摘要
中国大豆供求失衡,进口大豆凭借其低价格、高油脂含量的特点已占领国内70%的市场;而北方大豆种植面积增长空间有限,正面临连续种植带来重迎茬减产严重,土壤生态状况恶化,产销分离导致成本增加等不利因素。发展南方套作大豆是振兴我国大豆产业,保护我国粮食安全的必然之路。
南方是我国的主要农业生产区,自然条件优越,人多地少,套作大豆具有与主体粮食作物和谐共存、蛋白质含量高、利于发展加工业、减轻季节性灾害的优点,发展潜力巨大。“麦-玉-豆”种植模式是一种以大豆为核心的新型旱地多熟套作种植模式。自2003年起,在四川省内建立示范区进行推广,成效显著,种植面积逐年增加,但在广大非示范地区却发展缓慢,许多农户依然采用传统的耕作方式,新种植模式的技术未能真正实施。因此,本文通过对农户采用“麦-玉-豆”种植模式的影响因素进行研究,找出影响农户采用的关键因素,对于新农业技术采用率的提高和南方新型大豆种植规模的扩大,都具有现实的指导意义。
本文以行为理论和创新扩散理论为基础,借鉴已有学者的相关研究成果,通过问卷调查,以四川南充、广安、达州、遂宁、绵阳、简阳、泸州等12个地区439户农户的调查数据为样本,从内外部两个角度进行农户采用“麦-玉-豆”种植模式的单因素一般描述性分析;运用二元logistic模型,从农户个人特征、家庭特征、种植模式技术特征、环境特征四方面进一步定量研究农户采用“麦-玉-豆”种植模式的主要因素,并提出相关建议。主要研究结论如下:
(1)四川地区“麦-玉-豆”种植模式凭借良好的综合效益,播种面积增长迅速,但示范与非示范地区间发展水平差距巨大。主要原因是非示范区无政府政策和项目支撑,农户普遍未接受专业培训,相关技术采用率低,采用难题多依靠自身解决,故对该种植模式效益评价一般。加之新种植模式品种、农艺农具等配套技术研发滞后,导致新种植模式进一步推广面临严峻的挑战。
(2)对农户采用“麦-玉-豆”种植模式的影响因素进行实证研究的结果显示:农户的种植习惯、文化程度、生猪养殖、耕地规模、种植模式特征中的增加产量、减少劳动投入、改善土壤、节水抗旱和外部环境中政府政策、农技推广因素对农户有显著影响;而农户年龄、性别、特殊身份,经济收入来源、劳动力数量、种植模式防止病虫害特征、市场风险、膳食结构改变等因素对农户采用“麦-玉-豆”种植模式没有影响。
(3)根据“麦-玉-豆”种植模式发展概况和农户采用影响因素的分析,笔者对加快“麦-玉-豆”新型大豆种植模式的应用和推广提出了加大政府政策引导力度,建立适宜农业技术推广体系;加强科研单位配套技术研究,形成综合栽培技术体系;推进大豆产业开发,大力发展龙头企业;提高农民科学文化素质,转变传统耕作习惯;建立抛荒土地流转机制,扩大农户经营规模五个方面政策建议。
The domestic soybean supply is not enough for soybean demand in China, imported soybean with its low price and high oil-containing has occupied seventy percent of Chinese market. The soybean production in Norththern China is restricted by many unfavorable factors, such as limited growth in soybean planting area, yield decreasing induced by continuous-cropping, high cost by separating production from marketing areas, and so on. To develop relay-planting soybean in Southern China is very important for the soybean industry and food security of China.
Southern China with superior natural conditions and small cultivated area per person is a major agricultural production area in China, and the relay-planting soybean is encouraged by several obvious advantages, for example coexistence consonantly with other main crops, high protein content, benefits to soybean-food industry, the strong resistance to drought, high yield and income per unit area and so on " Wheat/Corn/Soybean " planting model which takes soybean as the key crop of its system is one of new arid land multi-ripe planting models. Since 2003, " Wheat/Corn/Soybean" planting model has been putting in practice in demonstration area in Sichuan province, and its planting area has increased year by year because of good comprehensive benefits. But it developed very slowly in other area, most extension area are still remained in the demonstrating stage. Traditional cultivating methods are being used by most of the farmers and their cultivating skills have not been improved. The core techniques of new planting model are not been put in practice actually. Finding out restrict factors in new planting model adoption through the analyzing of farmers adoption behavior in Sichuan country is very important for the promotion of new agricultural technology, and for the expansion of soybean planting area in south China.
My paper is based on the behavior theory and innovation diffusion theory, some successful study and questionnaires of 439 farmers in Nanchong, Guangan, Dazhou, Siuning, Mianyang, Jianyang, Luzhou and so twelve cities of Sichuan province. At first, the paper describes the overall statistics about the questionnaires, and analyzes the relationship between farmers'adoption and influence factors both from internal and external point of view. Second, author uses Binary-logistic model to analyze farmers' adoption on "Wheat/Corn/Soybean" planting model from four aspects, such as personal characteristics, family characteristics, technical characteristics of planting model and environmental characteristics to find the main influence factors. At last, the article gives five political suggestions.
According to results of theoretical and empirical research, three conclusions are drawn:
(1) With good comprehensive benefits, the planting area of" Wheat/Corn/Soybean" planting model has increased rapidly in Sichuan, but the development level of demonstration areas is different form non-demonstration areas, the gap between them is huge. Because lack of projects supported and government policies supported in non-demonstration areas, farmers generally did not receive professional training, their adoption rate of relevant technologies is low. And the most of farmers solve problems when adopting new planting model on their own. So the farmers'evaluation of comprehensive benefits of new planting model is general. Combined with the lack of technology research on new variety, agronomic and agricultural machinery, the further promotion of " Wheat/Corn/Soybean" is being challenged.
(2) The major influence factors of farmers'adoption are as follows:planting habit and education degree of farmer, cultivated area, pig-breeding, the technical characteristics of planting model such as yield increase, labor cutback, soil improvement, drought resistance, and government policy about new planting model, agricultural extension system. And these influence factors include the age, gender and social identity of farmer, and the main source of income, amount of labor, and the characteristics to prevent pests and diseases of planting model, and the marker risk, changes of diet which do not have any impact on farmers'adoption.
(3) Through the analysis of development situation and farmers'adoption of Wheat/Corn/Soybean" planting model, five political advices are suggested to promote the application and extension the of new planting model.①The government should strengthen the policy guidance and establish appropriate agricultural extension system.②As to establish the synthetic technique system of new planting model, research institutions should strengthen the research on matching technology such as new variety, agronomic and agricultural machinery.③In order to promote the industrial production of soybean, leading enterprises should be greatly developed.④The scientific and cultural qualities of farmers should be improved and their traditional farming practices should be changed.⑤As to expand planting scale of farmer, it is necessary to establish the transfer mechanism of rural abandoned land.
引文
[1]郭庆元等.发展大豆生产,弘扬华夏文明[J].大豆通报,2007(5)
[2]王健等.巴州多熟种植模式发展初探[J].农村科技,2008(9)
[3]王竹.中国南方丘区大豆种植新模式[J].现代农业,2008(12)
[4]池泽新.农户行为的影响因素、基本特点与制度启示[J].农业现代化研究,2003,25(5)
[5]周行.优质稻新技术推广的实证研究[D].北京:中国农业大学,2005.
[6]苑晶,迟宝旭.基于产业链角度的黑龙江省大豆竞争力分析[J].经济研究导刊,2009(15)
[7]姚向高,王同朝.农业推广理论研究[M].北京:中国农业出版社,1995
[8]韩天富,侯文胜.发展转基因大豆,振兴中国大豆产业[J].中国农业科技导报,2008(3)
[9]康涛等.浅析我国农户采用科学技术的心理特点[J].农业现代化研究,1996(2)
[10]张照新.中国大豆市场与贸易分析[J].农业展望,2006(6)
[11]刘永忠等.从农户对科技接受的心理特点谈加强农业科技推广对策[J].农业科技管理,2006(1)
[12]李云辉,李肖白.关于稳定和发展黑龙江大豆生产及相关问题[J].大豆科技,2008(4)
[13]王爽凌.黑龙江大豆生产与加工看我国大豆竞争力[J].黑龙江对外经贸,2004(9)
[14]汤文光肖小平.湖南农作制高效种植模式及其发展策略[J].湖南农业科学,2009(1)
[15]吴德明等.讨论发展湖南大豆种植业及加工产业化[J].武汉食品工业学院学报,1998(3)
[16]董丽华.论三种大豆种植方式[J].大豆通报,1998(2)
[17]张智策,王守国.大豆种植方式对产量的影响研究[J].耕作与栽培,1996(6)
[18]雍太文,杨文钰.发展套作大豆促进四川大豆产业发展[J].作物杂志,2007(6):
[19]刘吉堂.“麦-玉-豆”高效种植新模式[J].种植技术,2006(12)
[20]顾和平,沈克琴.我南方大豆种植制度的现状及育种方向[J].作物研究,1992(3)
[21]唐崇伟.加入WTO后南方大豆发展的基本对策[J].科技进步与对策,2001(12)
[22]赵政文,马继风.加入WTO后湖南大豆生产发展探讨[J].作物研究,2002.16(4)
[23]超玉庭.发展大豆生产,丰富群众生活[J].大豆通报,1994(6)
[24]王小波.四川省大豆高蛋白品种的地理分布[J].作物品种资源.1996(3)
[25]超玉庭,罗晞.大力发展四川省大豆生产的建议[J].1997(3)
[26]张明荣等.四川大豆育种研究存在的问题与发展对策[J].大豆通报,2006(5)
[27]韩颖,马增林.中国大豆产业发展对策研究[J].北方经贸.2008(6)
[28]张蕊.中国大豆产业出路在哪里[J].饲料广角,2007(16)
[29]常汝镇,韩天富.关于发展南方间套作大豆生产的建议[J].大豆科技,2008(6)
[30]杨文钰.发展套作大豆,振兴大豆产业[J].大豆科学,2008(2)
[31]运连鸿.推进麦豆轮作,保护大豆安全[J].中国农业综合开发,2008(10)
[32]杨文年.我国大豆种植产业现状分析与对策[J].饲料广角,2008(17)
[33]梅方权.中国大豆发展战略分析[J].中国食物与营养,2000(1)
[34]赵政文,马继凤.加入WTO后湖南大豆生产发展探讨[J].作物研究,2002(4)
[35]朱希刚.中国大豆业的困境和发展对策[J].中国农村经济,2003(1)
[36]章胜勇,李崇光.中国大豆的比较优势及中美大豆成本效益的经济学分析[J].中国农村观察,2005(1)
[37]周应恒,邹林刚.我国大豆产业发展战略的另一种选择——基于产品差别化的审视[J].农业经济问题,2005(9)
[38]王育民.发展南方大豆生产潜力、问题与对策[J].大豆通报,1994(5)
[39]孙雄松.对积极发展南方大豆产业的思考[J].佛山科学技术学院学报(自然科学版),2009(5)
[40]何元农.黄建斌.小麦玉米大豆不同方式间套作效果分析[J].西南农业学报.1989(5)
[41]何元农等.“麦-玉-豆”全年复种小麦地面空间分布效应和冬春干旱下接茬的研究[J].耕作与栽培,1988(3)
[43]杨继芝等.播期对套作大豆幼苗生长与叶片光合性能的影响[J].作物杂志,2008(5)
[44]闫艳红等.不同品种及播期对丘区套作大豆产量的影响[J].大豆科学,2007(4)
[45]王孟雪,张玉先.“麦-玉-豆”轮作制度下不同施肥措施对大豆产量的影响[J].大豆科学,2009(6)
[46]王孟雪,张玉先.麦-玉-豆轮作制度下施肥措施对土壤养分的影响[J].中国油料作物学报,2009,31(3)
[47]王竹等.不同播期对套作玉米苗期生长的影响[J].玉米科学,2006,14(3)
[48]王竹等.玉米株型和幅宽对套作大豆初花期形态建成及产量的影响[J].应用生态学报,2007(19)
[49]雍太文等.两种三熟套作体系中的氮素转移及吸收利用[J].中国农业科学,2009,42(9)
[50]罗利.川南麦/玉/豆高产栽培技术[J].种植技术,2008(5)
[51]王永强等.旱地新三熟“麦-玉-豆”模式的推广及运用[J].种植技术,2009(1)
[52]雍太文等.旱地新3熟“麦-玉-豆”模式的内涵、特点及栽培技术[J].耕作与栽培,2008(5)
[53]伯顿E.斯旺森等著.许无惧等译.世界农业推广[M].四川科学技术出版社,1989
[54]张舰,韩纪江.有关农业新技术采用的理论及实证研究[J].中国农村经济,2002(11)
[55]林毅夫.制度、技术与中国农业发展[M].上海人民出版社,1994
[56]高启杰.澳大利亚农业推广政策的演变及其对我国的启示[J].世界科技研究与发展,2004(12)
[57]孔祥智等.西部地区农业技术应用的效果、安全性及影响因素分析[M].中国农业出版社,2005
[58]王维赞.蔗农采用“吨糖田”栽培技术影响因素研究[D].北京:中国农业大学,2004
[59]胡瑞法.影响农民采用新品种的因素分析[M].科学出版社,1998
[60]朱希刚,赵绪福.贫困地区农业技术采用的决定因素分析[J].农业技术经济,1995(3)
[61]速水佑次郎.发展经济学—从贫困到富裕[M].社会科学文献出版社,1998
[62]黄宗智.华北的小农经济与社会变迁[M].中华书局,2000
[64]王济文.我国贫困地区农户技术应用行为的实证分析[J].农业技术经济济,1995(3)
[65]陈超,周宁.农民文化素质的差异对农业生产和技术选择渠道的影响——基于全国十省农民调查问卷的分析[J].中国农村经济,2007(9)
[66]曹光乔,张宗毅.农户采纳保护性耕作技术影响因素研究[J].2008(8)
[67]康云海.农业产业化中的农户行为分析[J].农业技术经济,1998(1)
[68]朱明芬等.农户科技行为与调控对策[J].农业科技管理,2001(4)
[69]肖焰恒.我国农业技术应用的宏观取向与农户技术采用行为诱导[J].科技导报,2002(5)
[70]苏岳静等,农民抗虫棉技术选择行为及其影响因素分析[J].棉花学报,2004,16(5)
[71]孔祥智等,西部地区农户禀赋对农业技术采纳的影响分析[J].经济研究,2004(12)
[72]张湘.晋州农户新品种采用行为影响因素研究[D].华中农业大学,2009
[73]黄智俊.我国农户节水灌溉技术采用的激励研究[D].上海财经大学.2006
[74]刘红梅等,影响中国农户采用节水灌溉技术行为的因素分析[J].中国农村经济,2008(4)
[76]高启杰等.论我国农业技术推广模式的优化[J].农业技术经济,1996(2)
[77]李南田,王磊等.农业技术传播模式分析[J].农业科技管理,2004(23)
[78]吕玲丽.农户采用新技术的行为分析[J].经济问题,2000(11)
[79]陈风波,丁士军.南方农户水稻种植行为差异分析[J].湖北社会科学,2003(4)
[80]蒋和平.高新技术改造传统农业论[M].北京:中国农业出版社,1996
[81]姜太碧.农技推广与农民决策研究[J].农业技术经济,1998(1)
[82]陈继宁.农民采用新技术影响因素分析[J].社会科学研究,1998(2)
[83]宋军等.农民的农业技术行为分析[J].农业技术经济,1998(6)
[84]唐永金,敬永周.农民自身因素对采用创新的影响[J].绵阳经济技术高等专科学校学报,2000(6)
[85]何震天.高邮农民采用稻麦新品种影响因素分析[M].2005
[86]吴冲.农户新技术选择行为的影响因素分析及对策建议[J].上海农村经济,2007(4)
[87]高雷.农户采纳膜下滴灌技术行为分析[D].中国农业科学院.2006
[88]兰徐民,赵冬缓.我国农业科技进步障碍因素分析与对策探讨[J].农业技术经济,2002(3)
[89]李冬梅.农户选择水稻新品种的意愿及影响因素分析——基于四川省水稻主产区402户农户的调查[J].农业经济问题,2009(11)
[90]刘永功.影响农户采纳无公害蔬菜生产技术的因素及采纳行为研究[D].中国农业大学,2004
[91]黄季煜等,技术进步和农业生产发展的原动力——水稻生产力增长的分析[J].农业技术经济,1993(6)
[92]Schulz T. W.. Transforming Traditional Agriculture[M]. Yale Univesrity Press,1964.
[93]Saha Atanu H., Alan Love and Robert Schwar. Adoption of Emerging Technologies under Output Uncertainty[J]. Amer. J. Agr. Econ.,1994(11)
[94]Doss R. C., MorrisL. M.. How Does Gender Affect The Adoption of Agricultural Innovations? The Case of Improved Maize Technology in Ghana[J]. Agricultural Economics,2001(250)
[95]Lydia Zepeda, Marco Castillo. The Role of Husbands and Wives in Farm Technology Choice[J]. Amer. J. Agr. Econ.1997 (5)
[96]Jamnick S. F., Klindt, T. H., An Analysis of'No-tillage'Practice Decisions. Department of Agricultural Economics and Rural Sociology[J]. University of Tennessee.1985 (2)
[97]Negatu W., Parikh A.. The Impact of Perception and Other Factors on the Adoption of Agricultural Technology in the More and Jiru Woreda of Ethiopis[J]. Agicultural Economics,1999(10)
[98]Wozniak G D.Human Captial, Information acquisition and new technology adoption: later versus early adoption, the review of economics and statics,1993(75)
[99]Sheikh A. D., Rehman T. and Yates C. M.. Logit Models for Identifying the Factors that Influence the Uptake of New'No-tillage'Technologies by Farmers in the Rice-Wheat and the Cotton-Wheat Farming Systems of Pakistan's Punjab[J]. Agricultural Systems. 2003(75)
[100]Timothy Conley, Christopher Udry. Social Learning through Networks:The Adoption of New Agricultural Technologies in Ghana [J]. Amer. J. Agr. Econ.,2001(8)
[101]Sally Marsh, David Pannell. Agricultural Extension in Australia:The Changing Roles of Public and Private Secto[J].http://www.rirdc.gov.au/pub/shortreps/sr66.html,1999
[102]Ervin Christine A., Evin, David E.. Find More Like This Factors Affecting The Use of Soil Conservation Practices:Hypotheses, Evidence and Policy Implications[J]. Land Economics,1982(8)
[103]Lyubov Kurkalova, Catherine Kling, Jinhua Zhao, Green Subsidies in Agriculture: Edtimating the Adoption Costs of Conservation Tillage from Observed Behavior [J]. Canadian Journal of Agricultural Eeconomics,2006,54(2)
[104]Fliegel, Frederick C., Kivlin, Jjoseph E..Attributes of Innovations as Factors in Diffusion[J].American Journal of Sociogy,1966(11)
[105]Rogers, Event M.Diffusion of Innovation (Forth EditonJ)[M]. The New York Free Press, 1995
[106]Khanna Madhu. Sequential Adoption of Site—Specific Technologies and Its Implications for Nitrogen Productivity:A Double Selectivity Model[J]. Amer. J. Agr. Econ.,2001(2)
[107]Dorfman, Jeffrey. H. Modeling Multiple Adoption Decision in a Joint Framework[J]. Amer. J. Agr. Econ.,1996(8)
[108]Feder, Gershon and Slade, Roger:The Role of Public Policy in the Diffusion of Improved Agricultural Technology [J]. American Journal of Agricultural Economics,1985(5)