我国水权转换模式及转换价值评估研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
本文在综合利用水资源学、法学、经济学、数学、管理学、博弈论等理论的基础上,基于水权理论的分析和理解,借助对国外水权市场和水权转换的分析,研究了我国水权转换模式和水权转换价值评估模型,从而有利地指导我国水权转换,促进我国水权交易市场的形成。
     本文首先借鉴西方国家成熟水市场的经验,基于中国的国情,研究和探讨适合中国水市场的运作模式、框架结构,并给出了我国水市场的短期规划模式和长期规划模式,并设计了水权期货交易的组成和交易模式,并多个角度对我国实施水权转换的可行性和必要性进行了分析。其次,在整体分析水权转换所带来的正外部性和负外部性后,从水资源、工业、农业、生态和经济五个系统方面建立了水权转换外部效应的整体分析模型和五个子模型分析模型,具体分析水权转换与工业、农业、水资源及经济之间的联动关系及各系统内参数之间的相互关联关系,并对水权转换的外部效应结合实例进行了水权转换外部效应分析。第三,在结合资产评估、土地评估、矿业权评估的思想和原理的基础上,建立了水权价值评估的成本法、市场法和收益法模型,并对转换模型中的参数进行了探讨。最后以黄河水权转换为例从水权分配,节水、需水,到水权转换、转换定价、转换水量和补偿费用等进行了实证计算。第四,在分析水权转换市场上博弈要素的基础上,从博弈的角度对我国水权转换定价进行了分析,分别建立了初级水权分配的博弈模型和正式水权交易市场的博弈定价模型。第五,基于水市场的可持续发展角度,围绕我国水市场的研究,从制度、管理、立法等方面全面探讨了完善我国水权转换的策略,进一步促进了我国水市场的完善。
On the basis of analysis and comprehend of water right theory, by using the theories synthetically, such as law theory, economics theory, game theory, mathematics, managing method etc., water right conversion mode and water right conversion value evaluation model were analyzed with the analysis of abroad water right conversion mode and water right markets. It will guide our country the water right converts, promote the formation of the water right trades market in our country.Firstly, this text draw lessons from the mature market of water in west country, according to Chinese state of the nation, researched the mode, frame construction which were fit for the Chinese market of water, gave a short- term and long- term programming mode, designed the water right futures trade of constitute with trade the mode, and analysed the possibility and necessity from several angles .Secondly, after wholly analyzed the positive exterior and negative exterior that water right bring when converting, established water right conversion exterior effect of the whole analysis model and five statures model analysis model from the resources of water, industry, agriculture, ecosystem with economy five systems, analyzed combinable relation and parameter inside each systems mutually connection relating in a specific way between water right conversion and industry, agriculture, the resources of water and economy ,and analysed water right conversion exterior effect combining the solid cases. Thirdly, on the base of the thought and the foundation of the principle property evaluation, land evaluation, mineral industry power valuation, established the the models of the cost method, market method and income method about that water right value evaluation , and converted the parameter in the model proceeded the study, then took yellow river water right convert as an example from the water right assign, stanza water, need the water, to the water right convert, convert the list price and convert the water measures with compensate expenses etc, proceeded the substantial evidence the calculation. Forthly, on the foundation of analyzing the game elements in water right conversion market, converted the list price of our country water right from the angle of the game analysis, established the entry- level water right and the formal water right respectively. Finally according to the market of water must keep up with the developping , inquiried into the strategy of the water right conversion completely perfect our country, from the system, management, lawmaking etc, moreover promoted our country water market of perfect furtherly.
引文
[1] 陈峰.水权交易的经济分析[D].浙江大学硕士学位论文,2002,11.
    [2] 水利部政策法规司.水权与水市场(资料选编之一,二)[Z],2001,12.
    [3] 张仁田.区域水资源可持续利用研究[D].河海大学博士论文P32,2002.
    [4] 常云昆.黄河断流与黄河水权制度研究[M].中国社会科学出版社,2001,9.
    [5] 汪恕诚.水权和水市场——谈实现水资源优化配置的经济手段[J].中国水利,2000(11):6-9.
    [6] 胡鞍刚,王亚华.转型期水资源的优化配置,从东阳——义乌水权交易看我国水资源分配体制改革[Z],光明日报,2001-5-16.
    [7] 孟志敏.水权交易市场——水资源配置的手段[J].中国水利,2000(12):11-12.
    [8] Brajer V. and Martin W.. Allocating a Scarce Resource: Water in the West. American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 1989(48): 259-271.
    [9] 邵自平.美国西部水权历史演变及启示[D].武汉大学硕士学位论文,2004,5.
    [10] Saliba B C &Bush D B. Water markets in theory and practice: market transfers, water values and public policy, Studies in water policy and management. 1987, (12).
    [11] 王金霞等.国外水权交易的经验及对我国的启示[Z].水信息网,2002-4-16.
    [12] Rosegrant. Mark. W. and Renato Gazmuri Scheleyer, Tradble Water Rights;Experiences in Reforming Water Allocation Policy. Irrigation Support Project for Asia and the near East;Sponsored by the U.S. Agency for international Development, 1994.
    [13] 姜广斌.中国水权市场的建立和管理[D].北京理工大学硕士学位论文,2002,2.
    [14] Shupe S.. Weatherford G. and Checchio E.. Western Water Rights: The Era of Reallocation. Natural Resources Journal, 1989(29): 414-434.
    [15] Ralph A.Wurbs, Assessing Water Availability under a Water Rights Priority System, Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management, 2001(4): 127-143.
    [16] 傅春,胡振鹏.国内外水权研究的若干进展[J].中国水利,2000(6):40-41.
    [17] Janet C N. Beneficial Use, Water and Forfeiture: the Inefficient Search for Efficiency in Western Water Use. Environmental Law, 1998, 28(4).
    [18] Vaux H. and Howitt R..Managing Water Scarcity: An Evaluation of Interregional Transfers. Water Resources Research.1984(20): 785-792.
    [19] 张平.水权制度与水资源优化配置[J].人民黄河,2005年第4期.
    [20] 刘伟.中国水制度的经济学分析[D],复旦大学博士学位论支.2004.4.
    [21] Rosegrant M. and Binswanger. Markets in Tradable Water Rights: Potential for Efficiency Gains in Developing-country Water Resource Allocation. World Development, 1994(11): 1613-1625.
    [22] Green G. etal. Water allocation, transfers and conservation links between Policy and Hydrology[J]. Water Resources Development, 2000vol.16(2).
    [23] North Douglass C. and Robert Thomas. The Rise and Fall of the Manorial System, A System: A theoretical Model. Journal of Economic History, Dec. 1973.
    [24] Maass A. and Anderson R.. The Desert Shall Rejoice: Conflict, Growth and Justice in Arid Environments. MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass., 1978.
    [25] Tietenberg T.H.. Environmental .and Resource Economics, Scot, Foresman and Company. Boston, Massachusetts, 1998.
    [26] Green G, etal. Water allocation, transfers and conservation: links between policy and Hydrology, Water Resources Development, 2000, Vol.16(2)..
    [27] Colby B. Transactions costs and efficiency in western water allocation, American Journal of Agriculture Economics, 1990..
    [28] 苏青,施国庆,祝瑞祥.水权研究综述.水利经济,2001(7):3-11.
    [29] 姜爱华.水资源使用权制度研究[D].山东大学硕士学位论文,2003,9.
    [30] 李晓琳.水价研究的理论、模型与实践[D].河海大学硕士学位论文,2002,3.
    [31] 兰伟龙.马克思产权理论在我国水权管理中的运用[D].福建师范大学硕士学位论文,2004,4.
    [32] 滕朝霞.水权法律制度研究[D].山东大学硕士学位论文,2003,9.
    [33] 田圃德.水权制度创新及效率分析[M].中国水利水电出版社,2004,10.
    [34] 沈满洪,陈峰.我国水权理论研究评述[J].浙江社会科学,2002(5).
    [35] 钱燮铭,王伟英.水权转让的实践与认识[J].水利发展研究.2002(1).
    [36] 傅晨,吕绍东.水权转让的产权经济学分析[J].广东水利水电,2001(4).
    [37] 蔡守秋.论水权转让的范围和条件[J].城市环境,2002(1).
    [38] 张仁田,童利忠.水权、水权分配与水权交易体制的初步研究[J].水利发展研究,2002(5).
    [39] 沈菊琴,陆庆春.浅谈水权市场与水资源资产[J].中国水利,2003(4):10-11.
    [40] 单飞跃.经济法学[M].长沙:中南工业大学出版社,1999.
    [41] 杨向辉.甘肃省退耕还林还草规划及张掖地区开展退耕的综合分析.水土保持研究.2002(5):120~122.
    [42] 杨向辉.黑河流域水资源现状及其开发利用[J].水利水电科技进展.2003(3):25~27.
    [43] 田圃德,施国庆.关于水权价格的探讨[J].中国水利,2003(7B).
    [44] 姜文来.水权及其作用探讨[J].中国水利,2000(12).
    [45] 石玉波.关于水权和水市场的几点认识.水权与水市场(资料选编之一)[Z],水利部政策法规司,2001.3.
    [46] 黄河.水市场的特点和发展措施[J].中国水利,2000(12):15-16.
    [47] 董文虎.不同经济性质水的配置原则和管理模式——四论水权、水价、水市场[J].水利发展研究.2002(5).
    [48] 董文虎.三论水权、水价、水市场[J].水利发展研究,2002(2).
    [49] 葛颜祥.水权市场与农用水资源配置[D].山东农业大学博士学位论文,2003,5.
    [50] 傅春等.水权水权转让与南水北调基金的设想[J].中国水利,2001(2).
    [51] Saunders R., Warford J.J., Mann P.C.. Alternative Concepts of Marginal Cost of Pricing: Problems of Application in the Water Supply Sector. World Bank Staff Working Paper No.259.Washington, D.C., World Bank, 1977.
    [52] Hamilton J.N., Whittlesey N. and Halverson P., Interruptible Water Markets in the Pacific Northwest. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 1989(71): 63-75.
    [53] 周鑫根.浙江省城市间水资源交易过程与启示[J].中国给水排水,2003(9):22-24.
    [54] 王磊.两亿元买清水——国内第一笔水权交易详记[Z].人民日报华东新闻,2001-6-20
    [55] 吴文静.水市场的培育途径研究[D],河海大学硕士论文,2004,3.
    [56] Larry Simpson, Klsa Ringskog, Water Markets in the Americas. The World Bank Washington, D.c.1997.
    [57] Randll A.. Property Entitlements and Pricing Policies for a Maturing Water Economy. Australian Journal of Agricultural Economics, 1981(25): 195-212.
    [58] Lewis Warthai. The Theory of Economic Growth. London, George Allen& Urwin, 1955.
    [59] Lodge George C.and Ezra Vogel F. etat., Ideological and National Competition: An Analysis of Nine Countries, Cambridge, Mass. Harvard Business School, 1987.
    [60] Meinzen- Dick R.. Groundwater Markets in Pakistan: Participation and Productivity, Research Peports 105. International Food Policy Research Institute, Washington, D.C., 1996.
    [61] Anderson T. and Leal D.. Building Coalitions for Water Marketing. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management. 1989(8): 432-455.
    [62] Clyde S.. Adapting to the Changing Demand for Water Use Through Continued Refinement of the Prior Appropriation Doctrine: An Alternative Approach to Wholesale Real Location. Natural Resources Journal, 1989(29): 435-455.
    [63] Harper J. and Griffin R.. The Structure and Role of River Authorities in Texas. Water Resources Bulletin, 1988(24): 1317-1328.
    [64] Brajer V. and Martin W.. Water Rights Markets: Social and Legal Considerations. American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 1990(49): 35-44.
    [65] 袁浩.南澳大利亚的水权交易[J].中国农村水利水电,2000(9).
    [66] Bowen R., Moncur J. and Pollock R.. Rent Seeking, Wealth Transfers, and Water Rights: The Hawaii Case. Natural Resources Forum.1991(31): 429-448.
    [67] Chang C. and Griffin R.. Water Marketing as a Reallocative Institution in Texas. Water Resources Research, 1992(28): 879-890.
    [68] Howe C.. Lazo J. and Weber K.. The Economic Impacts of Agriculture-to-Urban Water Transfers on the Agricultural Economics, 1990(72): 1200-1204.
    [69] Weinberg M., , Kling C., and Wilen J..Water Markets and Water Quality, American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 1993.
    [70] [澳]水改革高级指导小组.鞠茂森,张仁田译.澳大利亚水交易[M].郑州.黄河水利出版社,2001.
    [71] Dinar A. and Letey J.. Agricultural Water Marketing, Allocative Efficiency, and Drainage Reduction. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 1971(20): 210-223.
    [72] Charney A. and Woodard G.. Socioeconomic Impacts of water Farming on Rural Areas of Origin in Arizona. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 1990(72): 1193-1199.
    [73] John R. Reerink and Masahiro Nakashima.刘斌等译.美国日本水权水价分配[M].天津:天津科学技术出版社,2000.
    [74] Rosen M. and Sexton R. Irrigation Districts and Water Markets: An Application of Cooperative Decision-Making Theory. Land Economics, 1993(69): 39-53.
    [75] Colby B, . Transactions Costs and Efficiency in Western Water Allocation. American Journal Economics , 1990 (72): 1184-1192.
    [76] Coward E.W.. Direct or indirect alternatives for irrigation investment and the creation of property. In irrigation Investment, Technology and Management Strategies for Development, ed K.W. Easter, Boulder, Westview Press, 1986: 225-244.
    [77] Koechler C.L.. Water rights and the Public Trust Doctrine: Resolution of the Mono Lake controversy.. Ecological Law Quarterly, 1995(3): 22: 541-590.
    [78] Meinzen-Dick R., Mendoza M.. Sadoulet L.. Abiad-Shields G. and Subramanian A.. Sustainable Water User Associations: Lessons from a Literature Review. Subramanian A.N.. Japannathan V. and Meizen-Dick R.. User Organization for Sustainable Water Services. World Bank Technical Paper No. 354, World Bank, Washington D.C..1997.
    [79] Moench M.. Allocating the common heritage: Debates over water rights and governance structures in India. National Heritage Institute, San Francisco(mimeo), 1995.
    [80] Phelps C.., Moore N.., and Graubard M.. Efficient Water Use in California: Water Rights, Water Districts and Water Transfers. The Rand Corporation, Santa Monica. CA..1978.
    [81] Rosegran M. and Binswanger H.. Markets in Tradable Water Rights: Potential for Efficiency Gains in Developing Country Irrigation. Unpublished Draft, 1992.
    [82] Strosser P. and Meinzen-Dick R.. Groundwater Markets In Pakistan: An Analysis OF Selected Issues. In Selling Water: Conceptual and Policy Debates over Groundwater Markets in India. Ed. M Moench. Gujarat.. India: VIKSAT, Pacific Institute, Natural Heritage Institute, 1994.
    [83] 孙卫.水权管理制度的国际比较与思考[J].中国软科学,2001(12).
    [84] 潘春梅.水权市场的法律分析[D].河海大学硕士论文,2004年3月.
    [85] Mahmood Ahmad, Water pricing and markets in the Near East: policy issues and options, Water Policy, 2000(2): 229-242.
    [86] White Stephene. Appropriation and Water Rights Issues in the High Plains Ogallala Region[J]. The Social Science Journal, 1996(4), : 437-450.
    [87] Vishal Narain. India's water crisis: the challenges of governance. Water Policy 2(2000) 433-444.
    [88] Charles S. Sokile, Barbara van Koppen. Local water rights and local water user entities: the unsung heroines of water resource management in Tanzania[J]. Physics and Chemistry of the Earth 29 (2004) 1349-1356.
    [89] Clay Landry, Market transfers of water for environmental protection in the western United States.[J]. Water Policy 1(1998) 457-469.
    [90] Marian L. Weber. Markets for Water Rights under Environmental Constraints. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 2001(42): 53-64.
    [91] Ralph A. Wurbs. Modeling river/reservoir system management, water allocation, and supply reliability. Journal of Hydrology 300 (2005) 100-113..
    [92] Wim H. Kloezen. Water markets between Mexican water user associations. Water Policy 1 (1998)437-455.
    [93] Mahmood Ahmad. Water pricing and markets in the Near East: policy issues and options. Water Policy 2 (2000) 229±242.
    [94] Sylvain R. Perret. Water policies and smallholding irrigation schemes in South Africa: a history and new institutional challenges Sylvain R. Perret.
    [95] 潘忠文.我国水权制度重构[D].东北林业大学硕士论文,2003,5.
    [96] 蔡守秋.论水权转换的范围和条件[J].城市环境,2002(1).
    [97] Wescoat J.L.. The Right of Thirst for Animals in Islamic Law: A Comparative Approach. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space, 1995(13): 637-654.
    [98] Sadeque S.Z. and Turnquist S.. Handpump financing issues in Bangladesh: An exploratory study, UNDP/World Bank Water and Sanitation Program. New Delhi(mimeo). 1995.
    [99] Spulber N. and Sabbaghi A.. Economics of Water Resources. Kluwer Academic Publishers. Norwell. Massachusetts.1994.
    [100] 王治.关于建立水权转让制度的思考[J].中国水利,2003(7):13-15.
    [101] 熊向阳.对水资源专有性、定价和水权交易等问题的探讨[Z].水利部政策法规司,2001-6-22.
    [102] Ioslovich Ilya , Gutman Per-Olof. A model for the global optimization of water prices and usage for the case of spatially distributed sources and consumers[J]. Mathematics and Computers in Simulation 56 (2001) 347-356.
    [103] 张永武.《水权、水价、水利工程管理体制改革创新与水行政执行法》(实务全书)第一、二、三册,地震出版社,2000.
    [104] Whittlesy N. and Houston J.. Water Markets for Stream Flow Augmentation in a Critical Assessment of Forecasting in Western Water Management. Cassidy J. and Lettenmair D.etal.. American Water Resources Associstion, 1984: 139-146.
    [105] 杨琴.对水权交易的几点思考[J],人文杂志 2005(1):80-82.
    [106] 康芒斯.制度经济学(上)[M].于树生译,商务印书馆,1962年版.
    [107] 史尚宽.物权法论[M].北京:中国政法大学出版社,2000年.
    [108] Alchian A.A. and Demsetz Harold. The Property Right Paradigm, Journal of Economic History, 1973(16): 16-27.
    [109] 张郁,吕东辉,秦丽杰.水权交易市场构想[J].中国人口.资源与环境,2001(4):59-61.
    [110] 张郁,吕东辉,秦丽杰.基于合约化的水权交易市场分析[J],地理科学,2003,第23卷第1期,118-121.
    [111] Colby Saliba B., Do Water Markets "work"? Market Transfers and Trade Offices in the Southwestern States. Water Resources Research, 1987(23): 1113-1122.
    [112] 杨向辉,陈洪转等.我国水市场的构架及运作模式探讨[J].人民黄河.2006(3).
    [113] 焦爱华,杨高升.中国水市场的运作模型研究[J],水利水电科技进展,2001(4):37-40.
    [114] 吴国平.水权转让的基本理念和应用分析[J].中国水利,2004(16):15-17.
    [115] Howe C.W.. Schurmeier D.R. and Shaw W.D.. Innovative Approaches to Water Allocation: The Potential for Water Markets. Water Resources Research, 1986(22): 439-455.
    [116] 赵玉秋,我国水权交易法律问题探讨,东北林业火学硕士论文.2003.5
    [117] Janet C N. Beneficial Use, Water and Forfeiture: the Inefficient Search for Efficiency in Western Water Use. Environmental Law, 1998, 28(4).
    [118] 刘莹.关于水权交易市场相关问题的探讨[J].中国水利,2004(9):6-8.
    [119] 姚滐宝,王道席,柴成果.黄河水权初始水权配置优先位序初步研究[J].人民黄河,2005(5).
    [120] 杨向辉,陈洪转等.我国水权转换的制约因素分析[J].水利经济.2006(7).
    [121] Rosegrant. Mark. W. and Renato Gazmuri Scheleyer, Tradble Water Rights;Experiences in Reforming Water Allocation Policy. Irrigation Support Project for Asia and the near East;Sponsored by the U.S. Agency for international Development, 1994.
    [122] 李磊.我国水权交易的新思路——实物期权交易[J].价格理论与实践.2004(8):54-55.
    [123] Winpenny J.. Managing Water as an Economic Resource. Routledge, London, 1994.
    [124] 孙广生、裴勇.黄河水资源统一管理与调度的实践与展望[J].人民黄河,2004(5).
    [125] 黄河水文水资源科研所、黄委水资源管理与调度局,《南水北调工程西线调水与黄河水资源统一管理调度研究》[Z],2004.8.
    [126] 杨彦明.科罗拉多河水权分配的启示[J].水利发展研究,2004(9).
    [127] Slim Zekria, William Easterb. Estimating the potential gains from markets: a case study from Tunisia[J]. Agricultural Water Management 72 (2005) 161-175.
    [128] Clay Landry, Market transfers of water for environmental protection in the western United States, Water Policy, 1998(1): 457-469.
    [129] Larry Simpson, Klsa Ringskog, Water Markets in the Americas. The World BankWashington, D.c.1997.
    [130] 黄委水政局、清华大学公共管理学院.《转型期中国水资源产权研究报告》[Z].2003.11.
    [131] 沈满洪.水权交易制度研究——中国的案例分析[D],浙江大学博士学位论文,2004,4.
    [132] 胡玉荣 陈永奇.黄河水权转让的实践与认识[J].中国水利,2004(15):46-48.
    [133] Colby Saliba B. and Bush D.. Water Markets in Theory and Practice, Westview Boulder, 1987.
    [134] 尹云松、糜仲春.建立水权市场对农村发展的影响及其应对措施[J].农业经济问题2004(7),45-47.
    [135] Becker N. .A comparative analysis of water price support versus drought compensation scheme[J]. Agricultural Economics 21(1999) 81-92..
    [136] 杨彦明,董锁成.跨地区调水对水成本的影响分析:一个类比[J].水科学进展vol 14,2003(6):774-780.
    [137] 钟水映.调水与调人:人口与水资源合理配置的另外一个视角[J],人口与经济,2004(6):55-59.
    [138] 汪达.论国外跨流域掉水工程对生态环境的影响与发展趋势[Z].人大复印资料,2000(1)(原载:环境科学动态,1999(3)).
    [139] 郑垂勇.科技统计与科技发展战略——理论、模型、实践[M].南京:河海大学出版社,1992.
    [140] 郑垂勇.水资源与国民经济协调发展研究[M].南京:河海大学出版社,1996.
    [141] Hong Yang, Xiaohe Zhang, Alexander J.B. Zehnder. Water scarcity, ricing mechanism and institutional reform in northern China irrigated agriculture. Agricultural Water Management 61(2003) 143-161.
    [142] 刘杰,姜文来.任天志.农业用水使用权转让补偿机制研究[J].中国农业资源与区划.2001年第6期.
    [143] 姜文来.中国水权实践的起点[J].中国水利报,2001-2-10.
    [144] 钱燮铭,王伟英.水权转换的实践与认识[J].水利发展研究,2002.1.
    [145] 汪丁丁.产权博弈[J].经济研究,1996(10).
    [146] 贾芝锡.坚持和发展马克思的劳动价值论建立自然资源有价值论[J].中国地质经济,1992(9):24-32.
    [147] 杨向辉等.流域水资源管理信息决策支持系统研究[J].《人民黄河》,(已录用).
    [148] 沈大军,梁瑞驹等.水价理论与实践.科学出版社,1999.
    [149] 姜文来.水资源价值论.科学出版社,1999.
    [150] 董浩.关于发展水权市场的思考[J].中国农村水利水电,2001(11).
    [151] 刘卫东.资源性资产评估理论、方法研究[D].青岛建筑工程学院硕士学位论文,2000,3.
    [152] 陈久梅.无形资产评估理论、方法若干问题研究[D].西安电子科技大学硕士学位论文,2002,3.
    [153] 耿书文.基于博弈论的矿业权评估理论与方法研究[D],北京科技大学博士论文.2002.
    [154] Michelsen A. M. etal.. Expectations in water-rights prices[J]. Water Resources Development, 1993, vol, 16(2).
    [155] 沈满洪.论水权交易与交易成本[J].人民黄河2004(7).
    [156] 王克强,刘红梅.水资源公共定价模型研究[J].数量经济技术经济研究,2003(10):72-75.
    [157] 孔珂,解建仓等.水市场的博弈分析[J].水利学报,2005(4):491-495.
    [158] 谢标,杨永刚.水资源定价方法的初步探讨[J].环境科学,1999(3).
    [159] 潘向东.我国跨国企业转让定价的研究[D].湖南大学硕士学位论文,2001,9.
    [160] 蒋宜勋.风险企业的市场价值评估及定价博弈研究[D].西南交通大学硕士学位论文,2001,1.
    [161] Goodman .D.J.&Howe C.W.. Determinations of ditch company share prices in the South Platte River Basin[J]. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 1997..
    [162] 胡鞍刚,王亚华.转型期水资源配置的公共政策:准市场和政治民主协商.中国 水权分析研究报告[Z],2000(16).
    [163] 侯云先,王锡岩.战略产业博弈分析.机械工业出版社,2004,8.
    [164] George B. Frisvold a, Margriet F. Caswell. Transboundary water management Game-theoretic lessons for projects on the US-Mexico border.[J]. Agricultural Economics 24 (2000) 101-111.
    [164] 汪丁丁.从交易费用到博弈均衡[J].经济研究,1995(9).
    [165] 内蒙古自治区水利水电勘探设计院.内蒙古自治区黄河水权转换总体规划报告.2004,7.
    [166] 内蒙古自治区水利科学研究院.内蒙古黄河南岸灌区向内蒙古珠江投资有限公司水权转让可行性研究报告[Z].2003,11.
    [167] 水利部黄河水利委员会,黄河水资源管理、调度及灌溉节水潜力研究,黄河中下游水资源开发利用及河道减淤清淤关键技术研究报告[Z],2002,4.
    [168] 水利部黄河水利委员会水政局,清华大学公共管理学院.转型期中国水资源产权研究报告[Z].2003,11.
    [169] 董文虎.浅析水资源水权与水利工程供水权[J].中国水利,2001(2).
    [170] 钟玉秀.对水权交易价格和水市场立法原则的初步认识[Z].中国水利报,2001-6-29.
    [171] 刘文,黄河,王春元.培育水权交易机制促进水资源优化配置[J].水利经济,1998(8).
    [172] 陈庆秋.水资源管理市场经济机制的理论剖析[J].人民黄河,2005(5).
    [173] Ralph A. WurbS. Modeling river/reservoir system management, water allocation, and supply reliability. Journal of Hydrology 300 (2005) 100-113
    [174] United Nations. Efficiency and Distributional Equity in the Use and Treatment of Water: Guidelines for Pricing and Regulations. Natrual Resources/Water Series No.8. United Nations: New York, 1980.
    [175] 钱燮铭、王伟英.水权转换的实践与认识[J].水利发展研究,2002(1).
    [176] 胡振鹏,傅春等.水资源使用权有偿转让浅议[J].中国水利,2001(5):16-17.
    [177] Whittlesey N. etal.. Water Policy issues for the twentyfirst century[j]. American Journal of Agriculture Econmics, 1995(5): 77.
    [178] 温桂芳 钟玉秀.我国水价形成机制和管理制度深化改革研究一深化水价改革:进程与问题[J].价格理论与实践.2004(8):7-9.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700