摘要
脱氧雪腐镰刀菌烯醇(DON)半抗原的分子设计是建立其免疫分析方法的关键步骤,目前,DON半抗原设计仍采用经验法,造成时间和资金的浪费。本文从半抗原设计的最大原则(不改变待分析物的结构性质)出发,明确DON最佳半抗原的设计思想:最大化抗原表位相似度。利用分子模拟技术,通过分析分子的空间构型、电子特性、疏水性质这几个影响抗原-抗体间作用力的因素在DON修饰前后的变化,研究半抗原结构与免疫识别之间的关系,建立DON半抗原设计的理论模拟方法,为小分子半抗原设计提供新的思路,并在此基础上建立了DON的直接竞争酶联免疫分析方法。
根据DON抗原设计流程:选择结合位点→引入连接臂→偶联载体蛋白,首先研究结合位点对DON免疫识别的影响,在DON分子中的4个潜在结合位点(3 ,7 ,15位羟基以及8位酮基)引入相同碳链长度的的连接臂,借助分子模拟软件Hyperchem7.5对DON及半抗原的表位决定参数(空间结构、原子点电荷、疏水常数)进行计算分析,3位半抗原具有与DON最相似的结构性质,表明3位是DON引入连接臂的最佳位点,这与Casale和Ramesh的免疫实验结果一致。
其次,在3位羟基上设计不同的连接臂结构,通过抗原表位相似度模拟筛选得到最佳连接臂结构:丁二酸酐臂。同时合成不同连接臂的DON完全抗原,并将之进行免疫抗体实验,测定抗体的效价以及抑制率,验证分子模拟结果,研究半抗原结构对抗体免疫活性的关系。结果表明B组(顺丁烯二酸酐臂)抗体平均效价:256000,A组(丁二酸酐臂)、C组(邻苯二甲酸酐臂)平均效价:64000; DON浓度为500 ng/ml时对抗体的抑制率分别:A组(66.4 %)>B组(21.1 %)>C组(10.8 %)。抑制率的大小与抗体对DON的特异性相关,A组与DON具有最高的抗原表位相似度,抗体对DON的特异性强,抑制率高;抗体的效价可以反映半抗原分子的抗原性,苯环结构、不饱和键可以增强抗原性,B组连接臂中含有不饱和键,增强了半抗原的抗原性,产生的抗体效价高;C组虽含有苯环结构,确未能产生高效价的抗体,结合其空间结构发现C组半抗原中羧基端与半抗原主体结构非常靠近,半抗原结构可能被载体蛋白屏蔽而影响免疫识别;综合考虑,丁二酸酐臂是DON的最佳连接臂,免疫试验结果与分子模拟具有很好的相关性。
在最佳半抗原基础上,比较BSA和KLH两种载体蛋白的DON完全抗原的免疫原性。通过丁二酸酐衍生法和碳二亚胺法(EDC法)制备不同载体蛋白的DON完全抗原,免疫新西兰长耳兔获得DON抗体,并运用酶联免疫方法(ELISA)对制备的抗体进行研究。
在上述研究结果基础上合成DON-KLH完全抗原,建立DON的直接竞争酶联免疫分析方法,通过一步抗原抗体反应,快速检测食品中DON。检测范围为1 -100 ng/mL。半数抑制率IC50为10 ng/mL,最低检出限为0.56 ng/mL,与T-2毒素等真菌毒素的交叉反应率小于12 %;平均批内变异系数为2.82 %,平均批间变异系数为14.54 %;对玉米粉的加标回收率在80.2-91.1 %,准确性较高;与商品化试剂盒相比具有所需时间短,精密度高,灵敏度高的优点。
本研究表明分子模拟方法对DON半抗原设计有积极作用,指导半抗原设计,减少半抗原设计中时间及资金的投入。不同载体DON免疫抗原的免疫原性不同,DON-KLH免疫原性优于DON-BSA。6本研究所建立的DON的直接竞争ELISA方法,快速、方便,具有较好的实用价值,为进一步研究DON的ELISA检测试剂盒提供了重要的实验依据。
DON hapten design is the key step to establish the immune analysis methods. Currently, DON hapten design still adopt experience, causing the waste of time and money. From half antigen design principle, clear DON best hapten design thought: maximization similarity.of antigen sites.
Study the changes of molecular space configuration, electronic characteristics, hydrophobic property that several influence the antigen-antibody intercropping force factors , before and after DON modified. Research the relationship between hapten structure and immune discrimination. Establish DON hapten theory simulation design method. Provide a new thinking for hapten design. And on this basis, build a DON direct competition enzyme-linked immunosorbent analysis method.
According to the design process: choose binding sites→introduced connection arm→coupling carrier protein. Firstly, study the effect of binding sites to immune discrimination, introduced the same length of carbon chain of connection arm in the four potential binding sites (3, 7, 15-hydroxyl and 8-ketone base),Using molecular simulation software Hyperchem7.5 analysis determines parameters (spatial structure, atomic stereograph.furthermore, hydrophobic constant), 3-hapten is most similar to DON. Show 3-OH is the best DON binding site. Consistent to immune experiment results of Casale and Ramesh. Secondly, designed different connection arm structure in 3-OH, through similarity simulation received the best connection arm: succinic anhydride arm.
Choose 3 DON hapten with different arms structure to do immune antibody test, determination of antibody titer and inhibition rate to verify the molecular simulation results, study relationship of hapten structure and antibody immunity activity.
Group B antibody titer: 256000; Group A, C average titer: 64000. DON concentration for 500 ng/ml of group A antibodies suppression rate respectively: 66.4%, group B: 21.1%, group C: 10.8%. Inhibition rate of antibodies related to the specificity of DON, Group A has the highest similarity with DON, the specificity of strong, DON inhibition rate high, Antibody titer can reflect the carp of hapten. the benzene rings, unsaturated double bond can enhance the carp. Group B containing unsaturated double bond, enhanced the carp, produce high titer antibody, Although group C contains benzene structure, but failed to produce high titer antibody, combined with its spatial structure found: group C carboxyl end is very close to the main structure, may be shielded by carrier protein and affect immune discrimination. Comprehensive consideration, succinic anhydride is the best connected arm to DON .
In basis of the best hapten, compare the immunogenicity effect of vector protein(BSA、KLH).Preparation completely antigen of different carrier protein, to obtain DON antibody. Study antibody using enzyme-linked immunosorbent method (ELISA) and round two color spectrum (CD).
Established DON direct competition enzyme-linked immunosorbent analysis method. Examination scope for 1~100 ng/ml, half the inhibition rate IC50 for 10 ng/mL, minimum detect limit get 0.56 ng/ml, cross reaction rate less than 12 %, average batch coefficient of variation within 2.82 %,average batch coefficient of variation between 14.54 %;the recovery in 80.2-91.1 %.
This study shows that the molecular simulation method has the positive role to DON hapten design, guiding half antigen design, reduce time and capital investment. DON-KLH immunogenicity is superior DON–BSA. Established DON direct competition ELISA method, quick, convenient, and has good practical value.
引文
1.R K,S B,R J.The State-of-the art in the analysis of type-A and-B trichithecend mycotoxins in cereals[J].Fresenius J Anal Chem.2001,371:285-299.
2.孟昭赫.食品卫生学检验方法注解,微生物学部分[M].人民卫生出版社: 1990:158-160.
3.Lisa M. Cahill S C K, Brian T. McAlice, Catherine S. Ramsey, Reginaldo Prioli , Barb Koh.Quantification of deoxynivalenol in wheat using an immunoaffinity column and liquid chromatography[J].Journal of Chromatography A.1999,859:23-28.
4.S C P,D C.Abramson Superheated steam reduction of deoxynivalenol in naturally contaminated wheat kernels[J].Food Control.2006,17:789–796.
5.J P J.Deoxynivalenol:toxicity,mechanisms and animal health risks[J].Animal Feed Science and Technology.2007,137:283-298.
6.A R B,B P D,J P J.Toxicology of deoxynivalenol(vomitoxin) [J].Toxicol Environ Health.1996,48:1-34.
7.B P D,G G R,L U K.Effects of lowlevel dietary deoxynivalenol on haematological and clinical parameters of the pig[J].Nat Toxins.1994,2:97-104.
8.ZHANG X H X T X, LI S S.Contamination of fungi and mytoxins in foodstuffs in high risk area of esophageal cancer[J].Biomed Environ Sci.1998,11,(2):140-146.
9.JC L, J H,I P. Workshop on trichothecenes with a focus on DON: summary report[J].Toxicology Letters.2004,153,(1):1-22.
10.李斌,郭红卫.镰刀菌毒素DON,NIV的细胞毒性和致突变、致畸、致癌研究进展[J].癌变?畸变?突变[J].1999,11(4):206-207
11.庞炜,王治伦,吕社民.真菌毒素DON研究进展[J].中国地方病防治杂志.1996,11,(6):349-351.
12.魏润蕴.小麦中脱氧镰刀菌雪腐烯醇(DON)的薄层色谱测定[J].卫生研究.1986,15(5):39-46.
13.Abouzied M M,J.I.Azcona,W.E.Braselton. Immunochemical assessment of mycotoxins in 2000 grain foods: evidence for deoxynivalenol (vomitoxin) contamination[J]. Applied Environment Microbiology.2001,57,(3):672.
14.Kasuga F,Hara-Kudo Y,Saito N.In vitro effect of deoxynivalenol on the differentiation of humancolonic cell lines Caco-2 and T84[J].Mycopathology. 2001,142:161-167.
15.Jajic I, Juric V. First survey of deoxynivalenol occurrence in crops in Sebia[J].Food Control.2008,19:545-550.
16.Schothorst R C,Jekel A A.Determination of trichothecenes in beer by capillary gas chromatography with flame ionisation detection[J].Food Chemistry.2003,82(3):475-479.
17.尹珺.脱氧雪腐镰刀菌烯醇_DON_检测方法的研究[D].南京农业大学:南京, 2006.
18.A P.Natural occurrence of mycotoxins in foods and feeds-an updated review[J].Revue Med.1998,149:479-492.
19.M P C,F M J B,MC M A.A review of world contamination of cereal grains and animal feed with Fusarium mycotoxins[J].Anim Feed Sci Technol.1999,78:21-37.
20.M S,M M H,M R.Natural occurrence of 16 FusaHum toxins in grains and feedstuffs ofplant origin from Germany[J].Mycopathologia.2006,161: 52-53.
21.颜姜瑜,赖心田,郑彦婕.深圳地区大豆加工食品中呕吐毒素污染与暴露状况调查[J].广东化工.2010,7:49-50.
22.王晓云.2005年中国六省玉米中脱氧雪腐镰刀菌烯醇的污染调查[D].2006.
23.于宝柱.2005年中国四省小麦中脱氧雪腐镰刀菌烯醇的污染调查[D].2006.
24.张艺兵,鲍蕾,褚庆华.农产品中真菌毒素的检测分析[M].化学工业出版社:北京, 2006.
25.中华人民共和国国家质量监督检验检疫总局,中华人民共和国国家标准.饲料卫生标准GBl3078.3.
26.苏福荣,王松雪,孙辉.国内外粮食中真菌毒素限量标准制定的现状与分析[J].粮油食品科技.2007,15,(6):57-59.
27.祭芳,李华.脱氧雪腐镰刀菌烯醇(DON)人工抗原及多克隆抗体的研制[J].江苏农业学报.2008,24(4):419-424.
28.陈怀谷,王永文,王裕中.应用赤霉毒素-芽鞘生测法鉴定小麦抗赤霉病性[J].江苏农业科学.1990,6:23-24.
29.游淑珠.小麦、玉米中DON气相色谱检测方法的建立及OTA单克隆执体免疫亲和柱的研制[D].南昌大学:南昌, 2005.
30.E R-F,J B,W L.Determination of nivalenol and deoxynivalenol in wheat using liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry with negative ion atmospheric pressure chemical ionization [J].J Chromatogr A.1999,854(12):45-55.
31.U B,M O,F K.Quantitative determination and structure elucidation of type A- and B-trichothecenes by HPLC/ion trap multiple mass[J]..J Agric Food Chem.1999,47(10):4240-4245.
32.G L D,M A,P B.Myelotoxicity of trichothecenes and apoptosis: an in vitro study on human cord blood CD34+ hematopoietic progenitor[J]. Tociol In Vitro.2005,19(8):1015-1024.
33.A H,EN K,Mills C.Enzyme-linked Immunosorbent Assayof 3-Acetyldeoxynivalenol Applied to Rice[J]. J.Sci.Food Agric.1986,37:888-894.
34..Kim,Lee.Investigation of the effect of hapten heterology on Immunoassay sensitivity and development of an enzyme-linked immunosorbent Assay for the organophosphorus insectide fenthion[J].Analytica Chimica Acta.2003,494:29-40.
35.张奇.倍硫磷和速灭威半抗原分子设计及其免疫效果研究[D].2007.
36.桑光明.残杀威和氯氟氰菊酯的半抗原分子设计、合成及人工抗原制备[D].2009.
37.谢桂勉.硫代磷酸二乙酯类农药半抗原设计及抗体识别特性[J].高等学校化学学报.2009, 30,(11).
38.李方实.苯基脲类和磺酰脲类除草剂半抗原设计策略[J].农业环境科学学报.2008,27,(5).
39.陈正隆,徐为人,汤立达.分子模拟的理论与实践[M].2007.
40.Spinks C A.Broad-specificity immunoassay of low molecular weight food contaminants: new paths to Utopia[J].Trends in Food Science & Technology.2000,11(6):210-217.
41.Newman D.J. P C P. Molecular aspects of design of immunoassays for drugs in therapeutic drug monitoring[J].Therapeutic drug monitoring.1996,18:493-497.
42.Delaunay-Bertoncini N,Pichon V,Hennion M-C. Experimental comparison of three monoclonal antibodies for the class-selective immunoextraction of triazines.Correlation with molecular modeling and principal component analysis studies[J].J Chromatngrapy A.2003, 999:3-15.
43.Jones C,Bantz K,Haynes C. Partition layer-modified substrates for reversible surface-enhanced Raman scattering detection of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons[J].Analytical and Bioanalytical Chemistry.2009,394(1):303-311.
44.刘涛,王向红,常彧.直接竞争酶联免疫法检测大麦中玉米赤霉烯酮[J].食品与机械.2008,24,(2):97-117.
45.杨丽丽.动物源性食品中氯霉素快速检测的ELISA方法研究[D].华中农业大学:武汉, 2009.
46.李宗妍.水产品中恩诺沙星残留一步式酶联免疫快速检测方法的研究[D].中国海洋大学:青岛, 2009
47.计融.河豚毒素单抗ELISA检测试剂盒的研制[J].中国公共卫生.2005,21(12):1423-1424.
48.周家驹,王亭.药物设计中的分子模拟化方法[M].人民军医出版社:北京, 2001: 1-36.
49.朱立平,陈学清.免疫学常用实验方法[M]人民军医出版社:北京, 2000: 17.
50.罗满林,顾为望.实验动物学[M].中国农业出版社:北京2002: 242-243.
51.赵春城,龚燕,赵晓联.酶联免疫吸附法检测罂粟碱研究(II)抗体制备和酶标抗原合成[J].中国卫生检验杂志.2003,13(1):47-49.
52.刘红,曾振灵,杨桂香.恩诺沙星ELISA快速检测方法的建立[J].中国兽药杂志.2006,40(11):13-15.
53.WJ M, CT E, SRH C. Determination of sulfadimidine in animal feedstuffs by an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay[J]. Food Additives and Contaminants.1990,7(2):259-264.
54.A M,A H-B,J M.Production and specificity of mono and polyclonal antibodies against microcystins conjugated through N-methyldehydroalanine[J]. Toxicon.2001,39(4):477-483.
55.冯仁丰.分析灵敏度(检测限) [J].上海医学检验杂志.2002,17:133-136.
56.高雷,黄飚,李秋萍,张莲芬,金坚.脱氧雪腐镰刀烯醇时间分辨免疫法的建立[J].食品科学.2009,30(20):398-402.
57.韩丹,于梦,吴梅.酶联免疫吸附分析法测定食品中的苏丹红Ⅰ号[J].分析化学. 2007,35(8):1168-1170.
58.林英武,王中华,聂长明.取代基对卟吩结构和性质的影响[J].物理化学学报.2007,23(10):1594-1598.
59.Kaul P N,Conway M W,Clark M L. Sensitive Quantitative Determination of Chlorpromazine Metabolites[J].Nature.1970,226(5243):372-373.