零售渠道及零供双方策略选择对产品创新的影响
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
制造业与零售业的专业化分工使专业的制造商和零售商在商品经济的背景下都取得了充分的发展,双方的市场势力不断扩大,此消彼长,并存在一定程度的竞争,在共同利益基础上根据市场势力的对比对零售渠道中的利润进行重新分配。零售市场是直接面对消费者并实现商品最终销售的地方,是制造商实现利润的必经渠道,因此零售市场中的利润可以通过一系列中间变量反向影响上游生产领域的决策。在现有的研究中,大都将产品创新作为既定的事实,研究在特定的创新程度以及某种新产品特定的风险和收益的情况下,零售商应采取何种通道费政策,或者应采取何种自有品牌发展战略,或者怎样发展自建销售渠道。但是实际经济中各种因素都是互为因果的,产品的创新既然能够影响下游零售市场中的均衡状况,那么零售市场中的参数以及相关政策必然也会对生产领域造成一定的影响。近年来中国零售市场上引发零售商与制造商冲突的通道费,以及在通道费作用下进一步强化发展的零售商自有品牌与制造商自建渠道经营,都可以通过影响零供双方的合作意愿、零售商对创新产品的接纳程度以及零售市场结构的变化,对制造商生产过程中的创新投入决策产生影响。本文的研究目的就在于,将以往研究中零售行业中与产品创新有关的因素提炼出来,具体的研究零售过程中各种变量是如何对生产过程中的创新决策产生影响的,尤其是通道费、零售商自有品牌和制造商自建渠道经营对创新决策的影响,并通过借鉴发达国家零售市场的发展经验,为中国零售业的发展提出一定的参考意见。
     论文共有八个部分,分别是导论、相关概念及文献综述、零售渠道与产品创新的关系分析、通道费对产品创新的影响、自有品牌对产品创新的影响、自建渠道对产品创新的影响、中国零售业的发展方向及促进产品创新的政策建议,以及最后的结论与研究展望。通过对现有研究中对有关产品创新和零供双方纵向关系的文献进行梳理,找出影响各阶段各种类型产品创新的因素,以及零供纵向约束关系中影响双方利润以及市场绩效的因素,找出两个研究领域中的关联点,并从此关联点入手,通过建立在博弈工具基础上的理论分析,在对实际经济过程合理的简化的基础上,在符合实际情况的假设前提下,对引入通道费前后、引入自有品牌前后、引入自建渠道前后有无创新以及不同类型创新时的市场均衡进行分析,探讨在其他因素不变时某种经济变量的变动是如何影响生产过程决策的,进而在分析零售业的发展方向和相关政策制定的方针怎样才能促进生产过程中的产品创新。
     本文的研究成果主要有以下几点:首先,通道费、自有品牌与自建渠道作为零售渠道中相互影响的三种重要因素,都会通过零售市场的相关机制对上游制造商的利润及创新激励产生影响。除了制造商通过零售商平台进行销售的方式外,自有品牌和自建渠道可以作为与之相并列的策略选择。通道费是在传统渠道内部制造商利润向零售商利润的转移,可以通过弥补零售商的风险成本使零售商有激励接纳制造商的新产品,但是过多的通道费却会占用制造商大量的资金,影响其创新能力;零售商要综合考虑销售制造商品牌商品和自有品牌商品两方面的总利润最大化,因此自有品牌的低价和收取通道费都可以成为零售商保持盈利的工具,使零售商的利益得到更好的保证从而提高双方的合作意愿。自建渠道经营方式的引入会对该品牌商品的零售市场结构产生较大的影响,可以有效的打破零售商的垄断,形成竞争的局面,因此制造商为保证其产品的竞争活力,必定会加强产品创新的力度,保持自身产品的多样性。
     其次,线性通道费不会影响市场的最终均衡,也不会对零供双方的收益产生影响,但一次性通达道费会将制造商利润转移给零售商。这种利润的转移不会像广告那样造成资金向渠道外的扩散。零售商在制定通道费政策时,要综合考虑自身所处的发展阶段,以及制造商的市场规模。当零售市场趋于竞争或垄断时,降低通道费有利于刺激制造商产品创新,而当零售市场接近垄断竞争的市场结构时,适当提高通道费可以促进产品创新投入。同时,提高零售商的库存管理水平,降低边际储存成本和边际经营成本,减小制造商产品的可替代性,降低产品的需求弹性,都可以促进零供双方的合作,从而是创新产品得以顺利销售。
     第三,当存在零售商自有品牌时,产品的创新激励会有所增加。自有品牌的引入会降低原有制造商品牌商品的交易价格,而产品创新又会使两种商品市场交易价格均下降,制造商品牌产品的创新会降低自有品牌商品的交易量,增加制造商品牌商品交易量。零售商销售自有品牌产品会增加自己的利润水平,同时使制造商利润水平下降,但两者利润之和会比没有自有品牌时高。制造商对产品的创新会增加其利润,但是零售商销售品牌产品的利润会减少,进而零售商的总利润会受到影响,因此为保证零售商接纳新产品,制造商有可能会在新产品交易过程中适当的提高一次性通道费水平。而作用于提高产品的感知质量而非降低生产成本的创新,会提高消费者对商品的认知度,从而扩大商品的市场需求量,无论对零售商还是制造商利润都是有利的。更进一步,当放宽本文的假设(零售商自有品牌商品没有能力进行创新)后,即零售商也可以进行产品创新时,双方的利润都会得到提高。
     最后,制造商自建渠道有两种效应,一种是对原有渠道中消费者的分流,即对传统渠道的替代效应,另一种是在提高消费者对产品品牌认可的基础上增加市场总需求,即对传统渠道的拓展效应。本文的分析中重点考察自建渠道的拓展作用。制造商对自建渠道中降低边际经营成本的创新可以提高自身的利润以及消费者剩余,但是这种创新仅仅是在流通领域的改善,实质是一种促销手段。作用于生产领域降低边际生产成本的创新在有无自建渠道时对零售商利润的影响是相同的。当制造商有一定的市场势力,可以通过自建渠道实现规模经济和范围经济从而降低边际生产成本和边际销售成本时,其面临的市场规模越大,创新激励也就越强。当制造商的创新结果是生产出一种全新产品时,通道费可能演变成零售商向制造商的支付或者在原有通道费上的优惠,这部分支付或者优惠,可以看做是零售商为购买这项收益率较高的风险资产付出的成本。此外,建立在互联网发展、交通便利、支付手段快捷等科技发展基础上的网络零售可以视为一种新型的自建渠道形式,能够起到促进产品创新的作用。
     本文的创新之处在于,第一,从研究视角上有所创新,改变了现有研究中将生产领域与零售领域分开研究的状况,重点研究两个领域之间的相互联系,从零售渠道入手研究其对上游制造企业产品创新投入决策的影响。第二,将当前流行的网络零售作为制造商自建渠道经营的一种新形式,拓展了国内学者对网络零售研究的理论背景。第三,将零供双方合作意愿、产品质量和新产品经营策略的差异化分别作为通道费、自有品牌和自建渠道对产品创新影响的中间变量,比现有对零售领域与生产领域联系的相关研究更符合三者的现实特点。
Both manufacturers and retailers have accomplished great development since the specialization between them. With the enlarging and shifting market powers of the two participants, manufacturers and retailers share the common interests, and at the same time they are competing with each other base on their market powers. Retail market is the place for the final products to face the consumers and obtain their final values, and for the manufacturers to realize their profits, hence the profits made in retail market could effect the decision in the upstream market through a series of intermediate variables. In most of the existing literatures, innovation is considered to be a given condition, based on which the risk and profit are fixed and the retailers take corresponding measures. Nevertheless, under the real economic environment, all the factors interacts with each other, as a result, not only the innovation could effect retail market, but also the situation in the downstream market could effect manufacturers' decision on innovation too. In the recent years, most of the conflicts between manufacturers and retailers are caused by slotting allowances, which reinforce the development of retailers' private brands and manufacturers' self-constructed channels. All of the three aspects could influence manufacturers' innovation decision by impacting the participants' willing to cooperate, retailers' desire for new products and chances in retail market structures. This paper if aimed at the influence of parameters of retail market on innovation decision in the product process, especially how the slotting allowances, retailers' private brand and producers' self-built channels affect the innovation policy. Further more some suggestions are given for the development of Chinese retail business. And considering the open retail market in the environment of economic globalization, we should draw the experiences of developed markets and furthermore improve our laws and rules on retail market.
     The paper is consist of the following eight parts, introduction, the relevant concept and literature review, the relationship between retail channel and innovation, the effect of slotting allowances on innovation, the effect of retailers' private brands on innovation, the manufacturers' self-constructed channels on innovation, currents development of China's retail market and suggestions to promote innovation, and finally the conclusion and research prospect.
     By reviewing the current literatures on innovation and vertical relationship between manufacturers and retailers, factors that effect innovation of different product stages and types, and the ones that effect producers'and retailers' profit, are found. The connections between the factors are the basic of this paper. With reasonable simplified assumption, we could compare the situations with or without the slotting allowances, privation brands and self-built channels before and after innovation. When other parameters are fixed, alteration of some facts may change the innovation decision, based on which the directors of retail market could make relative policies to guarantee the positive influence of retail market on innovation.
     There are four mail conclusions of this paper. First of all, slotting allowances, private brands and self-built channels could effect the profits and innovation inspiration of innovation in the upstream market. Define the common retail pattern of producers sell products through specialized retailers as tradition retail channel, and then the private brands and self-constructed channels could be viewed as the expanded form of the traditional channel, namely the outside choice. Slotting allowances are shift of profit from manufacturers to retailers within the channel, and could stimulate manufacturers'innovation by offsetting the potential risks. However an excess of slotting allowance would occupy big amount of the producers'capital and hinder the innovation. Specialized retailer should take into account the profits made by selling both private brand product and manufacturer brand product, and maximize the combination profit. Private brands with low prices and slotting allowances could both be the tools of the retailer to make profit. Self-constructed channels would impact the structure of the retail market by breaking the retailers' monopoly in the industry. To stay profitable in the competition with retailers, producers have to focus on innovation so as to maintain the products'diversity.
     Secondly, it is the one-time slotting allowance rather than linear fee that would affect the equilibrium. Such transfer of profit would not cause a waste of capital as advertisement does. When making the decisions, retailers have to take their development stage as well as the manufacturers'scopes in to consideration.
     Thirdly, retailers'private brands could stimulate innovation by decrease the prices of manufacturer brand products, and the innovation would lower the prices of both brands in return. When the innovation reduces the marginal cost of production, there could be a chance that manufacturers would like to increase the slotting allowances so as to reinforce the retailers' willing to cooperate. Further more, when relaxing the assumption to allow the retailers' private brand production to innovate, both the manufacturer and the retailer would enjoy more profit.
     Finally, there are two effects of manufacturers'self-built channels. On the one hand, they could convert the consumers from the original channels to the new ones, on the other hand, they could attract more customers and increase the demand. This paper mainly focuses on the latter one. Manufacturers'innovation could reduce the marginal cost in production or marketing, or could generate a completely new product. Slotting allowances could become an actual payment from retailers to manufacturers as a cost for the risk assets with relatively high rate of return. Besides, with the development of internet, transportation and electronic commerce, internet retail, which could be considered as a kind of self-built channels, could stimulate innovation more than ever before.
     Three innovation ideas could be seen in this paper. First of all, the effect of retail channels on innovation is systematically studied. Although in the existing researches, innovation of products has been taken into account, the retailers'strategies'influence on innovation have seldom been studied. Secondly, internet retail is considered as a new type of innovation with lower costs, lower risks and better chances to succeed. Finally, the willing to cooperate, the quality of products and the differential marketing strategies of new products are considered respectively as the intermediate variables of slotting allowances, private brands and self-built channels effect of innovation. Such assumption is more accordance with the reality.
引文
1陈劲等(2002)
    1贝思·罗杰斯(2003)
    1李妍姝(2003)
    2同4
    3甘华鸣(2002)
    1本部分资料部分转引自邸智源(2007)
    1转引自李飞,程丹,西方零售商自有品牌理论研究综述(2006)
    1转引自Cannon & Bloom(1991)
    1转引自余晖(2006):冯昭奎,[日]小山周三,《中日流通业比较》
    1. 陈劲等译.创新管理——技术、市场与组织变革的集成[M].北京:清华大学出版社,2002.
    2.傅家骥.工业技术经济学[M].北京:清华大学出版社,1986.
    3.彭玉冰,白国红.谈企业技术创新与政府行为[J].经济问题,1999年第7期:35-36.
    4. 贝思·罗杰斯,产品创新战略[M].大连:东北财经大学出版社,2003.
    5.徐庆瑞.研究与发展管理[M].北京:高等教育出版社,2000.
    6. 胡树华.预警管理——产品开发预警管理[M].石家庄:河北科学技术出版社,1999.
    7.李妍姝.产品创新[M].北京:中国纺织出版社,2003.
    8.甘华鸣.新产品开发[M].北京:中国国际广播出版社,2002.
    9.谭国富.纵向约束的经济理论[J].产业经济评论,2004(2):1-22.
    10.邸智源.美国转售价格维持的反垄断法调整探析[J].商场现代化,2007(2):314.
    11. Comanor W.S., Kirwood J. B. Resale price maintenance and antitrust policy [J]. Contemporary Economic Policy,1985,3(3):9-16.
    12. Hamilton J.H.,Resale price maintenance in a model of consumer search [J]. Managerial and Decision Economics,1990, 11(2):87-98.
    13. Deneckere R., Marvel H.P., Peck J. Demand uncertainty and price maintenance:L markdowns as destructive competition [J]. American Economic Association,1997, 87(4):619-641.
    14. Chen M. The effects of advertising on retail price competition under vertical restraint:a Japanese case [J]. Journal of Business Research,2004,57(3):277-283.
    15. Secrieru O. The economic theory of vertical restraints [J]. Journal of Economic Surveys,2006,20(5):797-822.
    16. Mathewson F., Winter R. Territorial restrictions in franchise contracts [J]. Economic Inquiry,1994,32(2):181-192.
    17. Jullien B., Rey P. Resale price maintenance and collusion [J].The RAND Journal of Economics,2007,38(4):pp.1-40.
    18. Cosac C. Vertical restraints and parallel imports with differentiated products [D]. Unpublished PHD Thesis, Feb.2003.
    19. Matsumura T. Stacklberg mixed duopoly with a foreign competitor [J]. Bulletin of Economic Research,2003,55(3):275-287.
    20. Shaffer G. Slotting Allowances and resale price maintenance:a comparison of facilitating practices [J]. The RAND Journal of Economics,1991,22(1):120-135.
    21. Bloom P. N., Gundlach G. T., Cannon J. P. Slotting allowances and fees, schools of thought and the views of practicing managers [J]. The Journal of Marketing, 2000,64(2):92-108.
    22.汪浩.通道费与零售商市场力量[J].经济评论,2006(1期):29-34.
    23.李骏阳.对收取通道费原因的分析——基于我国零售企业的盈利模式研究[J].管理学报,2009(12):1691-1695.
    24.李健生,闫传强.自有品牌对零供博弈关系的影响分析[J].中国零售研究,2010(1):42-50.
    25.李飞,程丹.西方零售商自有品牌理论研究综述[J].北京工商大学学报(社会科学版),2006(1):1-5.
    26. Koskinen S. UK private label:European brand leader [J]. European Retail Digest, 1999,(21):5-8.
    27. Linn S. Moving from private label to private brand [J]. Drug Store News,2003, 25(16):14.
    28. Hoch S.J. How should national brand think about private label? [J]. Sloan Management Review,1996,37(2):89-102.
    29. Sayman S., Hoch S.J., Raju J.S. Positioning of store brands [J]. Marketing Science,2002,21(4):378-397.
    30. Scott M., Zettlemeyer F. The strategic positioning of Store Brands in Retailer-Manufacturer negotiations [J]. Review of Industrial Organization, 2004(24):161-194.
    31. Soberman D. A., Parker P. M. The economics of quality-equivalent store brands[J]. International Journal of Research in Marketing,2006(23):125-139.
    32. Olson J.C.,Jacoby J. Research of perceiving quality [J]. Emerging Concepts in Marketing,1972(9):220-226.
    33. Bettman J. R. Relationship of information-processing attitude structures to private brand purchasing behavior [J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,1990(1):79-83.
    34. Zeithaml V. A. Consumer perception of private label quality [J]. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Service,1988(2):48-49.
    35. Livesey F., Lennon P. Factors affecting consumers'choice between manufacturer brand and retailer own brands [J]. European Journal of Marketing, 1978(12):58-70.
    36. Bellizzi J.A. Consumer perceptions of national private and generic brands [J]. Journal of retailing,1981(57):56-70.
    37. Richardson, Contextual influences on perceptions of merchant supplied reference prices [J]. Journal of Consumer Research,1994(16):55-66.
    38. Guerrero L., Colomer Y., Guardia M.D., Xicola J. Clotet R. Consumer attitude towards store brands [J]. Food Quality and Preference,2000(11):387-395.
    39. Vahie A., Paswan A. Private label brand image:its relationship with store image and national brand [J]. International Journal of Retail & Distribution Management, 2006,34(1):67-84.
    40.毕雪梅.顾客感知质量研究[J].华中农业大学学报(社会科学版),2004(3),42-45.
    41.江明华,郭磊.商店形象与自有品牌商品感知质量的实证研究[J].经济科学,2003(4):119-128.
    42. Arrow K. J. The Economic implications of learning by doing [J]. The Review of Economic Studies,1962,29(3):155-173.
    43. Weeds H. Strategic delay in a real options model of R&D competition [J]. Review of Economic Studies,2002,69(3):729-747.
    44. Lin C. Y, Chen M. Y Does innovation lead to performance? An empirical study of SMEs in Taiwan [J]. Management Research News,2007,30(2):115-132.
    45. Vickers J. The evolution of market structure when there is a sequence of innovation [J]. The Journal of Industrial Economics,1986, ⅩⅩⅩⅤ:1-12.
    46. Greenstein S., Ramey G. Market structure, innovation and vertical product differentiation [J]. International Journal of industrial organization,1998, 16(3):285-311.
    47. Boone J. Intensity of competition and the incentive to innovation [J]. International Journal of Industrial Organization,2001,19(5):705-726.
    48. Ben-Zion U., Fixler D. J. Market structure and product innovation [J]. Southern Economic Journal,1981,48(2):437-448.
    49. Tandon P. Innovation, market structure, and welfare [J]. American Economic Association,1984,74(3):394-403.
    50. Bonanno G., Haworth B. Intensity of competition and the choice between product and process innovation [J]. International Journal of Industrial Organization,1998, 16(4):495-510.
    51. Lin P., Saggi K. Product differentiation, processes R&D and the nature of market competition [J]. European Economic Review,2002,46(1):201-211.
    52. Mansfield E. Patents and innovation:an empirical study [J]. Management Science, 1986,32(2):173-181.
    53. Baily M. N., Chakrabarti A. K., Levin R. C. Innovation and productivity in U.S. Industry[J]. Brooking Papers on Economic Activity,1985,1985(2):609-639.
    54. Braga H., Willmore L. Technological imports and technological effort:an analysis of their determinants in Brazilian firms [J]. The Journal of Industrial Economics,1991, XXXIX:421-432.
    55.千慧雄,卜茂亮.异质性条件下产品创新的最优市场结构研究[J].经济评论,2011(3):12-20.
    56.陈羽,李小平,白澎.市场结构如何影响R&D投入?——基于中国制造业行业面板数据的实证分析[J].南开经济研究,2007(1):135-145.
    57.吴延兵.企业规模、市场力量与创新:一个文献综述[J].经济研究,2007(5):125-138.
    58.朱乾龙,钱书法.基于网络经济的技术创新与市场结构关系分析[J].产业经济研究,2009(1):54-61.
    59. Kohli A., Jaworski B. Marketing orientation:the construct, research propositions and managerial implications [J]. Journal of marketing,1990,54(2):1-18.
    60. Narver J.C., Slater S.F. The effect of market orientation on business profitability [J]. Journal of Marketing,1990,54(4):20-35.
    61. Li C.R., Lin C. J., Chu C. P. The nature of market orientation and the Ambidexterity of innovations [J]. Management Decision,2008,46(7):1002-1026.
    62. Deshpande R., Fariley J., Webster F. Corporate culture, customer orientation, and innovativeness in Japanese Firms:A quadrad analysis[J]. Journal of Marketing, 1993,57(1):23-38.
    63. Jaworski B. J., Kohli A. K. Marketing orientation:antecedents and consequences [J]. Journal of Marketing,1993,57(7):53-70.
    64. Slater S. F., Narver J. C. Does competitive environment moderate the market orientation performance relationship [J]. Journal of Marketing,1994,58(1):46-55.
    65. Berthon P., Hulbert J., Pitt L. To serve or to create? Strategic orientation towards customers and innovation [J]. California Management Review,1999,42(1):37-58.
    66. Christensen C. M., Bower J. L. Customer Power, strategic investment, and the failure of leading firms [J]. Strategic Management Journal,1996,17(3):197-218.
    67. Massimo Motta. Endogenous quality choice:price vs. quantity competition [J]. The Journal of Industrial economics,1993, XLI:113-131.
    68. Tse D. K. Improving media decisions in China:a targetability and cost-benefit analysis [J]. Journal of Advertising,2005,34(1):49-63.
    69. Dutta P.K., Rustichini A. A theory of stopping time games with applications to product innovations and asset sales [J]. Economic Theory,1993,3(4):743-763.
    70. Aoki R., Prusa T. J. Sequential versus simultaneous choice with endogenous quality [J]. International Journal of Industrial Organization,1997,15(1):103-121.
    71. Lambertini U., Mantovani A., Process and product innovation by a multiproduct monopolist:a dynamic approach [J]. International Journal of Industrial Organization,2009,27(4):508-518.
    72. Symeonodis G. Comparing Cournot and Bertrand equilibria in a differentiated duopoly with product R&D [J]. International Journal of Industrial Organization, 2003,21(1):39-55.
    73. Delbono F., Denicolo V. R&D investment in a symmetric and homogeneous oligopoly:Bertrand vs. Cournot [J]. International Journal of Industrial Organization,1990,8(2) 297-313.
    74. Marion B. W. Changing Power Relationships in US Food Industry:Brokerage Arrangements for Private Label Products [J]. Agribusiness,1998,14(2):85-93.
    75. Dobson P. W., Waterson M. Countervailing power and consumer prices [J]. The Economic Journal,1997,107(441):418-430.
    76. Kadiyali V., Chintagunta P., Vilcassim N. Manufacturer-retailer channel interactions and implications for channel power:an empirical investigation of pricing in a local market [J]. Marketing Science,2000,19(2):127-148.
    77. Barros P.P., Brito D., Lucena D. Mergers in the food retailing sector:An empirical investigation [J]. European Economic Review,2006,50:447-468.
    78. Bloom P. N., Perry V. G. Retail power and supplier welfare:the case of Wal-Mart [J]. Journal of Retailing,2001,77:379-396.
    79. Dobson P., Waterson M., Konrad K., Matutes C. Retailer power:recent developments and policy implications [J]. Economic Policy,1999,14(28):133-16.
    80. Dobson P, Waterson M., Chu A. The welfare consequences of the exercise of buyer power [R]. London:Office of Fair Trading,1998.
    81. Hunter A. Notes on countervailing power [J]. The Economic Journal,1958, 68(269):89-103.
    82. Sellers-Rubio R., Mas-Ruiz F. J. Efficiency vs. market power in retailing: analysis of supermarket Chains [J]. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services, 2009,17:61-67.
    83. Dobson P. W., Waterson M. Countervailing power and consumer prices [J]. The Economic Journal,1997,107(441):418-430.
    84. Kadiyali V., Chintagunta P., Vilcassim N. Manufacturer-retailer channel interactions and implications for channel power:an empirical investigation of pricing in a local market [J]. Marketing Science,2000,19(2):127-148.
    85. Mathewson G. F., Winter R. A. An economic theory of vertical restraints [J]. The RAND Journal of Economics,1984,15(1):27-38.
    86. Romano R. E. Double moral hazard and resale price maintenance [J]. The RAND Journal of Economics,1994,25(3):455-466.
    87. Bernheim B. D., Whinston M. D. Exclusive dealing [J]. The Journal of Political Economy,1998,106(1):64-103.
    88. Lal R., Villas-Boas J. M. Exclusive dealing and price promotions [J]. The Journal of Business,1996,69(2):159-172.
    89. O'Brien D. P., Shaffer G. Vertical control with bilateral contracts [J]. The RAND Journal of Economics,1992,23(3):299-308.
    90. Bolton P., Bonanno G. Vertical restraints in a model of vertical differentiation [J]. The Quarterly Journal of Economics,1988,103(3):555-570.
    91. Besanko D., Perry M. K. Equilibrium incentives for exclusive dealing in a differentiated products oligopoly [J]. The RAND Journal of Economics,1993, 24(4):646-667.
    92. O'Brien D. P., Shaffer G. Nonlinear supply contracts exclusive dealing and equilibrium market foreclosure [J]. Journal of Economics & Management Strategy, 1997,6(4):755-785.
    93. Shaffer G. Slotting allowances and resale price maintenance:a comparison of facilitation practices [J]. The RAND Journal of Economics,1991,22(1):120-135.
    94. Li L. Information sharing in a supply chain with horizontal competition [J]. Management Science,2002,48(9):1196-1212.
    95. MacAvoy C. J., Arnold H. S., LLP. W. Enforcement policy regarding slotting allowances, Federal Trade Commission Workshop On Slotting Allowances, 2000[C]. Washington, D.C.:May 31-June 1,2000.
    96. Rey P., Thal J., Verge T., Slotting allowances and conditional payments. Supermarkets Conference,2006[C]. Londres:Institute for Fiscal Studies: December 8-9,2006.
    97. Bloom P.N., Gundlah G.T., Cannon J. P. Slotting allowances and fees:schools of thought and the views of practicing managers [J]. The Journal of Marketing,2000, 64(2):92-108.
    98. Hamilton S. F. Slotting allowances as a facilitating practice by food processors in wholesale grocery [J]. American Journal of Agricultural Economics,2003,85(4): 797-813.
    99. Comanor W. S. Vertical price-fixing, vertical market restrictions, and the new antitrust policy [J]. Harvard Law Review,1985,98(5):983-1002.
    100.Chen Z. Dominant retailers and the countervail ing-power hypothesis [J]. The RAND Journal of Economics,2003,34(4):612-625.
    101.Cannon J. P., Bloom P. N. Are slotting allowances legal under the antitrust laws? [J]. Journal of Public Policy & Marketing,1991,10(1):167-186.
    102.Yong J. Exclusionary vertical contracts and product market competition [J]. The Journal of Business,1999,72(3):385-406.
    103.Cannon J. P., Bloom P. N. Are slotting allowances legal under the antitrust laws? [J]. Journal of Public & Marketing,1991,19(1):167-186.
    104.Bone P. F., France K. R., Riley R. A multiform analysis of slotting fees [J]. Public Policy & Marketing,2006,25(2):224-237.
    105.Kim S. Y., Staelin R. Manufacturer allowances and retailer pass-through rate in a completive environment [J]. Marketing Sciences,1999,18(1):59-76
    106.Shaffer G. Slotting allowances and resale price maintenance:a comparison of facilitation practices [J]. The RAND Journal of Economics,1991,22(1):120-135.
    107.Innes R., Hamilton S. F. Naked slotting fees for vertical control of multi-product retail markets [J]. International Journal of Industrial Organization,2006,24(2): 303-318.
    108.Rao A. R., Mahi H. The price of launching a new product:empirical evidence on factors affecting the relative magnitude of slotting allowances [J]. Marketing Science,2003,22(2):246-268.
    109.张赞,郁义鸿.零售商垄断势力、通道费与经济规制[J].财贸经济,2006(3):60-66.
    110.刘向东,沈建.我国的通道费:理论发展与规制策略[J].管理世界,2007(7):164-165.
    111.Kelly K. The antitrust analysis of grocery slotting allowances:the procompetitive case [J]. Journal of Public Policy & Marketing,1991,10(1):187-198.
    112.Richards T. J., Patterson P.M. Slotting allowances as real options:an alternative explanation [J]. The Journal of Business,2004,77(4):675-696.
    113.Chu W. Demand signaling and screening in channels of distribution [J]. Marketing Science,1992,11(4):327-347.
    114.边翠兰.超市收费的合理性初探[J].中国物价,2005(04):46-50.
    115.徐颖.进场费对商品价格的影响[J].价格理论与实践,2006(06):68-69.
    116.上海连锁经营研究所.中国连锁超市的通道费报告[R].http://wenku.baidu.com/view/01eb89eaaeaad1f346933f38.html
    117.谢庆怡.超市进场费的合理性分析[J].现代商贸工业,2007(12):159-160.
    118.兰蕾.“通道费”应受反不正当竞争法规制吗[J].特区经济,2005(06):296-297.
    119.沈荣耀.关于通道费的法律思考[J].上海商业,2005(8):32-33.
    120.Blair B. F., Lewis T. R. Optimal retail contracts with asymmetric information and moral hazard [J]. The RAND Journal of Economics,1994,25(2):284-296.
    121.Rey P., Tirole J. The logic of vertical restraints [J]. The American Economic Review,1986,76(5):921-939.
    122.Chu W. Demand signalling and screening in channels of distribution [J]. Marketing Science,1992,11(4):327-347.
    123.Lariviere M. A., Padmanabhan V. Slotting allowances and new product introductions [J]. Marketing Science,1997,16(2):112-128.
    124.Sullivan M. W. Slotting allowances and the market for new Products [J]. Journal of Law and Economics,1997,40(2):461-493.
    125.Desai P. S. Multiple messages to retain retailers:signaling new product demand [J]. Marketing Science,2000,19(4):381-389.
    126.Desiraju R. New product introductions, slotting allowances, and retailer discretion [J]. Journal of Retailing,2001,77:335-358.
    127.Dekimpe M. G., Steenkamp E.M., Meelens M., Abeele P.V. Decline and variability in brand loyalty [J]. International Journal of Research in Marketing, 1997,14(5):405-420.
    128.Bhasin A., Dickinson R., Nandan S. Retailer brands:a channel perspective:the United states [J]. Journal of Marketing Channels,1995,4(4):17-36.
    129.Hoch S. J. How should national brands think about private labels [J]. Sloan Management Review,1996,37(2):89-102.
    130.Quelch J. A., Harding D. Brands versus private labels:fighting to win [J]. Harvard Business Review,1996,74(1):99-109.
    131.Gable M., Fairhurst A., Dickinson R. The use of benchmarking to enhance marketing decision making [J].The Journal of Consumer Marketing,1993,10(1): 52-60.
    132.Burt S., Davis S. Follow my Leader? Lookalike retailer brands in non-manufacturer-dominated markets in the U.K. [J]. International Review of Retail, Distribution and Consumer Research,1999,9(2):163-185.
    133.Verhoef P.C., Nijssen E. J.,Sloot L. M. Strategic reactions of national brand manufacturers towards private labels:An empirical study in the Netherlands [J]. European Journal of Marketing, Bradford,2002,36(11/12):1309-1326.
    134.Hoch S. J., Banerji S. When do private labels succeed? [J]. Sloan Management Review,1993,34(4):57-67.
    135.Reynolds J., Howard E., Cuthbertson C., Hristov L. Perspectives on retail format innovation:relating theory and practice [J]. International Journal of Retail & Distribution Management,2007,35(8):647-660.
    136.Nandan S., Dickinson R. Private brands [J]. The Journal of Consumer Marketing, 1994,11(4):18-28.
    137.朱瑞庭.零售商自有品牌的功能和市场定位[J].北京工商大学学报,2004(2):38-43.
    138.林佳.制造企业如何应对零售商自有品牌策略[J].北京市财贸管理干部学院学报,2004(2):15-17.
    139.常永胜,王卫红.论零售商自有品牌管理[J].财经理论与实践,2004(2):112-115.
    140.李艳松,朱哲.大商集团自有品牌管理实证研究[J].商场现代化,2007(1):243-244.
    141.汪旭辉.中国零售商自有品牌实施的难点及对策[J].经济与管理,2006(5):59-62.
    142.江明华,郭磊.商店形象与自有品牌感知质量的实证研究[J].经济科学,2003(4):119-128.
    143.张赞.零售商引入自有品牌动机的博弈分析[J].财贸经济,2009(4):129-134.
    144.Wang Y., Bell D. R., Padmanabhan V. Manufacturer-owned retail stores [J]. Market Letters 2009,20:107-124.
    145.Etgar M. The effects of forward vertical integration on sevice performance of a distributive industry, Journal of Industrial Economics,1978,26:249-255.
    146.Coughlan A.T. Competition and cooperation in marketing channel choice:theory and application [J]. Marketing Science,1985,4(2):110-129.
    147.McGuire T. W., Staelin R. An industry equilibriu.m analysis of downstream vertical integration [J]. Marketing Science,1983,2(2):161-191.
    148.Moorthy K. S. Strategic decentralization in channels [J]. Marketing Science,1987, 7(4):335-355.
    149.Trivedi, M. Distribution channels:an extension of exclusive relationship [J]. Management Science,1998,44:896-909.
    150.Eliashberg J. R., Michie D.A. Multiple business goals sets as determinants of marketing channels conflict:an empirical study [J]. Journal of Marketing Research,1984,21 (February):75-88.
    151.中国电子商务研究中心.2010年中国网络团购调查报告.[R].2010,9.http://wenku.baidu.com/view/21b7c6b665ce0508763213d5.html
    152.余晖.日本的《大店法》及对中国零售业规制的启示[J].开放导报,2006(8):108-110.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700