摘要
沥青路面是我国高等级公路路面结构的主要形式之一。随着重载交通的出现与形成,沥青路面早期破坏现象愈来愈普遍,重载已成为影响路面服务性能和缩短路面使用寿命的重要因素之一。由于交通、环境、轴组、路基路面结构、施工质量及维修政策因时因地而异,造成路面损坏的原因也各不相同。为此,本论文从具体路面状况和理论分析两方面入手,对重载沥青路面进行结构分析与性能评价。
论文首先就国道108线广北段二期工程的路面状况调查结果,对各种路面病害的原因进行了分析,特别是附加结构响应对路面早期破坏的影响。其次,以商业软件ANSYS为计算工具,应用弹性和弹塑性理论,对重载沥青路面进行数值仿真分析,研究了路面结构在双轮车辆荷载作用下的力学响应,分析讨论了超重荷载、路面类型与结构组合对沥青路面的应力应变、承载能力及疲劳寿命等方面的影响,同时探讨了不同超限量对路面关键响应的变化规律。最后,结合具体实例,将理论分析结果与路面的实际特征和状态作了对照分析。
论文研究结果表明:施工质量和外界环境是导致路面损坏的外因;重载交通使路面关键响应增大,使路面的损坏过程加快、损坏程度加深,结构组合影响路面各结构层性能的发挥,制约着路面的使用性能和使用寿命,这两者都是路面损坏的内因。论文的研究成果对路面结构设计、公路管理及养护维修具有指导意义,为今后重载交通沥青路面设计提供了一些可供参考的有价值的思路。
Asphalt pavement is one of the primary structures for main roads in China. Along with the appearing and forming of the heavy-loaded traffic in recent years,the premature failure of asphalt pavements is becoming more and more widespread. Consequently, Over loading has become one of the key factors which influence the in-servive performance of pavements and shorten the natural life of pavements.Due to the variation in traffic, environment, axle configuration, subgrade condition, pavement structure, construction quality, and maintenance policy from agency to agency, from place to place, the deterioration of pavement may be caused by different factors. Therefore, the structural analysis and performance evaluation of heavy-loaded asphalt pavement have been conducted on two aspects about specific pavement conditions and theoretical analysis in this thesis.
In this thesis, firstly, based on the investigation results of pavement status of highway pavement structures in the 2nd phase of Guangbei Section of National Highway 108 (Beijing to Kunming),the causes of pavement deteriorations were analysed, especially, the factor of additional structural responses influencing pavement distress, especially premature failure,was analysed, the measures of prevention and cure for pavement failure were put forward. Secondly, Numerical simulation analysis about heavy-loaded asphalt pavement was performed using elastic and elastic-plastic theories with commercial finite element analysis software-ANSYS.and the mechanical responses of pavement in two cyclic traffic loads were studied. Also, the influences on the asphalt pavement,such as the stress, the strain, the carrying-capacity and the fatigue-national life, by the factors about over-loadings, pavement styles and structural layer combinations, were analysed and discussed.At the same time,the changed characters of key response
s of pavement which conducted by the loads, which preponderated over the allowable weight, were discussed too. Finally, the theoretical analysis results were compared to the actual characters and states of pavement by specific examples.
The results of the thesis show that construction quality and environment condition be the exterior factors in the development of pavement deteriorations. Heavy-loaded traffic can be brought on increasing critical responses of pavement, accelerating the process of pavement deteriorations and making the deterioration degree deepper. And the structural layer combination can influence pavement performance, can restrict the in-servive performance of pavement and can determine it's natural life too. Both the above two factors(Namely, heavy-loaded traffic and structural layer combination) are the interior factors in the formation of pavement dilapidations. Major conclusions drawn from this study can be beneficial to the structural design, supervision, maintenance, and rehabilitation of pavements for roads. And offer some useful thoughtways, which are referenced and valuable for heavy-loaded asphalt pavement design in future.
引文
1.交通部综合规划司.2001年公路水路交通行业发展统计公报.http://www.moc.gov.cn.
2.魏连雨.车辆超载运输对沥青路面的破坏作用.1996年中国公路学会道路工程学会论文集.北京:人民交通出版社,1996.
3.童言白,李长来,赵振家.浅析超载车辆对路面的影响.公路,1999(12):77~79.
4.田波.重载水泥混凝土路面结构分析.同济大学博士学位论文,2001,11
5.沙庆林.高等级公路半刚性基层沥青路面.北京:人民交通出版社,1998.
6.魏连雨,李巧茹,张多马.超载交通运输对津围公路路面和桥梁的影响及对策研究.天津公路,1999(5).
7.江瑞龄,肖泉,孙蔚.超载运输对路面结构破坏的影响.华东公路,1999(5).
8.林伍湖.超载车辆对高速公路沥青路面破坏原因的分析及对策.华东公路,2002(2):38~40.
9.西南交通大学土木工程学院公路工程研究所.国道108线广北段路面早期破坏研究之一《路面早期破坏中结构与材料的影响》,2001.
10.沙庆林.高速公路沥青路面早期破坏现象及防治.北京:人民交通出版社,2001.
11.朱照宏,王秉纲,郭大智.路面力学计算.北京:人民交通出版社,1985.
12.陆辉.轮载作用下沥青路面结构三维非线性有限元分析方法研究.同济大学博士学位论文,2000.
13.邓学钧,黄晓明.路面设计原理与方法.北京:人民交通出版社,2001.
14. C. Older, Highway Research in Illinois, Trans. ASCE, vol.87, P. 1180,1924.
15. H.M.S. Westergaard, Stresses in Concrete Pavememt Computed by Theoretical Analysis, Proc. HRB, Part 1, 1925.
16.徐家钰,程家驹.道路工程.上海:同济大学出版社,1995.
17.E.J.约德,M.W.韦特捷 著.陈炳麟 等译.路面设计原理.北京:人民交通出版社,1983.
18.姚祖康 主编.公路设计手册《公路》(第二版).北京:人民交通出版社,1999.
19. Burmister, D.M., The Theroy of Stresses and Displacements in Layered Systems and Application to The Design of Airport Runways. Proceedings, Highway Research Board, 1943.
20. Burmister, D.M., The Theroy of Stresses and Displacements in Layered Soil Systems. Journal of Applied Physics Vol. 16, 1945.
21.邓学钧,黄卫,黄晓明.路面结构计算和设计电算方法.南京:东南大学出版社,1997.
22. J. Verstraeten. Stresses and Displacements in Elastic Layered Systems: General Theroy-Numercial Stress Calculation in Four-Layered Systems with
Continuous Interfaces. Proc. 2rd Int. Con. Asp. Pave. Des. The University of Michigan. Ann Arbor. Michigan. August7-11.1967, p223~238.
23. C.L. Monismith et al. A general Analytically Based Approach to the Design of Asphalt Concrete Pavement. Proc. 6rd Int. Con. Asp. Pave. Des. The University of Michigan. Ann Arbor. Michigan. U.S.A. July13-17.1987, p344~365.
24. F. Finn et al. The Use of Distress Prediction Subsystems for The Design of Pavement Structure. Proc. 4th Int. Con. Asp. Pave. Des. The University of Michigan. Ann Arbor. Michigan. August22-26.1977, p3~38.
25.黄仰贤.路面分析与设计.北京:人民交通出版社,1998.
26. Jean Balay et al. Mechanical Behaviour of Soils and Unbound Granular Materials, Modelling of Flexible Pavements-Recent Advances. Proc. 8th Int. Con. Asp. Pave. Des. University of Washington. Seattle. Washington. U.S.A. August10-14,1997, p823~842.
27.郭大智,任瑞波.路桥结构理论与工程系列丛书—层状粘弹性体系力学.哈尔滨:哈尔滨工业大学出版社,2001.
28.郭大智,冯德成.路桥结构理论与工程系列丛书—层状弹性体系力学.哈尔滨:哈尔滨工业大学出版社,2001.
29.李朝阳.沥青路面应力位移简化计算.重庆交通学院学报,1999(3):42~48.
30.孙璐,郑凯.柔性路面中层底面弯拉应力分析.重庆交通学院学报,1998(4):24~28.
31.林秀贤.柔性路面设计方法.北京:人民交通出版社,1988.
32.中华人民共和国交通部.公路沥青路面设计规范(JTJ014—97).北京:人民交通出版社,1997.
33.黄卫,钱振东.高等沥青路面设计理论和方法.北京:科学出版社,2001.
34.王选仓,潭权,王新岐,李春平,齐在春,鞠江庆,重载沥青路面研究.西安公路交通大学学报,1998(4):7~10.
35.何兆益,沈颖,黄卫,邓学均.具有碎石基层的半刚性沥青路面合理结构研究.岩土工程学报,1998(2):93~96.
36.严作人.弹粘性半空间的力学分析.同济大学学报,1987(2):191~199.
37.许志鸿,郭大智,吴晋伟,朱永灵.沥青路面车辙的理论计算.中国公路学报,1990(3):27~36.
38.张肖宁,潘大林,朱希岭.沥青混合料一维非线性粘弹性本构关系.力学学报,1996(6):728~734.
39.李国强,黄卫,邓学均.沥青混凝土非线性流变模型与路面缩裂温度欲估.重庆交通学院学报,1997(1):50~59.
40.高英,曹荣吉.超重交通荷载作用下沥青路面的应力分析.公路交通科技,2001(6):25~27.
41. Cheung, Y.K. and Zienkiewicz, O.C.,Plates and Tanks on Elastic Foundation-an Application of Finite Element Method, International Journal of Solids and
Structures, Vol. 1,1965, p451~461.
42. Hudson, W.R. and Matlock, H., Analysis of Discontinuous Orthotropic Pavement Slabs Subjected to Combined Loads, Highway Research Record, No. 131 H.R.B. 1966, p1~48.
43. J.R. Morgan and G.K. Searle. Strains in Bituminous Concrete Pavements. ARRB, Proc. 5th Con. Vol. 5 Part. 4,1970, p218~227.
44. K. Ueshita, T. Arakwa, Y. Watanabe. Some Constructions of the Theoretical Estimation for Deflection of Pavement Structures. Proc. 3rd Int. Con. Asp. Pave. Des. London. England. September 11-15, 1972, p536~541.
45. R.G. Hicks and C.L. Monismith. Prediction of the Resilient Response of Pavements containing Granular Layers Using Non-Liner Elastic Theory. Proe. 3rd Int. Con. Asp. Pave. Des. London. England. September 11-15, 1972, p410~429.
46. F. Wolff. Design of Pavement in Tropical Regions with the Finite Element Method. Proc. 5th Int. Con. Asp. Pave. Des. The Delft University of Technology. The Netherlands. August 23-26,1982, p192~208.
47. G.T.H. Sweere, A. Penning and E. Vos. Development of A Structural Design Procedure for Asphalt Pavements with Crushed Rubble Base Courses. Proc. 6th Int. Con. Asp. Pave. Des. University of Michigan. Ann. Arbor. Michigan. U.S.A. July 13-17,1987, p34~49.
48. Punya P. Khanal and Michael S. Mamlock. Program BIMODPAV for Analysis of Flexible Pavements. J. Trans. Eng. ASCE. 1997,123(1):43~50.
49. Michale s. Luther. Mechanistic Investigation of Reflection Cracking of Asphalt Overlays. Committee on Design of Composite Pavement and Structural Overlays. 1976.
50. Jacob Uzan, Arich Sides and Mordechai Perl. Viscoelasoplatic Model for Predicting Performance of Asphaltic Mixtures, TRR. 1043,1985:78~88.
51. M.A. Castell, A.R. Ingraffea and L.H. Irwin. Fatigue Crack Growth in Pavements. J. Trans. Eng. ASCE. 2000,126(4):283~290.
52. Honore Goacolou. Calculation of the Rutting of Structure-CASTOR Program. Proc. 6th Int. Con. Asp. Pave. Des. University of Michigan. Ann. Arbor. Michigan. U.S.A. July 13-17,1987, p191~199.
53. Geoffrey M. Rowe and Stephen F. Brown. Fatigue Life Prediction Using Visco-elastic Analysis. Proc. 8th Int. Con. Asp. Pave. Des. University of Washington. Seattle. Washington. U.S.A. August10-14,1997, p1119~1122.
54. Sam Helwany, John Dyer and Joe Leidy. Finite-Element Analysis of Flexible Pavements. J. Trans. Eng. ASCE, 1997,124(5):p491~499.
55. A.H. de Bondt and A. Scarpas. Design of (Reinfoced) Asphaltic Overlays. Proc. 8th Int. Con. Asp. Pave. Des. University of Washington. Seattle.
Washington. U.S.A. August10-14,1997, p1161~1180.
56. T.D. White et al. Pavement Analysis for Moving Aircraft Load. J. Trans. Eng. ASCE, 1997,123(1):p436~446.
57. Raj V. Siddharthan, Jian Yao and Peter E. Sebaaly. Pavement Strain from Moving Dynamic 3D Load Distribution. J. Trans. Eng. ASCE, 1998, 124(6): p557~566.
58. W. Uddin et al. Finite Element Dynamic Analysis of Distressed Asphalt. Pavements. Proc. 8th Int. Con. Asp. Pave. Des. University of Washington. Seattle. Washington. U.S.A. August10-14,1997, p725~739.
59.张起森 编著.道路工程有限元分析法.北京:人民交通出版社,1983.
60.张起森,郑健龙.多层弹性体系考虑层间接触非线性的有限单元分析法.土木工程学报,1989(3):63~74.
61.黄晓明.柔性路面层状体系的边界元分析法.重庆交通学院学报,1992(3):93~99.
62.张起森,郑健龙,刘益河.半刚性沥青路面的开裂机理.土木工程学报,1992(2):13~21.
63.周志刚,张起森.结构层组合对路面裂缝扩展的影响.中国公路学报,1997(2):5~10.
64.周志刚,张起森,郑健龙.加筋材料阻止沥青路面反射裂缝的桥联增韧的有限元分析.土木工程学报,2000(1):93~99.
65.凌天清.柔性路面结构非线性分析研究.同济大学博士学位论文,1995.
66.曾德荣,凌天清,王士杰.非线性有限元法计算路面结构弯沉和应力.重庆交通学院学报,1997(2):27~36.
67.何兆益,唐伯明.柔性基层沥青路面非线性特性及模量研究.公路交通科技,2001(1):13~16.
68.周行春.软土地基上沥青路面应力的有限元分析.重庆交通学院学报,1998(2):56~62.
69.曹东伟,郝大力,韩瑞民.土工网格加强沥青混凝土路面结构的力学分析.重庆交通学院学报,2000(1):47~52.
70.胡萌.重载交通沥青路面分析及对策.东南大学硕士学位论文,2001.
71.黄开文.高等级公路重载交通沥青路面设计的研究.交通部公路科研所硕士学位论文,2000.
72.倪富健,邓学钧.汽车轴重与路面破坏的关系.重庆交通学院学报,1997(4):41~50.
73.武和平.高等级公路路面结构设计方法.北京:人民交通出版社,1999.
74. Wei-Hsing Huang Yu-Ling Sung etc. Effects of Heavy Vehicle And Tire Pressure on Flexible Pavement Design in Taiwan. Paper Submitted for Presentation and Publication at the 80th Annual Meeting in January 2001 of the Transportation Research Board, Washington, D.C.
75.林绣贤.沥青路面设计中轴载换算方法的研究.1996年道路厂程“高等级公路与科技进步”学术会议论文集,1996,10.
76.陈忠明,孙立军,席雅如,顾迎春.对超重车辆等效轴载换算系数的研究.公路,1991(8)4~6.
77.孙立军,姚祖康,李舜范,胡东明.柔性路面轴载换算式在北京地区的验证与补充.中国公路学报,1992(3):1~13.
78.黄勇.按疲劳等效原理确定重车轴载换算公式.公路,1993(12):31~35.
79.李巧茹,李国强,魏连雨.超载车辆弯沉等效换算方法研究.重庆交通学院学报,1998(1):62~68.
80.彭波.公路超重车辆对路面的损坏影响及管理对策分析.同济大学博士学位论文,1999.
81.董占文,张润,李羚.超载车对太旧高速公路路面结构使用寿命的影响分析.全国第九次高速公路管理工作研讨会高速公路论文集,2000,8.
82.黄开文.沥青路面超重车轴载换算初步研究.公路交通科技,2000(1):5~9.
83.杨群,黄晓明.半刚性基层拉应力验算时双轴系数的分析.公路交通科技,2002(1):1~3.
84.刘朝晖,秦仁杰,李宇峙.汽车超载对沥青路面结构的影响分析.长沙交通学院学报,1999(2):22~26.
85.孙立军,张宏超,刘黎萍,胡小弟.沥青路面初期损坏特点和机理分析(重交通沥青路面设计方法之一).同济大学学报,2002(4):416~421.
86.刘伯莹.网级路面管理系统研究.同济大学博士学位论文,1992.
87.贾渝,张全庚.沥青路面结构层厚度与沥青混合料类型选择.公路,No.3 2000.
88.Saeed,M.,Finite Element Analysis,Theory and ApplicatiOn with ANASYA, Prentice Hall,1~44.
89.张起森.道路工程有限元分析法.北京:人民交通出版社,1983.
90.丁皓江,何福保,谢贻权,徐兴编.弹性和塑性力学中的有限单元法(第2版).北京:机械工业出版社,1989.
91.朱伯芳.有限单元法原理与应用(第二版).北京:中国水利水电出版社,1998,10.
92.胡长顺,王秉刚.复合式路面设计原理与施工技术.北京:人民交通出版社,1999.
93.北京办事处.ANSYS分析手册,2000,1
94.康国政 编.大型有限元程序的原理、结构与使用.西南交通大学应用力学与工程系.2000,7