高等农业教育教材建设效率评价及优化研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
现代农业是以科技为依托、技术密集型的农业,现代农业的发展过程,实质上是先进科学技术在农业领域广泛应用的过程,是依赖不断发展的新技术投入,用现代科技改造传统农业的过程。“农业与农村社会发展”是我国现阶段的重大战略问题,为农业与农村发展输送专门人才、产出重大科研成果并提供服务是高等农业教育的中心任务,而教材建设是发展农业教育的重要环节。大力发展高等农业教育,培养和造就适应社会需要的高科技人才,必须重视高等农业教育的教材建设与改革。本研究选择了“高等农业教育教材建设效率评价及优化研究”这一课题作为研究对象,着力从宏观的高等农业教育教材建设体系设计和微观的院校教材建设体制建立、机制创新等方面,集成对高等农业教育教材建设的相关问题研究。
     前人对教材建设的研究绝大多数是对一般教材的内涵建设和建设管理等方面的普遍性规律进行探讨,针对高等农业教育教材方面的研究成果甚显不足。基于此,本论文的研究旨在丰富我国高等农业教育的教材建设理论,探究形成一套体现农业教育自身特点的教材建设实践应用成果体系。通过发挥教材建设在人才培养中的基础性作用,为培养高素质的农业科技人才服务。
     论文首先对高等农业院校教材的有关理论进行了定性分析。同时,通过对高等农业教育教材建设发展历程的回顾,梳理、总结、分析了不同时期高等农业教育教材建设的成绩、经验、创新与不足。随后文章系统分析了高校农业教育教材建设的现状,分析结果指出,高等农业教育的教材建设仍存在一些突出问题。论文进一步研究认为,这些问题出现的根本原因集中体现在教材建设的评价方法和教材自身建设这两个要素上。由此论文开展了两方面的研究与写作,一是对教材质量评价指标体系进行了优化;二是运用经济学的资源配置理论和实证方法,实证检验了教材建设状况对学校教育效率的重要作用,现状实证分析结果和教材建设相关理论为解决存在问题指明了研究路径。论文最后从宏观的高等农业教育教材建设体系设计和微观的学校教材建设体制建立、机制创新等方面提出了建议。
     本论文研究过程分别应用了书斋式研究、问卷法、比较法、实测法、系统分析法、哲学分析法,以及经济学的资源配置理论和实证分析等研究方法。注重书斋式研究与现场研究结合,理论研究与实证分析并举,定性研究与定量研究结合,宏观研究与中观、微观研究协作,纵向研究与横向研究配合进行了论文的研究与写作。
     论文首先在梳理国内外教材建设研究和自身理论的基础上,对高等农业院校教材建设的基本概念及历史演进状况进行了定性分析。其次,完整地回顾、介绍了新中国成立以来我国高等农业教育教材建设的历程。第三,文章整理分析了高等农业教育教材建设的现状,分析形成了影响高等农业教育教材建设的要素。第四,重新优化构建了高等农业教育教材质量评价指标体系;第五,通过经济学方法,使用建立在优化后教材质量评价指标体系基础上对教材现状进行调查中得出的相关数据,采用Tobit回归方法,实证检验了高校资源配置效率的影响因素。同时,分析形成了问题解决的针对性措施。文章的最后就教材建设中存在的突出问题,通过分析研究分别给出了问题解决方法。
     本论文可能具备的创新点集中体现在以下四个方面:第一,首次提出将高等农业教育教材建设的历程分为五个时期,填补了国内该方面研究的空白。在回顾历程的基础上,梳理、总结、分析了不同时期高等农业教育教材建设的成绩、经验、创新与不足,为今后高等农业教育的教材建设和科学研究形成了重要的可借鉴资源。第二,论文对原有教材质量评价指标体系进行了较为全面、系统的优化,使其维度界定更加清晰,内涵更加明确,操作性更强。第三,论文应用经济学实证分析方法,在该研究领域首次分析计算了包括教材建设在内的高等农业院校本科教育阶段的资源配置效率。文章第一次将教材建设作为其中的一项解释变量,实证检验了影响高等农业院校资源配置效率的因素。第四,就今后一个时期高等农业教育教材建设的管理、编写、出版、选用机制和开展教材质量评价的方法等方面进行了多维度的理论研究和实践探索,形成了一整套理论支持充分、实践基础可靠;理念先进、操作性强、针对性好;科学、系统、较为完整的教材建设体系设计与机制建立、体制创新建议。
Modern agriculture is technology-dependent and technology-intensive in nature. The process of development for modern agriculture is in essence one of wide-spread application of advanced technology in the field of agriculture as well as one of transforming agriculture with modern technology with the continuous development of new technological inputs. The development of agriculture and agricultural society is an important strategical issue, and it is the central task of agricultural higher education to deliver talents for agricultural development, to end up with significant academic achievement and to provide service. That makes material development the major tache of the improvement of agriculture education. The great value of material development and reformation is vital to striving to develop agricultural higher education and cultivating high-caliber innovative talents specialized in agricultural technology. In light of this, this dissertation selected the topic of“A Research into the Optimization and Efficiency Evaluation of Development of teaching Materials for Agricultural Higher Education”as the object of research, striving to integrate relevant issues on the development of agricultural higher education into a whole with special emphasis on the establishment of the system of teaching materials for agricultural higher education on the macro-level and such aspects as the teaching material development mechanisms and institutional choices for the institutions of higher learning on the micro-level.
     The previous studies were mainly discussing the universal rules about the contents development and management of regular material, and there is not enough research in agricultural higher education. Based on that, the dissertation endeavor to enrich the theoretical basis for agricultural higher education in China, to explore and form a material development practical application results system which reflects its own characteristics of agricultural education. By giving full play to the foundation station of material development in cultivation of talents, we concentrate on cultivating High-caliber talents.
     The dissertation begins with a qualitative analysis of the basic concepts and historical evolution of the development of teaching materials for agricultural higher education. At the same time, On the basis of historical retrospect, the dissertation sorts out, summarizes and analyzes the accomplishments, experiences, innovation and drawbacks in the field of teaching material development in different phases. Following that, the dissertation analyses the current situation of the teaching material development for agricultural higher education, with the view that there are still some outstanding problems in this field.
     The author believes the underlying reason for such problems lies in two aspects: the evaluation method for the development of teaching materials as well as the self-improvement of teaching materials. The dissertation researchs and writes from two aspects: the first is to optimize the system of teaching material quality evaluation, and the second is to employ economic theories of resource allocation and empirical methods to prove the extremely important role of the situation of teaching material development plays in the efficiency of education, and the empirical analysis results of the dissertation and the relevant theories of teaching material development point out the paths of research for the existing problems. At last, the dissertation offer suggestions about the establishment of the system of teaching materials for agricultural higher education on the macro-level and such aspects as the teaching material development mechanisms and institutional choices for the institutions of higher learning on the micro-level.
     Applying study research method, questionnaire method, comparison method, measurement method, systematically analysis method, philosophical analysis method, and the economic theories of resource allocation and empirical methods. The author combines study research and field research, develops theoretical research and empirical research simultaneously, intergrates qualitative research and quantitative research, collaborates macro research, medium research and micro research, coordinates longitudinal research and cross-sectional research during the research procedure.
     On the basis of sorting out the past researches and theories on the development of teaching materials for agricultural higher education domestically and internationally, the dissertation begins with a qualitative analysis of the basic concepts and historical evolution of the development of teaching materials for agricultural higher education. It then fully recalls and introduced the history of the development of teaching materials for agricultural higher education since the founding of the People’s Republic. Thirdly, the dissertation analyses the current situation of the teaching material development for agricultural higher education, analysing the factors affecting the material development in agricultural higher education. Fourthly, the dissertation optimizes and rebuilds a whole system of quality evaluation indicators for teaching materials for agricultural higher education in close combination with the objectives for cultivating talents and the relevant educational evaluation theories for agricultural higher education in China. Fifthly, the dissertation employs economic theories, and then uses the relevant data from the current situation surveys built on the basis of the emerging system of teaching material quality evaluation indicators to verify empirically the factors affecting the efficiency of resource allocation in the institutions of higher learning by adopting the Tobit regression method. Meanwhile, it finalizes targeted measures by analysing the problems. Lastly, the dissertation proposes solutions to the outstanding problems in material development.
     The possible innovations are: first, the dissertation states for the first time to divide the process of agricultural higher education into five stages, filling the gap in this field in China. On the basis of historical retrospect, the dissertation sorts out, summarizes and analyzes the accomplishments, experiences, innovation and drawbacks in the field of teaching material development in different phases, leaving important referrence for future material development and scientific research of agricultural higher education. Second, the dissertation optimizes the system of teaching material quality evaluation roundly and systematically, making the dimension definition clearer, clarifying the connotation, and strengthening in the operability. Third, the dissertation analyses and calculates the resource allocation efficiency of agricultural institution college including the material development, using the economic empirical analysis for the first time. For the first time, the dissertation takes the material development as one of the explanatory variables, verifying empirically the factors affecting the efficiency of resource allocation in the institutions of higher learning. Fourth, about the management, formulation, publishing and selecting mechanisms for teaching materials development, the dissertation proceed a dimensional theoretical study and practical exploration, forming a whole suggestion system of theory-supportive, practice-basic, advanced-idea, operable, targeted, scientific, systematic, complete material development system design, establishment of mechanisms and mechanisms innovation.
引文
白光义.1991.浅谈高等学校教材和教材管理工作任务.清华大学教育研究,1:38~44
    边春光.1992.出版词典.上海辞书出版社
    陈伟.2006.关于高等教育教材建设的思考.1:106~107
    陈祖福.1999.半世艰辛探索百花园精品争艳——高教教材50年回眸.中国高等教育,21:28~31大学院公报,第1年第7期
    丁明珠,李顺兴.2001.试论高校教材质量保障体系的建设.漳州职业大学学报,1:59~61
    弗朗索瓦·魁奈.魁奈<经济表>及著作选.晏智杰译.2006.华夏出版社,213~217
    傅殷才,颜鹏飞.1995.自由经营还是国家干预——西方两大经济思想概论.经济科学出版社,54
    高凌庵.2002.基础教育教材评价.北京:人民教育出版社:23~28
    郭晓明.2004.试论教材的生态式设计.教育理论与实践,8:36~39
    郝云霞.2009.对当前教材建设存在问题的思考.出版发行研究,8:39~41
    贺乐凡,杨文荣.1998.现代教育原理.科学出版社:6
    华东六省一市教育学院.1984.教育学.浙江教育出版社
    欢喜隆司.1980.社会科教育的理论与发展.第一法规出版社:6
    黄显华,霍秉坤.2002.寻找课程论和教科书设计的理论基础.北京:人民教育出版社:122
    黄显华,霍秉坤.2002.寻找课程论和教科书设计的理论基础.人民教育出版社:81
    江雪松.2002.大学教材建设的国际化.江苏高教,3:109~111
    姜安丽.2005.中美《护理学基础》教材建设的比较研究. [硕士学位论文].第二军医大学:10
    姜安丽.2005.中美《护理学基础》教材建设的比较研究. [硕士学位论文].第二军医大学:11
    蒋丽音,易钟煌,白光义.1987.英国高等学校教材使用及编写出版情况介绍.中国大学教学,5:2~4,42
    柯积荣,张耀荣.2008.为高教改革和发展服务,构建大学出版价值观.高教探索,4
    夸美纽斯.大教学论.傅任敢译.1984.北京:人民教育出版社:255
    李海平.2004.高校教材建设中存在的问题及解决措施.北京教育(高教版)11:35~37
    李辉.2007.高等职业教育教材建设与指标体系研究[硕士学位论文]西北农林科技大学:7
    李辉.2007.高等职业教育教材建设与指标体系研究[硕士学位论文]西北农林科技大学:7
    李辉.2007.高等职业教育教材建设与指标体系研究[硕士学位论文]西北农林科技大学:8
    李辉.2007.高等职业教育教材建设与指标体系研究[硕士学位论文]西北农林科技大学:8
    李辉.2007.高等职业教育教材建设与指标体系研究[硕士学位论文]西北农林科技大学:8
    李辉.2007.高等职业教育教材建设与指标体系研究[硕士学位论文]西北农林科技大学:8
    李辉.2007.高等职业教育教材建设与指标体系研究[硕士学位论文]西北农林科技大学:42
    李辉.王鑫.彭立强.2010.高等农业院校本科阶段教育资源配置效率研究中国高教研究:63
    李辉.2010.创新人才培养中的教材建设途径中国高等教育:52
    李辉.2010.创新人才培养中的教材建设途径中国高等教育:52
    李辉.2010.创新人才培养中的教材建设途径中国高等教育:53
    李辉.2010.创新人才培养中的教材建设途径中国高等教育:53
    李辉.2010.创新人才培养中的教材建设途径中国高等教育:53
    李辉.吴博.2010.基于新一轮教材质量评价指标体系的评价工作实施研究中国大学教学:85
    李辉.吴博.2010.基于新一轮教材质量评价指标体系的评价工作实施研究中国大学教学:86
    李辉.2007.关于建立高职教材指标体系的对策研究.中国高等教育,1:150~154
    李辉.2009.坚持德育为先,创新航空科技人才思想品德教育培养模式.中国大学教学,4:89~92
    李辉.2003.立足创新、注重实践、建立高校教材建设管理新模式.中国大学教学,12:102~104
    李辉.2002.蓬勃发展的西北工业大学教材建设.中国大学教学,12:98~102
    李辉.2007b.我国高职教材建设现状与思考.中国大学教学,4:98~101
    李建春.2001a.高校教材质量问题浅议.广西民族学院学报,23(4):132~134
    李建春.2001b.浅谈衡量高校教材质量的标准.广西高教研究,6:111~113
    李进才.2003.更新教材机制推进教材建设.高等教育出版社:123
    李进才.2003.更新教材机制推进教材建设.高等教育出版社:227
    刘芳新.2002.教材将会给教师带来些什么.北京大学出版社:2
    刘贵友.2007.高等农林教育“面向21世纪课程教材”建设的思考.中国大学教学,2:92~94
    刘贵友.2007.高等农林教育“面向21世纪课程教材”建设的思考.中国大学教学,2:93
    刘兰芝.2002.高校教材管理理论与实践.黑龙江科学技术出版社:147
    刘兰芝.2002.高校教材管理理论与实践.黑龙江科学技术出版社:3~4
    刘志鹏.2007.富有远见意义重大——“面向21世纪课程教材”建设回顾.高等教育出版社:105~106
    楼才汀,张永军,楼毅.2004.教材管理机制必须适应高等教育改革需要].中国高等医学教育,3:20~21,36
    鲁洁.2003.回归生活——“品德与社会”课程与教材探寻.课程·教材·教法,9:2~9
    罗正华.1986.教育学.东北师范大学师范出版社:12
    毛达如.1995.中国普通高等农业学校要览.中国农业大学出版社:3
    农业部科技教育司.1999.中国农业教育50年回顾与展望.中国农业出版社:3
    任长松.2002.教材的逻辑顺序与心理顺序:泰勒的探索.http://www.pep.com.cJ/200212/ca8607.htm
    盛邵瀚,朱乔,吴广谋.1996.DEA理论、方法与应用].科学出版社:214~216
    苏开颜,邢美园.2002.国内外高等教育教材差异比较.出版发行研究,7:14~16
    谭焕忠.2002.论高等教育改革与高校教材建设.东北财经大学学报,4:86~88
    王颗.2007.高校教材建设的后现代思考.教育探索,3:16
    王丽云.2005.适应市场经济改革教材建设.新乡师范高等专科学校学报,5:149~150
    王毅.1997.高校教材建设改革的思路.石家庄经济学院学报,20(4):360~363
    吴雪萍.国际职业技术教育研究.杭州:浙江大学出版社
    伍吉云,刘小英.教材质量与高校教学改革的思考.卫生职业教育,24(9):8~9
    武贵景,黄会敏.高等农林院校教材建设与管理浅议.邯郸农业高等专科学校学报,18:45~46
    吴洪成, 1998.中国教育史研究·中国高校教材史,西南师范大学出版社,312
    夏征农.1979.辞海.上海辞书出版社
    保罗·萨缪尔森,威廉·诺德豪斯.微观经济学.第17版.萧琛译2004.人民邮电出版社:2
    徐金娥,周婷,张鸽盛.2006.从人才培养看我国高校教材建设.大学出版:60~63
    徐丽萍.2006.国外优秀大学教材特点浅析.科技与出版,2:71~72
    徐行,赵绥生.2003.关于构建教材成果评价体系的探索.西安航空技术高等专科学校学报,21(4): 17~20
    徐玉宝,张永军,于萍.2003.加强教材建设与管理刍议.中国大学教学,6:40~41
    许国彬,王文祥.2003.论高职教材建设.职教论坛,(24)
    亚当·斯密.2009.国富论(上).郭大力,王亚楠译.上海三联书店:4
    亚当·斯密.2009.国富论(上).郭大力,王亚楠译.上海三联书店:5
    亚当·斯密.1979.国民财富的性质和原因的研究(下卷).商务印书馆:27
    亚当·斯密.1979.国民财富的性质和原因的研究(下卷).商务印书馆:30
    杨丽华.1994.试论教材的选题.科技与出版,4:9~11
    杨鸣.2009.科学发展观与高校教材建设.理论界,4:125~126
    杨士谋,彭干梓,王金昌.1994.中国农业教育发展史略.北京农业大学出版杜:14~15
    杨士谋,彭干梓,王金昌.1994.中国农业教育发展史略.北京农业大学出版社:16~18,21~23
    叶澜.1991.新编教育学教程.华东师大出版社:10
    尹川蓉.2002.高等学校教材管理琐议.中国成人教育,7:44
    杨玲薛捷2008高等教育精品教材构成要素与编写规范研究首都经济贸易大学学报:118
    臧宏.2003.高等农业院校教材建设初探.农机化研究,1:247
    臧宏,张忠远,崔卫国.2004.加强农业院校教材管理提高教学质量.农机化研究,4:252~253
    曾天山.1997.教材论.江西教育出版社
    张焕庭.1985.中国大百科全书(教育卷).中国大百全科全书出版社:144
    张念宏.1988.教育学辞典.西南师大出版社:299
    张晓鹏.1986.列宁与高等学校教材建设[J].中国大学教学,4:1~3
    张燕镜.1992.教育学.北师大出版社:10
    赵志强.2005.高校立体化教材建设思考.北京印刷学院学报,13(1):78~80
    中华人民共和国教育部.关于“十五”期间普通高等教育教材建设与改革的意见. http://law.lawtime.cn/d437409442503.html/pos=0
    中野和光.教材编制与教学过程[M].钟启泉译.2000.外国教育资料,1
    中央教育科学研究所, 1988.中国现代教育大事记.教育科学出版社,558
    钟启泉.2001.教材概念的界定与教材编制的原则及技术(一) .上海教育,4
    钟启泉.2008.课程的逻辑.上海华东师范大学出版社:297
    钟启泉.1980.现代课程论.上海教育出版社:329
    周敏,常建清.2004.教材质量探析.常熟高专学报,6:103~104
    周范林.1999.进一步加强高校教材建设与管理.江苏高教,6:74~76
    周士林,李嘉瑶.1986.教材建设浅论.北京:北京航空学院出版社:42
    周晓辉,易露霞.2007.高等教育大众化阶段的教材改革思考.太原理工大学学报(社会科学版),25(3):77~79
    朱树国,吕守华,冯永平.2006.开展教材选用工作评价促进高质量教材进课堂.中国农业教育,4:43
    朱玉琴,尹华.2005.高校教材建设改革探讨.长沙民政职业技术学院学报,1:91~92
    Gulcan Numanoglu Safak Bayir 2009 Evaluation of information and communication technology textbooks according to principles of visual design[J] Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences,1(1): 2140-2144
    James Reininger 2010 My Text: An alternative to the traditional textbook[J] Computers in Human Behavior 26:119–121
    Juan Luis Jiménez Javier Campos 2010 Modelling Competition in the Textbook Market: Some Lessons still to Learn[J] J Ind Compet Trade 10:71–85
    Kirk M, Matthews C E, Kurtts S.2001. The trouble with textbooks[J]. The Science Teacher, 12:44-45
    LlN Fuzong 2003 The Experience in Developing Textbook[J] IBM Journal of Research and Development 8:162-165
    Maley A.1998. Squaring the circle-reconciling materials as constraint with materials as empowerment[M]. In B.Tomlinson Ed. Materials Development in language teaching. Cambridge University Press:279
    P.Shannon.2010. Textbook Development and Selection [J] International Encyclopedia of Education, 3: 397-402
    Paldy L G.2002. On the textbooks and teaching[J]. Joural of College Science Teaching, 4:354~355
    R. L. Venezky 2004 Textbooks[J] international Encyclopedia of the Social & Behavioral Sciences, 15631-15636
    Tohman M N, Hardy G R, Sudweets R R.1998. Science and children current science textbook use in the united states[J]. Academic Research Library, 5:22~23
    Taylor C P.2003. Textbook pages and hourly wages: the effects of cooperative education on student academic performance[D]. University of Alaska Anchorge in partial fulfillment of the requirement:29~30
    Weinbrenner P.2000. Methodologies of textbook aJalysis used to date. In Bourdillon,Hilary ED. History and social studies-Methodologies of Textbook Analysis. Amsterdam: Swets & Zeitlinger:45
    Walpole S.1998. Changing texts, changing thinking:comprehension demands of new science textbooks[J]. The Reading Teacher, 12:358~359
    Whitley J.1998. One person's opinion: the textbook isn’t dying in the 1990s[J]. English Journal, 1:15~16

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700