地面核磁共振探测地下水数值模拟与影响因素分析
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
本论文对地面核磁共振找水技术中影响地面核磁共振信号的因素进行了详细的研究,建立了层状大地单一含水层及多个含水层仿真模型,并针对所建立模型对理想情况下及实际地电条件下单一含水层进行仿真计算,分析两种情况下核磁共振信号的关系;根据理论表达式中存在的等价的问题,对单一含水层进行仿真计算,得出多个模型仿真结果一致的结论。对于层状大地存在多个水平含水层的情况下,分析了理想情况及多个含水层上方存在不同导电性介质时平均电阻率的计算方法,给出多个含水层核磁共振信号的计算方法,仿真对比理想情况及实际地电条件下多个含水层总信号与各个单一含水层信号的贡献关系,为数据反演奠定基础。针对实际找水仪器野外工作时出现的反演解释勘探深度与钻孔获得的勘探深度存在误差的情况,仿真分析几种参数变化时的最大勘探深度,结合野外实测地点的数据与钻孔资料提出增大勘探深度的有效办法。分析地层岩性对钻孔出水量的影响,利用野外实测地点的数据与钻孔资料验证地层中平均含水量大而且地层弛豫时间较长的地点才能得到较大的出水量。
The nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) technique is mainly known in geophysics for well logging and laboratory applications. In recent years, Surface NMR (SNMR) has become available for hydrogeological applications, NMR is observed with nuclei of certain atoms which are immersed in a static magnetic field and exposed to a secondary oscillating magnetic field, The amplitude of the signal is proportional to the amount of spinning nuclei, e.g. H-proton and the decay of the signal contains information on the pore space. The power of SNMR lies in the fact, that it is the only available geophysical technique which provides direct information of the water content and structural parameters, like porosity or pore size. These abilities of SNMR make it a promising tool for much broader applications in near surface geophysics than for hydrogeophysical exploration alone, like ground water quality, waste disposal, site exploration, soil physics, dam wetness/stability or agriculture (agro-geophysics) research. Since 1992, there are few personnel to develop scientific research on SNMR for groundwater in China, though abundant investigations have already developed in foreign country, so it has science importance to develop research of theoretics and method based on SNMR groundwater, and it will promote grow of SNMR technology in our country.
    Application research of SNMR miss quite mature, datum exist error tested by France NUMIS Instrument, the depth of water-saturated layers from the NMR data
    interpretation and the depth of bore is not coherent, the depth of theory and the antenna diameter have corresponding relationship, but certain parameters should be simulated and analyzed the influence factors about depth of investigation in order to present appropriate model. Otherwise, there are some problems to evaluate underground abnormity and provide appropriate explaination accord with geologic structure. SNMR Method was initially developed for the detection of free water in aquifers. SNMR capability of separation of groundwater into free and bound water is based on the measurement of signal relaxation time constant. Generally speaking, in some rock, bound water is characterized by shorter relaxation time constant (<30 ms) and longer time constant(>30 ms) corresponds to free water, when water in the unsaturated zone(bound water) is the target, the relaxation time of the NMR signal is usually longer, so the bound water can be detected and the errors between water content and water yield of substratum can appear during the NMR data inversion. It is important that the manifold factors should be considered to detect the water-saturated layers which water can be detected. Based on numerical simulation on surface NMR for groundwater, focusing on influence factors on surface NMR technique for groundwater exploration, linking fund projects of Jilin University “Study on key technique of SNMR -instrument for groundwater”, “Coal mine sap water circumstance detection on NMR method”, “TEM and NMR amalgamation”and outspreading research work. The main research work and achievements are as following: 1. The basic theory of NMR is introduced, the relaxation mechanism of atom nuclei is particular analyzed, relaxation process of hydrogen proton-containing at subterranean liquids is calculated. 2. The electromagnetic theory is introduced and the Maxwell equations based on transient electromagnetic field and frequency electromagnetic field are presented, the basic method of SNMR for groundwater is analyzed, calculation method of NMR signal based on single water-saturated earth layers homogeneous half-space model is particular deduced。The ideal homogeneous model and actual conductive homogeneous half-space model are founded, the NMR signal is computed used by up to date math software
    MAPLE, the relationship of NMR signal amplitude and excited pulse moment is studied when the depth, thickness, water content of water-saturated layers and antenna area are changed. There are equivalence problem about NMR signal from different models through calculating single water-saturated layers, it means that the same NMR signal tested at surface may be come from the different models which in the same depth, different thickness and water content, and it means that inversion may lead to several models, which in turn means that different models may fit equally well a given SNMR experimental data. 3.The multi-water-saturated layers model is founded based on the results of the single water-saturated layer model, the method of calculation about multi-water-saturated layers is given from ideal homogeneous half-space model, and the NMR signal of multi-water-saturated layers is calculated at the same time the contribution from every single layers to total signal is analyzed. The practical conductive homogeneous half-space model is presented according to ideal homogeneous half-space model. The computation method of the average resistance ratio is studied from several layers which in the different medium, and the relationship between the amplitude and the pulse moment of the total NMR signal is calculated when the layer is in the same and the different medium, and the electrical conductivity of the layers above the water-saturated layer will decrease the amplitude of NMR signal, in contrary, the electrical conductivity of the layers under the water-saturated layer has not influence to the amplitude of NMR signal. 4. The maximum depth at which water can be detected is calculated used the model of ideal free and the conductive homogeneous half-space based on the NMR signal from the stratum medium, the relationship between the amplitude versus pulse moment and the amplitude versus depth of investigation of NMR signal is contrasted, the errors between depth of investigation from instrument and depth of investigation from the full theoretical description are analyzed. The maximum depth of investigation is calculated when there are the electrical conductivity of the layers above the water-saturated layer, it is proved that the depth of investigation is decreased when there are the electrical conductivity of the layers above the water-saturated layer, this information is then used to
    estimate the depth range over which most of the NMR signal is obtained at the field experiment. 5. The testing results from NMR instrument made by our work group are given in Chang Chun suburb, there are coherence through the corresponding data obtained from NMR instrument compared with the calculated data obtained from the simulation model. The data obtained from a nearby boring are compared with the data from interpretation by NUMIS instrument (France) and the results from computer modeling, It can be seen that the NMR signal calculated using a conductive homogeneous half-space model is in fair agreement with the NMR data obtained Experimentally, the validity of model calculation is validated. 6.There are disagreement between the water content from the NMR data interpretation and the yield from the boring of stratum, it can be found from the data of Hydrogeological Department in Mongolia that borehole data only 20% compared with the NMR data interpretation are creditability. Based on analyzing the relaxation property of hydrogen protons of water in a porous medium and linking NMR method for well logging, the relationship between water-saturated rocks lithology and the relaxation time is studied, the method of calculation about the porosity, the permeability and the yield of layers are presented, it shows that the relaxation mechanism of liquid in a porous medium depends on not only relaxation property but also the porous structures and components, and the difference lithology of water-saturated layers will influence the yield of borehole. 7. The influence on groundwater-saturated layers lithology to yield of borehole is analyzed by several experimental data in field from China and France, there are good agreements between the yield of borehole and layers lithology. It is also established that the borehole can offered the more yield when the average free water content is great and the layers lithology is good (its relaxation time is long). The results also provide a theoretical reference to NMR experiments for groundwater in field. Based on the above research findings, focused on “Study on SNMR theory and method for groundwater and develop SNMR instrument system”the problems that need further study are as follow: 1. The testing data from SNMR instruments should be analyzed and processed integrated, the accurate interpretation if there is free water exploited from subsurface
引文
[1] 蒋邦远.实用近区磁源瞬变电磁法勘探.地质出版社,1998,1.
    [2] 米萨克N 纳米吉安主编, 赵经祥等译.勘查地球物理电磁法. 第一卷理论, 地质出版社, 1992,1.
    [3] K.J.Dune, D.J.Bergman and G.A.Latorraca.Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Petrophysical and Logging Application. Handbook of Geophysical Exploration. Seismic Exploration.V.32. 2002,2.
    [4] 陈文升编著.核磁共振地球物理仪器原理. 地质出版社, 1992,7.
    [5] 王金山编.核磁共振波谱仪与实验技术.机械工业出版社, 1982,6.
    [6] 潘玉玲, 张昌达等编著.地面核磁共振找水理论和方法.中国地质大学出版社, 2000,8.
    [7] 姬广柱, 周强, 侯国强. 综合多种物探方法在贫水山区找水的实践. 地下水,2001,23(4):208-210.
    [8] 段佳松.浅层地震折射波法配合电测深法在花岗岩地区找水.地质与勘探, 1999,35(3):46-48.
    [9] David V. Fitterman and Mark T. Stewart Transient electromagnetic sounding for groundwater . Geophysics 1986,51(4):995-1005.
    [10] M. Goldman ,D. Gilad ,A. Ronen and A. Melloul. Mapping of seawater intrusion into coastal aquifer of Israel by the time domain electromagnetic method.Geoexploration,1991,28:153-174.
    [11] Theodore Mills, Pier Hoekstra, Mark Blohm and Lauren Evans. Time domain electromagnetic soundings for mapping sea-water intrusion in monterry county.California Ground Water.1988 ,26(6):771-782.
    [12] Barringer A R and White J F.Groundwater Survey Method and Apparatus.US Patent 3398335,1968.
    [13] Semenov A G, Burshtein A I, Pusep A Y and Shirov M D.A. Device for Measurement of Underground Mineral Parameters.USSR Patent 1079063,1988.
    [14] Varian R H. Ground Liquid Prospecting Method and Apparatus. US Patent 3019383,1962.
    [15] Avenue Buffon B, Orleans Cedex. The proton Magnetic Resonance Method for Groundwater Investigations. IRIS Instrument, France. 1998,2 :6007 -45060.
    [16] Perter B. Weichman, Eugene M. Lavely, and Michael H. Ritzwoller. Theory of surface nuclear magnetic resonance with applications to geophysical imaging problenm. Physical Review E 2000,62(1) :1290-1312.
    [17] Perter B. Weichman, Eugene M. Lavely, and Michael H. Ritzwoller. Surface nuclear magnetic resonance Imaging of large system. Physical Review Letters ,1999, 82(20):4102-4105.
    [18] Perter B. Weichman, Dong Rong Lun, Michael, H. Ritzwoller, Eugene M. Lavely. Study of surface nuclear magnetic resonance inverse problems. Journal of Applied Geophysics, 2002, 50(1) :129-147.
    [19] 刘东华, 李显耀, 孙朝晖. 核磁共振成像. 大学物理, 1997, 16(10):(42-43).
    [20] 赵岩松, 张一鸣, 夏平畴. 核磁共振测井系统中主要电磁场问题的探讨. 电工技术学报, 1999, 14(5):74-80.
    [21] 何国军, 石奇才, 毛进同. 核磁共振成像中不同K 空间的信号多次平均与图像信噪比. 南开学学报(自然科学),1996, 29(2):17-23.
    [22] 项仕标. 核磁共振及其实验演示. 河北大学学报(自然科学版), 1997,12 :75-77.
    [23] 刘炬民, 费振义, 刘恭民. 核磁共振信号的计算机数据处理. 山东电子1995,4:9-10.
    [24] 张连芳.核磁共振实验中氢核化学位移的相对测量. 大学物理,1996, 15(4):32-34.
    [25] 王艳祥, 沈德言. 固体核磁共振弛豫在高分子研究中的应用.高分子通报, 1996,9:152-159.
    [26] 孟庆安, 李子荣. 固态样品中扩散的核磁共振测量. 波谱学杂志, 第卷第期1997, 14(4):287-290.
    [27] 肖立志. 岩石核磁共振研究进展及其应用. 测井技术, 1996 20(1):27-31.
    [28] 肖立志. 核磁共振成像测井. 测井技术,1995, 19(4):284-293.
    [29] F. D’Orazio, J.C. Tarczon, and W.P. Halperin. Application of Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Pore Structure Analysis to Porous Silica Glass. J.Appl.Phys, 1989,65(2):742-751.
    [30] Gigi Qian Zhang, Chien-Chung Huang and George J. Hirasaki Interpretation of Wettability in Sandstones With NMR Analysis. Petrophysics, 2000 41(3):223-233.
    [31] M.Schirov and A.Legchenko. A New Direct Non-invasive Groundwater Detection Technology for Australia. Exploration Geophysics, 1991,22(2): 333-338.
    [32] Legchenko AV., Shushakov OA., Perrin J. and Portselan A .A Noninvasive NMR study of subsurface aquifers in France. 1995,3:35-39.
    [33] Ю.И.БУДГАКОВ, Г.Б.ИПКОВИЧ, А.Ю.ПУСЕП, А.Б.СТОРОЖЕВ, МАТЕМАТИЧЕСКОЕМОДЕЛИРОВАНИЕСИГНАЛАЯМРПРИПОИСКАХВОДЫВПРОВОДЯЩЕЙ СРЕДЕГЕОЛОГИЯИГЕОФНЗИКА1992,12:133-137.
    [34] M. Goldman , B. Rabinovich, M. Rabinovich, D. Gilad, I. Gev and M. schirov.
    Application of the integrated NMR-TDEM method in groundwater exploration in Israel. Joural of
    Applied Geophysics, 1994,31:27-52.
    [35] Ugur Yaramanci, Gerhard Lange and Klaus Knodel.Surface NMR within a Geophysical Study of an Aquifer at Haldensleben (Germany). Geophysical Prospecting ,1999,47:923-943.
    [36] Baltassat J.M., Legchenko A.., Mathieu F., Ambroise B., Mercier J.L., Wyns R. MRS and Resistivity Chara Cterisation of the Ringelbach Ingelbach Catchment Aquifer, Vosgesmassif, FRANCE. Proceedings of MRS 2nd international workshop on the Magnetic Resonance Sounding method applied to non-invasive groundwater investigations , France, Orleans2003,11:13-16.
    [37] J. P. Delaporte1, S. Boutaleb1, M. Chibout1, M. Boualoul.A Groundwater Prospecting Strategy in Discontinous Grounds and Arid Climate : Methodlogy and Case Studies in Morocco. Proceedings of MRS 2nd international workshop on the Magnetic Resonance Sounding method applied to non-invasive groundwater investigations . France, Orleans:2003 ,11:25-28.
    [38] O. Mohnke, M. Braun and U. Yaramanci. Inversion of Decay Time Spectra from Surface NMR Data. Technical University Berlin, Dept. of Applied Geophysics, Ackerstr. 71-76, 13355 Berlin, Germany。
    [39] Krishnamurthy N.S., Baltassat J.M., Robain H., Legchenko A., Descloitres. MRS and Electrical Imagery for Characterising Weathered and Fractured Ractured Hard-Rock Aquifer in the Maheshwaram Watershed, Hyderabad, India. Proceedings of MRS 2nd international workshop on the Magnetic Resonance Sounding method applied to non-invasive groundwater investigations, France, Orleans, 2003 ,11:53-56.
    [40] J.M. Miehé, A. Legchenko, J.M. Baltassat, Experimental Study of a Chalk Formation Using Magnetic Resonance Soundings (MRS) at LE Bois DE Cize, Near Ault (Picrdy, France). Proceedings of MRS 2nd international workshop on the Magnetic Resonance Sounding method applied to non-invasive groundwater investigations . France, Orleans, 2003 ,11:77-80.
    [41] Félix M. Rubio and Juan Luis Plata. MRS (Magnetic Resonance Sounding) Survey in a Detrital Coastal Aquifer in Castellon, Spain. Proceedings of MRS 2nd international workshop on the Magnetic Resonance Sounding method applied to non-invasive groundwater investigations ,France, Orleans, 2003 ,11:109-112.
    [42] F.Vermeersch, B. Texier, J.Bernard. Comparison of Various Loop Geomentries in Magnetic Resonance Soundings on the Pyla Sand Dune (France) . Proceedings of MRS 2nd international workshop on the Magnetic Resonance Sounding method applied to non-invasive groundwater investigations, France, Orleans, 2003 ,11:117-120.
    [43] Francis Mathieu, Robert Wyns, Jean-Michel Baltassat, Anatoly Legchenko1,, Patrick Lachassagne, Bruno Mougins. Application of Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Soundings to Groundwater Reserves Mapping in Weathered Hard-Rock Aquifer. (Brittany, France), Proceedings of MRS 2nd international workshop on the Magnetic Resonance Sounding method applied to non-invasive groundwater investigations . France, Orleans, 2003 ,11:145-148.
    [44] M. Müller and U. Yaramanci. History and Future Developments for Small Scale Applications of Nuclear Magnetic Resonance. Proceedings of MRS 2nd international workshop on the Magnetic Resonance Sounding method applied to non-invasive groundwater investigations, France, Orleans, 2003 ,11:153-156.
    [45] О.А.ШУШАКОВ, А.В.ДЕГЧЕНКО, РАСЧЕТСИГНАЛАПРОТОННОГОМАГНИТНОГОРЕЗОНАНСАОТПОДЗЕМОЙВОДЗЕМНОЙВОДЫСУЧЕТОМЭЛЕКТРОПРОВОДНОСТИСРЕДЫГЕОЛОГИЯИГЕОФНЗИКА1994,3:130-136.
    [46] S. Dippel, H. Golden. MRS and TEM for Shallow Aquifer Definition at Phosphate Hill, NW Queensland, Australia. Proceedings of MRS 2nd international workshop on the Magnetic Resonance Sounding method applied to non-invasive groundwater investigations . France, Orleans, 2003 ,11 :29-32.
    [47] 邹家衡. 核磁共振找水方法. 铀矿地质, 1999,15(1):62-64.
    [48] 潘玉玲, 万乐, 袁照令, 李振宇. 核磁共振找水方法的现状和发展趋势. 物探与化探, 2000,19(1):105-108.
    [49] 袁照令,万乐,李振宇. 核磁共振找水方法在贫水地区找地下水的效果. 应用科学学报, 2001,19(3):265-267.
    [50] 潘玉玲, 李振宇, 万乐, 袁照令. 利用核磁共振方法探查基岩裂隙水. CT 理论与应用研究, 2000,9(1):22-25.
    [51] 潘玉玲,Jean BERNARD.地面核磁共振找水仪及其在水文地质调查工作中的应用研究. CT理论与应用研究,2001,9(11):38-43.
    [52] 袁乐, 袁照令, 潘玉玲. 地面核磁共振感应系统(NUMIS)及其在找水中的应用.物探与 化探,1999,23(5):330-334.
    [53] 潘玉玲, 贺颖, 李振宇, 李国安, 姜焕忠. 核磁共振找水方法在中国的应用效果. 地质通报, 2003,2:135-139.
    [54] Zhenyu LI, Yuling PAN, Huiming TANG, Bing ZHANG, QU Zan. Application of SNMR method in engineering geology. Proceedings of MRS 2nd international workshop on the Magnetic Resonance Sounding method applied to non-invasive groundwater investigations . France, Orleans, 2003,11 :129-133.
    [55] Haisheng Li, Wei Liu, Yongfu Wei. Groundwater Reources Assessment by Using PMR Sounding. Proceedings of MRS 2nd international workshop on the Magnetic Resonance Sounding method applied to non-invasive groundwater investigations . France, Orleans, 2003,11:37-40.
    [56] 李振宇,潘玉玲,张兵,许顺芳,袁照令,李大明,顾涛.利用核磁共振方法研究水文地质问题及应用实例. 水文地质工程地质,2003,4:50-55.
    [57] 李振宇, 高秀花, 潘玉玲. 核磁共振测深方法的新进展. CT 理论与应用研究, 2004,13(2):6-11.
    [58] 潘玉玲,李振宇, 熊玉珍, 甘涛. 轻便新型核磁共振找水仪及其在堤坝监测中的应用. 大坝与安全, 2004,1 :27-29.
    [59] 袁照令, 潘玉玲, 万乐, 李振宇, 董浩斌, 张兵. 核磁共振找水方法的应用效果. 地球科学—中国地质大学学报, 2000, 25(3):132-158.
    [60] 邓靖武,潘玉玲, 熊玉珍. 探查地下水的新方法-地面核磁共振找水方法的应用研究. 现代地质, 2004 18(1):121-126.
    [61] Anatoly V. Legchenko and Opleg A. Shushakov. Inversion of surface NMR data. Geophysics, 1998, 63(1):75-84.
    [62] Anatoly V. Legchenko. Some Aspects of the Performance of the Surface NMR Method. SEG 1996 66th,NS 6.5:936-939.
    [63] Karl E.Butler and R. Don Russell. Short Note Subtraction of Powerline Harmonics From Geophysical Records. Geophysics , 1993,58(6):898-903.
    [64] Anatoly Legchenko, Pierre Valla. Removal of Power-line Harmonics From Proton Magnetic Resonance Measurements. Journal of Applied Geophysics , 2003, 53(2): 103-120.
    [65] Anatoly Legchenko. Industrial Noise and Processing of the Magnetic Resonance Signal.Proceedings of MRS 2nd international workshop on the Magnetic Resonance Sounding method applied to non-invasive groundwater investigations, France, Orleans, 2003,11:69-71.
    [66] D.V.Trushkin ,O.A.Shushakov and A.V. Legchenko. The potential of a noise –reducing antenna for surface NMR groundwater surveys in the earth’s magnetic field. Geophysical Prospecting, 1994,42(8):855-862.
    [67] Jared D. Abraham, Anatoly Legchenko, Dr. Aldo Mazzella.TDEM and Numisplus Soundings at the ASH Meadows National Wildlife Refuge: A Case Study. Proceedings of MRS 2nd international workshop on the Magnetic Resonance Sounding method applied to non-invasive groundwater investigations, France, Orleans, 2003,11:5-8.
    [68] Legchenko, A.V., Baltassat, J.M., Beauce, A., and Bernard, J..Nuclear magnetic resonance as a geophysical tool for hydrogeologists. Jour. Appl. Geophys., 2002,50(1):21-46.
    [69] 张建中, 孙存谱, 磁共振教程. 中国科学技术大学出版社,1996,10.
    [70] 孙淑琴, 林君, 张庆文, 嵇艳菊. 氢质子弛豫过程. 物探与化探, 2005,2 :153-156.
    [71] Stefan Kooman1, Martin Müller, Ugur Yaramanci. Hydrological Properties Derived From Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Properties of Unconsolidated Rocks and Synthetic Samples. Proceedings of MRS 2nd international workshop on the Magnetic Resonance Sounding method applied to non-invasive groundwater investigations, France, Orleans, 2003 ,11:49-52.
    [72] 张志涌. 精通MATLAB 5.3 版. 北京航空航天大学出版社, 2000,8.
    [73] Edward B., Magrab 等著, 高会生, 李新叶, 胡智奇等译. MATLAB 原理与工程应用. 电子工业出版社, 2002,6.
    [74] 冯恩信.电磁场与波. 西安交通大学出版社, 2002,6.
    [75] 谢处方, 饶克谨. 电磁场域电磁波. 高等教育出版社, 2004,4.
    [76] 楼仁海, 电磁场理论, 成都电子科技大学出版社, 1996,4.
    [77] Oleg A. Shushakov. Groundwater NMR in conductive water. Geophysics, 1996,61(4):998-1006.
    [78] О.А.ШУШАКОВ, А.В.ДЕГЧЕНКО, ПРОТОННЫЙМАГНИТНЫЙРЕЗОНСОТПОДЗЕМНОЙВОДЫВГОРИЗОНТАЛЬНОСЛОИСТЫХСРЕДАХРАЗЛИЧНОЙЭЛЕКТРОПРОВОДНОСТИГЕОЛОГИЯИГЕОФНЗИКА1994 ,3:140-145.
    [79] 翁爱华,李舟波,王雪秋. 地表大回线源在任意层状介质中产生磁场的计算. 物探化探计算技术,2000,22(3):244-248.
    [80] 翁爱华,李舟波,王雪秋. 地面核磁共振响应数值模拟研究. 物探化探计算技术, 2002,24(2):98-101.
    [81] 翁爱华,李舟波,王雪秋.层状导电介质中地面核磁共振响应特征理论研究. 地球物理学报, 2004,47(1):156-163.
    [82] 李强. Maple 8 基础应用教程. 中国水利水电出版社, 2004,2.
    [83] 黎捷. MAPLE 9.0 符号处理及应用. 科学出版社, 2004,8.
    [84] 孙淑琴, 林君, 张世雄, 导电性对地面核磁共振信号的影响研究. 物探与化探计算技术, 2005,2:78-81.
    [85] Baltassat J.M., Legchenko A1 , Vouillamoz J.M., Sabatier S., Calibration of MRS Results Using Hydrodynamic Characteristics from Pumping Tests. Proceedings of MRS 2nd international workshop on the Magnetic Resonance Sounding method applied to non-invasive groundwater investigations . France, Orleans:2003,11:9-11.
    [86] Brian R. Spies. Depth of investigation in electromagnetic sounding methods. Geophysics,1989, 54(4):872-888.
    [87] A.A.Kaufman, G.V.Keller. 频率域和时间域电磁测深,王建谋译.北京:地质出版社,1987。
    [88] 朴化荣.电磁测深原理,地质出版社,1990。
    [89] 林君.电磁探测技术在工程与环境中的应用现状.物探与化探,2000,3 :169-176.
    [90] Don Hunter and Anton Kepic. Depth of SNMR Signal Contribution in Counductive Terrains. Proceedings of MRS 2nd international workshop on the Magnetic Resonance Sounding method applied to non-invasive groundwater investigations, France, Orleans,2003,11:45-48.
    [91] 董浩斌,,袁照令,李振宁,张兵,潘玉玲,万乐.核磁共振找水方法在河南某地区的试验结果,物探与化探,1998,22(5):343-347.
    [92] D. V. Trushkin , O.A. Shushakov and A.V. legchenko. Surfaace NMR applied to an electroconductive medium. 1995,43(3):623-633.
    [93] Marie Boucher, Anatoly Legchenko, Jean-Michel Baltassat. On the Possibility of MRS Monitoring of Chalk and Limestone Aquifers. Proceedings of MRS 2nd international workshop on the Magnetic Resonance Sounding method applied to non-invasive groundwater investigations . France, Orleans, 2003 ,11:17-20.
    [94] 高效曾.核磁共振孔隙度和岩性有关.测井技术,1998,22(4):295~298.
    [95] 陈世毅.核磁共振弛豫时间的测量. 杭州师范学院学报, 1996,3 :42-46.
    [96] 王为民,孙佃庆,苗盛. 核磁共振测井实验研究. 测井技术, 1997, 21(6) :285-392.
    [97] 胡镜寰.核磁共振成像术. 学科教育,1996,11:38-38.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700