摘要
快速城市化和机动化的进程,使得我国城市交通系统对能源需求的增长迅速;不可再生能源的有限,也让城市人口增长和降低交通能耗之间的矛盾成为制约我国城市交通可持续发展的瓶颈。有鉴于此,城市交通系统的节能减排已成为规划和建设“绿色城市”的重要组成部分。本文从影响因素、需求量、城市空间结构、城市交通规划和节能减排政策等五个方面系统研究了城市交通系统和能源消耗之间的关系,找到了降低城市交通能耗的有效方法,主要研究内容包括以下几个方面:
(1)从系统的角度,以城市交通能耗的基本统计和计算方法为基础,从宏观层面(城市整体)、中观层面(交通小区或路网)、微观层面(交通工具)三个层面研究并总结了影响城市交通能源的因素:在城市经济社会发展的背景下,城市空间结构、城市规模和城市交通结构是影响城市交通总能耗的宏观因素,其中城市空间结构是首要因素,城市规模是重要因素,城市交通结构则是关键因素,各因素间相互关联共同决定了城市交通总能耗的发展趋势;城市路网、可达性和交通微循环系统是影响城市交通总能耗的中观因素;交通工具的单体能耗是影响城市交通总能耗的微观因素。
(2)在总结国内外已有交通能源需求量预测模型的基础上,构建了Gompertz和Spread Sheet的组合模型作为城市交通能源需求量预测模型,并对成都市未来交通能源需求量及影响需求量因素进行了预测分析。另外,为分析各种因素对成都市客运交通能源需求量的影响,选用分解模型计算各因素的贡献率。结果显示:过去十年,城市化的进程是成都市客运交通能耗的首要驱动因素;未来十年,居民出行结构和机动化出行率将是影响成都市客运交通能源需求量的最主要因素。
(3)从单中心和多中心的角度分析了城市空间结构对交通出行和能耗的影响,并以一个简单的计算实例,比较了单中心和多中心城市在交通能耗上的差异。在对复合功能开发、“紧凑城市”理念等进行分析之后,得到城市土地集约化发展有助于减少城市交通能耗的结论,在此基础上,以区间最小出行时耗为目标函数,建立了在城市交通能源约束情况下的土地优化模型。该模型的计算结果显示了在土地集约、混合发展的目标指引下,各种功能用地的最优比例,以及对城市交通总能耗的控制。
(4)探讨了可持续交通、绿色交通、低碳交通等相关概念的内涵及意义。在此基础上,以可持续交通发展为目标,将交通系统能耗的概念引入交通规划,建立了城市交通系统最小能耗模型。该模型在满足城市机动化发展的前提下,考虑城市路网时空的容量限制,以实现城市交通系统的最小能耗。模型求解结果可显示常规公交车与小汽车在城市路网中的关系及合适的发展规模。为鼓励城市更多居民采用公共交通方式出行,建立了在交通能源、路网资源、环境容量等限制条件下,以城市交通系统交通效率最优和居民出行交通成本最少为目标函数的城市交通结构优化模型。模型以重庆市主城区2020年的规划目标值为参考,分析了规划年重庆市合理的交通结构组成。
(5)在分析了交通政策的特点、分类及制定过程的基础上,采用动力学建模方法建立了城市客运交通的节能减排政策评估模型。模型以预测的上海市2020年的能源消耗和CO2排放量为基准情景,选取了三组不同的交通政策对上海市2020年客运交通的情景进行了分析对比,结果表明只有将不同目标的交通政策同时结合使用,才能真正实现节能减排的目标,单一政策的实施效果难以达到节能目标的要求。
本文研究内容为在能源约束情况下的城市可持续交通发展提供了全新的思路和方法。总结来说,要实现绿色城市交通的目标,我国城市只能选择以公交模式为主导的交通系统,实行公共交通适度超前发展的战略,推动公共交通导向的土地利用和紧凑布局形态。只有在构建节能交通系统的基础上降低交通工具对油品燃料的依赖,才是城市交通系统可持续发展的最优途径。
With the process of rapid urbanization and motorization in China, the energy demand of urban transport system is corresponding increasing. Due to limited non-renewable energy sources, the conflict between urban population growth and the reduction of transport energy has been held back the sustainable development of urban transport system. In view of this, the energy saving in urban transport system has become the aim of "low-carbon city" planning. In this paper, influencing factors, energy demand forcast, urban spatial structure, urban traffic planning and the policies on energy saving are chose to research the relationship between urban trasport system and transport energy consumption, and the main of this paper includes the following aspects:
(1) From the system point of view, the influencing factors of urban transport energy consumption could be classified by the macro-level (whole city), the meso-level (road network or community) and the micro-level (vehicle). In terms of the macro-level, urban spatial structure, city size and urban traffic structure are the main factors, in which urban spatial structure is the primary factor, city size is the important factor and urban traffic structure is the key factor. All the interrelated macro-level factors together determine the total energy consumption of urban transport traffic. Urban road network, accessibility and city micro-transportation circulation are the meso-level factors to urban transport energy consumption. With respect to the micro-level, the energy consumption of monomer vehicle is the leading factor.
(2) Based on the existing forecasting models of transport energy demand, Gompertz model and Spread Sheet model are made up to forecast urban transport energy demand, and this associated model is applied to Chengdu city. In addition, for analyzing the impact of various factors upon transport energy demand in Chengdu city, the decomposable model is created. The results showed that in the past decade, the process of urbanization is the primary factor to the increase in transport energy consumption, and in the next decade, traffic structure and trip rate of mobility will affect the change of passenger transport energy demand in Chengdu city mainly.
(3) In terms of single-center and multi-center, the impacts of urban spatial structure on resident trips and transport energy consumption are studied. Through a simple numerical example, the fact is that multi-central city is superior to single-center city in transport energy saving. Besides, the researches on complex land use and "compact city" show that the intensive development of urban land could help reduce transport energy consumption. Be based upon these concepts, the optimization model of urban land use is constructed. In the model, the objective function is to minimize the total travel time among communities, and the main restrictive condition is urban transport energy consumption. The result of the model is the proportion of various land functions under the guidance of mixed urban land use and reasonable transport energy consumption.
(4) Sustainable transportation develpment, green transport system, low-carbon transport system and other related concepts are discussed. On the basis of this, transport energy consumption is introduced into urban traffic planning for creating the minimum energy consumption model of urban trasport system. Considering the capacity constraint of urban road network, the aim of this model is to solve the problem on the appropriate scale of conventional buses and cars. In addition, to encourage more residents travel by public transportation, the optimization model of urban traffic structure is established under the restrictive conditions of transport energy consumption, network resources, environment capacity and other constraints. This model is applied to analyze the reasonable urban traffic structure of Chongqing city in 2020.
(5) In view of the characteristics, the classification and the development process of traffic policy, the dynamic modeling method is applied to evaluate urban transport energy saving policies. Firstly, the model forecasts transport energy consumption and CO2 emissions of Shanghai city in 2020. The forecasting results are set up as the base scenario, and the other three scenarios are got by three different groups of energy saving policies. After the scenarios are analyzed and compared, the results show that single energy saving policy will be difficult to achieve energy saving and emissions-reduction targets, and the different combined polices can be help to meet goals.
This paper offers new ideas and methods for studing sustainable urban transport development under the energy constraints. In conclusion, to achieve the goal of green urban transport system, urban public transport should only be chosen as the leading traffic mode, the strategy of public transport first and the complex land use should be implemented in China. Only urban energy-saving traffic system could reduce the consumption of fuels and meet the demands of sustainable urban transport development.
引文
[1]王炜,项乔君,常玉林,李铁柱,李修刚.交通系统能源消耗与环境影响[M].北京:科学出版社,2003
[2]中华人民共和国国务院.国家中长期科学和技术发展规划纲要(2006—2020年)[R].北京,2006
[3]陆大道.我国的城镇化进程与空间扩张[J].城市规划学刊,2007(4):47-52
[4]何建中.中国城市交通可持续发展对策[J].北京:城市交通报,2010
[5]张佰瑞.城市化水平预测模型的比较研究——对我国2020年城市化水平的预测[J].理论界,2007(04):48-51
[6]李迅.中国城市交通发展的和谐之路[R].中国城市科学研究会,2007
[7]中国可持续交通课题组.城市交通可持续发展——要素、挑战及对策[M].北京:人民交通出版社,2008
[8]周伟Joseph S. Szyliowicz.迈向可持续发展的未来——中国交通能源与环境政策研究[M].北京:人民交通出版社,2005
[9]中国中心城市交通改革与发展研讨会学术委员会编.中国中心城市可持续交通发展年度报告(2007)[M].北京:人民交通出版社,2007
[10]陆化普,毛其智,李政,贺克斌,帅石金,张希亮等.快速城镇化进程中的城市可持续交通——理论与中国实践[M].北京:中国铁道出版社,2008
[11]陈莎,杨少辉.城市公共交通系统节能降耗对策研究[J].城市交通,2009,7(3):43-47
[12]U. S. Department of Transportation. National Transportation Statistics 2002. Washing-ton D. C.:U. S. Government Printing Office,2002
[13]中国可持续交通课题组编著.城市交通可持续发展——要素、挑战及对策[M].北京:人民交通出版社,2008
[14]亚洲开发银行编著.中国公路交通资源优化利用——指南、手册与技术规程(上卷)[M].北京:中国经济出版社,2009
[15]周伟Joseph S.Szyliowicz迈向可持续发展的未来——中国交通能源与环境政策研究[M].北京:人民交通出版社,2005
[16]岳睿.我国城市交通节能减排政策研究[J].汽车节能,2009(3):13-16
[17]江玉林,姜克隽.中国城市交通节能政策研究[M].北京:人民交通出版社,2009
[18]陆锡明.亚洲城市交通模式[M].上海:同济大学出版社,2009
[19]贾顺平,彭宏勤,刘爽,张笑杰.交通运输与能源消耗相关研究综述[J].交通运输系统工程与信息,2009,9(3):6-16
[20]刘莉,董国亮,王云龙等.公路运输能源消耗统计指标研究[J].交通节能与环保,2008(3):16-22
[21]Jean-Paul Rodrigue, Claude Comtois, Brian Slack. The Geography of Transport Systems[M]. New York:Routledge,2009
[22]Newman, P. W. G., Kenworthy, J. R. Gasoline consumption and cities. A comparison of US cities in a global survey. Journal of the American Planning Association,1989 (55):24-36
[23]van de Coevering, P. and Schwanen, T. Re-evaluating the Impact of Urban Form on Travel Patterns in Europe and North-America[J]. Transport Policy,2006,13(3):229-239
[24]Antonio Nelson Rodrigues da Silva, Guilherme Camargo Ferraz Costa. Urban sprawl and energy use for transportation in the largest Brazilian cities[J]. Energy for Sustainable Development,2007,14(3):44-50
[25]Gordon P, Richardson H. Are compact cities a desirable planning goal?[J] Journal of the American Planning Association,1997,63(1):95-106 (Winter)
[26]马强.走向“精明增长”——从“小汽车城市”到“公共交通城市”[M].北京:中国建筑工业出版社,2007
[27]费移山.城市形态与城市交通相关性研究[D].南京:东南大学硕士论文,2003
[28]Thomson, J.M著.倪文彦,陶吴馨译.城市布局与交通规划[M].北京:中国建筑工业出版社,1982
[29]Robert, Cervero et al. Transit-Oriented Development and Joint Development in the United States:A Literature Review[J]. University of California, Berkeley,2001:80-87
[30]孙斌栋,潘鑫.城市空间结构对交通出行影响研究的进展——单中心与多中心的论争[J].城市问题,2008(1):19-28
[31]丁成日.城市空间规划——理论、方法与实践[M].北京:高等教育出版社,2007
[32]Bertaud, A. World development report 2003:Dynamic development in a sustainable world background paper:The spatial organization of cities:Deliberate outcome or unforeseen consequence. World Bank,2003
[33]黄建中.特大城市用地发展与客运交通模式[M].北京:中国建筑工业出版社,2006
[34]Cervero, R. Mixed land-uses and commuting:evidence from the American housing survey[J]. Transportation Research A,1996(5):361-377
[35]Schwanen T., Dieleman F. M., Dijst M. Travel behavior in Dutch mono-centric and policentric urban systems[J]. Journey of Transport Geography,2001 (9):173-186
[36]北京市城市规划设计研究院.城市土地使用与交通协调发展——北京的探索与实践[M].北京:中国建筑工业出版社,2009
[37]Cameron I., Kenworthy J. R., Lyons T. J. Understanding and predicting private motorized urban mobility[J]. Transportation Research Part D,2003 (8):267-283
[38]Coevering P. V. D., Schwanen T. Re-evaluating the impact of urban form on travel patterns in Europe and North-America[J]. Transport Policy,2006 (13):229-239
[39]毛海虓.中国城市居民出行特征研究[D].北京:北京工业大学博士论文,2005.03
[40]孙斌栋,潘鑫,吴雅菲.城市交通出行影响因素的计量检验[J].城市问题,2008(7):11-15
[41]中华人民共和国建设部.城市道路交通规划设计规范[G].北京,1995
[42]杨涛.城市化进程中的南京交通发展战略与规划(上)[J].现代城市规划,2003(1):52
[43]陆锡明.亚洲城市交通模式[M].上海:同济大学出版社,2009
[44]张树伟,姜克隽,刘德顺.城市客运交通的发展与能源消费——分析与情景模拟[J].城市问题,2006(9):61-64
[45]仇保兴.以举办城市公共交通周及无车日活动为契机大力推进和谐城市交通体系建设——在中国城市公共交通周及无车日活动工作会议上的讲话[J].城市车辆,2007(9):21-26
[46]陆化普,王建伟,张鹏.基于能源消耗的城市交通结构优化[J].清华大学学报(自然科学版),2004,44(3):383-386
[47]姚胜永,潘海啸.基于交通能耗的城市空间和交通模式宏观分析及对我国城市发展的启示[J].城市规划学刊,2009(3):46-52
[48]余启航,杨涛,刘罗军.中小城市交通特性与交通模式研究[A].杨涛,和谐交通:都市交通发展新战略新任务——第十六届海峡两岸都市交通学术研讨会论文集[C].南京:东南大学出版社,2008,268-273
[49]张卫华,王炜,尹红亮,胡刚.信号交叉口汽车燃油消耗的研究[J].东南大学学报(自然科学版),2002,32(2):249-251
[50]项乔君,王炜,陆键.信号交叉口汽车燃油消耗分析方法研究[J].公路交通科 技,2004,21(12):100-102
[51]Duany Plater-Zyberk&Compony. The Lexicon of New Urbanism[R].1999
[52]孔令斌.城市发展与交通规划——新时期大城市综合交通规划理论与实践[M].北京:人民交通出版社,2009
[53]刘望保.国内外城市交通微循环和支路网的研究进展和展望[J].规划师,2009,25(6):21-24.
[54]李王鸣,刘吉平,张颖瑛.交通能耗定量化研究尝试——城市微循环交通能耗模拟[J].城市发展研究,2010,17(6):32-36
[55]亚洲开发银行编著.中国公路交通资源优化利用——指南、手册与技术规程(上卷)[M].北京:中国经济出版社,2009
[56]项乔君.城市交通系统汽车燃油消耗研究[D].南京:东南大学博士论文,2000.09
[57]Asian Development Bank. Energy Efficiency and Climate Change Considerations for On-road Transport in Asia [R]. Manila,2006
[58]张卫华,王炜,胡刚.基于低交通能源消耗的城市发展策略[J].公路交通科技,2003,20(1):80-84
[59]石静雅,苏永清,岳继光.轨道交通能耗影响因素分析及能耗评价体系的建立[J].铁路运输与经济,2008,30(9):46-49
[60]宋敏华.城市轨道交通节能技术发展趋势研究[J].工程建设与设计,2009(1):15-19
[61]赵娴.北京市2008年交通能源需求与环境排放分析[D].北京:北京交通大学硕士论文,2007.06
[62]Bose R K,Srinivasachary V. Policy to reduce energy use and environmental emissions in the transport sector——A case of Delhi city[J]. Energy Policy,1997,25(14/15): 1137-1150
[63]Murat Yetis Sazi, Ceylan Halim. Use of artificial neural networks for transport energy demand modeling[J]. Energy Policy,2006,34(17):3165-3172
[64]Soner Haldenbilen, Halim Ceylan. Genetic algorithm approach to estimate transport energy demand in Turkey[J]. Energy Policy,2005,33(1):89-98
[65]Ramanathan R. Estimating energy consumption of transport modes in India using DEA and application to energy and environmental policy[J]. Journal of the Operational Research Society,2005,56(6):732-737
[66]朱松丽,姜克隽.北京市城市交通能源需求和环境排放:19982020[J].中国能 源.2002(6):26-31
[67]黄成,陈长虹,王冰妍.城市交通出行方式对能源与环境的影响[J].公路交通科技,2005,22(11):163-166
[68]张树伟,姜克隽,刘德顺.城市客运交通的发展与能源消费——分析与情景模拟[J].城市问题,2006(9):61-64
[69]冯相昭.城市交通温室气体减排的战略研究[M].北京:气象出版社,2009
[70]Dargay J, Gately D. Vehicle ownership to 2015:Implication for energy use and emission [J]. Energy Policy,1995,25(14/15):1121-1127
[71]Dargay J, Gately D. Income's effect on car and vehicle ownership, worldwide:1960-2015[J]. Transportation Research Part A,1999(33):101-138
[72]李政,付峰,高丹.中国特大城市客运交通能源需求变化的因素分解[J].清华大学学报(自然科学版),2008,48(11):1769-1772
[73]张明,穆海林.基于LMDI分解方法的中国特大城市客运能源消耗研究[J].北京大学学报(自然科学版),2010,46(3):483-486
[74]孙玉.集约化的城市土地利用与交通发展模式[M].上海:同济大学出版社,2010.05
[75]孙斌栋.我国特大城市交通发展的空间战略研究——以上海为例[M].南京:南京大学出版社,2009.03
[76]刘俊娟,王炜,程琳.单中心大城市土地利用对居民出行方式的影响[J].交通信息与安全,2010,28(2):74-78
[77]王海燕.基于紧凑型的多中心组团城市发展策略研究[D].湖南:中南大学硕士论文,2009.05
[78]杨振山,蔡建明.国外多中心规划理念与发展经验对中国的借鉴作用[J].国际城市规划,2008,23(4):71-77
[79]马清裕,张文尝,王先文.大城市内部空间结构对城市交通作用研究[J].经济地理,2004,24(2):215-220
[80]石忆邵.从单中心城市到多中心城市——中国特大城市发展的空间组织模式[J].城市规划汇刊,1999(3):36-39
[81]李娟,石建军,吴子啸.组团式城市居民出行特征变化趋势分析[J].交通运输工程与信息学报,2008,6(4):70-75
[82]万霞,陈峻,王炜.我国组团式城市小汽车出行特性研究[J].城市规划学刊,2007(3):86-89
[83]ITE Technical Council Committee. Guidelines for Transportation Impact Assessment of Proposed New Development[J]. ITE Journal,1998(6):6A-33
[84]张卫华,王炜,胡刚.基于低交通能源消耗的城市发展策略[J].公路交通科技,2003,20(1):80-84
[85]张代胜,柏海舰,张卫华.基于区间居民出行量最小的用地结构优化模型[J].华中科技大学学报(城市科学版),2007,24(1):28-31
[86]陆化普,王建伟,袁虹.基于交通效率的大城市合理土地利用形态研究[J].中国公路学报,2005,18(3):109-113
[87]江玉林.迈向可持续发展的未来——可持续交通发展国际经验[M].北京:人民交通出版社,2007
[88]陆化普,高嵩.考虑可持续发展的主动引导型交通规划新理论体系开发[J].公路交通科技,1999(12):29-33
[89]林飞龙.绿色交通:实现城市交通可持续发展的有效手段[J].生态经济,2004(7):26-28
[90]陈旭梅,袁庆达,高世廉.绿色交通理念下的城市交通可持续发展[J].综合运输,2002(2):26-27
[91]陆化普.城市绿色交通的实现途径[J].城市交通,2009,7(12):23-27
[92]金石.WWF启动中国低碳城市发展项目[J].环境保护,2008(2A):22
[93]陆建.城市交通系统可持续发展规划理论与方法[D].南京:东南大学博士论文,2003.05
[94]曹昌智,王显璞.构建城市低碳交通的规划策略研究——以常州新龙组团实践为例[J].2010城市发展与规划国际大会,2010:52-58
[95]Bracken J, McGill J. Mathematical programs with optimization problems in the constraints[J]. Operation Research.1973(21):37-44
[96]Candler W, R Norton. Multilevel programming.1977,Technical Report 20, World Bank Development Research Center, Washington D.C.
[97]董子刚.双层规划性质及若干算法研究[D].山东:山东科技大学硕士论文,2006.05
[98]Jeroslow R. The polynomial hierarchy and a simple model for competitive analysis[J]. Mathematical Programming.1985(32):146-164.
[99]Ben-Aye O, Blair C. Computational difficulties of bi-level linear programming[J]. Operations Research.1990(38):556-560.
[100]Bard J. Some properties of the bi-level programming problem[J]. Journal of Optimization Theory and Applications.1991(68):371-378
[101]Hansen P, Jaumard B, Savard G. New branch-and-bound rules for linear bi-level programming[J]. SIAM Journal on Scientific and Statistical computing.1992(13): 1194-1217.
[102]Vicente L, Savard G, Judice J. Descent approaches for quadratic bi-level programming [J]. Journal of Optimization Theory and Applications.1994(81):379-399
[103]周爱民,谭春桥.双层规划模型及其算法研究综述[J].零陵学院学报,2005,26(2):133-137
[104]马健霄.城市局域交通网络容量研究[D].南京:南京林业大学博士论文,2007.12
[105]王继峰.基于可达性的交通规划方法研究[D].北京:清华大学工学博士学位论文,2008.06
[106]邹胜勇.面向可持续发展的城市总体交通结构优化[J].交通运输系统工程与信息,2006,6(2):106-110
[107]吕慎,田锋,李旭宏.我国大城市客运交通结构发展模式研究——应用层次分析主成分分析组合评判法[J].土木工程学报,2003,36(1):30-35
[108]欧洲运输部长联合会经济合作与发展组织.《交通运输成本的内部化》[M].北京:中国环境科学出版社,1996
[109]陈艳玲.公共交通与小汽车出行成本对比研究[D].南京:南京林业大学硕士论文,2009.06
[110]吕慎,田锋,李旭宏.大城市客运交通结构优化模型研究[J].公路交通科技,2007,24(7):117-120
[111]Carlsson-Kanyama A, Linden A. Travel patterns and environmental effects now and in the future:implications of differences in energy consumption among socio-economic groups[J]. Ecological Economics.1999(30):405-417
[112]李淑庆.重庆主城区公共交通发展规划目标研究[J].重庆交通学院学报,2007,26(1):83-86
[113]李淑庆.城市路网容量约束下的机动车发展规模研究[J].重庆交通大学学报(自然科学版),2008,27(1):100-104
[114]刘会军.有利于节能的重庆市公共交通运输结构优化研究[D].重庆:重庆交通大学硕士论文,2010.04
[115]季令.交通运输政策[M].北京:中国铁道出版社,2003
[116]陆锡明等.城市交通战略[M].北京:中国建筑工业出版社,2006
[117]王庆云.交通运输发展理论与实践[M].北京:中国科学技术出版社,2006
[118]高中岗.从京、沪城市交通政策的差异看北京的交通拥堵[J].城市规划汇刊,2004(4):35-39
[119]杨少辉,马林,陈莎.我国城市交通发展政策分析[J].生态文明视角下的城乡规划——2008中国城市规划年会论文集,2008
[120]山中英生,小谷通泰,新田保次.城市交通中存在的问题及其对策[M].北京:中国建筑工业出版社,2009
[121]The Institute of Highways and Transportation:Guidelines for Developing Urban Strategies[R]. HMSO,1996
[122]Piric A, Reeve N. Evaluation of Public Investment in R&D--towards a contingency analysis[A]. Policy Evaluation in Innovation and Technology:toward Best Practices (OECD Proceedings) [C]. OECD,1997.49-64.
[123]王瑞祥.政策评估的理论、模型与方法[J].预测,2003,22(3):6-11
[124]赵大晖,卢凤君,何发,郭锐.汽车工业及其产业政策效应的评估方法综述[J].武汉汽车工业大学学报,2000,22(2):10-14
[125]Urban Transport and the Environment:An International Perspective[R]. World Conference on Transport Research Society and Institute for Transport Policy Studies. 2004. Elsevier, Amsterdam.
[126]May A.D., Shepherd S.P., Timms P.M. Optimal transport strategies for European cities [J]. Transportation,2000(27):285-315.
[127]Tsamboulas D, Vrenken H, Lekka A.M. Assessment of a transport policy potential for intermodal mode shift on a European scale [J]. Transportation Research Part A,2006 (41):715-733.
[128]Vieira J., Moura F., Viegas J.M. Transport policy and environmental impacts:the importance of multi-instrumentality in policy integration [J]. Transport Policy,2007(14): 421-432.
[129]杨伟杰,裴玉龙,徐秋实.模糊数学在城市交通政策评价中的应用[J].公路,2003,4:103-105
[130]陈海波,王璇,毛保华.城市交通政策的可持续性研究[J].交通运输系统工程与信息,2006,6(3):100-112
[131]王孝坤,杨东援,胡小文.城市商业中心区的货运交通特征及政策评估[J].交通运输系统工程与信息,2006,6(6):130-135
[132]张国伍.交通运输系统工程创新与发展——交通人生60年[M].北京:北京交通大学出版社,2008
[133]靳玫.北京市交通结构演变的系统动力学模型研究[D].北京:北京交通大学硕士学位论文,2007.12
[134]海德堡能源与环境研究所.中国交通:不同交通方式的能源消耗与排放[R].德国:海德堡,2008.05
[135]赵敏,张卫国,俞立中.上海市居民出行方式与城市交通C02排放及减排对策[J].环境科学研究,2009,22(6):747-752