导机制模型及实证检验[J].经济科学,2002(6)
    [101]陆磊.论银行体系的流动性过剩[J].金融研究,2007(1)
    [102]林毅夫,蔡昉,李周.中国的奇迹:发展战略与经济改革[M].上海:上海人民出版社,1994.
    [103]罗伯特·J·希勒.非理性繁荣(中译本,第二版)[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2008.
    [104]罗伯特.戈登.美国经济商业周期[M],第25卷,芝加哥大学出版社,1986年.
    [105]罗忠洲.流动性、物价稳定与资产价格上涨[R].复旦大学工作论文,2011.
    [106]默里·罗斯巴德(谢育华译).美国大萧条[M].上海:上海人民出版社,2009.
    [107]彭兴韵.流动性、流动性过剩与货币政策[J].经济研究,2007(11)
    [108]钱小安.流动性过剩与货币调控[J].金融研究,2007(8)
    [109]秦月星,熊平安.从美国次贷危机探视“流动性之谜”[J].财政研究,2007(11).
    [110]史正富.30年与60年:中国的改革与发展[M].上海:上海出版社,2009.
    [111]宋国青.流动性与股票价格[R].北京大学中经济研究中心,2007年宏观经济专题课程讲义,2007.
    [112]王剑.应对外部流动性冲击的国际经验与中国的政策选择[J].金融教育研究,2011(4).
    [113]王培辉.货币冲击与资产价格波动:基于中国股市的实证分析[J].金融研究,2010(7).
    [114]王沅,朱隽.对东南亚货币冲击的分析[J].金融研究,1997(10)
    [115]汪洋.中国M2/GDP比率问题研究评述[J].管理世界,2007(1)
    [116]文宗瑜,张晓杰.中国改革三十年[M].济南:上冻人民出版社,2009.
    [117]吴敬琏.当代中国经济改革教程[M].上海:上海远东出版社,2010.
    [118]伍超明.货币流通速度的再认识:对中国1993-2003年虚拟经济与实体经济关系的分析[J].经济研究,2004(9)
    [119]谢平.新世纪中国货币政策的挑战[J].金融研究,2000(1)
    [120]谢平,张怀清.融资结构、不良资产与中国M2/GDP[J].经济研究,2007(2)
    [121]杨新松,龙革生.货币政策是否影响股票市场-基于中国股市的实证分析[J].中央财经大学学报,2006(3)
    [122]杨雪莱,许传华,徐慧玲.美国货币冲击与中国资产价格波动[J].中南财经政法大学学报,2010(3)
    [123]姚仲枝,张亚斌.中国资本项目的变化及其宏观影响[J].世界经济,2001(8)
    [124]易纲.中国经济改革过程中的货币化进程[M].北京:商务印书馆,2003.
    [125]余永定.美国次贷危机:背景、原因与发展[J].国际金融,2009(1)
    [126]约翰·梅纳德·凯恩斯(邓传军,刘志军译).货币论[M].合肥:安徽人民出版社,2012.
    [127]约翰·梅纳德·凯恩斯(宋韵声译).就业、利息和货币通论[M].北京:华夏出版社,2012.
    [128]约翰·肯尼斯·加尔布雷思.1929年大崩盘[M].上海:上海财经大学出版社,2006.
    [129]张季风.日本经济概论[M].北京:中国社会科学出版社,2009.
    [130]张军.“双轨制”经济学:中国的经济改革(1978-1992)[M].上海:上海人民出版社,2006.
    [131]张军,陈钊.承前启后:中国经济发展的见证与展望[M].北京:北京大学出版社,2009.
    [132]张明.流动性过剩的测量、根源和风险涵义[J].世界经济,2007(11).
    [133]张新泽.关于流动性几个问题的研究[J].金融研究,2008(3)
    [134]张雪春.流动性过剩:现状分析与政策建议[J].金融研究,2007(8)
    [135]赵进文,闵捷.央行货币政策操作效果非对称性实证研究[J].经济研究,2005(2).
    [136]钟伟,黄海南.利率市场化系列报告[R].平安证券,2012.
    [137]周其仁.中国做对了什么[M].北京:北京大学出版社,2010.
    [138]朱民.改变未来的金融危机[M].北京:中国金融出版社,2009.
    [139]朱琰等.利率市场化深度研究报告[R].中信证券,2010.
    [140]经济数据来源:Wind资讯,CEIC、财汇、中经网统计数据库、,中国统计年鉴(各期)和各国央行等.
    [141]标准普尔凯斯-席勒指数:www.standardanpoors.com.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700