多功能农业与中国农业政策研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
半个多世纪以来,在传统增长模式与发展模式的影响下,发达国家与发展中国家都将农业看作是工业与城市的“小侍女”,认为农业的作用在于服务经济增长这一主要目标,“本质上是食品生产”,而对于农业自身却缺乏应有的关怀,结果造成了全球范围内的农业危机。中国作为最大的发展中国家,在经济发展取得巨大成就的同时,出现了严重的“三农”问题。2004年以后,国家的农业政策发生了明显的变化,解决“三农”问题与新农村建设成了构建和谐社会的重要内容。但对于农业从“取”到“予”的转变还刚刚开始,传统的基于单独生产、私人产品、无外部性、无交易成本的政策理论已经不能适应要求。
     八十年代末,多功能农业(文中简称MFA)在“农业在现代社会中的地位与作用以及未来农业政策的彻底思考”中出现。它的基本思想是:农业不仅提供食品和纤维,还提供形形色色的非经济产品。不仅有经济价值,还有环境价值与社会价值。作为一种理念、一种方法或一种目标,多功能农业将政策措施由传统的生产者—产品—市场模式转向了广阔的社会目标,将农业的所有功能放在一个整体的框架内进行分析,以其系统性和科学性吸引了大量学者与决策者的注意力。
     本文的目的就是以已有的理论成果为基础,在MFA的基础上,构建中国农业政策的理论框架,并将重点放在农业的非经济功能上。主要的结论有:
     农业是多功能的,这些功能源于它所产生的经济品与非经济品的多样性,而非经济品大多具有外部性和公共产品特性,市场无法解决它们的最佳供给问题,与社会对这些非经济品日益增加的需求产生了矛盾。
     农业经济品与非经济品是联合生产的结果,这种联合不同于其它产业,是以生物联合为基本单元的物理联合或交叉联合。联合生产改变了市场均衡方式,而生物联合的紧密性与农业生产要素的自然依赖性又使得多数非经济品没有农业之外的替代供给途径。
     由于联合生产,经济品与非经济品之间是相互关联相互影响的,同时由于非经济品的公共产品特性与唯一性,要求农业政策不仅要考虑经济品,还要考虑非经济品,不仅考虑经济功能,还要考虑社会功能与其它功能,不仅要从产业内考虑,还要从产业外考虑。这不仅是农业、农民与农村的需要,更是全社会的需要,是可持续发展与和谐社会的需要。
For more than half a century, under the guiding of traditional growth and development models, both developed and developing countries have considered their agricultural sector as a "serve maid" for other industries and their urban areas. The role that agriculture played was to serve economic growth. "Agriculture itself in nature is the production of food", Accompanied by the increasing use of new technologies and globalization, agriculture was seriously impaired all over the world.
     As the biggest developing country in the world, China has made great achievements since the last two decades; meanwhile, she faces more serious farm-related problems. Since the year 2004, Chinese agricultural policy has changed remarkably. Solving of the three farm-related problems and construction of new rural areas are the main components of the harmonious society. For this reason, continuing measures have been taken favorably to farmers. But the turning from "taking" to "giving" is just at its beginning. The classical economic approach based on separate production, private goods, no externality and zero transaction cost are no longer fit well into the new context.
     In the end of 1980s, the notion of multifunctionality emerged "in a thoroughly rethinking about the role and function of agriculture in modern society, and changes of agriculture system in the future." The basic idea behind multifunctionality is that agricultural production provides not only food and fibre, but also different non-market commodities. As a philosophy, a methodology and an objective, MFA incorporates all the natures of agriculture especially jointness, externalities and public goods characteristics into a single framework, and has gained more and more attentions. Many of the agricultural policy makers consider multifunctional agriculture the new direction of agriculture policy and a powerful trend of future agriculture.
     This paper aims to develop a theoretical framework for Chinese agriculture policies based on the researches have been done by others. The stress will put on the non-commodities. The main results are:
     Agriculture is multifunctional, the multifunctionality derived from various commodities and non-commodities. Most non-commodities exhibit externality and public goods characteristics, for which markets do not exist or function poorly. This cause trade-off between the provision of them and the increasingly demand for them.
     Agriculture production is joint production. Different from other industry, it is physical or cross jointness composed by several unit biological ones. Jointness has strongly changed the way of market equilibrium. The strong degree of jointness and the inputs ' nature dependency makes most agricultural products unique.
     Because of the jointness, commodities and non-commodities are interrelated and interdependent. Also because of the public goods and uniqueness of most non-commodities, policy measures must consider not only commodities but also non-commodities, not only economic functions but also social functions, not only from the agriculture sector but also from the society as a whole both nationly and internationly. It's is not just for farmers. It is more needed by the public, by the sustainable development and the building of the homornous society.
引文
1 Bertrand Hervieu. Multifunctionality: a conceptual framework for a new organisation of research and development on grasslands and livestock systems[R]. Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique (INRA), Paris, France.
    2 Hainsworth, Geoffrey B. Population-Environment Linkages: Toward a Conceptual Framework[R]. EMDI Project and Indonesian Ministry of Population and Environment, Halifax and Jakarta, 1992.
    1 凯恩斯集团由以下国家构成: Argentina, Australia, Bolivia, Brazil, Canada, Chile, Colombia, Costa Rica, Guate-mala, Indonesia, Malaysia, New Zealand, Paraguay, the Philippines, South Africa, Thailand and Uruguay.
    2 Philip L. Paarlberg, Maury Bredahl, and John G.Lee. Multifunctionality and Agricultural Trade Negotiations[J]. Review of Agricultural Economics--Volume 24.
    3 David Freshwater. Applying Multifunctionality To U.S. Farm Policy, Agricultural Economics Staff Paper # 437, 2002, http://www.uky.edu/Ag/AgEcon.
    1 Peter Boothroyd, Pham Xuan Nam. Socioeconomic renovation in vietnam-The Origin, Evolution, and Impact of Doi Moi, 2000.
    2 2001 figures-http://odin.dep.no/html/multifunc/multifunc6a.html.
    1 Johnston, B.F., and J.W. Mellor. "The Role of Agriculture in Economic Development." Amer. Econ. Rev. 51, September, pp. 566-93. 1961.
    2 Kuznets, S. (1968). Toward a Theory of Economic Growth with Reflections on the Economic Growth of Nations, Norton, New York.
    3 Randy Stringer. How important are the 'non-traditional' economic roles of agriculture in development?[J]. Asian-Pacific Economic Literature, 2001,Volume 15.
    4 Schumacher,E,F.The small is beautiful[M]. Harper Perennial, New York, 1973.
    1 Rural Multifunctionality in Europe: the concept and policies. 90th EAAE seminar "multifunctional agriculture, policies and. markets: Understanding the critical linkage", October 27-28, 2004, Rennes.
    2 王威,杨丹妮,方志权.日本多功能性农业对我国都市农业的启示[J].社会科学,2005,3.
    3 UN. Agenda 21, Chapter 14, United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED), Rio de Janerio, Brazil, 3-14 June, 1992.
    4 Hervieu, B., C. Beranger. New regulation of agriculture and rural development in Europe particularly in France through multifonctional character of agriculture and land[A]. International Conference: European Rural Policy at the Crossroads[C]. Scotland:The Arkleton Centre for Rural Development Research, King's College, University of Aberdeen, 2000.
    1 Alan Swinbank. Multifunctionality: A European Euphemism for Protection? The University of Reading.
    2 OECD. Declaration of Agricultural Ministers Committee, 1998.
    3 Brad Devries. Multifunctional Agriculture in the International Context: A Review, The Land Stewardship Project, October, 2000.
    1 Tapani Yrjola ja Jukka Kola. Consumers' attitudes towards multifunctional agriculture, Helsingin yliopisto, Taloustieteen laitos, PL 14, 00014 Helsinging yliopsto.
    2 Isabelle Garzon.Multifunctionality of agriculture in the European Union: Is there substance behind the discourse's smoke? European Commission, Berkeley, April 6 2005.
    1 Mary Bohman et al. the Use and Abuse of Multifunctionatity, Economic Research Service/USDA, November 1999.
    2 OECD. Multifunctionality: towards an analytical framework, Paris, 2001.
    1 OECD. Multifunctionality: the policy implications, AGR/CA/APM(2002)10/FINAL, 2003, P24.
    2 Erwin Schmid,Franz Sinabell. Modelling multifunetionality of agriculture-concepts, challenges, and an application, DP-08-2004, Institut für nachhaltige Wirtschaftsentwicklung, Oktober 2004.
    1 Erwin Schmid, Franz Sinabell. Modeling multifunctionality of agriculture-concepts, challenges, and an application, 2004.
    2 OECD. Multifunctionality: towards an Analytical Framework, Paris, 2001.
    1 OECD. Multifunctionality, towards an Analytical Framework,2001.
    2 Gerrit Faber. The concept of multifunctionality and aneotiations on agriculture in the WTO,September 2002.
    1 K. Arovuori and J. Kola, International Food and Agribusiness Management Review Volume 8, Issue 3, 2005.
    2 Kyosti Arovuoril, Jukka Kola. Policies and measures for multifunctional agriculture: Experts' insight, Research and Technology and the Multifunctional Character of Agriculture and Land, Background Paper 5: Research and Technology.
    3 Mary Bohman, et al. The Use and Abuse ofMultifunctionality, Economic Research Service/USDA, November 1999.
    1 Konrad Hagedorn. The Role of Integrating Institutions for Multifunctionality, Paper prepared for presentation at the Ⅺth Congress of the EAAE, 'The Future of Rural Europe in Global Agri-Food System', Copenhagen, Denmark, August 24-27, 2005.
    2 Chen Qiuzhen, John Sumelius. Comparative Study on Chinese and Finnish Experts' Opinion of Multifunctional Agriculture, 2005.
    1 David Freshwater, Haili Jia. improving our understanding of joint production as the basis for multifunctionality, contributed paper prepared for the Euoropen Agricultural Economics Association seminar on multifunctionality, Rennes, France, 2004.
    1 Multagri project: Summary of main results. September 2005. www.multagri.net.
    1 Multagri project: Summary of main results. September 2005. www.multagri.net.
    2 L.H.G. Slangen, R.A. Jongeneel and N.B.P. Polman. Institutional Analysis of Multifunctional Agriculture, Wageningen University, Agricultural Economics and Rural Policy Group, Correspondence: P.O. box 8130 6700 EW, Wageningen, the Netherlands, Louis. Slangen@wur.nl.
    1 Kyosti Arovuori, Jukka Kola. Multifunctional policy measures for multifunctional agriculture, Paper prepared for presentation at the Ⅺth conference of the EAAE, 'The Future of Rural Europe in the Global Agri-Food System', Copenhagen, Denmark, August 24-27, 2005.
    2 姬亚岚,郑四渭,蔡细平.森林地位与作用评价指标体系研究[J].浙江林学院学报,2003.2.
    1 Isabelle GARZON. Multifunctionality of agriculture in the European Union: Is there substance behind the discourse's smoke? Agriculture and Resource Economics,Berkeley, April 6 2005.
    1 David Freshwater. Applying Multifunctionality To U.S. Farm Policy.
    2 That was then but this is now. http://www.caimsgroup.org/papers/paper_9901_multifunctionality.html.
    1 http://www.caimsgroup.org/papers/paper_9901_multifunctionality.html.
    1 David R. Harvey. Agri-Environmental Relationships & Multi-functionality: Further Considerations, School of Agriculture. Food and Rural Development, University of Newcastle upon Tyne,The World Economy, 26 (5), May, 2003, 705-725.
    2 Manuel Rodríguez Rodríguez,Emilio Galdeano Gómez,José Céspedes Lorente. Rural multifunctionality in Europe. The concept and policies. 90th EAAE Seminar "Muntifunctional agriculture, policies and markets: Understanding the critical linkage"-October 27-29, 2004-Rennes.
    1 The WTO negotiations in Seattle, the 1999 Maastricht conference on the Multifunctional Character of Agriculture and Land, the CSD-8 etc. 6 see Einarsson (2000),Page 7.
    2 第一支柱是指传统的以生产为目的的支持措施。
    3 Manuel Rodríguez, Emilio Galdeano G6mez, José Céspedes Lorente. RURAL MULTIFUNCTIONALITY IN EUROPE. THE CONCEPT AND POLICIES, 90th EAAE Seminar "Muntifunctional agriculture, policies and markets: Understanding the critical linkage"-October 27-29, 2004-Rennes.
    1 周淑景.多功能农业与我国农业发展方向[J],广西经济干部管理学院学报,2003.
    2 河南社科院网.http://www.hnass.com.cn/11dt-sjk/list.asp?id=229.
    1 王威,杨丹妮,方志权.日本多功能性农业对我国都市农业的启示[J],社会科学,2005.3,37~40.
    2 江建国.疯牛病引发农业政策之争,人民日报,2001年04月13日,第七版。
    3 邹德秀.绿色的哲理[M],农业出版社,1990.
    4 王亚新.多功能农业研究[D],西北农林科技大学,2003年博士论文。
    1 翟虎渠.农业概论[M].高等教育出版社,北京,1999.
    2 瓦罗.论农业[M].商务印书馆,1982.
    1 Randall A, Stoll J R. Existence value in a total valuation framework. In: Row R D, Chesmut L G (eds.), Managing air quality and scenic resources at national parks and wilderness areas. Boulder, Colorado: Westview Press, 1983.
    1 David Pearce, Dale Whittington, Steven Georgiou, et al. Environmental Economics Series Paper No. 14[R]. Nairobi, United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP), 1994.
    1 Eirik Romstad et al.. Multifunctional Agriculture Implications for Policy Design, Agricultural University of Norway, Department of Economics and Social Sciences, Report No. 21, ISSN 0802-9210,2000.
    1 OECD.中国农业政策回顾与评价,中国经济出版社,2005,48.
    1 胡火金.中国古代农业社会经济与农业文化的构建.中国经济史论,2003.12.
    1 湖南娄底28岁的青年农民王成新所说:“从我到的第一天开始,我就下定决心要把根留在城市。我这辈子打死也不会当农民,当然也不会再回到农村去。”王成新说出大多数来城里农民工的心声。(都想进城谁来建设新农村?中国金融网,http://www.zgjrw.com/zhuanti/pagemain/2006032901).
    1 Bergland. Valuing Multidimensional Environmental Changes with Contingent Ranking. Department of Economics and Social Sciences Discussion Paper D-15/1994, Agricultural University of Norway, Norway, 1994.
    2 Nordic Council of Ministers. Cultural landscapes and Agriculture: Policies towards the Cultural Landscape in the Nordic Countries, Oslo, Norway. 1991.
    1 Olsson, G. A, K. Ronningen. Environmental values in Norwegian Agricultural Landscape, Report no 10/99, Centre for Rural Research, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Trondheim, Norway, 1999.
    1 Brouwer, F, P. Lowe. CAP and the Rural Environment in Transition: A panorama of national perspectives, Wageningen Pers, Wageningen, The Netherlands. 1998.
    1 FAO. FAO's Special Program for Food Security, 1999, http://www.fao.org/spfs.
    1 Eirik Romstad, Arild Vain, Per Kristian Rorstad, et al. Multifunctional Agriculture Implications for Policy Design, Agricultural University of Norway Department of Economics and Social Sciences, Report No. 21, ISSN 0802-9210.
    1 黄季煜.数字说话:中国的粮食安全,2006-5-9,http://wwwl.casd.cn/zzjjbglt/081932549_2.html.
    2 中国农业科学院.21世纪初我国粮食安全的国际环境,农业经济研究所网,http://www.iae.org.cn/Zjlt/lwmlw.htm.
    1 程国强.粮食进口如何趋利避害,瞭望新闻周刊,2005.4.18.
    1 Hatlestad, B., V. Soyland. Food quality, more than taste-dealing with an "impure private good", MSc thesis, Department of Economics and Social Sciences, Agricultural University of Norway, As, Norway, 1998.
    1 陈锦屏,张志国.关于影响食品安全因素的探讨,食品科学,2005.8.
    2 梅方权.食品安全的问题与对策,农产品加工,2006.2.
    1 转基因食品潜在危害是什么?2004-10-21,http://www.39.net.
    2 杜娟,马小森.九成原奶生产前已严重污染,牛奶行业丑闻频曝,北京晨报,2005-06-16.
    1 OECD. Multifunctionality: A framework for policy analysis, AGR/CA(98)9,Directorate for Food, Agriculture and Fisheries, Committee for Agriculture, OECD, Paris. 1998.
    1 曾小华.关于文化的定义.http://www.china.org.cn/chinese/zhuanti/xxsb/545593.htm.
    2 易钢.农业文化及其在中国传统文化中的地位,农业现代化研究,1998.6.
    1 闵庆文,孙业红.全球重要农业文化遗产保护需要建立多方参与机制[J]——“稻鱼共生系统多方参与机制研讨会”综述.古今农业,2006年第3期,国学网,http://economy.guoxue.com/anicle.php/10205.
    2 谭其骧.中国文化的时代差异和地域差异,复旦学报,1986.2.
    1 费立鹏,李献云,张艳萍.中国的自杀率:1995-99年,柳叶刀(英国医学杂志),2002.3.9,中文稿来自http://www.crjsjs.org.cn/page/downfile/200481811152472.doc.
    1 朱四海.我国农业政策演变的两条基本线索,农业经济问题,2005年11期。
    2 李成贵.中国农业政策:理论框架与应用分析,社会科学文献出版社,1999年1月。
    1 http://zy-zjyx.ftedu.cn/Resource/Book/Edu/JXCKS/TS015011/0012_ts015011.htm.
    1 Boadway, R.W., N. Bruce. Welfare Economics, Basil Blackwell, New York, NY.Bowes, M. D. & J. V. Krutilla Multiple-Use Management: The Economics of Public Forestland, Resources for the Future, Washington, D.C. 1989.
    2 Bromley, D. W. Economic Interests and Institutions. The Conceptual Foundations of Public Policy,Basil Blackwell, Oxford, UK,1989.
    1 http://info.chem.hc360.com/HTML/001/001/027/147923.htm.
    1 方时姣,刘思华.论农村和谐社会与农业发展的终极目标.农业经济问题,2004.6.
    1 维华.媒体撰文评析广西将大幅调减甘蔗种植面积,中华工商时报,2004-8-11.
    1 2006年暑假,笔者对西安市某厂打工的农民工进行问卷调查,收回了63份有效问卷。
    1 Buckwell, A. "If...Agricultural economics in a brave liberal world", Editorial Material, European Review of Agricultural Economics, 1997:24(3-4):339-358.
    1 赵海东.农业补贴方式的创新与“三农”问题的破解——兼评当前对农民直接补贴的效应,江海学刊,2006.2.
    [1] Bertrand Hervieu. Multifunctionality: a conceptual framework for a new organisation of research and development on grasslands and livestock systems[R].Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique (INRA), Paris.
    
    [2] Hainsworth, Geoffrey B. Population-Environment Linkages: Toward a Conceptual Framework.[R]. Halifax and Jakarta: EMDI Project and Indonesian Ministry of Population and Environment, 1992.
    [3] Philip L. Paarlberg, Maury Bredahl, John G. Lee. Multifunctionality and Agricultural Trade Negotiations[J] .Review of Agricultural Economics-Volume 24, Number 2: 322-335.
    [4] David Freshwater.Applying Multifunctionality To U.S. Farm Policy[EB/OL]. Kentucky:Agricultural Economics Staff Paper # 437, 2002, http://www.uky.edu/Ag/AgEcon.
    [5] Peter Boothroyd, Pham Xuan Nam. Socioeconomic Renovation in viet nam-The Origin, Evolution, and Impact of Doi Moi, 2000.
    
    [6] 2001, figures-http://odin.dep.no/html/multifunc/multifunc6a.html.
    [7] Johnston, Mellor. The Role of Agriculture in Economic Development [J]. American Economic Review, 1961,51(4): 566-93.
    [8] Kuznets, S. Toward a Theory of Economic Growth with Reflections on the Economic Growth of Nations, Norton, New York. 1968.
    
    [9] Randy Stringer, How important are the 'non-traditional' economic roles of agriculture in development?[J]. Asian-Pacific Economic Literature, 2001,Volume 15.
    [10] Schumacher,E,F.The small is beautiful[M]. Harper Perennial, New York, 1973.
    
    [11] Randall, Alan. Valuing the Output of Multifunctional Agriculture[J]. European Review of Agricultural Economics. 2002. Vol. 29 (3): 289-308.
    
    [12] Rodriguez, Galdeano, Cespedes. Rural Multifunctionality in Europe: the concept and policies[R], Rennes:90th EAAE seminar "multifunctional agriculture, policies and markets: Understanding the critical linkage", 2004.
    
    [13] 王威,杨丹妮,方志权.日本多功能性农业对我国都市农业的启示[J]。社会科学,2005.3.
    
    [14] United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED). Agenda 21, Chapter 14. Rio de Janerio, Brazil, 1992.
    [15] Hervieu, B., C. Beranger. New regulation of agriculture and rural development in Europe particularly in France through multifonctional character of agriculture and land[A]. International Conference: European Rural Policy at the Crossroads [C]. Scotland:The Arkleton Centre for Rural Development Research, King's College, University of Aberdeen, 2000.
    [16] Alan Swinbank. Multifunctionality: A European Euphemism for Protection?[A]. Presented at the FWAG Conference: Multifunctional Agriculture-A European Model, Stoneleigh, UK, November 29,2001.
    [17] OECD. Declaration of Agricultural Ministers Committee[EB/OL].1998. http://www.oecd.org//news_and_events/release/nw98-22a.htm.
    [18] Brad DeVries. Multifunctional Agriculture in the International Context: A Review [EB/OL].The Land Stewardship Project,October, 2000. www.landstewardshipproject.org/mba/MFAReview.pdf.
    [19] Baumol, W. and Oates, W. The Theory of Environmental Policy. Cambridge: Cambridge university press, 1988.
    [20]Tapani Yrjola ja, Jukka Kola. Consumers' attitudes towards multifunctional agriculture[R]. Proceedings of the NJF's 22nd Congress "Nordic Agriculture in Global Perspective" 2003, Turku Finland (409 p.): 155.
    [21] Isabelle GARZON, Multifunctionality of agriculture in the European Union: Is there substance behind the iscourse's smoke?[A]. Center on Institutions and Governance Presentation Paper No. 20. European Commission, Berkeley, April 6 2005.
    
    [22] Mary Bohman, Joseph Cooper, Daniel Mullarkey, et al. The Use and Abuse of Multifunctionality [J]. Economic Research Service/USDA, November 1999.
    [23] OECD.Multifunctionality : towards an analytical framework[R]. Paris, 2001.
    
    [24] Portney, P.R: (1994): The Contingent Valuation Debate: Why Economists Should Care, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 8(4):3-17.
    
    [25] A. Myrick Freeman. 环境与资源价值评估—理论与方法[M].中国人民大学出版社,2002.
    [26] Potter, C. Decoupling by degrees? Agricultural liberalisation and its implications for nature conservation in Britain[R]. English Nature Research Reports, 1996: No. 196.
    
    [27] OECD. Multifunctionality: the policy implications, AGR/CA/APM(2002)10/FINAL, 2003.
    [28] Schmid,Franz Sinabell. Modelling multifunctionality of agriculture - concepts, challenges, and an application, Erwin DP-08-2004, Institut fur nachhaltige Wirtschaftsentwicklung, October 2004.
    [29] Gerrit Faber. The Concept of multifunctionality and Negotiations on Agriculture in the WT0[A]. Paper for the conference: "Multifunctionality and the WTO Negotiations on Agriculture" held at Clingendael Institute on 7 October 2002. http://www. cedla.uva.nl/pdf.
    [30] Michael Boehlje, Todd Doehring, Steve Sonka. Farmers of the Future:Market Segmentation and Buying Behavior[J]. International Food and Agribusiness Management Review, 2005,Volume 8, Issue 3.
    [31] Kyosti Arovuoril, Jukka Kola. Policies and measures for multifunctional agriculture: Experts' insight[J]. International Food and Agribusiness Management Review, 2005,Volume 8, Issue 3.
    [32] Bastian, O., Roder, M. Landscape functions and natural potentials: Development and Perspectives of Landscape Ecology[M]. Boston London: Dordrecht,2002:213-230.
    [33] Manuel Rodriguez Rodriguez et al., Rural Multifunctionality in Europe. The Concept and Polices[A]. 90th EAAE Seminar "Muntifunctional agriculture, policies and markets: Understanding the critical linkage" Rennes,2004.
    [34] Eugenio Diaz-Bonilla, Jonathan Tin. That was then but this is now: multifunctionality in industry and agriculture[EB/OL]. TMD DISCUSSION PAPER NO. 94, May 2002. Paper is available at http://www.cgiar.org/ifpri/divs/tmd/dp.htm.
    [35] Konrad Hagedorn.The Role of Integrating Institutions for Multifunctionality, Humboldt University of Berlin, Germany, Paper prepared for presentation at the XIth Congress of the EAAE (European Association of Agricultural Economists), "The Future of Rural Europe in Global Agri-Food System', Copenhagen, Denmark, August 24-27, 2005.
    [36] Chen Qiuzhen, John Sumelius. Comparative Study on Chinese and Finnish Experts' Opinion of Multifunctional Agriculture [J]. International Food and Agribusiness Management Review, 2005,Volume 8, Issue 3.
    [37] David Freshwater and Haili Jia, improving our understanding of joint production as the basis for multifunctionality [A], contributed paper prepared for the Euoropen Agricultural Economics Association seminar on multifunctionality, Rennes, France, 2004.
    [38]Abler D. Multifunctionality: the question of jointness: applying the OECD framework - a review of literature in the United States, OECD, 2001,25 .
    [39] Eirik Romstad, Arild Vatn, Per Kristian Rorstad. Multifunctional Agriculture,Implications for Policy Design[R], Agricultural University of Norway Department of Economics and Social Sciences,Report No. 21,ISSN 0802-9210.2000.
    [40] Konrad Hagedorn. Multifunctional Agriculture: an Institutional Interpretation[A]. 90th EAAE Seminar "Muntifunctional agriculture, policies and markets: Understanding the critical linkage" Rennes,2004.
    [41] EU.Multagri project: Summary of main results [R]. September 2005. www.multagri.net.
    [42] L.H.G. Slangen, R.A. Jongeneel and N.B.P. Polman. Institutional Analysis of Multifunctional Agriculture[A]. 90th EAAE Seminar "Muntifunctional agriculture, policies and markets: Understanding the critical linkage" Rennes,2004.
    [43] OECD. Multifunctionality: A framework for policy analysis[R]. AGR/CA(98)9, Directorate for Food, Agriculture and Fisheries, Committee for Agriculture, OECD, Paris. 1998.
    [44] Konrad Hagedorn. The Role of Integrating Institutions for Multifunctionality [A]. Paper prepared for presentation at the Ⅺth Congress of the EAAE (European Association of Agricultural Economists), 'The Future of Rural Europe in Global Agri-Food System', Copenhagen, Denmark, August 24-27, 2005.
    [45]Kyosti Arovuori, Jukka Kola.Multifunctional policy measures for multifunctional agriculture[A]. Paper prepared for presentation at the Ⅺth conference of the EAAE, 'The Future of Rural Europe in the Global Agri-Food System', Copenhagen, Denmark, August 24-27, 2005.
    [46]Cairol, D,Coudel E, et al. Multifunctionality of agriculture and rural areas: From trade negotiations to contributing to sustainable development[R]. Multagri synthesis report (www.multagri.net). CEMAGREF, September 2005.
    [47]Cudlinova et al. Multagri: Summary Report of Consumer and Societal Demands for multifunctionality based on Three Different Secondary Case Studies Aimed at Different Functions of MFA[A]. WP2 summary report, ILE, Czech Republic, 2005.
    [48]Caron P., Aumand A, Barthélemy D, et al. MultAgri: Concept Oriented Research Clusters: application to the multifonctionnality concept[R]. 2005
    [49]Wu, J., R. Adams, W. Boggess. Cumulative Effects and Optimal Targeting of Conservation Efforts[J]. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 2000.82:400-413.
    [50]Knickel et al. Multagri: Evaluation of policies with respect to multifunctionalityof agriculture; observation tools and support for policy formulation and evaluation: WP6 summary report, IfLS, Germany, 2005.
    [51]Renting et al. Multifunctionality of activities, plurality of identities and newinstitutional arrangements[R]. WP4 synthesis report, WUR, the Netherlands, 2005.
    [52]Rossing, W.A.H., Groot, J.C.J. MultAgri: Knowledge, models, techniques and toolsthat help to explain and forecast multifimctionality of agriculture[R]. WP3 Country report TheNetherlands; Biological Farming Systems Group, Wageningen University, 2004.
    [53]姬亚岚,郑四渭,蔡细平.森林地位与作用评价指标体系研究[J].浙江林学院学报,2003.2.
    [54]郑四渭.森林环境可持续发展管理的理论与实践[D].杭州:浙江大学,2001.
    [55]David R. Harvey. Agri-Environmental Relationships & Multi-functionality: Further Considerations[J]. The World Economy, 2003 (5): 705-725.
    [56]http://www.cairnsgroup.org/papers/paper_9901_multifunctionality.html.
    [57]Manuel Rodríguez Rodríguez, Emilio Galdeano G6mez,José Céspedes Lorente. Rural multifunctionality in Europe: the concept and policies[A]. 90th EAAE Seminar "Muntifunctional agriculture, policies and markets: Understanding the critical linkage"-October 27-29, Rennes, 2004.
    [58]The WTO negotiations in Seattle, the 1999 Maastricht conference on the Multifunctional Character of Agriculture and Land, the CSD-8 etc. 6 see Einarsson (2000), Page 7.
    [59]周淑景,多功能农业与我国农业发展方向[J].广西经济干部管理学院学报,2003.
    [60]河南社科院网http://www.hnass.com.cn/11dt-sik/list.aso?id=229.
    [61]包永红,吴文良,王明新等.都市多功能农业发展战略研究[J].生态经济,2006.10
    [62]江建国.疯牛病引发农业政策之争[N].人民日报,2001年04月13日第七版.
    [63]张陆彪.正确认识农业多功能性问题[J].中国农业科学院,研究简报,2002年第3期(总第98期).
    [64]邹德秀.绿色的哲理[M].农业出版社,1990.
    [65]王亚新.多功能农业研究[D].西安:西北农林科技大学,2003.
    [66]翟虎渠等.农业概论[M].高等教育出版社,1999.
    [67]瓦罗.论农业[M].商务印书馆,1982.
    [68]Randall A, Stoll J R. Existence value in a total valuation framework. In: Row R D, Chestnut LG (eds.), Managing air quality and scenic resources at national parks and wilderness areas. Boulder, Colorado: Westview Press, 1983.
    [69]David Pearce, Dale Whittington, Steven Georgiou. Environmental Economies Series Paper No. 14[R]. Nairobi, United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP), 1994
    [70]赵济主编.中国地貌的基本特征及形成因素中国地貌的基本特征及形成因素[M].中国自然地理.第三版.
    [71]OECD.中国农业政策回顾与评价[M].中国经济出版社,2005.
    [72]胡火金.中国古代农业社会经济与农业文化的构建[J].中国经济史论坛,2003.12.
    [73]Blekesaune. Agriculture's Importance for the Viability of Rural Norway[R]. Centre for Rural Research, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Trondheim, Norway, 1999.
    [74]贺爱琳.建设社会主义新农村的几个问题[EB/OL].http://www.jxagriec.gov.cn,江西农经网,2006.
    [75]党国英.专家:农村劳动力转移是大势所趋,不可逆向调节[EB/OL].2007年01月07日,http://www.chinanews.com.cn/sh/news/2007/01-07/849973.shtml.
    [76]林毅夫.中国还没达到工业反哺农业阶段不该增加农业补贴[N],南方周末,2003.7.25.
    [77]学习时报:中国农民工问题调查[EB/OL].新华网,2006年01月18日,www.XINHUANET.com.
    [78]Bergland, Valuing Multidimensional Environmental Changes with Contingent Ranking[R]. Department of Economics and Social Sciences Discussion Paper D-15/1994, Agricultural University of Norway, Norway, 1994.
    [79]Nordic Council of Ministers. Cultural landscapes and Agriculture: Policies Towards the Cultural Landscape in the Nordic Countries[R]. Oslo, Norway. 1991.
    [80]Olsson, G. A, K. Ronningen. Environmental values in Norwegian Agricultural Landscape[R]. Report no 10/99, Centre for Rural Research, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Trondheim, Norway, 1999.
    [81]Brouwer, F, P. Lowe. CAP and the Rural Environment in Transition. A panorama of national perspectives[R], Wageningen Pers, Wageningen, The Netherlands. 1998.
    [82]Dragun, A. K.The Agricultural Production of Environment, Some Nordic Issues[J]. Swedish Journal of Agricultural Research, 1998:28:49-55.
    [83]黄季焜.数字说话:中国的粮食安全[EB/OL].中国科学发展网2006-5-9.http://www1.casd.cn/Html/zzjjbglt/081932549_2.html.
    [84]FAO. FAO's Special Program for Food Security[EB/OL]. 1999. http://www.fao.org/spfs.
    [85]中国农业科学院.21世纪初我国粮食安全的国际环境[EB/OL].农业经济研究所网,http://www.iae.org.cn/zjlt/lwmlw.htm.
    [86]程国强.粮食进口如何趋利避害[J].瞭望新闻周刊,2005.4.18.
    [87]Hatlestad, B., V. Soyland. Food quality, more than taste-dealing with an "impure private good". MSc thesis, Department of Economics and Social Sciences, Agricultural University of Norway, As, Norway. 1998.
    [88]陈锦屏,张志国.关于影响食品安全因素的探讨[J].食品科学,2005,8.
    [89]梅方权.食品安全的问题与对策[J],农产品加工,2006.2.
    [90]精品健康导刊.“食”面埋伏:06年食品安全事件回顾,http://www.sxfs.gov.cn,2006-12-18.
    [91]周婷玉.食源性寄生虫病成影响我国食品安全主要因素之一[EB/OL].2005-05-17新华网.
    [92]转基因食品潜在危害是什么?[EB/OL].http://www.39.net,2004.10-21.
    [93]俄全面禁止大米进口,中国再次撞到“绿色壁垒”[EB/OL].2006—12—7,http://www.sxfs.gov.cn.
    [94]杜娟,马小森.九成原奶生产前已严重污染[N].牛奶行业丑闻频曝,北京晨报,2005-06-16.
    [95]中华人民共和国统计年鉴[M].统计出版社,北京,2005.
    [96]曾小华.关于文化的定义[EB/OL].http://www.china.org.cn/chinese/zhuanti/xxsb/545593.htm.
    [97]易钢.农业文化及其在中国传统文化中的地位[J].农业现代化研究,1998.6..
    [98]闵庆文,孙业红.全球重要农业文化遗产保护需要建立多方参与机制——“稻鱼共生系统多方参与机制研讨会”综述[J],古今农业,2006.3.http://economy.guoxue.com/article.php/10205.
    [99]谭其骧.中国文化的时代差异和地域差异[J].复旦学报,1986.2.
    [100]费立鹏,李献云,张艳萍.中国的自杀率:1995-99年[J],柳叶刀(英国医学杂志),2002-3-9,中文稿来自http://www.crisis.org.cn/page/downfile/200481811152472.doc.
    [101]朱四海.我国农业政策演变的两条基本线索[J].农业经济问题,2005.11.
    [102]李成贵.中国农业政策:理论框架与应用分析[M].社会科学文献出版社,1999年1月.
    [103]石磊.现代农业政策的范式与范式转换[J].农业现代化研究,2005,4.
    [104]贺聪志,李玉勤.社会主义新农村建设研究综述[J],农业经济问题,2006,10.
    [105]卢鸿鹏.我国农业政策目标及政策支持[J].农村经济,2006.3.
    [106]http://zy-zjyx.ftedu.cn/Resource/Book/Edu/JXCKS/TS015011/0012_ts015011.htm.
    [107]Bowes, M. D., J. V. Krutilla Multiple-Use Management: The Economics of Public Forestland, Resources for the Future[R]. Washington, D.C. 1989.
    [108]Bromley, D. W., Economic Interests and Institutions. The Conceptual Foundations of Public Policy[M]. Basil Blackwell, Oxford, UK, 1989.
    [109]http://info.chem.hc360.com/HTML/001/001/027/147923.htm.
    [110]方时姣,刘思华.论农村和谐社会与农业发展的终极目标[J].农业经济问题,2004.6.
    [111]维华.媒体撰文评析广西将大幅调减甘蔗种植面积[N].中华工商时报,2004-8-11.
    [112]WTO, Doha Work Programme. Decision Adopted by the General Council on August 1, 2004.World Trade Organisation. Available: www.wto.org.
    [113]Lankoski, J., Ollikainen, M.. Agri-Environmental externalities: a framework for designing targeted policies[J]. European Review of Agricultural Economics,2003, 1:51-75.
    [114]Lankoski, J., Ollikainen, M. Multifunctional agriculture: The effect of non-public goods on socially optimal policies. In the proceedings Part 1 of the 90th EAAE seminar "Multifunctional agriculture, policies and markets: Understanding the critical linkages", 2004, Rennes, France.
    [115]European Commission. Contribution of the European Community on the Multifunctional Character of Agriculture. Info-Paper, October 1999. Available. www.europa. eu.int/comm/agriculture/external/wto/archive/index_en.htm.
    [116]OECD. Production, externality and public good aspects of multifunctionality. 2000. (COM/AGR/APM/TD/WP(00)3/PART1). Paris: OCDE,12.
    [117]Mariko Hara. Environmental interests in the negotiation of Agreement on Agriculture: country positions, policy implications and assessment[R]. Second draft for review, Economics and Trade Branch, Division of Technology, Industry and Economics,United Nations Environment Programme.22 March 2002.
    [118]Buckwell, A. If...Agricultural economics in a brave liberal world, Editorial Material, European Review of Agricultural Economics, 1997.24(3-4):339-358.
    [119]赵海东.农业补贴方式的创新与“三农”问题的破解——兼评当前对农民直接补贴的效应[J].江海 学刊,2006.2.
    [120]韦苇,杨卫军.农业的外部性及补偿研究[J].西北大学学报,哲学社会科学版,2004,34.
    [121]谭崇台.发展经济学的新发展[M].武汉大学出版社,1999.
    [122]黄祖辉,蒋文华等.农业与农村发展的制度透视[M].中国农业出版社,2002.
    [123]林毅夫,再论制度、技术与中国农业发展[M].北京大学出版社,2000.
    [124]温铁军,三农问题之根本—农业三要素长期净流出[N].经济参考报,2005.12.26.
    [125]费孝通,江村经济[M].商务印书馆,2001.
    [126]OECD.Policy-related transaction costs and policy choice:preliminary report[R].AGR/CA/APM,(2003) 15.OECD.47p.Restricted use.
    [127]刘茂松.彻底地解决”三农”问题的关键:农业工业化[EB/OL].人民网,2006年06月22日.
    [128]刘文勇.中国城乡收入差距扩大的程度、原因与政策调整[J].农业经济问题,2004,3.
    [129]曹幸穗.旧中国苏南农家经济研究[M],中央编译出版社,1996.
    [130]余恩海.中国农民的理性[J].社会科学论坛.2002.12.
    [131]塞缪尔·亨廷顿,劳伦斯·哈里森等.文化的重要作用[M],新华出版社,2001.
    [132]秦晖.土地·公平·效率:关于我国土地制度改革的若干问题[J].中国土地,1997,1.
    [133]Vatn, A., D.W. Bromley. Choices Without Prices Without Apologies[J]. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 1994: 26(2): 129-148.
    [134]Vatn, A., D.W. Bromley. Externalities-A Market Model Failure[J]. Environmental and Resource Economics, 1997: 9:135-151.
    [135]Tyler, T.R.: Why People Obey the Law[M]. Yale University Press, New Haven and London, UK. 1990.
    [136]Tinbergen, J. On the Theory of Economic Policy[M]. Elsevier, North-Holland, Amsterdam,.The Netherlands,1950.
    [137]Shumway, R. C, R. D. Pope, E. Nash. Allocatable Fixed Inputs and Jointness in Agricultural Production: Implications for Economic Modeling[J]. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 1984:66(1):72-78.
    [138]Potter, C. Decoupling by degrees?, Agricultural liberalisation and its implications for nature conservation in Britain[R]. English Nature Research Reports, 1996, No. 196.
    [139]Portney, P.R. The Contingent Valuation Debate: Why Economists Should Care[J]. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 1994:8(4):3-17.
    [140]Brouwer, F.M., B. Crabtree. Environmental Indicators and Agricultural Policy[M]. CAB International, Oxon, UK. 1999.
    [141]亚当·斯密.国民财富的性质和原因研究[M].商务印书馆,1996.
    [142]2003 CAP reform agreement and organic farming, Published by Organic Centre Wales, Institute of Rural Studies, University of Wales Aberystwyth, Ceredigion, SY23 3AL. Tel. 01970 622248.
    [143]Thomas Dobbs, Jules Pretty. Agricultural-Environmental Policies: Implications of the United Kingdom Experience for Europe and the United States[R].South Dakota State University Economics Research Report 2001-1.
    [144]Coleman J. Social capital and the creation of human capital[J]. American Journal of Sociology 94, supplement 1988,S95-S120.
    [145]Countryside Commission. Countryside Stewardship: monitoring and evaluation of the pilot scheme.Countryside Commission Research Note 3. 1998.
    [146]G. van der Bijl. EU Agricultural Polict Aftre 2000:Has the environment been integrated?[R]. A report for the European Environmental Bureau, centre for agriculture and rnvironment,utrecht, octobre 1999,CLM-446-1999.
    [147]Pavlos D. Pezaros, The Environmental Dimension of the Common Agricultural Policy-An Overview[A], Discussion paper prepared for the seminar "The CAP and the Environmental Challenge-New Tasks for Public Administrations?" organised by the European Institute of Public Administration, Maastricht (NL), 14-15 May 2001.
    [148]OECD. Agriculture and the Environment: Issues and Policies, Paris (ISBN 92-64-160485),1998.
    [149]OECD.The Environmental Effects of Reforming Agricultural Policies, Paris (ISBN 92-64-162445), 1998.
    [150]OECD. Environmental Indicators for Agriculture, Volume 3: Methods and Results, Paris (ISBN 92-64-18855-X),2000.
    [151]Roberto Henke, Roberta Sardone, From the first to the second pillar of CAP: hypotheses of direct aid modulation in Italy, Istituto Nazionale di Economia Agraria,Working Paper 26/02, 2002.
    [152]柯兴彬等.农业价值负功能的探索[J].价值工程,2004,9.
    [153]Dennis meadows等.增长的极限—罗马俱乐部关于人类困境的报告[M].吉林人民出版社,1997.
    [154]香港树人学院.农业的起源和发展[M].南京大学出版社,1996.
    [155]李长年.齐民要术研究[M].农业出版社,1959.
    [156]石声汉.中国古代农书评价[M].农业出版社,1980.
    [157]李周,旅游业对中国农村和农民的影响研究[M].中国农业出版社,2004.
    [158]叶敬忠,张楠,杨照.不同角色对新农村建设的需求差异[J].农业经济问题,2006,10.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700