系统性风险的来源、预警机制与监管策略
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
近三十年来,全球经济体系发展的一个重要特征是虚拟经济的发展速度和规模远大于实体经济。在虚拟经济与实体经济的关系上,国内外学术界过去的研究多重视虚拟经济的发展越来越背离实体经济的发展,如国际货币市场的交易额远大于国际贸易额的规模,有些经济学家甚至认为这种“倒金字塔”型的经济、金融体系有系统性崩溃的可能性。总之随着虚拟经济的快速发展,市场波动和系统性风险导致发展中国家和发达国家频繁发生的金融危机,对实际经济产生了负面冲击,而且在世界范围内导致了经济增长和就业水平的普遍下降,因此各国和一些国际组织开始对系统性风险的控制表现出担心和重视。
     遗憾的是,经济学家对系统性风险的原因和本质的认识并不统一,很难为系统性风险下一个十分清晰的定义。既有研究文献中,一般认为“系统性”一方面是指一个事件影响了整个体系的功能,另一方面是指一个事件让不相干的第三方也承担了一定的成本;“系统性风险”则是指一个事件在一连串的机构和市场构成的系统中引起一系列连续损失的可能性。因此系统性风险是一种“外部性”,是单个机构强加于全社会的高于其实际价值的成本,风险的溢出和传染是系统性的风险发生时最为典型的特征,而且系统性风险的这一特征不仅仅局限于一国的经济、金融领域。尤其是上世纪80年代以来,全球经济一体化和金融全球化的趋势使各国经济极易受到国际经济环境变化的冲击;股票市场、外汇市场价格联动的特征则使金融系统性风险的连锁反应速度加快;现代通讯技术及金融交易的高科技程度也为信息的传播及风险的溢出创造了条件,某个市场的动荡结果会通过计算机网络体系迅速得到蔓延,影响到世界其他地区的经济和金融局势。
     本文以系统性风险研究为切入点,全面梳理系统性风险的来源、预警和监管,本文中与系统性风险相对应的“系统”主体对象是以整个金融机构(或者整个虚拟经济部门)为对象,但分析的案例一般则回到小系统的概念,突出证券市场的主体被研究地位。
     文章的创新逻辑就是想以虚拟经济理论为背景结合国内外金融系统(主要是证券市场)发展的经验及现状,突出分析在虚拟经济日渐成为经济活动主体的情况下,主要是虚拟经济日渐膨胀使得影响系统性风险的因素更多和更加复杂,我们究竟该如何对整个整体金融这个大系统以及证券市场这个小系统的系统性风险来源、预警和监管进行认识。如果说在虚拟经济不发达的情况下,某些资产价格波动、市场波动没有能力引起全盘金融体系波动的情况下,那么当现代经济步入虚拟经济时代,虚拟经济已经基本独立于实体经济发展的形势下,日益独立运行化运行,此时一些金融市场乃至资产价格的微小波动就成为不断冲击整体市场的独立波动源,成为系统性风险的导火索。本文第一部分就既有理论对系统性风险的界定、传染机制、危害等方面进行了必要的介绍,在此基础上阐述了本文的基本研究逻辑、框架和创新点;接下来本文第二部分和第三部分主要讨论了虚拟经济的蓬勃发展对整体金融这个大系统以及证券市场这个小系统的影响,主要分析了虚拟经济的发展导致的资产价格偏离其原有内在价值而表现出特有的波动,虽然这种偏离和波动是证券市场与生俱来的,但在经济虚拟化和金融自由化的大趋势下,这种偏离和波动不断被放大而更多地受到非理性因素的影响,导致证券市场的系统性风险和金融机构整体的系统性风险不断加强。文章指出当前我国证券市场系统性风险主要源于政策干预频繁、信息不对称严重、投资者在证券市场上的行为具有较明显的羊群效应等。在这个部分,笔者还对证券市场系统性风险的测度问题以及中美证券市场在金融危机期间的系统性风险相互传递的关系进行了实证分析;第四部分就整个系统性风险的预警机制、指标体系等问题进行了详细研究,总结了已有系统性风险预警指标体系中存在的问题——仅仅关注存量和净流量的指标,损失了很多信息,从理论逻辑上设计了一个涵盖全部机构部门的资金流量矩阵表来对系统性风险进行预警的系统;第五部分和第六部分就系统性风险的监管笔者提出了一些看法,对中国金融市场的系统性风险管理进行小结并提出思考,认为从总体上来监管系统性风险应该采用宏观审慎监管的策略。
     本文的创新点主要为以下三个方面:第一,文章对系统性风险的界定、内涵和传染机制的已有研究进行了全面梳理和分析,解决了以前研究比较散乱的问题,首次提出了基于虚拟资产价格波动解释系统性风险来源的分析框架并具体阐述了经济虚拟化对整体金融系统和证券市场系统性风险的影响机制;第二,文章指出在经济虚拟化的大趋势下证券市场价格偏离基本面和波动幅度不断加大,导致证券市场的系统性风险不断加强,实证研究了中美两国在金融危机之间的风险波动溢出效应,发现两国证券市场不存在系统性风险的传递关系;第三,文章全面梳理了系统性风险预警指标体系,指出了现有系统性风险预警指标最大问题在于它所基于的分析方法都是采用净流量与存量的概念,大量的有用信息都因此被忽略了,尤其用这种方法来分析金融市场的不稳定性,监测系统性风险时更是如此,进而文章从理论逻辑上创新设计出了一个涵盖全部机构部门的资金流量矩阵表系统性风险预警体系,进而文章在预警指标基础上细致分析和总结了系统性风险的监管策略——宏观审慎监管的内涵。
In the past three decades, an important feature the development of the global system is the situation that the speed and scale of fictitious economy is much greater than that of the real economy. In the research of the relationship of fictitious economy and real economy, the domestic and international academic paid more attention to the problem that the development of the fictitious economy is more and more deviated from the entities, such as the scale of the turnover of the international currency market is much larger than that of international trade, some economist even think it is possible that this "inverted pyramid" type of economy and financial system may collapse. In short, with rapid development of fictitious economy, market fluctuation and systematic risk led to frequent financial crisis in developing and developed countries, a negative impact to the real economy, and a worldwide general decline in the growth of economy and employment levels, so countries and international organizations had began to show some concern and attention on the control of the systematic risk.
     Unfortunately, the understanding of economists on the causes and nature of systematic risk is not uniform. It is difficult to give a very clear definition for systematic risk. The general view of "systematic" of the existing literature on one hand refers to the situation that an event affects the function of the whole system, on the other hand refers to that an event makes the unrelated third party bear a certain cost; "systematic risk" refers to the probability of the a series of consecutive losses which will be made by an event in the system composed by a series of institutions and markets. Systematic risk is therefore a kind of "externality", is the cost over the actual value that imposed on the whole society by a single sector, the overflow and transmission of risk is the most typical feature when the systematic risk occurs, and this feature of systematic risk is not limited to the economic and financial field of only one country. Especially since the 80s of last century, the tendency of global economic integration and financial globalization makes economy of the countries vulnerable to the impact of changes of the international economic environment; the price linkage mechanism in the stock market and the foreign exchange market led to faster response to the financial systematic risk; modern communication technology and the high technology degree of financial transactions create the conditions for the spread of the information and the overflow of the risk, the results of the turbulence of one market will be spread rapidly through the computer network system and affect economic and financial situation of other parts of the world.
     In this paper, I use the research of the systematic risk as the breakthrough point, card the source, early warning and monitoring of systematic risk. The agent object of the "system" in this article is the whole financial institution (or the fictitious economy as an object), however, when we analysis the case we return to the concept of small systems, to highlight the status of the security market to be studied.
     The innovation logic of this article is that I want to research how should we recognize the source, early warning and monitoring of systematic risk of the big system-the whole financial institution and the small system-the security market, in the situation thafictitious economy is becoming the main economic activity, mainly that the expansion of fictitious economy make factors that affect the systematic risk more complicated, in the background of the fictitious financial theories, with the development experience and current situation at home and abroad financial system (mainly the stock market). The fluctuation of some assets and the market has no ability to cause fluctuations in the whole financial system in the case of undeveloped fictitious economy, but when the modern economy steps into fictitious economy and fictitious economy has basically been independent of the development of the real economy, some small fluctuations of financial market and even the price of some asset are becoming the constant independent source of the fluctuation of the whole market, as the fuse of systematic risk. In the first segment of this article I gave some necessary introduction of the definition of systematic risk, transmission mechanism and the hazard, etc. of the existing theories, and elaborated the logic, frame and innovation of this article on this basis; then in the second part of this article and the third part I focused on the effect of the rapid development of fictitious economy on the big system-overall financial institution and the small system-the security market, mainly analyzing the fluctuations caused by assets prices deviating from their original value because of the development of the fictitious economy. Although this deviation and the fluctuation of the security market is inherent, the situation that the deviation and the fluctuation has been enlarged and affected by more Irrational factors made the systematic risk of the security market and the financial institution constantly be strengthened in the tendency of fictitiousization of economy and financial liberalization. This article points out that the current systematic risk in China's security market mainly dues to the frequent policy interventions, information asymmetry, the obvious herding behavior of the investors in the security market and so on. In this section I also made empirical analysis of the measure of systematic risk of the security market and the systematic risk transfer relationship between China' security market and U.S. security market during the financial crisis; in the fourth part I studied the entire early warning system, index system and other issues of the whole systematic risk in detail, summed up the problem of the early warning system of the existing index system——just paying attention to index of the stock and net flows, lost a lot of information, I designed a flow of funds matrix which covered all institutions from a theoretical logic to represent the system of early warning; In the Part V and Part VI I put forward some views on the regulation of systematic risk, gave a summary of the China's financial market systematic risk management and put forward some thoughts that we should adopt macro-prudential supervision strategies from the overall supervision of systematic risk.
     The innovation of this paper is mainly the following three aspects:first, this article gave the definition of systematic risk, sorted and analyzed the content and transmission mechanism of the existing study, solved the scattered problem of the past research, and for the first time concretely analyzed the effects on the whole financial institution system and the security market system of the fictitiousization of economy; Second, the article pointed out that in the major trend of the fictitiousization of economy, the security market price's deviation from fundamentals and the fluctuation continued to increase, led the systematic risk of the security market to be strengthened constantly, gave the empirical study of the fluctuation and overflow effects between China and U.S. in financial crisis, and found that there was no systematic risk transfer relationship between the security markets of the two countries; third, the article sort of the early warning index system of the systematic risk, pointed out that the biggest problem of the existing early warning index of systematic risk is that it is based on analysis using the concept of net flow and stock, a lot of useful information are therefore neglected, especially when this method is used to analyze financial market stability and monitor systematic risk. Thus, this article designed a flow of funds matrix which covered all institutions from a theoretical logic to represent the system of early warning, and then on the basis of early warning index analyzed and summarized content of the regulatory strategy of the systematic risk-the of macro prudential supervision in detail.
引文
1. 普拉萨德,罗高夫,魏尚进,柯赛.金融全球化对发展中国家的影响:实证研究结果.中国金融出版社,国际货币基金组织,2004.
    2. 谢平,陆磊.金融腐败:非规范融资行为的交易特征和体制动因.经济研究,2003.06.
    3. 李扬,余维彬.人民币汇率制度改革:回归有管理的浮动.经济研究,2005.08.
    4. 江小娟.中国对外开放进入新阶段:更均衡合理地融入全球市场.经济研究,2006.03.
    5. 夏斌,陈道富.国际货币体系失衡下的中国汇率政策.经济研究,2006.02.
    6. 姜波克.均衡汇率理论和政策的新框架.中国社会科学,2006.01.
    7. 阎坤,陈新平.我国当代金融风险财政化问题及对策.管理世界,2005.01.
    8. 黄达.人民币的风云际会:挑战与机遇.经济研究,2004.07.
    9. 黄达.论人民币完全可兑换及其经济地位.国际金融研究,2004.07.
    10.黄达.面对经济全球化的中国金融改革.中国行政管理,1999.11.
    11.刘鸿儒.金融业发展问题需要深入思考与研究.银行家,2006.11.
    12.宋逢明.对金融风险管理的几点认识.国际金融研究,2001.12.
    13.赵锡军,许容.B股市场当前存在的问题及未来可能的发展方向.国际金融研究,2000.08.
    14.贺强,祁敬宇,王翠琳.我国金融开放进程与金融监管的国内外协调.价格理论与实践,2006.10.
    15.贺强.对我国《证券投资基金法》出台的几点思考.中国金融,2003.22.
    16.董安生,潘李美.资本市场的培育与规则完善.中国金融,2004.07.
    17.董安生,温烨.我国B股市场开放的证券交易法制基础.证券市场导报,2004.03.
    18.平新乔,李自然.上市公司再融资资格的确定与虚假信息披露.经济研究,2003.02.
    19.朱武祥.储蓄资金如何进入资本市场.银行家,2002.05.
    20.周春生,杨云红,王亚平.中国股票市场交易型的价格操纵研究.经济研究,2005.10.
    21.周春生.金融监管与企业投资股市.税收与企业,2003.03.
    22.刘纪鹏.中国股市需要休养生息.改革与理论,2002.11.
    23.林义相.切断股市风险社会化的渠道.中国改革,2005.06.
    24.胡祖六.关于中国引进外资的三大问题.国际经济评论,2004.02.
    25.胡祖六,金荦.入世:中国开放资本项目的催化剂.国际经济评论,2001.04.
    26.焦瑾璞.加入WTO与中国银行业的改革和发展.中国金融,2000.01.
    27.焦瑾璞.激发商业银行的竞争力必须进行制度创新.中国金融,2003.07.
    28.詹向阳,张兴胜.巴塞尔新资本协议草案与国有商业银行风险管理,2001.07.
    29.梅君.保险资金入市带来资本市场新格局.中国金融,2004.22.
    30.梅君.谁为失去诚信“买单”——主承销商在证券发行中的法律责任分析.中国审计,2003.21.
    31.梅君.股市第一案的罪与罚——从“中科创业操纵证券交易价格案”看我国证券法律责任制度.中国审计,2003.12.
    32.祁斌,王雪松.完善QFII制度是发展资本市场的有力举措.中国金融,2006.21.
    33.曹凤歧.中国金融业的发展与监管策略.福建论坛(经济社会版),2000.07.
    34.江曙霞.银行监督管理与资本充足性管制.中国发展出版社,1994.
    35.许成刚.法律、执法与金融监管.经济社会体制比较,2001.05.
    36.贺力平,张艳花.资本外逃损害经济增长吗?经济研究,2004.12.
    37.黄金老.金融自由化与金融脆弱性.中国金融出版社,2001.
    38.刘锡良等.中国经济转轨时期金融安全问题研究.中国金融出版社,2004.
    39.孙立坚等.金融体系的脆弱性不会影响经济增长吗?——来自对中国案例实证分析的答案,复旦大学金融研究院,网址:http://www.ifsfd.org/focus/more.asp?id=26,2005-10-12.
    40.洪飞,李子奈.资本流动与货币危机.清华大学中国经济研究中心学术论文,2001.
    41.伍志文.金融脆弱性:理论及基于中国的经验分析.经济评论,2003.01.
    42.沈中华,谢孟芬.事件风险:以货币危机及银行危机为例.企银季刊,1999.03.
    43.欧文·伊文斯.金融体系稳健性的宏观审慎指标.中国金融出版社,2001.
    44.禄正平.金融开放与资本监管.国际融资,2007.03.
    45.周道许.现代金融监管体制研究.中国金融出版社,1999.
    46.刘建新.全球金融监管趋势.国际融资,2007.03.
    47.刘宇飞.国际金融监管的新发展.经济科学出版社,1999.
    48.凡国君.“虚拟交易”:又一个金融监管战场.第一财经日报,2007-01-16.
    49.伊特韦尔[英],泰勒[美].成永军,邓薇译.全球金融风险监管.经济科学出版社,2001.
    50.雍瑞祥.金融创新与金融监管.社科纵横,2007.02.
    51.王自力.我国金融监管体系与临管模式的重新探讨.金融研究,2000.12.
    52.李德.金融监管失灵与监管体制问题分析.金融研究,2001.07.
    53.戴相龙,关于金融全球化问题,金融研究,1999年第1期
    54.尹龙.金融创新理论的发展与金融监管体制演进.金融研究,2005.03.
    55.鹿小楠.混业经营下金融监管体制发展趋势与选择.商业时代,2007.02.
    56.李宝伟.经济虚拟化与政府对金融市场的干预.南开大学出版社,2005.
    57.范小云.繁荣的背后——金融系统性风险的本质、测度与管理.金融出版社,2006.
    58.戴国强.论我国货币市场发展的目标及途径.经济研究,2004.05.
    59.谢多.中国货币市场发展的分析.经济研究,2004.09.
    60.卜永祥,秦宛顺.关税、货币政策与中国实际汇率.经济研究,2002.05.
    61.陈平,王曦.人民币汇率的非均衡分析与汇率制度的宏观效率.经济研究,2002.06.
    62.林伯强.人民币均衡实际汇率的估计与实际汇率错位的测算.经济研究,2002.12.
    63.范小云,2002,行为与新兴市场的货币危机传染,南开经济研究,2002年第5期
    64.范小云,2001,投机性货币冲击的传导与扩散机制,南开经济研究,2001年1期
    65. Chung-Hua, Shen; Meng-Fen, Hsieh. Capital Inflows and Banking Vulnerability-Across-ountry Comparison. Journal of Financial Studies, Vol.8 No.3, December 2000(1-40).
    66. Cypher James M. Mexico:financial fragility or structural crisis? Joumal of Economics Issues, Jun, Vol.30.451-460,1996.
    67. David M. Jones. Fed Policy, Financial Market Efficiency, and Capital Flows. The Journal of Finance, Vol.54, No.4.
    68. Dellas, Harris and Martin K. Hess. Financial Development and the Sensitivity of Stock Markets to External Influences. Review of International Economics,Vol.10,No.3(August),pp.525-38,2002.
    69. Demirguc-Kunt and Detragiache. Financial Liberalization and Financial Fragility, IMF Working Paper 98/83,1998. Demirguc-Kunt and Detragiache. The Determinants of Banking Crises in Developing and Developed Countries. IMF Staff Paper, Vol.45, No.1,81-109,1998.
    70. Detragiache, Enrica. Bank Fragility and International Capital Mobility. IMF Working Paper 99/113,1999.
    71. Detragiache, Enrica and Spilimbergo,Antonio. Crisis and Liquidity-Evidence and Interpretation, IMF Working Papers 01/2 (IMF),2001.
    72. Diamond Dougias W. and P.H.Dybvigr. Banking Runs, Deposit Insurance and Liquidity. Journal of Political Economy,Vol91:401-419,1983.
    73. Diamond Douglas W.and Raghuram G. Rajan. Liquidity risk, liquidity creation, and financial fragility:A theory of banking. Journal of Political Economy, Vol.109:287-327,2001.
    74. Dirk Krueger; Felix Kubler. Intergenerational Risk-Sharing via Social Security When Financial Markets Are Incomplete. The American Economic Review, Vol.92, No.2.
    75. Douglas W. Diamond. Liquidity, Banks, and Markets. The Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 105, No.5. Oct.,1997.
    76. Edward J. Kane. Interaction of Financial and Regulatory Innovation. The American Economic Review, Vol.78.
    77. Franco Modigliani; Enrico Perotti. Protection of Minority Interest and the Development of Security Markets. Managerial and Decision Economics, Vol.18.
    78. Frederic S. Mishkin. Global Financial Instability:Framework, Events, Issues. The Journal of Economic Perspectives, Vol.13, No.4.Autumn,1999.
    79. Fred H. Klopstock. The International Money Market:Structure, Scope and Instruments. The Journal of Finance, Vol.20, No.2.
    80. Friedman M.and Schwartz.A.J. Has the government any role in money? Journal of Monetary Economics,Vol17:37-62,1986.
    81. Geoffrey Garrett. Global Markets and National Politics:Collision Course or Virtuous Circle? International Organization, Vol.52.
    82. Giulio Pontecorvo. The Stock Exchange:its Role at Various Stages of Capitalist Development. The Journal of Finance, Vol.13, No.4, Dec.,1958.
    83. Gonalez-Hermosllo, Pazarbasioglu and Billings. Determinants of Banking System Fragility: A case Study of Mexico. IMF Staff Papers Vol.44, No.3,295-314,1997
    84. Grossman S.J and Joseph E.Stiglitz. Information and Competitive Price System. American Economic Review,66(2):3246-253,1976.
    85. Guillermo A. Calvo; Enrique G. Mendoza. "Capital-Markets Crises and Economic Collapse in Emerging Markets:An Informational-Frictions Approach". The American Economic Review, Vol.90.
    86. Guillermo A. Calvo; Jacob A. Frenkel. "Credit Markets, Credibility, and Economic Transformation". The Journal of Economic Perspectives, Vol.5, No.4,1991.
    87. Hardy, C. Daniel, and Ceyla Parbasiouglu. Leading Indicators of Banking Crises:Was Asia Different? IMF Working Paper WP/98/91,1998
    88. Henry,Peter. Stock Market Liberalization, Economic Reform, and Emerging Market Equity Prices, Journal of Finance, Vol.55(April), pp.529-64,2000.
    89. Hirokazu Miyazaki. "Economy of Dreams:Hope in Global Capitalism and Its Critiques" Cultural Anthropology, Vol.21.
    90. Ishii et.al. Capital Account Liberalization and Financial Sector Stability. IMF Occasional Paper No.211,IMF,2002.
    91. James C. Van Home. "Financial Innovations and Excesses". The Journal of Finance, Vol.40, No.3.
    92. John G. Gurley; E. S. Shaw. "Financial Structure and Economic Development".Economic Development and Cultural Change, Vol.15.
    93. Kaminsky, G., S. and Reinart. The Twin Crises:The Causes of Banking and Balance of Payments Problems. American Economic Review, Vol.89, No.3,473-500,1999
    94. Kane E..I. "Impact of Regulation on economic behavior". Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, Vol.9:355-367,1981.
    95. Kane E.J. "Technological and regulatory forces in the developing fusion of financial services competition". Ohio State University,1984.
    96. Kane E.J. "A Market perspective on financial regulation". CATO,Vol.13:333-338,1994.
    97. Kareken John and Wallace Neil. "Deposit insurance and bank regulation:a partial equilibrium exposition". Journal of Business,Vol.51:413-38,1983.
    98. Kaufman George G. " Bank failures, risk and bank regulation". CATO Journal, Spring/Summer, Vol.16:17-46,1996.
    99. Kose, Eswar S. Prasad and Marco E. Terrones. Financial Integration and Macroeconomic Volatility, Staff Papers, IMF,2003.
    100. Kregel J.A. "Margins of safety and weight of the argument in generating financial fragility" Journal of Economic Issues, Vol.31:543-548 Jun,1997.
    101. Mathew Shane. "Capital Markets and the Process of Economic Growth". The Journal of Finance, Vol.25, No.4. Sep.1970.
    102. Meade J.E. "The theory of economic externalities". Geneve,P15,1973.
    103. Melike Altikemer. Capital Inflows and Central Bank's Policy Response. The Central Bank of Republic of Turkey Research Department, December 1998.
    104. Meltzer A.H. "Margins in the regulation of financial institutions". The Journal of Political Economy, Vol.75:482-511,1967.
    105. Minsky,Hyman P. "The financial instability Hypothesis:Capitalist processes and the behavior of the economy "in financial crises:theory,history, and policy, edited by charles p.kindle berger and Jean-PierreLaffargue. Cambridge University press,1982.
    106. Neil Fligstein. "Markets as Politics:A Political-Cultural Approach to Market Institutions" American Sociological Review, Vol.61, No.4. Aug.,1996. Patrick J. Kehoe. "On the Roles of International Financial Markets and Their Relevance for Economic Policy:Comment". Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, Vol.20, No.3.
    107. Peter Dombrowski. "Haute Finance and High Theory:Recent Scholarship on Global Financial Relations". Mershon International Studies Review, Vol.42, No.1. May,1998.
    108. Philip Arestis; Panicos Demetriades. "Financial Development and Economic Growth: Assessing the Evidence". The Economic Journal, Vol.107, No.442., May,1997.
    109. Qinglai Meng and Andres Velasco. Can Capital Mobility be Destabilizing? NBER Working Paper 7263, July 1999.
    110. R. J. Bromley; Richard Symanski; Charles M. Good. "The Rationale of Periodic Markets" Annals of the Association of American Geographers, Vol.65,2000.
    111. Robert Heinkel. "Discussion:Sorting Equilibria in Financial Markets:The Incentive Problem ". The Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, Vol.16, No.4,2001.
    112. Robert L. Perry; John D. Robertson. "Political Markets, Bond Markets, and the Effects of Uncertainty:A Cross-National Analysis ". International Studies Quarterly, Vol.42, No.1, Mar., 1998.
    113. Robert Van Order. "A Model of Financial Structure and Financial Fragility". The Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, Vol.38,, Apr.,2006.
    114. Ross Levine. "Stock Markets, Growth, and Tax Policy". The Journal of Finance, Vol.46, Sep.,1991.
    115. Sena Eken. "Integration of Domestic and International Financial Markets:The Japanese Experience". Staff Papers-International Monetary Fund, Vol.31, Sep.,1984.
    116. Sol Picciotto; Jason Haines. "Regulating Global Financial Markets". Journal of Law and Society, Vol.26, No.3, Sep.,1999.
    117. Spierings Rence. " Reflection on the regulation of financial intermediaries" Kyklos,Vol.43:91-110,1990.
    118. Stefan H. Robock. "Overseas Financing for U.S. International Business". The Journal of Finance, Vol.21,1992.
    119. Stephen A. Ross. "Informational Asymmetries, Financial Structure, and Financial Intermediation:Discussion".The Journal of Finance, Vol.32, No.2,1967.
    120. Stigler G.J. "The Theory of Economic Regulation". he Bell Journal of Economic and Management Science, Vol.2:3-21,1971.
    121. Stiglitz J.E. "the role of the state in financial markets". Proceedings of the world bank annual conference on development economics,19-52,1993.
    122. Stiglitz J.E. and Andrew Weiss. "Credit Rationing in Market With Imperfect Information" American Economics Review,73(3):393-410,1981.
    123. Stulz,Rene, nternational Portfolio Flows and Security Markets, International Capital Flows, NBER Conference Report Series,pp.257-93,1999.
    124. Stulz,Rene. Globalization of Equity Markets and The Cost of Capital, NBER Working Paper 7021, March,1999.
    125. Sudhir Wanmali. "The Regulated and Periodic Markets and Rural Development in India".Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series, Vol.5,2004.
    126. Timothy J. Kehoe. "Comment on Dollarization and the Integration of Interna-tional Capital Markets".Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, Vol.33, No.2,2003.
    127. Varian Hal R. "Intermediate Microeconomics:A modern Approach", W. W. Norton & Company,1996.
    128. Viral V. Acharya and Alberto Bisin. "Optimal Financial-Market Integration and Security Design ", The Journal of Business, Vol.78,2005.
    129. W. Gary Simpson; Timothy C. Ireland. "The Impact of Financial Futures on the Cash Market for Treasury Bills", The Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, Vol.20,1965.
    130. William Leo Silber, "Monetary Policy, Debt Management and Capital Allocation:The Implications of Behavior in the Financial Sector and Substitutability Between Securities".The Journal of Finance, Vol.22, No.4.,1967.
    131. William L. Silber. "The Process of Financial Innovation".The American Economic Review, Vol.73,2005.
    132. Benston, George and George Kaufman.1995. "Is the Banking Payments System Fragile?" Journal of Financial Services Research, December
    133.Calvo, G., (1998),'Capital Market Contagion and Recession:An Explanation of the Russian Virus', University of Mariland working paper.
    134. Calomiris, Charles.1999. "Runs on Banks and Lessons of the Great Depression." Regulation.22:1:4-7
    135. Calomiris, Charles and Gary Gorton.1991. "The Origins of Banking Panics:Models, Facts, and Bank Regulation" in R. Glenn Hubbard, ed., Financial Markets and Financial Crises, Chicago:University of Chicago Press
    136. Calomiris, Charles and Joseph Mason.1997. "Contagion and Bank Failures During The Great Depression:The June 1932 Chicago Banking Panic." American Economic Review. December
    137. Corrigan, Gerald.1987. "Financial Market Structure:A Longer View," in Federal Reserve Bank of New York Annual Report.
    138. Crockett, Andrew.1997. "Why is Financial Stability a Goal of Public Policy?" in Maintaining Financial Stability in a Global Economy. Kansas City, Mo.:Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City.
    139. Davis, Philip.1995. Debt, Financial Fragility, and Systemic Risk. Oxford:Oxford University Press.
    140. Eisenbeis, Robert.1995. "Private Sector Solutions to Payments System Fragility." Journal of Financial Services Research, December.
    141. Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation.1998. Managing the Crisis:The FDIC and RTC Experience,1980-1990, Washington, D.C.
    142. George, E.A.J.1998. The New Lady of Threadneedle Street, " Governor's Speech, Bank of England, London, February 24.
    143. Gupta, Atul and L. Misra.1999. "Failure and Failure Resolution in the U.S. Thrift and Banking Industries." Financial Management 28:4.
    144. Hancock, Diana, James Wilcox and David Humphrey.1996. "Intraday Management of Bank Reserves." Journal of Money, Credit and Banking.28:4.
    145. Institute of International Finance, Inc.,1998, "Capital Flows to Emerging Market Economies", report
    146. Jones, David and Kathleen King.1995. "The Implementation of Prompt Corrective Action: An Assessment." Journal of Banking and Finance.19:3-4.
    147. Jordan, John, Joe Peek and Eric Rosengren.2000. "The Market Reaction to the Disclosure of Supervisory Actions:Implications for Bank Transparency." Journal of Financial Intermediation, July.27
    148. John Eatwell and Lance Taylor (2000), "Global Finance at Risk:the case for international regulation", The New Press
    149. Kaminsky, G., Lyons, R. and Schmukler, S., (2001), Mutual Fund Investment in Emerging Markets:An overview, in Claessens, S and Forbes, K(Eds)'International Financial Contagion', Kluwer Academic Publishers.
    150. Kaufman, George.1999. "Central Banks, Assets Bubbles, and Financial Stability." In Mario Blejer and Marko Skreb, eds., Central Banks, Monetary Policies, and the Implications for Transition Economies. Boston:Kluwer.
    151. Kaufman, George G.,1999, " Banking and Currency Crises and Systemic Risk", Working Paper, Loyola University
    152. Kaufman, George.2000a. "Banking and Currency Crises and Systemic Risk:A Taxonomy and Review, "Financial Markets, Institutions and Instruments, May.
    153. Kaufman, George.2000b. "Banking and Currency Crises and Systemic Risk:Lessons From Recent Events." Economic Perspectives (Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago), Third Quarter.
    154. Kaufman, George and Steven Seelig.2000. "Treatment of Depositors at Failed Banks and the Severity of Bank Crises." Working Paper, Loyola University Chicago.28
    155. Kodres, L., and M. Pritsker, (1999),'A Rational Expectations Model of Financial Contagion', typescript, International Monetary Fund.
    156. McAndrews, James and Samira Rajan.2000. "The Timing and Funding of Fedwire Funds Transfers." Economic Policy Review (Federal Reserve Bank of New York), July.
    157. Mishkin, Frederic.1991. "Asymmetric Information and Financial Crises:A Historical Perspective, " in Financial Markets and Financial Crises, ed. R. Glenn Hubbard. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
    158. Mishkin, Frederic.1995. "Comment on Systemic Risk", in Research in Financial Services:Banking, Financial Markets, and Systemic Risk (Vol.7), ed. George Kaufman. Greenwich, CT:JAI Press.
    159. Wicker, Elmus.1996. The Banking Panics of the Great Depression. Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge Press.
    160. Zhou, Ruilin.2000. "Understanding Intraday Credit in Large-Value Payment Systems, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago Economic Perspectives.24:3,29.
    1 由于所采取的金融发展模式不同,法国、德国等一些欧洲国家以银行业为主,其资本市场与美国、日本相比要相对规模要小得多,但是在金融自由化以来证券业发展也很快,北欧国家也出现了股市危机。
    1 Jean Tirole,"Asset Bubbles and Overlapping Generations",Econometrica.Vol.53,No.6,Nov.1985,pp.1499-1528.
    1 rf为国外利率水平,f为本币的远期贴水。这表明股票价格与本币未来变化同方向变化,即股市与汇市同时上升,同时下跌。
    1 国内前一阵子为了严格规范经营,降低风险,三申五令地要求房地产开发商的自有资本率不低于30%,杠杆率相当于1:3.3;尽管现实中的房地产开发商的杠杆率常在1:10左右

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700