用户名: 密码: 验证码:
我国商业银行消费信贷违约概率模型研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
随着金融全球化和自由化进程的加快,金融市场的风险呈现出高关联、高频发和高损失的特点。拉美银行危机、亚洲金融风暴、美国次贷危机等一系列事件反映出金融市场的脆弱性,也引发了业界和学术界对商业银行信用风险管理的深入思考。
     巴塞尔银行监管委员会作为国际清算银行的正式机构,其所制定的巴塞尔协议是全球公认的商业银行监管标准。该委员会于2006年颁布了新巴塞尔协议,新协议将信用风险、市场风险、流动性风险和操作风险纳入风险计量范畴,构建了资本监管的“三大支柱”,即资本充足率、监督检查和市场约束。新协议对商业银行信贷风险管理提出了更为严格的条件,它将违约概率的测度和评估列为内部评级法的核心内容,要求各成员国银行使用内部评级法来确定风险权重和计提风险资本。同时,理论界对违约概率模型的研究也做了大量的研究,主要集中于影响违约率的关键因素的选择,并基于分类算法,以历史数据为驱动、以数学模型和统计方法为基础来建立违约概率模型。
     我国现代商业银行体制刚刚建立,自身的风险管理水平有限以及历史数据积累不够,尚不能满足商业银行对各种形式贷款安全性的准确测量。但是随着我国商业银行国际化程度的加深,中国银监会以新巴塞尔协议为基准,要求我国各大商业银行提升消费信贷风险管理水平,在加强违约损失率历史数据库建立的同时,着重研究贷款的违约概率。
     本文在现有消费信贷违约概率度量研究的相关文献进行系统综述的基础上,构建了SenV-RBF-SA和时变相依的量化模型来度量消费信贷的违约风险,采用Copula方法建立了商业银行消费信贷整体风险的度量模型,并利用商业银行消费信贷的实际数据进行实证。本文的主要工作及成果如下:
     首先,考虑到SenV-RBF神经网络对数据无分布要求且在处理非线性问题是表征出的特性,以及半参数Cox比例危险模型可进行违约概率的动态预测,因而构建了基于SenV-RBF-SA融合的违约概率动态模型,对借款人未来某个时点的违约概率风险进行度量;并通过商业银行消费信贷的实际数据,实证研究发现,本文构建的混合模型在判别精度和稳健性方面与传统模型相比有一定的竞争性。
     其次,考虑到GDP、利率、CPI、上证综合指数等宏观经济的波动给借款人带来的系统性风险的影响,本文在上述混合模型基础上,采用时变相依Cox比例危险方法构建了一类消费信贷违约概率度量模型,客观度量了宏观经济因素对借款人平均违约水平的影响,它克服了以Logistic回归模型为代表的传统模型在度量消费信贷违约概率时仅考虑个体非系统性风险的局限。最后,通过实证分析,本文提出的时变模型相比于传统违约概率模型有较高的准确率和稳健性,这是对第三章研究的一个拓展。
     最后,本文通过研究提前还款与实质性违约之间的相依关系,基于Copula方法建立了二者间的整体违约风险的度量模型。我们依据非参数核密度方法估计出两组信贷产品的生存时间的边际分布;然后对每一个生成的Copula相依结构采用QQ图和Kolmogorov-Smirnov检验挑选出最优的Copula;再利用之前已获得的违约边际分布,基于Copula相依测度思想,从而构建构建了一种新的相依违约度量模型;最后给出基于Copula相依性违约测度的Kendall的秩相关系数,并进行了实证研究。
In the accelerated development of globalization and liberalization in financial market,the risk of finance has appeared to be highly inter-related,frequently occurred and caused heavily losses.A series of events such as bank crisis in Latin America,the Asian financial crisis,the subprime mortgage crisis in the US reflected fragility of finance market,and it also arose the further thinking of the commercial banks' credit risk management in banking section and academic world.
     Basel capital accord,which is enacted by Basel Committee on Banking Supervision(as the formal institution for international settlement) is the standards of regulation of commercial banks accepted globally.The Committee issued the new Basel accord in 2006.It included the credit risk,market risk,liquidity risk and operational risk into the research field of the measuring risk;hence he argued the three pillars of capital regulation,namely capital adequacy ratio,supervision and inspection,market discipline.The new accord has set up more tightened requirements in the credit risk management of commercial bank.The new approach ranked the measurement and evaluation of the default probability as the core of Internal Rating Based(IRB) approach;it proposed that IRB should be adopted in practice of risk weight as well as the counting and drawing of capital at risk.Meanwhile,theoretical circles have done a lot of works on the research of Probability of Default Model.It mainly focused on the option of influence on the key factor of default rate and established Probability of Default Model to historical data as driven,on the basis of mathematical models and statistical methods based on classification algorithm.
     China's modern commercial banking system had just been established,the limited level of their risk management,as well as the inadequate accumulation of historical data,all of those were not possible to meet all forms of commercial banks loans accurate security measurement.However,as the China's commercial banks deepening degree of internationalization,based on the new Basel Accord,the China Banking Regulatory Commission required the major commercial banks to enhance their level of consumer credit risk management,and focused on studying the loan default probability,at the same time of enhancing building default loss rate history databases.
     Based on the systematic reviews of relevant literature on researching consumer credit loan default probability measurement,this paper constructed SenV-RBF-SA and time-varying covariates quantitative model to measure consumer credit loan default risk,and established the commercial bank Overall consumer credit risk measurement model using Copula method,and using actual commercial bank consumer credit loan data to research.The main work and the results of this paper are as follows:
     First of all,considering the SenV-RBF neural network had no requirements for data distribution,and the characterization in dealing with non-linear problems,as well as the semi-parametric Cox proportional hazard model can dynamically predict default probability,this paper constructed SenV-RBF-SA dynamic models of default probability to measure borrower's default probability in a future point.At the same time,the empirical research on actual data of commercial banks consumer credit, found that this hybrid model had a certain degree of competitive in the identification accuracy and robustness compared with traditional model.
     Secondly,taking into account the systemic risks impact on borrowers,caused by GDP,interest rates,CPI,the Shanghai Composite Index and Etc.macroeconomic fluctuations.Base on the above hybrid model,this paper used the time-varying Cox proportional hazard model to build a class of consumer credit default probability measure model,and objectively measure the impact of the macro-economic factors on the borrowers' average default level.The model overcomed the limitations of traditional model which took the Logistic regression model for representative,which only considered individual non-systemic risk when measured consumer credit default probability.Finally,through empirical analysis,the time-varying model had higher accuracy and robustness compared with the traditional default probability model,this is a development study of the third chapter.
     Finally,this chapter mainly investigated the dependent relationship of prepayment and real default,and constructed a model which can measure the whole default risk between prepayment and real default based on the Copula method.We gained survival time maginal distribution of the two groups of credit products through non-parameter kernel density estimation method.Then optimal Copula would be chosen by QQ diagram and Kolmogorov-Smirnov test on every dependent structure of generated Copula.And then a new PD model of dependent risk was established based on measurement ideas of Copula and default marginal distribution.At last gave the kendallτbased on Copula dependent default measure,and conducted empirical research.
引文
陈家鼎,戴中维译,1998.生存数据分析的统计方法[M],中国统计出版社.
    陈忠阳,2004.违约损失率(LGD)研究[J],国际金融研究,5:49-57.
    杜本峰,2008.事件史分析及其应用[M],经济科学出版社.
    方先明,熊鹏,2005.基于RBF网络的商业银行信用风险控制研究[J],金融论坛,4:33-38.
    李竹渝,鲁万波,龚金国,2007.经济、金融计量学中的非参数估计技术[M],科学出版社.
    刘宏峰,杨晓光,2003.违约损失率的估计:发达国家的经验及启示[J],管理评论,6:23-27.
    马兰芳,刘金兰,杨军,花保民,2002.人工神经网络在商业银行监测预警中的应用研究[J],管理工程学报,2:5-9.
    彭非,王伟,2004,生存分析[M],中国人民大学出版社.
    王启华,2005.生存数据统计分析[M].科学出版社.
    王启华,朱力行,2003.Kaplan-Meier L-估计的Berry-Essen不等式[J],数学学报,1:11-18.
    韦艳华,张世英,2008.Copula理论及其在金融分析上的应用[M],清华大学出版社.
    袁敏,2006.国外资信评级的相关研究述评[J],上海立信会计学院学报,5:71-79.
    Ahn,B.,Cho S.,Kim,C.,2000.The integrated methodology of rough set theory and artificial neural network for business failure prediction[J],Expert Systems with Applications,65-74.
    ALtman,E.,1968.Financial ratios:discriminant analysis and the prediction of corporate bankrupt[J],Journal of Finance.
    Altman,E.,Haldeman,R.,Narayanan,P.,1977.Zeta TM analysis-a new model to identify bankruptcy risk of corporations[J],Journal of Banking and Finance,1:29-54.
    Andreeva,G.,Ansell,J.,Crook,J.,2007.Modelling profitability using survival combination scores[J],European Journal of Operational Research,1-19.
    Asberg,P.,Shahnazarian,H.,2008.Macroeconomic impact on expected default freqency,Working Paper,1-34.
    Baesens,B.,Gestel,T.,Stepanova,M.,Poel,D..2004.Neural network survival analysis for personal loan data[J],Journal of the Operational Research Society,1-23.
    Barnhill,T.,Maxwell,W.,2002.Modeling correlated interest rate,exchange rate,and credit risk in fixed income portfolios[J],Journal of Banking and Finance,
    Bellotti,T.,Crook,J,2008.Credit scoring with macroeconomic variables using survival analysis[J],Journal of the Operational Research Society,1-18.
    Bellotti,V.,Nuvolone,M.,Giorgetti,S.,Obici,L.,2007.The workings of the amyloid diseases[J],Annals of Medicine.
    Beynon,M.,Peel,M.,2001.Variable precision rough set theory and data discretisation:an application to corporate failure,Omega,29:561-576.
    Blossfeld,H.,Rohwer,G.,2002.Techniques of event history modeling:new approaches to causal analysis[R].
    Bouy?E.,Durrleman,V,Nikeghbali,A.,Riboulet,G.2000.Copulas for finance:a reading guide and some applications,Working Paper of Financial Econometrics Research Centre,City University Business School,London.
    Boylel,C.? Brannl,E.,1992.Proxy respondents and the validity of occupational and other exposure data[J],American Journal of Epidemiology,136:712-721.
    Brand,l.,Bahar,R.,1999.Rating Performance 1998[R],Standard & Corporation.
    Breiman,L.,Friedman,J.,Olshen,R.,Stone,C,1984.Classification and regression trees.Belmont[J],CA:Wadsworth International Group.
    Brown,C,1997.Examining the emergence of hybrid IS governance soIutions:evidence from a single case site[J],Information Systems Research,8:69-95.
    Carter,C,Catlett,J.,1987.Assessing credit card applications using machine learning,IEEE Expert,Fall:71-79.
    Chatterjee,S.,Barcun,S.,1970.Nonparametric approach to credit screening[J],Journal of the American Statistical Association,150-154.
    Chava,S.,Jarrow,R.,2004.Bankruptcy prediction with industry effects[J],Review of Finance.
    Chung,H.,Gray,R,1999.Special section:Data mining[J],Journal of Management Information Systems,1:11-16.
    Cossettea,H.,Gaillardetza,R,Marceau,E.,Riouxb,J.,2002.On two dependent individual risk models[J],Insurance:Mathematics and Economics,30:153-166.
    Cox,D.,1972.Regression models and life-tables[J],Journal of the Royal Statistical Society,Series B.
    Cox,D.,1972.Regression models and life-tables[J],Journal of the Royal Statistical Society,34:187-220.
    Craven,M.,Shavlik,J.,1997.Using neural networks for data mining[J],Future Generation Computer Systems,211-229.
    Cristianini,N.,Shawe-Taylor,J.,2000.An introduction to support vector machines[M],Cambridge University Press,Cambridge.
    Crook,J.,Edelman,D.,Thomas,L.,2007.Recent developments in consumer credit risk assessment[J],European Journal of Operational Research,183:1447-1465.
    Crook,J.,Hamilton,R.,Thomas,L.,1992.Credit card holders:characteristics of users and non-users[J],The Service Industries Journal.
    Davis A.,1991.Insidious rationalities.The institutionalisation of small boat fishing and the rise of the rapacious fisher[J],Maritime Anthropological Studies,4:13-31.
    Davis,C,2003.Factors underlying masked priming effects in competitive network models of visual word recognition,In S.Kinoshita,& S.J.Lupker,Masked Priming:the state of the art.Hove,UK:Psychology Press,121-170.
    Davis,L.,Handbook of Genetic Algorithms,Van Nostrand Reinhold,NY.
    Desai,V,Conway,D.,Crook J.,George,A.,1997.Credit-scoring models in the credit-union environment using neural networks and genetic algorithms[J],Journal of Management Mathematics,4:323-346.
    Desaia,V,Crookb,J.,Overstreet,G,1996.A comparison of neural networks and linear scoring models in the credit union environment[J],European Journal of Operational Research,24-37.
    Dimitras,A.,Slowinski,R.,Susmaga,R.,Zopounidis,C,1999.Business failure prediction using rough sets[J],European Journal of Operational Research.
    Dobson,A.,1990.An Introduction to Generalized Linear Models[M],London:Chapman and Hall.
    Donald van Deventer & Kenji Imai,Credit Risk Models and the Basel Accords,John Wiley & Sons(Asia) Pte.Ltd.
    Durand,D.,1941.Risk elements in consumer instalment financing,Risk Elements in Consumer Instalment Financing.
    Durrleman,V,Nikeghbali,A.,Riboulet,G,Roncalli,T.,2000.Copulas for finance a reading guide and some applications.Working Paper.
    Eleuteri,A.,Tagliaferri,R.,Milano,L.,Placido,S.,2003.A novel neural network-based survival analysis model[J],Neural Networks,16:855-864.
    Embrechts,P,H鰅ng,A.,Juri,A.,2003.Using copulae to bound the value-at-risk for functions of dependent risks[J],Finance and Stochastics.1-23
    Embrechts,P.,McNeil,A.,Straumann,D.,1999.Correlation:pitfalls and alternatives,Risk-London-Risk Magazine Limited.
    Epstein,M.,1958.An investigation into the purifying effect of a fluorocarbon on vaccinia virus[J],Brit.J.Exptl.Pathol.39:436-466.
    Feigl,P,Zelen,M.,1965.Estimation of exponential survival probabilities with concomitant information[J],Biometrics,21:826-838.
    Feraud,R.,Cleror,R,2002.A methodology to explain neural network classification[J],Neural Network,2:237-246.
    Forbes,K.,Rigobon,R.,2003.No contagion,only interdependence:Measuring stock market co-movements[J],Journal of Finance,57:2223-2261.
    Fridson,M.,Garman,C,Wu,S.,1997.Real Interest Rates and the Default Rate on High-Yield Bonds(Digest Summary)[J],Journal of Fixed Income,28:27-28.
    Geman,S.,Bienenstock,E.,Doursat,R.,1992.Neural networks and the bias/variance dilemma[J],Neural Computation.
    Genest,C,MacKay,J.,1986.The joy of copulas:bivariate distributions with uniform marginals[J],American Statistician,40:280-283.
    Giudici,R,2003.Applied data mining:Statistical methods for business and industry[M],New York:Wiley.
    Goldberg,D.,1989.Genetic algorithms in search,optimization and machine leaming[M],Addison-Wesley Longman Publishing.
    Gompertz,B.,1825.On the nature of the function expressive of the law of human mortality,and on a new mode of determining the value of life contingencies[J],Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London,115:513-583.
    Gordy,M.,2000.A Comparative anatomy of credit risk models[J],Banking Finance,24:119-149.
    Grablowsky,B.,Talley,W,1981.Probit and discriminant functions for classifying credit applicants:a comparison[J],Journal of Economic Business.
    Hand,D.,Henley,W,1997.Statistical classification methods in consumer credit scoring:a review[J],Journal of the Royal Statistical Society,3:523-541.
    Hand,D.,Henley,W,1997.Statistical classification methods in consumer credit scoring:a review[J],Journal of the Royal Statistical Society,3:523-541.
    Haykin,S.,Neural Networks:A Comprehensive Foundation[M],2th ed,Englewood Cliffs,NJ:Prentice-Hall.
    Henley,W.,Hand,D.,1996.A k-nearest-neighbour classifier for assessing consumer credit risk[J],The Statistician,77-95.
    Holland,J.,1975.Adaptation in natural and artificial system[M],Ann Arbor,MI:University of Michigan Press.
    Hollander,M.,Wolfe,D.,1973.Nonparametric statistical methods[M],New York,USA.
    Huang,C,Chen,M.,Wang,M.,2007.Credit scoring with a data mining approach based on support vector machines[J],Expert Systems with Applications,847-856.
    Jarrow,R.,Turnbull,S.,1995.Pricing Derivatives on Financial Securities Subject to Credit Risk[J],Journal of Finance,50:53-86.
    Joachimsthaler,A.,Stam,A.,1990.Mathematical programming approaches for the classification problem in two-group discriminant analysis[J],Multivariate Behavioral Research,25:427-454.
    Joe,H.,1997.Multivariate Models and Dependence Concepts.Monographs in Statistics and Probability[M],Chapman & Hall,New York.
    Kaplan,E.,Meier,P.,1958.Nonparametric estimation from incomplete observations[J],Journal of the American statistical association,53:457-481.
    Kingdom,J.Feldman,K.,1995.Genetic algorithms for bankruptcy prediction[R].Search Space Research Report,No.01-95.
    Lane,W.,Looney,S.,Wansley,J.,1986.An application of the Cox proportional hazards model to bank failure[J],Journal of Banking and Finance.
    Lawless,J.,1998.Statistical analysis of product warranty data[J],International Statistical Review,66:41-60.
    Lee,S.,Urrutia,J.,1996.Analysis and prediction of insolvency in the property-liability insurance industry:A comparison of logit and hazard models[J],Journal of Risk and Insurance,63:121-130.
    Maddala,G.,2001.Introduction to Modern Econometrics[M],New York:Wiley.
    Mahfoud,S.and Mani,G.,1995.Genetic algorithms forpredicting individual stock performance,Proceedings of the 3th International Conference on Arificial Intelligence Applications on Wall Street,174-181.
    Mahlhotra,R.and Malhotra,D.,2003.Evaluating consumer loans using neural networks[J],OMEGA:The International Journal of Management Science,2:83-96.
    Mangasarian,O.,1965.Linear and Nonlinear Separation of Patterns by Linear Programming[J],Operations Research,13(3):444-452.
    Matteis,R.,2001.Fitting copulas to data[J],Institute of Mathematics/University of Zurich.McCulloch,W.,Pitts,W.,1943.A logical calculus of the ideas immanent in nervous activity[J],Bulletin of Mathematical Biology,115-133.
    McDonald,C.,Gucht,L.,1999.High-yield bond default and call risks[J],Review of Economics and Statistics.
    McDonald,C.,Gucht,L.,1999.High-yield bond default and call risks[J],Review of Economics and Statistics,81:409-419.
    Mehta,D.,1968.The formulation of credit policy models[J],Management Science.
    Minsky,M.,Papert,S.,1969.Perceptrons[M],Cambridge,MA:MIT Press.
    Moeller,T,Molina,C,2003.Curvival and Default of Original Issue High-Yield Bonds[J],Financial Management.
    Moody's Investors Service,1991.Global credit analysis,working paper.
    Morgan,J.,Sonquist,J.,1963.Problems in the analysis of survey data,and a proposal[J],Journal of the American Statistical Association.
    Narian,B.,1992.Survival and biochemical profiles of the adults of the nematode parasites, Ascaridia galli of fowl and Trichuris ovis of sheep,maintained in vitro,Z.Angew.Zool.279-290.
    Narian,B.,1992.Survival and biochemical prowles of the adults of the nematode parasites,Ascaridia galli of fowl and trichuris ovis of sheep,maintained in vitro,Z.Angew.Zool,279-290.
    Natha,R.,Rajagopalanb,B.,Rykerc,R.,1997.Determining the saliency of input variables in neural network classifiers[J],Computers & Operations Research,24:767-773.
    Nelsen,R.,1999.An introduction to copulas.In:Lecture Notes in Statistics[M],New York:Springer,139.
    Nelson,C,1972.The term structure of interest rates[M],Basic Books,New York.
    Nickell,R,Perraudin,W.,Varotto,S.,1998.Ratings-versus equity-based credit risk models:an empirical investigation,unpublished Bank of England mimeo.
    Noh,S.,2005.A new iris recognition method using independent component analysis,IEICE Trans.Inform.Systems,2573-2581.
    Onga,C,Huanga,J.,Tzengb,G,2005.Building credit scoring models using genetic programming[J],Expert Systems with Applications.
    Packard,N.,1990.A genetic learing algorithm for the analysis of complex data[J],Complex Systems,4:543-572.
    Parzen,E.,1962.On estimation of a probability density function and mode[M],The Annals of Mathematical Statistics,33:1065-1076.
    Patton,M.,2002.Qualitivative research and evaluation methods[M],3thed thousand Oaks,CA:Sage.
    Paula,G.,Modelos de Regressao com Apoio Computacional,Book available in http://www.ime.usp.br/~giapaula/livro.pdf accessed in 12/05/2004.
    Pawlak,Z.,1982.Rough sets[J],International Journal Computer Information Science,341-356.
    Pawlak,Z.,Busse,J.,Slowinski,R.,Ziarko,W.,1995.Rough sets:New horizons in commercial and industrial AI,Communications of the ACM.
    Piramuthul,S.,1999.Financial credit-risk evaluation with neural and neurofuzzy systems[J],European Journal of Operational Research,310-321.
    Pontil,M.,Verri,A.,1998.Support vector machines for 3D object recognition,IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine,20:637-646.
    Powell,R.,1985.Regression diagnostics and robust regression in geothermometer/geobarometer calibration:the garnet-clinopyroxene geothermometer revisited[J],Journal of Metamorphic Geology,3:231-243.
    Press,S.,Wilson,S.,1978.Choosing between logistic regression and discriminant analysis[J].Journal America Statistics Association,699-705.
    Ripley,B.,1994.Neural networks and related methods for classification[J],Journal of the Royal Statistical Society,3:409-456.
    Ripley,B.,1994.Neural networks and related methods for classification[J],Journal of the Royal Statistical Society,3:409-456.
    Robert,J.,Schilling,J.,Carroll,J.,2001.Approximation of nonlinear systems with radial basis function neural networks[J],IEEE Trans Neural Networks,12:1-15.
    Rosa,P.,2000.Modelos de credit scoring:Regressao logistica,CHAID E REAL,CA de Braganea Pereira.
    Rose,P.,Andrews,W.,Giroux,G,1982.Predicting business failure:A macroeconomic perspective[J],Journal of Accounting,Auditing and Finance,20-31
    Rosenberg,E.,Gleit,A.,1994.Quantitative methods in credit management:a survey[J],Operations Research,4:589-613.
    Rosenblatt,M.,1956.Remarks on some nonparametric estimates of a density function[J],The Annals of Mathematical Statistics,27:832-837
    Roszbach,K.,2004.Bank lending policy,credit scoring,and the survival of loans[J],Review of Economics and Statistics,86:946-958.
    Rutan,E.,1993.Experiments with optimal stock screens,Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Artificial Intelligence Application on Wall Street,269-273.
    Saretto,A.,2004.Predicting and pricing the probability of default,Working Paper,1-41
    Scho'lkopf,B.Smola,A.,2000.Statistical learning and kernel methods[M],MIT Press,Cambridge.
    Seetharaman,P,Chintagunta,R,2003.The proportional hazard model for purchase timing[J],Journal of Business and Economic Statistics.
    Shi,D.,Yeung,D.,Gao,J.,2005.Sensitivity analysis applied to the construction of radial basis function networks[J],Neural Networks,18:951-957.
    Shumway,T.,2001.Forecasting bankruptcy more accurately:a simple hazard model[J],The Journal of Business.
    Silva,A.,Stam A.,1997.A mixed integer programming algorithm for minimizing the training sample misclassification cost in two-group classification[J],Annals of Operations Research,11:129-157.
    SkIar,A.,1959.Fonctions de repartition an dimensionset leurs marges[M],Publ.Inst.Statis.Univ.Paris,8:229-231
    Srinivasan,V,Kim,Y.,1987.Credit granting:a comparative analysis of classification procedures[J].Journal of Finance,42:665-683
    Stepanova,M.,Thomas,L.,2002.Survival analysis methods for personal loan data[J],Operations Research,50:277-289.
    Tan,R,Steinbach,M.,Kumar,V.,2006.Introduction to Data Mining[M].Addison-Wesley.
    Tay,R,Shen L.,2002.Economic and financial prediction using rough sets model[J],European Journal of Operational Research,141:641-659.
    Thomas,L.,2000.A survey of credit and behavioural scoring:forecasting financial risk of lending to consumers[J],International Journal of Forecasting,16:149-172.
    Thomas,L.,Edelman,D.,Crook,J.,2002.Credit scoring and its applications[M],SIAM.
    Tiwari,G.,Bangdiwala,S.,Saraswat,A.,Gaurav,S.,2007.Survival analysis:Pedestrian risk exposure at signalized intersections[R],Transportation Research Part F:Psychology and Behaviour.
    Vandell,K.,1993.Handing over the keys:a perspective on mortgage default research[J],Journal Real Estate Economics,21:211-246.
    Walker,R.,Haasdijk,E.,Gerrets M,1995.Credit evaluation using a genetic algorithm[J],Intelligent Systems for Finance and Business,39-59.
    Weibull.W.,1951.A statistical distribution function of wide applicability,Appl.Mech.
    West,D.,2000.Neural network credit scoring models[J],Computers and Operations Research,27:1131-1152.
    Whalen,G.,1991.A proportional hazards model of bank failure:an examination of its usefulness as an early warning tool[J],Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland Economic Review,21-31.
    Wheelock,D.,Wilson,R,2000.Why do banks disappear?The determinants of US bank failures and acquisitions[J],Review of Economics and Statistics,1-31.
    Wong,E,Tan,C,1994.Hybird neural,genetic and fuzzy systems[M].Trading on The Edge.New York:John Wiley.245-247.
    Wong,S.,Ziarko,W.,1985.On optimal decision rules in decision tables[J],Bulletin of Polish Academy of Science,33:693-696.
    Yu,G.,Ostrouchov,G,Geist,A.,Samatova,N.,2003.An SVM-based algorithm for identification of photosynthesis-specific genome features,Bioinformatics Conference,CSB.Proceedings of the 2003 IEEE,235-243.
    Zandi,M.,1998.Incorporating economic information into credit risk underwriting[R].In:Mays,E.,Editor,Credit risk modeling,Glenlake Publishing,Chicago,155-168.
    Zaslavsky,V,Strizhak,A.,2006.Credit Card Fraud Detection Using Self-Organizing Maps[J], Information and Security.
    Zeng,X.,Yeung,D.,2001.Sensitivity analysis of multilayer perceptron to input and weight perturbations[J],IEEE Transactions on Neural Networks.
    Zeng,X.,Yeung,D.,2003.A quantified sensitivity measure for multilayer perceptron to input perturbation[J],Neural computation,183-212.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700