摘要
首次公开发行市场是一个特殊的市场,发行双方“契约磨擦”与“沟通阻碍”的存在导致IPO公司盈余管理是一个非常普遍的现象。综观相关文献,国内外对于IPO中盈余管理问题的研究主要集中于二个方面,一是IPO公司盈余管理动因研究;二是IPO盈余管理治理机制研究。关于盈余管理动因的属性,会计学界有两种不同的观点:信号观和机会主义观。盈余管理究竟是有益的,还是有害的?还是一个有待回答的理论和实证问题。不论是机会主义观还是信号观,都会导致利益再分配效应。盈余管理行为会引发契约关系人之间财富的重新分配,并且过分的盈余管理容易演变成会计欺诈和内幕交易等非法行为,影响到资本配置效率,甚至导致市场失败。探讨IPO公司盈余管理的动因与治理,有利于促进IPO市场的健康持续发展。
在文献综述的基础上,本文运用统计模拟的方法,首先比较各盈余管理应计利润计量模型的检验效果;然后运用实证方法,探讨IPO公司盈余管理的动机;最后检验证券监管制度的变迁对IPO公司盈余管理的约束。本文的主要研究内容有三个方面:
运用统计模拟的方法,本文通过测试各模型产生第一类错误和第二类错误的频率,比较基本琼斯模型、修正琼斯模型、无形资产琼斯模型、前瞻性修正琼斯模型、收益匹配琼斯模型、现金流量琼斯模型、非线性琼斯模型等七种常用的截面操纵性应计利润模型在中国资本市场的检验效果。研究发现,在中国资本市场上,基本琼斯模型、修正琼斯模型和无形资产琼斯模型相对较优,它们所犯第一类错误和第二类错误的频率较小,但在收入操纵检测上,修正琼斯模型检验能力更突出;现金流量琼斯模型、非线性琼斯模型虽然检验盈余管理的能力较强,但是存在较为严重的第一类错误,易夸大中国上市公司盈余管理的程度。前瞻性修正琼斯模型计算复杂,存在第一类错误,而且检验盈余管理的能力上比修正琼斯模型没有明显的提高;收益匹配琼斯模型对于费用操纵的检验能力较差。综合各项检测结果发现中国证券市场上,分年度分行业回归的截面修正琼斯模型在模型的设定和盈余管理的检验能力方面表现更佳。
本文利用“承销商声誉”划分好企业与差企业,分析企业类型、IPO公司盈余管理水平与IPO后股票异常业绩之间的相关性。结果发现无论是高声誉的承销商所承销的好企业,还是低声誉的承销商所承销的差企业,其上市前一年盈余管理水平都显著为正,且与企业类型没有显著相关性,表明IPO公司盈余管理是一种普遍策略。但通过IPO后股票异常业绩与IPO公司盈余管理水平相关性的进一步检验,发现对于差企业,IPO后异常股票业绩与IPO公司盈余管理水平之间有显著的负相关性,而对于好企业,这种显著的负相关性并不存在。总体的实证结果支持企业类型决定IPO公司盈余管理动因属性的理论分析。表明对于好企业,盈余管理是传递企业未来业绩的信号,而对于差企业,盈余管理是一个机会主义行为。这一发现为盈余管理的机会主义观与信号观的争议提供了一种可能的解释,也在一定程度上,证明了中国IPO市场承销商声誉机制的有效性。
基于中国IPO公司管制诱发型盈余管理动因的考虑,本文根据中国证券发行制度演变,运用应计利润模型和实质盈余管理模型来计量IPO公司盈余管理水平,通过描述性统计和多元回归方法,分析证券发行制度市场化进程对于中国IPO公司盈余管理程度和方式的动态影响。研究发现随着证券发行制度由审批准转向核准制,通道制转向保荐制,IPO公司盈余管理水平显著下降。在盈余管理方式的研究上,本文发现在中国IPO市场上,应计盈余管理和实质盈余管理是显著正相关,并没有发现,Cohen et al.(2008)等西方研究文献所证明的随着监管制度的加强,应计管理和实质盈余管理方式相互替代,此消彼长的趋势。总体的实证结果表明核准制的实施,可以约束IPO公司机会主义盈余管理的行为,系统提高中国上市公司质量。
本文通过对IPO盈余管理常用计量模型的检验能力的分析,发现分年度分行业回归的截面修正琼斯模型在模型的设定和盈余管理的检验能力方面表现更佳,为盈余管理研究的模型选择提供了一种依据。另外对IPO公司盈余管理动因的实证分析,为盈余管理的机会主义观与信号观的争论提供了一种可能的解释,也在一定程度上,证明了中国IPO市场承销商声誉机制的有效性。同时从制度变迁的角度,研究IPO公司盈余管理行为,验证了证券发行制度的市场化的完善能有效约束IPO公司机会主义盈余管理,为证券发行制度进一步向注册制发展提供了证据。
The Initial public offering market is a special market, due to “contracting frictions”and “blocked communication” between issuers and investors, earnings managementsurrounding IPO is very common. Throughout the related studies of earnings managementsurrounding IPO, there are two important issues. One is the nature of earningsmanagement surrounding IPO, the other is the constraint mechanism of earningsmanagement surrounding IPO. For the first one, there are two different views. Someresearchers think the manager takes advantage of earnings management to obtain someprivate gain; others argue earnings management can be used to deliver a more precisemeasure of firm performance. Is earnings management opportunistic or signaling? Whichis still a theoretical and empirical question needed to be answered. Nevertheless, no matterwhich kind of view, earnings management may lead to interest redistribution effect andtrigger the wealth retribution between the related persons. Excessive earnings managementeasily evolve into accounting fraud, insider trading and other illegal behavior, which canharm efficiency of capital allocation and even lead to stock market failure. Studying onnature and constraint mechanism of earnings management surrounding IPO can promotethe healthy and sustainable development of IPO market.
Based on the literature review, this paper firstly uses statistical simulation method toevaluate the specification and power of different discretionary accruals in the Chinesecontext, to looking for the suitable measure model. Then we theoretically and empiricallyanalyze the nature of earnings management surround IPO. Finally, based on issuingsupervision system changes, we study the dynamic change on the level and means ofearnings management by Chinese IPO firms. This paper has three main conclusions:
In the third chapter of this article, this paper evaluates alternative discretionaryaccruals models for detecting earnings management. This comparison uses test statistics toevaluate the specification and power of different discretionary accruals in the Chinesecontext. Specifically, we assess the Jones standard model, the modified Jones model, theJones model with intangible assets, the Jones model with ROA, The forward-lookingmodified Jones model, the Jones model with cash flow, and the non-linear Jones model.We find that:(1) the Jones standard model, the Modified Jones model and the Jones modelwith intangible assets exhibit well specified and the better power in detecting earningsmanagement, especially the modified Jones model, which is more powerful than its standard version at detecting revenue-based manipulation.(2)The Jones model with cashflow and the non-linear Jones model exhibit the most power in detecting earningmanagement, but appear worse specified when applied to a random sample of firm-years.(3)The forward-looking modified Jones model is complicated in computation and itdoesn’t improve the power in detecting earnings management than the original modifiedversion.(4)The Jones mode with ROA performs is worst at detecting expense-basedearnings management. Finally we think it is advisable to put the cross-sectional modifiedJones model in priority when we use the discretionary accruals models in our research ofthe earnings management in the Chinese stock market.
In the forth chapter of the article, we distinguish between IPO firms according to thereputation ranking of underwriters. We find that IPO firms associated with moreprestigious underwriters have significantly less aggressive earnings management, and thatthe negative relationship between earnings management and the post-IPO performance ofa firm’s stocks is discernible only for firms associated with less prestigious underwriters,with no significant results being found for firms associated with more prestigiousunderwriters. Our findings suggest that the firms’ type determines the nature of earningsmanagement.
In the fifth chapter of the article, this paper studies the dynamic change on the leveland means of earnings management by Chinese IPO firms. Based on Chinese stockissuance system evolution, we adopt Jones model and real earnings management model asour measure of earning management, while providing controls for the changes indiscretionary accruals attributable to changes in performance. We found the level ofearnings management declines with the transformation from authorized system toapproval system, and from channel system to sponsor system, but we can’t find the accrualmanagement and real management action can replace each other. On the whole, our studyproves stock issuance system reform can restrain the opportunistic earnings managementactions and improve the earnings quality of Chinese IPO firms.
Our paper contributes to the extant literature on the nature of IPO firm’s earningsmanage by verifying that the firms’ type determines the nature of earnings management,These findings could provide one possible explanation to the dispute betweenopportunistic earnings management view and signal view. Meanwhile what we foundshow the Chinese underwriter reputation mechanism is effective to a certain extent. Ourstudy is also closely related to the literature on the constraint mechanism of earningsmanagement surrounding IPO by proving stock issuance system reform can restrain the opportunistic earnings management actions surrounding IPO, What we finding providessupport for the market-oriented stock supervision system reform.
引文
[1]蔡春,蔡利,陈幸.内部审计质量与盈余管理——来自中国A股制造业上市公司的经验证据.上海立信会计学院学报,2009,(06):9~18
[2]蔡吉甫.会计盈余管理与公司治理.当代财经,2007,(06):109~114
[3]蔡宁,米建华.股权分置改革后盈余管理对IPO发行影响的实证研究.系统管理学报,2010,(04):439~443
[4]陈工孟,高宁.中国股票一级市场发行抑价的程度与原因.金融研究,2000,(08):1~11
[5]陈共荣,李琳. IPO前盈余管理与抑价现象的实证研究.系统工程,2006,(09):74~80
[6]陈书燕.监管制度变革对IPO公司盈余管理的影响.山西财经大学学报,2006,(S2):1~3
[7]陈武朝,张泓.盈余管理、审计师变更与审计师独立性.会计研究,2004,(08):81~86
[8]陈晓,李静.地方政府财政行为在提升上市公司业绩中的作用探析.会计研究,2001,(12):20~28
[9]陈祥有.风险投资与IPO公司盈余管理行为的实证研究.财经问题研究,2010,(01):64~69
[10]陈祥有.我国A股发行公司IPO前盈余管理的影响因素实证研究.北京工商大学学报(社会科学版),2009,(06):66~72
[11]邓长荣,马永开.三因素模型在中国证券市场的实证研究.管理学报,2005,(05):591~596
[12]杜兴强,温日光.公司治理与会计信息质量:一项经验研究.财经研究,2007,(01):122~133
[13]杜兴强,周泽将.高管变更、继任来源与盈余管理.当代经济科学,2010,(01):23~33
[14]高大为,魏巍.盈余管理对资本结构的影响——中国上市公司的实证分析.南开管理评论,2004,(06):67~72
[15]高雷,张杰.公司治理、机构投资者与盈余管理.会计研究,2008,(9):64~72
[16]郭泓,赵震宇.承销商声誉对IPO公司定价、初始和长期回报影响实证研究.管理世界,2006,(03):122~128
[17]韩德宗,陈静.中国IPO定价偏低的实证研究.统计研究,2001,(04):29~35
[18]胡奕明,唐松莲.独立董事与上市公司盈余信息质量.管理世界,2008,(09):149~160
[19]黄春铃,陈峥嵘. IPO市场承销商声誉机制的形成机理及实证检验.证券市场导报,2007,(02):19~25
[20]黄虹荃,崔文娟.中介机构声誉与IPO公司盈余管理水平关系——来自A股市场的实证研究.财会通讯,2010,(33):90~93
[21]江维琳,李琪琦,向锐.董事会特征与公司盈余管理水平——基于中国民营上市公司面板数据的研究.软科学,2011,(05):142~144
[22]李仙,聂丽洁.我国上市公司IPO中审计质量与盈余管理实证研究.审计研究,2006,(06):67~72
[23]李延喜,杜瑞,高锐.机构投资者持股比例与上市公司盈余管理的实证研究.管理评论,2011,(03):39~45
[24]林舒,魏明海.中国A股发行公司首次公开募股过程中的盈利管理.中国会计与财务研究,2000,2(2):87~130
[25]刘江会,尹伯成,易行健.我国证券承销商声誉与IPO企业质量关系的实证分析.财贸经济,2005,(03):9~16
[26]刘力,李文德.中国股市股票首次公开发行首日超额收益研究.中国会计与财务研究,2000,2(4):1~53
[27]刘景章,项江红.风险投资与中国IPO公司盈余管理行为的实证研究——基于深圳和香港创业板的数据.产经评论,2012,(04):151~160
[28]陆建桥.中国亏损上市公司盈余管理实证研究.会计研究,1999,(09):25~35
[29]陆宇建.上市公司基于配股权的盈余管理行为实证分析.南京社会科学,2002,(3):26~32
[30]孟焰,张秀梅.上市公司关联方交易盈余管理与关联方利益转移关系研究.会计研究,2006,(04):37~43
[31]潘越,吴超鹏,史晓康.社会资本、法律保护与IPO盈余管理.会计研究,2010,(05):63~67
[32]汪宜霞.基于抑价和溢价的中国IPO首日超额收益研究:[博士学位论文].华中科技大学,2006
[33]王春峰,李吉栋. IPO企业盈余管理的实证检验.天津大学学报(社会科学版),2003,(04):324~328
[34]王春峰,姚锦.中国股票发行市场价值低估现象实证.天津大学学报(社会科学版),2002,(04):316~321
[35]王克敏,廉鹏.首发上市盈利预测制度变迁与公司盈余管理研究.会计研究,2012,(03):72~77
[36]王克敏,王志超.高管控制权、报酬与盈余管理——基于中国上市公司的实证研究.管理世界,2007,(07):111~119
[37]王雄元,刘焱.产品市场竞争与信息披露质量的实证研究.经济科学,2008,(01):92~103
[38]王彦超,林斌,辛清泉.市场环境、民事诉讼与盈余管理.中国会计评论,2008,(01):21~40
[39]王志强,刘星.上市公司IPO盈余管理与其后期市场表现的实证分析.经济管理,2003,(18):78~81
[40]魏明海.盈余管理基本理论及其研究述评.会计研究,2000,(09):37~42
[41]夏立军.国外盈余管理计量方法述评.外国经济与管理,2002,(10):35~40
[42]夏立军.盈余管理计量模型在中国股票市场的应用研究.中国会计与财务研究,2003,5(2):94-154.
[43]谢赤,张祺.关于中国IPO市场季节性变动现象的实证研究.长沙理工大学学报(社会科学版),2004,(03):50~53
[44]徐浩萍.会计盈余管理与独立审计质量.会计研究,2004,(01):44~49
[45]徐浩萍,陈超.会计盈余质量、新股定价与长期绩效——来自中国IPO市场发行制度改革后的证据.管理世界,2009,(08):25~38
[46]杨丹,林茂.我国IPO长期市场表现的实证研究——基于超常收益率不同测度方法的比较分析.会计研究,2006,(11):20~23
[47]杨芳.新股发行定价机制变迁对会计盈余质量的影响研究:[博士学位]复旦大学,2011
[48]杨清香,张翼,张亮.董事会特征与盈余管理的实证研究——来自中国上市公司的经验证据.中国软科学,2008,(11):133~140
[49]应益荣,刘士杰.我国股票IPOs热销市场的实证研究.江西师范大学学报(自然科学版),2004,(03):232~236
[50]余明桂,夏新平,邹振松.控股股东与盈余管理——来自中国上市公司的经验证据.中大管理研究,2006,1(1):79~97
[51]张海云,徐春波.承销商声誉与IPO企业质量关系的实证分析——基于我国A股市场的数据.财会通讯,2009,(24):39~42
[52]章卫东.定向增发新股与盈余管理——来自中国证券市场的经验证据.管理世界,2010,(01):54~63
[53]张为国,王霞.中国上市公司会计差错的动因分析.会计研究,2004,(04):24~29
[54]张昕,杨再惠.中国上市公司利用盈余管理避免亏损的实证研究.管理世界,2007,(09):166~167
[55]张祥建,郭岚.盈余管理与控制性大股东的“隧道行为”——来自配股公司的证据.南开经济研究,2007,(6):76~93
[56]张祥建,徐晋.盈余管理的原因、动机及测度方法前沿研究综述.南开经济研究,2006,(06):123~139
[57]张雁翎,陈涛.盈余管理计量模型效力的实证研究.数理统计与管理,2007,(03):481~487
[58]张逸杰,王艳,唐元虎.上市公司董事会特征和盈余管理关系的实证研究.管理评论,2006,18(3):14~19
[59]张兆国,刘晓霞,邢道勇.公司治理结构与盈余管理——来自中国上市公司的经验证据.中国软科学,2009,(1):122~133
[60]张宗益,黄新建.我国上市公司首次公开发行股票中的盈余管理实证研究.中国软科学,2003,(10):37~39
[61]周铁,罗燕雯,荆娴.应计利润计量偏差及对识别盈余管理的影响——基于计量信息相关性分析和中国制造业上市公司经验验证.会计研究,2006,(06):63~69
[62]朱星文,廖义刚,谢盛纹.高级管理人员变更、股权特征与盈余管理——来自中国上市公司的经验证据.南开管理评论,2010,(02):23~29
[63] Aggarwal R, Leal R. The Aftermarket Performance of Initial Public Offerings inLatin America. FM: The Journal of the Financial Management Association,1993,22(1):42
[64] Aggarwal R, Rivoli P. Fads in the Initial Public Offering Market?. FM: The Journalof the Financial Management Association,1990,19(4):45
[65] Agrawal A, Cooper T. Accounting Scandals in IPO Firms: Do Underwriters andVcs Help?. Journal of Economics&Management Strategy,2010,19(4):1117~1181
[66] Aharony J, Lee C J, Wong T J. Financial Packaging of IPO Firms in China. Journalof Accounting Research,2000,38(1):103
[67] Aharony J, Lin C, Loeb M P. Initial Public Offerings, Accounting Choices, andEarnings Management. Contemporary Accounting Research,1993,10(1):61
[68] Aharony J, Wang J, Yuan H. Tunneling as an Incentive for Earnings ManagementDuring the Ipo Process in China. Journal of Accounting&Public Policy,2010,29(1):1~26
[69] Ahmad-Zaluki N A, Campbell K, Goodacre A. Earnings Management in MalaysianIpos: The East Asian Crisis, Ownership Control, and Post-Ipo Performance.International Journal of Accounting,2011,46(2):111~137
[70] Alcarria Jaime J J, De Albornoz Noguer B G. Specification and Power ofCross-Sectional Abnormal Working Capital Accruals Models in the SpanishContext. European Accounting Review,2004,13(1):73~104
[71] Ball R, Shivakumar L. Earnings Quality at Initial Public Offerings. Journal ofAccounting&Economics,2008,45(2):324
[72] Barber B M, Lyon J D. Detecting Long-Run Abnormal Stock Returns: TheEmpirical Power and Specification of Test Statistics. Journal of FinancialEconomics,1997,43(3):341~372
[73] Baron D P. A Model of the Demand for Investment Banking Advising andDistribution Services for New Issues. Journal of Finance,1982,37(4):955
[74] Barry C B, Muscarella C J, Peavy Iii J W, et al. The Role of Venture Capital in theCreation of Public Companies: Evidence From the Going-Public Process. Journalof Financial Economics,1990,27(2):447
[75] Bartov E, Gul F A, Tsui J S L. Discretionary-Accruals Models and AuditQualifications. Journal of Accounting&Economics,2000,30(3):421~452
[76] Bartov E, Mohanram P. Private Information, Earnings Manipulations, andExecutive Stock-Option Exercises. The Accounting Review,2004,79(4):889~920Berle A A, Means G C. The Modern Corporation and Private Property, New York:Macmillan.
[77] Beatty R P. Auditor Reputation and the Pricing of Initial Public Offerings.Accounting Review,1989,64(4):693
[78] Beasley M S. An Empirical Analysis of the Relation Between the Board of DirectorComposition and Financial Statement Fraud. The Accounting Review,1996,71(4):443~465
[79] Beaver W, Mcnichols M, Nelson K. An Alternative Interpretation of theDiscontinuity in Earnings Distributions: Springer Netherlands,2007:12,525~556
[80] Becker C L, Defond M L, Jiambalvo J, et al. The Effect of Audit Quality OnEarnings Management. Contemporary Accounting Research,1998,15(1):1
[81] Benninga S, Helmantel M, Sarig O. The Timing of Initial Public Offerings. Journalof Financial Economics,2005,75(1):115
[82] Benveniste L M, Spindt P A. How Investment Bankers Determine the Offer Priceand Allocation of New Issues. Journal of Financial Economics,1989,24(2):343
[83] Booth J R, Smith Ii R L. Capital Raising, Underwriting, and the CertificationHypothesis. Journal of Financial Economics,1986,15(1/2):261~281
[84] Boynton C E, Dobbins P S, Plesko G A. Earnings Management and the CorporateAlternative Minimum Tax. Journal of Accounting Research,1992,30(3):131~153
[85] Brau J C, Johnson P M. Earnings Management in Ipos: Post-EngagementThird-Party Mitigation Or Issuer Signaling? Advances in Accounting,2009,25(2):125~135
[86] Brav A, Gompers P A. Myth Or Reality? The Long-Run Underperformance ofInitial Public Offerings: Evidence From Venture and Nonventure Capital-BackedCompanies. Journal of Finance,1997,52(5):1791
[87] Burgstahler D C, Eames M J. Earnings Management to Avoid Losses and EarningsDecrease: Are Analysts Fooled? Contemporary Accounting Research,2003,20(2):253
[88] Burgstahler D, Eames M. Management of Earnings and Analysts' Forecasts toAchieve Zero and Small Positive Earnings Surprises: Journal of Business Finance&Accounting,2006:33,633~652
[89] Carter R B, Dark F H. Underwriter Reputation and Initial Public Offers: TheDetrimental Effects of Flippers. Financial Review,1993,28(2):279~301
[90] Carter R B, Dark F H, Singh A K. Underwriter Reputation, Initial Returns, and theLong-Run Performance of Ipo Stocks. Journal of Finance,1998,53(1):285~311
[91] Carter R, Manaster S. Initial Public Offerings and Underwriter Reputation. Journalof Finance,1990,45(4):1045~1067
[92] Chahine S, Arthurs J D, Filatotchev I, et al. The Effects of Venture CapitalSyndicate Diversity On Earnings Management and Performance of Ipos in the Usand Uk: An Institutional Perspective. Journal of Corporate Finance,2012,18(1):179~192
[93] Chemmanur T J, Fulghieri P. Investment Bank Reputation, Information Production,and Financial Intermediation. The Journal of Finance,1994,49(1):57~79
[94] Chui A P L, Lau H F W, Ip Y K. The Post Issue Performance of Initial PublicOffering Firms in the People's Republic of China. Advances in InternationalAccounting,2001,14(0):75~100
[95] Chung R, Ho S, Kim J. Ownership Structure and the Pricing of DiscretionaryAccruals in Japan. Journal of International Accounting, Auditing and Taxation,2004,13(1):1~20
[96] Cohen D A, Dey A, Lys T Z. Real and Accrual-Based Earnings Management in thePre-And Post-Sarbanes-Oxley Periods. Accounting Review,2008,83(3):757~787
[97] Cohen D A, Zarowin P. Accrual-Based and Real Earnings Management ActivitiesAround Seasoned Equity Offerings. Journal of Accounting and Economics,2010,50(1):2~19
[98] Datar S M, Feltham G A, Hughes J S. The Role of Audits and Audit Quality inValuing New Issues. Journal of Accounting&Economics,1991,14(1):3~49
[99] Datar V, Mao D Z. Deep Underpricing of China's Ipos: Sources and Implications.International Journal of Financial Services Management,2006:345
[100] Deangelo H, Deangelo L, Skinner D J. Accounting Choice in Troubled Companies.Journal of Accounting and Economics,1994,17(1–2):113~143
[101] Deangelo L E. Managerial Competition, Information Costs, and CorporateGovernance. Journal of Accounting&Economics,1988,10(1):3
[102] Dechow P M, Dichev I D. The Quality of Accruals and Earnings: The Role ofAccrual Estimation Errors. Accounting Review,2002,77(4):35
[103] Dechow P M, Sloan R G. Executive Incentives and the Horizon Problem: AnEmpirical Investigation. Journal of Accounting and Economics,1991,14(1):51~89
[104] Dechow P M, Sloan R G. Detecting Earnings Management. Accounting Review,1995,70(2):193~225
[105] Dechow P M, Sloan R G, Sweeney A P. Causes and Consequences of EarningsManipulation: An Analysis of Firms Subject to Enforcement Actions by the Sec.Contemporary Accounting Research,1996,13(1):1
[106] Deboskey D G, Jiang W. Earnings Management and Auditor Specialization in thePost-Sox Era: An Examination of the Banking Industry. Journal of Banking&Finance,2012,36(2):613~623
[107] Defond M L, Jiambalvo J. Debt Covenant Violation and Manipulation of Accruals.Journal of Accounting&Economics,1994,17(1):145
[108] Dempsey S J, Hunt H G, Schroeder N W. Earnings Management and CorporateOwnership Structure: An Examination of Extraordinary Item Reporting: Journal ofBusiness Finance and Accounting,1993:20,479~500
[109] Ducharme L L, Malatesta P H, Sefcik S E. Earnings Management: Ipo Valuationand Subsequent Performance. Journal of Accounting, Auditing&Finance,2001,16(4):369
[110] Ducharme L L, Malatesta P H, Sefcik S E. Earnings Management, Stock Issues,and Shareholder Lawsuits. Journal of Financial Economics,2004,71(1):27~49
[111] Durtschi C, Easton P. Earnings Management? Erroneous Inferences Based OnEarnings Frequency Distributions. Journal of Accounting Research,2009,47:1249~1281
[112] Durtschi C, Easton P. Earnings Management? The Shapes of the FrequencyDistributions of Earnings Metrics are Not Evidence Ipso Facto. Journal ofAccounting Research,2005,43(4):557~592
[113] Dye R A. Auditing Standards, Legal Liability, and Auditor Wealth. Journal ofPolitical Economy,1993,101(5):887
[114] Erickson M, Shiing-Wu Wang M. Earnings Management by Acquiring Firms inStock for Stock Mergers. Journal of Accounting&Economics,1999,27(2):149
[115] Fama E F. Market Efficiency, Long-Term Returns, and Behavioral Finance. Journalof Financial Economics,1998,49(3):283~306
[116] Fama, Eugence F, Jensent.Spearation of Ownership and Cortol. Journal of Lawand Econnomics,1983,26(2):301
[117] Fan Q T. Earnings Management and Ownership Retention for Initial PublicOffering Firms: Theory and Evidence. Accounting Review,2007,82(1):27~64
[118] Fan J P H, Wong T J. Corporate Ownership Structure and the Informativeness ofAccounting Earnings in East Asia. Journal of Accounting and Economics,2002,33(3):401~425
[119] Fang L H. Investment Bank Reputation and the Price and Quality of UnderwritingServices. The Journal of Finance,2005,60(6):2729~2761
[120] Friedlan J M. Accounting Choices of Issuers of Initial Public Offerings.Contemporary Accounting Research,1994,11(1):1
[121] Graham J R, Harvey C R. The Theory and Practice of Corporate Finance: EvidenceFrom the Field. Journal of Financial Economics,2001,60(2/3):187~243
[122] Guay W R, Kothari S P, Watts R L. A Market-Based Evaluation of DiscretionaryAccrual Models. Journal of Accounting Research,1996,34(3):83~105
[123] Guiso L, Sapienza P, Zingales L. Does Local Financial Development Matter? TheQuarterly Journal of Economics,2004,119(3):929~969
[124] Hanleya K W, Wilhelm Jr W J. Evidence on the Strategic Allocation of InitialPublic Offerings. Journal of Financial Economics,1995,37(2):239
[125] Healy P M. The Effect of Bonus Schemes on Accounting Decisions. Journal ofAccounting and Economics,1985,7(1–3):85~107
[126] Healy P M, Wahlen J M. A Review of the Earnings Management Literature and itsImplications for Standard Setting. Accounting Horizons,1999,13(4):365~383
[127] Hei W L, Yan A X, Jian Z. Role of Underwriters in Restraining EarningsManagement in Initial Public Offerings. Journal of Applied Business Research,2012,28(4):709~724
[128] Hribar P, Collins D W. Errors in Estimating Accruals: Implications for EmpiricalResearch. Journal of Accounting Research,2002,40(1):105~134
[129] Ibbotson R G. Price Performance of Common Stock New Issues. Journal ofFinancial Economics,1975,2(3):235
[130] Ibbotson R G, Jaffe J F."Hot Issue" Markets. Journal of Finance,1975,30(4):1027
[131] Iqbal A, Espenlaub S, Strong N. Earnings Management Around Uk Open Offers.European Journal of Finance,2009,15(1):29~51
[132] Jain B A, Kini O. The Post-Issue Operating Performance of Ipo Firms. Journal ofFinance,1994,49(5):1699~1726
[133] Jensen M C. The Modern Industrial Revolution, Exit, and the Failure of InternalControl Systems. The Journal of Finance,1993,48(3):831~880
[134] Jensen M C, Meckling W H. Theory of the Firm: Managerial Behavior, AgencyCosts and Ownership Structure. Journal of Financial Economics,1976,3(4):305~360
[135] Jiraporn P, Miller G A, Yoon S S, et al. Is Earnings Management Opportunistic OrBeneficial? An Agency Theory Perspective. International Review of FinancialAnalysis,2008,17(3):622~634
[136] Johnson, Simon, Rafael La Porta, Florencio Lopez-de-Silanes, and Andrei Shleifer.Tunneling. American Economic Review,2000,90(2):22–27
[137] Jones J J. Earnings Management During Import Relief Investigations. Journal ofAccounting Research,1991,29(2):193~228
[138] Jiraporn P, Miller G A, Yoon S S, et al. Is Earnings Management Opportunistic OrBeneficial? An Agency Theory Perspective. International Review of FinancialAnalysis,2008,17(3):622~634
[139] Kim M, Ritter J R. Valuing IPOs. Journal of Financial Economics,1999,53(3):409~437
[140] Klein A. Audit Committee, Board of Director Characteristics, and EarningsManagement. Journal of Accounting&Economics,2002,33(3):375
[141] Kothari S P, Leone A J, Wasley C E. Performance Matched Discretionary AccrualMeasures. Journal of Accounting and Economics,2005,39(1):163~197
[142] Kothari S P, Warner J B. Measuring Long-Horizon Security Price Performance.Journal of Financial Economics,1997,43(3):301
[143] la Porta R, Lopez-De-Silanes F, Shleifer A, et al. Law and Finance. Journal ofPolitical Economy,1998,106(6):1113
[144] La Porta R, Lopez-De-Silanes F, Shleifer A, et al. Investor Protection andCorporate Governance. Journal of Financial Economics,2000,58(1–2):3~27
[145] Lee G, Masulis R W. Do More Reputable Financial Institutions Reduce EarningsManagement by IPO Issuers? Journal of Corporate Finance,2011,17(4):982~1000
[146] Leland H E, Pyle D H. Informational Asymmetries, Financial Structure, andFinancial Intermediation. Journal of Finance,1977,32(2):371~387
[147] Levitt Jr A. The 'Numbers Game'. CPA Journal,1998,68(12):14
[148] Leuz C, Nanda D, Wysocki P D. Earnings Management and Investor Protection: AnInternational Comparison. Journal of Financial Economics,2003,69(3):505~527
[149] Loughran T, Ritter J R. Long-Term Market Overreaction: The Effect of Low-PricedStocks. Journal of Finance,1996,51(5):1959
[150] Loughran T, Ritter J R. The New Issues Puzzle. Journal of Finance,1995,50(1):23
[151] Loughran T, Ritter J R. Why Don't Issuers Get Upset About Leaving Money On theTable in Ipos? Review of Financial Studies,2002,15(2):413
[152] Louis H, Robinson D. Do Managers Credibly Use Accruals to Signal PrivateInformation? Evidence From the Pricing of Discretionary Accruals Around StockSplits. Journal of Accounting and Economics,2005,39(2):361~380
[153] Liu J, Uchida K, Gao R. Political Connections and the Long-Term StockPerformance of Chinese Ipos. Journal of International Financial Markets,Institutions and Money,2012,22(4):814~833
[154] Lucas D J, Mcdonald R L. Equity Issues and Stock Price Dynamics. Journal ofFinance,1990,45(4):1019
[155] Lyon J D, Barber B M, Tsai C. Improved Methods for Tests of Long-Run AbnormalStock Returns. Journal of Finance,1999,54(1):165~201
[156] Mcnichols M F. Research Design Issues in Earnings Management Studies. Journalof Accounting and Public Policy,2000,19:313~345
[157] Megginson W L, Weiss K A. Venture Capitalist Certification in Initial PublicOfferings. Journal of Finance,1991,46(3):879~903
[158] Michaely R, Shaw W H. The Pricing of Initial Public Offerings: Tests ofAdverse-Selection and Signaling Theories. Review of Financial Studies,1994,7(2):279
[159] Michaely R, Shaw W H. Does the Choice of Auditor Convey Quality in an InitialPublic Offering? Financial Management,1995,24(4):15~301
[160] Miller E M. Risk, Uncertainty, and Divergence of Opinion. Journal of Finance,1977,32(4):1151~1168
[161] Morsfield S G, Tan C E L. Do Venture Capitalists Influence the Decision toManage Earnings in Initial Public Offerings? The Accounting Review,2006,81(5):1119~1150
[162] Peasnell K V, Pope P F, Young S. Detecting Earnings Management UsingCross-Sectional Abnormal Accruals Models. Accounting&Business Research(Wolters Kluwer UK),2000,30(4):313~326
[163] Perry S E, Williams T H. Earnings Management Preceding Management BuyoutOffers. Journal of Accounting&Economics,1994,18(2):157
[164] Qian H, Yao L J. An Explanation for Earnings Management: Opportunistie OrSignaling? Journal of Theoretical Accounting Research,2008:5,153~168
[165] Rajgopal S, Venkatachalam M, Kotha S. Managerial Actions, Stock Returns, andEarnings: The Case of Business-to-Business Internet Firms. Journal ofAccounting Research,2002,40(2):529~556
[166] Rangan S. Earnings Management and the Performance of Seasoned EquityOfferings. Journal of Financial Economics,1998,50(1):101
[167] Ritter J R. The Long-Run Performance of Initial Public Offerings. Journal ofFinance,1991,46(1):3~27
[168] Ritter J R. The "Hot Issue" Market of1980. Journal of Business,1984,57(2):215~240
[169] Ritter J R, Welch I. A Review of Ipo Activity, Pricing, and Allocations. Journal ofFinance,2002,57(4):1795
[170] Ritter J R, Welch I. A Review of Ipo Activity, Pricing, and Allocations. Journal ofFinance,2002,57(4):1795
[171] Rock K. Why New Issues are Underpriced. Journal of Financial Economics,1986,15(1):187
[172] Roosenboom P, van der Goot T, Mertens G. Earnings Management and InitialPublic Offerings: Evidence From the Netherlands. International Journal ofAccounting,2003,38(3):243
[173] Roychowdhury S. Earnings Management through Real Activities Manipulation.Journal of Accounting&Economics,2006,42(3):335~370
[174] Schipper K. Commentary On Earnings Management. Accounting Horizons,1989,3(4):91
[175] Siew H T, Welch I, Wong T J. Earnings Management and the Underperformance ofSeasoned Equity Offerings. Journal of Financial Economics,1998,50(1):63
[176] Stein J C. Efficient Capital Markets, Inefficient Firms: A Model of MyopicCorporate Behavior. Quarterly Journal of Economics,1989,104(4):655
[177] Stoll H R, Curley A J. Small Business and the New Issues Market for Equities.Journal of Financial&Quantitative Analysis,1970,5(3):309
[178]Subramanyam K R. The Pricing of Discretionary Accruals. Journal of Accounting&Economics,1996,22(1):249
[179] Teoh S H, Welch I, Wong T J. Earnings Management and the Long-Run MarketPerformance of Initial Public Offerings. Journal of Finance,1998,53(6):1935~1974
[180] Teoh S H, T. J W, Rao G R. Are Accruals During Initial Public OfferingsOpportunistic? Review of Accounting Studies,1998,3(1):175
[181] Teoh S H, Wong T J, Rao G R. Incentives and Opportunities for EarningsManagement in Initial Public Offerings. Working Papers (Faculty)--University ofMichigan Business School,1994:1
[182] Thomas J, Zhang X. Identifying Unexpected Accruals: A Comparison of CurrentApproaches. Journal of Accounting and Public Policy,2000,19(4–5):347~376
[183] Titman S, Trueman B. Information Quality and the Valuation of New Issues.Journal of Accounting&Economics,1986,8(2):159~172
[184] Trueman B, Titman S. An Explanation for Accounting Income Smoothing. Journalof Accounting Research,1988,26(3):127
[185] Venkataraman R, Weber J P, Willenborg M. Litigation Risk,Audit Quality, andAudit Fees: Evidence From Initial Public Offerings. Accounting Review,2008,83(5):1315
[186] Wagenhofer A. Voluntary Disclosure with a Strategic Opponent. Journal ofAccounting and Economics,1990,12(4):341~363
[187] Warfield T D, Wild J J, Wild K L. Managerial Ownership, Accounting Choices, andInformativeness of Earnings. Journal of Accounting&Economics,1995,20(1):61~91
[188] Wan W. The Effect of External Monitoring On Accrual-Based and Real EarningsManagement: Evidence From Venture-Backed Initial Public Offerings*.Contemporary Accounting Research,2012:1~29
[189] Welch I. Seasoned Offerings, Imitation Costs, and the Underpricing of InitialPublic Offerings. Journal of Finance,1989,44(2):421
[190] Xie B, Davidson Iii W N, Dadalt P J. Earnings Management and CorporateGovernance: The Role of the Board and the Audit Committee. Journal of CorporateFinance,2003,9(3):295~316
[191] Yeo G H H, Tan P M S, Ho K W, et al. Corporate Ownership Structure and theInformativeness of Earnings. Journal of Business Finance&Accounting,2002,29(7/8):1023~1046
[192] Zang A Y. Evidence On the Trade-Off Between Real Activities Manipulation andAccrual-Based Earnings Management. Accounting Review,2012,87(2):675~703