外资银行进入对中国商业银行竞争行为的影响研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
随着我国银行业对外开放进程的稳步推进,尤其是2006年底银行业全面开放后,外资银行对中国市场的参与程度越来越深。中国商业银行面临的外部竞争环境发生了变化,不仅仅是国内同业的竞争,还有国际强手的挑战。在此背景下,研究外资银行进入对中国商业银行竞争行为的影响,不仅对保证中国银行业持续发展的监管政策制定、促进市场竞争等具有重要的实践意义;而且,对在保证国家金融安全前提下,发挥外资银行对金融发展和稳定的积极作用,具有十分重要的战略意义。
     本文得到结论:第一,1996-2010年间我国银行业处于垄断竞争格局,并且偏向竞争性。外资银行进入与中国商业银行竞争之间表现为倒U关系。外资银行进入加剧了中国商业银行之间的竞争,并且中小型商业银行之间竞争的加剧明显高于大型商业银行,当外资银行进入程度达到一定水平时,中国商业银行之间的市场竞争会出现反转。现阶段属于外资银行进入初期,中国商业银行的市场竞争仍处于倒U型阶段的上升阶段。第二,中国商业银行贷款市场的竞争比存款市场激烈。外资进入显著加剧了中国商业银行存贷款市场的竞争,过渡期结束后,竞争虽有所缓和,但相比入世前,竞争仍比较激烈。第三,大型商业银行之间比中小型商业银行之间的竞争激烈,尤其是大型商业银行的信贷市场接近完全竞争,国内银行业的规模经济效益只体现在信贷业务领域。第四,外资银行进入对人民币业务冲击不大,外汇存款业务具有明显优势。外资银行不同的进入方式,对中资银行贷款业务竞争行为的影响不同:外资银行以参股方式进入时,在甄别客户信息上所具有的优势,使其可以更多地选择质量好的借款人进行贷款,留给中资银行的借款人质量相对较差,中资银行更多通过产品创新而不是价格作为主要竞争工具;外资银行以独资模式进入时,外资银行倾向于新客户的开发,中资银行更注重对老客户的维护。外资银行在地域上的转移,导致国内中资银行在中西部地区的信贷竞争加剧。外资银行进入所产生的竞争压力,使资本实力较为雄厚经营风格较为稳健的国内银行的风险厌恶程度提高,信贷供给趋于保守,使资本较为匮乏的国内银行的信贷竞争行为更为冒进。中间业务方面,外资银行进入使中资银行开始重视利用价格工具进行市场调节,促使中资银行的竞争策略从“以产品为中心”开始转向“以客户为中心”。
As Chinese banking industry is opening up steadily, especially after the banking industry’scomplete opening-up at the end of2006, foreign banks are becoming increasingly involved inChinese market. The external competition environment has changed, as Chinese banks not onlyconfront with domestic counterparts’ competition but also face the challenge from stronginternational companies. In this context, the research on the influence of the entering of foreignbanks on Chinese banks competitive behaviors not only attributes practically to theestablishment of regulatory policies that ensure the continuous development of Chinese bankingand the promotion of market competition, but also makes strategic sense to ensure foreign banks’positive effect on Chinese financial development and stability on the condition that nationalfinance safety is guaranteed.
     In this paper, we draw the following conclusions: First, China's banking industry is ofmonopolistic competition pattern between1996and2010, and the competition is more obvious.Further, the relationship between foreign banks entering and China's commercial bankscompetition shows U shape. It means that foreign banks entering will aggravate competition ofChina's commercial banks, and the scope of small and medium-sized commercial banks is higherthan large commercial banks. Only when the entering level becomes to a significant extent,competition degree will become weaken. Now China’s banking industry is in primary phase offoreign banks entering, so the competition is on the rise. Second, the competition of loan marketis more intense than deposit market. The foreign banks entering aggravate the competition ofdeposit and loan market. After transitional period the competition is weaken, but it still moreintense than it was before china joined WTO. Third, the competition of large commercial banksis more intense than small and medium-sized commercial banks. Furthermore, the loan market oflarge commercial banks is close to perfect competition, and only loan business appears scaleeconomies. Finally, the impact of foreign banks entering on RMB transactions is unconspicuous,and the advantage of foreign banks is foreign exchange deposit business. Then, the entry offoreign banks in different ways has different effects on the competitive behavior of Chinesebanks loan business. When foreign banks enter with equity participation, it has the advantage in the screening of customer information. So it can choose good quality borrowers, and leave thepoor borrowers to Chinese banks. Therefore, Chinese banks choose product innovation ratherthan price change as the major competitive tool; when foreign banks enter with wholly-ownedmode, it tend to develop new customers, while Chinese banks pay more attention to themaintenance of old customers. Besides, the geographical change of foreign banks aggravatescredit competition of Chinese banks in the Midwest. The competitive pressures of foreign banksentering, increases the risk aversion of domestic banks whose management style is more prudentand capital is adequate, and makes credit supply to be conservative. Also, banks with lack ofcapital will be more aggressive in credit competitive behavior. In addition, in intermediarybusiness, the entering of foreign banks cause Chinese banks focus on price tool for marketregulation and promote the competitive strategy of the domestic banks to shift fromproduct-centric to customer-centric.
引文
①Bain,J.S.,1956. Barriers to New Competition,Harvard University Press,p.3.
    ①波士顿咨询公司(BCG)调查报告《巨龙展翼中国消费信贷开始起飞》。
    ①《中国支付体系发展报告(2010)》。
    ①2006年、2010年《中国银行业监督管理委员会年报》。
    [1]毕继繁、胡振兵,2002:《供给约束与萨伊定律:金融机构中间业务案例研究》,《金融研究》第2期。
    [2]才宏远、王新华,2005:《商业银行中间业务发展现状分析》,《中国金融》第14期。
    [3]蔡卫星、曾诚,2011:《境外战略投资者改变了国有商业银行的贷款行为吗——基于动态面板数据模型的经验分析》,《当代经济科学》第1期。
    [4]陈晓红、黎璞,2003:《分工演化与关系型融资:中小企业融资问题的新理论解释》,《管理评论》第5期。
    [5]陈伟光,2007:《银行垄断及其市场势力研究》,《国际经贸探索》第2期。
    [6]陈伟光、肖晶,2007:《外资银行进入效应实证研究》,《经济学家》第1期。
    [7]迟国泰,2005:《中国商业银行成本效率实证研究》,《经济研究》第5期。
    [8]段明,2000:《加入WTO与中小商业银行的决策》,《金融研究》第2期。
    [9]高晓红,2000:《外资银行进入与中国国有商业银行改革困境的解除》,《金融研究》第6期。
    [10]郭红珍、张卉,2003:《我国商业银行中间业务的资源配置行为分析》,《国际金融研究》第4期。
    [11]郭妍、张立光,2005:《外资银行进入对我国银行业影响效应的实证研究》,《经济科学》第2期。
    [12]贺春临,2004:《我国银行业的市场结构与绩效研究》,《经济评论》第6期。
    [13]何德旭,1999:《关于中小企业融资‘难’的辨证思考”》,《财贸经济》第6期。
    [14]黄隽,2007:《银行竞争与银行数量关系研究》,《金融研究》第7期。
    [15]黄隽、白冰心,2007:《银行业市场竞争度:基于韩国、中国内地和中国台湾比较分析》,《经济理论与经济管理》第4期。
    [16]黄宪,2001:《国际银行业的转型》,《金融研究》第10期。
    [17]黄宪,熊福平,2005:《外资银行在中国发展的经营动机和经营策略分析》,《金融研究》第2期。
    [18]黄宪、熊福平,2006:《外资银行进入对我国银行业影响的实证研究》,《国际金融研究》第5期。
    [19]柯孔林,2010:《中国银行业市场竞争结构测度:基于Bresnahan范式研究》,《数理统计与管理》第4期。
    [20]雷震、彭欢,2009:《我国银行业改革与存贷款市场结构分析——基于推测变分的结构模型》,《管理世界》第6期。
    [21]李杜环,2000:《利率自由化—理论,实践与绩效》,上海:上海财经出版社。
    [22]李良、陈晓红,2004:《外资银行的专利壁垒与我国商业银行的专利战略》,《金融论坛》第4期。
    [23]李明志、柯旭清,2004:《产业组织理论》,北京:清华大学出版社。
    [24]李伟、韩立岩,2008:《外资银行进入对我国银行业市场竞争度的影响:基于Panzar-Rosse模型的实证研究》,《金融研究》第5期。
    [25]李晓峰、陈光,2000:《在华外资银行经营现状及发展前景分析》,《国际金融研究》第5期。
    [26]李艳虹,2008:《中国银行业的市场结构与竞争行为》,《贵州财经学院学报》第5期。
    [27]梁建华,2003:《从银行经营者行为差异看利率市场化》,《金融研究》第4期。
    [28]林毅夫、李永军,2001:《中小金融机构发展与中小企业融资》,《经济研究》第1期。
    [29]刘华、卢孔标,2006:《外资银行对新兴市场经济国家银行体系效率与稳定性的影响》,《南方金融》第11期。
    [30]刘琛和宋蔚兰,2004,《基于SFA的中国商业银行效率研究》,《金融研究》第6期。
    [31]刘涛,2007:《后WTO时期外资银行对中资银行影响分析及其路径选择》。
    [32]刘伟、黄桂田,2003,《银行业的集中、竞争与绩效》,《经济研究》第11期
    [33]陆文安,2005:《外资银行进入对我国银行业的影响及对策》,《国际商务研究》第5期。
    [34]罗珺,2003:《国有商业银行市场势力分析》,《金融研究》第10期。
    [35]罗旋,2008:《外资银行进入对中国银行业效率影响的分析》,《财经界》第3期。
    [36]吕剑,2006:《外资银行的进人对我国银行业的影响——基于面板数据的分析》,《对外经贸大学学报》第5期。
    [37]马雪虹,2004:《当前在华外资银行的核心业务》,《经济研究参考》第45期。
    [38]毛泽盛,2006:《外国银行进入对我国银行业影响的实证研究》,《南京师大学报》第7期。
    [39]毛泽盛、吴洁、刘敏楼,2010:《外资银行对中国信贷供给影响的实证研究》,《金融研究》第1期。
    [40]彭欢、雷震,2010:《放松管制与我国银行业市场竞争实证研究》,《南开经济研究》第2期。
    [41](美)富兰克林·艾伦、道格拉斯·盖尔著,2002:《比较金融系统》,北京:中国人民大学出版社。
    [42](美)刘易斯·卡布罗著,2002:《产业组织导论》,北京:人民邮电出版社。
    [43](美)唐E·沃德曼、伊丽莎白J·詹森著,李宝伟,武立东,张云译,2009:《产业组织理论与实践》,北京:机械工业出版社。
    [44]钱小安,2000:《加入WTO对中国银行业和金融调控的影响及对策》,《金融研究》第2期。
    [45]秦宛顺、欧阳俊,2001:《中国商业银行业市场结构、效率和绩效》,《经济科学》第4期。
    [46]邱兆祥,粟勤,2008:《信息不对称条件下银行业市场结构与市场竞争研究综述》,《金融研究》第8期。
    [47]石奇主编,2008:《产业经济学》,北京:中国人民大学出版社。
    [48]史青青、费方域,2010:《中国信贷市场存在过度供给吗》,《财经研究》第7期。
    [49]史忠良主编,2007:《新编产业经济学》,北京:中国社会科学出版社。
    [50]盛松成、童士清,2007:《商业银行存贷利差:扩大还是缩小》,《金融研究》第11期。
    [51]宋慧英,2012:《中国商业银行竞争行为的实证研究》,《暨南学报》第1期。
    [52]宋剑斌、吴涛,1997:《我国商业银行存贷款利率决定行为及利率自由化的过渡选择》,《国际金融研究》第5期。
    [53]苏东水主编,2005:《产业经济学》,北京:高等教育出版社。
    [54]孙健、戚逸颖,2006,《国民待遇后外资银行竞争优势及对策》,《农村金融研究》第12期。
    [55]谭政勋、王聪,2007:《商业银行贷款竞争行为的比较研究——基于人力成本差异的分析》,《山西财经大学学报》第4期。
    [56]陶士贵,2002:《外资银行争夺优质客户的策略分析》,《经济与管理》第11期。
    [57]王聪著,2011:《中国证券业的交易成本制度研究——关于证券业的SCP分析框架》,北京:中国社会科学出版社。
    [58]王聪、宋慧英,2010:《我国证券市场集中度研究》,《南方金融》第8期。
    [59]王聪、宋慧英,2011:《市场结构、股权结构与证券公司成本效率——基于PR模型的静态、动态考察》,《投资研究》第11期。
    [60]王聪、宋慧英,2012:《中国证券公司市场结构与绩效的实证分析》,《经济经纬》第1期。
    [61]王聪、宋慧英,2012:《中国证券公司股权结构、市场结构与成本效率的实证研究》,《金融研究》第5期。
    [62]王聪、宋慧英,2012:《外资银行进入对中国商业银行竞争行为影响的实证研究》,《南方经济》。
    [63]王佳佳著,2007:《发展中国家的外资银行:竞争、效率与稳定》,北京:人民出版社。
    [64]王馨,2006:《中国银行业竞争效率分析》,《金融研究》第12期。
    [65]王勇,张艳和童菲,2006:《我国商业银行非利息业务困境与对策》,《金融研究》第10期。
    [66]魏鹏,2008:《我国上市银行中间业务收入发展现状——基于10家上市银行2006-2007年年报数据》,《财经科学》第9期。
    [67]武捷思,1996:《中国国有商业银行行为研究》,北京:中国金融出版社。
    [68]吴喜雁,2010:《我国网上银行发展分析》,《改革与战略》第2期。
    [69]厦门银监局课题组,2004:《银行牌照管理研究——兼谈我国银行市场准入的政策建议》,《金融研究》第8期。
    [70]谢康,2001:《中国进入WTO后对网上银行的挑战与对策研究》,《金融研究》第5期。
    [71]谢雨白,2004:《外资银行进入与我国银行业市场结构变动趋势分析》,《上海金融》第10期。
    [72]许学军,2010:《商业银行中小企业贷款业务》,上海:上海财经大学出版社。
    [73]徐忠、沈艳、王小康、沈明高,2009:《市场结构与我国银行业绩效:假说与检验》,《经济研究》第10期。
    [74]杨德勇,2004:《金融产业组织理论研究》,北京:中国金融出版社。
    [75]杨浩,2003:《外资银行在华扩张的方式及策略选择》,《世界经济研究》第2期。
    [76]杨华,2000:《中、外银行核心业务、核心竞争力对比》,《国际商务研究》第5期。
    [77]杨公朴、夏大慰主编,2005:《现代产业经济学》,上海:上海财经大学出版社。
    [78]杨如彦,2007:《中国金融工具创新报告(2007)》,北京:中国金融出版社。
    [79]叶欣,2006:《外资银行进入对中国银行业效率影响的实证研究》,《财经问题研究》第2期。
    [80]叶欣、冯宗宪,2003:《外资银行进入对本国银行体系稳定性影响的实证研究》,《经济科学》第2期。
    [81]叶欣、郭建伟和冯宗宪,2001:《垄断到竞争:中国商业银行市场结构的变迁》,《金融研究》第11期。
    [82]殷孟波、石琴,2009:《金融业全面开放对我国银行业竞争度的影响——基于Panzar-Rosse模型的实证研究》,《财贸经济》第11期。
    [83]殷孟波、石琴和梁丹,2009:《银行业竞争测度模型评述——基于非结构分析视角》,《金融研究》第7期。
    [84]尹毅飞,2004:《论国有商业银行治理机制的改革:以中间业务为例》,《金融研究》第12期。
    [85]于良春、鞠源,1999:《垄断与竞争:中国银行业的改革和发展》,《经济研究》第8期。
    [86]于文涛、郝玉龙,2005:《外资银行进入对我国银行业的影响分析》,《宏观经济管理》第8期。
    [87]苑素静,2005:《韩国金融危机中银行特许权价值的实证分析》,《现代财经》第12期。
    [88]臧旭恒、徐向艺和杨蕙馨主编,2005:《产业经济学》,北京:经济科学出版社。
    [89]张国海、高怿,2003:《商业银行中间业务的国际比较与发展战略》,《金融研究》第2期。
    [90]张红军著,2009,《外资银行:进入与监管——理论及基于中国市场的实证》,北京:社会科学文献出版社。
    [91]张杰,1998:《中国金融制度的结构与变迁》,山西:山西经济出版社。
    [92]张捷,2003:《结构转换期的中小企业金融研究》,北京:经济科学出版社。
    [93]张金清、吴有红,2010:《外资银行进入水平影响商业银行效率的“阙值效应”分析——来自中国商业银行的经验证据》,《金融研究》第6期。
    [94]赵旭,2008:《国有商业银行市场势力及其福利损失估计》,《当代财经》第7期。
    [95]赵旭、蒋振声、周军民,2001:《中国银行业市场结构与绩效实证研究》,《金融研究》第3期。
    [96]赵子铱、彭琦和邹康,2005:《我国银行业市场竞争结构分析——基于Panzar-Rosse范式的考察》,《统计研究》第6期。
    [97]郑荣年,牛慕鸿,2007:《中国银行业非利息业务与银行特征关系研究》,《金融研究》第9期。
    [98]邹新月,2005:《商业银行信贷风险统计与纳什均衡策略》,北京:中国经济出版社。
    [99]中国工商银行城市金融研究所课题组,2009:《我国境内商业银行信贷利差变化及对策研究》,《金融论坛》第3期。
    [100]中国人民银行怀化分行课题组,1998:《存款人的金融风险意识与银行业的退出制度》,《金融经济》第9期。
    [101]《中华人民共和国外资银行管理条例》,中华人民共和国国务院令(第478号)。
    [102]《中华人民共和国商业银行法》,中华人民共和国主席令(第十三号)。
    [103]中国银行国家金融研究所课题组,2003:《外资银行在中国:业务竞争状况及其发展趋势》,《中国金融》第4期。
    [104]周好文,王菁,2008:《我国商业银行收入波动性的方差分解》,《经济问题探索》第10期。
    [105]周新生、郭戎,2000:《我国国有商业银行行为分析》,《当代经济科学》第5期。
    [106]周业安,1999:《金融抑制对中国企业融资能力影响的实证研究》,《经济研究》第2期。
    [107]邹薇,2007:《外资银行进入与中国银行体系的稳定性》,《求索》第2期。
    [108]宗良,2000:《加入WTO后国内银行面临的网上银行竞争及相应对策》,《国际金融研究》第8期。
    [109] Al-Muharrami, S., Matthews, K. and Khabari, Y.,2007,“Market Structure and Competitive Conditionsin the Arab GCC Banking System,”Journal of Banking&Finance30.
    [110] Angelini, P., Cetorelli, N.,2003,“The Effects of Regulatory Reform on Competition in the BankingIndustry,” Journal of Money, Credit and Banking35, pp.663-684.
    [111] Anthony N. Rezitis,2010,“Evaluating the State of Competition of the Greek Banking Industry,”Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions&Money20, pp.68-90.
    [112] Arellano, M., and Bond, S.,1991,“Some Tests of Specification for Panel Data: Monte Carlo Evidenceand an Application to Employment Equations,” Review of Economic Studies58, pp.277-297.
    [113] Arellano, M., and O. Bover,1995,“Another Look at the Instrumental Variables Estimation of ErrorComponent Models,” Journal of Econometrics68, pp.29-51.
    [114] Barajas A.,N. Salazar,and R. Steiner,2000,“Foreign Investment in Columbia’s Financial Sector. in:S.Claessens and M.Jansen(eds). The Intenationalization of Financial Services:Issues and Lessons forDeveloping Countries,” Kluwer Academic Press,Dordrecht and Boston.
    [115] Baumol,W. J.,Panzar J. C. and R. D. Willig.,1982,“Contestable Markets and the Theory of IndustryStructure,” Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
    [116] Belaisch,A. J.,2003,Do Brazilian Banks Compete? International Monetary Fund, Working Paper03/113.
    [117] Berger,A. and T.H. Hannan,1989,“The Price-Concentration Relationship in Banking,” Review ofEconomics and Statistics71,pp.291-299.
    [118] Berger, A.,1995,“The Profit-Structure Relationship in Banking Tests of Market-Power andEfficient-Structure Hypotheses,” Journal of Money,Credit and Banking27,pp.404-431.
    [119] Berger, A.N., Bonime, S.D., Covitz, D.M., and Hancock, D.,2000,“Why are Bank Profits so Persistent?The Roles of Product Market Competition, Information Opacity and Regional Macroeconomic Shocks,”Journal of Banking and Finance24, pp.1203-1235.
    [120] Bikker,J.A.,and Groeneveld,J.M.,1998,“Competition and Concentration in the EU Banking Industry.De Nederlandsche Bank,” Research Series Supervision8.
    [121] Bikker, J. A., and Groeneveld, J. M.,2000,“Competition and Concentration in the EU BankingIndustry,” Kredit and Kapital33, pp.62-98.
    [122] Bikker,J.A.,and Haaf,K.,2000,Competition,Concentration and Their Relationship:An EmpiricalAnalysis of the Banking Industry. Financial Structure,Bank Behavior and Monetary Policy in the EMUConference,October5-6,Groningen.
    [123] Bikker,J. A. and Haaf,K.,2000,Measures of Competition and Concentration in the Banking Industry:A Review of the Literature. September,De Nederlandsche Bank,Research Series Supervision27.
    [124] Bikker, J.A., and Haaf, K.,2002,“Competition, Concentration and Their Relationship: As EmpiricalAnalysis of the Banking Industry,” Journal of Money, Credit and Banking35, pp.2191-2214.
    [125] Bikker,J. A.,2003,“Testing for Imperfect Competition on EU Deposit and Loan Markets withBresnahan's Market Power Model,” Credit and Capital36,pp.167-212.
    [126] Blaug, M.,1980, The Methodology of Economics. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.
    [127] Blundell, R., and S. Bond,1998,“Initial Conditions and Moment Restrictions in Dynamic Panel DataModels,” Journal of Econometrics87, pp.115-143.
    [128] Bond, Stephen Roy&Hoeffler, Anke&Temple, Jonathan,2001, GMM Estimation of EmpiricalGrowth Models. CEPR Discussion Papers.
    [129] Bresnahan,T.,1982,“The Oligopoly Solution Concept is Identified,” Economics Letters10,pp.87-92.
    [130] Bresnahan,T.,1989,“Empirical Studies in Industries With Market Power,” Handbook of IndustrialOrganization2,pp.1011-1058.
    [131] Brozen, Y.,1971,“Bain’s Concentration and Rates of Return Revisited,” Journal of Law and Economics13, pp.279-292.
    [132] Canhoto, A.,2004,“Portuguese Banking: a Structural Model of Competition in the Deposits Market,”Review of Financial Economics13, pp.41-63.
    [133] Casu, B., and C., Girardone,2006,“Bank Competition, Concentration and Efficiency in the SingleEuropean Market,” The Manchester School, pp.441-468.
    [134] Cho.K.R.,1990,“Foreign Banking Presence and Banking Market Concentration:The Case ofIndonesia,” The Journal of Development Studies27,pp.98-100.
    [135] Claessens,S.,A. Demirgu,c-Kunt,and H. Huizinga,2001,“How Does Foreign Entry Affect DomesticBanking Markets,” Journal of Banking and Finance25,pp.891-911.
    [136] Claessens,S.,and L. Laeven,2003,“What Drives Bank Competition? Some International Evidence,”Journal of Money,Credit and Banking36,pp.563-583.
    [137] Claessens, S., and Laeven, L.,2004,“What Drives Bank Competition? Some International Evidence,”Journal of Money Credit, and Banking36, pp.563-583.
    [138] Claessens,S.,and Laeven,L.,2005, Financial Dependence,Banking Sector Competition,andEconomic Growth. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper3481,January.
    [139] Clarke,G.,R.Cull,L. D’Amato,and A. Molinari,2000,On the kindness of strangers? The Impactof Foreign Entry on Domestic Banks in Argentina. In:Claessens,S.,Jansen,M.(eds). TheIntenationalization of Financial Services:Issues and Lessons for Developing Countries,KluwerAcademic Press,Boston.
    [140] Coccorese, P.,1998,“Assessing the Competitive Conditions in the Italian Banking System: SomeEmpirical Evidence,” BNL Quarterly Review205.
    [141] Coccorese, P.,2004,“Banking Competition and Macroeconomic Conditions: A Disaggregates Analysis,”Journal of International Financial Markets,Institutions and Money14.
    [142] Dages,B.G.,L.Goldberg,and D.Kinney,2000,Foreign and Domestic Bank Participation in EmergingMarkets:Lessons from Mexico and Argentina,Federal Reserve Bank of New York Economic PolicyReview6,pp.17-36.
    [143] Damien Neven, Lars-Hendrik Roller,1999,“An Aggregate Structural Model of Competition in theEuropean Banking Industry,” International Journal of Industrial Organization17, pp.1059–1074.
    [144] De Bandt, Olivier, Jacquinot, Pascal,1992,“The Financing of Corporate Firms in France: anEconometric Model,” Economic Modelling9, pp.253-269.
    [145] De Bandt, Jacques,1996,“Business Services: Markets and Transactions,” Reviews of IndustrialOrganization11.
    [146] De Bandt,O.and Davis P.,2000,“Competition,Contestability and Market Structure in EuropeanBanking Sectors on the Eve of EMU,” Journal of Banking and Finance24,pp.1045-1066.
    [147] Delis, Manthos D., Staikouras, Christos, Varlagas, Panagiotis,2008,“On the Measurement of MarketPower in the Banking Industry,” MPRA Paper14038, University Library of Munich, Germany.
    [148] Demsetz,H.,1973,“Industry Structure,Market Rivaliy and Public Policy,” Journal of Law andEconomics l6,pp.1-9.
    [149] Denizer,C.,2000,Foreign Bank Entry in Turkey’s Banking Sector,1980-1997. in:S. Claessens andM. Jansen(eds),The Internationalization of Financial Services:Issues and Lessons for DevelopingCountries,Boston,Kluwer Academic.
    [150] Evanoff D. D. and D. L. Fortier,1988,“Re-evaluation of the Structure-Conduct-Performance Paradigmin Banking,” Journal of Financial Services Researeh l,pp.277-294.
    [151] Freixas,X.,and J. C. Roche.,1977, Microeconomics of Banking. Cambridge. London,England:TheMIT Press.
    [152] Garcia-Herrero A,Gavila S,Santabarbaraz D.2006,“China’s Banking Reform:an Assessment of itsEvolution and Possible Impact,” Economic Studies52, pp.304-363.
    [153] Gelos,R.G. and J. Roldos,2002,“Consolidation and Market Structure in Emerging Market BankingSystems,” IMF Working Papers2,186-203.
    [154] Gischer and Horst,1995,“The Price-Concentration Relationship in Banking,” Review of Economicsand Statistics74.
    [155] Goddard, J., Molyneux, P., and Wilson, J.O.S.,2004a,“Dynamics of Growth and Profitability inBanking,” Journal of Money, Credit and Banking36, pp.1069-1090.
    [156] Goldberg,L.,and A. Saunders,1981,“Determinants of Foreign Banking Activity in the US,” Journal ofBanking and Finance5,pp.678-684.
    [157] Gray,J. M. and H.P. Gray,1981,“The Multinational Bank:a Financial MNC?” Journal of Banking andFinance5,pp.33-63.
    [158] Haber S.2005,“Mexico’s Experiments with Bank Privatization and Liberalization:1991-2003,” Journalof Banking&Finance29,pp.2325-2353.
    [159] Haber,S. and A. Musacchio,2005,Contract Rights and Risk Aversion:Foreign Banks and the MexicanEconomy,1997-2000. Stanford University,Mimeo.
    [160] Hall, R.E.,1988,“The Relation between Price and Marginal Cost in U.S. Industry,” Journal of PoliticalEconomy96(51), pp.921–947.
    [161] Hannan,T.H.,1997,“Market Share Inequality,the Number of Competitors and the HHI,anExamination of Bank Pricing,” Review of Industrial Organization12,pp.23-35.
    [162] Hempell,H.S.2002,Testing for Competition Among German Banks. Economic Research Centre,Deutsche Bundesbank Discussion Paper04/02.
    [163] Hermes. N.,and R. Lensink,2002,The Impact of Foreign Bank Entry on Domestic Banks in LDCs,an Econometric Analysis. in T. Kowalski, R. Lensink and V. Vensel,(eds.),Foreign Banks andEconomic Transition,Poznan University Press,Poznan.
    [164] Hindriks, F.A.,1999,“Non-competitive Rents in Dutch Manufacturing: Conduct and Performance in theNew Empirical Industrial Organization,” EIM Research Report9905/E.
    [165] Hondroyiannis,G.,Lolos,S. and Papapetrou,E.1999,“Assessing Competitive Conditions in the GreekBanking System,” Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money9,pp.377-391.
    [166] Iwata,1974,“Measurement of Conjectural Variations in Oligopoly,”Econometrica42,(5).
    [167] Janek UibouPin,2005,Short-term Effects of Foreign Bank Entry on Bank Performance in Selected CEECountries. Bank of Estonia working Papers4.
    [168] John Goddard, and John O.S. Wilson,2009,“Competition in Banking: A Disequilibrium Approach,”Journal of Banking&Finance33, pp.2282-2292.
    [169] Kent Matthews, Victor Murinde and Tianshu Zhao,2007,“Competitive Conditions among the MajorBritish Banks,” Journal of Banking and Finance31.
    [170] Koji Kubo,2006,“The Degree of Competition in the Thai Banking Industry before and after the EastAsian Crisis”, IDE Discussion Papers56, Institute of Developing Economies, Japan External TradeOrganization.
    [171] Koutsomanoli-Fillipaki, N., and Staikouras, C.,2005,“Competition and Concentration in the NewBanking Landscape,” Department of Accounting and Finance, Athens University of Economics andBusiness.
    [172] Lau,L.,1982,“On Identifying the Degree of Competitiveness from Industry Price and Output Data,”Economics Letters10,pp.93-99.
    [173] Leece, D.,1995,“Rationing, mortgage demand and the impact of financial deregulation,” OxfordBulletin of Economics and Statistics57, pp.43-66.
    [174] Leigh L,Podpiera R.2006. The Rise of Foreign Investment in China’s Banks-Taking Stock. IMFWorking Paper.
    [175] Levy Yeyati,E. and A. Micco,2007,“Concentration and Foreign Penetration in Latin AmericanBanking Section:Impact on Competition and Risk,” Journal of Banking and Finance31,pp.1633-1647.
    [176] Lindenberg,E. B. and Ross,S.A.,1981,“Tobin’s q Ratio and Industrial Organization,” Journal ofBusiness54,pp.1-32.
    [177] Lloyd-Williams, D. M.&Molyneux, Phil&Thornton, John.,1991,“Market Structure and Performancein Spanish Banking,” Journal of Banking&Finance18.
    [178] Luc,L.and Stijn,C.,2003,What Drives Bank Competition?Some International Evidence. World BankPolicy Reworking Paper3113.
    [179] Mamatzakis, E., Staikouras, C. and Koutsomanoli-Fillipaki, N.,2005,“Competition and Concentration inthe Banking Sector of the South Eastern European Region,” Journal of Emerging Market Review6.
    [180] María Pía Olivero, Yuan Li, and Bang Nam Jeon,2011,“Competition in Banking and the LendingChannel: Evidence from Bank-level Data in Asia and Latin America,” Journal of Banking&Finance35,pp.560-571.
    [181] Martins, J.O., Scarpetta, S., Pilat, D.,1996,“Mark-Up Ratios in Manufacturing Industries,” OECDEconomics Department, Working Papers No.162.
    [182] Martinez Peria M. S.,and A. Mady,2004,How Foreign Participation and Market Concentration ImpactBank Spreads:Evidence fmm Iatin America. Policy Research Working Papers Series3210,WorldBank,Washington,D. C.,United States,February.
    [183] Mathieson D. and Roldos J.,2000,The Role of Foreign Banks in Emerging Markets. Paper presented atthe3rd Annual World Bank,IMF and Brookings Financial Markets and Development Conference,NewYork,April2001,Published In:International Capital Markets:Developments,Prospects and Key PolicyIssues,IMF,Washington,D. C,United States,Chapter VI:152-182.
    [184] Molyneux,P., Lloyd-Williams D.M. and J. Thornton,1994,“Competitive Conditions in EuropeanBanking,” Journal of Banking and Finance18,pp.445-459.
    [185] Molyneux, P., Thornton, J., and Lloyd-Williams, D. M.,1996,“Competition and Market Contestabilityin Japanese Commercial Banking,” Journal of Economics and Business48, pp.33-45.
    [186] Nathan,A. and Neave,E.H.,1989,“Competition and Contestability in Canada’s Financial System:Empirical Results,” Canadian Journal of Economics22, pp.576-594.
    [187] Never.R.,1990,“Competition in the Japanese Banking Industry,” Journal of Banking&Finance33.
    [188] Northcott,C. A.,2004,Competition in Banking:A Review of the Literature. Bank of Canada Workingpaper.
    [189] Panzar,J.C. and Rosse,J.N.,1977,Chamberlin vs. Robinson:An Empirieal Test for Monopoly Rents.Bell Laboratories Eeonomic,Discussion Papers90.
    [190] Panzar,J.C. and Rosse,J.N.,1982,Structure,Conduct and Comparative Statistics. Bell LaboratoriesEconomic,Discussion Papers248.
    [191] Panzar, J.C. and Rosse, J.N.,1987,“Testing for Monopoly Equilibrium,” Journal of IndustrialEconomic25,pp.443-456.
    [192] Peltzman,S.,1977,“The Gains and Losses From Industrial Concentration,” National Bureau ofEconomic Research Working Papers20,pp.229-263.
    [193] Podpiera R.2006. Progress in China’s Banking Sector Reform:Has Bank Behavior Changed. IMFWorking Paper.
    [194] Rezitis, Anthony N.,2010,“Evaluating the State of Competition of the Greek Banking Industry,”Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money20, pp.68-90.
    [195] Ribon, S., O. Yosha,1999,“Financial liberalisation and Competition in Banking:an EmpiricalInvestigation,” Working Paper.
    [196] Rime, B.,1999,“Measure Degree Concurrence Duns le System Banc ire Suisse Model of Panzar andRosse Revue Suisse,” Economic Politic Statistic135.
    [197] Robert Lensink,Niels Hermes,2004,“The Short-term Effects of Foreign Bank Entry on Domestic BankBehaviour:Does Economic Development Matter?” Journal of Banking&Finance28,pp.553-568.
    [198] Roeger,W.,1995,“Can Imperfect Competition Explain the Difference between Primal and dualProductivity Measures? Estimates fro U.S. Manufacturing,” Journal of Political Economy103(2), pp.316–331.
    [199] Schulz,H.,2006,“Foreign Banka in Mexico:New Conquistadors or Agents of Change?”The WhartonSchool,Financial Institutions Center,Working Paper,University of Pennsylvania.
    [200] Schumpeter, J.A.,1954, History of Economic Analysis. George Allen and Unwin, London.
    [201] Sengupta,R.,2006,Foreign entry and bank competition. Working paper,SSRN.
    [202] Shaffer,S.,1982,“Competition Conduct and Demand Elasticity,” Economic Letters10,pp.167-171.
    [203] Shaffer, S.,1982,“Anonstructural Test for Competition in Financial Markets. In:Proceedings of aConference on Bank Structure and Competition,” Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, pp.225-243.
    [204] Shaffer,S.,1983,“The Rosse-Panzar Statistic and the Lerner Index in the Short Run,” Economic Letters11, pp.175-178.
    [205] Shaffer,S.,1989,“Competition in the US Banking Industry,” Economics Letters29, pp.321-323.
    [206] Shaffer,S.,1993,“A Test of Competition in Canadian Banking,” Journal of Money,Credit and Banking25, pp.49-61.
    [207] Shaffer,S. and DiSalvo,J.,1994,“Conduct in a Banking Duopoly,” Journal of Banking and Finance18,pp.1063-1082.
    [208] Shaffer, S.,2004,“Patterns of Competition in Banking,” Journal of Economics and Business56, pp.287-313.
    [209] Smirlock M.,1958,“Evidence on the (Non) Relationship Between Concentration and Profitability,”Journal of Money,Credit and Banking17,pp.69-83.
    [210] Smirlock,M.,1984,“Tobin’s q and the Structure Performance Relationship,” American EconomicReview74,pp.1051-1060.
    [211] Steen, F., K.G. Salvanes,1999,“Testing for Market Power Using a Dynamic Oligopoly Model,”International Journal of Industrial Organisation17, pp.147-177.
    [212] Stiglitz,J. E.,1993,“The Role of the State in Financial Market,” Proceeding of the World Bank AnnualConference on Development Economics101,pp.299-326.
    [213] Stijn Claessens, and Luc Laeven,2003,“What Drives Bank Competition? Some InternationalEvidence,” Journal of Money, Credit and Banking36, pp.563-583.
    [214] Stiroh, K., and Strahan, P.E.,2003,“Competitive Dynamics of Deregulation: Evidence for US Banking,”Journal of Money, Credit and Banking35, pp.801-828.
    [215] Suominen, M.,1994,“Measuring Competition in Banking: a two-product Model,” Scandinavian Journalof Economics96, pp.95-110.
    [216] Swank, J.,1995,“Oligopoly in Loan and Deposit Markets: an Econometric Application to theNetherlands,” De Economist143, pp.353-366.
    [217] Toolsema, L.A.,2002,“Competition in the Dutch consumer credit market,” Journal of Banking andFinance26, pp.2215-2229.
    [218] Uchida, H. and Tsutsui, Y.,2005,“Has Competition in the Japanese Banking Sector Improved?” Journalof Banking and Finance29, pp.419-439.
    [219] Unite,A.,and M. J. Sullivan,2003,“The Effect of Foreign Entry and Ownership Structure on thePhilippine Domestic Banking Sector,” Journal of Banking and Finance27,pp.2323-2345.
    [220] Vesala,1995,“Testing for Competition in Banking: Behavioral Evidence from Finland,” Bank ofFinland Studies.
    [221] Wilhelmsson, F.,2006,“Market Power and European Competition in the Swedish Food Industry,”Journal of Agricultural&Food Industrial Organization4, Article7.
    [222] Winker, Peter.,1994,“A Macroeconometric Disequilibrium Analysis of Current and Future Migrationfrom Eastern Europe into West Germany,” Journal of Population Economics7.
    [223] Yildirim, S. and Philippatos, C.,2002, Competition and Contestability in Central and Eastern EuropeanBanking Mmarkets. FMA International Annual Meeting, Dublin:Ireland.
    [224] Yildirim,H. S,and G. C. Philippatos,2007,“Restructuring,Consolidation and Competition in LatinAmerican Banking Markets,” Journal of Banking and Finance31,pp.629-639.
    [225] Zardkoohi, A., D.R. Fraser,1998,“Geographical Deregulation and Competition is US BankingMarkets,” The Financial Review33,pp.85-98.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700