用户名: 密码: 验证码:
居民收入的分位数回归与反事实因素分解
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
本文基于CHNS调查数据,首先以城镇人均住户收入为例,对我国居民收入的分布形态、分位数的变化与收入差距进行了简单描述,认为我国居民收入分布存在明显的右偏“厚尾”现象,传统的关于收入正态分布假定或对数正态分布假定的方法受到质疑,而非参数核密度估计则被认为是一个比较适合的研究方法。实证研究表明,最近20年在不同的收入分位点呈现“分位点越高,增长趋势越快”的态势,反映出我国收入分配领域已经存在“穷者愈穷,富者愈富”的“马太效应”,居民收入差距在不断扩大。
     进一步,本文将非参数、半参数理论与分位数回归分析技术结合起来,应用到我国居民个人收入分布的研究中,顺次构建了均值线性回归模型、线性分位数回归模型、非参数分位数回归模型与半参数分位数回归模型,对比研究了适合我国居民收入分布数据的最佳模型,最终论证了性别、教育、城乡户籍对收入的参数影响和年龄、地区经济对收入的非参数影响,同时讨论了同一影响因素在收入不同分位点处影响作用及显著性呈现巨大差异的原因,全方位展示了性别、年龄、教育、地区经济和城乡户籍等因素对收入的影响结构及变化规律。
     本文最后在实证分析的另一方面,将反事实分析方法与传统的指数理论结合起来,分别在时间与截面两个维度上,运用分位数回归模型对居民收入的变化进行了因素分解研究,将居民收入的时间变化、性别差异与城乡差异分解为要素报酬效应、变量效应与残差效应,既分析了绝对收入效应的影响,又反映了各效应引起的相对收入变化,使居民收入在时间与截面两个维度的变化得到了较为透彻的分解,并得出了合理的分析结论。尤其是针对性别与城乡两个截面维度对收入进行分解时,成功地将代表女性因性别带来收入劣势和农民因户籍带来收入劣势的要素报酬效应从收入的性别差距与城乡差距中剥离出来,并分析了各种效应在不同的收入分位点对居民收入影响作用的差异。
     本文对我国居民收入差距的深度研究与收入分配政策导向具有一定的借鉴意义,同时对税收、社会保障以及各种民生制度的完善也能够提供一定的参考。
In this paper, based on the CHNS survey data, we describe the urban household per capita income distribution in China, and find that the income obeys a right-tailed distribution. It is difficult to choose a good parametric method to fit the distribution. Naturally, nonparametric kernel density estimation is a more appropriate one. Meanwhile, we give a description about the income quantile changes and income gap in brief, and consider that the gap is expanding ceaselessly due to the Matthew effect.
     Then, we combine the nonparametric and semi-parametric theory and quantile regression analysis to study on the individual income distribution, construct the least-square linear regression, the linear quantile regression, the nonparametric quantile regression, and the semi-parametric quantile regression one by one, disscuss the best model to fit the data in this paper, and conclude that the gender, education and the urban-rural household registration have a parametric influence on the income, while the age and the region economy give a nonparametric one. In terms of every single factor, the effects on the different income quantiles show a large divergence. The semi-parametric quantile regression analysis provides an all-round display of the income structure and its change rules caused by the factors mentioned above.
     Finally, in the empirical analysis based on the quantile regression, we employ the counterfactual analysis method with the traditional index theory together, to decompose the gap of the income distribution into several factors, not only on the time dimension, but on the cross-sectional one. We separate three effects from the income change, which are aroused by the coefficients, the covariates, and the residuals respectively. We get a relatively thorough decomposition of the income change and draw a rational conclusion. Especially, the decomposition conclusions on the two cross-sectional dimensions deserve to be mentioned. We successfully separate the gender discrimination and the rural discrimination from the income gender difference and urban-rural difference respectively, and take deep account about the different effects on the different income quantiles.
     These conclusions have certain significance in deep study on the income gap and the income allocation policy in China. Meanwhile, they also can provide certain reference to make decisions about the tax, social security and the people's livelihood system.
引文
[1]Roger Koenker, Quantile Regression, Cambridge University Press,2005
    [2]Piotr Lukasiewicz, Arkadiusz Orlowski,Probabilistic models of income distributions, Physica A 2004,344:146-151
    [3]Michael Newby, Adam Behr, Mitra Shojania Feizabadi, Investigating the distribution of personal income obtained from the recent U.S. data, Economic Modelling 2011,28:1170-1173
    [4]Emmanuel Flachaire,Olivier Nunez, Estimation of the income distribution and detection of subpopulations:An explanatory model, Computational Statistics & Data Analysis,2007,51:3368-3380
    [5]F. Clementi, M. Gallegati, Power law tails in the Italian personal income distribution, Physica A,2005,350:427-438
    [6]Andrea Vinh, William E. Griffiths, Duangkamon Chotikapanich, Bivariate income distributions for assessing inequality and poverty under dependent samples, Economic Modelling,2010,27:1473-1483
    [7]He Yuqing, Income distribution:Boltzmann analysis and its extension, Physica A,2007,377:230-240
    [8]F. Chami Figueira, N. J. Moura Jr., M. B. Ribeiro, The Gompertz-Pareto income distribution, Physica A,2011,390:689-698
    [9]Jens Bonke, Income distribution and financial satisfaction between spouses in Europe, The Journal of Socio-Economics,2008,37:2291-2303
    [10]Anand Banerjee, Victor M. Yakovenko, T. Di Matteo, A study of the personal income distribution in Australia, Phvsica A,2006,370:54-59
    [11]梁志军,北京市城镇贫困群体最低生活保障问题研究,中国知网:优秀硕士、博士论文文库,2007
    [12]迟巍、黎波、余秋梅,基于收入分布的收入差距扩大成因的分解,数量经济技术经济研究,2008,9:52-64
    [13]罗娟娟,农民收入分布函数的探讨,保险职业学院学报,2007,1:70-74
    [14]阮敬,亲贫困增长理论与测度方法研究,中国知网:优秀硕士、博士论文文库,2008
    [15]夏鹏,基于基尼系数的收入分布格局研究,中国知网:优秀硕士、博士论文文库2008
    [16]陈云,居民收入分布及其变迁的统计研究——基于现代非参数方法的拓展与创新,中国知网:优秀硕士、博士论文文库,2009
    [17]胡学锋,王鹤,基于密度函数核估计法的城乡居民收入差距分析,统计与决策2009,9:89-91
    [18]陈立中,中国城镇居民收入分布演进特征—基于非参数Kernel密度估计方法和省域区域视角,财贸研究,2010,6:8-13
    [19]陈娟,我国城镇贫困变动及影响因素研究—基于收入分布拟合及分解模型研究,数学的实践与认识,2010,10:68-75
    [20]张纯记,中国省际区域收入趋同实证研究,财经论丛,2011,3:9-13
    [21]纪宏,陈云,我国中等收入者比重及其变动的测度研究,经济学动态,2009,6:11-16
    [22]林坚,杨奇明,中国农村地区收入分布的趋同及其演化,浙江大学学报(人文社会科学版),2010,5:1-13
    [23]Roger Koenker, Quantileregression for longitudinaldata, Journal of Multivariate Analysis,2004,91:74-89
    [24]Taisuke Otsu, Conditional empirical likelihood estimation and inference for quantile regression models, Journal of Econometrics,2008,142:508-538
    [25]Keming Yu, Julian Stander, Bayesian analysis of a Tobit quantile regression model, Journal of Econometrics,2007,137:260-276
    [26]Paul Thompsona, Yuzhi Cai, Rana Moyeeda, Dominic Reeveb, Julian Stander, Bayesian nonparametric quantile regression using splines, Computational Statistics and Data Analysis,2010,54:1138-1150
    [27]Carlos Martins-Filho, Feng Yao, A smooth nonparametric conditional quantile frontier estimator, Journal of Econometrics,2008,143:317-333
    [28]Rahim Alhamzawi, Keming Yu, Conjugate priors and variable selection for Bayesian quantile regression, Computational Statistics and Data Analysis, 2012,1:1-11
    [29]Yu Ryan Yue, Havard Rue, Bayesian inference for additive mixed quantile regression models, Computational Statistics and Data Analysis,2011,55: 84-96
    [30]Ngai HangChan, Rong-MaoZhang, Quantile inference for heteroscedastic regression models, Journal of Statistical Planning and Inference 2011,141: 2079-2090
    [31]Weihua Zhou, A weighted quantile regression for randomly truncated data, Computational Statistics and Data Analysis,2011,55:554-566
    [32]James W. Taylor, Forecasting daily supermarket sales using exponentially weighted quantile regression, European Journal of Operational Research,2007,178:154-167
    [33]Tracy Z. Wu, Keming Yu, Yan Yu, Single-index quantile regression, Journal of Multivariate Analysis,2010,101:1607-1621
    [34]Rong Jiang, Zhan-Gong Zhou, Wei-Min Qian, Wen-Qiong Shao, Single-index composite quantile regression, Journal of the Korean Statistical Society, 2011,17:1-10
    [35]Toshio Honda, Quantile regression in varying coefficient models, Journal of Statistical Planning and Inference,2004,121:113-125
    [36]Joel L. Horowitz, Sokbae Lee, Testing a parametric quantile-regression model with an endogenous explanatory variable against a nonparametric alternative, Journal of Econometrics,2009,152:141-152
    [37]Lin-An Chen, Lanh Tat Tran, Li-Ching Lin, Symmetric regression quantile and its application to robust estimation for the nonlinear regression model, Journal of Statistical Planning and Inference,2004,126:423-440
    [38]Lan Wang, A simple nonparametric test for diagnosing nonlinearity in Tobit median regression model, Statistics & Probability Letters,2007,77: 1034-1042
    [39]Lingjie Ma, Roger Koenker, Quantile regression methods for recursive structural equation models, Journal of Econometrics,2006,134:471-506
    [40]Matthew Harding, Carlos Lamarche, A quantile regression approach for estimating panel data models using instrumental variables, Economics Letters,2009,104:133-135
    [41]Rati Ram, Parametric variability in cross-country growth regressions:An application of quantile-regression methodology, Economics Letters,2008, 99:387-389
    [42]Andrey A. Kudryavtsev, Using quantile regression for rate-making, Insurance:Mathematics and Economics,2009,45:296-304
    [43]ThomasC. Chiang, Jiandong Li, Lin Tan, Empirical investigation of herding behavior in Chinese stock markets:Evidence from quantile regression analysis, Global Finance Journal,2010,21:111-124
    [44]Chien-Liang Chen, Chung-Ming Kuan, Chu-Chia Lin, Saving and housing of Taiwanese households:New evidence from quantile regression analyses, Journal of Housing Economics,2007,16:102-126
    [45]Victor Chernozhukov, Christian Hansen, Michael Jansson, Finite sample inference for quantile regression models, Journal of Econometrics,2009, 152:93-103
    [46]Paul Hewson, Quantile regression provides a fuller analysis of speed data, Accident Analysis and Prevention,2008,40:502-510
    [47]Antonio F. Galvao Jr., Quantile regression for dynamic panel data with fixed effects, Journal of Econometrics,2011,173:1-16
    [48]Pedro S. Martins, Pedro T. Pereira,Does education reduce wage inequality —Quantile regression evidence from 16 countries,Labour Economics,2004, 11:355-371
    [49]SzeMan Tse, Composing the cumulative quantile regression function and the Goldie concentration curve, Journal of Multivariate Analysis,2011,102:674-682
    [50]欧阳资生,厚尾分布的极值分位数估计与极值风险测度研究,数理统计与管理,2008,1:70-75
    [51]吴建南,马伟,估计极端行为模型:分位数回归方法及其实现与应用 数理统计与管理,2006,9:536-543
    [52]刘生龙,教育和经验对中国居民收入的影响—基于分位数回归和审查分位数回归的实证研究,数量经济技术经济研究,2008,4:75-85
    [53]韦盛学,删失分位数回归模型的经验似然置信区域,玉林师范学院学报,2008,5:5--
    [54]陈建宝,段景辉,中国城乡家庭收入差异的分位数回归解析:1988-2005,经济学家,2009,9:46-53
    [55]王新宇,分位数回归理论及其在金融风险测量中的应用,科学出版社2010
    [56]陈娟,林龙,叶阿忠,基于分位数回归的中国居民消费研究,数量经济技术经济研究2008,2:16-27
    [57]郭凤鸣,中国城镇劳动力市场中性别工资差异的经验研究,中国知网:优秀硕士博士论文文库,2011
    [58]张敏强,王宣承,异方差条件下两种回归方法的比较,统计与决策,2011,12:9-12
    [59]许娜,中国上资差异变动的分解,统计与信息论坛,2011,9:61-67
    [60]吕萍,分位数回归模型在小域估计中的应用,统计教育,2009,1:56-59
    [61]解栋栋,服务业发展与人均收入的关系:基于分位数回归的实证研究,当代财经,2009,8:80-84
    [62]王杰,劳动制度变迁与个人收入流动效应—新劳动法下的山东面板数据分析,数量经济技术经济研究,2009,6:127-137
    [63]陈珍珍,游家兴,基于分位回归法的农民工收入影响因素分析,统计研究,2009,6:79-84
    [64]何军,代际差异视角下农民工城市融入影响因素分析—基于分位数回归方法,中国农村经济,2011,6:15-25
    [65]罗彩琴,陈娟,叶阿忠,教育投资风险的区域差异分析—基于分位数回归方法,统计教育,2009,2:20-25
    [66]金玉国,崔友平,行业属性对劳动报酬的边际效应及其细部特征—基于分位数回归模型的实证研究,财经研究,2008,7:4-15
    [67]叶阿忠,非参数计量经济模型的变窗宽核估计,福州大学学报(自然科学版),2006,4:180-183
    [68]李艳娟,核估计量与窗宽选择,辽宁工程技术大学学报,2006,6:478-480
    [69]岳小云,刘学,李艳坡,密度核估计的局部窗宽选择法,河北科技师范学院学报,2007,3:56-57
    [70]黎运发,黄名辉,核密度估计逐点最优窗宽选择的改进,统计与决策,2011,14:28-32
    [71]郭芳,赵新振,殷鸣放等,非参数核密度估计在阔叶红松天然林直径分布研究中的应用,河南农业大学学报,2008,6:303-312
    [72]孙剑芬,基于高斯核密度估计的运动目标检测新方法,计算机技术与发展,2010,8:45-48
    [73]朱红伟,加权核密度估计及对我国消费支出的分析,山西财经大学学报,2006,10:40-41
    [74]Xiaohong Chen, Yanqin Fan, Estimation of copula-based semiparametric time series models, Journal of Econometrics,2006,130:307-335
    [75]Francesco Bravo, Two-step generalised empirical likelihood inference for semiparametric models, Journal of Multivariate Analysis,2009,100:1412-1431
    [76]Hidehiko Ichimura,Sokbae Lee, Characterization of the asymptotic distribution of semiparametric M-estimators, Journal of Econometrics,2010, 159:252-266
    [77]Arnab Maity, Efficient estimation of population quantiles in general semiparametric regression models, Statistics and Probability Letters,2008, 78:2744-2750
    [78]Zongwu Cai, Zhijie Xiao, Semiparametric quantile regression estimation in dynamic models with partially varying coefficients, Journal of Econometrics,2012,167:413-425
    [79]Pascal Lavergnea, Valentin Patilea, Breaking the curse of dimensionality in nonparametric testing, Journal of Econometrics,2008,143:103-122
    [80]JinhongYou, Xian Zhou, Statistical inference in a panel data semiparametric Regression model with serially correlated errors, Journal of Multivariate Analysis 2006,97:844-873
    [81]叶阿忠,非参数和半参数计量经济模型理论,科学出版社,2008
    [82]翁云妹,半参数变系数分位数回归模型及其两阶段估计:以波士顿房价应用为例,中国知网:优秀硕士、博士论文文库,2008
    [83]卢静,变系数部分线性模型的局部M-估计,中国知网:优秀硕士、博士论文文库,2008
    [84]王成勇,艾春荣,王少平,有结构变化的半参数回归模型,应用概率统计,2010,10:501-514
    [85]姜素红,城市化、工业化及城乡差距,中国知网:优秀硕士、博士论文文库,2009
    [86]高赞玥,影响中国城市工业减排因素的半参数分析,中国知网:优秀硕士、博士论文文库,2010
    [87]魏传华,梅长林,半参数空间变系数回归模型的两步估计方法及其数值模拟,统计与信息论坛,2005,1:16-19
    [88]刘文丽,吕书龙,半参数回归模型中部分问题的直观探讨,吉林师范大学学报(自然科学版),2010,4:5-8
    [89]李琪琪,韦来生,半参数回归模型中参数的Bayes估计,中国科学技术大学学报,2010,9:881-886
    [90]孙浩,赵选民,部分线性模型中参数分量与非参数分量估计的收敛速度,工程数学学报,1999,8:11-18
    [91]黄振生,含指标项半参数回归模型的估计与检验,中国知网:优秀硕士、博士论文文库,2010
    [92]胡宏昌,半数模型的估计方法及其应用,中国知网:优秀硕士、博士论文文库,2004
    [93]赵越,半参数模型的统计推断及其在金融中的应用,中国知网:优秀硕士、博士论文文库,2010
    [94]安景文,半参数回归法预测短期焦炭价格,中国知网:优秀硕士、博士论文文库,2010
    [95]Binh T. Nguyen, James W. Albrecht, Susan B. Vroman, M. Daniel Westbrook A quantile regression decomposition of urban-rural inequality in Vietnam, Journal of Development Economics,2007,83:466-490
    [96]Blaise Melly, Decomposition of differences in distribution using quant ile regression, Labour Economics,2005,12:577-590
    [97]Joan Costa-Font, Daniele Fabbri b, Joan Gil, Decomposing body mass index gaps between Mediterranean countries:A counterfactual quantile regression analysis, Economics and Human Biology,2009,7:351-365
    [98]Elena Martinez-Sanchis, Juan Mora, Ilker Kandemir, Counterfactual distributions of wages via quantile regression with endogeneity, Computational Statistics and Data Analysis,2012,10:1-32
    [99]Thai-Hung Pham, Barry Reilly, The gender pay gap in Vietnam 1993-2002:A quantile regression approach, Journal of Asian Economics,2007,18:775-808
    [100]James Albrecht, Aico van Vuuren, Susan Vroman, Counterfactual distributions with sample selection adjustments:Econometric theory and an application to the Netherlands, Labour Economics 2009,16:383-396
    [101]胡枫,农民工汇款与家庭收入不平等:基于反事实收入的分析,人口研究,2010,3:89-100
    [102]李攀登,资产定价模型的非参数方法研究,中国知网:优秀硕士、博士论文文库,2010
    [103]邹薇、周浩,中国省际增长差异的源泉的测算与分析(1978-2002),管理世界,2007,7:37-46
    [104]解垩,公共转移支付和私人转移支付对农村贫困、不平等的影响:反事实分析,财贸经济,2010,12:56-61
    [105]陶庄,杨功焕,环境因子对人群健康影响的测量与评估方法,环境与健康杂志,2010,4:342-346
    [106]赵飞,何海燕,基于反事实分析的产业损害幅度计算方法及CADIC扩展模型,北京理工大学学报,2009,2:181-184
    [107]葛玉好,工资分布的性别差异:分位数分解方法,上海经济研究,2007,4:22-30
    [108]邹伟,王小梅,城镇家庭收入差异演变及其原因解析.统计与信息论坛,2011,3:101-107
    [109]李竹渝,鲁万波,龚金国编著,经济、金融计量学中的非参数估计技术,科学出版社,2007
    [110]罗素.戴维森,詹姆斯.G.麦金农,计量经济理论和方法,上海财经大学出版社,2006
    [111]屈文建,熊国经,非参数密度估计法比较分析及应用,沈阳农业大学报,2008,8:468-472
    [112]李熠,收入差距扩大成因的半参数分析,中国知网:优秀硕士、博士论文文库,2010
    [113]迟巍、黎波、余秋海,一种新的收入差距研究的计量方法—基于分布函数的半参数化分析,数量经济技术经济研究[J],2007,8:119-129
    [114]郭长安,吴婧,对我国城乡居民收入分布演变的分析,统计与决策,2009,13:77-79
    [115]李育安,分位数回归及应用简介,统计与信息论坛,2006,5:35-38
    [116]陈建宝,丁军军,分位数回归技术综述,统计与信息论坛,2008,3:89-96
    [117]Moulinath Banerjee, Debasri Mukherjee, Santosh Mishra, Semiparametric binary regression models under shape constraints with an application to Indian schooling data, Journal of Econometrics,2009,149:101-117
    [118]陈建宝,杜小敏,董海龙,基于分位数回归的中国居民收入和消费的实证分析,统计与信息论坛,2009,7:44-50
    [119]张瑜,我国城乡居民收入分布的核密度估计,统计观察,2006,10:73-74
    [120]镇志勇,李军,非参数核密度估计在恒生指数收益率分布中的应用,统计与决策,2011,9:22-24
    [121]郭照庄,霍东升,孙月芳,密度核估计中窗宽选择的一种新方法,佳木斯大学学报,2008,5:401-403
    [122]海新权,杨林娟,基于分位数回归的农村居民消费问题的研究,湖南财经高等专科学校学报,2009,4:99-100
    [123]赖晓东,赖微微,分位数回归方法在资本结构影响因素分析中的应用,数理统计与管理,2008,3:227-234
    [124]邓露,郑展,一种刻画不同水平研究对象的统计方法:分位数回归,统计与决策,2009,4:154-155
    [125]谢中华,Matlab统计分析与应用:40个案例分析,北京航空航天大学出版社,2010
    [126]陈超,Mat lab应用实例精讲——数学数值计算与统计分析,电子工业出版社,2010
    [127]汤银才,R语言与统计分析,高等教育出版社,2008
    [128]薛毅,陈立萍,统计建模与R软件,清华大学出版社,2008
    [129]Paul D.Allison,吴晓刚,高级回归分析,上海人民出版社,2011
    [130]孙营,郭鹏江,变系数联立模型的局部线性工具向量变窗宽估计,纺织高校基础科学学报,2011,3:42-45
    [131]周金燕、钟宇平,教育对中国收入不平等变迁的作用(1991-2006),北京大学教育评论,2010,10:106-120
    [132]姜素红、陈晓,一种非参数可加模型回归估计的简便方法,统计与决策,2009,18:19-21
    [133]Huixia, JudyWang, ZhongyiZhu, Empirical likelihood for quantile regression models with longitudinal data, Journal of Statistical Planning and Inference,2011,141:1603-1615
    [134]Antonio F. Galvao, GabrielV. Montes-Rojas, Penalized quantile regression for dynamic panel data, Journal of Statistical Planning and Inference, 2010,140:3476-3497
    [135]Mehdi Hosseinkouchack, Further improvements in the calculation of Censored Quantile Regressions, Journal of Computational and Applied Mathematics,2011,235:1429-1445
    [136]Jan Kloppenborg Moller, Henrik Aalborg Nielsen,Henrik Madsen,Time-adaptive quantile regression, Computational Statistics & Data Analysis,2008,52:1292-1303
    [137]魏传华,梅长林,半参数空间变系数回归模型的Back-Fitting估计,数学的实践与认识,2006,3:177-184
    [138]安东尼.B.阿特金森,弗兰科伊斯.布吉尼翁,收入分配经济学于册,经济科学出版社,2009
    [139]马丁.布朗芬布伦纳,收入分配理论,华夏出版社,2010
    [140]李实,史泰丽,别雍.古斯塔夫森,中国居民收入分配研究,北京师范大学出版集团,2008
    [141]薛进军,中国的不平等—收入分配差距研究,社会科学文献出版社,2008
    [142]陈娟,浙江省城镇居民地区收入不平等统计研究—基于非参数理论的研究视角,浙江工商大学出版社,2011
    [143]关静,分位数回归理论及其应用,中国知网:优秀硕士、博士论文文库,2008
    [144]Timo Simil, Self-organizing map visualizing conditional quantile functions with multidimensional covariates, Computational Statistics & Data Analysis,2006,50:2097-2110

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700