摘要
危险废物的污染控制,是当今世界各国所面临的一个重要问题。铬渣治理是国际性环保科技难题。铬盐生产中固体危险废物污染问题主要涉及两个方面:一是多年积存的老渣,二是不断产生的新渣。重庆市铬渣排放量非常大,目前累积堆放量已超过44万t,除少部分被利用外,绝大部分都没有经过处理而直接堆放。作为我国酸沉降危害严重区之一,酸雨危害加剧了铬渣对地表水,土壤和地下水的危害。尽管铬渣的资源化处理和利用有许多成熟的技术,但其工艺较复杂,处理成本高,受当地资源利用的环境限制,加之废渣的运输成本高。因此,寻找一种既经济有效,又切实可行的铬渣治理技术对消除或降低铬对环境的影响是十分必要的。
基于上述原因,本文针对重庆市民丰农化铬渣的污染危害情况,根据铬渣堆放年代的不同选取了上世纪60年代、80年代和2005年初才生产排放的三种年代铬渣,分别表示为C、B、A。通过模拟酸雨浸泡和淋溶实验,弄清楚铬渣的毒性作用和对环境的危害性。并通过稳定剂的稳定化试验研究,初步弄清楚不同稳定剂处理铬渣的作用机理,揭示稳定剂的稳定效果,了解不同添加剂和药剂对稳定化效果的影响,分析稳定剂、添加剂和药剂共同处理铬渣的可行性,筛选出稳定剂、添加剂和药剂稳定铬渣的最佳方案。为铬渣的处理提供一种经济有效、简便的治理方法。
结果表明:三种年代铬渣A、B、C的Cr(Ⅵ)浓度分别为1.37、1.19、1.73mg/L,总Cr浓度分别为4.68、4.86、4.71mg/L。理论上总Cr的浓度是随堆积年代增长而减少的,但是由于生产工艺的改进,使得A年代新渣的总Cr浓度较B、C年代的老渣要少。酸雨浸泡、淋溶对铬渣的影响,表现为随着酸雨pH减小,铬的浸出浓度增大。酸雨浸泡对不同年代铬渣的影响表现为C>A>B,与Cr(Ⅵ)浓度规律相同;而酸雨淋溶对铬渣的影响表现为C>B>A,与水溶态的Cr(Ⅵ)浓度规律相同。Cr在酸雨影响下,不仅有形态的溶出,同时存在着形态的转化,酸度越大,水溶态和酸溶态金属量越多,这主要是源于铁锰氧化态的转化,另外也有少部分结晶态发生了溶出转化。而浸泡反应时间比较长,这样的形态之间的转化反应的越充分,转换成水溶态和酸溶态的Cr(Ⅵ)就越多。虽然铬渣的浸出毒性随着pH的增大而减小,但是随着浸泡时间的增加,铬浸出浓度的增长幅度却随着pH的增长而增大,其作用机理有待
Pollution control of hazard waste is an important problem to all the countries today. Chromium slag treatment was the international environmental protection problem. Pollution problem of solid hazard waste from production of chromium salt refer two aspect: the one was old slag of donkey's years' store up, the another was keeping procreant fresh slag. In Chongqing, discharge amount of chromium slag was very large, now cumulating stack amount has excessed 440 kilotons, excepted a small portion was used, almost had straight stacked without treatment. As one of acid sedimentation harm severity area in China, acid rain pricked up harm of chromium slag to surface water, soil and ground water. There were many adult technology of reclamation of chromium slag, but technics complexed, treatment cost was too high, be restricted by local environment, and traffic cost of chromium was high. So searching an economical and feasible treatment technology of chromium slag was necessary.
This paper aimed at pollute circumstance of chromium slag from Chongqing Minfeng Pesticide & Chemical, choose chromium slag from 60's, 80's of last century and 2005, be each represented as A, B, C. Through simulation acid rain marinate and eluviate experiment, make clear the toxicity and the harm to environment of chromium slag. And through stabilization experiment, maked clear action mechanism of different stabilizer, revealed it's stabilized effect, realized the affect of different additive and medicament to stabilization effect, analyzed the feasibility of this treat chromium slag together and screened out preferred plan. Offer an economical and handy treatment method to chromium slag.
The results showed: Cr (VI) concentration of A, B, C was 1.37, 1.19, 1.73mg/L, total Cr concentration was 4.68, 4.86, 4.71 mg/L. Theoretically total Cr concentration decreasing follow accumulate time's rise, but due to technical improvement, making total Cr concentration of A was little than B, C. Acid rain marinate and eluviate made lixiviate concentration of Cr increase follow decrease of pH. Effect of acid rain marinate to chromium slag represented C>A>B, as the same as
引文
[1] 承伯兴译.有害废物的处理技术[M].北京,中国环境科学出版社.1993:189~201.
[2] 陈灿.国家正在制定方案 彻底治理铬渣污染[J].新材料产业.2004.(9):7.
[3] 常文越.含铬(Ⅵ)废物堆放场所土壤/地下水的污染特点及土著微生物的初步生物解毒试验研究[J].环境保护科学.2002.114(28):102~105.
[4] 陈玉成,林榕光.AY—1型阳离子沥青乳化剂的研制[J].贵州大学学报.2002.19(4):346~348
[5] 杜葆光,吴凤鸣,詹勤.Na—1水玻璃固化机及其应用[J].腐蚀与防护.1998,(6):23~27.
[6] 丁翼.我国铬盐生产状况与发展建议[J].无机盐工业.2000.(4):28~30.
[7] 福本勤著.赖耿阳编译.废弃物处理工学[M].台湾复文书局.1985:153~155
[8] 高连存,何桂华.冯素萍,等.模拟酸雨条件下降尘中Cu、Pb、Zn、Cr各种形态的溶出和转化研究[J].环境化学.1994.13(5):448~452.
[9] 官月平,刘会洲,安振淘,等.高梯度磁分离铬盐浸出浆液中的铬渣[J].化工冶金.2000.21(3):318~322.
[10] 高月弘,酒井伸一.有害废弃物[M].1990.256~264.
[11] 顾宗勤.浅议我国铬盐行业的规划发展[J].化工技术经济.1999.(3):11~13.
[12] 韩怀芬,黄玉柱,金漫彤.亚铁盐预还原技术在铬渣固化/稳定化中的应用[J].上海环境科学.2002.21(8):466~468.
[13] 韩怀芬,黄玉柱,金漫彤.铬渣的固似稳定化研究[J].环境污染与防治.2004.24(4):199~200.
[14] 黄启飞.垃圾堆肥对铬污染土壤的修复机理研究[J].土壤与环境.2001.10(3):23~26.
[15] 胡勇,全学军,王万能.铬渣污染治理及其利用现状[J].重庆工学院学报,2004.10(5):42~44.
[16] 蒋建国,王伟,范浩,等.砷渣和铬渣的药剂稳定化研究[J].环境科学研究.1998.(1):30~31.
[17] 蒋建国,王伟.危险废物稳定似固化技术的现状与发展[J].环境科学进展.1998.6(1):55~62.
[18] 蒋建国,聂永丰,张继红,等.危险废物在填埋场中的浸出规模模拟实验方法研究[J].环境科学学报.2000.20(2):254~256.
[19] 金漫彤,姚超英.危险固体废弃物处理技术概念[J].浙江化工.2001.32(2):28~29.
[20] 纪柱.铬渣的物相组成及鉴定[J].无机盐工业.1981.(6):5.
[21] 蒋展鹏.环境工程学[M].北京,高等教育出版社.1992:453~454.[22] 刘大梁,刘小燕.环氧沥青混凝土性能试验研究[J].公路交通科技.2005.22(4):13~19
[23] 刘方斌.中国铬盐清洁生产日臻成熟中国环境科学学会发布6项铬渣治理技术[J].铬盐工业.2005,2:45.
[24] 刘新民.利用“正交设计方法”进行香波基质配方设计[J].天津轻工.1992(2):22~26.
[25] 刘光全.铬的浸出毒性实验方法研究[J].环境污染与防治.2000.8:12~14.
[26] 李健鹰.泥浆胶体化学[M].山东:石油大学出版社.1988:8~149.
[27] 李其林.重庆市蔬菜基地土壤重金属含量情况[J].土壤.2001.33(3):198~201.
[28] 李天杰.土壤环境学[M].北京:高等教育出版社,1996,128.
[29] 黎小华.含铬废渣的综合利用[J].重庆环境科学.1995.17(2):48~51.
[30] 罗杰.巴斯顿.有害废物的安全处置—发展中国家的特殊需要和问题[M].北京:中国环境科学出版社.1993:46~57.
[31] 芦令超,沈晓冬,严生,等.模拟高效放射性废物碱矿渣水泥基固化体的性能研究[J].硅酸盐学报.1997.25(2):139.
[32] 林树昌.分析化学[M].北京:高等教育出版社.1982.51~590.
[33] 孟紫强.环境毒理学[M].北京:中国环境科学出版社.2000:140~145.
[34] 齐涛,张懿,郭跃华,等.铬渣零排放绿色化工新过程[J].化工冶金.1999.20(1):92~97.
[35] 齐文启.国外固体废物浸出液毒性试验研究的现状[J].上海环境科学.1995.14(10).
[36] 邱学婷,肖磊,石晓波.新型水玻璃耐水固化机—磷酸硅[J].无机盐工业.1999.(6):24~26.
[37] 日本专利.昭44—8977.
[38] 任爱玲.含铬废液在土壤中迁移规律的研究[J].城市环境与城市生态.2000.2(13):154~157.
[39] 盛灿文,柴立元,王云燕,等.铬渣的湿法解毒研究现状及发展前景[J].工业安全与环保.2006.32(2):1~3.
[40] 社良,王金生.铬渣毒性对环境的影响与产出量分析[J].安全与环境学报,2004.4.(2):34~37.
[41] 施惠生,阚黎黎.铬渣—水泥体系物理性能及其Cr(Ⅵ)的控制研究[J].水泥技术.2005.6:15~18.
[42] 孙游云.铬对植物体生长生理的影响及其在植物体中的积累规律[J].环境污染与防治,2001,23(1):45~46.
[43] 孙志良,朱耀华,张大年.铬渣中Cr~(6+)的溶出特性研究[J].上海环境科学.1992.11(3):13~16.
[44] 唐景春,丁立强,殷红,等.铬渣制砖的毒性浸出及评价[J].工业安全与环保.2001.27??(8):33~34.
[45] 王博.国外工业废渣利用情况[M].北京:中国建筑工业出版社.1981:1~4.
[46] 吴敦敖,鲁文毓.铬在沉积物中存在的形态研究[J].上海环境科学.1990.9(2):13~17.
[47] 汪瀚,刘大银,刘先利,等.铬渣与粉煤灰混合填埋固定六价铬的研究.地质勘探安全.2001(1):35~39.
[48] 菀文颖,丁庭华,赵淑霞,等.北京市工业固体废物浸出毒性研究[J].环境工程.2001.19(6):50~52.
[49] 徐家保.材料建筑学[M].北京:华南理工大学出版社.1981:1~4.
[50] 杨景辉.土壤污染与防治[M].北京:科学出版社,1995,73.
[51] 袁爱群,黄平.聚合磷酸铝水玻璃固化机及应用[J].四川化工与腐蚀控制.1999.2(3):9~11.
[52] 郑礼胜.王士龙,李建霞.铬渣的稳定化研究[J].现代化工.1999.(3):30~31.
[53] 振明.固体废物的处理与处置[M].北京:高等教育出版社.1988:68~69.
[54] 周锡荣,唐绍裘,周武艺.新型无机涂料的制备及其应用[J].山东陶瓷.2004.27(1):17~20.
[55] Bell, N.E, Solidification of low-volume power plant sludges[J]. Electric Power Research Institute Project. 1981.
[56] C. Langton, Slay based material for metal and radioactive waste stabilization[J], Proc. Of Trondheim Conference, 1989, 225~264.
[57] Chen-Fong Lin. Teng-Hung Huang.Lenching Characterisities of a moldel stabilization/solidification system: tricalcium silicate and copper oride[J]. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 1990, 36.
[58] Charles M.Wilk and Ragbu Arora. Remediation[M]. 1995.5(3):335~367.
[59] C. Vipulanandan and S. Krishnan, Stabilization/solidification of phenolic waste with cementitious and polymeric materials. Journal of Hazardous Materials[J]. 1990. 24(2):81~94.
[60] Cao L. Ten environmental problem in the world[J]. A Cta Sci Circ. 16(4):88~86.
[61] Edwin F.Barth, An overview of the history, present status and future direction of solidification/stabilization technologies for hazardous waste treatment[J], Journal of Hazardous Material. 1990.24(3):235~239.
[62] Edwin E Barth, Stabilization/solidification of CERLA and RCRA waste-physical Tests. Chemical testing procedures technology and screening and field activities. USEPA. 1989.
[63] Eaton, H.C, M.B.Walsh, M.E. Tittlebaum, et al. Microscopic characterization of the Stabilization/solidification of organic hazardous wastes[M], Energy-sorces and Technology Conference and Exhibition. 1985. ASME Paper No.85-Pet-4.[64] Hoffmann, Robert E, Evaluation of the reclamation of decommissioned wood preserving plant sites in Alberta, MS.Thesis, University of Alberta, 1992.
[65] H.R. Lubowiz, Development of a polymeric and encapsulation process for managing hazardous waste, U.S.EPA Cincinnati, Ohio EPA-600/2-77-045.Auguat. 1997.
[66] Gunartnam M, Grant M H.The role of glutathione reductase in the cytotoxicity of chromium in the isolated rat bepatocytes[J].Chemico-Bilolgical Interaction, 2001, 134:191~202.
[67] Gnffin R P. R P Trost, N.F. Shimp. Ln effect of pH on removal of heavy metals from leachates by clay minerals. Illinois State Uelolgical Survey.
[68] Griffm.R.A, A.K, Au, and R.R. Frost, J. Environ.Sci. Heaclth Part A. P.431~449.1977.
[69] Jesse R. Corner, Chemical fixation and solidification of hazardous, Chemical Waste Management. nc. 1990.23(6):235~241.
[70] Jesse R.Corner, Stabilizing hazardous waste, CHEMTECH.1993.23(2).56~67.
[71] Kuang Ye Cheng, Paul Bishop, jerry lsenburg. Leaching boundary in cement-bused waste forus[J]. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 30(1990).
[72] Langton,Slag based matrial for toxic metal and radioactive waste stabilization[J]. Proc. of Trondheim Conference. 1989:351~362.
[73] MJ. Cullinane. Handbook for stabilization/solidification of hazardous waste. USEPA. 986:122~134.
[74] P.D. Kalb, J.H. Heiser, and P. Colomb, Modified sulfur cement encapsulating of mixed waste contamination incineratory fly ash[J].Waste Management, 1991, 1 (11):634~645.
[75] Robert. American Nuclear Society, Measurement of the leachability of solidified low-level radioactive waste. 1981.
[76] R. Soundararajan and E. Barth, The evaluation of an organophilic clay chemically stabilizing a waste containing organic compounds[J], Hazardous Material Contral J. 1990.3(1).45~51.
[77] Salam. Emmobolization and leachability of hazardous wastes[J], Environ, Sci. Technol. 16(4). 1982. 21(3):121~130.
[78] S. Ddaniali, Stabilization/solidification of heavy metals in latex modified Portlant cement matrices[J], Journal of Hazardous Materials, 1990, 24(2):112~134.
[79] Weast R C. CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics.55th edition.U.S.A.CRC Press, Inc 1974. B77.