现代风险导向的并购审计风险研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
作为一项以商务控制权为标的的交易,并购在追求协同效应、追求市场势力、降低风险、获取目标公司优势资产等方面发挥着越来越重要的作用。尽管并购对企业的发展有着非同寻常的意义,但并购交易的进行并非总是一帆风顺,其中总是充斥着各种各样的风险。风险的存在在很大程度上影响着并购交易的成功,因此如何甄别和防范并购过程中的风险就成为其中很重要的一项工作。在此,利用专业中介机构如会计师事务所所提供的审计服务则能够在很大程度上防范和降低并购中的风险。
     随着并购交易活动的繁荣发展,并购审计业务也越来越多,然而学术界对并购审计风险相关问题的研究却较少,相对于审计风险理论及一般审计业务的研究,并购审计风险的研究仅是“沧海之一粟”,研究文献很少且不深入、也没有完善的理论分析框架,理论的研究在很大程度上落后于并购审计业务的发展,更无法对并购审计业务进行有效的引导和指导。鉴于此,本文拟针对企业并购这一类特殊审计项目,从注册会计师审计的视角,综合运用企业并购理论、审计风险理论、委托代理理论和博弈理论,深入分析和揭示企业并购各环节涉及的审计风险并提出相应的应对策略。本文的主要内容如下:
     首先,本文从并购审计与一般财务报表审计的共性特征出发,结合并购交易的特点,概括了并购审计的个性特征,包括审计目标、审计关系、审计报告的特殊性;作为一项专项审计业务,并购审计由于增加了与企业并购活动相关的风险因素,具有较高的风险性。对于并购审计高风险性的产生,从信息经济学的角度看,是由于在并购交易过程中普遍存在的信息的不对称。同时,并购交易中不同主体间对利益追求的倾向的不同极易造成各方利益上的冲突,无疑会对审计的独立性产生较大的威胁,从而增大审计的风险。
     其次,在对比传统与现代审计模型的基础上,阐述了并购审计与现代风险导向审计的适用性,把现代风险导向审计模型应用到并购审计中;并对现代风险导向审计模型在并购审计中的具体应用进行了深入的分析。
     再次,本文通过调查问卷的方式,利用层级结构法和模糊评价法,对比分析了一般财务报表审计和并购审计重大错报风险的影响因素以及并购审计重大错报风险点的分布。结果显示:在一般性财务报表审计业务和并购审计业务中,影响重大错报风险因素相对重要性水平有所不同。在并购审计重大错报风险点的分布上,长期股权投资、无形资产、商誉、应交税费、应付职工薪酬、预计负债、营业外收入在所有重大错报风险点中属于第一级重要的财务报表项目。
     最后,根据理论分析和实证分析的结果,本文从会计师事务所和行业主管两个层面提出了防范和控制并购审计风险的对策和建议,包括在重大并购审计业务领域引入有限责任合伙人制度;完善会计师事务所内控体系,确保并购审计的独立性;提高会计师事务所和审计人员专业胜任能力;中国注册会计师协会要针对并购审计特殊领域出台相应业务操作指南。
Merger and Acquisition are transactions targeted at business control, which play an important role in Synergy Effects, market forces, risk reducing and good-quality assets. However, Merger and Acquisition transactions are not plain sailing, which are always filled with a variety of risks. The presence of risks affects the success of Merger and Acquisition. As a result, screening and preventing the risk in the Merger and Acquisition process becomes a very important question. At this time, Merger and Acquisition auditing work is extremely important,which can prevent and decrease the audit risk.
     With the prosperity and development of the Merger and Acquisition transactions, Merger&Acquisition auditing services becomes more and more. However, there are few literatures on Merger and Acquisition auditing risk. Compared with the research of auditing risk theories and the general auditing, the research literature on Merger and Acquisition auditing is not only less and less in-depth, but also no perfect theoretical analysis framework.
     In all, the theoretical research is lagging behind the development of the Merger and Acquisition auditing business, furthermore, the theoretical research cannot do the effective guidance on the Merger and Acquisition auditing service. In view of this, this paper would do some research on the Merger and Acquisition auditing from the perspective of the CPA auditing, using the Merger and Acquisition theory, auditing risk theory, principal-agent theory and game theory, in order to analyze and reveal the various aspects of auditing risk and advances the corresponding strategies.
     Firstly, this paper summed up the specialist of the Merger and Acquisition auditing from its generality, combined with the characteristics of Merger and Acquisition transactions. The specialist of the Merger and Acquisition auditing includes the auditing objective, auditing relationship and the auditing report. As a special auditing services, Merger and Acquisition auditing has the higher risk due to the risk of the Merger&Acquisition transactions. From the perspective of information economics, it is the information asymmetry prevalent in the process of mergers and acquisitions that cause the high risk of the Merger&Acquisition auditing. In the meantime, the different pursuit of the interests among the various participating bodies easily cause the conflict of interests, which no doubt would bring the threat on the auditing dependence, and therefore increasing the auditing risk.
     Secondly, this paper build the Merger and Acquisition audit risk, regarding the specialist of the Merger and Acquisition, with the theory of the modern risk auditing standards. The contents of the model includes:various kinds of the Merger and Acquisition audit transactions, basing on the different periods of the Merger and Acquisition, the stakeholders and focusing on the auditing risk preventing.
     Thirdly, this paper compared the distribution and influencing effect of the risks of significant misstatements of Merger and Acquisition between the general FS audit and Merger and Acquisition audit. The main methods of the comparing research are analytic hierarchy process and fuzzy evaluation method. The results showed that:it is quite different on the significance level of the influencing factors on the significant misstatements between the general Financial Statement audit and Merger and Acquisition audit. On the distribution of the significant misstatements of Merger and Acquisition, long-term equity investment, intangible assets, goodwill, taxes payablevable, accrued payrolletie, accrued liabilities, non-operating incometionsare all belonging first level of important accounts of the risks of material misstatement.
     Finally, this paper draws the following policy suggestions to the prevention and the controlling of the Merger and Acquisition audit risk, based on the theoretical and empirical research from two perspective:the accounting firms and the industry executives.
     The suggestions including as the following:introducing the limited partner system in Merger and Acquisition audit; improving the internal controlling system of the accounting firms; improving the quality of the accounting firms and the auditors; Corresponding operational guidance should be introduced to the Merger and Acquisition by Chinese Institute of Certified Public Accountants.
引文
①张秋生.并购基本理论框架的研究[Z].北京交通大学中国企业兼并重组研究中心工作论文,2005.
    ①沈征.企业兼并的会计与审计架构[D].天津财经学院博士论文,2000.
    ①刘芳,刘海潇.企业兼并审计探讨[J].财会研究,2005(1):64-65.
    ①Brown.R.G. Changing audit objectives and techniques[J].Accounting Review.1962(37):696-703.
    ②AICPA.Statement on auditing standards NO.47:Audit risk and materiality in conducting an audit[R].New York.1983.
    ③ AICPA.AICPA Professional standards[M].Chicago:Commerce Clearing House,Volume2.1988.
    ④Kinney.Jr.,W.R.Achieved audit risk and the audit outcome space[J]. Auditing:A Journal of Practice and Theory, 1989(Supplement):67-84.
    ⑤ Sennetti,J.T.Toward a more consistent model for audit risk[J].Auditing:A Journal of Practice and Theory,1990, Spring:103-112.
    ⑥ BaIachandran.B.V.,Nagarajan.N.J.Imperfect information.insurance.and auditor's legal liability[J].Contemporary Accounting Research,1987(3):281-301.
    ⑦Nelson.J. J.,Ronen.,L. White.Legal liabilities and the market for auditing services[J].Journal of Accounting, Auditing and Finance,1988(3):255-295.
    ⑧ Dye.R.A.Auditing standards,legal liability.and auditor wealth[J].Journal of Political Economy,1993(101): 887-914.
    ①Schwartz,R.Legal regimes.audit quality.and investment[J].The Accounting Review,1997(72):385-406.
    ①孙坤.论审计风险的形成与控制[J].财经问题研究,1995(4):59-62.
    ②胡春元.审计风险研究[M].大连:东北财经大学出版社,1997.
    ③王如燕,武魏巍.新审计风险准则下环境绩效审计风险模型的应用[J].财会月刊.2007(2):56-57.
    ④刘力云.审计风险与控制[M].北京:中国审计出版社,1999.
    ⑤吴联生.审计理论体系结构:一种新观点[J].中国注册会计师,2000(12):15-17.
    ⑥叶忠明.论审计策略[J].郑州航空工业管理学院学报,2001(6):5-8.
    ⑦何毅,杨永宁.审计风险的可保属性初探[J].审计理论与实践,2003(7):22-23.
    ① William W.S.Auditors' assessments of inherent and control risk in field[J].The Accounting Review. 1993,68(4):783-804.
    ② Bloomfield,R.Strategic dependence and inherent risk assessments[J].The Accounting Review.1995.70(1):71-91.
    ③ Mock.T.J.. Wright.A. Are audit program plans risk-adjusted?[J]. Auditing:A Journal of Practice and Theory, 1999,18(1):55-74.
    ④ Dusenbury,R.B.,Reimers.J. L..Wheeler,S.W.The audit risk model:an empirical test for conditioned dependenceies among assessed component risks[J].Auditing.2000,19(2):105-118.
    ⑤ Messier Jr.,W.F.,Austen.L.A.Inherent risk and control risk assessments:evidence on the effect of pervasive and specific risk factors[J].Auditing:A Journal of Practice and Theory,2000,19(2):119-131.
    ⑥Low,Kin-Yew.The effects of industry specialization on audit risk assessments and audit-planning decisions[J]. Accounting Review,2004,79(1):201-219.
    ⑦ Houston,R.W.,Peters,M.F.,Pratt,Jamie H.P.The audit risk model.business risk and audit-planning decisions[J]. Accounting Review,1999,74(3):281-298.
    ⑧ Johnstone.K.M.Client-acceptance decisions:simultaneous effects of client business risk.audit risk,auditor business risk,and risk adaptation[J].A Journal of Practice and Theory,2000,19(1):1-25.
    ①Eilifsen.A., Knechel.W.R., Wallage.P.Application of the business risk audit model:a field study[J]. Accounting Horizons.2001,15(3):193-208.
    ② Fearnley, S.,Beattie,V.,Brandt, R. Auditor independence and audit risk:a reconceptualisation[J]. Journal of International Accounting Research,2005,4(1):39-71.
    ③ Stephan L.,Yves Z., Audit Risk and Rent Extraction:Evidence from a Randomized.working paper,2011.
    ④车嘉丽.上市公司关联交易的审计风险及规避[J].审计理论与实践,2003(6):67-68.
    ⑤卢树华.企业并购专项审计和财务评价[J].现代商业,2007(24):74-75.
    ⑥蒋毓翔.审计风险概念及其模型重构[J].研究与创新,2008(5):36-27.
    ⑦董春丽.构架完整的风险导向审计体系防范审计风险的发生[J].探索与开拓,2008(6).
    ⑧阙圣贵.网络时代的审计风险与防范[N].中国财经报/2008年/1月/18日/第004版.
    ①张萍,王莹.ERP环境下的审计风险研究[J].财会研究.2010(20):71-73.
    ②赵保卿.创业板上市公司审计风险的形成与方法[J].注册会计师.2011(25):26-28.
    ③吴联生.社会审计风险及其责任关系分析[J].审计研究,1995(5):38-41.
    ④陈毓圭.对风险导向审计的由来及其发展的认识[J].会计研究,2004(2):58-63.
    ⑤ Cushing, B.E.,Loebbecke, J.K..Analytical approaches to audit risk:a survey and analysis[J]. Auditing:A Journal of Practice and Theory,1983,3(1):23-41.
    ⑥Rhodes.R.. Auditing Manual.1985.
    ① Richard W.H., Michael F.P., Jamie H.P., The Audit Risk Model, Business Risk and Audit-Planning Decisions[J].The Accounting Review,1999,74(3):281-298.
    ②该模型由莱斯利,奥尔德斯利,科们恩,赖特四位学埏于1986年提出,简称LACR模型.
    ③吴联生.论审计风险决策模型[J].注册会计师通讯,1997(11):18-22.
    ④张友平,张志君.论审计风险模型的改进[J].电子财会,2002(7):20-23.
    ⑤曹筱春,宋夏云,仇丹虹.审计风险模型的应用研究[J].江西社会科学,2003(9):129-130.
    ⑥高晓春,李鸿斌,高振宾.从信息学角度重建审计风险模型[J].审计与经济研究,2003(4):19-22.
    ⑦郭莉.现代审计风险模型及其推行难点分析[J].审计与经济研究,2006(11):46-48.
    ⑧王如燕,武魏巍.新审计风险准则下环境绩效审计风险模型的应用[J].财会月刊(理论),2007(2):56-57.
    ⑨辛旭,刘佳.现代审计风险模型的演进与应用[J].中国沣册会计师,2009(12):57-61.
    ①张萍,王莹.基于模糊综合评判的虚拟企业审计风险评估[J].审计与经济研究,2010(7):44-50.
    ②审计风险=固有风险*控制风险*检查风险
    ③审计风险=重大错报风险*检查风险
    ④谢海洋.审计风险与审计风险模型研究[J].财会研究,2010(24):69-71.
    ⑤葛秋东,程书萍,邱大灿.吴嘉慧.大型工程设计风险模型构建及其应用[J].审计月刊,2011(1):11-12.
    ⑥王会金.基于动态模糊评价的审计风险综合评价模型及其应用[J].会计研究,2011(9):89-95.
    ⑦翟佳琪,田治威,刘诚.FMEA技术对审计风险模型的改进和实证研究[J].生产力研究,2011(2):190-192.
    ⑧马春英,周允征.试论我国环境审计风险模型的构建及应用[J].财经问题研究.2011(8):88-94.
    ①并购审计风险的相关文献综述将单独在2.3节进行阐述。
    ②沈征.企业兼并的会计与审计架构[D].天津财经学院博士论文,2000.
    ③陈兰辉.企业并购审计风险与防范[D].中南大学学位论文,2005.
    ④董竹,李益平.试论企业兼并中的审计[J].审计与经济研究,1999(1):17-18.
    ⑤指出广义的兼并审计是指会计师事务所组织收购专门小组,和投资银行并行参与顾问业务,为兼并企业和被兼并企业设定严密的买收或防御策略,狭义的兼并审计是指会计师事务所在双方签订兼并协议后,为核实资产和利润,确定收购底价而对被兼并企业所施行的综合性审计工作。
    ①朱蕾.并购审计的目标研究[J].当代审计.2002(4):6-7.
    ②张爱民,洪梅.企业并购前期审计的特殊性分析.审计月刊,2009(5):34-35.
    ③傅磊.发挥社会审计机构在企业并购中的作用[J].山东审计,1998(4):36.
    ④张建军.企业兼并应强化审计监督[J].山西经济管理干部学院学报,2001(12):28-29.
    ⑤王咏梅.企业并购过程中的审计风险研究[J].北京工商大学学报,2002(3):48-51.
    ⑥钱桂萍.浅谈并购前对目标公司的审计[J].上海会计,2002(1):54-55.
    ⑦任丽英.企业并购中的审计风险及其防范[J].合作经济与科技,2009(16):52-53.
    ①谢盛纹.企业并购审计的性质和范围[J].上海管理科学,2002(6):35-36.
    ②宗刚.企业购并中的商誉及其审计[J].审计研究,1999(5):49-50.
    ③沈征.企业兼并的会计与审计架构[D].天津财经学院博士论文.2000.
    ④杨雅梅,张丽明,张晓光.企业并购中资产评估问题的探讨[J].河北农业大学学报(农林教育版),2002(1):60-62.
    ①刘芳,刘海潇.企业兼并审计探讨[J].财会研究,2005(1):64-65.
    ②卢树华.企业并购专项审计和财务评价[J].现代商业,2007(24):74-75.
    ③欧阳农,李明海.企业并购过程中置换股权的审计方法探讨[J].武汉金融,2005(9):41-42.
    ④赵瑾.现代风险导向的企业战略性并购审计模式研究[J].武汉理工大学学报,2009(16):162-166.
    ⑤董秋娜.企业并购中关联方交易的审计对策[J].科学咨询,2010(13):119-120.
    ① Healy P,K.,Palepu. R.Ruback.Does corporate performance improve after mergers[J].Journal of Financial Economics.1992.32(2):135-182.
    ②王咏梅.企业并购过程中的审计风险研究[J].北京工商大学学报.2002(3):48-51.
    ③戚计范.企业并购过程中的审计风险与防范[J].上海轻工业,2009(6).
    ④刘宇.对企业并购审计风险的探讨[J].会计之友,2008(5):53.
    ⑤李民,陈兰辉.企业并购交易中的审计风险与防范[J].郑州航空工业管理学院学报.2005(1):65-69.
    ⑥李鑫彬.并购审计及其风险点控制[J].财会学习,2009(9):52-53.
    ⑦魏新.企业并购的审计风险规避[J].财会月刊,2006(10):59-60.
    ⑧周树大.企业并购审计[J].中国内部审计,2008(2):46-49.
    ①潘峰.并购审计风险模型研究[Jl.中央财经大学学报,2012(2):86-89.
    ①张秋生.并购学:一个基本理论框架[M].北京:中国经济出版社,2010.
    ①朱正萱.企业集团与“协同效应”[J].南京理工大学学报(社会科学版),1999(4):66-69.
    ①王长征.企业并购整合[M].武汉大学出版社,2002.
    ② Mautz. R. K., Sharaf.H.A. Philosophy of Auditing[M]. American Accounting Association,1961.
    ①美国注册会计师协会American Institute of Certified Public Accountants简称AICPA是由执业人员(即注册会计师)和非执业人员组成。
    ②加拿大特许会计师协会Chartered Accountants of Canada.简称CICA是加拿大最大的会计师职业团体(民间审计团体)。
    ③ Arens. A. A.,Locbbecke. J. K. Auditing-An integrated approach[M].New York:Prentice-Hall.1992.
    ④辛旭,刘佳.现代审计风险模型的演进与应用[J].中国注册会计师,2009(12):57-61.
    Berle,A., Means.G.The modern corporation and private propertyfM]. New York.Macmillan,1932.
    ① Cournot.A. Recherches sur les principles mathematiques de la theorie des richesses.1838.English edition: Researches into the mathematical principles of the theory of wealth. Edited by N.Bacon.New York:Macmillan, 1897.
    ②Bertrand,J. Theorie mathematique de la richesse sociale[J]. Journal des Savants.1883:499-508.
    ③ Edgeworth.F.Y., The pure theory of monopoly, in papers relating to the political economy.(MacMillan,London). 1925(1):111-142.
    ④John von Neumann., Oskar Morgenstern:Theory of Games and Economic Behavior[M].Princeton University Press,1944.
    ① Nash,J., Equilibrium points in n-persons games[J].Proceedings of the national academy of the sciences. 1950(36):48-49.
    ② Harsanyi,J.,Games with randomly distributed payoffs:a new rationale for mixed strategy equilibrium points[J]. International Journal of Games Theory.1973(2):1-23.
    ③ Krpes.D., R.Wilson. Sequential equilibrium[J].Econometrica,1982(50):863-894.
    ④ Kreps,D.,P..Milgrom,Roberts., R.Wilson, Rational Cooperation in the Finitely Repeated Prisoners Dilemma[J]. Journal of Economic Theory 1982(27):245-252.
    ①张爱民,洪梅.企业并购前期审计的特殊性分析审计月刊,2009(5):34-35.
    ① Cushing, B.E.,Loebbecke, J.K..Analytical approaches to audit risk:a survey and analysis[J]. Auditing:A Journal of Practice and Theory,1983,3(1):23-41.
    ②Rhodes.R.,Auditing Manual.1985.
    ①张洋.借鉴战略管理方法应用现代审计风险模型[D].天津财经大学研究生部,2006.
    ①美国注册会计师协会(AICPA)认为:“固有风险是假定没有内部控制的条件下,财务报表出现重大错误的敏感性。”国际审计准则的定义则为:“固有风险是指假定没有相关的内部控制时,账户余额和业务中存在单个或综合的重大错报的可能性。”《蒙哥马利审计学》第11版的定义认为“固有风险是不考虑内部控制结构时账户余额和业务中存在重大错误的可能性。”
    ④ Bell.T.B., Marrs.F.O., Auditing Organizations through a Strategic Systems Lens, KPMG monograph,1997.
    ②谢荣,吴建友.现代风险导向审计理论研究及实务发展[J].会计研究,2004(4):47-51.
    ③中国注册会计师协会.2011年度注册会计师全国统一考试轴导教材:审计[M].中国财政经济出版社,2011.
    ①张洋.借鉴战略管理方法应用现代审计风险模型[D].天津财经大学研究生部,2006.
    ①张龙平,聂曼曼.试论新审计风险模型的理论进步与运用[J].审计研究,2005(4):26-33.
    ②谢志华,崔学刚.风险导向审计:机理与运用[J].会计研究,2006(7):15-20.
    ③宋夏云.警示系数与现代风险导向审计模型[J].审计与经济研究,2005(2):27-30.
    ①赵瑾.现代风险导向的企业战略性并购审计模式研究[J].武汉理工大学学报,2009(8):162-166.
    ②杭思源.风险导向审计在我国国内会计师事务所运用现状的调查和分析[D].复旦大学,2008.
    ①陈兰辉.企业并购审计风险及防范[D].中南大学,2005.
    ②胡慧.现代风险导向审计的理论框架及其应用研究[D].四川大学,2006.
    ①胡永宏,贺恩辉.综合评价方法[M].北京:科学出版社,2000.
    ②杨纶标.模糊数学原理及应用[M].广州:华南理工大学出版社,2000.
    ①李士勇.工程模糊数学及应用[M].哈尔滨:哈尔滨工业大学出版社.2004.
    ①佟春生.系统工程的理论与方法概论[M].北京:国防工业出版社,2000.
    ①姜启源.数学模型[M].北京:高等教育出版社,2005.
    ①李怀祖.管理研究方法论[M].西安交通大学出版社,2004.
    ② Benbasat. L., Weber.R. Research Commentary:Rethinking "Diversity" in Information Systems Research[J]. Information Systems-Research.1996.7(4):199-389.
    ③ Pinsonneault.A., Kraemer.K. Survey research methodology in management information systems:An A.ssessment[J]. Journal of Management Information Systems.1993.10(2):75-106.
    ① Dunn,S.C.,Seaker,R.F..Waller.M.A.Latent Variables in Business Logistics ResearchrScale Development and Validation[J].Joumal of Business Logistics.1994.15(2):145-172.
    ② Churchill, Jr.G.A. A Paradigm for Developing Better Measures of Marketing Constructs[J].Journal of Marketing.1979.
    ①韩振华,任剑锋.社会调查研究中的社会称许性偏见效应[J].华中科技大学学报.2002(3):47-50.
    ①王立生.社会资本、吸收能力对知识获取和创新绩效的影响研究[D].浙江大学博士研究生学位论文,2007.
    ①李怀祖.管理研究方法论(第二版)[M].西安交通大学出版社.2006:260.
    ①Nunnally. J.C. Psychometric Theory[M].2th ed. New York:McGraw-Hill,1978.
    ① Cronbach, L. J. Coefficient alpha and the internal structure of tests[J]. Psychometrika.1951,16(3): 297-334.
    ①赵瑾.现代风险导向的企业战略性并购审计模式研究[J].武汉理工大学学报,2009(16):162-166.
    [1]AICPA. Auditing Sampling.SAS39, New York:AICPA,1981.
    [2]AICPA. Auditing risk and materiality in conducting an auditing. New York: AICPA,1983.
    [3]AICPA. The auditor's study and evaluation of internal control.Sap54. New York: AICPA,1972.
    [4]Arens.A.A., Locbbecke.J.K. Auditing-An integrated approach[M].New York: Prentice-Hall,1992.
    [5]Balachandran.B.V., Nagarajan. N.J.Imperfect information,insurance,and auditor's legal liability[J].Contemporary Accounting Research,1987(3):281-301.
    [6]Bell.T., Marrs.F.,Solomon.I.,Thomas.H. Auditing Organizations through a Strategic Systems Lens, KPMG monograph,1997.
    [7]Berle.A., Means.G.The modem corporation and private property[M]. New York:Macmillan,1932.
    [8]Benbasat.L., Weber.R. Research Commentary:Rethinking "Diversity" in Information Systems Research[J].Information Systems-Research.1996,7(4): 199-389.
    [9]Bertrand,J. Theorie mathematique de la richesse sociale[J]. Journal des Savants. 1883:499-508.
    [10]Bloomfield.R. Strategic dependence and inherent risk assessments[J].The Accounting Review.1995,70(1):71-91.
    [11]Brown.R.G. Changing audit objectives and techniques [J]. Accounting Review.1962(37):696-703.
    [12]Buckley.J.J.Fuzzy Hierarchical Analysis[J].Fuzzy Sets and Systems,1985(17): 343-350.
    [13]Churchill.Jr.G.A. A Paradigm for Developing Better Measures of Marketing Constructs [J]. Journal of Marketing.1979.
    [14]Coase,R.H. The Nature of the firm[J]. Economica,1937,16(4):386-405.
    [15]Cournot,A. Recherches sur les principles mathematiques de la theorie des richesses,1838.English edition:Researches into the mathematical principles of the theory of wealth. Edited by N.Bacon,New York:Macmillan,1897.
    [16]Cronbach.L. J. Coefficient alpha and the internal structure of tests [J].Psychometrika.1951,16(3):297-334.
    [17]Cushing, B.E.,Loebbecke, J.K. Analytical approaches to audit risk:a survey and analysis[J]. Auditing:A Journal of Practice and Theory,1983,3(1):23-41.
    [18]Cushing, B. E., Graham L.E., Palmrose, J.Z.Risk Orientation, practice, research, and education:A Productive Collaboration[M].New York:Amer Inst of Certified Public,1995.
    [19]Dusenbury,R.B.,Reimers.J. L.,Wheeler,S.W.The audit risk model:an empirical test for conditioned dependenceies among assessed component risks[J].Auditing,2000,19(2):105-118.
    [20]Dunn,S.C.,Seaker,R.F.,Waller,M.A.Latent Variables in Business Logistics Research:Scale Development and Validation[J].Journal of Business Logistics. 1994,15(2):145-172.
    [21]Dye,R.A.Auditing standards,legal liability,and auditor wealth[J].Journal of Political Economy,1993(101):887-914.
    [22]Edgeworth,F.Y., The pure theory of monopoly, in papers relating to the political economy.(MacMillan, London).1925(1):111-142.
    [23]Eilifsen,A., Messier,W.F., Austen,L.A. Characteristics of Auditor Detected Misstatements:Evidence from Norwegian Audits. Working paper, Georgia State University,2000.
    [24]Eilifsen,A., Robert.W. Knechel,Philip Wallage.Application of the business risk audit model:a field study[J].Accounting Horizons,2001,15(3):193-208.
    [25]Fearnley.S., Beattie.V, Brandt.R, Auditor independence and audit risk:a reconceptualisation[J].Journal of International Accounting Research,2005,4(1): 39-71.
    [26]Harsanyi,J.,Games with randomly distributed payoffs:a new rationale for mixed strategy equilibrium points[J]. International Journal of Games Theory.1973(2): 1-23.
    [27]Healy P,M., Palepu.K.G., Ruback.R.C. Does corporate performance improve after mergers[J].Journal of Financial Economics.1992,32(2):135-182.
    [28]Hribar, P., Collins, D.Errors in estimating accruals:Implications for empirical research [J]. Journal of Accounting Research.2002(40):105-134.
    [29]Houston,R.W.,Peters,M.F.,Pratt,Jamie H.P.The audit risk model,business risk and audit-planning decisions[J]. Accounting Review,1999,74(3):281-298.
    [30]Houghton,C.W., Fogarty J.A. Inherent Risk. Auditing [J].A Journal of Practice & Theory(Spring).1991:1-21.
    [31]Johnstone,K.M.Client-acceptance decisions:simultaneous effects of client business risk,audit risk,auditor business risk,and risk adaptation[J].A Journal of Practice and Theory,2000,19(1):1-25.
    [32]John von Neumann., Oskar Morgenstern:Theory of Games and Economic Behavior[M].Princeton University Press,1944.
    [33]Kinney,Jr.,W.R.Achieved audit risk and the audit outcome space[J].Auditing:A Journal of Practice and Theory,1989(Supplement):67-84.
    [34]Krpes,D., Wilson. R. Sequential equilibrium[J].Econometrica,1982(50):863-894.
    [35]Kreps.D.M.,Milgrom.P.,Roberts.J., Wilson.R. Rational Cooperation in the Finitely Repeated Prisoners Dilemma[J]. Journal of Economic Theory. 1982(27):245-252.
    [36]Lin. W. B. A comparative study on the trends of entrepreneurial behaviors of enterprises in different strategies[J]. Expert System with Applications,2006(31): 208-209.
    [37]Low,Kin-Yew.The effects of industry specialization on audit risk assessments and audit-planning decisions[J]. Accounting Review,2004,79(1):201-219.
    [38]Mautz. R. K., Sharaf.H.A. Philosophy of Auditing[M]. American Accounting Association,1961.
    [39]Messier Jr.,W.F.,Austen.L.A.Inherent risk and control risk assessments:evidence on the effect of pervasive and specific risk factors[J].Auditing:A Journal of Practice and Theory,2000,19(2):119-131.
    [40]Mock,T.J., Wright.A. Are audit program plans risk-adjusted?[J].Auditing:A Journal of Practice and Theory,1999,18(1):55-74.
    [41]Nash,J. Equilibrium points in n-persons games[J].Proceedings of the national academy of the sciences.1950(36):48-49.
    [42]Nunnally, J.C. Psychometric Theory[M].2th ed, New York:McGraw-Hill,1978.
    [43]PinsonneauIt.A., Kraemer.K. Survey research methodology in management information systems:An Assessment[J]. Journal of Management Information Systems,1993,10(2):75-106.
    [44]Ray.O.W., Pany.K. Principle of Auditing and Other Assurance Services[M]. China Machine Press,2003.
    [45]Robert.C. Audits:moving from a traditional to a risk-based approach[J]. North Western Financial Revies.2006(16):22.
    [46]Paul J.,Joseph J.Jr. The Role of procedural and declarative knowledge in performing accounting tasks[J]. Behavioral Research in Accounting,1999(11): 1-26.
    [47]Richard W.H., Michael F.P., Jamie H.P., The Audit Risk Model, Business Risk and Audit-Planning Decisions [J].The Accounting Review,1999,74(3):281-298.
    [48]Venkataraman.R., Weber.J., Willenborg.M. Litigation risk, audit quality, and audit fees:evidence from initial public offerings[J]. The Accounting Review, 2008,83(5):1315-1345.
    [49]Robson. R. Auditing Manual.1985.
    [50]Schwartz,R. Legal regimes,audit quality,and investment[J].The Accounting Review,1997(72):385-406.
    [51]Steel. A. Another look at the levels of assurance issue in auditing [J]. Accounting and Business Research,1984(14):8-11.
    [52]Stephan L.,Yves Z., Audit Risk and Rent Extraction:Evidence from a Randomized.working paper,2011.
    [53]Waller.W. S.Auditors' assessments of inherent and control risk in field[J]. The Accounting Review,1993,68(4):783-804.
    [54]Williamson. O.E. Markets and Hierachies:Analysis and Antitrust Implications[M]. New York-London,1975.
    [55]William W.S.Auditors' assessments of inherent and control risk in field[J].The Accounting Review,1993,68(4):783-804.
    [56]Yang.J.T., Liu.Y.H., Sun.Z.L. Research and control of audit risk based on Fuzzy Comprehensive evaluation[C]. The 2nd International Conference on Engineering Management and Service Sciences,2009.9.
    [57]Zadeh.L.A. Fuzzy Sets[J].Information and Control,1965(8):338-353.
    [58]希特等著.吕巍等译.战略管理:竞争与全球化(概念)(原书第六版).北京:机械工业出版社,2005.
    [59]托马斯.惠伦,戴维.亨格著.工毅译.战略管理精要[M].北京:电子工业出版社,2004.
    [60]曹筱春,宋夏云,仇丹虹.审计风险模型的应用研究[J].江西社会科学,2003(9):129-130.
    [61]陈琪,刘星,雷浩.企业并购过程中的审计风险与防范[J].审计与理财,2006(5):24-25.
    [62]陈丹萍.现代审计技术与方法的战略调整[J].审计研究,2000(6):55-59.
    [63]陈兰辉.企业并购审计风险与防范[D].中南大学学位论文,2005.
    [64]陈丽娜,张蕊.略论并购审计业务领域的扩展[J].当代财经,1998(6):32-25.
    [65]陈燕,张戟,盛青辉.企业兼并审计的主要内容与方法[J].会计之友,1998(2):20-21.
    [66]陈毓圭.对风险导向审计的由来及其发展的认识[J].会计研究,1004(2):58-63.
    [67]陈志强.从审计风险模型的改进论风险导向审计的战略调整[J].审计研究,2005(2):78-81.
    [68]池凌娜.企业并购审计风险研究[D].河北大学学位论文,2007.
    [69]车嘉丽.上市公司关联交易的审计风险及规避[J].审计理论与实践,2003(6):67-68.
    [70]董春丽.构架完整的风险导向审计体系防范审计风险的发生[J].探索与开拓,2008(6).
    [71]董竹,李益平.试论企业兼并中的审计[J].审计与经济研究,1999(1):17-18.
    [72]董秋娜.企业并购中关联方交易的审计对策[J].科学咨询,2010(13):119-120.
    [73]傅磊.发挥社会审计机构在企业并购中的作用[J].山东审计,1998(4):36.
    [74]高晓春,李鸿斌,高振宾.从信息学角度重建审计风险模型[J].审计与经济研究,2003(4):19-22.
    [75]高允斌.企业重组的会计处理与纳税处理[M].大连:东北财经大学出版社.
    [76]葛秋东,程书萍,邱大灿,吴嘉慧.大型工程设计风险模型构建及其应用[J].审计月刊,2011(1):11-12.
    [77]郭俊华.并购企业知识资本协同及其价值创造潜能的三维分析[J].科技管理研究,2005(2):143-147.
    [78]郭莉.现代审计风险模型及其推行难点分析[J].审计与经济研究,2006(11):46-48.
    [79]郭瑞东,刘宇赤.企业收购兼并过程中的审计风险研究[J].改革与理论,2002(9):37-40.
    [80]杭思源.风险导向审计在我国国内会计师事务所运用现状的调查和分析[D].复旦大学,2008.
    [81]韩振华,任剑锋.社会调查研究中的社会称许性偏见效应[J].华中科技大学学报,2002(3):47-50.
    [82]何毅,杨永宁.审计风险的可保属性初探[J].审计理论与实践,2003(7):22-23.
    [83]胡继荣,张麟.论社会审计风险评估[J].审计研究,2000(3):14-15.
    [84]胡春元.审计风险研究[M].大连:东北财经大学出版社,1997.
    [85]胡永宏,贺恩辉.综合评价方法[M].北京:科学出版社,2000.
    [86]蒋毓翔.审计风险概念及其模型重构[J].财会通讯,2008(5):36-37.
    [87]姜启源.数学模型[M].北京:高等教育出版社,2005.
    [88]李怀祖.管理研究方法论[M].西安交通大学出版社.2004.
    [89]李民,陈兰辉.企业并购交易中的审计风险与防范[J].郑州航空工业管理学院学报,,2005(1):65-69.
    [90]李士勇.工程模糊数学及应用[M].哈尔滨:哈尔滨工业大学出版社,2004.
    [91]李鑫彬.并购审计及其风险点控制[J].财会学习,2009(9):52-53.
    [92]廖义刚,孙俊奇,陈燕.法律责任、审计风险与事务所客户选择[J].审计与经济研究,2009(5):34-40.
    [93]刘宇.对企业并购审计风险的探讨[J].会计之友,2008(5):53.
    [94]刘文纲.企业购并中的无形资产效应研究[D].中国社会科学院研究生院,2000.
    [95]刘力云.审计风险与控制[M].中国审计出版社.1999
    [96]刘芳,刘海潇.企业兼并审计探讨[J].财会研究,2005(1):64-65.
    [97]卢树华.企业并购专项审计和财务评价[J].现代商业,2007(24):74-75.
    [98]吕跃进.基于模糊一致矩阵的模糊层次分析法的排序[J].模糊系统与数学,2002(2):79-85.
    [99]马春英,周允征.试论我国环境审计风险模型的构建及应用[J].财经问题研究.2011(8):88-94.
    [100]钱桂萍.浅谈并购前对目标公司的审计[J].上海会计,2002(1):54-55.
    [101]欧阳农,李明海.企业并购过程中置换股权的审计方法探讨[J].武汉金融,2005(9):41-42.
    [102]潘峰.并购审计风险模型研究[J].中央财经大学学报,2012(2):86-89.
    [103]戚计范.企业并购过程中的审计风险与防范[J].上海轻工业,2009(6).
    [104]阙圣贵.网络时代的审计风险与防范[N].中国财经报/2008年/1月/18日/第004版.
    [105]任丽英.企业并购中的审计风险及其防范[J].合作经济与科技,2009(16):52-53.
    [106]沈征.企业兼并的会计与审计架构[D].天津财经学院博士论文,2000.
    [107]时杰,郑慧.对企业兼并审计的思考[J].审计与经济研究,2001(1):31-33.
    [108]宋夏云.警示系数与现代风险导向审计模型[J].审计与经济研究,2005(2):27-30.
    [109]孙坤.论审计风险的形成与控制[J].财经问题研究,1995(4):59-62.
    [110]王光远.制度基础审计学[M].湖北科技出版社,1992.
    [111]王会金.风险导向审计[M].北京:中国审计出版社,2000.
    [112]王会金.基于动态模糊评价的审计风险综合评价模型及其应用[J].会计研 究,2011(9):89-95.
    [113]王素梅.国际审计风险模型评析[J].中国注册会计师,2005(8):68-70.
    [114]王宏霞.模糊综合评价在评估重大错报风险中的应用[J].审计月刊,2008(4):52-53.
    [115]王翠林,李西媛.基于重大错报风险评估的新审计风险模型应用研究[J].中国管理信息化,2009(6):49-51.
    [116]王立生.社会资本、吸收能力对知识获取和创新绩效的影响研究[D].浙江大学博士研究生学位论文,2007.
    [117]王咏梅.企业并购过程中的审计风险研究[J].北京工商大学学报,2002(3):48-51.
    [118]王长征.企业并购整合[M].武汉大学出版社,2002.
    [119]王应顺.企业并购中审计风险的探讨[J].当代经理人,2006(1):239-240.
    [120]王如燕,武魏巍.新审计风险准则下环境绩效审计风险模型的应用[J].财会月刊.2007(2):56-57.
    [121]魏新.企业并购的审计风险规避[J].财会月刊,2006(10):59-60.
    [122]吴溪.审计失败中的审计责任认定与脆管倾向:经验分析[J].会计研究,2007(7):53-61.
    [123]武恒光.审计证据、审计风险及不规则关系研究[J]1审计与经济研究,2010(4):21-29.
    [124]吴联生.审计理论体系结构:一种新观点[J].中国注册会计师,2000(12):15-17.
    [125]吴联生.社会审计风险及其责任关系分析[J].审计研究,1995(5):38-41.
    [126]吴联生.论审计风险决策模型[J].注册会计师通讯,1997(11):18-22.
    [127]谢盛纹.企业并购审计的性质和范围[J].上海管理科学,2002(6):35-36.
    [128]谢志华.审计职业判断、审计风险与审计责任[J].审计研究,2000(6):42-47.
    [129]谢志华,崔学刚.风险导向审计:机理与运用[J].会计研究,2006(7):15-20.
    [130]谢荣,吴建友.现代风险导向审计理论研究及实务发展[J].会计研究,2004(4):47-51.
    [131]谢海洋.审汁风险与审汁风险模型研究[J].财会研究,2010(24):69-71.
    [132]辛旭,刘佳.现代审计风险模型的演进与应用[J].中国注册会计师,2009(12):57-61.
    [133]杨雅梅,张丽明,张晓光.企业并购中资产评估问题的探讨[J].河北农业大学学报(农林教育版),2002(1):60-62.
    [134]杨纶标.模糊数学原理及应用[M].广州:华南理工大学出版社,2000.
    [135]叶忠明.论审计策略[J].郑州航空工业管理学院学报,2001(6):5-8.
    [136]张爱民,洪梅.企业并购前期审计的特殊性分析审计月刊,2009(5):34-35.
    [137]张秋生.并购基本理论框架的研究[Z].北京交通大学中国企业兼并重组研究中心工作论文,2005.
    [138]张秋生.并购学:一个基本理论框架[M].北京:中国经济出版社,2010.
    [139]张建军.企业兼并应强化审计监督[J].山西经济管理干部学院学报,2001(12):28-29.
    [140]张来斌,程传勇.审计人员在企业并购中应关注的问题及审计风险的探讨[J].特区经济,2006(5):364-366.
    [141]张文祥.财务报表重大错报风险要素识别与评估[J].财会通讯,2008(1):92-93.
    [142]张友平,张志君.论审计风险模型的改进[J].电子财会,2002(7):20-23.
    [143]张萍,王莹.基于模糊综合评判的虚拟企业审计风险评估[J].审计与经济研究,2010(4):44-50.
    [144]张萍,工莹.ERP环境下的审计风险研究[J].财会研究,2010(20):71-73.
    [145]张龙平,李长爱,邓福贤.国际审计风险准则的最新发展及其启示[J].会计研究.2004(12):76-81.
    [146]张龙平,聂曼曼.试论新审计风险模型的理论进步与运用[J].审计研究,2005(4):26-33.
    [147]张洋.借鉴战略管理方法应用现代审计风险模型[D].天津财经大学研究生部,2006.
    [148]翟佳琪,田治威,刘诚FMEA技术对审计风险模型的改进和实证研究[J].生产力研究,2011(2):190-192.
    [149]赵瑾.现代风险导向的企业战略性并购审计模式研究[J].武汉理工大学学报,2009(16):162-166.
    [150]赵俊星,杨猛.风险导向下的战略审计发展与应用对策[J].河北大学学报,2009(2):60-61.
    [151]赵保卿.创业板上市公司审计风险的形成与方法[J].注册会计师,2011(25):26-28.
    [152]翟华云,廖洪.投资机会、审计风险与审计质量研究[J].审计与经济研究,2011(4):46-53.
    [153]周树大.企业并购审计[J].中国内部审计,2008(2):46-49.
    [154]中国注册会计师协会.2011年度注册会计师全国统一考试辅导教材:审计[M].中国财政经济出版社,2011.
    [155]朱蕾.并购审计的目标研究[J].当代审计,2002(4):6-7.
    [156]朱正萱.企业集团与“协同效应”[J].南京理工大学学报(社会科学版),1999(4):66-69.
    [157]祝青.新审计准则风险导向审计下企业并购审计风险浅析[J].2007(21):110-112.
    [158]宗刚.企业购并中的商誉及其审计[J].审计研究,1999(5):49-50.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700