摘要
自1978年以来,中国旅游经济一直保持强劲的增长势头。经过30年的发展,旅游产业已经成长为国民经济的一大产业,在经济社会发展中扮演着越来越重要的角色。随着在经济社会中重要性的提升,旅游产业曾分别被确立为第三产业的重点产业、第三产业新兴产业序列第一位、国民经济重点产业、国民经济增长点,2009年,国务院常务会议讨论并通过了《关于加快发展旅游业的意见》,旅游业被确立为国民经济的战略性支柱产业。
然而作为一个受到各级政府和产业界高度重视的产业,旅游业在大量的资本、劳动力投入下并未取得明显的经济增长优势。近年来旅游收入占GDP的比重不仅没有上升,反而逐年下滑,在第三产业中的比重也停滞不前。和1998年同时被列为国民经济增长点的信息产业、房地产业、汽车业相比,旅游产业增长速度最慢。
本文第一章是导论,第二章是理论综述,第三章开始进入正题。在借鉴传统旅游经济增长衡量方法的基础上,提出了旅游经济增长的四个核算指标,旅游消费、旅游收入、旅游投资、旅游出口,并利用历史数据对中国旅游经济增长的历程进行回顾,总结了中国旅游经济增长的基本特点。接着把旅游产业置于国民经济序列中,计算了旅游经济在国民经济中的比重,并和信息产业、房地产业、汽车业进行了横向比较。
第四章利用计量经济学相关理论和方法,对宏观经济变量和旅游经济增长的关系进行了定量研究。首先从国民经济发展总体水平入手,分析GDP、人均GDP、城市化水平和旅游经济增长之间的关系。其次分别对影响旅游消费、旅游投资、旅游收入、旅游出口的因素进行单项分析,并在此基础上建立了旅游消费、旅游投资、旅游出口的宏观经济决定模型。
第五章利用新古典增长理论中的索洛模型估计了劳动力、资本、全要素生产率(广义技术进步)对旅游产业收入增长的贡献率,得到了中国旅游产业生产函数。由于旅游产业涵盖不同的行业,本文以饭店业、旅行社业为代表,分别估计了饭店业生产函数和旅行社业生产函数,测算了生产要素对各个行业的贡献。最后,利用各省数据,估计了生产要素对中国各省旅游经济的贡献,并根据资本和劳动力的贡献程度把我国30个省市的旅游经济增长划分为资本驱动型、劳动力驱动型和资本一劳动力共同驱动型。
第六章利用制度经济学理论,研究了制度变迁对旅游经济增长的影响。主要分析了产权制度变迁、市场化制度变迁、收入分配制度变迁、假日制度变迁对旅游收入、旅游消费的影响程度。
第七章总结了上述章节的研究结论,并在此基础上提出了相应的政策建议。
China's tourism economy has remained steep rise since 1978. With this rapid development during the past 30 years, tourism industry has become a great industry of the national economy and played a more important role in the society. As its importance in economic and social development is increasing, tourism industry has been regarded as the key industry of the tertiary industry, the first industry among new industries of tertiary industry, key industries of national economy, new economic growth source of national economy at different times. On Dec.1st,2009, Executive meetings of the State Council discussed and adopted the“Opinions of the State Council on Accelerating the Development of Tourism Industry”, in this documents, tourism has been established as a strategic pillar industry of national economy.
However, tourism industry, an industry which has been valued highly by governments of all levels and industry circles, did not enjoy its significant economic growth advantage in accord with the great amount of input of labor and capital. In recent years, the proportion of total tourism income in GDP has not seen the rise, but has been decreasing year by year. Furthermore, the proportion of total tourism income in tertiary industry has been at a standstill. The growth rate of tourism industry was the slowest, in comparison with the information, real estate and auto industry which were defined as a new source of economic growth of national economy together with tourism in 1998.
For chapter 1 is the introductory, and a theoretical review is the second chapter. In chapter 3, the author proposes four variables to measure the economic growth of tourism by employing the traditional method. These variables include tourism consumption, tourism income, tourism investment and tourism export. Then, the author reviews the history of tourism economic growth in China by using historical data and generalizes basic features of tourism economy growth in China. At the end of this chapter, by putting the tourism industry under national economy series, the author calculates the proportion of tourism income in the national economy and draws a horizontal comparison between tourism industry and information, real estate and auto industry.
In chapter 4, the author conducts a quantitative study of relationship between macroeconomic variables and tourism economic growth based on the basic theory and method of econometrics. First, the relationship between tourism economic growth and GDP, per capita GDP, the level of urbanization has been analyzed; then, there is an individual study of factors which has influenced tourism consumption, tourism invest, tourism export. And under this condition, the macro-economic decision models of tourism consumption, tourism investment, tourism export has therefore been established.
In chapter 5, based on the Solow Model of Neo-classical growth theory, the author estimates the contribution by labor, capital, total factor productivity (TEP) and draws a production function of tourism industry of China. Because tourism industry consists of many businesses such as hotels and travel agencies, the paper estimates production function of hotel and travel agency respectively and calculates the contribution by factor of production to hotel and travel agency. Similarly, the contribution by factor of production to provinces of China has also been estimated, and the tourism economic growth of 30 provinces has been divided into 3 categories: capital-driven, labor-driven and capital-labor driven.
Chapter 6 concerns the influence on tourism economic growth by institutional change in terms of the Institutional economics theory. It is mainly focused on the institutional change of the property, the market, the income and Distribution System and the holiday reform, which has a significant influence on tourism economic growth.
Chapter 7 is a summary of the whole article, and some policies are recommended correspondingly.
引文
[1]唐晓云,中国旅游经济增长因素的理论与实证研究[D],天津大学,2007.
[2]赵俊民,全国视角下的陕西省经济增长因素研究[D],西北大学,2009.
[3]吕中楼,新制度经济学研究[M],中国经济出版社,2005.
[4]计志英,中国转型期制度变迁与经济增长—实证研究[D],复旦大学,2004.
[5]JACINT BALAGUER, Tourism as a long-run economic growthfactor:the Spanish case, Applied Economics,2002,34,877-884.
[6]Isabel Cortes-Jimenez, Which Type of Tourism Matters to the Regional Economic Growth? The Casesof Spain and Italy, INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF TOURISM RESEARCH Int. Tourism Res,10, (2008),127-139.
[7]Julie Jie Wen and Clement, Tourism and China's Development:Policies, Regional Economic Growth and Ecotourism, The Singapore Economic Review, Vol.50, No.1 (2005) 139-142.
[8]F. Roy Willis, tourism as an instrument of regional economic growth, growth and change, april, (1977):43-47.
[9]李天元:旅游学[M],高等教育出版社,2002:20.
[10]转引自张辉:旅游经济论[M],旅游教育出版社,2001:39.
[11]转引自谢彦君:基础旅游学(第二版),中国旅游出版社,2004:69.
[12]谢彦君:基础旅游学(第二版),中国旅游出版社,2004:70.
[13]谢彦君:基础旅游学(第二版)[M],中国旅游出版社,2004:73.
[14]张辉、厉新建:旅游经济学原理,旅游教育出版社,2004:287.
[15]李江帆、李美云:旅游产业与旅游增加值的测算[J],旅游学刊,1999(5):16-19.
[16]北京旅游附属账户编制组:北京旅游附属账户(BJ-TSA)编制理论与实践,中国旅游出版社,2009.
[17]国家旅游局:中国旅游统计年鉴,旅游统计基本概念和主要指标解释.
[18]彭德芬:经济增长质量研究[D],中南财经政法大学博士论文,2001:31.
[19]吴金梅:进军旅游业—中国大企业进入旅游业研究[M],中国水利水电出版 社,2007:140.
[20]国家旅游局规划发展与财务司:2007中国旅游投资报告,中国旅游出版社,2007:3-13.
[21]吴忠才.中国入境旅游对经济增长拉动作用的定量研究[J].北京第二外国语学院学报(旅游版),2007,(9):30-33.
[22]蒋满元.旅游外汇收入对国民经济增长的贡献分析[J],旅游学刊,2008,23(8):30-33.
[23]刘迎辉、郝索.国内旅游与入境旅游对促进我国经济增长的比较研究[J],统计与决策,2009,290(14):120-122.
[24]张玉娟.基于双对数线性模型的中国入境旅游需求影响因素研究[D],中国科学技术大学,2008.
[25]刘长生、简玉峰.中国入境旅游市场需求的影响因素研究[J],产业经济研究(双月刊),2006,23(4):54-60.
[26]殷书炉、杨立勋.中国入境旅游发展影响因素研究[J],统计教育,2009,112(1):18-22.
[27]宁士敏.影响中国旅游消费的经济和社会因素[J],旅游学刊,2000,3:75-76.
[28]牛利民,杨开福,朱道静.影响我国旅游消费的经济因素分析[J],资源开发与市场,2008,24(9):858-860.
[29]雷平.基于多变量序列分量方差分析模型的国内旅游需求影响因素研究[J],软科学,2008,22(7):14-17.
[30]张玮.影响我国旅游收入因素的实证分析[J],太原城市职业技术学院学报,2007,76(7):22-23.
[31]余美灿.试论政府在旅游投资中的调控作用[J],经济问题探索,2009,2:115-120.
[32]孙小培、曹妲妲、李宏彦.金融危机对中国旅游投融资的影响及对策[J],经济理论研究,2009:101-103.
[33]孙根年.基于本底趋势线的秦俑馆旅游危机后评价研究[J],地理科学,2008,28(1):107-112.
[34]苏怡,庄嘉琳,基于灰色关联分析的云南省旅游服务贸易影响因素初探[J], 昆明学院学报,2009,31(2):81-84.
[35]唐晓云.中国旅游经济增长因素的理论与实证研究[D],天津大学,2007.
[36]张辉,厉新建.旅游经济学原理[M],旅游教育出版社,2004:27-28.
[37]闫敏.旅游业与经济发展水平之间的关系[J],旅游学刊,1995(5):9-15.
[38]张辉.旅游经济论[M],旅游教育出版社,2002:94.
[39]林南枝,陶汉军.旅游经济学,南开大学出版社,2000:66.
[40]保罗.萨缪尔森:宏观经济学(第十六版),华夏出版社,1999:92.
[41]国家旅游局规划发展与财务司:2007中国旅游投资报告,中国旅游出版社,2007:3-12.
[42]李正欢,论中国旅游经济增长的特征与政策选择[J],经济与管理,2003,(7):7-8.
[43]李仲广、宋慧林,中国旅游业增长的要素贡献率[J],辽宁工程技术大学学报(社会科学版),2008,10(2):138-140.
[44]左冰、保继刚,1992-2005年中国旅游业全要素生产率及省际差异[J],地理学报,2008,4(4):417-427.
[45]胡庆龙,人力资本积累与黄山市旅游经济增长的关系研究[J].黄山学院学报,2009,11(1):53-56.
[46]黄秀娟,中国旅游产业经济增长的因素贡献分析[J],技术经济,2009,28(7):67-71.
[47]把多勋,基于增长理论的旅游地经济发展分析[J],产业经济研究,2009,40(3):65-69.
[48]吴金梅:进军旅游业—中国大企业进入旅游业研究,中国水利水电出版社,2007:140.
[49]国家旅游局规划发展与财务司,2007中国旅游投资报告[M],中国旅游出版社.
[50]张辉,转型时期中国旅游产业环境、制度与模式研究[M],旅游教育出版社,2005:前言.
[51]贾生华、邬爱其,制度变迁与中国旅游产业的成长阶段和发展对策[J],旅游学刊,2002,17(4):19-22.
[52]余凤龙、陆林,制度对旅游发展影响研究综述与启示[J],旅游学刊,2008, 23(9):90-96.
[53]郭鲁芳,县域旅游经济制度变迁的实证分析[J],旅游学刊,2004,19(2):22-25.
[54]沈和江,制度、技术、管理:中国旅游产业化成长的制度安排[J],石家庄学院学报,2006,8(3):90-94.
[55]宋德勇,工业化、市场化、国际化与中国的经济增长[J],华中理工大学学报,1999,3.
[56]金玉国,我国市场化进程的统计测度[J],统计研究,2000,12:15-20.
[57]王文博、陈昌兵、徐海燕,包含制度因素的中国经济增长模型及实证分析[J],统计研究,2002,5.
[58]吴忠才,我国国有饭店产权退出战略[J],旅游科学,2003,3:9-12.
[59]吴三忙,李树民,产权、竞争、中国饭店业绩效及改进路径研究[J],商业经济与管理,2007,188(6),70-74.
[60]戴斌:《中国国有饭店的转型与变革研究》北京:旅游教育出版社,2003.
[61]张辉、魏翔,对中国旅行社业的经济分析与再定位[J],旅游学刊,2004,(5).
[62]宋振春、马永刚,对旅行社产权改革和规模化经营的思考[J],旅游学刊,2005,(2).
[63]张凌云,旅行社产权改革、规模化经营和市场制度[J],旅游学刊,2005,(6).
[64]金玉国,市场化进程测度:90年代成果总结与比较[J],经济学家,2000,(5):90-95.
[65]樊纲、王小鲁、张立文,中国各地区市场化进程2000年报告,国家行政学院学报,2001,(3).
[66]国家旅游局规划发展与财务司,中国旅游投资报告2005[M],2005.
[67]武力、温锐,新中国收入分配制度的演变及绩效分析[J],当代中国史研究2006,13(4),4-12.
[68]沈卫平,我国现行收入分配制度的理论依据辨析[J],深圳大学学报(人文社会科学版),2004,21(5):29-33.
[69]张维迎,中国改革30年十位经济学家的思考,上海人民出版社,2008:251- 253.
[70]杜海忆,我国高端旅游的发展现状及对策建议[J],武汉大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2007,60(3):395-399.
[71]于光远,论普遍有闲的社会[M],中国经济出版社,2005.
[72]邓洲,中国休假制度的历史、变迁与发展[D],北京第二外国语学院,2007.