天津市能源消耗碳足迹影响因素研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
在2009年的哥本哈根全球气候变化大会上,中国政府作出承诺:到2020年,单位GDP的碳排放量相比2005年下降40%-45%。这体现了我国作为一个大国的责任感。但是,目前我国处于城市化、工业化迅速发展的阶段,完成这样的减排目标有很大的挑战性。这就要求全国每个省区都积极行动,为实现碳减排目标而努力。天津市是中国的经济重镇,也是碳排放大户。天津碳减排的效果对于我国能否实现碳减排的目标具有重要的影响。本文针对天津市碳足迹的影响因素进行深入研究,为天津市制定减排政策,实现碳足迹的降低提供理论依据。主要研究内容如下:
     (1)基于LMDI法的天津市能源消耗碳足迹影响因素分解。首先,核算出天津市2001—2009年的能源消耗碳足迹,进而计算出天津市碳足迹生态压力,并对碳足迹生态压力进行分析。然后建立LMDI模型对天津市三大产业以及34个工业部门进行因素分解,将碳足迹的变化分解为碳足迹因子、能源强度、能源结构、经济结构、经济发展五个因素,通过对因素分解结果的分析确定各个因素对碳足迹变化的作用,结果表明经济发展是天津市碳足迹增加最主要的促进因素,能源强度是最主要的抑制因素。
     (2)基于CDM和GFI法的天津市能源强度因素分解。由前一章的结论可知,能源强度是天津市碳足迹增加最主要的抑制因素。为了实现天津市的碳足迹的降低,就要充分发挥能源强度对碳足迹增长的抑制作用,这就需要充分了解能源强度的影响因素。本文首先分析了CDM法和GFI法的特点,然后利用CDM法将2001—2009年天津市三大产业能源强度的变化分解为结构份额和效率份额,利用GFI法将天津市工业能源强度分解为技术进步、能源结构和产业结构,结合两种方法的计算结果可知:对于三大产业,技术进步是能源强度下降的最主要的促进因素,而产业结构是最主要的抑制因素;对于工业,对能源强度变动的影响作用由大到小依次是技术进步、产业结构、能源结构。(3)基于VAR模型的碳足迹影响因素的动态作用分析。根据VAR模型构建的要求,对碳足迹以及因素分解方法分解出的能源强度、能源结构、经济结构进行平稳性检验和协整检验;检验通过后构建碳足迹与这三种影响因素的VAR模型,并利用脉冲响应函数与方差分解方法分析能源强度、能源结构、经济结构对碳足迹的长期动态作用。分析结果显示,能源强度、能源结构、经济结构三种因素对碳足迹的长期解释性较强,存在长期的影响作用。
On the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change in Copenhagen in2009,Chinese government promised that the carbon emission intensity of China in2020would be reduced by40%-45%compared with the carbon emission intensity in2005.This reflects our sense of responsibility as a big country. However, China is in thestage of rapid development of urbanization, industrialization. So the emissionreduction target would be very challenging. Every province has to carry out positiveactions to achieve the carbon reduction targets. Tianjin is the economic center ofChina, making large carbon emissions. Tianjin carbon emission reduction effect hasimportant implications for the goal of carbon reduction. In this paper, the impacts ofthe carbon footprint of Tianjin factors were intensively analyzed to provide atheoretical basis for Tianjin to establish emission reduction policies. The maincontents are as follows:
     (1) Influencing factor analysis on Tianjin carbon footprint based on the LMDImethod. First, the accounting of the carbon footprint of Tianjin in2001-2009wasgiven, and then the ecological pressure was calculated and analyzed. Then with LMDImethod, changes of carbon footprint of Tianjin as a whole and34industrial sectorswas decomposed into carbon footprint factor, energy intensity, energy structure,economic structure and economic development as the five factors. According to thefactor decomposition results, the various factors for the changes in the role of thecarbon footprint were determined. The results showed that the economic developmentof Tianjin increased carbon footprint as the most important contributing factor, andenergy intensity was the main inhibiting factor.
     (2) Factors decomposition of Tianjin Industry energy intensity based on completedecomposition and GFI. According to the conclusion of the previous chapter, theenergy intensity is the main inhibiting factor of carbon footprint in Tianjin. In order toreduce carbon footprint in Tianjin, we should make full use of the inhibition of energyintensity, which needs fully understanding on the impact of influencing factors onenergy intensity. This paper first analyzed the characteristics of CDM and GFI. Andthen the change of energy intensity in Tianjin from the year of2001-2009wasdecomposed into structure share and efficiency share based on CDM, and then thechange of energy intensity was decomposed into technological progress, energy and industrial structures by using the method of GFI. Considering the results of CDM andGFI, for the three major industries, the role of technological progress is the mostimportant contributing factor to the decline in energy intensity, and industrial structureis the main inhibiting factors; and for industry, the effects of the factors on the changein energy intensity in descending order are technical progress, industrial structure andenergy structure.
     (3) Based on VAR model, dynamic effects of influencing factors of carbonfootprint were analyzed. According to the requirements of the VAR model, thestationary test and cointegration test were used to the carbon footprint as well as thefactors of energy intensity, energy structure and economic structure; after tests werepassed, VAR model of carbon footprint and three influencing factors was set up. Andimpulse response function and variance decomposition method were used to analyzethe long-term dynamic effects of energy intensity, energy structure, the economicstructure to the carbon footprint. The result of the analysis showed that the factors ofenergy intensity, energy structure and economic structure had the strong explanatoryto carbon footprint, with a long-term effect.
引文
[1] IPCC.Climate Change2001:The Scientific Basis.Third Assessment Report ofIntergovernmental Panel on Climate Change[M].Cambridge:CambridgeUniversity Press.2001.
    [2] Jones T H, Thompson I J, Lawton J H, et al. Impact of rising atmosphericcarbon dioxide on model terrestrialecosystems[J].Science,1998,280(5454):441-443.
    [3] Diggle P J,Liang K Y&Zeger S L. Analysis of longitudinal data[M].MJ.Oxford, Clarendon Press,1999:253.
    [4] Levitus S,Antonov J,Boyer T P et al. Warming of the world ocean[J]. Science.2000,287(5461):2225-229.
    [5] Pollack H,Huang S&Shen P Y. Climate change revealed by subsurfacetemperatures: A global perspective [J]. Science.1998,282(5455):279~291.
    [6] Hansen J, Ruedy R, Sato M, et al. A closer look at United States andglobalsurface temperature change [J]. J. Geophys. Res.,2001,106(D20):23947-23963.
    [7]葛军.特别代表解读“气候变化”——访外交部气候变化谈判特别代表于庆泰大使[J].世界知识,2007(20):27-35.
    [8]国家气候变化对策协调小组办公室/中国21世纪议程管理中心.全球气候变化——人类面临的挑战[M].北京:商务印书馆,2004:2.
    [9]张庆阳,全球气候变化问题的对策[J].成都气象学院学报,1998,13(2):109-115.
    [10]王京安,马立钊,高翀.英国能源产业政策及其启示[J].河南社会科学.2010(06):106-109.
    [11]廖建凯.德国减缓气候变化的能源政策与法律措施探析[J].德国研究.2010(02):27-34.
    [12]苏明,傅志华等.碳税的国际经验与借鉴[J].经济研究参考,2009(72):17-23.
    [13]李志英.美国能源效率与节能法及对我国的启示[J].知识经济.2010(17):31.
    [14]陈志恒.日本构建低碳社会行动及其主要进展[J].现代日本经济,2009(6):1-5.
    [15]庄贵阳.哥本哈根气候博弈与中国角色的再认识[J].外交评论,2009(6):13-21.
    [16]史培军等,中国土地利用/覆盖变化的生态环境安全响应与调控[J]。地球科学进展,2006(2):24-29.
    [17]Rees W E. Ecological footprints and appropriated carrying capacity: what urbaneconomics leaves out [J]. Environment and Urbanization,1992,2(34):121-130.
    [18]Wackernagel M, Rees W E. Our ecological footprint reducing human impact onthe earth [J]. Gabriola Island, B.C, Canada: New Society Publishers,1996.
    [19][]BP. What is a carbon footprint? British Petroleum.http://www.bp.com/liveassets/bp_internet/globalbp/,2007.
    [20]Energetics. The reality of carbon neutrality[R].2007
    [21]ETAP. The carbon trust helps UK businesses reduce thieir environmentalimpact[R].2007.
    [22]Hammond G. Time to give due weight to the carbon footprint issue[J]. Nature,2007,455(7125):256
    [23]陈文颖,代光辉.广西重点行业二氧化碳减排潜力分析[J].环境科学与技术,2007,30(6):45-48.
    [24]Carbon Trust. Carbon Footprint Measurement Methodology [R].2007.
    [25]POST. Carbon Footprint of Electricity Generation [R]. Parliamentary Office ofScience and Technology,2006.
    [26]Wiedmann T, Minx J. A definition of carbon footprint [J]. SA Research&Consulting,2007,4(56):9.
    [27]GFN. Ecological Footprint Glossary [R]. Global Footprint Network, Oakland, CA,USA,2007.
    [28][] Grubb E. Meeting the carbon challenge: the role of commercial real estateowners, users&managers[R]. Chicago,2007.
    [29]王微,林剑艺,崔胜辉等.碳足迹分析方法研究综述[J].环境科学与技术,2010,33(7):71-78.
    [30]DEFRA.http://campaigns.direct.gov.uk/actonco2/home.html.
    [31]http://www.coolcalifornia.org/chinese/calculator.html[EB/OL].
    [32]山水自然保护中心.http://www.hinature.cn/Nature/what_we_car/001/carbon_tree/Main.shtml[EB/OL]
    [33]Brentona P, Jonesb G E, Jensena MF. Carbon Labelling and Low Income CountryEexports: an Issues Paper[R]. International Trade Department of The WorldBank.
    [34]Gamage G B, Boyle C, McLaren S J. Life cycle assessment of commercialfurniture: a case study of Formaway LIFE chair [J]. Inernational Journal of LifeCycle Assess,2008,13(5):401-411.
    [35]Weber C L, Matthews H S. Quantifying the global and distributional aspects ofAmerican household carbon footprint [J]. Ecological Economics,2008,66(2/3):379-391.
    [36]Peters G P, Hertwich E G. The importance of imports for householdenvironmental impacts [J]. Journal of Industrial Ecology,2006,10(3):89-109.
    [37]Kenny T, Gray N F. Comparative performance of six carbon footprint models foruse in Ireland [J]. Environmental Impact Assessment Review,2009,29(6):1-6.
    [38]Padgett J P, Steinemann A C, Clarke J H,et al. A comparison of carbon calculators[J]. Environmental Impact Assessment Review,2008,28(6):106-115.
    [39]中国经济新闻网.2009.3.31.http://www.jjxww.com/html/show.aspx?id=146646&cid=113[EB/OL]
    [40]SEI.UK schools carbon footprint scoping study for sustainable developmentcommission by global action plan [R]. Stockholm Environment Institute,2006.
    [41]Matthews H S, Hendrickson C T, Weber C L. The importance of carbon footprintestimation boundaries [J]. Environmental Science&Technology,2008,42(16):5839-5842.
    [42]Wang T, Watson T. Who owns China’s carbon emissions [J]. Tyndall BriefingNote,2007:23
    [43]刘强,庄幸,姜克隽等.中国出口贸易中的载能量及碳排放量分析[J].中国工业经济,2008,8(245):46-55.
    [44]Angela Druckman, Tim Jackson. The carbon footprint of UK households1990–2004: A socio-economically disaggregated, quasi-multi-regionalinput–output model [J]. Ecological Economics,2009,68(6):2066-2077.
    [45]Larsen H N, Hertwich E G. The case for consumption-based accounting ofgreenhouse gas emissions to promote local climate action [J]. EnvironmentalScience&Policy,2009,12(7):791-798.
    [46]Marilyn A, Brown F S, Sarzynski A. The geography of metropolitan carbonfootprints [J]. Policy and Society,2009,27(8):285-304.
    [47]Justin Kitzes, Audrey Peller, Steve Goldfinger et al. Current methods forcalculating national ecological footprint accounts [J]. Science for environment&sustainable society,2007,4(1):1-9.
    [48]Johnson E. Disagreement over carbon footprints: a comparison of electric and lpgforklifts [J]. Energy Policy,2008,36(4):1569-1573.
    [49]Friedrich E, Pillay S, Buckley C A. Carbon footprint analysis for increasing watersupply and sanitation in south africa: a case study [J]. Journal of CleanerProduction,2009,17(1):1-12.
    [50]Lenzen M. Double-counting in life cycle calculations [J]. Journal of IndustrialEcology,2008,12(4):583-599.
    [51]Zhang L, Huang Z. Life cycle study of coal-based dimethyl ether as vehicle fuelfor urban bus in China [J]. Energy,2006,32(5):1896-1904.
    [52]Lim S R, Park J M. Cooperative water network system to reduce carbon footprint[J]. Environmental Science&Technology,2008,42(16):6230-6236.
    [53]百度百科. http://baike.baidu.com/view/2828.htm
    [54]岳超,胡雪洋,贺灿飞等.1995—2007年我国省区碳排放及碳强度的分析——碳排放与社会发展III[J].北京大学学报(自然科学版),2010,4(64):510-516.
    [55]李智,鞠美庭,刘伟等.中国1996年-2005年能源生态足迹与效率动态测度与分析[J].2007,29(6):54-60.
    [56]何丹,蔡建明,周璟。天津城市用地时空扩展研究[J].水土保持通报,2009,29(3):56-60.
    [57]Kaya Yoichi. Impact of Carbon Dioxide Emission on GNP Growth: Interpretationof Proposed Scenarios [R]. Paris: Presentation to the Energy and IndustrySubgroup, Response Strategies Working Group, IPCC,1989
    [58]Juan Antonio Duroa, et al. International inequalities in per capita CO2emissions:a decomposition methodology by Kaya factors[J]. Energy Economics,2006,28(6):170-187.
    [59]查冬兰,周德群.地区能源效率与二氧化碳排放的差异性——基于Kaya因素分解[J].系统工程,2007,25(11):65-71.
    [60]赵奥,武春友.中国CO2排放量变化的影响因素分解研究——基于改进的Kaya等式与LMDI分解法[J].软科学,2010,12(24):55-59.
    [61]冯相昭,邹骥.中国CO2排放趋势的经济分析[J].中国人口.资源与环境,2008,18(3):43-47.
    [62]J W Tester. Sustainable Energy: Choosing among Options[M]. US: MIT Press,2005.
    [63]Sun JW. Changes in energy consumption and energy intensity: a completedecomposition model[J]. Energy Economics,2008,20(12):85-100.
    [64]Dabo Guan, Klaus Hubacek, Christopher L. Weber, Glen P. Peters, David M.Reiner. The drivers of Chinese CO2emissions from1980to2030.[J] GlobalEnvironmental Change,2008,18(4):626–634.
    [65]Youguo Zhang. Structural decomposition analysis of sources of decarbonizingeconomic development in China;1992–2006.[J] Ecological Economics,2009,68(6):2399–2405.
    [66]Xin Tian, MiaoChang, HirokiTanikawa, FengShi, HidefumiImura. Structuraldecomposition analysis of the carbonization process in Beijing: A regionalexplanation of rapid increasing carbon dioxide emission in China.[J] EnergyPolicy,2013,53(2):279–286.
    [67]Ying Fan, Lancui Liu, Gang Wu, Hsien-Tang Tsai, Yi-Ming Wei. Changes incarbon intensity in China: Empirical findings from1980-2003.[J] EcologicalEconomics,2007,62(3-4):683-691.
    [68]Ma C, Stern DI. China's changing energy intensity trend: a decompositionanalysis [J]. Energy Economics,2008,30(7):1037-53.
    [69]Wachsmann U, Wood R, Lenzen M, Schaeffer R. Structural decomposition ofenergy use in Brazil from1970to1996[J]. Applied Energy,2009,(67)86:578-87.
    [70]Weber CL. Measuring structural change and energy use: Decomposition of theUS economy from1997to2002[J]. Energy Policy,2009,37(26):1561-1570.
    [71]Salta M, Polatidis H, Haralambopoulos D. Energy use in the Greekmanufacturing sector: a methodological framework based on physical indicatorswith aggregation and decomposition analysis [J]. Energy,2009,34(17):90-111.
    [72]Alvydas Balezentis, Tomas Balezentis, Dalia Streimikiene. The energy intensityin Lithuania during1995–2009: A LMDI approach [J]. Energy Policy,2011,39(20):7322–7334
    [73]Luciano Charlita de Freitas. Decomposing the decoupling of CO2emissions andeconomic growth in Brazil [J]. Ecological Economics,2011,70(18):1459–1469
    [74]Paul A.Steenhof, ChrisJ.Weber. An assessment of factors impacting Canada’selectricity sector’s GHG emissions[J]. Energy Policy,2011,39(12):4089–4096
    [75]Subhes C. Bhattacharyya, Wataru Matsumura. Changes in the GHG emissionintensity in EU-15: Lessons from a decomposition analysis[J]. Energy,2010,35(17):3315-3322
    [76]D. Diakoulaki, M. Mandaraka. Decomposition analysis for assessing the progressin decoupling industrial growth from CO2emissions in the EU manufacturingsector[J]. Energy Economics,2007,29(20):636–664
    [77]Wang C, Chen J, Zou J. Decomposition of energy-related CO2emission in China:1957–2000[J]. Energy,2005,30(1):73-83.
    [78]Wu L, Kaneko S, Matsuoka S. Driving forces behind the stagnancy of China’senergy-related CO2emissions from1996to1999: the relative importance ofstructural change, intensity change and scale change[J]. Energy Policy,2005,33(3):319-335.
    [79]Zhang M, Mu H, Ning Y, et al. Decomposition of energy-related CO2emissionover1991–2006in China[J]. Ecological Economics,2009,68(7):2122-2128.
    [80]Tan Z, Li L, Wang J, et al. Examining the driving forces for improving China'sCO2emission intensity using the decomposing method[J]. Applied Energy,2011,88(12):4496-4504.
    [81]Wang W W, Zhang M, Zhou M. Using LMDI method to analyze transport sectorCO2emissions in China[J]. Energy,2011,36(10):5909-5915.
    [82]Zhang J, Zhang Y, Yang Z, et al. Estimation of energy-related carbon emissions inBeijing and factor decomposition analysis[J]. Ecological Modelling,2010,23(45):156-162.
    [83]Liu Z, Liang S, Geng Y, et al. Features, trajectories and driving forces forenergy-related GHG emissions from Chinese mega cites: The case of Beijing,Tianjin, Shanghai and Chongqing[J]. Energy,2012,37(1):245-254.
    [84]Jidong Kang, Tao Zhao, Xiaosong Ren, et al. Using Decomposition Analysis toEvaluate the performance of China's30Provinces in CO2Emissions Reductionduring Eleventh Five-year Period (2005-2009)[J]. Natural Hazards,2012,64(2):999-1013.
    [85]许士春,习蓉,何正霞.中国能源消耗碳排放的影响因素分析及政策启示[J].资源科学,2012,34(1):2-12.
    [86]Ming Zhang, Hailin Mu, Yadong Ning, Yongchen Song. Decomposition ofenergy-related CO2emission over1991–2006in China[J]. EcologicalEconomics2009;68:2122–2128.
    [87]Lan-Cui Liu, Ying Fan, Gang Wu, Yi-Ming Wei et.al. Using LMDI method toanalyze the change of China’s industrial CO2emissions from final fuel use: Anempirical analysis [J]. Energy policy,2007,(35):5892-5900.
    [88]Zhaohua Wang, Bin Zhang, Jianhua Yin. Determinants of the increased CO2emission and adaption strategy in Chinese energy-intensive industry[J]. NatHazards2011; DOI10.1007/s11069-011-9937-y.
    [89]W.W. Wang, M. Zhang, M. Zhou. Using LMDI method to analyze transportsector CO2emissions in China[J]. Energy2011;36:5909-5915.
    [90]宁亚东,丁涛,外冈丰.中国能源消费特征分析—基于完全因素分解模型的实证研究[J].大连理工大学学报,2012,52(5):641-647.
    [91]郑慕强.能源与碳排放强度完全因素分解—基于东盟五国的实证分析[J].云南财经大学学报,2012,27(2):83-86.
    [92]谭忠福,蔡丞恺.北京市能源强度分析的完全因素分解方法[J].华北电力大学学报(社会科学版),2008,12(6):28-31.
    [93]李国璋,王双.区域能源强度变动:基于GFI的因素分解分析[J].中国人口.资源与环境,2008,18(4):62-66.
    [94]范丹,王维国.中国产业能源消费碳排放变化的因素分解——基于广义GFI的指数分解[J].系统工程,2012,30(11):48-54.
    [95]田立新,张蓓蓓.中国碳排放变动的因素分解分析[J].中国人口·资源与环境2011,21(11):1-7.
    [96]Na Liu, B.W.Ang. Factors shaping aggregate energy intensity trend for industry:Energy intensity versus product mix[J]. Energy Economics,2007,29(4):609-635.
    [97]Hea-Jin Lima, Seung-Hoon Yoob, Seung-Jun Kwakc. Industrial CO2emissionsfrom energy use in Korea: A structural decomposition analysis[J]. Energy Policy,2009,37(2):686–698.
    [98]B. Sudhakara Reddy,Binay Kumar Ray. Decomposition of energy consumptionand energy intensity in Indian manufacturing industries[J]. Energy for SustainableDevelopment,2010,14(1):35–47.
    [99]Md. Shahiduzzaman, Khorshed Alam. Changes in energy efficiency in Australia:A decomposition of aggregate energy intensity using logarithmic mean Divisiaapproach.[J] Energy Policy,2013,56(1),341-351.
    [100] Xiaoli Zhao, Na Li, Chunbo Ma. Residential energy consumption in urbanChina: A decomposition analysis.[J]Energy Policy,2012,41(2):644-653.
    [101] Wang Xiping, Tian Dandan. Laspeyres Decomposition of Energy Intensity inHebei Province.[J]Energy Procedia,2012,14(2):1798–1803.
    [102]齐绍洲,罗威.中国地区经济增长与能源强度差异分析.[J]经济研究,2007(7):75-82.
    [103] Ugur Soytas, Ramazan Sari, Bradley T. Ewing. Energy consumption, income,andcarbon emissions in the United States.[J] Ecological Economics,2007,62(3-4):482-489.
    [104] Ferda Halicioglu.An econometric study of CO2emissions, energyconsumption, income and foreign trade in Turkey.[J] Energy Policy,2009,37(3):1156-1164.
    [105] Pani, Mukhopadhyay. Identifying the major player behind increasing globalcarbon dioxide emissions: A decomposition analysis.[J] Environmentalist,2010,30(2):183-205.
    [106] Ratnakar Pani, Ujjaini Mukhopadhyay. Variance analysis of global CO2emission–amanagement accounting approach for decomposition study[J].Energy,2011,36(1):486-499.
    [107] Chiun-Sin Lin, Fen-May Liou, Chih-Pin Huang. Grey forecasting model forCO2emissions:A Taiwan study[J]. Applied Energy,2011,88(11):3816-3820.
    [108] Karen Turner. Negative rebound and disinvestment effects in response to animprovement in energy efficiency in the UK economy [J]. Energy Economics,2009,31(5):648-666.
    [109] Sam Anson, Karen Turner. Rebound and disinvestment effects in refined oilconsumption and supply resulting from an increase in energy efficiency in theScottish commercial transport sector.[J] Energy Policy,2009,37(9):3608–3620.
    [110] Jinlong Ouyang, Enshen Longa, Kazunori Hokao. Rebound effect in Chinesehousehold energy efficiency and solution for mitigating it[J]. Energy,2010,35(12):5269-5276.
    [111] Fisher, I. The Making of Index Numbers[M]. Boston: Houghton Mifflin,1922.
    [112] Wisniewski, J.K.. Extension of Fisher’s formula number353to three ofmore variables. Journal of the American Statistical Association[J].1931,26:62–65.
    [113] Gini, C. Methods of eliminating the influence of several groups of factors[J].Econometrica,1937,5(1),56–73.
    [114] Seigel, I.H. The bideal Q index-number formula[J]. Journal of the AmericanStatistical Association.1945,40:520–523.
    [115] Liu, F.L., Ang, B.W. Eight methods for decomposing the aggregate energyintensity of industry[J]. Applied Energy,2003,76(1-3):15–23.
    [116] Boyd, G.A., Roop, J.M. A note on the Fisher ideal index decomposition forstructural change in energy intensity[J]. The Energy Journal,2004,25(1):87–101.
    [117] B.W. Ang, F.L. Liu, Hyun-Sik Chung. A generalized Fisher index approach toenergy decomposition analysis[J]. Energy Economics,2004,26(5):757-763.
    [118] Ang.B. W. DecompositionAnalysisfor PolicymakinginEnergy: Whichis thePreferredMethod?[J]. EnergyPolicy,2004,(32):1131-1139.
    [119]韩智勇,魏一鸣,范英。中国能源强度与经济结构变化特征研究[J].数理统计与管理,2004,23(2):1-6.
    [120]钱珍.经济增长、居民消费与保险发展的长期联动效应分析--基于VAR模型和脉冲响应函数的研究[J].统计与信息论坛,2008,23(7):50-54
    [121] Jing You. China’s energy consumption and sustainable development:Comparative evidence from GDP and genuine savings[J]. Renewable andSustainable Energy Reviews,2011(15):2984-2989.
    [122]叶初升,张凤华.政府减贫行为的动态效应--中国农村减贫问题的SVAR模型实证分析(1990-2008)[J].中国人口资源与环境,2011,21(9):123-131.
    [123] Ching-Chih Chang et al. Energy conservation and sustainable economicgrowth: The case of Latin America and the Caribbean[J]. EnergyPolicy,2011(39):4215-4221
    [124] Guo Jianhua et al. Econometrical Investigation on Infrastructure Investmentand Economic Development in China: A Case Study Using Vector AutoregressionApproach[J]. KSCE Journal of Civil Engineering,2011,15(3):561-567.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700