合作社对农户生产效益和规模效率的影响
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
随着经济的发展和市场的完善,我国农业生产逐渐从生产导向型转变为市场导向型,农产品市场方式越来越依赖于产品特性、双方交易主体特征和交易特性,交易组织形式由市场交易逐渐向各种合同生产方式、纵向一体化等转变。而现有生产方式的改变、供应链垂直一体化和专业化程度的提高、国际食品市场开放度和价格竞争的加剧,都威胁着小农户的生存,这些挑战势必导致新的制度安排或组织形式的产生和发展。
     目前,我国的农产品供应链结构和管理正处于转型和多种形式并存的局面,既有以小农户、贩销户、批发市场和加工企业等主体为代表的传统供应链模式,又有加入了农民合作社、超市、专业化配送中心和物流公司等为特征的新型供应链结构。作为代表小农户进入市场的农民合作社,能否真正为小农户带来经济效益?这正是本研究想要回答的问题。尽管关于这个问题的研究数不胜数,持肯定观点的占多数,却也不乏质疑的声音,但是现有研究大多为定性研究和案例研究,很少有深入、具有说服力的理论模型推导或数理模型检验。
     本研究基于合作社影响农户的经济效益的假说,从三个角度来检验这一假说:第一,不存在合作社的市场和存在合作社的市场中,农户所获得的价格和收益是否不同?第二,合作社社员和非社员农户的生产效益是否有差异?第三,合作社社员和非社员农户的规模效率是否不同?
     本研究的主要特点在于:首先,构建了博弈理论模型对农户选择交易组织形式的过程进行模拟和求解,这在国内尚属创新性和尝试性的研究;其次,实证研究中专注于一种特定的产品,即利用浙江省梨果产业的第一手数据,运用经典数理模型和计量工具对理论假说进行检验;再次,一方面理论模型的结论具有对所有地区和产品的普遍应用性和理论性意义,另一方面经验研究的结论具有对特定地区特定产业的实践性意义。
     本研究的具体内容和结论如下:
     第一章为绪论,交待本研究的现实背景和研究目的,提出本研究拟解决的问题,进而对本研究中的一些关键性概念进行界定,制定整个研究的技术路线图和内容框架,并介绍研究所使用的各种方法,最后提出本研究可能存在的创新和不足之处。
     第二章为文献综述,梳理了各种合作社相关理论和农业生产效率及规模效率的成果,发现现有研究在关于合作社对农户生产效益及效率影响的理论模型研究和数量模型研究方面存在薄弱和空白,以此确定本研究的切入点。
     第三章分别构建了在三种不同市场结构下小农户选择交易组织形式的博弈模型,即IOF垄断市场、IOF-合作社混合市场、纯合作社市场,求解博弈的均衡战略,模型结果显示,农户在IOF垄断市场中只能获得微薄的收益;合作社的出现提高了所有农户的收益水平;纯合作社市场虽然能够使农户收益达到最大,然而搭便车行为使资源分配极为不合理,因而并不是一个长期稳定的市场结构。
     第四章介绍了浙江省农民合作社运行情况和梨果产业发展情况,解释以浙江省梨果产业为经验研究对象的理由,进而描述了样本抽取和数据收集过程,为开展第五章和第六章的计量分析奠定基础。
     第五章为合作社对农户生产效益的影响研究,建立用以检验合作社是否影响农户的资金成本、自有劳动力成本、每亩产量、产品销售价格、每亩收益和净收益等生产效益指标的数理模型,检验结果显示,合作社社员的资金投入成本、产品价格、每亩收益和净收益都显著高于非社员农户,但是社员和非社员的自有劳动力成本和每亩产量并没有表现出显著性差异。
     第六章为合作社对农户规模效率的影响研究,参照Battese & Coelli(1992)的经典前沿生产函数,结合柯布-道格拉斯生产函数,建立分组的随机前沿生产函数模型,将规模效率分解为面积规模效率、资金规模效率、自有劳动力规模效率,对社员和非社员两组农户的各个规模效率指标进行比较分析,模型结果表明,合作社提高了社员农户的总规模效率,同时对规模效率的结构产生了较为显著的影响;相对于非社员农户,社员的种植面积规模效率明显较高,但资金规模效率和自有劳动力规模效率较低;小规模和大规模社员农户的规模效率得到了较为显著的提高,但是这种效应没有对中等规模社员起作用。
     第七章为本研究的结论和展望,对本研究做概括性的总结,提出一些政策含义,并展望今后可进一步研究的问题。
Nowadays as the economy developing and market perfecting, agriculture production is changing from production oriented to market oriented, agriculture product transactions depend more and more on characteristics of products, transaction participators, and transaction as well, and governance structure is transferring from market exchange toward contracting and vertical integration. The improving production methods, increased concentration in the supply chain, lower world prices and more open markets to international competition are all threatening to small farmers.
     The product supply chain in China at present is diversified and undergoing transformation in both structure and management. It includes not only the traditional production-supply-marketing system constituting of small farm households, peddlers, processing enterprises, wholesalers, and retailers, but also new retailers such as farmer cooperatives, supermarkets, and specialized distribution centers. Therefore, is farmer cooperative, as a representative of small farmers, able to help farmers out and bring farmers economic benefits? That's the question we are going to answer in our research. Although there are abundant studies on this issue, most of answers to which being positive, there are still skeptical voices. Besides, most of existing studies are qualititive studies and case studies, whereas seldom is devoted to theoretical model derivation or mathematical model examination.
     This study examines the hypothesis that cooperatives have an influence on farmers' economic benefits by answering three questions. Firstly, what are the prices and payoffs farmers obtain in a market without cooperatives and a market with cooperative respectively? Secondly, are there different production profits between cooperative members and non-member farmers? Thirdly, do cooperative members and non-member farmers differ in scale efficiencies in production?
     There are some distinct characteristics in the study. (1) A theoretical model based on game theory is formulated to imitate and deduce enterprises'pricing decision and farmers' outlet choice in product marketing market. It is a creative and tentative research method applying to study farmer cooperatives in China. (2) The empirical study focuses on a specific product, i.e. pear in Zhejiang province, China. And classical mathematical models and econometric softwares are applied to examine the hypotheses. (3) The theoretical model comes to some conclusions with broad and general application, while the empirical analyses draw out some results which are of significantly practical meaning to specific area and industry.
     Main contents and results of the studies are:
     ChapterⅠis introduction. The research background, research objectives, and research questions are introduced, research technology roadmap and paper framework are formulated, and various research methods applied in the research are described. In addition, some innovation points and shortages of the research are concluded.
     ChapterⅡis dedicated to literature review. Some theories related to farmer cooperatives, agriculture production efficiency, and scale efficiency are covered and sorted out. The research points are formulated when awaring that there are shortages and vacuum in quantitive studies pertaining to the impact of cooperatives on farmers' production profits and efficiencies.
     ChapterⅢformulates a game model of farmers'choices for organizational forms in alternative market structures, i.e. pure IOF market, IOF-Coop mixed market, and pure cooperative market. According to the sub-game perfect equilibrium results, farmers gain a small profit in a pure IOF market; the presence of cooperatives in market increases farmers'payoffs; although farmers gain the largest payoffs in a pure cooperative market, the free riding problem in a pure cooperative market leads to unreasonable or inefficient resource distribution.
     ChapterⅣintroduces farmer cooperatives and pear industry development in Zhejiang province. Reasons for choosing pear industry in Zhejiang province as the population of emprical studies are explained. Then methods of sampling and data collection are elaborated. This chapter lays the foundation for emprical studies in the next two chapters.
     ChapterⅤis devoted to the emprical study on the influence of cooperatives on farmers' production profits. A statistical model is formulated to examine if cooperatives have an impact on members'capital cost, family labor cost, yield per mu, product price, income per mu, and net income per mu in pear production. The results show that members have higher capital cost, product price, pear production incomeper mu, and net income per mu than non-members do. However, there is no significant difference in family labor investment or yield per mu between members and non-members.
     Chapter VI examines the influence of cooperatives on members'scale efficiency. Borrowing the classical frontier production function and Cobb-Douglas production function, a stochastic frontier production function model is established. By grouping farmers into members and non-members, scale efficiencies, including production area scale efficiency, capital scale efficiency, and family labor scale efficiency, are calculated and compared between the two groups. The results indicate that (1) cooperatives enhance the general scale efficiency of members; (2) members have a significantly higher production area scale efficiency than non-members, whereas non-members have higher capital scale efficiency and family labor scale efficiency; (3) cooperatives help to increase members with small production area and large production aear, rather than members with middle production area.
     Finally, some conclutions, policy implications, and further researches in future are summed up in chapter VII.
引文
[1]Afriat, S. N. Efficiency estimation of production functions. International Economic Review.1972,13(3),568-598.
    [2]Aigner, D. J.,& Chu, S. F. On estimating the industry production function. The American Economic Review,1968,58(4),826-839.
    [3]Aigner, D., Lovell, C.,& Schmidt, P. Formulation and estimation of stochastic frontier production function models. Journal of econometrics,1977,6(1),21-37.
    [4]Akridge, J. T.,& Hertel, T. W. Cooperative and investor-oriented firm efficiency: A multiproduct analysis. Journal of Agricultural Cooperation,1992,7,1-14
    [5]Albaek S.,& Schultz, C. On the relative advantage of cooperatives. Economic Letters,1998,59,397-401.
    [6]Alvarez, A. M., Fidalgo, E. G., Sexton, R. J., et al. Oligopsony power with uniform spatial pricing:Theory and application to milk processing in Spain. European Review of Agricultural Economics,2000,27(3),347-364.
    [7]Antle, J. M. The new economics of agriculture. American Journal of Agricultural Economics,1999,81(5),993-1010.
    [8]Azzam, A.,& Andersson, H. Measuring price effects of concentration in mixed oligopoly:An application to the Swedish beef-slaughter industry. Journal of Industry, Competition and Trade,2008,8(1),21-31.
    [9]Barton, D. G. What is a cooperative? in Cobia D.W. (ed.). Cooperatives in Agriculture. Prentice-Hall, Inc. New Jersey,1989,1-1.
    [10]Basu, S.,& Fernald, J. G. Returns to scale in US production:Estimates and implications. Journal of political economy,1997,105(2),249-283.
    [11]Battese, G. E.,& Coelli, T. J. A model for technical inefficiency effects in a stochastic frontier production function for panel data. Empirical economics, 1995,20(2),325-332.
    [12]Battese, G. E.,& Coelli, T. J. A stochastic frontier production function incorporating a model for technical inefficiency effects. Working Papers in Econometrics and Applied Statistics,1993.
    [13]Battese, G. E.,& Coelli, T. J. Frontier production functions, technical efficiency and panel data:with application to paddy farmers in India. Journal of productivity analysis,1992,3(1),153-169.
    [14]Battese, G. E.,& Coelli, T. J. Prediction of firm-level technical efficiencies with a generalized frontier production function and panel data. Journal of econometrics,1988,38(3),387-399.
    [15]Battese, G. E.,& Corra, G. S. Estimation of a production frontier model:with application to the pastoral zone of Eastern Australia. Australian Journal of Agricultural Economics,1977,21(3),169-179.
    [16]Boger, S. Quality and contractual choice:a transaction cost approach to the Polish hog market. European Review of Agricultural Economics,2001,28(3),241-261.
    [17]Bonus, H. The cooperative association as a business enterprise. A study in the economics of transactions. The New institutional economics:a collection of articles from the Journal of institutional and theoretical economics,1991,142-171.
    [18]Boyle, G. E. The economic efficiency of Irish dairy marketing co-operatives. Agribusiness,2004,20(2),143-153.
    [19]Bresnahan, T. F. Empirical studies of industries with market power. Handbook of industrial organization,1989,2,1011-1057.
    [20]Brester, G. W.,& Boland, M. A. The Rocky Mountain Sugar Growers' Cooperative:"Sweet" or "Sugar-Coated" Visions of the Future?. Applied Economic Perspectives and Policy,2004,26(2),287-302.
    [21]Bruce, F. H.,& Le Veen, E. P. Farm size and economic efficiency:the case of California. American Journal of Agricultural Economics,1978,60(4),589-600.
    [22]Carlton, D. W.,& Perloff, J. M. Modern Industrial Organization. Scott, Foresman/Little, Brown High Education,1990,526-526.
    [23]Caswell, J. Vertical Quality control systems:a potential marketing advantage for cooperatives, in:R.W. Cotterill (ed), Competitive strategy analysis for agricultural marketing cooperatives. Boulder, etc.:Westview Press,1994.
    [24]Caswell, J.,& Roberts, T. Vertical quality control systems:A potential marketing advantage for cooperatives, in Cotterill R. W. (ed.), Competitive Strategy Analysis for Agricultural Marketing Cooperatives. Boulder:Westview Press,1994,145-169.
    [25]Chaddad, F. R.,& Cook, M. L. An ownership rights typology of cooperative models. Department of Agricultural Economics, Working Paper, No. AEWP,2002,6.
    [26]Chaddad, F. R.,& Cook, M. L. The emergence of non-traditional cooperative structures:public and private policy issues. Working paper, http://ageconsearch. umn.edu/bitstream/31799/1/cp03ch13.pdf.
    [27]Charnes, A., Cooper, W. W.,& Rhodes, E. Measuing the efficiency of decision making units. European. Journal of Operational Research,1978,2,429-444.
    [28]Chen, K. S., Babb, E. M.,& Schrader, L. F. Growth of large cooperative and proprietary firms in the US food sector. Agribusiness,1985,1 (2),201-210.
    [29]Choi, E. K.,& Feinerman, E. Producer cooperatives, input pricing and land allocation. Journal of Agricultural Economics,1993,44(2),230-244.
    [30]Clark, E. Farmer cooperatives and economic welfare. Journal of Farm Economics,1952,34(1),35-51.
    [31]Coase, R. H. The nature of the firm. Economica n. s.,1937,4(16),386-405.
    [32]Coelli, T. J. A guide to frontier version 4.1:a computer program for stochastic frontier production and cost function estimation. Centre for Efficiency and Productivity Analysis, University of New England, Armidale, Australia,1996.
    [33]Cook, M. L. The future of US agricultural cooperatives:A neo-institutional approach. American Journal of Agricultural Economics,1995,77(5),1153-1159.
    [34]Cook, M. L. The role of management behavior in agricultural cooperatives. Journal of Agricultural Cooperation,1994,9,42-58.
    [35]Cook, M. L.,& Burress, M. J. A cooperative life cycle framework. University of Missouri, Columbia, working paper,2009.
    [36]Cook, M. L.,& Chaddad, F. R. Redesigning cooperative boundaries:The emergence of new models. American Journal of Agricultural Economics,2004, 86(5),1249-1253.
    [37]Cotterill, R. W. Agricultural cooperatives:A unified theory of pricing, finance, and investment, in Cooperative Theory:New approaches, ACS Service Report no.18, Toyer J. (ed.), Washington, D.C.:United States Department of Agriculture,1987,171-251.
    [38]Deinlnger, K.,& Binswanger, H. The evolution of the World Bank's land policy: principles, experience, and future challenges. The World Bank Research Observer,1993,14(2),247-276.
    [39]Deller, S., Hoyt, A., Hueth, B., and Sundaram-Stukel, R. Research on the economic impact of cooperatives. Working paper,2009.
    [40]Deprins, D.,& Simar, L. Estimating technical inefficiencies with correction for environmental conditions. Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics,1989a, 60(1),81-102.
    [41]Deprins, D.,& Simar, L. Estimation of Deterministic Frontiers with Exogenous Factors of Inefficiency. Annals of Economics and Statistics (Paris),1989b, 14,117-150.
    [42]Diewert, W. E.,& Fox, K. J. On the estimation of returns to scale, technical progress and monopolistic markups. Journal of econometrics,2008,145(2), 174-193.
    [43]Doucouliagos, H.& Hone, P. The efficiency of the Australian dairy processing industry. Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics,2000, 44(3),423-438.
    [44]Drivas, K.,& Giannakas, K. The effect of cooperatives on quality-enhancing innovation. Journal of Agricultural Economics,2010,61(2),295-317.
    [45]Drivas, K.,& Giannakas, K. The effect of marketing cooperatives on cost-reducing process innovation activity. Paper presented at conference "American Agricultural Economics Association" (New Name 2008: Agricultural and Applied Economics Association),2007.
    [46]Druska, V.,& Horrace, W. C. Generalized moments estimation for spatial panel data:Indonesian rice farming. American Journal of Agricultural Economics,2004,86(1),185.
    [47]Dubey, P.,& Geanakoplos, J. Competitive pooling:Rothschild-Stiglitz reconsidered. Cowles Foundation for Research in Economics, Yale University, Discussion Paper,2002.
    [48]Duval, Y.,& Biere, A. Grain Producers' Attitudes to New Forms of Supply Chain Coordination. International Food and Agribusiness Management Review, 1998,1(2),179-193.
    [49]Eilers, C.,& Hanf, C. H. Contracts between farmers and farmers-processing cooperatives:A principal-agent approach for the potato starch industry, in Heidelberg (ed.) Vertical Relationships and Coordination in the Food System, 1999,267-284.
    [50]Emelianoff, I. V. Economic theory of co-operatives. Washington DC:Edward Brothers, Int.,1942.
    [51]Enke, S. Consumer cooperatives and economic efficiency. The American Economic Review,1945,35(1),148-155.
    [52]Evans, L.,& Meade, R. The Role and Significance of Cooperatives in New Zealand Agriculture:A Comparative Institutional Analysis. Wellington:New Zealand Institute for the Study of Competition and Regulation, Inc,2006.
    [53]Fafchamps, M., Gabre-Madhin, E.,& Minten, B. Increasing returns and market efficiency in agricultural trade. Journal of Development Economics,2005,78(2), 406-442.
    [54]Fama, E. F. Agency Problems and the Theory of the Firm. The Journal of Political Economy,1980,88(2),288.
    [55]Farrell, M. J. The measurement of productive efficiency. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society. Series A (General),1957,120(3),253-290.
    [56]Featherstone, A. M.,& Rahman, M. Nonparametric analysis of the optimizing behavior of Midwestern cooperatives. Review of Agricultural Economics,1996, 18(2),265-273.
    [57]Feinerman, E.,& Falkovitz, M. S. An agricultural multipurpose service cooperative:Pareto optimality, price-tax solution, and stability. Journal of Comparative Economics,1991,15(1),95-114.
    [58]Ferrier, G. D.,& Porter, P. K. The productive efficiency of us milk processing co-operatives. Journal of Agricultural Economics,1991,42(2),161-173.
    [59]Fosund, F. R.,& Jansen, E. S. On estimating average and best practice homothetic production functions via cost functions. International Economic Review,1977,18(2),463-476.
    [60]Fulton, M.,& Sanderson, K. Co-operatives and farmers in the new agriculture, working paper, Centre for the Study of Co-operatives, University of Saskatchewan,2002.
    [61]Fulton, M.,& Giannakas, K. Organizational commitment in a mixed oligopoly: Agricultural cooperatives and investor-owned firms. American Journal of Agricultural Economics,2001,83(5),1258-1265.
    [62]Garcia, P., Sonka, S. T., and Yoo, M. S. Farm size, tenure, and economic efficiency in a sample of Illinois grain farms, American Journal of Agricultural Economics,1982,64(1),119-123.
    [63]Giannakas, K.,& Fulton, M. Process innovation activity in a mixed oligopoly: The role of cooperatives. American Journal of Agricultural Economics,2005, 87(2),406-422.
    [64]Good, D. H., Roller, L. H.,& Sickles, R. C. Airline efficiency differences between Europe and the US:Implications for the pace of EC integration and domestic regulation. European Journal of Operational Research,1995,80(3), 508-518.
    [65]Griffiths, W. E.,& O'Donnell, C. J. Estimating variable returns to scale production frontiers with alternative stochastic assumptions. Journal of Econometrics, 2005,126(2),385-40.
    [66]Grosskopf, S., Hayes, K. J., Taylor, L. L., et al. Budget-constrained frontier measures of fiscal equality and efficiency in schooling. Review of Economics and Statistics,1997,79(1),116-124.
    [67]Hailu, G., Jeffrey, S.,& Unterschultz, J. Cost efficiency for Alberta and Ontario dairy farms:an interregional comparison. Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics,2005,53(2-3),141-160.
    [68]Hansmann, H. The ownership of enterprise. Harvard University Press,1996.
    [69]Hansmann, H. Cooperative firms in theory and practice. LTA,1999,48(4), 404-417.
    [70]Hansmann, H. The changing roles of public, private, and nonprofit enterprise in education, health care, and other human services, in Fucbs V. R. (ed.) Individual and social responsibility:Child care, education, medical care, and long-term care in America. The University of Chicago Press, Ltd., Londaon, 1996,245-275.
    [71]Hansmann, H. The ownership of enterprise, Belknap Press,2000.
    [72]Hardesty, S. D.,& Salgia, V. D. Comparative financial performance of agricultural cooperatives and investor-owned firms. Working paper,2004, http://www.agecon.k-state.edu/accc/ncera194/Events/2004meeting/Hardesty.pdf.
    [73]Harris, A.,& Fulton, M. E. Comparative financial performance analysis of canadian co-operatives, investor-owned firms, and industry norms. Centre for the Study of Co-operatives, University of Saskatchewan, working paper,1996.
    [74]Hart, O.,& Moore, J. The governance of exchanges:members' cooperatives versus outside ownership. Oxford Review of Economic Policy,1996,12(4),53-69.
    [75]Hart, O.,& Moore, J. Cooperatives vs. outside ownership. National Bureau of Economic Research Cambridge, Mass., USA,1998.
    [76]Harvey Jr, S. J.,& Sykuta, M. E. Farmer trust in producer- and investor-owned firms:Evidence from Missouri corn and soybean producers. Agribusiness, 2006,22(1),135-153.
    [77]Hayek, F. A. The use of knowledge in society. American Economic Review, 1945,35 (4),519-520.
    [78]Hazell, P., Poulton, C., and Wiggins, S., The future of small farms:synthesis paper, Based on Research Workshop organized by IFPRI, ODI and Imperial College, Wye,2006.
    [79]Heckman, J. J. Sample selection bias as a specification error. Econometrica: Journal of the econometric society,1979,47(1),153-161.
    [80]Helmberger, P.,& Hoos, S. Cooperative enterprise and organization theory. Journal of Farm Economics,1962,44(2),275-290.
    [81]Helmberger, P.,& Hoos, S. Cooperative enterprise and organization theory. Journal of Farm Economics,1962,44(2),275-290.
    [82]Helmberger, P. G. Cooperative enterprise as a structural dimension of farm markets. Journal of Farm Economics,1964,46(3),603-617.
    [83]Helper, S. How much has really changed between U. S. manufactures and their suppliers? Sloan Management Review,1991,32(4),15-28.
    [84]Hendrikse, G. Grower heterogeneity and governance:Authority, access, and countervailing power. Selected paper presented at the Conference "American Agricultural Economics Association Annual",2004.
    [85]Hendrikse, G. W. J. Contingent control rights in agricultural cooperatives. Strategies for Cooperation. Shaker Verlag,2005,385-394.
    [86]Hendrikse, G. W. J. On the Nature of a Cooperative:A System of Attributes Perspective. Working paper, Erasmus Research Institute of Management, Erasmus University,2007.
    [87]Hendrikse, G. W. J. Restructuring agricultural cooperatives. Erasmus University Rotterdam,2004.
    [88]Hendrikse, G. W. J. Screening, Competition and the Choice of the Cooperative as an Organisational Form. Journal of Agricultural Economics,1998,49,202-217.
    [89]Hendrikse, G.,& Bijman, W. On the emergence of growers associations: Self-selection versus market power. European Review of Agricultural Economics,2002,29(2),255-269.
    [90]Hendrikse, G.,& Bijman, W. Ownership structure in agrifood chains:The marketing cooperative. Americon Journal of Agricultural Economics,2002, 84(1),104-119.
    [91]Hendrikse, G.,& Veerman, C. P. Marketing cooperatives and financial structure:a transaction costs economics analysis. Agricultural Economics,2001,26(3),205-216.
    [92]Herath, D., Hassan, Z.,& Henson, S. Adoption of food safety and quality controls:Do firm characteristics matter? Evidence from the Canadian food processing sector. Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics,2007,55(3), 299-314.
    [93]Herbst, P.,& Prufer, J. Firms, nonprofits and cooperatives:a theory of organizational choice, Working paper,2007, papers.ssrn.com.
    [94]Hoffmann, R. Ownership structure and endogenous quality choice:Cooperatives versus investor-owned firms. Journal of Agricultural & Food Industrial Organization,2005,3(8),1-24.
    [95]Holmstrom, M. B. Future of cooperatives:A corporate perspective. LTA,1999, 4,404-417.
    [96]Hu D., Reardon, T.,& Rozelle, S. The emergence of supermarkets with Chinese Characteristics:Challenges and opportunities for China's agricultural development, Development Policy Review,2004,22(5),557-586.
    [97]Huang, C. J.,& Liu, J. T. Estimation of a non-neutral stochastic frontier production function. Journal of Productivity Analysis,1994,5(2),171-180.
    [98]Jaforullah, M.,& Devlin, N. J. Technical efficiency in the New Zealand dairy industry:a frontier production function approach. New Zealand Economic Papers,1996,30,1-7.
    [99]James, Jr, H. S.,& Sykuta, M. E. Property right and organizational characteristics of producer owned firms and organizational trust. Annals of public and cooperative economics,2005,76(4),545-580.
    [100]Johnson, N. L.,& Ruttan, V. W. Why are farms so small? World Development, 1994,22(5),691-706.
    [101]Karantinis, K.,& Zago, A. Endogenous membership in mixed duopolies. American Journal of Agricultural Economics,2001,83(5),1266-1272.
    [102]Koopmans, T. C. Activity analysis of production and allocation. New York, 1951, http://cowles.econ.yale.edu/P/cm/m13/m13-03.pdf.
    [103]Kumbhakar, S. C.,& Lovell, C. A. K. Stochastic Frontier Analysis. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge,2003.
    [104]Kumbhakar, S. C., Ghosh, S.,& McGuckin, J. T. A generalized production frontier approach for estimating determinants of inefficiency in US dairy farms. Journal of Business & Economic Statistics,1991,9(3),279-286.
    [105]Kurkalova, L.,& Jensen, H. Production efficiency in Ukrainian agriculture and the process of economic reform. Centre for Agricultural and Rural Development, Iowa State University, working paper,1996,10,96-167.
    [106]Lee, L. F.,& Tyler, W. G. The stochastic frontier production function and average efficiency. An empirical analysis. Journal of Econometrics,1978,7(3), 385-389.
    [107]Lee, Y. H. A stochastic production frontier model with group-specific temporal variation in technical efficiency. European Journal of Operational Research, 2006,174(3),1616-1630.
    [108]Lee, Y. H.,& Schmidt, P. A. production frontier model with flexible temporal variation in technical efficiency. The Measurement of Productive Efficiency: Techniques and Applications,1993,237-255.
    [109]Lerman, Z.,& Parliament, C. Comparative performance of food-processing cooperatives and investor-owned firms. Agribusiness,1990,6(6),527-540.
    [110]LeVay, C. Agricultural co-operative theory:A review. Journal of Agricultural Economics,1983,34(1),1-44.
    [111]Li, S., Ye, B.,& Yu, J. Incentives and quality provision in organizations: cooperative vs IOF. Working paper,2010.
    [112]Ling, K. C. Dairy cooperative's role in vertical coordination, in Royer, J. S.,& Rogers, R. T. (ed.), The Industrialization of Agriculture:Vertical coordination in the US food system. Ashgate,1998.
    [113]Lovell, M. C.,& Selover, D. D. Econometric software accidents. The Economic Journal,1994,104(424),713-725.
    [114]MacPherson, I. The ICA Statement on the Co-operative Identity. Co-operative Principles for the 21st Century,1996.
    [115]Meeusen, W.& Van Den Broeck, J. Efficiency estimation from Cobb-Douglas production functions with composed error. International Economic Review, 1977,18(2),435-444.
    [116]Milford, A. Coffee, co-operatives and competition:the impact of fair trade. CMI Report 2004, Chr. Michelsen Institute, http://bora.cmi.no/dspace/handle /10202/143.
    [117]Mohammad, J.,& Whiteman, J., Scale efficiency in the New Zealand dairy industry:a non-parametric approach. The Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics,1999,43(4),523-541.
    [118]Mosheim, R. Organizational type and efficiency in the Costa Rican coffee processing Sector. Journal of Comparative Economics,2002,30(2),296-316.
    [119]Narayanan, S.,& Gulati, A. Globalization and the smallholders. MTID discussion papers,2002.
    [120]Notta, O.,& Vlachvei, A. Performance of cooperatives and investor-owned firms:The case of the Greek dairy industry, in Karantininis, K.,& Nilsson, J. (ed.) Vertical Markets and Cooperative Hierarchies. Springer,2007,275-285.
    [121]Nourse, E. G. The economic philosophy of cooperation. American Economic Review,1922,12,577-597.
    [122]Nourse, E. G. The place of the cooperative in our national economy. Journal of Agricultural Cooperation,1942,33-39.
    [123]Novkovic, S. Defining the co-operative difference. Journal of Socio-Economics, 2008,37(6),2168-2177.
    [124]Parcell, J., Schroeder, T., Kastens, T., et al. Perceptions of marketing efficiency and strategies:research vs. extension marketing economists. Working paper,1998.
    [125]Parliament, C., Lerman, Z.,& Fulton, J. Performance of cooperatives and investor owned firms in the dairy industry. Staff Papers,1989.
    [126]Pattison, D. Agricultural cooperatives in selected transitional countries. Discussion paper, International Cooperative Agricultural Organization,2000.
    [127]Phillips, R. Economic nature of the cooperative association. Journal of Farm Economics,1953,35(1),74-87.
    [128]Porter, P. K.,& Scully, G. W. Economic efficiency in cooperatives. The Journal of Law and Economics,1987,30(2),489-512.
    [129]Rhodes, V. J. The large agricultural cooperative as a competitor. American Journal of Agricultural Economics,1983,65(5),1090-1095.
    [130]Robotka, F. A theory of cooperation. Journal of Farm Economics,1947,29, 94-114.
    [131]Royer, J. Cooperative forward integration in oligopsonistic markets, in Karantininis, K.,& Nilsson, J. (ed.) Vertical Markets and Cooperative Hierarchies:The Role of Cooperatives in the Agri-Food Industry,2007,169-194.
    [132]Royer, J. S. Potential for cooperative involvement in vertical coordination and value-added activities. Agribusiness,1995,11(5),473-481.
    [133]Royer, J. S.,& Bhuyan, S. Forward integration by farmer cooperatives: Comparative incentives and impacts. Journal of Cooperatives,1995,10,33-48.
    [134]Royer, J. S.,& Smith, D. B. Patronage refunds, producer expectations, and optimal pricing by agricultural cooperatives. Journal of Cooperatives,2007,20,1-16.
    [135]Rsund, F. R.,& Hjalmarsson, L. Generalized Farrell measures of efficiency:an application to milk processing in Swedish dairy plants. The Economic Journal, 1979,89(354),294-315.
    [136]Saitone, T. L.,& Sexton, R. J. Optimal cooperative pooling in a quality-differentiated market. American Journal of Agricultural Economics,2009, 91(5),1224-1232.
    [137]Savage, J. K. Comment on "Economic Nature of the Cooperative Association". Journal of Farm Economics,1954,36(3),529-534.
    [138]Schrader, L. F. Equity capital and restructuring of cooperatives as investor-oriented firms. Journal of Agricultural Cooperation,1989,4(4),41-53.
    [139]Sexton, R. J. Imperfect competition in agricultural markets and the role of cooperatives:A spatial analysis. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 1990,72(3),709-720.
    [140]Sexton, R. J. The formation of cooperatives:A game-theoretic approach with implications for cooperative finance, decision making, and stability. American Journal of Agricultural Economics,1986,68(2),214-225.
    [141]Sexton, R. J.,& Iskow, J. The competitive role of cooperatives in market-oriented economies:A policy analysis, in Csaki, C.,& Kislev, Y. (ed.), Agricultural Cooperatives in Transition, Boulder Colo.:Westview Press,1993,55-83.
    [142]Sexton, R. J., Wilson, B. M.,& Wann, J. J. Some tests of the economic theory of cooperatives:Methodology and application to cotton ginning. Western Journal of Agricultural Economics,1989,14(1),56-66.
    [143]Shaffer, J. D. Thinking about farmers'co-operatives, contracts, and economic coordination, in Toyer, J. S. (ed.), Cooperative Theory:New Approaches, Washington D. C.:Agricultural Co-operative Service, U. S. Department of Agriculture,1987,33-60.
    [144]Simon, H. A. Models of man. Wiley New York,1957.
    [145]Singh, S., Coelli, T.,& Fleming, E. Measurement of technical, allocative, and economic efficiency in Indian dairy processing plants:an input distance function approach. Working Paper, Department of Econometrics, University of New England,2000.
    [146]Staatz, J. M. A game-theoretic analysis of decision making in farmer cooperatives. Cooperative theory:New approaches,1987(18),117-147.
    [147]Staatz, J. M. Farmer cooperative theory:Recent developments. ACS Research Reports No.84,1989, Washington, DC:USDA.
    [148]Staatz, J. M. The cooperative as a coalition:a game-theoretic approach. American Journal of Agricultural Economics,1983,65(5),1084-1089.
    [149]Subal, C. K. Short-run returns to scale, farm size, and economic efficiency. The Review of Economics and Statistics,1993,75 (2),336-341.
    [150]Summer, D. A.,& Leiby, J. D. An econometric analysis of the effect of human capital on size and growth among dairy farms. American Journal of Agricultural Economics,1987,69,465-470.
    [151]Swinnen, J., Rozelle, S., Xiang, T., et al. A theory of standards-driven rural development. LICOS Discussion paper No.199,2008, Leuven.
    [152]Tennbakk, B. Marketing cooperatives in mixed duopolies. Journal of Agricultural Economics,1995,46(1),33-45.
    [153]Tina, L. S.,& Richard, J. S. Optimal cooperative pooling in a quality-differentiated market. Paper presented at International Conference Rural Cooperative in the 21st Century:Lessons from the Past, Pathways to the Future, June 14-17,2009, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Israel.
    [154]Tribl, C. Spatial competition of food processing cooperatives in a mixed market-the case of uniform delivered pricing. Working paper, Federal Institute of Agricultural Economics, Austria,2009.
    [155]Trifon, R. The economics of cooperative ventures:further comments. Journal of Farm Economics,1961,43(2),215-235.
    [156]Valentinov, V. Why are cooperatives important in agriculture? An organizational economics perspective. Journal of institutional Economics,2007,3(1),55-69.
    [157]Van Sickle, J.J.,& Ladd, G.W. A model of cooperative finance. American Journal of Agricultural Economics,1983,65(2),273-281.
    [158]Vandeplas, A., Minten, B.,& Swinnen, J. F. M. On food quality in domestic markets of developing economies. Contributed paper prepared for presentation at the International Association of Agricultural Economists Conference, Beijing, China, August 16-22,2009.
    [159]Vernimmen, T., Verbeke, W.,& Van Huylenbroeck, G. Transaction cost analysis of outsourcing farm administration by Belgian farmers. European Review of Agricultural Economics,2000,27(3),325-345.
    [160]Vitaliano, P. Cooperative enterprise:An alternative conceptual basis for analyzing a complex institution. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 1983,65(5),1078-1083.
    [161]Von Braun, J. The world food situation:an overview. http://citeseerx.ist.psu. edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.78.1191&rep=rep1&type=pdf,2005.
    [162]Wann, J. J.,& Sexton, R. J. Imperfect competition in multiproduct food industries with application to pear processing. American Journal of Agricultural Economics,1992,74(4),980-990.
    [163]Williamson, O. E. Transaction cost economics:The governance of contractual relations. Journal of Law and Economics,1979,22,233-262.
    [164]Williamson, O. E.,& Ouchi, W. G. The markets and hierarchies and visible hand perspectives, in A. H. Van de Ven and W.H. Joyce (ed.), Perspectives on Organization Design and Behavior, New York:Wiley,1981,387-390.
    [165]Williamson, O. E. Markets and Hierarchies. New York:Free Press,1975.
    [166]Williamson, O. E. The economics of governance:framework and implications. Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics,1984,140(1),195-223.
    [167]Williamson, O. E. The economic institutions of capitalism. New York:Free Press,1985.
    [168]Williamson, O. E. Transaction cost economics:The governance of contractual relations, Journal of Law and Economics,1979,22(2),233-261.
    [169]Yu, J. Quality provision and farmer inclusion of agricultural cooperatives. Paper presented at the 27th International Association of Agricultural Economics (IAAE) Conference, August 16-22,2009, Beijing, China.
    [170]Ziegenhorn, R. Networking the farm:The social structure of cooperation and competition in Iowa agriculture. UK:Ashgate,1999.
    [171]Zusman, P.,& Rausser, G. C. Intra-organizational influence relations and the optimality of collective action. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 1994,24(1),1-17.
    [172]Zusman, P. Constitutional selection of collective-choice rules in a cooperative enterprise. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization,1992,17(3),353-362.
    [173]蔡臣臣.论农民合作经济组织与农业规模经济的实现.现代商贸工业,2008,20(10),25-27.
    [174]陈欣欣,史清华,蒋伟峰.不同经营规模农地效益的比较及其演变趋势分析.农业经济问题,2000(12),6-9.
    [175]范里安·R.哈尔[美].微观经济学:现代观点. (第六版),上海:上海三联出版社,上海人民出版社,2006.
    [176]范艳芝.一个蔬菜专业合作社的产业化发展调查.中国合作经济,2008(4),60-61
    [177]高贵如,王双进.基于交易成本的农民合作组织需求分析.中国经济评论,2007,7(10),60-62.
    [178]顾建列,赵静方.合作拓宽增收路——来自尧南村三个合作社的调查.江苏农村经济,2005(6),21-23.
    [179]郭红东.我国农户参与订单农业行为的影响因素分析.中国农村经济,2005(3),24-32.
    [180]郭红东,黄祖辉.以兔业合作社为龙头 促进农业产业化经营—新昌兔业合作社的实践与启示.中国农村经济,2001(4),24-28.
    [181]郭红东,蒋文华.影响农户参与专业合作经济组织行为的因素分析.经济研究参考,2004(63),29-29.
    [182]郭红东,袁路明,林迪.影响社员对合作社满意度因素的分析.西北农林科技大学学报:社会科学版,2009,9(5),32-36.
    [183]黄利军,胡同泽.基于数据包络法(DEA)的中国西部地区农业生产效率分析.农业现代化研究,2006(6),420-423.
    [184]黄胜忠.农业合作社的环境适应性分析.开放时代,2009a(4),27-35.
    [185]黄胜忠.农业合作社理论研究述评.商业研究,2009b(3),175-179.
    [186]黄胜忠,林坚,徐旭初.农民专业合作社治理机制及其绩效实证分析[J].中国农村经济,2008(3),65-73.
    [187]黄胜忠,徐旭初.成员异质性与农民专业合作社的组织结构分析.南京农业大学学报:社会科学版,2008,8(3),1-7.
    [188]黄祖辉,陈欣欣.农户粮田规模经营效率:实证分析与若干结论.农业经 济问题,1998,19(11),2-7.
    [189]黄祖辉.农民合作:必然性,变革态势与启示.中国农村经济,2000(8),4-8.
    [190]黄祖辉.科学认识和发展农业合作组织.浙江经济,2008a(020),28-29.
    [191]黄祖辉.中国农民合作组织发展的若干理论与实践问题.中国农村经济,2008b(11),4-8.
    [192]黄祖辉.让合作社成为农村产业化经营的主力军.中国合作经济,2009(10),46-47.
    [193]黄祖辉,梁巧.小农户参与大市场的集体行动.农业经济问题,2007(9),66-71.
    [194]黄祖辉,梁巧.梨果供应链中不同组织的效率及其对农户的影响—基于浙江省的实证调研数据.西北农林科技大学学报:社会科学版,2009,9(001),36-40.
    [195]黄祖辉,刘东英.我国农产品物流体系建设与制度分析.农业经济问题,2005(4),49-53.
    [196]黄祖辉,徐旭初.农民专业合作组织发展的影响因素分析——对浙江省农民专业合作组织发展现状的探讨.中国农村经济,2002(3),13-21.
    [197]黄祖辉,徐旭初.大力发展农民专业合作经济组织.农业经济问题,2003(5),41-45.
    [198]黄祖辉,徐旭初.基于能力和关系的合作治理——对浙江省农民专业合作社治理结构的解释.浙江社会科学,2006(1),60-66.
    [199]黄祖辉,徐旭初.中国农民合作经济组织发展30年.国际学术动态,2009(5),8-12.
    [200]基思·格里芬[美].可供选择的经济发展战略.北京:经济科学出版社1992.
    [201]蒋东生.关于培育农民合作社问题的思考.管理世界,2004(7),136-137.
    [202]金剑,李伟,河北农业生产技术效率损失及其影响因素分析.商业研究,2010(5),145-148.
    [203]亢霞,刘秀梅.我国粮食生产的技术效率分析——基于随机前沿分析方法.中国农村观察,2005(4),25-32.
    [204]李相宏.农业规模经营模式分析.农业经济问题,2003(8),48-51.
    [205]李岳云,蓝海涛,方晓军.不同经营规模农户经营行为的研究.中国农村观察,1999(4),39-45.
    [206]雷贵荣,胡震云,韩刚.基于SFA的农业用水技术效率和节水潜力研究.水利经济,2010(01),55-58.
    [207]林迪,郭红东.农民专业合作社发展:基于部分合作社社员的调查与分析.农业经济,2009(2),81-82.
    [208]林坚,马彦丽.农业合作社和投资者所有企业的边界——基于交易费用和 组织成本角度的分析.农业经济问题,2006(3),16-20.
    [209]刘雪妮,刘雪梅,席晓宇.基于Malmquist指数的农业生产效率分析——以山东省为例.价值工程,2008(6),20-22.
    [210]刘勇.西方农业合作社理论文献综述.华南农业大学学报:社会科学版,2009,8(4),54-63.
    [211]卢向虎,吕新业,秦富.农户参加农民专业合作组织意愿的实证分析—基于7省24市(县)农户的调研数据.农业经济问题,2008(1),26-31.
    [212]罗必良.农地经营规模的效率决定.中国农村观察,2000(5),18-24.
    [213]马彦丽,孟彩英.我国农民专业合作社的双重委托—代理关系——兼论存在的问题及改进思路.农业经济问题,2008(5),55-60.
    [214]缪建平.再论高度重视农民专业合作组织的作用.农村合作经济经营管理,1999,10:26-29.
    [215]乔世君.中国粮食生产技术效率的实证研究——随机前沿面生产函数的应用.数理统计与管理,2004,23(3),11-16.
    [216]饶永,黄守洲.企业带动科技示范:云南省白竹山茶叶专业合作社助农增收60倍.中国合作经济,2008(4),49-49.
    [217]任大鹏,郭海霞.合作社制度的理想主义与现实主义.农业经济问题,2008(3),90-94.
    [218]桑乃泉.我国蔬菜产业组织纵向协调的变化:基于交易成本的分析.中国农业经济评论,2004,2(4),482-503.
    [219]邵科,徐旭初.成员异质性对农民专业合作社治理结构的影响—基于浙江省88家合作社的分析.西北农林科技大学学报:社会科学版,2008(8),5-9.
    [220]沈贵银.探索现代农业多元化规模经营制度——对十七届三中全会关于农村基本经营制度创新有关问题的思考.农业经济问题,2009(5),17-19.
    [221]石敏俊,金少胜.中国农民需要合作组织吗?.浙江大学学报:人文社会科学版,2004,34(3),35-44.
    [222]石秀和,徐红.重构我国农村合作经济组织体系.财贸研究,2004(3),27-31.
    [223]苏斯彬,卫龙宝.从交易费用角度看实现农业规模经营的新途径——对台州市农业合作社规模效应的交易费用经济学解释.农业经济,2004(8),20-21.
    [224]孙贺,李恩.繁荣农产品市场的有效途径:构建专业合作社——以吉林省长岭县永久镇葛平村为例.中国市场,2009(2),86-87.
    [225]孙林,孟令杰.中国棉花生产效率变动:1990-2001——基于DEA的实证分析.数量经济技术经济研究,2004(2),23-27.
    [226]孙亚范.现阶段我国农民合作需求与意愿的实证研究和启示——对江苏农户的实证调查与分析.江苏社会科学,2003(1),206-208.
    [227]孙亚范.新型农民专业合作经济组织发展研究.北京:社会科学文献出版社,2006.
    [228]孙艳华,刘湘辉,周发明等.生产合同模式对农户增收绩效的实证研究——基于江苏省肉鸡行业的调查数据.农业技术经济,2008(4),55-64.
    [229]孙艳华,周力,应瑞瑶.农民专业合作社增收绩效研究——基于江苏省养鸡农户调查数据的分析.复印报刊资料:农业经济导刊,2007(11),66-71.
    [230]唐华仓.农民专业合作社运作中的经验与问题——第四届农业政策理论与实践研讨会(河南会议)综述.农业经济问题,2008(1),103-106.
    [231]谢学东.服务规模经营:农业规模经济的有效实现形式.江苏农村经济,2008(1):20-22.
    [232]信桂新,杨庆媛,毛旭明,张丽.农地规模经营——取向,路径与运行框架的思考.江西农业学报,2008,20(11),156-159.
    [233]许锦英.我国农业规模经营的误区及其根源辨析.理论学刊,2009(12),59-62.
    [234]徐琼.技术效率与前沿面理论评述.财经论丛,2005(2),29-34.
    [235]徐旭初,黄祖辉.中国农民合作组织的现实走向:制度、立法和国际比较.浙江大学学报(人文社科版),2005(2),59-65.
    [236]徐旭初,邵科.略论现代农业的经营形式问题.农业经济,2008(1),7-9.
    [237]王培先.适度规模经营:我国农业现代化的微观基础.博士学位论文,复旦大学,2003.
    [238]王晓娟,李周.灌溉用水效率及影响因素分析,2005(7),11-18.
    [239]王孝莹,张可成,胡继连.农户生产合作博弈模型.运筹与管理,2006,15(003),114-118.
    [240]王学渊.基于前沿面理论的农业水资源生产配置效率研究.博士学位论文,浙江大学,2008.
    [241]卫新,毛小报,王美清.浙江省农户土地规模经营实证分析.中国农村经济,2003(10),31-36.
    [242]杨春,陆文聪.中国玉米生产率增长,技术进步与效率变化:1990-2004年.农业技术经济,2007(4),34-40.
    [243]杨国玉,郝秀英.关于农业规模经营的理论思考.经济问题,2005(12),42-45.
    [244]苑鹏.农民专业合作社联合社发展的探析.中国农村经济,2008(8),44-51.
    [245]张雪梅.我国玉米生产增长因素的分析.农业技术经济,1999(2)
    [246]张忠明,钱文荣.农民土地意愿经营规模影响因素实证研究——基于长江中下游区域的调查分析.农业经济问题,2007(9),65-70.
    [247]折晓叶.村庄边界的多元化——经济边界开放与社会边界封闭的冲突与共生.中国社会科学,1996(3),66-78.
    [248]战明华,吴小钢,史晋川.市场导向下农村专业合作组织的制度创新——以浙江台州上盘镇西兰花合作社为例.中国农村经济,2004(5),24-30.
    [249]张培刚.新发展经济学教程.经济科学出版社,2001.
    [250]张晓山.农民专业合作社的发展趋势探析.管理世界,2009(5),89-96.
    [251]张雪莲,冯开文.农民专业合作社决策权分割的博弈分析.中国农村经济,2008(8),61-69.
    [252]赵国杰,郭春丽.农民专业合作社生命周期分析与政府角色转换初探.农业经济问题,2009(1),76-80.
    [253]赵国杰,张月辰,杜素红.农户参与合作社意愿模型建构与分析——以河北省清苑县高优专业合作社为例.中国青年科技,2007(3),43-47.
    [254]钟智利,周娟,肖艳春.辽宁省农户参与农民合作经济组织行为的影响因素分析.农业经济,2008(1),65-66.
    [255]周曙东,戴迎春.供应链框架下生猪养殖户垂直协作形式选择分析.中国农村经济,2005(6),30-36.
    [256]朱红根,陈昭玖,翁贞林等.稻作经营大户对专业合作社需求的影响因素分析——基于江西省385个农户调查数据.农业经济问题,2008(12),71-78.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700