农村信用担保机构运行效率研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
在农村信贷市场上,担保约束造成了农村金融机构的农村信贷资产质量不高、农村信贷业务难以拓展和农村经济主体的融资难问题。为缓解这种困境,国际经验和我国部分地区的实践经验表明,构建以服务农民和农村经济发展为目的的信用担保体系,在参与金融交易的农村金融机构和农村经济主体之间引入一个传递信号的第三方担保,可以在一定程度上解决担保约束问题,从而缓解农户与农村中小企业融资难的问题。农村信用担保机构是农村信用担保体系运作的微观主体,也是社会信用体系的重要组成部分。农村信用担保机构持续健康的运行是农村信用担保体系能够发挥杠杆作用的前提和基础,也是社会信用体系完善的有力保障。因此,深入考察农村信贷融资的担保约束及当前农村信用担保机构的发展状况,特别是对已有的不同模式的农村信用担保机构的运行效率及其影响因素进行深入分析和研究,对构建适合农村经济及金融发展形势的农村信贷担保体系不仅有理论意义,更具现实意义。
     本文主要以福建为研究对象,分析了农村正规的信贷融资受担保约束的状况,明确了我国和福建信用担保业的发展状况,利用调查数据深入地分析了福建农村信用担保机构的运行状况,介绍了四个中东欧转型经济体国家的农村信用担保计划的发展经验,指出了值得借鉴的成功经验。在对信用担保机构运行效率度量方法分析讨论的基础上,根据调查数据,运用数据包络分析法(DEA)对农村信用担保机构运行效率进行测算和判断分析,并运用Tobit回归模型分析影响农村信用担保机构运行效率的因素,随后提出提高农村信用担保机构运行效率的政策建议。
     本文经系统研究而形成的主要结论有以下几个方面:
     第一,在农村金融市场上,事前金融合约的达成既受客观自然风险的影响,还受借贷双方信息不对称所导致的信用风险的制约。为了防范违约风险,农村金融机构普遍采用担保贷款的形式向农村经济主体发放贷款。但是,担保贷款却受农村经济主体从事产业的弱质性、实际财产状况不佳及其产权不明晰、抵押担保品产权交易市场缺乏和抵押担保贷款交易成本高昂等因素的制约,从而造成了农村经济主体的贷款难问题。通过模型分析表明,建立农村信用担保机构能有效的解除担保的约束,从而在一定程度上缓解农村经济主体的融资难问题。
     第二,通过对福建省农村信用担保机构运行状况的深入调查分析表明,农村信用担保机构的建立与快速发展,在一定程度上缓解了农村经济主体的资金压力。然而,由于农村信用担保机构建立的时间不长,目前尚处于发展初期,在其运行过程中还存在着诸如担保资金有限、规模小、信用面狭窄和难以满足众多农村经济主体的融资需求;担保放大倍数过小,信用扩张能力弱;担保机构与金融机构合作不畅,风险分散机制尚未建立;政府监管缺位,行业有待规范等许多问题。
     第三,通过对福建省农村信用担保机构运行状况的深入调查分析还表明,农村信用担保机构的发展受地方政府的政策影响较大,并由于地方政府的重视程度不同,而使各地区的发展不平衡;有的地方还存在着商业性农村信用担保机构过多、过滥及不规范经营问题。同时,由于不同模式的农村信用担保机构的目标、对象、机构性质、社会定位,以及追求的利益目标不同,其运行结果也有所不同,其中互助性农村信用担保机构的总体运行状况良好,而商业性和政策性农村信用担保机构的总体运行状况较差。
     第四,如何度量信用担保机构的运行效率,不同的学者从不同的角度提出了不同的方法,主要有财务比率分析法、成本收益法和投入产出法等,由于受基础数据的来源与准确性、替代问题及贡献模糊等因素的约束,导致对信用担保机构运行效率的度量远比对其内容和结构的分析判断要困难得多。
     第五,通过运用DEA方法,评价了福建省农村信用担保机构2008年的运行效率,实证结果表明,福建省农村信用担保机构的总体运行效率偏低,而且个体之间的差异较大。同时,不同地区的农村信用担保机构,其运行效率也存在着较大的差异。实证研究结果还表明,不同模式的农村信用担保机构,其运行效率也存在着差异,其中互助性农村信用担保机构的运行效率明显高于商业性和政策性担保机构的运行效率,而且其差异主要体现在纯技术效率层面上,即对现有资源利用能力的差异上,也就是互助性农村信用担保机构在运用担保资金进行贷款担保的能力上有明显的优势。
     第六,通过运用Tobit回归模型,对影响农村信用担保机构运行效率的因素进行实证分析,结果表明,担保机构的模式、保费收入占总收入的比例、担保机构成立的年数、担保费率、协议担保放大倍数、金融机构存贷比、工业产值占GDP的比例等因素对农村信用担保机构运行效率的影响是显著的。
     第七,通过分析四个中东欧转型经济体国家在农村信用担保计划方面十几年的发展经验可知,其中有很多成功的经验值得我国借鉴,特别是在农村信用担保计划的定位明确、政府支持方式得当及其与金融机构的良好合作关系等方面,都有借鉴意义。
     第八,通过调查分析和实证分析,本文提出应发展以互助性农村信用担保为主体,商业性和政策性农村信用担保为辅助的,能够有效地控制、分散和化解风险的多元化农村信用担保体系,同时应充分地发挥政府政策引导和监督作用,促进农村信用担保机构的良性发展,构建积极的农村信用担保机构与金融机构的合作关系。
In the rural credit guarantee market, there exist some problems such as the poor quality of credit property in rural financial organizations, the difficulty of developing credit services in rural area and collecting fund by rural economic subject, which are the result of the guarantee restraints. Constructing credit guarantee system and introducing the third party guarantee as a bridge between the rural financial institution and the rural economic subject will help to ease the difficulty of collecting fund for the farmers and small and medium-sized enterprises. As a microsubject in the rural credit guarantee system operation, the rural credit guarantee organization is also an important part of social credit system.Thus, its consistent operation provides the foundation for the leverage of the rural credit guarantee system and ensures the improvement of social credit system. Therefore, the systemic survey on the rural credit restraints and the analysis on the operation efficiency of the existing rural credit guarantee organizations will provide the theoretical basis and practical experience to construct the proper rural credit guarantee system.
     With Fujian Province as the study subject, the thesis starts with the analysis of the guarantee restraints on standard fund collecting to have a clear picture of the present situation of credit guarantee industry in China and Fujian Province. Then taking advantage of the experience of transitional economic countries in Central and Eastern Europe for reference, the thesis makes the analysis and estimation on the operation efficiency of the rural credit guarantee organizations in the method of Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA). The thesis also employs Tobit regression model to find the elements affecting the operation efficiency of rural credit guarantee organizations. After that, the policy proposals to improve the operation efficiency of rural credit guarantee organizations are put forward in the thesis.
     The main conclusions in the thesis are as follow:
     First, the financial contract is restrained by the natural risk and credit risk caused by the asymmetric information of both parties in rural financial market. Usually the rural financial organizations grant the loans to rural economic subjects in the manner of guarantee loan to decrease the risk of default. However, some elements such as the rural industry vulnerability, poor property state and unclearly-indentified property right, no trade fair for collaterals, and high trading cost, etc. make it difficult to ask for a loan for the rural economic subjects. The analysis of model shows that the construction of the rural guarantee organizations will relieve the guarantee restraints and reduce the difficulty of collecting fund for the rural economic subjects.
     Second, the complete survey on the operation of the rural credit guarantee organizations in Fujian Province displays that the construction and rapid development of the rural credit guarantee organizations help to relieve the funds shortage for the rural economic subjects in some extend. Meanwhile, there exists some problems in the process of operation. The problems are:for the rural economic subjects, limited guarantee capitals and small scale of credit coverage can't meet their needs; Security magnification is too small, weak expansion of credit; there is no risk dispersed mechanism; it is lacking in government regulation and industry standards, so on and so forth.
     Third, the complete survey on the operation of the rural credit guarantee organizations in Fujian Province also displays that the local government policies have great impact on the development of the rural credit guarantee organizations, resulting on the difference among the districts. In some districts, there are excessive amount of the rural commercial credit guarantee organizations, some of which offer irregular operations. In the meantime, the rural credit guarantee organizations in different models vary in their target, organization nature, social position and benefits pursued. As a result, mutually-owned organizations are in good operation, but commercial and policy ones are not.
     Fourth, various researchers put forward a lot of methods, like financial ratio analysis, return value assessment and input output method to measure the operation efficiency of the credit guarantee organizations. However, the sources of data and the inaccuracy of the figures, substitution problems and fuzzy contribution make it much harder to measure the operation efficiency than to analyze their content and structure.
     Fifth, the thesis makes an assessment on the operation efficiency of the rural credit guarantee organizations in Fujian Province in2008in the method of DEA and finds that the operation efficiency are generally poor and there are great difference among the organizations. And that is the case with the organizations in different models. The mutually-owned organizations are more efficient than the commercial and policy ones, especially when making full use of the available resources. Thus, the mutually-owned organizations possess the dominant position in the credit capital operation.
     Sixth, the thesis applies Tobit regression model to the positive analysis on the influential elements on the operation efficiency of the rural credit guarantee organizations. It is found that the organization model, the ratio of premiums revenue in gross revenue, the age history of the organization, guarantee rate, the scale up by guarantee agreement, the loan-deposit ratio in financial institutions, and the percentage of industrial output value in GDP have great impact on the operation efficiency of the rural credit guarantee organizations.
     Seventh, the analytical study on the rural credit guarantee schemes of four transitional economic countries in Central and Eastern Europe provides much valuable experience for China in many aspects such as the clear position of Rural Credit Guarantee Schemes, the proper government support system and good cooperation among the financial institutions.
     Eighth, Based on the survey and positive analysis, the thesis put forwards a proposal that the rural credit guarantee system should be mutual guarantee-centred with the auxiliary of the commercial and policy credit guarantees. The diversified system will help to guard against and reduce the risks. Meanwhile, the government policy guidance and supervision should be fully played to ensure the sound development of the rural credit guarantee organizations, and to construct a positive cooperation between the rural credit guarantee organizations and the financial institutions.
引文
1农业部软科学委员会办公室编.增加农业投入与改善农村金融服务.中国农业出版社,2005
    1马克思、恩格斯:《马克思恩格斯全集》第25卷,第390页
    1马亚军.西方融资担保理论综述[J].经济社会体制比较,2005(1)p135-141
    1农业部软科学委员会办公室编.增加农业投入与改善农村金融服务.中国农业出版社,2005
    1数据来源:中国人民银行研究局、日本国际协力机构《我国中小企业金融制度报告》,中信出版社2004年。
    1萨缪尔森.经济学(第12版).北京:中国发展出版社,1992.
    2樊纲、张曙光等.公有制宏观经济理论大纲[M].上海:上海三联书店,1990
    [1]G. A. Akerlof. The Market for "lemons":Quality Uncertainty and the Market Mechanism[J]. Quarterly Journal of Economics,1970, Vol.84, No.3:p488-500
    [2]Robert J. Barro. The Loan Market, Collateral and Rates of Interest [J]. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking,1976, Vol.8, No.4:p439-456
    [3]J. E. Stiglitz, Andrew Weiss. Credit Rationing in Markets with Imperfect Information [J]. American Economic Review,1981, Vol.71:p393-410
    [4) J. E. Stiglitz, Andrew Weiss. Asymmetric Information in Credit Markets and Its Implications for Macro-Economics [J]. Oxford Economic Papers,1992,Vol.44, No.4:p694-724
    [5]H. C. Wette. Collateral in Credit Rationing in Markets with Imperfect Information: Note [J]. The American Economic Review,1983, Vol.73, No.3:p442-445
    (6] Yuk-Shee Chan, A. V Thakor. Collateral and Competitive Equilibria with Moral Hazard and Private Information [J]. The Journal of Finance,1987, Vol.42, No.4:p345-363
    [7]David Besanko, A. V Thakor. Collateral and Rationing:Sorting Equilibria in Monopolistic and Competitive Credit Markets [J]. International Economic Review,1987, Vol.28, No.3:p671-689
    [8]A. W. A. Boot, A. V Thakor, Cx F. Udell. Secured Lending Default Risk:Equilibrium Analysis, Policy Implications and Empirical Results [J]. The Economic Journal,1991, Vol.101, No.4:p458-471
    [9]Yuk-Shee Chan, George Kanatas. Asymmetric Valuations and the Role ofCollateral in Loan Agreements [J]. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking,1985, Vol.17,No.1:p84-95
    [10]Donald D. Hester. Customer Relationship and Terms of Loans:Evidence from a Pilot Survey:Note [J]. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking,1979, Vol.11, No.3:p349-357
    [11]Allen N. Berger, G F. Udell. Relationship Lending and Lines of Credit in Small [12] Firm Finance [J]. The Journal of Business,1995, Vol.68, No.3:p351-381
    [12]Meyer,Richard L. and Greetha Nagatha Nagarajan."Commens on Sustainability of Credit Guarantee Systems",The Financier,Analyses of Capital and Money Market Transactions,Special Issue on SME Credit Guarantee Schemes,Vol.4,No.1&2,February/May,1997,pp.100-104.
    [13]Levitsky J. Best Practice in Credit Guarantee Schemes.Paper Presented at Round Table of Credit Guarantee Schemes,Inter American Bank,Washington DC,1996.
    [14]Vogel,R. and C.Adams.."Costs and Benefits of Loan Guarantee Programd"Inter-Americ-an Develo[ment Bank Round Table on Loan Guarantees,Washington,DC,1996.
    [15]Gudger,W.m.The Sustainability of Credit Guarantee Systems [J],The Financier,4(l-2):30,1999.
    [16]Allan L,Riding,George Haines,Jr,Defaulting on Loan Guarantees:Costs and Benefits of Encouraging Earily-Stage Growth[J].Frontiers of Entrepreneurship Research,19,1998:504-518.
    [17]Hatekayama M"Asian Guarantee System for SME",Paper presented at Round Table of Credit Guarantee chemes,Inter American Bank,Washington DC,1996.
    [18]Llorens J.L "Loan Guarantee System for SMEs in Europe" Paper presented at Round Table of Credit Guarantee Schemes,Inter American Bank,Washington DC,1996.
    [19]Llistertj"SME Credit Guarantee Schemes" [J]The Financier.4(2):5-112.
    [20]A. W. A. Boot, A. V Thakor. Moral Hazard and Secured Lending in an Infinitely Repeated Credit Market Game[J]. International Economic Review,1994,Vol.35, No.4: p899-920
    [21]Thorsten Beck, Asli Demirgu}-Kunt, and Vojislav Maksimovic. Bank Competition, Financing Obstacles And Access To Credit. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 2996, http://econ.worldbank.org. March 2003:1-51
    [22]Credit Guarantee Schemes For Small Business Lending:A Global Perspective (Volume I—Main Report). London:Graham Bannock and Partners Ltd.,April 1997. 1-103
    [23]Dimitri Vittas, Yoon Je Cho. Credit Policies:Lessons from East Asia. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 1458, May 1995:1-36
    [24]Inessa Love, Nataliya Mylenko.Credit Reporting And Financing Constraints.World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 3142,http://econ.worldbank.org. October 2003:Ⅰ}33
    [25]Rory McLaughlin. Financing Small High-Tech Firms in Northern Ireland:An Exploratory Study of Conservative Attitudes. Working Paper,2003:1-30
    [26]Par Marc Labie. Credits to Small Businesses and Microenterprises. http//www. globenet.org/horizon-local/ada/51296bq.html. December 19-95
    [27]Douglas R Snow, Terry F Buss. Development and the role of microcredit.Policy Studies Journal,2001, Vol.29, Iss.2:296-307
    [28]Hway-Boon Ong, Muzafar Shah Habibullah, Alias Radam, M Azali.Evaluating a credit guarantee agency in a developing economy:A non-parametric approach [J]. International Journal of Social Economics,2003, Vol.30, Iss.1/2:143-152
    [29]Michiel Bastiaenen, Peter van Rooij. Guarantee Funds and NGOs:Promise and Pitfalls. World Bank Poverty-oriented Banking Working paper No.18:1-52
    [30]Chryssanthi K. Balomenou. How the institution of mutual guarantee companies in Greece and in Japan facilitates the access of small and medium sized firms to the banking system and its contribution to their development in both countries. Regional Science Association 42nd European Congress, Dortmund (Germany),27th August—31 st August,2002:1-20
    [31]Allan L. Riding, George Haines Jr.. Loan Guarantees:Costs Of Default And Benefits To Small Firms. Journal of Business,2001, Vol.16:595-612
    [32]Jacob Levitsky. SME Guarantee Schemes:A Summary. The Financier, May 1997, Vol. 4,No.1:5-11
    [33]Diana Hancock, James A. Wilcox. The "credit crunch" and the availability of credit to small business[J]. Journal of Banking&Finance,1998, Vol.22:983-1014
    [34]David Camino,Clara Cardone. The valuation and cost of credit insurance schemes for SMEs:The role of the Loan Guarantee Associations [J]. International Small Business Journal, 1999, Vol.17, Iss.4:13-31
    [35]Chryssanthi K. Balomenou. The contribution of the European Investment Fund SMEs Guarantee Facility and of the Greek new Institution of SMEs Credit Guarantee Fund to the local Entrepreneurship and generally to the endogenous regional growth. Regional Science Association 43nd European Congress, Finland,27th—30th August,2003:1-28
    [36]Aniko Ulrich.Introduction of the activity of Rural-Credit Guarantee Foundation Hungary[EB/OL],http://www.eastagri.org/meetings/index.asp?id=20,2009-11-18.
    [37]Veronica Toncea. RCGF guarantee activity-Rural Credit Guarantee Schemes workshop[EB/OL], http://www.eastagri.org/meetings/index.asp?id=20,2009-11-18.
    [38]Danguole Cukauskienc.Lithuanian Rural Credit Guarantee Fund[EB/OL], http://www.eastagri.org/meetings/index.asp?id=20,2009-11-18.
    [39]Rain Vandre.Estonian Rural Development Foundation[EB/OL], http://www.eastagri.org/meetings/index.asp?id=20,2009-11-18.
    [40]FAO SEUR, Main Conference Room.Rural Credit Guarantee Schemes-A Financial Instrument for Agricultureand Rural Development[EB/OL], http://www.eastagri.org/meetings/index.asp?id=20,2009-11-18.
    [41]Robert A. Jarrow, David Lando, Stuart M. Turnbull. A Markov Model for the Term Structure of Credit Risk Spreads [J]. The Review of Financial Studies,1997,Vol.10, No.2: 481-523
    [42]Didier Cossin, Tomas Hricko. A Structural Analysis of Credit Risk With Risky Collateral:A Methodology for Haircut Determination. Economic Notes by Banca Monte dei Paschi di Siena SpA,2003, Vol.32, No.2:243-282
    [43]Avery W. Katz. An Economic Analysis of the Guaranty Contract.University of Chicago Law Review,1999, Vol.66, No.l:1-74
    [44]Tze-Wei Fu, Mei-Chu Ke, Yen-Sheng Huang. Capital Growth, Financing Source and Profitability of Small Businesses:Evidence from Taiwan Small Enterprises [J]. Small Business Economics,2002, Vol.18:257-267
    [45]Joseph Atta-Mensah. Collateral and Credit Supply. Bank of Canada Working Paper, April 2003, Vol.11:1-19
    [46]Chuang-Chang Chang, Van Son Lai, Min-Teh Yu. Credit enhancement and loan default risk premiums. Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences, Sep 2002, Vol.19, Iss.3:301-312
    [47]Bruce D. Smith, Michael J. Stutzer. Credit Rationing and Government Loan Programs: A Welfare Analysis. AREUEA Journal,1989, Vol.17, No.2:177-193
    [48]Yoshiro Miwa, J. Mark Ramseyer. Directed Credit? The Loan Market in High-Growth Japan [J]. Journal of Economics&Management Strategy,2004, Vol.13,No.1:171-205
    [49]Simon C. Parker. Do Bank Ration Credit to New Enterprises? And Should Governments Intervene? [J]. Scottish Journal of Political Economy, May 2002, Vol.49,No.2: 162-195
    [50]Stephen D. Williamson. Do informational fractions justify federal credit programs? [J]. Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking, Aug 1994, Vol.26, No.3:523-544
    [51]Southeast Europe Enterprise Development. Feasibility Study on Establishment of A Credit Guarantee Institution in Bosnia and Herzegovina. Working Paper, February 2002:1-173
    [52]Robert Cressy. Funding Gaps:A Symposium [J]. The Economic Journal,February 2002, Vol.112:1-16
    [53]Rafael J. Bautista-Mena. Government at Risk:Public Credit Guarantees.Working Paper, October 23,2003:1-24
    [54]Wenli Li. Government Loan, Guarantee, and Grant Programs:An Evaluation. Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond Economic Quarterly, Fall 1998,Volume 84/4:25-51
    [55]Garance Genicot, Debraj Ray. Group Formation in Risk-Sharing Arrangements. Review of Economic Studies,2003, Vol.70:87-113
    [56]Yibin Mu. Impediments to SME Access to Finance and Credit Guarantee Schemes in China. World Bank Working Paper, December 2002:1-29
    [57]Robin Boadway, Motohiro Sato. Information Acquisition and Government Interventon in Credit Markets [J]. Journal of Public Economic Theory,1999, Vol.1, No.3:283-308
    [58]Maria Sabrina De Gobbi. Mutual Guarantee Associations for Small and Micro-Entrepreneurs:Lessons Learned from Europe and Africa [J]. R&D Management,2003, Vol.15,No.1:23-34
    [59]Ben R. Craig, William E. Jackson, James B. Thomson. On SBA-Guaranteed Lending and Economic Growth. Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland Working Paper 04-03, www.clevelandfed.org/Research April 2004:1-33
    [60]Rui Albuquerque, Hugo A. Hopenhayn. Optimal Lending Contracts and Firm Dynamics [J]. Review of Economic Studies,2004, Vol.71:285-315
    [61]Joshua Aizenman, Stephen J. Turnovs Reserve Requirements on Sovereign Debt in The Presence of Moral Hazard—On Debtors or Creditors? [J]. The Economic Journal, January 2002, Vol.112:107-132
    [62]Gerhard Coetzee. Rural Finance.2002, Working Paper 04:1-62
    [63]James M. Bickley. The Bush Administration's Proposal for Credit Reform:Background, Analysis, and Policy Issues [J]. Public Budgeting&Finance, Spring 1991:50-65
    [64]Douglas W. Allen. Transaction Costs. Working Paper 0740:893-926
    [65]Mody, Ashoka, Patro, Dilip K. Valuing and accounting for loan guarantees [J].The World Bank Research Observer, February 1996, Vol.11, Iss.1:119-132
    [66]P M Hillebrandt, W Hughes. What are the Costs of Procurement and Who Bears Them?. Working Paper,2000:1-7
    [67]Beatriz Armendariz de Aghion. On the design of a credit agreement with peer monitoring. Journal of Development Economics,1999, Vol.60:79-104
    [68]Didier Cossin, Felipe M. Aparicio Acosta. Optimal Guarrantee Control. Working Paper. June 1996:1-47
    [69]U.S. Small Business Administration. State of the SBIC Program. Fiscal Year 2002 Special Report, December 31,2002:36-56
    [70]Brennan, Kraus. Efficient Financing under Asymmetric Information [J]. The Journal of Finance.1987, Vol.XLII:12251243
    [71]Goswami, Noe, Rebello. Debt Financing under Asymmetric Information. [J].The journal of Finance,1995, Vol.L:633-659.
    [72]Barclay, Smith Jr.. The Maturity Structure of Corporate Debt[J]. The Journal of Finance,1995a, Vol.L:609-631
    [73]Barclay, Smith Jr.. The Priority Structure of Corporate Liabilities [J]. The Journal of Finance,1995b, Vol.L:899-917
    [74]Carey. Credit Risk in Private Debt Portfolios [J]. The Journal of Finance, 1998,Vol.LⅢ:1363-1387
    [75]Boocock, Sheriff, Measuring the Effectiveness of Credit Guarantee Schemes Evidence from Malaysia [J]. International Small Business, Vol.23, No.4,427-454,2005.
    [76]Hway-Boon Ong,Muzafar Shah Habibullah,Alias Radma,M.Azali, Evaluating a credit guarantee agency in a developing economy:a non-parametric approach [J].International Journal of Social Economics, Volume30 Nuberl/22003 pp.143-152.
    [77]Farrell, M.J., The Measurement of productive Efficiency [J]. Journal of RoyalStatistical Society, Series A, General,120 (3):253-281,1957
    [78]中国人民银行农村金融服务研究小组.中国农村金融服务报告[EB/OL].[2008-09-16], http://www.pbc.gov.cn/xinwen/index.asp?keyword=中国农村金融服务报告
    [79]何广文等.农户融资中的信用担保行为研究[R].农业部研究报告.2002
    [80]农业部软科学委员会办公室编.增加农业投入与改善农村金融服务[M].北京:中国农业出版社,2005
    [81]黄庆安.对农村信用社农户小额贷款的调查与思考——来自福建省闽清县的调查[J].中国集体经济,2009(1):130-131
    [82]李毅和向党.中小企业信贷融资信用担保缺失研究[J].金融研究.2008(12):179-192
    [83]张捷.结构转换期的中小企业金融研究[M].北京:经济科学出版社,2003.
    [84]王静.涉农经济组织融资信用与金融支持研究[M].北京:农业出版社,2004.
    [85]冯兴元.温州市苍南县农村中小企业融资调查报告[J].管理世界,2004,(9):53-66
    [86]马克思、恩格斯.马克思恩格斯全集第25卷[M].390
    [87]黄利荣.我国市场经济信用制度探析[J].延安大学学报,2004,(3):71-74
    [88]梅强等.中小企业信用担保理论、模式及政策[MJ.经济管理出版社,2002,6.
    [89]曹凤岐.建立和健全中小企业信用担保体系[J].金融研究,2001,(5):41-48
    [90]马亚军.西方融资担保理论综述[J].经济社会体制比较,2005,(1):135-141
    [91]吕薇.借鉴有益经验,建立我国中小企业信用担保体系[J].金融研究,2000,(5):58-63
    [92]胡旭阳.东南亚四国的中小企业信用担保计划及其经验借鉴[J].国际金融研究,1999,(6):41-45
    [93]陈晓红,刘晖.中小企业贷款担保制度的国际比较及其借鉴[J].中南工业大学学报(社会科学版),1999,(4):277-281
    [94]王小哈,施健.台湾与大陆中小企业信用担保体系的比较研究与启示[J].管理科学,2003,(2):91-96
    [95]王传东,王家传.中小企业信用担保的国际经验与借鉴[J].国际金融研究,2005,(10):28-32
    [96]王召.中小企业信用担保制度建设的国际经验[J].证券市场导报,2006,(7):61-68
    [97]蔡文佳.中小企业信用担保体系的国际比较及其对我国的启示[D].湖南大学.2006
    [98]王丽珠.国中小企业信用担保体系的国际借鉴-以日本为例[J].国际金融研究,2009(7)87-96
    [99]陈柳钦,孙建平.论制度创新与中小企业信用担保体系的发展[J].上海财经学学报,2003,5(5):24-31
    [100]陈柳钦,孙建平.制度创新:发展和完善中小企业信用担保体系的关键路径[J].北京工业大学学报(社会科学版),2004,4(2):1-8
    [101]石静,刘首民.我国中小企业信用担保体系探讨[J].武汉金融,2001,(11)12-16
    [102]赵复元.我国中小企业信用担保问题综述[J].经济研究参考,2005,(23):40-45
    [103]金丽红,熊春红.完善我国中小企业信用担保体系的探讨[J].金融与经济2006,(5):93-94
    [104]赵红丽,糜仲春.我国中小企业信用担保体系研究[J].价值工程,2006,(8):118-120
    [105]姜长云.乡镇(中小)企业信用担保机制的建设问题探析[J].中国农村经济,2000,(11):46-54
    [106]张文棋,梁晖晴.健全乡镇企业信用担保制度的基本思路与对策[J].福建农林大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2003,(6):16-19
    [107]王传东,王家传.信贷配给视角下的农村中小企业融资担保[J].农业经济问题,2006,(6):48-52
    [108]袁洪斌,胡士华.论我国农村中小企业信用担保体系的构建[J].经济纵横,2006,(12):35-38
    [109]胡士华,李伟毅.农村信贷融资中的担保约束及其解除[J].农业经济问题,2006(2):68-72
    [110]中国人民银行潍坊市中心支行课题组.中小企业信用担保公司可持续发的模式选择[J].金融研究,2003,(11):129-134
    [111]苏旺胜,施祖麟.信用担保制度提高信贷市场绩效的理论与方案[J].清华大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2003,18(1):90-99
    [112]龙永俊,杨军.信用担保热的冷思考[J],武汉金融,2005,(5):21-22
    [113]王素莲.论中小企业信用担保体系的组织取向[J].当代经济研究,2005,(1):35-40
    [114]吕薇.我国中小企业信用担保的几种运作模式比较[J].经济研究参考2002,(67):34-39
    [115]吴明理,徐东风,姜春.创新路径与比较优势:三种担保模式的实证研究[J].金融研究,2002,(10):126-132
    [116]胡海波.我国中小企业信用担保制度问题研究[D].湖南大学,2007
    [117]晏露蓉,赖永文,张斌等.创建合理高效的中小企业融资担保体系研究[J].金融研究,2007(10):152-165.
    [118]邹高峰,熊熊.试论以互助担保为基础的中小企业信用担保体系之重建[J],现代财经2009,(6):35-39
    [119]彭江波.以互助联保为基础构建中小企业信用担保体系[J].金融研究,2008(2):75-82.
    [120]张利胜,狄娜.中小企业信用担保[M].上海:上海财经大学出版社,2001:28-35
    [121]何祖玉.中小企业信用担保风险管理研究[D].南京理工大学.2004
    [122]罗昕.论我国中小企业信用担保体系中风险的制度防范[J].社会科学家,2003,(7):30-33,39
    [123]刘新来.信用担保概论与实务(修订版)[M].北京:经济科学出版社,2006:101-105
    [124]梅保平.中小企业信用担保机构运行能力的评价体系及其因素分析[J].商业经济,2004,(6):76-84
    [125]林毅夫,孙希芳.信息、非正规金融与中小企业融资[J].经济研究,2005,(7):35-44
    [126]林毅夫.金融体系、信用和中小企业融资[J].浙江社会科学,2001,(6):9-11
    [127]敖慧.信用担保风险评价与控制研究[D].武汉理工大学,2007
    [128]金鑫.信用担保机构综合风险预警研究[D].武汉理工大学,2008
    [129]梅强,谭中明,任永平.中小企业信用担保与信用环境建设的研究[J].江苏大学学报(社会科学版),2002,4(1):100-106
    [130]方晓霞.发展中小企业信用担保的对策[N].中国社会科学院院报,2004-02-17:21.
    [131]戴中祥.我国中小企业信用担保的法律障碍与对策分析[J].武汉科技大学学报(社会科学版),2003,5(2):1-5.
    [132]索婷.我国信用担保法律机制研究[D].南京航空航天大学.2007
    [133]田土城.担保制度的成因及其发展趋势--简论我国担保立法的健全与完善[J].郑州大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2001,34(4):18-23.
    [134]孙海星.试论中小企业信用担保体系的完善与发展[J].北京工商大学学报,2003(11):17-20
    [135]周春梅.境外企业信用担保法律问题浅析[J].金融理论与实践,2004,(6):27-29.
    [136]吴兴国.我国中小企业信用担保法律体系之构建[J].中国发展,2005,(2):51-55.
    [137]齐秀梅.吉林省中小企业信用担保法律问题研究[J].长春理工大学学报(社会科学版),2005,18(2):59-60,75.
    [138]宋志国,宋瑞敏.我国中小企业信用担保的法律障碍与对策分析[J].社会科学家,2005,(10):88-89.
    [139]秦琳.我国中小企业信用担保体系的法律研究[D].哈尔滨工程大学.2007
    [140]黎四奇.对我国中小企业信用担保法律制度的检讨与反思[J].财经理论与实践2009(5):118-124
    [141]沈彤.我国中小企业信用担保体系及其税收政策[J].宏观经济管理2007,(3):61-63
    [142]杨鹏.我国中小企业信用担保机构与银行合作现状研究[D].西南财经大学.2006
    [143]朱灿.信用担保机构与协作银行合作关系研究[D].湖南大学.2007
    [144]李庚寅,李著.中小企业融资担保体系巫待解决的几个问题[J].财经理论与实践(双月刊),2001,(22):71-74
    [145]贾康,罗建钢,郑琳等.中小企业信用担保与财政资金的运用[J].经济研究参考,2002(2):1-9
    [146]巴曙松等.2006年度中国担保业监管研究.2006中国担保论坛(论文集)[M].北京:经济科学出版社,2007:63-76
    [147]董辅扔.关于信用和信用体系[J].中南大学学报(社会科学版),2003,(2):204-208
    [148]吴敬琏.信用担保与国民信用体系建设[EB/OL].国研网,2001年11月
    [149]张志强.债务担保的价值[J].财经问题研究,1999,(6):22-27
    [150]林昆辉,金玲,陈晓红.担保费的期权定价模型设计及实证研究[J].中南工业大学学报(社会科学版),2000(4):265-267
    [151]巴曙松,陈华良.企业年金市场的准入与退出制度研究[J].湖北经济学院学报2005,(1):6-11
    [152]何红渠,孙壮志.担保公司贷款担保业务模式的创新[J].中南大学学报(社会科学版),2004,10(1):128-132
    [153]中国信用再担保制度专家座谈会发言摘要[J].经济研究参考,2003(82):2-7.
    [154]中国信用再担保制度课题组.中国信用再担保制度研究[J].经济研究参考,2003(82):8-15.
    [155]陈国伟.担保业风险防范的战略与策略,中国中小企业信息网[EB/OL],2002.12
    [156]黄楠.中小企业信用再担保机构构建研究[D].中南大学.2007
    [157]陈乃醒.中国中小企业发展与预测(2002-2003)[M].北京:经济管理出版社,2002:322-323
    [158]金峰峰.民营中小企业信用担保中政府杠杆支持力度探讨[J].经济与管理研究,2004,(6):47-49
    [159]陈乃醒.中小企业信用担保[M].天津:南开大学出版社,2004,77-80
    [160]黄磊,倪民,孙丰山.论信用担保机构的融资职能与社会职能:理论与个案研究[J].金融研究,2005,(3):183-187
    [161]彭磊.均衡信贷配给、信用担保与中小企业融资[J].当代财经,2003,(8):50-53,60
    [162]张杰.民营经济的金融困境与融资次序[J].经济研究,2000,(4):3-10
    [163]林毅夫,李永军.中小金融机构发展与中小企业融资[J].经济研究,2001(1):10-18
    [164]董彦岭.中小企业银行信贷融资研究[D].天津:南开大学,2003
    [165]孔刘柳.商业银行信贷合约理论[M].上海:上海财经大学出版社,2001,160-165
    [166]黄海沧,李建琴.中小企业信用担保的冷思考[J].浙江社会科学,2003(4):48—52
    [167]董彦岭.中小企业贷款:信用担保机构是必需的吗?[EB/OL].httP:www.ccnot.org.cfl,2005-02-18
    [168]林平,袁中红.信用担保机构研究[J].金融研究,2005,(2):133-144
    [169]邹小凡,章智.中小企业信用担保中逆向选择问题的数理分析[J].浙江大学学报(人文社会科学版),2003,33(3):153-157
    [170]付俊文,赵红.信息不对称下的中小企业信用担保数理分析[J].财经研究,2004,(7):105-112
    [171]杨胜刚,胡海波.不对称信息下的中小企业信用担保问题研究[J].金融研究,2006,(1):118-126
    [172]全国人大常委会关于金融支农问题的调研报告[EB/OL].www. xinhuanet. com,2004-06-24
    [173]邹志强,农户信贷需求状况及影响因素分析——以福建为例[J],福建论坛(人文社会科学版),2008(11):89-92
    [174]林少伟.农村中小企业信贷约束实证研究[D].福建农林大学,2007
    [175]2008年中国统计年鉴,北京:中国统计出版社,2009
    [176]黄庆安.林权抵押贷款及其风险防范[J].山东财政学院学报,2008(5):76-79
    [177]黄庆安,林森.农村产权制度改革与农村金融创新问题探析[J].内蒙古农业大学学报(社会科学版),2009(5):44-46
    [178]中国人民银行研究局、世界银行集团外国投资咨询服务局、国际金融公司中国项目开发中心.中国动产担保物权与信贷市场发展[M].北京:中信出版社,2006
    [179]中小企业研究小组.中小企业金融支持体系:理论、证据与公共政策.研究报告[EB/OL] http://www. szse. cn/main/files/2009/09/15/043960439646.pdf
    [180]中小企业融资担保政策法规选编.福建省信用担保协会,2009年
    [181]2003、2004、2005、2006、2007、2008年全国担保行业发展报告[EB/OL].http://www. smecg. org/Html/Main.asp
    [182]中国人民银行研究局、日本国际协力机构.我国中小企业金融制度报告[M].北京:中信出版社,2004
    [183]2007年福建信用担保行业发展报告度.福建省信用担保协会,2008年
    [184]福安互助性行业担保畅通中小企业融资[EB/OL]. http://www.fujian.gov.cn/wsbs/jg/jjdt/200804/t20080430_67575.htm
    [185]萨缪尔森.经济学(第12版)[M].北京:中国发展出版社,1992.
    [186]樊纲、张曙光等.公有制宏观经济理论大纲[M].上海:上海三联书店,1990
    [187]陈乃醒.中小企业信用担保的经济效益与指标体系[J],经济管理,2001(7):36-37
    [188]陈晓红,谢晓光.提高我国信用担保经济杠杆效用的研究[J].软科学,2005(4):1-4
    [189]林毅.中小企业信用担保体系的运行绩效分析[D].山东大学.2006
    [190]任永平,梅强.中小企业信用担保基金若干重要参数的财务分析[J].数量经济技术经济研究,2002,(2):111-114
    [191]龚瑾瑜,韩刚.中小企业信用担保计划执行效率的成本收益分析框架[J],金融理论与实践,2006(11):52-54
    [192]盛昭瀚.DEA理论、方法与应用[M].北京:科学出版社,1996
    [193]魏权龄.数据包络分析[M].北京:科学出版社,2004
    [194]魏权龄.评价相对有效性的DEA方法[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,1988
    [195]2009年福建统计年鉴.福建人民出版社,2009年
    [196]王传东.中小企业信用担保问题研究[D].山东农业大学.2006
    [197]张卓琳.中小企业信用担保机构有效运行模式研究[D].中南大学,2005
    [198]秦默.我国中小企业信用再担保体系研究[D].江苏大学,2008
    [199]顾海峰.中小企业信用担保风险定价与控制研究[D].中南大学,2006
    [200]黄庆安.中东欧四个转型经济体国家的农村信用担保计划及其经验借鉴[J].中国农学通报,2010(5):351-355

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700