我国土地收购储备的运行机制研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
土地储备是城市土地收购储备中心通过征用、收购、置换、转制、收回等方式,从分散的土地使用者手中,把土地集中起来,并由土地收购储备中心组织进行职工和居民的安置、房屋拆迁、土地平整等一系列土地整理工作后,将土地储备起来,再根据城市规划和城市土地出让年度计划,有计划地将土地投入市场。2008年10月12日中国共产党第十七届中央委员会第三次全体会议通过了中共中央关于推进农村改革发展若干重大问题的决定中也强调指出合理进行土地流转,创新土地制度。这都说明了土地改革对整个国民经济的发展起到了举足轻重的作用。我国城市土地归国家所有,通过实行土地有偿有期限使用,形成土地市场。在这种土地制度框架下,国家是惟一的土地所有者,国有土地使用权出让和出租形成垄断性的城市土地一级市场:从国家取得的合法土地使用权在合同规定的范围内可以进入市场流通,进行转让和转租,形成竞争性的土地二级市场。土地储备制度的这一现象的出现不是偶然的,是我国经济体制改革、土地使用制度改革和土地管理改革深化的必然结果。
     随着我国土地储备制度的推行和发展,我国土地市场的规范化建设取得了长足的进步,但由于我国建立土地储备制度的时间还不长,尚存在一些不够完善的地方。缺乏法律法规的支撑,没有明确的法律地位,在实践中出现了许多的问题。土地储备机构性质定位模糊,责任、权利不明确,土地储备政策难以有效实施,且缺乏有效的监督机制,土地储备制度的公平、公正性很难保证等等。这些问题影响到我国土地市场的长远健康发展。加强土地储备制度的系统建设,建立多渠道资金筹集,保障土地储备顺利进行,才能使土地储备更好的服务于我国的经济建设。本文通过对土地储备运行机制及目前的发展现状的剖析,指出了土地储备三个环节即土地收购、土地储备和土地供应运作过程中的问题,并针对每个环节出现的问题做出了科学的分析。在土地收购储备运行机制中,存在着明显的寻租现象。在土地收购环节中,一些地方政府片面追求“以地生财”,几乎一切征地项目都搭车公共利益,随意出让,批租国有土地。还有一些开发区“圈而不用”、“储而不用”,真正的工业企业又征不到地,影响了企业的再发展;在土地储备过程中,城市政府在土地资源配置和土地利益的分配问题上,有强烈的追求地方经济利益的趋向。当国家的利益与地方利益有所冲突时,地方政府必然要竭力维护地方利益,从而导致地方政府与中央政府之间的寻租活动的出现。土地供应过程中,这种寻租行为表现在政府与开发商的博弈,其焦点体现在对开发商的授权上。本文的一个创新点就在于土地收购储备中的博弈分析。这包括中央政府和地方政府的博弈分析,地方政府不同届之间的征地博弈分析,政府与开发商的博弈分析。
     本文在深入分析土地收购储备运行机制各个程序的基础上提出了一个适合我国土地储备制度有效运行机制的基本框架,并对完善土地储备的管理措施进行了探讨。建立健全城市土地利用规划制度,科学客观评价储备土地实际价值,加强土地储备的管理,建立社会化的资金筹措机制,加强土地收购储备风险控制以及贷款的控制,确定合理的土地收购价格。加强城市土地收购储备中的法律法规。土地收购储备制度从表面上看,既是土地储备,也是资金储备,土地收购储备运作过程中需要大量资金,这成为土地收购储备制度顺利实施的关键所在。通过扩大筹资渠道、土地储备过程中开发项目方式多样化等手段,合理确定土地收购价格等从资金流入方向和资金流出方向的来构建资金内部良性循环体系。并提出要提高土地收购储备机构自有资金的比例才是保证土地收购储备过程中资金顺利流动的根本。土地收益分配体系也是土地收购储备财政保障制度必不可少的组成部分。正如十七届三中全会所提倡的,在土地制度改革中,必须探索一条满足工业化、城市化建设用地需要与保护耕地政策相协调的新途径。其出路在于:一是继续实行土地占补平衡政策,二是继续实行严格的节约用地制度,三是改革完善征地制度,规范政府和企业征地行为。由此可见,本文所研究的土地收购储备问题具有与时俱进的现实意义。
Land reserve is the land reserve centers in the city recover the land together from the land owners, by purchasing, exchanging, conversioning or some other ways. These lands reserved will be uesd by land reserve center for series land consolidation, for example, employees and residents’housings, house dismantlementin, land leveling and so on. Then put the land to the market, according to the urban planning and urban land remise of the annual plan. October 12th,2008, the 17th Central Committee of the Communist Party of China(CPC)started its third plenary session and obtained consistency to promote the rural reform.And a number of major issues in the decision also emphasized that the reasonable flow of land and the land system innovation, which reflected that the land reform development in the national economy has played an increasingly important role. Our urban land owned by the State, through the introduction of the land there is a fee to use the period to form the land market. In such a system of land within the framework of the state is the only land owners, the state-owned land have rights to sell and rent which form the monopolistic urban land market level. And achieve the legal national land-use rights can access market circulation in terms of the contract, transfer and sublet to form a competitive land on the secondary market. Land reserve system, the emergence of its phenomenon is not an accident, which were an inevitable result of our country’s economic structural reform, land use reform and the deepening of land management system reform.
     As the land reserve system being implemented and developed, China's land market standardization has made considerable progresses. As the establishment of land reserve system has not a long time, there still not be perfect. Because of the lack of supporting laws, regulations and not clear legal status, there have been many problems in practice. A land bank agency fuzzy nature of the position, responsibilities, rights are not clear, the land reserve policy for the effective implementation difficult, and a lack of effective supervision mechanism, the land reserve system of fairness, impartiality, so it is difficult to ensure.These problems affect the land market healthy development in a long term. To make a better service to our country's economic construction,we should strengthen the land reserve system and establish more channels to raise funds to protect the smooth progress of a land bank.Through a land bank of the operating mechanism and its development in current status, this paper points out the three steps in a land bank, the acquisition of land, land reserves and land supply, had some problems in the operation. And made scientific analysis for every aspect of the se problems. In the land purchase and reserve mechanism, there is a phenomenon of rent-seeking. The acquisition of land in the session, a number of local governments to pursue money one-sided and almost all land acquisition projects have a ride in the public interest, free to sell, lease state-owned land. There are a number of development zones have been circled but without reserve, while the real industrial enterprises also can not sign, which impact the enterprise’s further development. In a land bank, the city government had interests on the allocation of land resources and land distribution issues, the pursuit of a strong local economic interests had been a trend. When the interests of the country's conflict with local interests, local governments must safeguard their best interests, which leads to the emergence of the rent-seeking activities between central government and local governments. In the process of land supply, the rent-seeking behavior happened between government and the developers, the focus of which is the authorization of developers. The innovation in this article is using the game analysis to analyse land acquisition reserves. This includes the central and local governments in the game, the local government’s land between the different sessions in the game and the government and the developers in the game.
     This paper made a deep analysis of the land purchase and reserve mechanism on the basis of all the procedures, proposed the basic frame work for a land reserve system to run effectively, and improve the management of the land bank discussed. Establish and improve the urban land-use planning system, make an objective and scientific evaluation to the real value of the land reserves, strengthen the management of the social fund-raising mechanisms in the land bank, enhance the acquisition of land reserve loans, as well as risk management control, fix a reasonable price of land and strengthen the laws and regulations. The acquisition of land reserve system is not only a land bank but also reserve funds.Land reserves in the course of the operation need a lot of money, which has become the key to the land purchase and reserve system’s smooth implementation. By expanding financing channels for a land bank in the process of development projects, such as ways to diversify the means to determine a reasonable price of land from the direction of capital flows and financial direction of the outflow of funds to build a virtuous circle in-house system. And the way to improve the land purchase and reserve funds of its own institutions is to ensure that the ratio of land reserves in the capital flow is smooth.Finally, this paper presents reasonable proposals for the land reserves. Establish and improve the urban land-use planning system, use an objective and scientific evaluation to evalue land reserves, strengthen the management of land reserves, establish a social fund-raising mechanisms, enhance land reserve loans as well as risk management control, determine a reasonable price of land. Strengthen the laws and regulations. As the Central Committee decision, in the reform of the land system, it must be found a new way to meet the purposes of industrialization and urbanization of land for construction and the need to protect arable land policy. Its way out: First, continue to implement the balance of land policy. Second, continue to implement a strict system of land conservation and the third is reforming the land requisition system to improve and standardize government and enterprises behavior. As we can see, this article, studied the land reserves, has a time significance.
引文
[1]柯廷顿.开放经济非均衡宏观经济学[M].上海译文出版社. 1992.
    [2]洪银兴.转轨阶段的经济运行和经济发展[M].江苏人民出版社. 1997.
    [3]杨小凯著.经济学原理[M].中国社会科学出版社,1998,1(1).
    [4]林毅夫等.比较优势与发展战略[J].中国社会科学,1999,(05).
    [5]刘波.资本市场结构——理论与现实的选择[M].复旦大学出版社. 1999.
    [6]宋东林.市场有效性理论评析[J].经济学动态,1995,第(10).
    [7]郭鸿勋,武康平.土地储备运行中的财政风险——基于土地价格变动的分析[J].财政研究,2005,(04).
    [8]冯昌中,陈敬雄,范宇.土地储备与城市经营的融合、互动与协调[J].经济地理,2004,(01).
    [9]史大平.完善城市土地储备制度的政策措施[J].经济研究参考,2005,(55).
    [10]殷程旭,周寅康,彭补拙.土地储备贷款业务的风险分析及防范措施[J].中国房地产金融. 2005,(06).
    [11]於忠祥,李学明,崔莉.论城市土地储备制度[J].安徽农业大学学报(社会科学版),2004,(01).
    [12]陈卓咏,叶裕民.城市土地储备数量和周期的理论分析[J].中国土地科学,2005,(04).
    [13]刘新芝,张维.土地储备资金风险防范问题研究[J].经济师,2005,(12).
    [14]张文新.论城市土地储备的理论基础[J].城市发展研究,2004,(02).
    [15]刘新芝,张维.城市土地储备制度绩效研究[J].山东经济,2005,(04).
    [16]黄小彪,黄曼慧.城市土地储备制度的功能、问题与发展对策分析[J].中国房地产金融,2005,(04).
    [17]尚鸣.消除信息不对称的制度基础[J].中国投资,2002,(03).
    [18]吴唯实.委托代理制与国有企业管理体制的改革[J].江汉论坛,2001,(07).
    [19]张波.土地.如何储备——土地储备库内涵、储备方式及问题评析[J].中国土地,2005,(02).
    [20]何凤麟.我国城市土地储备研究[D].中国优秀博硕士学位论文全文数据库.
    [21]周亮.土地储备制度中若干问题的法律思考[J].行政与法,2004,(05).
    [22]尤建新,孙弘宇.土地储备组织过程的再思考及重新设计[J].同济大学学报(社会科学版),2004,(02).
    [23]张更深.中国土地储备研究[D].中国优秀博硕士学位论文全文数据库.
    [24]戴卫平,顾海英.我国的土地储备制度:纠正市场失灵还是弥补计划缺陷[J].华南农业大学学报(社会科学版),2005,(02).
    [25]武康平.土地储备制度的经济分析[J].福建论坛(人文社会科学版),2005,(07).
    [26]李厚德,陈德棉,张玉臣.信息不对称理论在风险投资领域的应用综述[J].外国经济与管理,2002,(01).
    [27]吴唯实.委托代理制与国有企业管理体制的改革[J].江汉论坛,2001,(07).
    [28]张文新.论城市土地储备的理论基础[J].城市发展研究,2004,(02).
    [29]郭立芳,卢吉勇,张树峰.论我国城市土地储备机构的组织重构[J].国土资源,2004,(06).
    [30]万劲波,叶文虎.地方政府推进区域可持续发展能力建设的思考[J].中国软科学,2005,(03).
    [31]杨遴杰,林坚,李昕,高永.国外土地储备制度及借鉴[J].中国土地,2002,(05).
    [32]陈伯庚.以制度创新规范土地市场[J].中国房地信息,2004,(04).
    [33]杨佃辉,屠梅曾.我国城市土地储备制度融资渠道探析[J].上海金融,2004,(09).
    [34]韦曙林.中西企业委托代理制比较研究[J].江西社会科学,2002,(07).
    [35]杨俊玲,胡朝斌.关于重构国有企业委托代理制的思考[J].学术探索,2003,S1期.
    [36]魏允平.对国有企业多级委托代理制存在的问题与对策的思考[J].中国监察,2005,(04).
    [37]欧阳安蛟.中国城市土地收购储备制度:理论与实踐[J].经济管理出版社,2002,1月1日.
    [38]张维迎著.博弈论与信息经济学[M].上海三联书店.上海人民出版社,1996,8(1).
    [39]克鲁格曼,奥伯斯法尔德.国际经济学[M].中国人民大学出版社,1998.
    [40]卢新海著.中国城市土地储备制度研究[M].科学出版社,2008,5(1).
    [41]约翰.梅纳德.凯恩斯.就业、利息与货币通论[M].商务印书馆,1936.
    [42]陈岱孙著.从古典经济学派到马克思[M].上海人民出版社,1981,1(1).
    [43]道格拉斯.诺思.制度、制度变迁与经济绩效[M].上海三联书店. 1994.
    [44]陈郁编.所有权控制权与激励[M].上海三联书店,1998,3(1).
    [45]赵敏,张安明,王力,刘渝.城镇国有土地储备补偿价格探讨[J].西北师范大学学报(自然科学版),2005,(01).
    [46]唐星龄.当前我国土地收购储备制度透视[J].中国土地,2005,(03).
    [47]李世谦.公开资本市场监管问题研究[M].经济管理出版社,1997.
    [48]克鲁格曼.萧条经济学的回归[M].中国人民大学出版社,1999.
    [49]张文新.城市土地储备对我国城市土地供求与地价的影响分析[J].资源科学,2005,(06).
    [50]夏普等.投资学[M].中国人民大学出版社,1998.
    [51]谢康.微观信息经济学[M].中山大学出版社,1995.
    [52]张维迎.博弈论与信息经济学[M].上海人民出版社,1996.
    [53]弗里德曼.弗里德曼文萃[M].北京经济学院出版社,1991.
    [54]爱伦·斯密德著.财产、权力和公共选择[M].上海三联书店,1999,6(1).
    [55]郭吴新. 30年代大危机:历史回顾与思考[J].世界经济,1999,(05).
    [56]辛琳.信息不对称理论研究[J].嘉兴学院学报,2001,(03).
    [57]邹德文,陈要军.从信息不对称理论看中国证券市场监管制度的建设[J].湖北行政学院学报,2002,(4).
    [58]本克林.B.金德尔伯格.新帕尔格雷夫经济学大词典[M].经济科学出版社,1992.
    [59] (英)埃普里姆·艾沙著.发展中国家的财政政策与货币政策及其问题.商务印书馆,1998,2(1)版.
    [60]仵志忠.信息不对称理论及其经济学意义[J].经济学动态,1997,(01).
    [61]潘飞.会计信息不对称的理论与实证研究[J].财经研究,1997,(02).
    [62]陈学彬著.宏观金融博弈分析[M].上海财经大学出版社,1998,5(1).
    [63]刘元春著.交易费用分析框架的政治经济学批判[M].经济科学出版社,2001,3(1).
    [64]徐俊贤,谷春艳.信息不对称理论对证券发行市场的影响[J].佳木斯大学社会科学学报,1999,(04).
    [65]吴春山,常青.在税收征管中运用信息不对称理论的思考[J].广西财政高等专科学校学报,2004,(02).
    [66]蔡宁,蒋景楠.信息不对称理论在房地产市场上的应用[J].价值工程,2003,(01).
    [67]慎金花,赖茂生.从信息不对称理论谈我国信用体系建设中的信息支持问题[J].情报资料工作,2003,(01).
    [68]张素凤,英焕君,袁华.关于“村会计委托代理制”运行情况的调研报告——以鞍山市千山区为对象[J].农业经济,2005,(10).
    [69]陈桢.信息不对称理论对我国经济改革的借鉴意义[J].河北经贸大学学报,1999,(04).
    [70]周明友.信息不对称理论在工程结算审计中的应用[J].西华师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2005,(05).
    [71]史秋衡.宁顺兰.从信息不对称理论看高等教育中的行政干预[J].集美大学学报(教育科学版),2004,(02).
    [72]李华.信息不对称理论在审计关系中的应用[J].审计与经济研究,2003,(05).
    [73]曹振良.房地产经济学通论[M].北京大学出版社,2003,6,1.
    [74] (冰)思拉恩.埃格特著.新制度经济学[M].商务印书馆,1996,10(1).
    [75]金德尔伯格. 1929-1933年世界经济萧条[M].上海译文出版社,1986.
    [76]国务院.关于发展房地产业若干问题的通知,1992,11.
    [77]中央.城市房地产管理法,1995,1.
    [78]中央政府11号文.土地管理法,1999.
    [79]中共中央、国务院.关于进一步加强管理切实保护耕地的通知,1997,4.
    [80]杭州市人民政府.杭州市土地储备实施办法,1999.3月,第137号令.
    [81]青岛市人民政府.关于建立土地储备制度的通知,1999,7月29日,第160号文.
    [82]国务院.国务院关于加强国有土地资产管理的通知,2001.
    [83]国家国土资源部.招标拍卖挂牌出让国有土地使用权规定.国土资源部第11号令.2002年7月1日生效,2002,5.
    [84] Benr.Laura N.A comparative empirical investigation of agency and market theory of insider trading.Discussion paper. The Center of Law.Economics.and Buscussion[J] .Harvard University. No.264.
    [85] Akerlof.G.The model of lomon squantitative uncertainty and market mechanism[J]. Quarterly Jourmal of Economics,vol.40.488-500.
    [86] Ausubel.Lawrence W..Inside trading in a rational expectation economy[J].American Economy Review,1990,vol.80.No.4.
    [87] Bainbridge.Stephen M. A Behavioral Economic Analysis of Mandatory Disclosure.A Thought Experiment Turned Cautionary Tale[EB/OL].http://papers.ssm.com,1999.
    [88] Bikhchandani.Sushil. David Hirshleifer and Ivo Welch.A Theory of fads.fashion custom.and cultural changes as informational cascades[J].Journal of political Economy , 1999 ,vol.100.No.5.
    [89] Chang.Eric C..et al.. An Examination of Herd Behavior in Equity Markets,An International Perpective[EB/OL].http://papers.ssm.com,1999,Aug.20.
    [90] Coase.Roland H. The problem of social cost[J].Journal of Law and Economics,1960,Oct.1-44.
    [91] Coffee.Jack C.Jr. Privitization and Corporate Governance. The Lessons from Securities Market Failure[J].Columbia Law School.The Center for Law and Economic Studies[J].Working Paper,1999,No.158.
    [92] Copeland.Thomas E.and Dan Galai..Information effect on bid-ask spread[J].Journal of Finance,1983,vol.38.No.3.
    [93] Dennis W.Garlton and Danial Fischel. The regulation of insider trading[J].Stanford Law Review,1983,vol.35.
    [94] Fama.E.Efficient Capital Markets. A Review of Theory and Empirical Work[J].Journal of Finance,1970,May.383-471.
    [95] IOSCO(International Organization of Securities Commissions).Objective and Principle of Securities Regulation[EB/OL].http://www.isoxo.org,1998.
    [96] Rafael La Porta.Florencio Lopez-de-Silanes.Andrei Shleifer.and Robert W.Vishny. Legal determinants of external finance[J].Journal of Finance,1997,vol.52.1131-1155.
    [97] Modigliani.Franco.and Enrico Miller.The cost of captial.corporation finance.and the theory of investment[J].American Economics Review,1958,vol.48.261-297.
    [98] Obsfeld.M.and Rogoff.K. Foundations of International Macroeconomics[M].MIT Press, 1996.
    [99] Rienier Kraakman. The legal theory of insider trading regulation of the United States[N].in European Insider Dealing.ed.By K.Hopt.and E.Wymeesrch,1991.
    [100] Romer.C.D. The Nation in Depression.Journal of Economis Perspectives[J],1993,7(2),19-39.
    [101] Samuelson.P. Proof that Properly Anticipated Prices Fluctcate Randomly[J].Industrial Management Review,1965,6.41-49.
    [102] Stigler.George. Public regulation of securities market[J].Journal of Business, 1964 ,37.112-142.
    [103] Stiglitz.J.and Weiss.A.Credit Rationing in Markets with Imperfect Information[J],1981,AER 71(3).393-410.
    [104] Altman. E.I. and P. Narayanan. An International Survey of Business Failure Classification Models[J]. Financial Markets. Instruments and Institutions,1997,Vol.6.No.2.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700