摘要
现有商圈理论基本都是从微观企业角度出发,但随着城市化进程的加快,城市圈(群)的出现,现有的企业商圈理论不能很好的满足现实需要。文章从中观层面提出城市商圈概念,并对影响城市商圈竞争力的要素进行了深入探讨,具有重要的理论价值和现实意义。
本文从商圈吸引力层面对国外文献进行了综述,并从商圈形成机理、商圈布局、商圈拓展、商圈竞争与商圈要素层面,对国内商圈文献进行了系统梳理,在此基础上设计城市商圈研究命题。并提出影响城市商圈竞争力的主要因素是区位要素、规模要素、业态要素、品牌要素,并就此提出了全文研究假设。运用多种研究方法构建模型,测算了各类要素的影响因素及其对城市商圈竞争力的影响程度。
城市商圈区位要素是影响城市商圈竞争力的最重要因素。在梳理相关区位理论的基础上,对哈夫修正模型中的“距离二次方反比”进行了再修正,用消费者到商圈的空间距离和该商圈到城市商业中心空间距离的乘积来表示。从而得到消费者在某城市商圈购物的机率与城市商圈规模大小成正比,与达到该商圈距离和该商圈与城市商业中心的距离成反比的结论。影响城市商圈区位条件的因素中,城市文教系统和城市交通系统对城市商圈发展影响最大。
城市商圈规模可以从投入和产出两个角度来度量。本文从产出角度选取了批发和零售业总额,从投入角度测度了新增固定资产投资、城市基础设施投入对城市商圈规模的影响,弹性系数分别为1.08和0.84,呈同向关系,且弹性较大。同时还得到了城市人口密度、人均收入和交通条件与社会消费品零售总额之间呈同向关系的结论,弹性系数分别为0.3、0.96和0.84,人均收入对城市商圈的影响是人口密度的3倍。城市商圈规模还与物流业和工农业之间存在密切关系。
城市商圈业态目前存在主体功能不清晰、业态结构不合理、业态趋同等现象。运用层次分析法研究了城市商圈业态组合问题,对于城市中心商圈,大规模型业态比中小规模型业态重要,应该布局大型超市、购物中心、百货店等大规模型零售业态,适当搭配中小规模型业态。而在城市郊区或者远离市中心地带,应该布局以中小规模型业态为主体,配以少量的大规模型城市商圈业态。不同区位的城市商圈主体功能存在差异,业态组合要与主体功能相吻合。
城市商圈品牌由城市商圈形象、城市商圈口碑、城市商圈布局、城市商圈信誉、城市商圈售后服务等因素组成。通过结构方程模型验证得到布局因素是最重要和关键的,其次为城市商圈信誉。
在分析城市商圈四大要素后,采用因子分析法对城市商圈竞争力进行了综合评价,得到了各省会城市商圈竞争力的得分和排序。排前五位的城市分别是上海、北京、广州、重庆、天津,东部沿海地区的城市排位靠前,中西部地区城市排位靠中间和中后的位置,与东、中、西部经济发展水平基本吻合。从合理规划城市商圈布局、完善基础设施建设、优化业态组合、加强城市商圈管理、打造城市商圈品牌五个方面,提出了增强和提升城市商圈竞争力的相关对策。
最后研究了城市商圈与区域经济建设的关系,城市商圈与地区国民经济三次产业之间高度相关。运用向量自回归模型得到了城市商圈与区域经济之间存在长期均衡的协整关系,存在区域经济增长到城市商圈发展的单向格兰杰因果关系。为了衡量城市商圈与区域经济之间的短期波动与长期均衡关系,得到了向量误差修正模型两个误差修正项系数为-0.11和-0.05,符合反向修正机制,系数绝对值大小反映了对偏离长期均衡的调整力度。
本文创新之处,表现在如下四个方面:
第一、明确提出把商圈分为企业商圈与城市商圈两大类,从根本上避免了商圈概念运用混乱的现象。企业商圈主要研究单个零售企业吸引力范围问题,具有微观属性。城市商圈主要研究城市内若干零售企业集聚在一定区域共同吸引顾客的范围问题,具有中观属性。
第二、把诸多影响城市商圈竞争力的零散因素,划分为城市商圈区位要素、规模要素、业态要素、品牌要素。关于城市商圈竞争力的这四要素,在现有商圈研究成果中属于创新性系统提出。
第三、提出了一个城市商圈区位再修正模型,对哈夫修正模型中的“距离二次方反比”用两个距离乘积来表示。一个距离是消费者到城市商圈的空间距离,另一个距离是该城市商圈到城市商业中心的空间距离,使模型解释力更强。
第四、运用多种研究方法分别测度了城市商圈区位、规模、业态、品牌要素各自影响因素的强度。在城市商圈规模与人口、收入关系的研究中,提出了在现阶段我国城市商圈主要靠城市在岗职工平均工资“质”的拉动,而不是主要靠人口密度“量”的拉动,来实现城市商圈快速发展的观点。在城市商圈业态要素研究中,运用层次分析法提出了在城市中心商圈应该布局大型超市、购物中心、百货店等大规模型零售业态,而城市郊区或者远离市中心地带,应该布局中小规模型业态的观点。在城市商圈品牌要素研究中,运用结构方程模型得到了影响城市商圈品牌的关键因素是城市商圈布局的观点。
Existing theories of trade area are developed from the angle of micro-enterprise. But with the acceleration of urbanization, the emerging of trade area of city, those existing theories cannot meet practical needs. Based on this, the notion of trade area of city is put forward from a medium perspective and the issues that affect competitiveness of trade area of the city are discussed in this paper. It proves to be a meaningful study in academic and reality.
The study is about summary of overseas studies in trade area from the perspective of attractiveness. Furthermore, the study illustrates the domestic literature from the perspective of mechanism of formation, layout, expansion, competition, and essential factors of trade areas. Based on these studies, the issue of urban trade area is addressed in this thesis. And some essential factors, that affect the competitiveness of urban trade area, is put forward. They are the factors of location, scale, brand and kind of business. The hypothesis of this paper is based on these. This paper constructs models on variety methods to estimate the impact of various factors and its influence degree to competitiveness of urban trade area.
Location of urban trade area is the most important factor that has great influence on the competitiveness. Based on those related location theories, this paper remodified the "inversely proportional to the square other distance" in Huff modified model, that is, the distance between the customers and trade areas multiplies the distance between the trade area and urban commercial center. So the conclusion is:the probability of consumer shopping in urban trade area and the scale of it are indirect proportion; the distance of consumer to trade area and the distance from trade area to commercial center are in inverse proportion. Cultural education system and transportation system are of the greatest impact on the development of urban trade area.
The scale of urban trade area can be measured from two angles, inputs and outputs. From the angle of outputs, the total amount of wholesale and retail trade is measured; in terms of inputs, elastic coefficient of newly increased fixed and inputs of infrastructure to urban trade area are 1.08 and 0.84 respectively, which are in concurrent relationship and the elasticity is comparatively large. So, we get the conclusion that the population density, average wage, communication condition, are in concurrent relationship to total retail sales of consumer goods, which elastic coefficients are 0.3,0.96, and 0.84. The effect of average wage on urban trade area is three times of that of population density. There is also a close relationship between the scale of urban trade area and logistics, industry and agriculture.
There are still some problems such as the indistinct of main function, the unreasonable structure and convergence of kind of business. Use AHP (Analytic Hierarchy Process) to analyze optimum combination of kind of business. The large scale of kind of business is more important than the small one to the central urban trade area. So large supermarkets, shopping malls, and department stores should be located and pair up some small ones.While in suburban trade area, for some remote areas are away from downtown, the small and medium-sized kind of business should be located and pair up the large ones. Different urban trade areas'main function is different, so the combination of different kinds of business should match the main function.
The brand of urban trade area consists of series of factors, including the image, public praise, business location, commercial reputation, and after-sale services. According to the structural equation modeling, the business location is of the greatest importance. And the reputation is in the second place.
This paper had a comprehensive competitiveness evaluation scored and sorted on trade area of provincial capital through factor analysis, which focus on the analysis of four factors of urban trade area.The top five cities are Shanghai, Beijing, Guangzhou, Chongqing, Tianjin. The sorting of eastern coastal cities is in the front rank, and those of central and western regions are in the middle and postposition. The results coincide with the economic development of eastern, central and western regions. Five measures are proposed to enhance and upgrade the competitiveness of urban trade area from reasonable planning and layout, improvement of infrastructure construction, optimum combination of kind of busines, strengthening the management and creating brand of urban trade area.
Finally, conclusion of the relationship between urban trade area and the development of regional economy is obtained,that is, highly correlated with the three industries. This paper adopts Vector Autoregression Model (VAR) and found that a long-term equilibrium co-integration relationship exists between urban trade area and regional economic development. One-way Granger causality exist between local economic growth and the development of urban trade area. A vector error correction model is put froward in order to measure the relationship of short-term fluctuation and long-term equilibrium between urban trade area and regional economy. Two coefficients of error-correction are-0.11 and-0.05, in line with the reverse correction mechanism. The absolute values of the coefficients reflects the adjustment deviation from long-run equilibrium.
The originalities of this study lie in the following aspects:
Firstly, it clearly puts forward a point that trade area should be divided into enterprise trade area and urban trade area, which avoids the confusion of application of those definitions. Enterprise trade areas are of micro-property, which mainly focus on the attraction of single retail enterprises. Urban trade areas are of medium-property, which mainly study how the retail enterprises in the same area attract customers.
Secondly, many scattered factors that bear influence on the competitiveness of the urban trade area are divided into four elements categories, location factor, scale factor, brand factor, kind of business factor. The classification is the first time to put forward in current studies about urban city area.
Thirdly, a location remodified model is proposed. That is, "inversely proportional to the square of the distance" in Huff modified model is replaced by the distance between the customers to trade areas multiplication the distance between the trade area to urban commercial center. So the remodified model has more explanatory power.
Fourthly, this paper estimate the impact of various factors, such as location,scale, kind of business, brand, and the intensity of the influence on urban trade area through variety methods. In terms of the study of the relationship between scale of urban trade area and population, income, a originality views is put forward, namely, it is the factor'quality'of average wage of staff and workers, rather than the'quantity' of population density, that achieve the development of urban trade area. This paper puts forward that some large supermarket, shopping mall, and department stores should be located at central trade area, and small or medium-sized kind of business should be located in suburban trade area. Some small enterprises houl be located in remote areas, which are in suburban areas or far away from the city centers. Through the structural equation modeling (SEM) method during the study on brand of urban trade area, we may conclude that location is the key element among impacts on urban trade area brand.
引文
①关于广州商圈演变的背景资料,来源于谭亦芳,严丽君2006年发表的一篇报道文章。详情请参见谭亦芳,严丽君.广州:商圈演变一路向东[N].南方日报,2006-4-7.
①关于重庆商圈竞争状况以及重庆市、江北区、南岸区、九龙坡区等政府部门关于城市商圈规划的背景资料,来源于信报记者曾臻和实习生陈春霖2008年发表的一篇报道文章。详情请参见曾臻,陈春霖.江北商圈:不做解放碑[N].时代信报,2008-8-27(1).
②关于城市圈问题的研究,美籍法国地理学家戈特曼(Jean Gottmann)1957年7月在美国《经济地理》杂志(Economic Geography, Vol.33, No.3,1957)发表了一篇题为《Megalopolis:or the Urbanization of the Northeastern Seaboard》的论文,该文2007年被李浩博士,陈晓燕硕士翻译成中文发表在《国际城市规划》2007年第5期《大城市连绵区:美国东北海岸的城市化》,也有学者翻译为《城市群:东北海岸的城市化》。文中介绍该文是戈特曼关于大城市连绵区研究的第一篇论文,或者说首次提出城市群的概念,经过半个世纪的历史检验,已成为国际上大城市连绵区研究的经典名著,并被公认为现代意义上大城市连绵区研究的开端。我国关于大城市连绵区的研究,一般被认为始于1983年于洪俊、宁越敏在《城市地理概论》一书中首次用“巨大城市带”的译名向国内介绍本篇论文的学术思想。1961年,戈特曼的城市群理论专著《Megalopolis:The urbanized northeastern seaboard of the United States》(《城市群:城市化的美国东北海岸》)在美国出版。
①2008年4月2日国务院法制办发布的《城市商业网点条例(征求意见稿)》第五条。http://www. chinanews. com.cn/cj/kong/news/2008/04-02/1210456.shtml
②详情请见2009年3月26日商务部发布的,商资发[2009]138号文件《商务部关于2009年国家级经济技术开发区工作的指导意见》,http://www.mofcom.gov.cn/aarticle/b/f/200904/20090406145873.html
①马克思对这些问题论述的研究,参见马龙龙.马克思论批发商品流通[J].财贸经济,2005,1:42-47.
①王任飞,王进杰在《中国基础设施的产出弹性与最优规模——基于总量生产函数的研究》第101-102页,《经济科学》2006年第2期;范九利,白暴力,潘泉分别在《基础设施资本与经济增长关系的研究文献综述》第38页, 《上海经济研究》2004年第1期,和《基础设施资本对经济增长贡献的研究进展——生产 函数法综述》第89页, 《当代经济科学》第2期,以列表形式较为清晰的总结了国外研究者从1989年—2004年基础设施与经济增长关系的定量研究方法、研究对象、数据类型和研究结论,有重要参考价值和意义。
① Biehl.D.(Ed). The Contribution of infrastructure to the regional development[J]. Regional policy division. EC, Brussels,1986:86-90.以及林明华,杨永忠.城市基础设施与城市经济增长关系之实证研究[J].福州大学学报,2006,3:38-41.
①环境理论的代表人物和作品主要有:G. H. Wadinambiaratchi,"Theory of Retail Development,"Social and Economic studies, Vol.21, No.4,1972, pp.8-36和E. D. Cundiff,"Concepts in comparative Retailing,"Journal of Marketing, January,1965, pp.59-63.
②冲突理论的代表人物和作品主要有:R. R. Gist. "Retailing:Concepts and Decisions", New York:John Wiley & Sons,1968, pp.106-109.和 Brown, S. "Institutional change in retailing:A review and synthesis",Journal of Marketing, Vol.21,6,1987,pp5-36.
①温家宝.政府工作报告[R].2009年3月5日在第十一届全国人民代表大会第二次会议上.新华网,http:// www.xinhuanetcom/20091h/gzbg/20090305/.
①2008年长沙市国民经济相关数据,来源于长沙统计信息网,http://www.cstj.gov.cn/。
①2008年长沙市商贸流通业相关数据,来源于长沙统计信息网,http://www.cstj.gov.cn/。
[1]Gottmann,J.Megalopolis:or the Urbanization of the Northeastern Sea board[J].Economic Geography, Vol.33, No.3,1957,pp.189-200.
[2]Gottmann,J.Megalopolis:The Urbanized Northeastern Seaboard of The United States[M]. New York:The Twentieth Century Fund,1961.
[3]Marshall,Alfred.Principles of Economics[M].London:Macmillan and Co., Ltd.,1890.
[4]Weber,Alfred.Theory of the Location of Industries[M].Chicago:The University of Chicago Press,1929.
[5]Florence,P.Sargant.Investment, Location, and Size of Plant[M]. Cambridge University Press,1948.
[6]August Losch.The Economics of Location[M].New Haven:Yale University Press, 1954.
[7]Masahisa Fujita,Paul Krugman,Anthony J.Venables.The Spatial Economy:Cities, Regions and International Trade.)藤田昌久、克鲁格曼、维纳布尔斯著,梁琦译.空间经济学—城市、区域与国际贸易[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2005.
[8]Masahisa Fujita, Jacques-Francois Thisse.Economics of Agglomeration:Cities, Industrial Location and Regional Growth.藤田昌久、雅克-弗朗科斯·蒂斯著,刘峰,张雁,陈海威译.集聚经济学:城市、产业区位与区域增长[M].成都:西南财经大学出版社,2004:2.
[9]Christaller,W. Central Places in Southern German[M],1933.Translated by Baskin C.W. Englewood Cliffs N J. London:Prentice Hall,1966.
[10]B.J.L.Berry.Geography of Market Centres and Retail Distribution[M].Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffe, New Jersey,1967.
[11]B.J.L.Berry,W. L.Garrison.A Note on Central Place Theory and the Range of a Good[J].Economic Geography, Vol.34 (1958), p.304.
[12]B.J.L.Berry,W.L.Garrison.Recent Developments of Central Place Theory[J]. Papers and Proceedings of the Regional Science Association, Vol.4 (1958), p.111.
[13]Reilly,W.J.Methods of the Study tof Retail Relationships[D].University of Texas,Bureau of Busines Research. Research Monograph (University of Texas Bulletin No.2994,1929(4).
[14]Reilly,W.J.The Lay of Retail Gravitation[M].Knickerbocker press, New York, 1931.
[15]Converse P. D.New Laws of Retail Gravitation[J].Journal of Marketing,1949, 14,pp.379-384.
[16]Converse P.D. Comment on Movement of. Retail Trade in Iowa[J].Journal of Marketing, vol.18, no.2 (October 1953), pp.170-171
[17]Luce,R.D.Semiorders and a theory of utility discrimination[J].Econometrica,24, 1956,178-191.
[18]Luce,R.D.,Edwards,W.The Derivation of Subjective Scales from just Noticeable Differences[J]. Psychological Review,65,1958,pp.222-237.
[19]Luce,R.D.Individual Choice Behavior:A Theoretical Analysis[M].New York: Wiley. Reprinted by Dover Publications,1959/2005
[20]Huff.D.L.A Probability Analysis of Shopping Center Trade Areas[J].Land Economics, 1963,53,pp.81-90.
[21]Huff.D.L.Defining and Estimating a Trading Area[J].The Journal of Marketing, Vol.28, No.3 (Jul.,1964), pp.34-38.
[22]Huff,, D.L.A Programmed Solution for Approximating an Optimal Retail Location[J].Land Economics, Vol.42,1966,pp.293-303.
[23]Huff, D.L.,Batsell, R.Delimiting the Areal Extent of a Market Area[J].Journal of Marketing Research,Vol.14,1977,pp.581-585.
[24]Huff, D.L.,Rust, R.Measuring the Congurence of Market Areas[J].Journal of Marketing,1984,pp.68-74.
[25]Nakanishi,M.,Cooper,L.G.Parameter Estimation for a Multiplicative Competitive Interaction Model-Least Squares Approach[J].Journal of Marketing Research,11, (August 1974),pp.303-311.
[26]Nakanishi,M.,Cooper, L.G., Simplified Estimation Procedures for MCI Models[J]. Marketing Science,1, (Summer 1982),pp.314-322.
[27]Cooper,L.G.,Nakanishi,M.Standardizing Variables in Multiplicative Choice Models[J].Journal of Consumer Research,10, (June 1983),pp.96-108.
[28]Stanley,T.,Sewall,M.Imaes Inputs to A Probabilistic Model:Predicting Retail Potential[J].Journal of Marketing, Vol.40 No.3,1976,pp.48-53.
[29]Jain, A.K, Mahajan, V. Evaluating the Competitive Environment in Retailing Using Multiplicative Competitive Interactive Model[J].in Sheth, J. (Eds), Research in Marketing, JAI Press,Greenwich, CT,Vol.2,pp,1979,217-235.
[30]Hansen,M.H.,Weinberg,C.B.Retail Market Share in a Competitive Environment [J].Journal of Retailing, Vol.55,pp.1979,37-46.
[31]J.A.Dawson.Retail Geography[M].London:Croom Helm,1980,pp.193-235.
[32]Gautschi,David A.Specification of Patronage Models for Retail Center Choice[J] Journal of Marketing Research, vol.18, May 1981, pp.162-174.
[33]Eppli,Mark J.,James D. Shilling.How Critical is a Good Location to a Regional Shopping Center?[J].Journal of Real Estate Research,12, no.3,1996,pp.459-469.
[34]Black,W.C.,Osthind,L.E.,Westbrook,R.A.Spatial Demand Models in an Intrabrand Context[J].Journal of Marketing, Vol.49,Summer 1985, p106-113.
[35]Westbrook,R.A.,Black,W.C.A Motivation-based Shopper typology[J].Journal of Retailing,61,1985,pp,78-103.
[36]KJones,J.Simmons.The retail environment[M].Routledge, London,1990.
[37]Bloch, P.H, Ridgeway, N.M, Sherrel, D.L.Extending the Concept of Shopping: an Investigation of Browsing Activity[J].Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,Vol.17,1989,pp.13-21.
[38]Ghosh,A.,McLafferty,S.L.Locating Stores in Uncertain Environments:a Scenario Planning Approach[J].Journal of Retailing,Vol.58,No.4,1982.pp.5-22.
[39]Ghosh,A.,Rushton.G.Spacial Analysis and Location Allocation Models[M]. New York:Van Nostrand-Reinhold,1987.
[40]Ghosh,A.,Tibrewala,V.Optimal Timing and Location in Competitive Markets[J]. INSEAD Working Paper,No.90/85/mkt,1990,INSEAD.
[41]Eppli,Mark J.,John D. Benjamin.The Evolution of Shopping Center Research:A Review and Analysis [J].Journal of Real Estate Research, Vol 9, no.1,Winter 1994,pp.5-32.
[42]Micheli,Thomas,C.F.Sirmans,Denise Stake.Optimal Competition and Allocation of Space in Shopping Centers [J].Journal of Real Estate Research, Vol 16, 1,1998,pp.113-125.
[43]Okabe, A.,Miki, F.A Conditional Nearest-Neighbor Spatial Association Measure for the Analysis of Conditional Locational Interdependence[J].Environment and Planning A,Vol.16,1984,pp.163-171.
[44]Okabe,A.,Yomono,H.,Kitamura,M.(1995)Statistical Analysis of the Distribution of Points on a Network[J]. Geographical Analysis,Vol.27,No.2,1995,pp.152-175.
[45]Okabe, A.,Kitamura, M.A Computational Method for Market Area Analysis on a Network[J].Geographical Analysis,Vol.28,No.4,1996,pp.330-349.
[46]Okabe, A.Spatial Analysis on a Network with GIS[J].Presented at the International Conference on Geographic Information Science October 28-31,2000. Savannah, Georgia, USA.
[47]Okabe,A.,Yamada,I.The K-function Method on A Network and Its Computational Implementation[J].Geographical Analysis,Vol.33,No.3,2001,pp.271-290.
[48]Okabe,A.,Okunuki, K.A Computational Method for Estimating the Demand of Retail Stores on A Street Network and Its Implementation in GIS[J].Transactions in GIS,Vol.5,No.3,2001,pp.209-220.
[49]Lee,Ming-Long,R.Kelley Pace.Local Housing Prices and Mortgage Refinancing in U.S. Cities[J].Property Management, Vol.24,No.4,2006,pp.427-441.
[50]J.E.(Joe) Barth.Customer Engagement and the Operational Efficiency of Wine Retail Stores [J].International Journal of Wine Business Research, Vol 19,3,2007, pp.207-215.
[51]Maria Pilar Martinez Ruiz,Alejandro Molla Descals.Retail Price Promotion Influences for Product Varieties in Grocery Stores:Evidence from Spain[J]. Inter national Journal of Retail & Distribution Management, Vol 36,6,2008,pp.494-517.
[52]Sooksan Kantabutra.Vision effects in Thai retail stores:practical implications[J]. International Journal of Retail & Distribution Management, Vol 36,4,2008,pp.323-342.
[53]Cheng Yu Sum, Chi Leung Hui.Salespersons' Service Quality and Customer Loyalty in Fashion Chain Stores:A study in Hong Kong Retail Stores[J].Journal of Fashion Marketing and Management, Vol 13,1,2009,pp.98-108.
[54]周建纲.现代商圈的集聚扩散功能[J].上海经济研究,2002,6:76-79.
[55]高觉民.南京都市商圈及其空间体系构造[J].南京财经大学学报,2004,5:13-18.
[56]徐从才.南京商圈构造及其对策[J].南京财经大学学报,2003,3:1-6.
[57]童听,王缉慈.全球商品链中的地方产业群——以东莞的“商圈”现象为例[J].地域研究与开发,2003,22(1):36-49.
[58]孙天福.徐家汇商圈是如何形成的——上海徐家汇商圈发展案例分析[J].港沪经济,2004,1:18-20
[59]陆立军.“义乌商圈”形成机理与发展趋势——三论“义乌模式”[J].商业经济与管理,2006,6:14-19.
[60]刘中南,罗建勤.城市商圈企业集群的生成和运行[J].经济导刊,2008,5:52-53.
[61]陆立军,任光辉.共享型市场、地方专业化与区域经济收敛——来自“义乌商圈”的证据[J].统计研究,2008,25(4):90-95.
[62]王海忠.商圈研究的理论模型[J].市场与人口分析,1999,5(3):23-26.
[63]侯丽敏,郭毅.商圈理论与零售经营管理[J].中国流通经济,2000,3:25-28.
[64]吴小丁.哈夫模型与城市商圈结构分析方法[J].财贸经济,2001,3:71-73.
[65]刘建堤.商圈测定与零售业店址选择[J].商场现代化,2001,6:24-26.
[66]迟克莲.运用雷利法则确定商圈[J].现代财经,2001,21(9):63-65.
[67]张荣齐,白人朴,张荣耀.商圈分析与网点布局——以洗染连锁业为例[J].中国农业大学学报,2001,3:40-45.
[68]李卫华.零售网点开发中的商圈分析[J].山西财经大学学报,2002,24(2):35-38.
[69]王厚东.商圈理论分析[J].山西财经大学学报,2002,Z:113.
[70]冯旭,鲁若愚,刘德文.零售商圈的吸引力分析[J].商业研究,2004,24:117-120.
[71]马燕,韩洪凌,高素芳.论零售商圈的测定方法[J].新疆师范大学学报(自然科学版),2005,24(3):192-196.
[72]张岩岩,赫连志巍.商圈量化分析在零售连锁业选址中的应用[J].价值工程,2006,2:99-101.
[73]杨丽君,朱华岚,吴健平.基于GIS的零售业商圈分析[J].遥感技术与应用,2003,18(3):144-148.
[74]廖秋敏,滕清安.GIS支持下的零售业商圈分析研究[J].科技情报开发与经济,2004,14(11):169-170
[75]潘萍,方源敏,常河.基于GIS的连锁超市网点选址的研究与实现[J].湘潭师范学院学报,2007,29(3):55-59.
[76]刘贞,张小真.基于最小聚类单元的商圈聚类方法研究[J].西南师范大学学报,2004,29(6):949-952.
[77]丁鹏飞,王远飞.基于Relly法则与加权Voronoi图的连锁超市商圈分析[J].上海商学院学报,2005,6(4):12-16.
[78]柳思维,唐红涛.基于AHP的城市零售企业商圈吸引力模型分析[J].系统工程,2006,24(3):53-57.
[79]王娟,柳思维.城市商圈布局的三维动态模型构建与述评[J].湖南商学院学报,2007,14(3):10-15.
[80]尹元元,陈柳钦.现代城市商圈布局的技术方法[J].重庆工商大学学报,2007,17(4):43-47.
[81]张宇,吴璟.基于零售物业竞争关系的商圈测定方法[J].商业研究,2007,8:194-197.
[82]卢振业.对超市选址模型中商圈范围参数D的探讨[J].集团经济研究,2006,15:232-233.
[83]朱李明.市场建设中的商圈问题[J].中国流通经济,2000,1:54-57.
[84]岑丽阳.应用商圈理论探讨梧州零售业的合理布局[J].广西大学梧州分校学报,2000,10(4):7-10.
[85]齐晓斋.城市商圈的类型与选址[J].江苏商论,2007,8:9-11.
[86]徐丽娟.从隆福寺变迁看城市商圈规划[J].物流技术,2007,26(6):37-39.
[87]周安平.购物成本与商圈[J].华东经济管理,2003,17(2):130-132.
[88]仵宗卿,戴学珍,戴兴华.城市商业活动空间结构研究的回顾与展望[J].经济地理,2003,23(3):327-332.
[89]李婷.徐家汇商圈的商业空间形态[J].上海艺术家,2003,3:8-9.
[90]侯丽敏,郭毅.连锁便利店商圈特性的实证研究[J].上海财经大学学报,2004,6(4):16-22.
[91]陈玉慧.市级商业中心建设居民参与的实证研究——以厦门市富山商圈为例[J].经济地理,2007,27(4):589-594.
[92]王兴中,刘永刚,高鑫,柳滢,赵多平.中国大城市“项链状”现代商娱场所引力圈的结构——以西安为例[J].经济地理,2008,28(2):214-221.
[93]王震.商圈三四级市场专卖店选址的首选要素[J].现代家电,2006,21:16-19.
[94]黄正祥.浅谈零售企业选址中的商圈调查[J].企业家天地,2007,9:87-88.
[95]程庆山.商业物业的供求与商圈理论[J].中国房地产,2000,4:36-37.
[96]褚有福.商圈建设与市场规律[J].商业经济与管理,2001,10:22-24.
[97]王建革.拨子商与近代东蒙的商业圈和物流[J].中国历史地理论丛,2005,20(3):14-24.
[98]陆立军.解读“义乌商圈”[J].浙江经济,2006,21:33-35.
[99]袁东.商圈消费能力与商圈[J].连锁与特许,2006,3:37-39.
[100]齐晓斋.上海都市商业中心客流与商圈特性分析[J].江苏商论,2006,9:15-17.
[101]齐晓斋.商业街区生态的平衡与发展[J].中国市场,2007,8:59-61.
[102]李雄.华南MALL的商圈环境分析[J].商业经济文荟,2006,4:24-27.
[103]陈建斌.广州市超大型购物中心的零售业商圈环境分析[J].企业经济,2008,4:125-127.
[104]王兆峰,胡郑波.消费环境与零售企业扩张研究——基于Huff模型的商圈分析[J].消费经济,2008,24(1):47-50.
[105]陈玉慧,苏文金,王永兴.厦门市富山商圈发展环境的SWOT分析[J].集美大学学报,2008,11(1):23-28.
[106]柳思维,唐红涛,王娟.城市商圈的时空动态性述评与分析[J].财贸经济,2007,3(6):112-116.
[107]唐红涛.中国古代城市商圈研究——以北宋东京城为例[J].兰州商学院学报,2008,24(1):41-47.
[108]徐丽娟,孟岳松.商圈蠕变与商店发展[J].中国流通经济,1999,3:31-32.
[109]洪涛.现代商圈及其动态发展——兼论北京南城商圈及其定位[J].商业时代,2002,12:10-12.
[110]张圣泉,张雁白,王树花.连锁零售企业扩张中的商圈分析[J].地质技术经济管理,2004,26(6):4-7.
[111]罗建勤,刘中南,蒋明.商圈规模与绩效的相关性分析[J].中共四川省委省级机关党校学报,2007,4:27-29.
[112]周诗岩,张式煜.业态演进与空间转型——探析上海徐家汇和五角场都市副中心商圈建设[J].时代建筑,2005,2:38-45.
[113]芮明杰,李想.零售业态的差异化和演进:产业组织的视角[J].产业经济研究,2007,2:1-8.
[114]任光辉.市场规模扩张、区际分工转换与“义乌商圈”之谜—一个基于新经济地理的分析[J].经济研究导刊,2008,1:147-149.
[115]陆立军,杨海军.市场拓展、报酬递增与区域分工——以“义乌商圈”为例的分析[J].经济研究,2007,4:67-78.
[116]周国红,陆立军.“义乌商圈”国际化拓展的影响因素及其战略选择——基于6363份问卷调查与分析[J].财贸经济,2007,3:106-111.
[117]饶志立.商圈定位与经营策略——天河城广场成功的启示[J].广东科技,2000,1:26-30.
[118]史健勇.徐家汇商圈错位经营模式的探讨[J].上海工程技术大学学报,2001,15:63-58.
[119]胡新,赵颖.城市副中心商圈定位研究[J].城市发展研究,2003,10(6):35-40.
[120]沈青.杭州武林商圈三大商场的市场定位研究[J].江苏商论,2005,6:9-11.
[121]徐丽娟.电子商务条件下零售业商圈研究[J].物流技术,2005,11:23-25.
[122]唐红涛,张俊英.虚拟商圈与现实商圈的比较研究[J].湖南商学院学报,2007,14(3):16-18.
[123]崔彬,孔荣.电子商务环境下的零售业虚拟商圈[J].商业研究,2008,2:206-208.
[124]李勇.CBD品牌结构升级与高端集群模式构建——以重庆解放碑商圈为例[J].重庆工商大学学报,2007,17(4):60-62.
[125]钱炜煜.定位与出位——试论商圈调整中的品牌战略[J].上海商业,2008,1:74-80.
[126]邢伟.对宁波万达广场商圈定位的几点思考[J].经济论坛,2008,10:27-30.
[127]匡东海,周坤惠.商圈的竞争环境分析与竞争战略重构[J].市场周刊财经论坛,2002,11:69-70.
[128]田原,李慧颖,彭永康.打造建陶行业网络商圈提升全球竞争力[J].中国建 材,2007,5:79-80.
[129]王风华.上海商圈的竞争战略[J].商业研究,2002,9:49-50.
[130]肯特·罗伯森,白友涛.小城市商圈的特点和发展原则[J].社会,2002,9:56-58.
[131]席俊峰,匡东海,罗贻芬.南京夫子庙地区商圈竞争力的提升[J].管理科学文摘,2004,2:57-59.
[132]王艳.日本连锁经营,“小商圈、高商圈占有率”模式研究[J].商业研究,2006,22:164-166.
[133]李文翎,曾素芬,周登杰.天河商圈竞争力及其开发策略[J].现代商业,2007,13:50-52.
[134]中共江北区委党校课题组.重庆市主城区商圈发展问题研究——以观音桥商圈为例[J].重庆行政,2008,2:65-67.
[135]蔡国田,陈忠暖.广州市北京路商圈与天河商圈竞合发展探讨[J].云南地理环境研究,2004,16(4):70-74.
[136]陈瑶.对重庆核心商圈和副商圈的对比分析[J].生态经济,2005,9:81-83.
[137]梁抒.对重庆市南坪商圈沃尔玛和好又多店铺形象各构成层面的比较研究[J].商场现代化,2007,7:145-147.
[138]芮明杰.市场营销管理:定位·联想·策略[M].上海:复旦大学出版社,2001:50-55.
[139]陆满平.国外测定商圈的理论法则[J].商场现代化,1998,5:11-12
[140]王海忠.商圈研究的理论模型[J].市场与人口分析,1999,5(3):23-26.
[141]闫军印.交易成本、外部性与模块化技术创新网络[J].湖北经济学院学报,2007,5(1):111-114.
[142]魏伟忠,张旭昆.区位理论分析传统述评[J].浙江社会科学,2005,5:184-192.
[143][德]约翰·冯·杜能.孤立国同农业和国民经济的关系[M].北京;商务印书馆,1986:19.
[144]Losch, A. Die Raumliche Ordnung der Wirtschaft [M](1940),translated as:The Economics of Location[M]by W.H.Woglom and W.F. Stopler, Yale Universit Press,NewHaven(1954),p.520.
[145]张舒.西方城市地域结构理论的评介[J].辽宁大学学报,2001,29(5):84-88.
[146]Ernest W. Burgess.The Growth of the City[A]. R. E. Park, E. W. Burgess, and R. D. McKenzie.The City[M].University of Chicago Press,1925,pp47-62.
[147]G.C.Cameron, A.W.Evans.The British conurbation centres[J].Regional Studies, Vol.7,No.1,March 1973, pp47-55.
[148]Button,K.J.The Use of Economics in Urban Travel Demand Modelling:A Survey [J]Socio-Economic Planning Sciences.Vol.10,No.2,1976,pp57-66.
[149]Hoyt Homer.The Structure and Growth of Residential Neighborhoods in American Cities[M].Washington DC:Federal Housing Administration,1939.
[150]R.D.McKenzie.The Metropolitan Community[M].NewYork:McGraw-Hill,1933.
[151]C.D.Harris,E.L.Ullman.The Nature of. Cities[J].The Annals, Vol.242,1945,pp7-17
[152]Raymond E.Murphy, J. E. Vance, Jr.,Bart J. Epstein. Internal Structure Of The CBD[J].Economic Geography,Vol.30,1954,pp21-46.
[153]Carter, H.,Rowley, G The morphology of the Central Business District of Cardiff [J].Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers,Vol.38,1966,pp 119-134.
[154]Merriman, David. Public Capital and Regional Output:Another Look at some Japanese and American Data[J]. Regional Science and Urban Economics,1991, 20(4):437-458.
[155]张望.城市基础设施与城市经济增长:基于VAR方法对福州市的实证分析[J].兰州商学院学报,2006,22(3):42-47.
[156]马龙龙,裴艳丽.零售商买方势力的滥用及其对策研究[J].商业经济与管理,2003,5:4-8.
[157]马龙龙.马克思论批发商品流通[J].财贸经济,2005,1:42-47.
[158]K.J.巴顿.城市经济学[M].北京:商务印书馆,1984.
[159]晏维龙,韩耀,杨益民.城市化与商品流通的关系研究:理论与实证[J].经济研究,2004,2:75-83.
[160]马龙龙,孟祥升.论我国工业品批发市场的发展[J].中国流通经济,2001,5:28-33.
[161]顾江.规模经济论[M].北京:中国农业出版社,2001:22.
[162]范九利,白暴力,潘泉.基础设施资本对经济增长贡献的研究进展——生产函数法综述[J].当代经济科学,2004,26(2):87-96
[163]王保乾,李含琳.如何科学理解基础设施概念[J].甘肃社会科学,2002.2:62-64.
[164]Merriman, David. Public Capital and Regional Output:Another Look at Some Japanese and American Data[J]. Regional Science and Urban Economics,1991, 20(4):437-458
[165]Garcia-Mila Teresa,McGuire Therese J. The Contribution of Publicly Provided Inputs to States' Economies[J]. Regional Science and Urban Economics,1992,22 (2):229-241
[166]John A.Tatom.Should Government Spending on Capital Goods be Raised?[J] Review,Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis,1991(3):3-15
[167]Douglas Holtz-Eakin.Public-Sector Capital and the Productivity Puzzle [J]. Review of Economics and Statistics,1994,76(1):12-21
[168]Evans Paul,Karras Georgios. Are Government Activities Productive? Evidence from a Panel of U.S. States[J].Review of Economics & Statistics,1994,76(4):1-11
[169]Robert Ford,Pierre Poret. Infrastructure and Private-Sector Productivity[J].OECD Economics Department Working Papers 91,1991,1:1-10
[170]Robert Eisner. Infrastructure and regional economic performance:comment[J]. New England Economic Review,1991(9):47-58
[171]JosE M.Albala-Bertrand,Emmanuel C.Mamatzakis.The Impact of Public Infrastructure on the Productivity of the Chilean Economy[J].Review of Development Economics,2004,8(2):266-278
[172]Federico Bonaglia,Eliana La Ferrara,Massimiliano Marcellino.Public Capital and Economic Performance:Evidence from Italy[J]. Giornale degli Economisti e Annali di Economia,2000,59(2):221-244
[173]王任飞,王进杰.基础设施与中国经济增长:基于VAR方法的研究[J].世界经济,2007.3:13-21.
[174]王国定,李来儿.山西省基础设施投资对经济增长的数量分析[J].山西财经大学学报,2000,22(5):34-36.
[175]王来栓.我国基础设施投资对经济增长贡献的统计分析[J].内蒙古财经学院学报,2004.1:118-119.
[176]杨凤林,陈金贤.基础设施投资与中国的经济增长[J].经济管理,1996.3:11-12.
[177]温惠英,沈毅贤.交通基础设施建设与经济发展的Granger因果关系[J].交通科技与经济,2008,46(2):82-84.
[178]范九利,白暴力,潘泉.我国基础设施资本对经济增长的影响:用生产函数法估计[J].人文杂志,2004.4:68-75.
[179]王任飞,王进杰.基础设施与中国经济增长:基于VAR方法的研究[J].世界经济,2007.3:13-21.
[180]马树才,李华,袁国敏,韩云虹,基础设施建设投资拉动经济增长测算研究[J].统计研究,2001.10:30-33.
[181]王国栋.基础设施投资流在经济增长中的作用分析[J].思想战线,2006,32(4):121-124.
[182]张望,周建安.中国基础设施投资对经济增长波动的冲击效应分析[J].统计与信息论坛,2007,22(3):87-93.
[183]陈国辉,李湛.基础设施对西安经济增长的影响[J].长安大学学报,2007,9(1):47-51.
[184]张学良.中国交通基础设施与经济增长的区域比较分析[J].财经研究,2007,33(8):51-63.
[185]范九利,白暴力.基础设施投资与中国经济增长的地区差异研究[J].人文地理,2004,19(2):35-38.
[186]刘伦武.基础设施投资对经济增长推动作用的动态计量模型与分析[J].数理统计与管理,2005,24(2):60-65.
[187]于博,刘新梅,郑响理.青岛市城市资源、基础设施与其经济社会协调发展的定量评价和分析[J].中国人口·资源与环境,2007,17(4):149-153.
[188]申金山,宋建民,关柯.城市基础设施与社会经济协调发展的定量评价方法与应用[J].城市环境与城市生态,2000,13(5):10-12.
[189]王卉彤,李为人.北京城市基础设施建设投资与经济发展水平研究[J].北京社会科学,2007.1:20-24.
[190]陈国辉,李湛.基础设施对关中地区小城市经济增长的影响:兼论基础设施对关中地区小城市土地利用的影响[J].中国土地科学,2007,21(3):37-43.
[191]踪家峰,李静.中国的基础设施发展与经济增长的实证分析[J].统计研究,2006.7:18-21.
[192]刘伦武.农业基础设施发展与农村经济增长的动态关系[J].财经科学,2006,223(10):91-98.
[193]鞠晴江.基础设施与农村经济发展关系的实证分析[J].安徽大学学报,2006,30(3):113-116.
[194]孔群喜,李敦瑞,许贵阳,农业基础设施投资经济增长效应实证分析[J].重庆工商大学学报,2007,17(6):22-25.
[195]傅晋华.农村基础设施的投资与运营管理:研究综述[J].首都经济贸易大学学报,2008.1:110-114.
[196]董利.基础设施投资与中国工业发展效率分析[J].经济管理,2001.4:38-43.
[197]李薇辉,茆训诚.流通经济理论与政策[M].上海:华东理工大学出版社,2008:339-342.
[198]夏春玉.零售业态变迁理论及其新发展[J].当代经济科学,2002,24(4):70-77.
[199]鲍观明,叶永彪.零售业态演变规律的综合模型构建[J].财贸经济,2006,4:48-94.
[200]M. P. McNair.Significant Trends and Developments in the Postwar Period[M].A. B.Smith(ed.), Competitive Distribution in a High-Level Economy and Its Implications for the University of Pittsburgh Press,1958, chap.1.
[201]O. Neilsen."Development in Retailing", in M. Kjaer-Hansen (ed.),Reading in Danish Theory of Marketing, North-Holland,1966, chap.1-7.
[202]S. C. Hollander,"Notes on the Retail Accordion Theory",Journal of Retailing, Vol.42,1966, pp.29-40.
[203]R. R. Gist. "Retailing:Concepts and Decisions", New York:John Wiley & Sons,1968, pp.106-109.
[204]D.Izraeli.The Three Wheels of Retailing:A Theoretical Note[J].European Journal of Marketing, Vol.7, No.1,1963, pp.70-74.
[205]W.R.Davidson,A.D.Bates,S.J.Bass.The Retail Life Cycle[J].Harvard Business Review, Vol.54,1976,pp.89-96.
[206]方虹.零售业态的生成机理与我国零售业态结构调整[J].商业经济与管理,2001,10:5-8.
[207]张羽琴,陈康海.基于我国零售业态现状的趋势介析[J].贵州社会科学,2006,6:26-28.
[208]Dooley.G,Bowie.D.Place Brand Architecture:Strategic Management of the Brand Portfolio [J].Place Branding,2005,1(4),pp.402-419.
[209]钱明辉.国外地区品牌理论研究综述[J].财贸经济,2007,6:121-126.
[210]Kavaratzis,M.Place Branding:A Review of Trends and Conceptual Models[J]. The Marketing Review,2005,4,pp.329-342.
[211]Hankinson,G..Relational Network Brands:Towards a Conceptual Model of Place Brands[J]. Journal of Vacation Marketing,2004,10(2),pp.109-12
[212]张锐,张燚.城市品牌理论研究综述[J].商业研究,2007,11:79-83.
[213]江振娜.我国区域(城市)品牌研究综述[J].福建行政学院福建经济管理干部学院学报,2005,4:38-42.
[214]夏玉曾,谢健.区域品牌建设探讨——温州案例研究[J].中国工业经济,2003,10:43-48.
[215]黄芳铭.结构方程模式:理论与应用[M].北京:中国税务出版社,2005:23-26.
[216]田肇云.挖掘售后服务领域的潜在价值[J].商业研究,2006,15:180-181.
[217]胡定平.实施口碑营销增强企业竞争优势[J].商业研究,2007,1:102-104.
[218]李陈华.中国零售上市公司的成长性与赢利性——以沃尔玛为基准的一个比较[J].湖南商学院工作论文,HNUCWP,200801:1-14.
[219]刘勇.我国典型地区区域竞争力初步研究[J].学习与实践,2003,1:31-35.
[220]李明武,何文兵.“生态位”现象与零售业的错位经营[J].商业经济文荟,2004,1:31-33.
[221]柳思维,黄福华.新兴流通产业发展研究[M].北京:中国市场出版社,2007:462
[222]柳思维.现代市场研究[M].北京:中国市场出版社,2007:471-494.
[223]张新国.微利时代我国企业提高国际竞争力的对策[J].管理世界,2003,3:141-142.