中国沿海渔民转产转业问题研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
近十年来,随着中国捕捞能力的不断膨胀,近海渔业资源迅速减少。特别是《中日渔业协定》、《中韩渔业协定》和《中越北部湾渔业协定》的签署和相继生效,中国沿海渔场大幅度收缩,大批渔船因此不得不撤出传统作业渔场,海洋渔业发展面临前所未有的严峻挑战。为解决沿海渔民日益严峻的生计问题,农业部于2002年作出决定,对沿海渔民实行转产转业政策,目标是力争用5年左右时间,减船3万艘,使约30万渔民实现转产转业。
     几年来,经过全国上下的共同努力,中国的减船转产工作取得了一定的成效,捕捞渔船总量得到降低,部分渔民实现转产。但总的看,该项工作并未取得预期的成效,大批渔民仍然滞留在海洋捕捞业,渔业生产维持在一个低效水平上,减船工作的难度越来越大,过度捕捞的压力不降反增,这就迫使我们重新认识中国沿海渔民转产转业这一问题的复杂性和艰巨性。
     对于转产转业问题产生的原因,笔者研究后认为,沿海渔民的转产转业是产业结构演化和城乡二元经济发展的必然结果,是海洋生态环境恶化、渔业资源过度利用和国际海洋渔业资源管理体制演变下的必然选择。从表面上看,中国沿海渔民转产转业问题是由三个双边渔业协定的相继签订实施引起的,客观上也表现为船多鱼少、人多鱼少的矛盾,但该问题背后起支配作用的是渔业资源的特性,即共有财产特性或曰公共池塘资源特性。尽管由这一财产性质所引发的公地悲剧具有普遍的意义,但悲剧并非是公地的宿命,渔业问题的根源是捕捞业事实上存在着的自由准入机制。渔民转产转业工作的本质是解决捕捞能力与渔业资源再生能力相适应的问题,最终目的是实现渔业资源的可持续利用。因此,不能把渔民转产转业作为一个简单问题加以对待,要看到纷繁复杂的渔业问题的本质和根源。
     笔者认为,自由准入机制内含非理性激励,激励渔民过度利用资源,无效率地利用资源,最后必然导致渔业劳动力和捕捞能力双过剩问题。在这种情况下,单靠政府鼓励渔民减船转产,不可能从根本上解决问题,必须着眼于制度建设,力求消除过度捕捞产生的根源。如果头痛医头、脚痛医脚,转产转业问题或可见效于一时,却终难避免该问题的再次复发。
     对于当前普遍存在的转产转业难的问题,笔者运用推拉理论,结合中国海洋渔业实际,初步建立起形象直观的渔民转产转业宏观受力模型,对渔民转产转业行为中的受力因素进行了系统分析。笔者认为,虽然当前中国面临非常强的渔业资源约束,转产转业受到一定程度的收益拉力,政府也在积极推动渔民转产转业,但受国家财力所限,政府的推动力表现不足,加之转产转业受到较强的成本、惯性和制度三重阻力,渔民转产转业的动力总体上没有明显超出阻力,这是造成渔民转产转业难的一个根本原因。
     为进一步说明这个问题,笔者继而从“经济人”假定出发,在合理借鉴托达罗模型的基础上,改进并建立了劳动力就业转换的一般模型,并运用该模型来分析中国沿海渔民转产转业行为,进一步得出结论:渔民从事渔业生产的目的是追求经济利益最大化,其转产转业行为是在成本与收益比较下理性决策的结果。在考虑到转产转业的成本因素后,如果从事其他行业比捕捞业盈利更多,渔民就会选择从捕捞业退出,转入高盈利行业。反之,如果转产转业的收益不抵成本,渔民的转产转业行为就很难发生。当前,沿海渔民转产存在渔船沉淀成本高、再就业机会少、转产所需资金大等不利因素,这使得渔民转产转业无利可图,从根本上制约了转产转业工作的进程。如果捕捞渔业在当下仍然有利可图,要想让渔民主动放弃主要经济来源,冒着失去生活依靠的风险去寻找净收益不确定性的新工作,这的确有违经济学常规。
     关于转产转业的路径,作者在分析国内外经验后认为,将海水养殖业、水产品加工业和休闲渔业作为渔民转产转业的目标产业加以选择,这符合世界产业结构演化和劳动力迁移的一般规律。需要指出的是,面对大量的渔业过剩人口,单凭渔业行业自身,其对劳动力容纳能力有限,渔业产业的发展有其自身的规律性,很难解决如此众多的过剩劳动力的就业问题,这就迫使部分渔民最终不得不跳出渔业,离开渔村,实现异地迁移就业,也就是要走城镇化之路。
     在论文最后一章,笔者借鉴渔业发达国家的成功经验,指出解决渔民转产转业问题的根本之道在于渔业制度创新。不论是从理论层面,还是从各国实践层面,ITQ制度都堪称为渔业问题的一个根本解。运用ITQ制度,可以有效解决遍布于全球范围内的过度捕捞问题,切断造成渔民转产转业问题的根源,实现渔业资源的可持续利用。为此,我们有必要从现在开始,着手做好制度实施前的一系列相关准备工作。着眼于我国沿海渔民转产转业问题根本解,本文在借鉴国内外渔业发展实践的基础上,提出了我国渔业制度变革的理想模式——基于产权的共同管理,并相应提出了从减船、产权、自主管理三方面共同推进的多维政策路径,为最终解决我国渔民转产转业问题提供了现实对策。
With constant inflation of the fishing capacity in nearly a decade,inshore fishery resources have being reducing sharp in China. After the signature and entry into force of the " Sino-Japanese fisheries agreement "," Sino-South Korean fisheries agreements " and " Sino-Vietnam fisheries agreement of northern Gulf " in succession,coastal fishery fields have been decreasing on a large scale than ever and large quantities of fishing boats have to be withdrawn from traditional fields, which encounter marine fishing an unprecedented rigorous challenge in China. In order to solve the problem of increasingly serious livelihood of the coastal fishermen,the Ministry of Agriculture made a policy of transferring fishermen to other industries in 2002, striving to reduce 30,000 fishing boats and realize 300,000 fishermen’transfer within about 5 years.
     Due to joint efforts nationwide in recent years, China has scored some achievements in the course of reducing boats and transferring fishermen, including reduced total fishing boats and realized transfer of part fishermen. However, there has not witnessed progresses as assumed on the whole as most fishermen still keep their previous occupation with a low level production. Actually there are more and more difficulties in reducing fishing boats and even bigger pressure of overfishing. Thus we are compelled to re-recognize the complexity and toughness of the undertakings of transferring coastal fishermen.
     As for the reason of fishermen’transfer, the author considers that it is inevitable thanks to structural change of the industry and binary economic development in urban and rural areas, which are coupled with deteriorated marine eco-environment, over-used fishery resources and changed international management system on marine fishery resources. Outwardly,it is the signature and enforcement of the three fishery bilateral agreements that force the fishermen to transfer to other industries, as they have resulted in comparatively more boats or fishermen but limited fishery resources. Whereas the dominated reason lies in the resources’characteristic of common property resource or common pool resource, which usually bring tragedy for the resources. And the root of problems in fishing industry lies in the free entrance mechanism. As transferring the fishermen is centering in fishing’s compliance with the regeneration of fishery resource and sustainable utilization of it finally, thus we need to attach much importance to the fishermen’transfer to find out the root cause of complicated problems in fishery.
     The author also holds the idea that,the free entrance system contains irrational stimulation , which stimulates the fishermen using the resources excessively and inefficiently and finally generates a double redundancy problem of both fishery labor and fishing capacity inevitably. In this case,it can't solve the problem basically merely depending on the government encouraging the fishermen to reduce their boats and switch to another industry. So we must focus on the construction of system,and try to eliminate the root which generates excessive capture. If cure somebody of his/her head when he/she has a headache,or cure somebody of his/her feet when he/she has a hurt in his/her feet,maybe the case of transfer can take effect for a while,but the problem can't be settled ultimately.
     As to the widely existed problem of difficulty in transfer, the author applies the Theory of Push & Pull,in conjunction with the practice of Chinese ocean fishery , initially establishes a visual intuitional macroscopic mechanical model of the fishermen's transfer,and analyses the mechanical factors in the activity of the fishermen's transfer systematically. In the author's opinion,our country is facing a strong restriction of fishery resources at present,the profit pulling force impacts on the transfer to some extent,and the government also actively impulses the fishermen's transfer , but the government's impulse represents deficiency limited by the country's financial resource,and transfer falls under somewhat strong resistance of cost, inertia and system, so the impetus of the fishermen's transfer doesn't obviously overcome the resistance as a whole. This is the fundamental cause which generates the difficulty in fishermen's transfer.
     Further,proceeding from the assumption of economic man and the Todaro Model , the author improves the general model of employment transfer which is used for analyzing the practice of transferring coastal fishermen in China. A conclusion is consequently made: fishermen work for maximum profits. Whether they decide to change their careers depends on how much is the cost and the return they will receive. If they can gain more when occupying in other industries,they will just make a switch, and will refuse otherwise. Currently , there are some negative factors bottlenecking the transfer of coastal fishermen,such as high sunk cost of fishing boats,few reemployment opportunities and much capital needed, which may indicate no profits for their . Given fishing is still profitable, it is certainly a violation of convention in economics that fishermen were required to abandon their current jobs at the risk of losing their living to search for new ones that seems to only bring uncertain income.
     With regard to the target industries of transfer,the author after analyzing the experience home and abroad agrees that,it conforms to the general law of the world industry structure evolution and labor migration to focus on saltwater aquaculture,aquatic processing and leisure fishery. One thing needs to be pointed out that the fishery alone is hard to absorb such a large quantity of surplus fishermen due to its capacity and development regularity. And in consequence some fishermen are compelled to leave fishing and their villages and earn their livings in other places, namely new cities and towns established in the process of urbanization.
     In the last chapter of this paper,drawing on successful experiences of fishery-developed countries,the author concludes that the radical solution for fishermen’transfer lies in fishery system innovation. Proved by both the theories and many countries’practices,the Individual Transferable Quotas (ITQ) system can serve as an ultimate solution for the problems existed in fishery industry. It can,by cutting the root baffling the transfer,solve the problem of overfishing which is common in the world at large so as to realize sustainable use of fishery resources. For this reason,we should spare no effort to prepare a series of elementary work for implementing ITQ system. To apply it more efficiently in the future,we should enhance traditional fishery management,strengthen the establishment of the system of fishermen allowance and fishing-access permit,tighten input controls so as to avoid periodical inflation of fishing capacity. And the realization of fishermen’s transfer backed by increased government policies actually will reduce the cost of implementing ITQ system as much as possible in the coming years.
引文
1 数据来源:联合国粮农组织(FAO)官方网站,www.fao.org
     2 数据来源:联合国粮农组织(FAO)官方网站,www.fao.org
     3 数据来源:“十五”渔业成就:沿海捕捞渔民减船转产工程取得初步成效,网址:http://www.cafs.ac.cn/, 发布日期:2005 年 12 月 27 日
     4 李德洗:农村劳动力转移的经济学分析,网址:http://www.tianyabook.com, 发布时间:2006 年 09 月04 日
     5 数据来源:中日就新渔业协定生效间题达成协议,网页:http://www.cfm.com.cn,发布日期:2004.12.4
     6 数据来源:马英杰,专属经济区制度对中国海洋捕捞渔业的影响,网页发布日期:2004-5-20,网址: www2.ouc.edu.cn
     7 数据来源:马英杰,专属经济区制度对中国海洋捕捞渔业的影响,网页发布日期:2004-5-20,网址: http://www2.ouc.edu.cn
     8 资料来源:毕士川,黄冬梅,中国近海渔业资源可持续发展问题与对策,网址:http://www.sfncc.org.cn发布时间:2004.7.12
     9 数据来源:招商中国网,网址:http://www.investcn.cn ,发布时间:2006 年 10 月 8 日
    10 数据来源:FAO 世界渔业和水产养殖状况(2004)[M].粮农组织出版管理处.
    11 关于 2003-2010 年海洋捕捞渔船控制制度实施意见,农渔函[2003]63 号
    12 数据来源:FAO 世界渔业和水产养殖回顾(1998)[M].罗马.联合国粮食及农业组织.1999 年.
    13 空白栏表示没有相应的制度。日本(韩国和台湾地区)还设有渔业权制度,中国大陆则没有。
     14 数据来源:舟山网:http://www.zhoushan.cn 发布时间:2006 年 3 月 10 日
    15 数据来源:中国渔业年鉴(2001、2005)。
     16 数据来源:浙江舟山市开辟“异地就业”双转新路,发布时间:2005-9-23,浙江省海洋与渔业局 网址:http://www.cnfm.gov.cn
    17 数据来源:舟山渔场怎么办?浙江省社会科学院 网址:http://www.zjss.com.cn 发布时间:2004 年 8 月10 日
    18 数据来源:浙江舟山实现六成以上双转渔民再就业,发布时间:2005-11-22,中国渔业政务网:http://www.cnfm.gov.cn
    19 数 据 来 源 : 舟 山 市 海 洋 捕 捞 渔 民 转 产转业规划纲要,2005 年 4 月 28 日
    20 数据来源:浙江舟山渔民转产转业的难点及途径分析 发布日期:2002 年 11 月 18 日 三农数据网:http://www.zjnw.gov.cn
    21 数据来源:同上
     22 数据来源:同上
     23 数据来源:“十五”渔业成就:沿海捕捞渔民减船转产工程取得初步成效,发表日期:2005 年 12 月 27日,出处:http://www.cafs.ac.cn/
    24 数据来源: 同上
    25 郑卫东,娄小波,李欣,中国沿海渔民转产转业的进展综述[J],中国渔业经济,2006 年第 2 期,27-28,
    26 数据来源:“十五”渔业成就:沿海捕捞渔民减船转产工程取得初步成效,发表日期:2005 年 12 月 27日,出处:http://www.cafs.ac.cn/
     27 数据来源:同上
     28 渔业权制度下构建渔业管理新体系的构想,舟山市海洋与渔业局 发布时间:2006-01-05 10:41:00.0,网址:http://www.zjnw.gov.cn
     29 数据来源:中国渔业年鉴(2005 年),中国农业出版社。
    
    30 数据来源:联合国粮农组织官方网站(FAO),www.fao.org
    31 数据来源:中国渔业年鉴 2005,中国农业出版社.
    
    32 数据来源:同上
    33 数据来源:中国农业自然资源与区域发展,1994
    34 数据来源:低值淡水鱼加工利用,江苏农业信息网,发布时间:2006-6-19 网址:http://info.jaas.ac.cn
    35 数据来源:中国渔业年鉴(2003 年),中国农业出版社
    
    36 数据来源:让休闲渔业“热”起来, 牡丹江农业信息网:www.mdjagri.gov.cn 2003-9-15
    37 渔业博览--休闲渔业,江苏海洋渔业网:http://www.jsmfm.gov.cn,发布日期:2006 年 9 月 12 日
     38 中原网谈:许昌市委书记刘春良与新华社记者王耕 http://www.ha.xinhuanet.com
     39 数据来源:舟山市海洋捕捞渔民转产转业规划纲要,2005 年 4 月 28 日
    40 数据来源:我国海洋捕捞强度控制工作步入“总量压减”新阶段,网址: http://www.hswy.heagri.gov.cn,发布日期:2003 年 12 月 2 日
     41 资料来源:中国渔业年鉴(2000、2001、2002、2003、2004、2005)。
     42 渔业权制度下构建渔业管理新体系的构想,舟山市海洋与渔业局 发布日期: 2006-01-05,网址:http://www.zjnw.gov.cn
    [1] 中华人民共和国渔业局.中国渔业年鉴,中国农业出版社,2005:1
    [2] 杨坚,李彦亮,陈家勇,杨子江.关于沿海渔民转产转业情况的调查报告[J].中国渔业经济.2001(6):5—6,29
    [3] 任爱珍.试论海洋渔业资源产权的地方化——沿海渔民“双转”途径研究[J].浙江海洋学院学报自然科学版,2004(6)(第 23 卷第 2 期): 121
    [4] 慕永通.市场理性、产权与海洋生物资源管理——兼析美国北太平洋渔业私有化之逻辑[J].中国海洋大学学报(社会科学版),2004 (6 ):100-101
    [5] 汤姆.泰坦博格.环境与自然资源经济学(第五版)[M].经济科学出版社,2003:272-302
    [6] R 汉纳森.渔业生物经济分析「M].北京,中国农业科技出版社,1995:4-50.
    [7] 吴万夫,刘大安.渔业技术经济学[M].北京:中国科学技术出版社,1995:45-65.
    [8] 宁宝英,何元庆.农户过度放牧行为产生原因分析—来自黑河流域肃南县的农户调查[J].经济地理,2006(1):128-132
    [9] 刘艳、齐升等.明晰草原产权关系 促进畜牧业可持续发展[J].农业经济,2005(9):30-31
    [10] 李仲广、吕振艳、高擎.草原环境恶化及退化的经济学分析[J].内蒙古农业大学学报(社会科学版),2001(2)(第 3 卷总第 8 期):17-20
    [11] 郑卫东.舟山地区捕捞劳动力流动性研究(2000 年)[J]:30-78
    [12] 邴绍倩.中国渔业劳动力城镇化迁移问题的研究(2005)[J]:42-98
    [13] 中华人民共和国和日本国渔业协定
    [14] 中华人民共和国政府和大韩民国政府渔业协定
    [15] 中越北部湾划界协定,中越北部湾渔业合作协定
    [16] 林龙山.执行《协定》对中国远洋渔业的影响[J].水产科学,2004(4):38-42
    [17] 马英杰.谈新的海洋制度下中国海洋捕捞渔业的发展对策[J].现代渔业信息,2003(1):5-8
    [18] 宋涛.政治经济学教程(第四版)[M].北京,中国人民大学出版社,1995:90-97
    [19] 杨黎明.绍兴海洋捕捞渔民转产转业调查与研究[J].中国渔业经济,2005(2):44
    [20] 苏东水. 产业经济学[M]. 高等教育出版社, 2001:223-246
    [21] 刘吉发.产业政策学[M].经济管理出版社,2004:29-37
    [22] [英]威廉?配第.配第经济著作选集[M].北京,商务印书馆,1981:19
    [23] 段小梅.人口流动模型与中国农村剩余劳动力转移研究[J].农村经济,2003(3):43-45
    [24] 中国二元经济社会结构基本特征分析.国务院发展研究中心、中国农村劳动力资源开发研究会《中国走出城乡二元经济结构战略研究》联合课题组[J]
    [25] 金浩. 农业过剩劳动二元经济发展[M].天津,南开大学出版社.2004:132-145
    [26] 刘志扬. 美国农业新经济[M]. 青岛:青岛出版社, 2003:145-176
    [27] 薛国琴.中国农村劳动力转移的阶段性特征[J].经济学家,2006(1):127
    [28] 贾根良. 发展经济学[M]. 天津:南开大学出版社, 2004:42-65.
    [29] Garrett Hardin (1968).The Tragedy of the Commons [J].
    [30] 谢识予.经济博弈论[M」.上海,复旦大学出版社,1997:59-63
    [31] 清光昭夫、岩崎寿男.水产经济学[M].北京,海洋出版社:6-7
    [32] 卢秀容.中国海洋渔业资源可持续利用和有效管理研究[D].武汉,华中农业大学,2005:32—38
    [33] 张德贤等.海洋经济可持续发展理论研究[M].青岛,青岛海洋大学出版社,2000:25-65
    [34] 张洪温.中国海洋渔业资源生产能力及其可持续发展对策研究[D].北京,中国农业科学院,2001:73-86.
    [35] 孙吉亭.中国海洋渔业可持续发展研究[D].青岛,青岛海洋大学,2003:2-11
    [36] 陈新军.海洋渔业资源可持续利用评价[D].南京,南京农业大学,2001:54-98
    [37] 韩兴勇.战后日本渔业人口过剩问题及对策[J].中国渔业经济.2002(4):49-50
    [38] 杨宝瑞.韩国渔业发展现状及对策[J].国外渔业:15
    [39] 朱明远,吉儒宝.中国和韩国渔业现状[J].黄渤海海洋,1998(第 16 卷第 1 期):65-71.
    [40] 朴英爱.关于韩国海洋渔业的减船政策分析[J].中国渔业经济,2003(4):49
    [41] 刘洪滨,朱贤姬,孙丽.中韩海洋渔业管理的比较研究[J].2007(3 月)
    [42] 郭文路, 黄硕琳.控制中国海洋捕捞强度所面临的问题与对策探讨[J].上海水产大学学报,2001(6)(第 10 卷第 2 期):56-57
    [43] 孙金华.各国渔船收购政策经验之比较与评估.“国际间对渔捞能力之管理概况及中国(台湾)之因应”座谈会发言稿[C].2005,6
    [44] 谢营梁,徐吟梅,李励年.关于韩国渔业管理体系的探讨[J].现代渔业信息, 2005(9),(第 20 卷第 9 期):9-10.
    [45] 唐庆宁等.美国渔业印象[J].水产养殖,2000(5):19-21
    [46] “世界各国和地区渔业概况研究” 课题组. 世界各国和地区渔业概况(上、下册) [M].海洋出版社,2002,65.
    [47] 李令华.美国的渔业状况和资源管理设想[J].海洋信息,1994(3):43
    [48] 周更生芳,程炎宏.国外渔船回购计划及执行情况介绍[J].中国渔业经济 2003(2):45
    [49] 陈宗尧,吴祥明.美国渔业及其管理简介[J].中国渔业经济,2004(1):53
    [50] 周先标.浅谈中外休闲渔业管理[J].中国渔业经济,2004(5):29
    [51] 管振青.台湾中山大学,台湾沿近海渔业减船政策之效益评估[J].35-67
    [52] 胡兴华. 台湾的渔业[M]. 台湾:远足文化出版社, 2003,49-86
    [53] 吴瑞荣.赴台湾渔业考察报告[J].中国渔业经济,2002(2):45-46
    [54] 陈新军、周应祺.国际海洋渔业管理的发展历史及趋势[J].上海水产大学学报,2000,9,(4):348.
    [55] 李昭信.美国渔业见闻与启示[J].广西水产科技(电子报刊),2001(3).
    [56](美)J.M.阿姆斯特朗、P.C.赖纳.美国海洋管理[M].北京:海洋出版社,1986:98-102
    [57] 韩兴勇.战后日本渔业人口过剩问题及对策[J].中国渔业经济.2002(4):49-50
    [58] GAO Jian,Chen Da-qun.Effects of fisheries production factors on the sustainable development of Chinese marine fisheries economics[J], Journal of Shanghai Fisheries University Vo1.12 Suppl:86-92
    [59] Peterson, M.J. International fisheries management[J]. Environment, May92, Vol. 34 Issue 4:p31, 1/4p.
    [60] Thorpe, Andy,Ibarra, Alfonso Aguilar. The New Economic Model and Marine Fisheries Development in Latin America[J]. World Development, Sep2000, Vol. 28 Issue 9, p1689, 14p, 3 charts.
    [61] Cullen, Ross. Fisheries management[J]. Choices: The Magazine of Food, Farm & Resource Issues,1996 3rd Quarter, Vol. 11 Issue 3, p29, 3p.
    [62] Bruce Arai, A. Policy and practice in the Atlantic fisheries: Problems of regulatory enforcement[J]. Canadian Public Policy; Dec94, Vol. 20 Issue 4, p353, 12p, 1 chart.
    [63] Crabbe, Phillippe,Van Long, Ngo. Entry deterrence and overexploitation of the fishery[J]. Journal of Economic Dynamics & Control; Jul93, Vol. 17 Issue 4, p679,26p, 5 graphs.
    [64] McGoodwin, James R. Mexico's Conflictual Inshore Pacific Fisheries: Problem Analysis and Policy Recommendations[J]. Human Organization; Fall87, Vol. 46 Issue 3, p221, 12p.
    [65] Karpoff, Jonathan M. Suboptimal Controls in Common Resource Management: The Case of the Fishery[J]. Journal of Political Economy; Feb87, Vol. 95 Issue 1, p179, 16p.
    [66] Anderson,Lee G.”The Relationship between Firm and Fishery in Common Property Fisheries” [J]. Land Econ.52(May 1976) :179-91.
    [67] Clark, Colin W. Bioecononic Modelling arzd Fisheries Mareagememt[J]. New York: Wiley, 1985.
    [68] Anon. l983b. "The Trouble with Boat Quotas”[R]Canadian Fishing Report 5(10): 4.
    [69] Bell, F. W,and R. F. Fullenbaum. 1973. “The American Lobster Fishery: Economic Analysis of Alternative Management Strategies” [J].Marine Fisheries Review 35(8): 1-6.
    [70] Campbell, David. 1984. Individual Transferable Catch Quatas: Their role. Use and Application[J]. Fishery Report No. 11,Datwin: Department of Primary Production, Northern Territort.
    [71] Copes, Parzival. A Critical Review of the Individual Quota as a Device in Fisheries Management[J]. Land Economics; Aug86, Vol. 62 Issue 3, p278, 14p.
    [72] Anderson, L.G. 1994. An economic analysis of highgrading in ITQ fisheries regulation programs[J]. Marine Resource Economics, Vol. 9, pp. 209-26.
    [73] Canada. 1996. Commercial Fisheries Licensing Policy or Eastern Canada[J]. Fisheries and Oceans. Ottawa: Minister of Supply and Services.
    [74] Wiber, Melanie G. Fishing Rights as an Example of the Economic Rhetoric of Privatization: Calling for an Implicated Economics[J]. Canadian Review of Sociology & Anthropology; Aug2000, Vol. 37 Issue 3, p267, 22p.
    [75] Clay, P 1996. Fishermen views on property in the Northeast fishery: Private versus common, quotas versus territories In The Role of Law in Natural Resource Management. J. Spiertz and M.G. Wiber (eds.). The Dutch and Belgian Law and Society Monograph Series: Recht der Werkelijkheid, pp. 121 14.
    [76] Copes, E 1995. Problems with ITQs in Fisheries Marzagement mith Tentative Comments on Refeuance for Faroe Island Fisheries. Discussion Paper 95-I, 22 pp. Simon Fraser University, Institute of Fisheries Analysis.
    [77] Crowley, B.L. (ed) the Atlantic 1996.Taking Ourzership: Property Rights and Fishery Management on Halifax: Atlantic Institute for Market Studies.
    [78] Scott, A.D. 1996.The ITQ as a property right: Where it came from, how it works, and where it is going. In Taking Ownership: Property Rights and Fishery Management on the Atlantic Coast. B.L. Crowley (ed.) [J]. Halifax: Atlantic Institute for Market Studies PP. 31-98.
    [79] Terkla, David G.Doeringer, Peter B.Moss, Philip I. Widespread Labor Stickiness in the New England Offshore Fishing Industry: Implications for Adjustment and Regulation[J]. Land Economics; Feb88, Vol. 64 Issue 1, p73, 10p.
    [80] Anderson, Lee G. The Share System in Open-Access and Optimally Regulated Fisheries[J]. Land Economics; Nov82, Vol. 58 Issue 4, p435, 15p, 4 graphs.
    [81] Anderson, L. G. 1977. The Economics of Fisheries Management. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkips University Press.
    [82] Meltzoff, S. K.,and E. LiPuma.1986. TheTroubled Seas of SpanishFishermen: MarinePolicy and the Economy of Change[J]. American Ethnologist 13 (Nov.):681一 99.
    [83] Crutchfield, J. A. 1961. An Economic Evaluation of Alternative Methods of Fishery Regulations[J].Journal of law and Econnrnics 4 (Oct.): 131-43
    [84] Sutinen, Jon G. 1979. Fishermen's Remuneration Systems and Implications for Fisheries Development[J]. Scottish Jnurrurl of Political Economy 26: 147-62.
    [85] Holland, Daniel SIntegrating spatial management measures into traditional fishery management systems: the case of the Georges Bank multispecies groundfish fishery[J]. ICES Journal of Marine Science; Oct2003, Vol. 60 Issue 5, p915, 15p.
    [86] Arévalo, J.R. Chinea, E. Barquín, E. Pasture management under goat grazing on Canary Islands. Agriculture[J]. Ecosystems & Environment; Jan2007, Vol. 118 Issue 1-4, p291-296, 6p.
    [87] Zou, Chunjing ,Wang, Kaiyun,Wang, Tianhou,Xu, Wenduo, Overgrazing and soil carbon dynamics in eastern Inner Mongolia of China[J]. Ecological Research; Jan2007, Vol. 22 Issue 1, p135-142, 8p, 3 charts, 1 map.
    [88] Orth, Robert J. Carruthers, Tim J. B. Dennison, William C. A Global Crisis for Seagrass Ecosystems[J]. Bioscience; Dec2006, Vol. 56 Issue 12, p987-996, 10p, 1 chart, 2 diagrams, 1 graph, 4c.
    [89] Batkin, Kirsten M. New Zealand's quota management system: A solution to the United States' federal fisheries[J]. Natural Resources Journal; Fall96, Vol. 36 Issue 4, p615, 26p, 2 graphs.
    [90] Kher, Unmesh,Dell, Kristina,Kingsbury, Kathleen,OCEANS OF NOTHING. Time; 11/13/2006, Vol. 168 Issue 20, p56-57, 2p, 1 chart, 2 graphs, 1 map, 1c
    [91] Hartnett, Mike,Seafood Industry Issues Take Center Stage[J]. Frozen Food Age; Nov2006, Vol. 55 Issue 4, p10-10, 1/3p
    [92] Annala, John,Holland, Daniel S.Hilborn, Ray, The cost of overfishing and management strategies for new fisheries on slow-growing fish: orange roughy (Hoplostethus atlanticus) in New Zealand[J]. Canadian Journal of Fisheries & Aquatic Sciences; Oct2006, Vol. 63 Issue 10, p2149-2153, 5p, 1 chart, 1 graph
    [93] Myers, R.&Worm, B. 2003, `Rapid worldwide depletion of predatory fish communities'[J].Nature, vol. 423, May,pp. 280-283.
    [94] Pauly, D.&McLean, J. 2003, In a perfect ocean: the state of fisheries and ecosystems in the North Atlantic Ocean, Island Press, Washington DC[J].
    [95] Hossain, Md. Monir,Islam, Md. Aminul,Ridgway, Stephen,Matsuishi, Takashi, Management of inland open water fisheries resources of Bangladesh: Issues and options[J]. Fisheries Research; Mar2006, Vol. 77 Issue 3, p275-284,10p
    [96] Turner, S. J. Thrush, S. F. Hewitt, J. E. Cummings, V. J. Funnell, G. , Fishingimpacts and the degradation or loss of habitat structure[J]. Fisheries Management & Ecology; Oct99, Vol. 6 Issue 5, p401-420, 20p.
    [97] Bohnsack J.A.&Ault J.S. (1996) Management strategies to conserve marine biodiversiry[J]. Oceanography 9, 73-82.
    [98] Satria, Arif,Matsida, Yoshiaki, Decentralization Policy: An Opportunity for Strengthening Fisheries Management System? [J]. Journal of Environment & Development; Jun2004, Vol. 13 Issue 2, p179-196, 18p.
    [99] Chen, Jie, Rapid urbanization in China: A real challenge to soil protection and food security[J]. CATENA; Jan2007, Vol. 69 Issue 1, p1-15, 15p.
    [100] Cao, Wenzhi ,Zhu, Hejian, Chen, Songlin, Impacts of urbanization on topsoil nutrient balances—a case study at a provincial scale from Fujian, China[J]. CATENA; Jan2007, Vol. 69 Issue 1, p36-43, 8p
    [101] Blyth, Robert E.,Kaiser, Michel J.,Edwards-Jones,Gareth, Hart, Paul J. B. Implications of a zoned fishery management system for marine benthic communities[J]. Journal of Applied Ecology,Oct2004, Vol. 41 Issue 5, p951-961, 11p.
    [102] 清光昭夫、岩崎寿男.水产经济学.北京:海洋出版社[M],253.
    [103] 孙金华.各国渔船收购政策经验之比较与评估.“国际间对渔捞能力之管理概况及中国(台湾)之因应”座谈会发言稿[C].2005(6).
    [104] 关于 2003-2010 年海洋捕捞渔船控制制度实施意见[R],农渔函[2003]63 号.
    [105] 任淑华.中韩渔业协定生效舟山 渔民转产转业的策略[J].渔业管理,2002:62-64;
    [106] 宋伟华、池弘福等,舟山市渔民转产转业的做法和建议,中国水产,2003(2):26.
    [107] 袁庆明.新制度经济学[M].北京,中国发展出版社,2005(2):44.
    [108] 段小梅.人口流动模型与中国农村剩余劳动力转移研究[J].农村经济,2003(3):43-45
    [109] 郑卫东.舟山地区捕捞劳动力流动性研究(2000 年)[J].48-56
    [110] 刘凡等著. 产权经济学[M]. 湖北人民出版社, 2002:76-87
    [111] 吕中楼. 新制度经济学研究[M]. 中国经济出版社, 2005:27-45.
    [112] 程恩富. 新制度经济学[M]. 经济日报出版社, 2005:37-48.
    [113] 邴绍倩.中国渔业劳动力城镇化迁移问题的研究[D],2005.
    [114] 慕永通.渔业问题及其根源剖析[J],中国海洋大学学报(社会科学版)2003(6):66-74
    [115] 刘建峰.公共池塘资源占用者集体行动的“第三条道路”——自主组织和自主治理的集体行动理论[J]
    [116] 落实科学发展观 构建健康发展的水产养殖业--李健华局长在全国水产养殖工作座谈会上讲话(摘要)[J].中国水产,2005(9)
    [117] 周先标.浅谈中外休闲渔业管理[J].中国渔业经济,2004(5):28
    [118] 邴绍倩.当前中国休闲渔业的发展状况及其战略[J].上海水产大学学报,2003 (9 )(第12 卷第 3 期):278
    [119] 张贡生.关于加快中国城镇化进程的四个问题[J].郑州轻工业学院学报( 社会科学版) ,2005(4)(第 6 卷第 2 期):47
    [120] 管振青.台湾中山大学,台湾沿近海渔业减船政策之效益评估[J].75-78
    [121] 中国渔业年鉴(2000、2001、2002、2003、2004、2005).
    [122] 慕永通.中国海洋捕捞业的困境与出路[J].中国海洋大学学报(社会科学版),2005(2):38-39
    [123] 唐建业,黄硕琳.渔业配额权的法律分析.上海水产大学,2003
    [124] 夏章英. 渔政管理学[M]. 海洋出版社,1996:35-75.
    [125] 张米尔. 市场化进程中的资源型城市产业转型[M]. 机械工业出版社,2005:79-104
    [126] 孙月平. 劳动经济问题研究[M]. 人民出版社,2004:38-45.
    [127] 袁乐平 等著. 失业经济学[M]. 经济科学出版社, 2003:44-67.
    [128] 刘东勋等著. 新区域经济学论纲[M]. 社会科学文献出版社, 2005:17-35.
    [129] 郝寿义等著. 区域经济学(第二版) [M]. 经济科学出版社,2004:78-86.
    [130] 刘江.21 世纪初中国农业发展战略[M].北京,中国农业出版,2000:48-78
    [131] 陈可文.中国海洋经济学[M].北京,海洋出版社,2003,68-76
    [132] 陈新军(主编).渔业资源与渔场学[M].北京,海洋出版社,2004:219-269
    [133] 夏世福(主编).中国水产资源开发利用的经济问题[M].北京,海洋出版社,1987(6):56-65
    [134] Y 巴泽尔(著),费方域、段毅才(译).产权的经济分析[M].上海,上海三联书店、上海人民出版社,2002:2;4-8
    [135] 青木昌彦(著),周黎安(译).比较制度分析[M].上海:上海远东出版社,2002: 212
    [136] 郭守前.资源特性与制度安排—海洋渔业资源开发的制度经济学分析[D].广州:华南农业大学,2002:173-184
    [137] 杨正勇.海洋渔业资源管理中 ITQ 制度交易成本研究[D].上海:复旦大学,2005:161-179
    [138] 罗贞礼.可持续发展背景下区域农业结构调整研究—以南方丘陵山区郴州市为例[D].长沙:湖南农业大学,2004:10-19
    [139] 黄小晶.农业产业政策理论与实证探析[D].广州,暨南大学,2002:20
    [140] 程慧荣.中国渔民收入问题研究[D].青岛:中国海洋大学,2005:19-21
    [141] 陆久炎.关于沿海渔民转产转业工作之探讨[J].现代渔业信息, 2003(5):19-20
    [142] 金素珍.促进福建省渔民增收的对策研究[J].福建水产,2005(3):68-72
    [143] 金锋. 台州地区如何实施捕捞渔民转产转业[J].中国渔业经济 2003(2):26-27
    [144] 杨坚,李彦亮.关于沿海渔民转产转业情况的政策建议[J].中国渔业经济. 2002(1):20-21
    [145] 杨黎明.绍兴海洋捕捞渔民转产转业调查与研究[J].中国渔业经济,2005(2):44
    [146] 于会国, 陈静娜, 慕永通.中国海洋渔业资源产权化管理模式研究[J].浙江海洋学院学报(自然科学版),2006(2):164-169
    [147] 郑卫东,娄小波,李欣.中国沿海渔民转产转业的进展综述[J].中国渔业经济,2006(2):27-28,63
    [148] 朴英爱,李相高,李华.中国渔业管理的效果分析与 TAC 制度[J].中国渔业经济研究,2000(1):23—26
    [149] 农业部渔业局.中国沿海捕捞渔民转产转业工作己全面展开[J].中国渔业经济.2002(5):43
    [150] 顾定康等.关于定海区捕捞渔民转产转业工作的思考[J].中国渔业经济.2003 (4):30-32
    [151] 姜海滨.中国捕捞渔业资源可持续利用分析[J].山东省农业管理干部学院学报,2006(2):61—62
    [152] 林光纪.渔业公共资源的市场配置及其政策[J].福建水产,2005(4):1-4
    [153] 王玮婧.ITQ 破解渔业资源的产权难题[J].上海国资 2005(3):55-56
    [154] 李瑜琴,赵景波.过度放牧对生态环境的影响与控制对策[J].中国沙漠,2005(5),404-408
    [155] 殷文伟,李隆华,戎其跃.舟山渔业剩余劳动力转移困难的症结和对策研究[ J],海洋开发与管理,2006(4):126-129
    [156] 张学义.加强农民科技培训加快农村劳动力转移就业步伐[J].内蒙古科技与经济,2004(20):13-14
    [157] 王占国,王正麟.加快农村剩余劳动力转移的对策选择[J].学习与探索,2001(4):94-97
    [158] 袁宗建.城镇化过程中的制约因素与对策研究[J].经济训究导刊,2006(4):42-44
    [159] 张合成.农业部渔业局,用科学发展观指导渔业发展战略研究[N],2004.12.16
    [160] 经济结构理论及区域竞争理论[J],2005(12):23-24
    [161] 杨金森等.中国海洋 21 世纪议程[R]
    [162] 王诗成.论实施国家海洋农牧化工程[A].海洋强国论[C].北京,海洋出版社,2000.
    [163] 任淑华,吴中平. 舟山渔民转产转业的策略及对策[R]. 海洋出版社, 2003:36-37

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700