摘要
汽车发动机结构越来越复杂,安装精度要求也越来越高。在不拆检的情况下,如何判断出故障的类型和位置,是目前研究的重点和难点。研究发动机故障时,往往需要测量故障状态下的相关参数变化情况,了解故障信息并提取故障特征,但是并不轻易具备收集各种故障信息的条件,而靠人为方法设置发动机故障,往往会导致发动机严重的损伤和破坏,试验成本很高,限制了发动机故障诊断的深入研究。
针对发动机故障诊断技术研究存在的不足,首次通过建模仿真和实验对发动机整机进行典型故障机理、特征提取和诊断方法研究。利用有限元与多体动力学联合建模,计算结果更精确可靠;通过模型进行了多种类型的故障仿真,从激励力变化这一内在因素分析机体表面振动响应变化,深层次了解故障引起的机体异常振动成因和特性,通过模型正常状态和故障状态的机体表面振动信号变化趋势分析来提取故障特征,为发动机故障诊断研究提供一种新方法。利用多体动力学和有限元技术建立高质量标杆发动机仿真模型,通过相关参数设置,分别模拟发动机失火故障、气门间隙大、凸轮轴承松脱、活塞敲缸和主轴承磨损等故障,从机理上进行了分析,提取了相应故障特征,得到了相关实验验证。
提出了应用小波包分解与解调方法来提取气门间隙过大和凸轮轴松脱故障的故障特征。利用发动机仿真模型进行了气门间隙大和凸轮轴承松脱的故障仿真分析,发现由于气门间隙增大,导致气门落座力、凸轮轴承力的增大,这些增大的冲击力使缸盖振动响应时域信号在一个工作循环内出现3个明显冲击,在频谱上激发起中高频频段内的显著振动能量。利用小波包分解到此特征频段后再解调,故障状态的解调谱中出现明显的1.5阶次成分;而对于凸轮轴松脱故障,用相同方法可得到故障状态下解调谱的0.5阶次的明显增大。从理论上说明了此种类型故障具有明显的中高频调制现象,为故障特征提取和故障诊断研究提供有力参考。通过仿真分析发现活塞敲缸故障会激发2500Hz以上高频段振动能量的加剧,提出故障状态与正常状态的小波包分解总能量比随转速变化趋势作为依据进行故障诊断的方法;通过对主轴承间隙过大造成主轴承反力的波动变化,解析了此类故障引起200~1000Hz中低频段振动能量增加的原因,为此类故障诊断研究提供理论依据。
The structure of automotive engine becomes increasingly complicated and therequirement for installation precision increasing too. How to diagnose the fault’s type andlocation under the non-overhaul condition has been the key and difficult points of researchnowadays. We need to measure the change of relative parameters, know the fault informationand exact fault features while studying the engine fault, however it’s difficult to collect theabove information.And,if the engine’s faults are made artificially, it will result in severedamage of engine and high testing cost, which limit the further survey.
Aimming at the existed weakness of engine fault diagnosis techniques, the faults’mechanism, feature extraction and diagnosis methods of the whole engine is studied for thefirst time by modeling and simulation. The results will become more accurate and reliable byjoint modeling under the finite element and multi-body dynamics. By analyzing the vibrationresponse on the surface of engine body considering the inner factor of exciting force, thereasons and characteristics of abnormal engine body vibration caused by the fault is obtained.By the trend analysis of vibration signals of the body surface under the normal and faultconditions, the fault feature is extracted, and which provided a new way for the engine faultdiagnosis. By the multi-body dynamics and the finite element technique, high qualitybenchmarking engine simulation model is builded. Faults including the engine misfire,largevalve clearance, cam bearing looseness, piston knocking and main bearing wears can besimulated by the related parameters setting. The fault features are extracted and verifiedaccordingly.
A fault feature extraction method is proposed by the application of wavelet packetdecomposition and demodulation method to extract the faults of the excessive valve clearanceand looseness of camshaft. The faults of the excessive valve clearance and looseness ofcamshaft are analyzed using the engine simulation model established. It is found that with theincreasement of valve clearance, the valve seating force and the bearing force increasing too.And because of the increasing impact forces, three significant impacts in a working cycleappear in the time domain vibration signal of cylinder head, which arouses the notablevibration energy in the high frequency. By wavelet packet decomposition, the signal of the high frequency band is decomposed. For the faults of excessive valve clearance and camshaftlooseness, the demodulation spectrum appears obvious1.5order component and the0.5ordercomponent, respectively. It is found that this kind of fault has significant high frequencymodulation phenomenon in theory, which provides strong reference to failure featureextraction and fault diagnosis. The reason why the energy of high frequency over2500Hzincreased when piston knock is analyzed theoretically. A method of fault diagnosis based onratio’s change trend with rotate speed between the total energy of wavelet packetdecomposition under fault condition and normal condition is presented. The reason why thevibration energy of medium-low frequency between200and1000Hz increased is analyzed intheory, which is caused by the fluctuations of main bearing reaction force caused by excessiveclearance of main bearing. The method can provide theoretical basis for this kind of faultdiagnosis research.
引文
[1]贾继德,孔凡让等.应用振动信号诊断汽油机磨损故障[J].汽车工程,2002,24(2):149-151
[2]成曙,张振仁.发动机现代诊断技术[M].西安:西安交通大学出版社,2006
[3]黄文虎,夏松波,刘瑞岩.设备故障诊断原理、技术及应用[M].北京:科学技术出版社,1996
[4]刘占峰,司景萍,梁红波.基于振动信号分析的发动机气缸壁间隙异常诊断[J].小型内燃机与摩托车,2011,40(2):86-88
[5]王静,刘焜,王伟等. SVM在缸套-活塞磨损状态监测中的应用研究[J].车用发动机,2010,(2):85-88
[6]王祝平,王为,李小昱等.基于EMD与神经网络的内燃机气门间隙故障诊断[J].农业机械学报,2007,38(12):133-136
[7]李志敏,王义,宋希庚等.内燃机主轴承磨损故障的振动监测方法研究[J].内燃机学报,2000,18(2):203-206
[8] Peng Z K, CHU F L. Application of the wavelet transform in machine conditionmonitoring and fault diagnostics: a review with bibliography[J]. Mechanical Systemsand Signal Processing,2004,18:199-221
[9]刘世元,杜润生,杨叔子.利用转速波动信号诊断内燃机失火故障的研究[J].内燃机学报,2000,18(4):395-398
[10] Getman Anya L. Zhou Heng, Jammalamadaka Sandhya D. An automated networkfor detecting diesel engine misfire. IEEE International Conference on NeuralNetworks-Conference Proceeding[C].2007,Orlando:3017-3021
[11] S. Liu, F. Gu, A. Ball, The on-line detection of engine misfire at low speed usingmultiple feature fusion with fuzzy pattern recognition, Proceedings of the Institution ofMechanical Engineers Part D: Journal of Automobile Engineering216(2002)391-402
[12]乔新勇,刘建敏,张小明.基于神经网络信息融合的发动机失火故障诊断[J].内燃机工程,2009,30(1):74-79
[13]夏勇,张振仁,成曙等.基于小波分析与神经网络的气阀机构故障诊断研究[J].内燃机学报,2001, I9(3):235-240
[14]唐洁,屈梁生.基于支持向量机的发动机故障诊断[J].西安交通大学学报,2007,41(9):1124-1126
[15] WU Jianda, CHEN Jiechen. Continuous wavelet transform technique for fault signaldiagnosis of internal combustion engines[J]. NDT&E international,2006,39:304-311
[16] F Gu, A.D.Ball. Diesel injector dynamic modeling an estimation of injection parametersfrom impact response. Part2: prediction of injection parameters from monitoredvibration. Proceedings of International Mechanical Engineering, Part D:Journal of automobile Engineering,1996, Vo1.210
[17] B. Samimy and G. Rizzoni, Mechanical signature analysis using time-frequency signalprocessing: application to internal combustion engine knock detection, Proceedings ofthe IEEE,84(9):1330-1343
[18] W.B. Ribbens and D. Gross. Torque non-uniformity measurements in gasoline fueledpassenger cars equipped with automatic transmission-theory and experimental results.SAE Paper860414:966-974
[19]孔凡让,贾继德等.连杆轴承故障的诊断研究[J].中国机械工程.2003,14(6):494-496
[20]贾继德,孔凡让,李志远等.活塞销故障的诊断研究[J].振动与冲击.2002,21(1):78-80
[21]胡以怀,刘永长.柴油机排气门漏气故障诊断的试验研究[J].内燃机工程,1997,18(3):51-58
[22] Wang W J, McFadden P D. Application of wavelets to gearbox vibration signals forfault detection. Journal of Sound and Vibration,1996,192(5):927-939
[23]肖云魁.汽车故障诊断学.北京:北京理工大学出版社.2006.5
[24]高强,何正嘉.谐波小波及其时频剖面图在旋转机械诊断中的应用[J].西安交通大学学报,2000,34(9):62-66
[25]訾艳阳,何正嘉等.小波分形技术及其在非平稳故障诊断中的应用[J].西安交通大学学报,2000,34(9):82-87
[26]刘刚,屈梁生.应用连续小波变换提取机械故障的特征[J].西安交通大学学报,2000,34(11):74-77
[27]林京,屈梁生.基于连续小波变换的奇异性检测与故障诊断[J].振动工程学报,2000,13(4):523-529
[28]伍学奎,周轶尘.基于小波包变换的内燃机气阀漏气诊断方法[J].振动工程学报,2000,13(2):210-215
[29]马孝江,袁景侠.双谱分析及其在机械故障诊断中的应用[J].大连理工大学学报,1998,29(2):114-119
[30]金萍,陈怡然.内燃机表面振动信号的性质[J].天津大学学报,2000,33(1):63-68
[31]陈怡然,周轶尘.发动机振动诊断中的多重分形法[J].内燃机学报,1997,15(1):177-182
[32] Lars J.Kangas,Frank L.Greitzer, Major Orlando J, Jr.Turbine Engine DiagnosticArtificial Neural Network.Advanced Information Systems and Technology Conference1994:PNL-SA-24733
[33] Essawy M.A, wavelet versus Fourier fault diagnosis in helicopter gearboxes.Preprocessing for neural-fuzzy systems for Intelligent Engineering Systems throughArtificial Neural Networks,1998,11:767-772
[34]燕学智,钱耀义.基于人工神经网络技术的发动机诊断系统[J].内燃机工程,2001,22(1):78-81
[35]冯志鹏,宋希庚.基于粗糙集与神经网络集成的内燃机故障诊断[J].内燃机学报,2003,21(1):1-6
[36]刘世元.基于瞬时转速与缸盖振动信号的内燃机故障诊断方法研究[D].武汉:华中理工大学,1998
[37]何学文,赵海鸣.支持向量机及其在机械故障诊断中的应用[J].中南大学学报(自然科学版),2005,36(1):97-101
[38]魏少华.基于声强知识与神经网络融合技术的发动机故障诊断研究[D].南京:南京理工大学,2006
[39] H.Y.Isaac Du. Simulation of flexible rotating crankshaft engine block andhydrodynamic bearings for a V6engine. SAE paper1999-01-175
[40] S.M. Athavale, P. R. Sajanpawar. Analytical studies on influence of crankshaftvibrations on engine noise using integrated parametric finite element model: quickassessment tool. SAE paper1999-01-176
[41] Z.P.Mourelatos. An efficient crankshaft dynamic analysis using substructuring with ritzvectors. Journal o f sound and vibration.2000,238(3):495-527
[42] M.Inagaki, A. Ka wamoto, T.Aoyama,etal. Prediction of structural And kinematiccoupled vibration on internal combustion engine. R&D review of Toyota,37(2):273
[43]段秀兵.基于低噪声发动机虚拟设计的曲轴机体耦合动力学研究[D].天津:天津大学,2004
[44]林琼.基于试验与仿真分析的发动机运动件摩擦耦合动力学研究[D].杭州:浙江大学,2008
[45]杨高宏,程珩,齐有军等.基于虚拟样机技术的齿轮故障特征提取方法研究[J].煤矿机械,2009,30(3):193-195
[46]白欣,黄博等.基于虚拟样机的发动机活塞销故障诊断研究[J].汽车技术,2005,(4):20-23
[47]贾长治,王兴贵.基于虚拟样机技术的火炮故障仿真及应用研究[J].机械工程学报,2004,40(9):89-93
[48]刘荣娥等.基于虚拟样机的风机不平衡故障仿真研究[J].煤矿机械,2007,28(11):178-180
[49]江峰.汽轮机转子故障状态下的振动仿真分析[D].武汉:武汉理工大学,2009
[50] D.Hogetts. The Vibrations of Crankshafts. PhD Thesis, University of London,1986
[51] Offner G., Priebsch H.H. A Numerical Model for the Simulation of Piston to LinearContact Excitation considering Elasto-hydrodynamics, WTC Congress,2001
[52]郭磊.基于AVL模拟软件包的变速箱振动噪声集成化仿真技术[C]. AVL中国年度年会论文集,2008
[53]邓晓龙.用EXCITE进行发动机结构振动及噪声预测[C]. AVL中国年度年会论文集,2008
[54]蓝宇翔.某发动机活塞环顶口故障分析[C]. AVL中国年度年会论文集,2007
[55]张磊.发动机特性分析及试验对比[C]. AVL中国年度年会论文集,2006
[56]蓝军.发动机噪声载荷激励分析与结构设计[C]. AVL中国年度年会论文集,2007
[57]李梅.发动机曲轴系动力学分析与动态性能优化[D].上海:上海交通大学,2009
[58]王永岩.动态子结构方法理论与应用[M].北京:科学出版社,1999
[59] R.R. Craig, M.C.C. Bamptom. Coupling of substructures for dynamics analyses[J].AIAA Journal,1968,6(7):1313-1319
[60] R.R. Craig. Structural Dynamics-An Introduction to Computer Methods[M]. JohnWiley&Sons, New York,1981
[61]彭禹.基于虚拟样机技术的发动机子系统设计方法研究[D].杭州:浙江大学,2007
[62] Zissimos P. Mourelatos. A crankshaft system model for structural dynamic analysis ofinternal combustion engines[J]. Computers&Structures,2001,79(20-21):2009-2027
[63] GUYAN R.J.. Reduction of Stiffness and Mass Matrices[J]. AIAA Journal,1965,3(2),p380
[64] Kim K.O., Anderson W.J.. Generalized Dynamic Reduction in Finite Element DynamicOptimization[J]. AIAA Journal,1984,22(11):1616-1617
[65] AVL List GmbH. Reference Manual Version2009: Excite Power Unit Theory[M]. April2009
[66] Harald Pramberger,蓝军.用于车辆降噪的发动机仿真[C].中国汽车工程学会2003学术年会论文集(下册),2003,pp278-286
[67]包学海,池茂儒,杨飞.子结构分析中主自由度选取方法研究[J].机械,2009,36(4):18-20
[68]贾继德.往复机械非平稳信号的特征提取及诊断[D].合肥:中国科学技术大学,2004
[69]郑世仿,韩捷.坦克发动机常见故障信号特征与诊断[J].郑州大学学报,2003,12(4):37-41
[70]贾继德,傅立峰,刘志刚等.基于瞬变工况阶比跟踪的内燃机监测方法研究[J].振动工程学报.2005,18(3):381-383.
[71]杜灿谊,杨志坚,丁康.小波分析在发动机失火监测中的应用[J].诊断、测试与诊断,2011,31(6):318-322
[72]贾继德,孔凡让,李志远等.基于时频分析的内燃机曲轴轴承磨损故障的诊断研究[J].中国科学技术大学学报,2003,39(6):38-44
[73]徐晓洁,王京,蔡文远等.发动机失火算法研究[J].微计算机信息,2008,24(11-1):174-176
[74]汪映,吴筱敏,关勇.一种新型发动机失火监测方法的探讨[J].内燃机学报,2002,20(1):46-48
[75]汪映,周龙保,吴筱敏.离子电流法检测发动机失火和爆震的研究[J].西安交通大学学报,2002,36(9):895-898
[76] P.Charles, Jyoti K.Sinha, F.Gu, etc. Detecting the crankshaft torsional vibration ofdiesel engines for combustion related diagnosis[J]. Journal of sound and vibration321(2009)1171~1185
[77]王虹,唐力伟,栾军英等.基于角域同步平均技术的内燃机失火故障诊断[J].振动、测试与诊断.2005,25(2):143-145
[78]樊新海,安钢,张传清等.基于排气噪声EMD的柴油机失火故障诊断[J].内燃机工程,2010,31(1):78-81
[79]陆金铭,王醇涛,周海港.基于EMD的柴油机失火故障诊断[J].江苏科技大学学报(自然科学版),2009,23(3):234-238
[80] Daniel T.L. Lee, Akio Yamamoto. Wavelet Analysis: Theory and Applications[J].Hewlett-Packard Journal,1994,45:44-52
[81] ZHENG D, NEOL C P. An efficient multibody dynamics model for internal combustionengine system[J]. Multibody System Dynamics,2003,10:363-391
[82] LIN Y J, Farahat R. CAD-based virtual assembly prototyping-a case study[J].International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology,2003,21(4):263-274
[83] Parikyan T., Reach T., Priebsch, H.H.. Structured model of crankshaft in thesimulation engine dynamics with AVL/EXCITE[C]. American Society of MechanicalEngineers,2001,37(3):105-114
[84]张桂昌.柴油机配气机构动力学分析及凸轮型线优化设计[D].天津:天津大学,2009
[85]冯仁华.发动机配气机构优化改进设计[D].长沙:湖南大学,2009
[86] Cardona A., Geradin M.. Kinematical and Dynamic Analysis of Mechnical withCams[J]. Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering,1993,103(2):171-175
[87] AVL List GmbH. Reference Manual Version2009: Excite TimingDrive Primer[M].April2009
[88]何正嘉,訾艳阳,张西宁.现代信号处理及工程应用[M].西安:西安交通大学出版社,2007
[89]贺银芝,沈松,应怀樵等.小波包分解及其能量谱在发动机连杆轴承故障诊断中的应用[J].振动工程学报,2001,14(1):72-75
[90]刘月辉.基于虚拟样机的发动机噪声控制研究[D].天津:天津大学,2004
[91] Tetsuya Kimura, Kazuki Takahashi, Shigeru sugiyama. Development of a pistonsecondary motion analysis program with elastically deformable piston skirt, SAE1999-01-3303
[92] Priebsch H H, Herbst H M, Offner Gunter. Piston Slap Induced Noise SimulationConsidering Elasto-hydrodynamic Contact Conditions. American Society of MechanicalEngineers, Internal Combustion Engine Division,2001,36(3):9-18
[93] Sam D. Haddad. Theoretical treatment of piston motion in I.C. piston engine for theprediction of piston slap excitation[J]. Mechanism and Machine Theory,1995,30(2):253-269
[94]叶枫桦.缸套-活塞润滑对内燃机振动影响研究[D].武汉:武汉理工大学,2010
[95] AVL List GmbH. Reference Manual Version2009: Excite PistonRings Theory[M].April2009
[96]卫海桥,舒歌群.内燃机活塞拍击表面振动与燃烧噪声的关系[J].内燃机学报,2004,22(1):27-32
[97] Lefteri H. Tsoukalas, Robert E. Uhrig. Fuzzy and Neural Approaches inEngineering[M]. John Wiley&Sons, Inc. New York,1996
[98] Du canyi, Ding Kan, Yang Zhijian, Yang Cuili. Diagnosis for Engine Misfire FaultBased on Torsional Vibration and Neural-network Analysis[C]. Advanced MaterialsResearch,2012,v433-440, p7240-7246
[99]秦萍,阎兵,李辉.小波分析在柴油机滑动主轴承接触摩擦故障诊断中的应用[J].内燃机工程,2003,24(3):56-60
[100]贾继德,刘志刚,孔凡让等.基于双谱分析的内燃机曲轴轴承磨损故障的诊断研究[J].中国科学技术大学学报,2004,34(6):688-693
[101]施谱尔,克劳舍著,宁汝新等译.虚拟产品开发技术[M].北京:机械工业出版社,2000
[102]林琼.基于试验与仿真分析的发动机运动件摩擦耦合动力学研究[D].杭州:浙江大学,2009
[103]林琼,郝志勇,郭磊.曲轴系统多体动力与油膜动力润滑耦合的数字化仿真研究[J].内燃机工程,2007,28(3):45-48
[104]王永亮,刘占生.圆瓦滑动轴承油膜力近似解析模型[J].中国电机工程学报,2011,31(29):110-116
[105] M Lahmara, A Haddad a, D Nicolas. An optimized short bearing theory for nonlineardynamic analysis of turbulent journal bearings[J]. Eur.J.Mech.A/Solids,2000,19:151-177
[106]藏玉萍,张德江,王维正.基于小波变换技术的发动机异响故障诊断[J].机械工程学报,2009,45(6):239-245
[107]王元龙.发动机曲轴轴承异响故障诊断研究[D].合肥:合肥工业大学,2007
[108] Y.S. Fan, G.T. Zheng. Research of high-resolution vibration signal detectiontechnique and application to mechanical fault diagnosis[J]. Mechanical System andSignal Processing,2007,21:678-687
[109] S.K. Lee, P.R. White. Higher-order time-frequency analysis and its application to faultdetection in rotating machinery[J]. Mech. Syst. Signal Process,1997,11(4):637-650
[110] Simone Delvecchio, Gianluca D’Elia, Emiliano Mucchi, et al. Advanced signalprocessing tools for the vibratory surveillance of assembly faults in diesel engine coldtests[J]. Journal of Vibration and Acoustics,2010,132/021008:1-10
[111] L. Cohen. Time-frequency distribution-a review[J]. Proceedings of the IEEE,1989,77(7):941-981
[112] Choi H., W.J. Williams. Improved Time-Frequency Representation of MulticomponentSignals Using Exponential Kernels[J]. IEEE Trans. ASSP,1989,37(6):862-871