DRM范式下的儿童错误记忆研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
错误记忆是记忆研究的重要领域。尽管目前为止人们错误记忆概念的理解并不一致,但现在心理学研究者多从两个方面来理解错误记忆:其一是指人们回忆出自己从未经历过的事情。其二是回忆出来的事情与实际发生的情况有较大偏差。心理学对错误记忆研究的热潮始于20世纪中叶。在基于事件的错误记忆研究中以信息误导范式为代表,而基于单词的错误记忆研究中则以集中联想范式(亦即DRM范式)为代表。已往的研究结果表明,人类的记忆是一个动态的变化系统,人类记忆的变化不仅存在记忆量的衰减,而且存在记忆内容的歪曲和扭曲。错误记忆现象的研究在理论和现实方面都有重要意义。
     基于单词的错误记忆主要以DRM研究范式为代表。目前关于DRM范式错误记忆的研究主要集中在两个方面,一是错误记忆的影响因素(现象学研究),二是错误记忆是如何发生的(机制研究)。在研究的被试选取方面,已从早期研究的正常成人和大学生被试,扩展到儿童、老年、脑损伤等各种记忆障碍人群。
     儿童错误记忆的研究,近年来受到心理学家的更多的关注,但受制于儿童心理发展的水平,许多在成人错误记忆研究中的材料和方法并不适用于儿童。这在某种程度上妨碍了对儿童错误记忆的研究。就目前国内错误记忆的研究而言,以成人或大学生和中学生为被试的研究居多,而以小学生为被试的研究较少,以学前儿童为被试的研究更是难得一见。
     本文以6岁(学前大班)、8岁儿童(小学中年级)和12岁儿童(小学高年级)为被试,使用汉语词、和彩色照片编制的DRM词表。通过五个实验研究儿童的错误记忆的产生机制及影响因素。具体研究如下:实验一:以词,简笔画,彩色照片为实验材料,以不同年龄的学龄前儿童和小学中、高年级儿童为被试,探索实验材料和年龄因素对错误记忆的影响;实验二:以词和不同背景的彩色照片实验材料,研究学习与测验情境一致与否对错误记忆的影响;实验三:在实验一和实验二的基础上,考察图片材料的主题信息是否影响错误记忆。实验四:通过整体呈现、分组呈现和随机呈现方式,考察实验材料的不同呈现方式对错误记忆的影响;实验五;通过有无预警考察预警对儿童错误记忆的影响。
The false memory is indispensible research field of memory. Though psychologist did not hold identical views with the concept of false memory, the idea has been accepted is that When people remember things that he had never experienced or recalled something have greater discrepancy with the thing should be, the false memories occur. The research of false memories boom began in the mid-20th century. There have been formed two research paradigm of false memory, one is centered with event and the represented form is misinformation paradigm, the other is word-based association paradigm (DRM paradigm). The psychologist's research results show that the human memory is not reliable as one imagine, as the content of memory is not only easy to be weaken, but also would be interfered by various factors in the memory process. Memory' distort and twist occur everywhere, the memory is not an exact copy of the human objective facts. The research of false memory has play an important role in theoretical and practical aspects.
     DRM research paradigm is representative method in the laboratory study in false memory. There are two item in false memory, one is the effect factor of false memory, another is how the false occur. The subject of false memory research has been changed from normal adults and college student in the earlier studies extended to children, the elder, brain damage and other memory disorders group.
     Children's false memories has been noticed frequently in recent years, but subject to the level of the psychological development of children, many materials and methods in the study of adult false memory does not apply to children's research and this slowed the study of children's false memories. The subject in false memory are often to be seen with adults, college students or high school students and less to be seen with primary school, and the preschool children for subjects research is rare to see. This dissertation with6-year-old (pre-school),8-year-old (primary school in the grade3) and12-year-old children (elementary school grade6) to take part in the experiments, use Chinese words, stick picture and color photographs formed the DRM vocabulary material. Through five experiment study the children's false memory mechanism and influence factors. All studies are as follows: Experiment1:Use the material of word, stick picture and color photographs and with the different subject of preschool, mid-primary and high-primary school students, to identify the materials and age as the effect factors to false memories; experimental; Experiment2:Use the materials of words and color-photographs with different backgrounds to study learning and test situation is consistent or not effected the false memory; Experimen3:Based on Experiments Ⅰ and Ⅱ to probe into the theme of the picture material information affecting the false memory; Experiment4:Use the different material present method.such as overall group presentation, partly group presentation and random presentation to investigated the material present form has the influence to children false Memory; experiment; Though the presence or absence of early warning to study the impact of early warning to children's false memories.
引文
1.杨治良,孙连荣,唐菁华.记忆心理学(第三版).上海:华东师范大学出版社,2012年7月第一版
    2.Miller,G.A.(1956).The magical number seven,plus or minus two:some limits on our capacity for processing information.Psychological Review,63(2):81-97
    3.Sternberg,S.(1966).High-speed scanning in human memory.Science,153:652-654
    4.Sternberg,S.(1969).Memory-scanning:Mental processes revealed by reaction-time experiments.American Scientist,57:421-457
    5.Sperling,G.(1960)The information available in brief visual presentations. Psychological Monographs:General and Applied,74(11):1-29
    6.Kirkpatrick,E.A.(1894).An experimental study of memory.Psychological Review,1:602-609
    7.Desse,J.(1959a).Influennce of inter-item associative strength upon immediate free recall.Psycho logical Reports,5:305-312
    8.Desse,J.(1959b).On the prediction of occurrence of particular verbal intrsions in immediate recall.Journal of Experimental Psychology,58(1):17-22
    9.Loftus,E.F.(1974).Reconstruction of automobile destruction:An example of the interaction between language and memory.Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior,13:585-589
    10.Roediger,H.L.,McDermott,K.B.&Robinson,K.J.(1998).The role associative processes in creating false memories.In M A Conway.S.E. Gathercole,& C.Cornoldi(Eds.), Theories of memory Ⅱ (pp187-245). Howe,U.K.Psychological Press.
    11.Roediger,H.L., & Mcdermott,K.B.(1999).False alarms about false memories.Psychological Review,106:406-410
    12.McDermott,K.B. & Watson,J.M.(2001).The rise and fall of false recall:The impace of presentation of associates. Journal of Memory and Language,45:160-176
    13.Ghetti,S.,Qin,J.,& Goodman,G..(2002).False memories in children and adults:Age,distinctiveness and subjective experience.Developmental Psychology,38:705-718
    14.Brainerd,C.J.,& Reyna,V.F.(2002).Fuzzy-trace theory and false memory,Current Directions in Psychological Science,11:164-169
    15.郭秀艳,周楚,周梅花.错误记忆影响因素的实验研究.应用心理学,2004,10(1):3-8
    16.周楚,杨治良.错误记忆研究范式评介.心理科学,2004,27(4):909-912
    17.Hintzman,D.L.(1988).Judgments of frequency and recognitionmmemory in a multiple-trace memory model. Psychological Review,95:528-551
    18.Seamon,J.G.,Luo,C.R.,Schlegel,S.E.,Greene,S.E.&Goldenberg,A.B.(2000).False memory for categorized picture and words:The category associates procedure for studying memory errors in children and adults.Journal of Memory and Language,42:120-146
    19.Jacoby,L.L.&Whitehouse,K.(1989).An illusion of memory:False recognition influenced by unconscious perception. Journal of Experimental psychology:General,118(2):126-135
    20.Loftus,E., & Palmer,J.(1974).Reconsrtuction of automobile destruction:An examole of the interaction between language and memory. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior,13:585-589
    21.Kassin,S.M., & Kiechel,K.L.(1996).The social psychology of false confessions: Compliance, internalization,and confabulation. Psychological Science,7(3):125-128
    22.Underwood,B.J.(1965).False recognition produced by implicit verbal responses.Journal of Experimental Psychology,70:122-129
    23.Gallo,D.A.,& Roberts,M.J.(1997).Seamom J G. Remembering words not presented in lists:Can weavoid creating false memory? Psychonomic Bulletin and Revies,4:271-276
    24.McDermott,K.B., & Roediger,H.L.(1998).Attempting to avoid illusory memories:Robust false recognition of associates persists underconditions of explicit warnings and immediate testing.Journal of Memory and Language,39:508-520
    25.Seamon,J.G.,Luo,C.R.,&Gallo,D.A.(1998).Creating false memories of words with or without recognition of list items:Evidence for nonconscious processes.Psycho-logical Science,9:20-26
    26.Seamon,J.G,Luo,C.R.,Schlegel,S.E.,Greene,S.E.,&Goldenberg,A.B.(2000).False memory for categorized pictures and words:The category associates procedure for studying memory errors in Children and adults.Journal of Memory and Language,42: 120-146
    27.Arndt,J., & Hishman,E.,(1998).True and false recognition in MINERVA2:Explanations from a global matching perspective Journal of Memory and Language,39:371-391
    28.Hintzman,D.L.(1988).Judgments of frequency and recognition memory in multiple-trace memory model.Psychological Review,95:528-551
    29.Roediger,H.L., & Mcdermott,K.B.(1995).Creating false memories:Rwmembering words not presented in lists.Journal of Experimental Psychology:Learning,Memory and Cognition,
    30. Brainerd,C.J.,& Kingma,J.(1984).Do children have toremember to reason?A fuzzy trace theory of transitivity development.Development Review,4:311-377
    31.Reyna,V.f.,& Brainerd,C.J.(1995).Fuzzy-trace theory:An interim synthesis.Learning and individual Difference,7:1-75
    32.Toglia,M.P.,Neuschatz,J.S.,& Goodwin,K.A.,(1999).Recall accuracy and illusory memoryes:When more is less.memory,7:233-256
    33.Seamon,J.G..,Luo,C.R.,Kopecky,J.J.,Price,C.A.,Rotheschild,L.,Fung,N.S.,&Schwa tz,M.A.(2002).Are false memories more difficult to forget then accurate memories?The effect of retention interval on recall and recognition..Memory and Cognition,30(7):1054-1065
    34.Johnson,M.K.,Taylor,T.H.,& Raye,C.L.(1977).Fact and fantasy:the effects of internally generated events on the apparent frequency of externally generated events.Memory and Cognition,5(1):116-122
    35.Johnson,M.K.,Hashtroudi,S., & Lindsay,D.S.,(1993).Scource monitoring. sycholohical ulletin,114(1):3-28
    36.Johnson,M.K., & Raye,C.L.,(1981).Reality monitoring.Psychological review, 8:67-85
    37.Whittlesea,B.W., & Williams,L.D.(2001).The discrepancy attribution hypothesis I.The heuristic basis of feelings of familiarity.Journal of Experimental Psychology:Learning,Memory and Cognition,27(1):3-13
    38.Whittlesea,B.W.,& Williams,L.D.(2001).The discrepancy attribution hypothesis II.Expectation uncertainty,surprise and feelings of familiarity. Journal of Experimental Psychology:Learning, Memory and Cognition,27(1):14-33
    39.Whittlesea,B.W.(2002).A false memoey and discrepancy-attribution hypothesis:The prototypefamilarity illusion. Journal of Experimental Psychology:General,131 (1):96-115
    40..Whittlesea,B.W.,Masson,M.E.J.,& HHughes,A.D.(2005).False memory following rapidly presented lists:The element of surprise.Psychological research,in press
    41.Roediger,H.L.,Balota,D.A.,& Watson,J.M.(2001).Spreading activation and the arousal of false memories.from The nature of remembering:Essays in honor of Robert G.Crowder(pp95-115).Washington DC:American Psychological association.
    42.杨治良,周楚,万璐璐,谢锐.短时间延迟条件下错误记忆的遗忘.心理学报,2006,38(1):1-6
    [43].Israel,L.,& Schacter,D.L.(1997).Pictorial encoding reduces false recognition of semantic associates.Psychonomic Bulletin and Review,4:577-581
    44.Schacter,D.L.,Israel,L., & Racine, C.(1999).Suppressing false recognition in younger and older adults:The distinctiveness heuristic.Journal of Memory and Language,40(1):1-24
    45.Gallo,D.A.,Roediger,H.L.,& McDermott,K.B.(2002).Associative false recognition occurs without strategic criterion shifts.Psychonomic Bulletin and Review,8(3):579-586
    46.McDermott,K.B.(1996).The persistence of previous occurrence.Journal of Memory and Language,35:212-230
    47.Kensinger,E.A., & Schacter,D.L.(1999). When true memories suppress false memories:Effects of aging.Cognitive Neuropsychology,16:399-415
    48.Neuschatz,J.S., & Penney,T.B.(2001).Lampinen,J.M. Toglia, M.P. Assessing the effectiveness of warnings and the phenomenological characteristics of false memories.Memory,9:53-71
    49.Benjamin,A.S.(2001).On the dual effect of repetition on false recognition.Journal of Experimental Psychology:Learning,Memory and Cognition,27(4):941-947
    50.Balota,D.A., & Cortese,M.J.(1999).Duchek,J.M., Adams,D., Roediger,H.L., McDermott,K.B., Yerys,B.E. Verdical and false memories in healthy older adults and in dementia of the Alzheimer's type.Cognitive Neuropsychology,16:361-384
    51.Robinson,K., & Roediger,H.L.(1997).Associative processes in false recall and false recognition.Psychological Science,8:231-237
    52.郭秀艳,周楚,周梅花.错误记忆影响因素的实验研究.应用心理学,2004,10 (1)3-8
    53.Roediger,H.L., & McDermott,K.B.(1999).False alarms about false memories. Psychologica Review,106:406-410
    54.Brainerd,C.J.,Wright,R.,Reyna,V.E.,& Moijardin,A.H.(2001).Conjoint recognition and phantom recollectionJournal of Experimental Psychology:Learning,Memory and Cognition,27:307-327
    55.Read,J.D.(1996).From a passing thought to a false memory in 2 mintues:Confusing real and illusion events.Psychonomic Bulletin and Review,3:105-111
    56.Tussing,A.A., & Greene,R.L.(1997).False recognition of associates:How robust is the effect?Psychonomic Bulletin and Review,4:572-576
    57.Rhodes,M.G., & Anastasi,J.S.(2000).The effects of a level-of-processing manipulation on false recall.Psychonomic Bulletin and Review,7:158-162
    58.史晓航,郝兴昌.加工水平与呈现时间对错误记忆的影响.心理科学,2009,32(2):342-345
    59.Mather,M.,Henkel,L.A.,&Johnson,M.K.,(1997).Evaluating characteristics of false memories:Remember/know judgements and memory characteristics questionnaire compared.Memory and Cognition,25:826-837
    60.Smith,R.E.,&Hunt,R.R.(1998).Presentation modality affects false memory. Psychonomic Bulletin and Review,5:710-715
    61.Maylor,E.A.,&Mo,A.(1999).Effects of study-test modality on false recognition. British Journal of Psychology,90:477-493
    62.毛伟宾,杨治良,王林松,袁建伟.非熟练中-英双语者跨语言的错误记忆通道效应.心理学报,2008,40(3):274-282
    63.刘晓华.熟练中-英文双语者跨语言的错误记忆研究.哈尔滨师范大学硕士论文,2012
    64.McCabe,D.P.,& Smith,A.D.(2002).The effect of warnings on false memories in young and older adults.Memory and Cognition,30:1065-1077)
    65.Neuschatz,J.S.,&Payne,D.G.(2001).Lampinen,J.M.,Toglia,M.P. Assessing the effectiveness of warnings and the phenomenological characteristics of false memories. Memory,9:53-71
    66.李宏英,连榕,翁洁.预警、重复学习和反馈对错误记忆的影响.心理科 学,2008,31(6):1507-1509
    67.Payne,D.G.,Elie,C.J.,Blackwell,J.M.,& Neuschatz,J.S.(1996).Memory illusions: Recalling, recognizing and recollecting events that neveroccurred. Journal of Memory and Language,35(2):261-285
    68.Cull,W.L.,Shaughnessy,J.J.,& Zechmeister,E.B.(1996).Expanding our understanding of the expanding pattern of retrieval mnemonic:Toward confidence in applicability. Journal of Experimental Psychology:Applied,2:365-378
    69.万璐璐,郭秀艳.测验情境对错误记忆的影响.心理科学,2007,30(3):600-603
    70.杨治良,王思睿,唐菁华.错误记忆的来源:编码阶段/保持阶段.应用心理学,2006,12(2):99-106
    71.Schacter,D.L.,Reiman,E.,Curran,T.,Sheng Yun.L.,Bandy,D.,McDermott,K.B., & Roediger,H.L.(1996).Neuroanatomical correlates of veridical and illusory recognition memory evidence from positron emission tomography.Neuron,17(2):267-274
    72.Kubota,Y.,Toichi,M.,Shimizu,M.,Mason,R.A.,Findling,R.L.,Yamamoto,K.,&Calab rese,J.R.(2006).Prefrontal hemodynamic activity predicts false memory-a near infrared spectroscopy study.NeuroImage,31:1783-1789
    73.Cabeza,R.,Rao,S.M.,Wagner,A.D.,Mayer,A.R.,& Schacter,D.L.(2001).Can medial temporal lobe regions distinguish true from false? An event-related fuctional MRI study of veridical and illusory recognition memory.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,98(8):4895-4810
    74.Walla,P.,Endl,W.,Lindinger,G.,Deecke,L., & Lang,W.(2000).False recognition in a verbal memory task:an event-related potential study.Cognitive Brain Research,11(2):249-257
    75.Okado,Y., & Stark,C.E.L.(2005).Neural activity during encoding predicts false memories created by disinformation.Learning and Memory,12(4):361-366
    76.Walla,P.,Hufnagl,B.,Lindinger G.,Deecke,L.,Imhol,H., & Lang,W.(2001).False recognition depends on depth of prior word processing:a magnetoencephalographic(MEG) study. Cognitive Brain Research, 11(2):249-257
    77.Urbach,T.P.,Windmann,S.S.,Psyne,D.G., & Kutas,M.(2005).Neural precursors of memory illusions in Electrical brain activity.Psychological Science,16(1):19-24
    78.Geng,H.,Qi,Y.,Li,Y.,Fan,S.,Wu,H., & Zhu,Y.,(2007).Neuroophysiological correlates of memory illusion in both encoding and retrieval phases.Brain Research,1136:154-168
    79.Nessler,D., & Mechlinger,A.(2003).ERP correlates of true and false recognition after different retention delays:stimulus-and response-related process.Psychophysiology,40(1):146-159
    80. Nessler,D.,Friedman,D.,& Bersick,M.(2004).Classic and false memory designs:An electrophysiological comparison.Psychology,41 (5):679-687
    81.Ward,J.,& Jones,L.(2003).Inappropriate association of semantics and context to novel stimuli can give rise to the false recognition of unfamiliar people. Neuropsychologia,41 (5):538-549
    82.Ecker,U.K.H.,Zimmer,H.D.,& GrohBordin,C.(2007).Context effects on familiarity are familiarity effects of context:An electrophysiological study. International Journal of Psychophysiology,64(2):146-156
    83.Gutchess,A.H.,Ieuji,Y.,& Federmeier,K.D.(2007).Event-related potentials reveal age differences in the encoding and recognition of scense.Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience,19(7):1089-1103
    84.Penney,G.G.(1975).Modality effects in short-term verbal memory. Psychological Bulletin,82(1):68-84
    85. Penney,GG(1989). Modality effects and the structure of short-term verbal memory. Memory and Cognition,17:398-442
    86.Wilding,E.L.,Doyle,M.C.,& Rugg,M.D.(1995).Recognition memory with and without retrieval of context:an event-related potential study.Neuropsychologia, 33(6):734-764
    87.罗跃嘉,魏景汉,翁旭初,卫星.(2002).汉字视听再认的ERP效应与记忆提取脑机制.心理学报,33(6):489-494
    88.Kayser,J.F.,Regan,T.,Craig,E.B., & Gerard,E-(2003).Event-related brain potentials during auditory and visual word recognition memory tasks. Cognitive Brain Research, 16(1):11-25
    89.Ghetti,S.,Qin,J., & Goodman,G.(2002).False memories in children and adults: Age,distinctiveness and subjective experience.Developmental Psycholoy,38:705-718
    90.Jeffrey,S. A., Matthew, G. R. (2008)Examining Differences in the Levels of False Memories in Children and Adults Using Child-Normed Lists.Developmental Psychology,44(3):889-894
    91.安静.小学高年级儿童词汇学习过程中的错误记忆研究.吉林大学硕士学位论文,2010
    92.刘丽敏.儿童错误记忆发展趋势.哈尔滨师范大学硕士论文.2011
    93.吕晓萍.注意状态和预警对儿童错误记忆的影响.浙江师范大学硕士学位论文,2012
    94. Mark, L. H., Marina,C. W., & Katrina, B.(2009). The role of associative strength in children's false memory illusions. MEMORY,17 (1),8-16
    95.Carmichael,L.,Hogan,H.P., & Walter,A.A.(1932).An experimental study of the effect of language on the reproduction of visual perceived form.Journal of Experimental Psychology,15:73-86
    96.周楚.错误记忆的理论与实践.华东师范大学博士学位论文,2005
    97.刘四英.时间因素影响错误记忆的实验研究.安徽师范大学硕士学位论文,2010
    98.Yana Fandakova, Yee Lee Shing, and Ulman Lindenberger. Differences in Binding and Monitoring Mechanisms Contribute to Lifespan Age Differences in False Memory. Developmental Psychology, Online First Publication, December 31,2012
    99.Intraub H, Hoffman JE. Reading and visual memory:remembering scenes that were never seen. American Journal of Psychology,1992,105:101-114
    100.Johnson MK, Foley MA., Leach K. The consequences for memory of imagining in another person's voice. Memory & Cognition,1988,16:337-342
    101.Johnson MK, Hashtroudi S. Lindsay DS, Source monitoring. Psychological Bulletin,1993,114:3-28
    102.Johnson MK, Raye CL, Wang AY, Taylor TH. Fact and fantasy:the roles of accuracy andvariability in confusing imaginations with perceptual experiences. Journal of Experimental Psychology:Human Learning&Memory,1979,5:229-240
    103.Krista D Forrest, Theresa A Wadkins, and Richard L, Miller, The Role of Preexisting Stress on False Confessions:An Empirical Study, The Journal of Credibility Assessment and Witness Psychology,2002,3:23-45
    104.周楚.强大的错误记忆效应:词表呈现时间与呈现方式的影响.心理科 学,2007,30(1):23-28

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700