摘要
美国社会认知发展心理学的创立者John Hurley Flavell在对儿童思维过程进行研究的基础上提出了元认知的概念,即元认知(metacognition)是主体对自身认知活动的认知。元认知的提出引发了学者们对传统智力的反思,成为认知心理学和教育心理学关注的又一焦点。从此,与儿童有关的元记忆、元模仿、阅读理解元认知、数学元认知等研究蓬勃兴起。
本文在以往元认知和数学元认知研究的基础上,采用实验法,以加、减运算为切入点,探索4~6岁儿童数学元认知的发展趋势、年龄特点和性别差异。并在此基础上提出教育建议,以期改变教师数学教学的方式与方法,为儿童已经萌发的数学元认知发展提供适宜的土壤。
本研究对数学元认知构成三要素(数学元认知知识、数学元认知体验和数学元认知监控)及各要素所含子维度进行了全面研究,其结论为:
(1)4~6岁儿童数学元认知随年龄增长而有所提高,但在其构成要素的发展上又存在年龄的特殊性。6岁是儿童数学元认知知识和数学元认知监控发展的重要时期,数学元认知体验在5岁时快速发展。
(2)4~6岁儿童数学元认知体验的发展好于数学元认知知识和数学元认知监控的发展水平。
(3)4~6岁儿童在减法中的数学元认知体验明显好于在加法中的数学元认知体验,但在数学元认知知识和数学元认知监控方面却无显著性差异。
(4)4~6岁儿童数学元认知的发展无明显的性别差异。
(5)虽然测试中儿童乐观主义现象随年龄增长而有所降低,但乐观主义现象始终伴随着儿童数学元认知的发展过程。
John Hurley Flavell, Founder of American social cognitive development psychology, put forward the conception of metacognition based on the researching of children’s thinking process. He considered that metacognition is the cognition of one’s own cognitive behavior. As soon as it is proposed, metacognition attracts the researcher’s attention. It turns into another hotspot and focus in the research of cognitive psychology and educational psychology. From now on, research about metamemory, metaimitation, Reading comprehension metacognition and mathematical metacognition related to children has been the rise.
This article based on the past researches of metacognition and mathematical metacognition. And it adopt experimental method. For the entry point to addition and subtraction operation, exploring 4-6 years old children’s mathematical metacognition development trend, age characteristics and gender differences. Moreover, the article put forward relevant educational suggestion in order to change the mathematics teaching methods and ways of teacher , and promote children’s mathematical met cognition development.
This research comprehensively study the tree elements of mathematical metacognition (mathematical metacognition knowledge, mathematical metacognition experience, mathematical metacognition monitor) and the dimensions of all the elements, The result indicates that:
(1) 4-6 years old children's mathematical metacognition improves with the growth of age, but in the development of its constituent elements there exists special nature of the age. 6-year-old is an important period of the development of mathematical metacognition knowledge and mathematical metacognition monitor, mathematical metacognition experience is experiencing a rapid development at the age of 5.
(2) The development of 4-6 years old children's mathematical metacognition experience is better than the development of mathematical metacognition knowledge and mathematical metacognition monitor.
(3) Mathematical metacognition experience of 4-6 years old children in the subtraction is significantly better than that in addition, but there is no significant difference between mathematical metacognition knowledge and mathematical metacognition monitor.
(4) The development of 4-6 years old Children's mathematical metacognition has no significant gender differences.
(5) Although the phenomenon of children optimism becoming less with the growth of age in the test, the process of children's mathematical metacognitive development is always accompanied by optimism.
引文
1 T.O.Nelson.Consciousness and metacognition.American Psycholgist,1996,51(2):102~116.
2 Flavel.J.H.Metacognition and cognitive monitoring :A new area of cognitive-developmental inquiry.American Psychologist,1979;34:906~911.
1【前苏】克鲁捷茨基.中小学数学能力心理学.上海教育出版社,1987.
1车文博.西方心理学史.杭州:浙江教育出版社,1999:147.
1 Desoete A,Roeyers H,Buysse A.Metacognition and mathematical problem solving in grade 3.Journal of Learning Disabilities,2001,34:435~449.
1 杨英.元认知理论与中学数学教学.东北师范大学硕士学位论文,2002,5.
2 王海英.智慧的跷跷板——幼儿元认知研究.江苏教育出版社,2005:108.
1 Parault S J&Schwanflugel P J.The development of conceptual categories of attention during the elementary school years.Journal of Experimental Child Psychology,2000,75:245~262.
2 陈英和.认知发展心理学.杭州:浙江人民出版社,1996,313~335.
3 江玲,朱琦,王红,吴丹,傅李娜.本体性游戏与幼儿元认知发展的研究.集美大学学报,2003,4(1).
1 李凌.幼儿能力自我知觉的发展研究.华东师范大学博士学位论文,2002:73.
2 Spinath,Birgit & Spinath,Frank M.Longitudinal analysis of the link between learning motivation and competence beliefs among elementary school children.Learning & Instruction,Apr2005,Vol.15 Issue2.
3 Schneider,W.Performance prediction in young children:effects of skill,metacognition and wishful thinking.Developmental Science(1998),Vol.1,Issue 2.
1 黄瑾.学前儿童数学教育.华东师范大学出版社,2007:162.
1 刘金花.儿童发展心理学.上海华东师大出版社, 1997:370~372.
2 王海英.智慧的跷跷板——幼儿元认知研究.江苏教育出版社,2005:166.
1 林崇德,沃建中.7—11 岁儿童自我监控能力的发展及对认知操作的影响.心理发展与教育,1999,15(4).
1 Schneider W,Vise M,Lockl K. Developmental trends in children’s memory monitoring:Evidence from a judgment-of-learning task Cognitive Development,2000(15).
2 Siegler,R.S.Five Generalizations about Cognitive Development.American Psychologist,1938(38).
1 王葵.4~6 岁幼儿的元认知水平对简单加法计算策略的影响研究.西南师范大学硕士学位论文,2004:42.
2 Siegler,R.S,Stern,E.Conscious and unconscious strategy discoveries:a microgenetic analysis.Journal of Experiment Psychology General,1998,127(4).
1 Siegler,R.S,Strategic development.Trends in Cognitive Science,1999,3(11).
1 Bjorklund,D.F.,Gaultney,J thinking.F.,& Green,B.L.(1993).“I watch,therefore I can do”:The development of metaimitation during the preschool years and the advantage of optimism about one’s imitative skills.In M.L.Howe & R.Pasnak(Eds),Emerging themes in cognitive developmen(tPP.79—102)(vol.2).New York:Springer—Verlag.
1 吕凯.影响幼儿能力评价的内外部因素研究.华东师范大学硕士学位论文,2006:47.
1 何洁,徐林,夏霖.教育心理学.上海人民出版社,2007:155~158.
2 朱智贤,林崇德.思维发展心理学.北京师范大学出版社,2002:545~552.
1 Flavell J , friedrichs A . & hoyt J . Developmental changes in memorization processes .cognitive psychology 1970,1:324-340.
2 Tiger,L.optimism:The biology of hope.In Peterson C.The Future of Optimism thinking.American Psychologist ,2000,55:44~55.
1 李凌.幼儿能力自我知觉的发展研究.华东师范大学博士学位论文,2002:71.
2 Stipek D.J,Young children’s performance expectations:Logical analysis or wishful thinking?IN J.G.Nicholls(ed.),the development of achievement motivation Greenwich,Conn.:JAI Press.
1 Fisher,Robert.Thinking About Thinking:Developing Metacognition in Children.Early Child Development and Care.1998,vl41 pl—13.
1李建才,张生春.试谈数学元认知在解题中的作用.首都师范大学学报.1998,Vol.19,No.2.
2陈宁,张庆林.教师期待效应的启示.教育探索.2006(6).
1 庄爱平.“现实数学”的基本思想及其对幼儿数学教育的启示.幼儿教育(教育科学版).2006(6).
1林青松,林婷.强化题后反思,提升数学能力.教学研究.2007(7).
[1]车文博.西方心理学史[M].杭州:浙江教育出版社,1999:147.
[2]姜英杰.元认知的理论与实证研究[M].东北师范大学出版社.2007:3-70.
[3]王海英.智慧的蹊跷板——幼儿元认知研究[M].江苏教育出版社.2005:65-304.
[4]孙连举.数学教育学概论[M].东北师范大学出版社.2004.
[5]朱智贤,林崇德.儿童心理学史[M]北京师范大学出版社.2002.
[6]陈英和.认知发展心理学[M].杭州:浙江人民出版社,1996:313~335.
[7]陈在瑞.数学学习心理学[M].北京:北京师范大学出版社.1996.
[8]曹才翰.章建阅.数学教育心理学[M].人民教育出版社.2006.
[9]黄瑾.学前儿童数学教育[M].华东师范大学出版社.2007:162.
[10]何洁,徐林,夏霖.教育心理学[M].上海人民出版社,2007:155~158.
[11]朱智贤,林崇德.思维发展心理学[M].北京师范大学出版社,2002:545~552.
[12]林泳海.幼儿教育心理学[M].商务印书馆出版,2006.
[13]黄瑾.学前儿童数学教育[M].华东师范大学出版社,2007:162.
[14]刘金花.儿童发展心理学[M].上海华东师大出版社,1997:370~372.
[15]龙毅.试论数学元认知[J].吉林大学学报(自然科学).1994.(6) .
[16]林道荣.非智力因素、元认知与数学教学质量提高[J].数学教育学报.1994(4).
[17]李玉琪.黄晓学.试析数学认知活动中的元认知[J].数学教育学报.1995(4).
[18]李玉琪.论数学元认知与问题解决能力的关系[J].山东师范大学学学报1995(3).
[19]刘东辉.元认知对提高数学思维能力的作用(元认知与数学思维的关系初探) [J].数学通讯.1995(8).
[20]龙毅.利用元认知理论发展学生思维能力[J].数学教育学报.1996(2).
[21]罗新建.论数学元认知的结构[J].四川师范学院学报.1996(6).
[22]张春生.数学元认知结构与数学解题[J].河北师范大学学报.1996(12).
[23]林青松,林婷.强化题后反思,提升数学能力.教学研究.2007(7).
[24]孙连众.数学元认知意识与数学学习[J].北京教育学院学报.1997(3).
[25]桑标.王小华.元认知与学生学习[J].中学数学教学参考.1997.(8).
[26]朱德全.数学问题解决的表征及元认知开发[J].教育研究.1997(3).
[27]董 琦.元认知与思维品质关系性质的相关实验研究[J].北京师范大学学报.1997(9).
[28]庄爱平.“现实数学”的基本思想及其对幼儿数学教育的启示.幼儿教育(教育科学版).2006(6).
[29]李建才.张生春.试谈数学元认知在解题中的作用[J].首都师范大学学报.1998(12).
[30]张庆林.邱江.试论数学解题活动中的元认知[J].首都师范大学学报.1998(6).
[31]周国富.试谈数学教学中如何发展学生元认知[J].中学教学月刊.1998(12).
[32]李玉琪.元认知开发与数学问题解决[J].数学教育学报.1998.8(4).
[33]李建才.试谈数学元认知在解题中的作用[J].首都师范大学学报.1998(6).
[34]毛松军.中学生数学元认知研究[J].数学教育学报.1998. (1).
[35]庞进生.元认知与数学元认知能力综述[J]. 商丘职业技术学院学报.2005.(5).
[36]王光明.王合义.数学元认知研究现状综述[J]. 中学数学教学考.1999.(10).
[37]江玲,朱琦,王红,吴丹,傅李娜.本体性游戏与幼儿元认知发展的研究[J].集美大学学报,2003,4(1).
[38]石晓辉.培养元认知能力与教学生学习[J].中州大学学报.1999.(3).
[39]张亚清.培养元认知能力 教学生学会学习[J].中学数学教学参考.1999.(5).
[40]郭海杰.中学数学学困生问题解决中的元认知知识、技能培训[J].山东师范大学学报(社会科学版).2000.(3).
[41]王晓明.中学生数学元认知能力的培养[J].全球教育展望.2000.(10).
[42]聂爱情.许晓晴. 中学数学问题解决中的元认知知识[J].华南师范大学学报(教育科学版).2000.(1).
[43]汤服成.唐剑岚.中学生数学学习元认知水平的调查分析[J].数学教育学报.2000(6).
[44]王光明.培养数学的元认知.提高问题解决能力[J].数学教育学报.2000.5(1).
[45]张志强.王合义.论元认知水平对数学学习的影响[J].中州大学学报.2000(10).
[46]章建跃.林崇德.中学生数学学科自我监控能力的发展[J].中国教育学刊.2000(8).
[47]蔡挺槐.充分发挥元认知在数学解题中的作用[J].中学教研(数学).2000(7).
[48]周学祁.着力提高学生的“元认知”水平[J].中学数学.2000 年第(7).
[49]程素萍.“元认知”与数学教学[J].数学教育学报.2001(7).
[50]刘明祥.浅论元认知在数学教学中的作用与培养[J].数学教育研究.2001(5).
[51]李中华.浅谈中学生数学元认知能力的培养[J].全球教育展望.2001.(12).
[52]涂荣豹.数学解题学习中的元认知[J].数学教育学报.2002(11).
[53]张乃达.“元认知”与数学教学[J].数学教育学报.2002.(3).
[54]何小亚.建构良好的数学认知结构的教学策略[J].数学教育学报.2002.11(1).
[55]王家聪.数学元认知水平调查问卷的设计[J].中学数学教学参考.2003(4).
[56]张奠宙.元认知与提出数学问题[J].贵州师范大学学报.2003(11).
[57]李洪玉.尹洪新.儿童元认知发展的研究综述[J].心理与行为研究.2004(2).
[58]匡荣.谈开发学生数学元认知能力[J].中国成人教育.2006(12).
[59]林崇德,沃建中.7—11岁儿童自我监控能力的发展及对认知操作的影响[J].心理发展与教育,1999,15(12).
[60]陈英和,王雨晴,肖兴荣.幼儿加减法运算中的策略发展特点[J].心理与行为研究,2006,4(1).
[61]沃建中,李峰,张宏.5~10岁儿童策略优越性及策略选择的个体差异的研究[J].心理科学,2006,4(1).
[62]刘凡,David D.Geary,C.Christine Bow Thomas Robert S.Siegler.数字记忆广度对策略应用的影响——中美儿童计算能力差异的比较研究[J].心理科学,1994(1) .
[63]石伟,黄希庭.内隐自尊心研究[J].心理科学,2003(4).
[64]李垒.谈数学教学中的问题解决与元认知开发[J].科学咨询(教育科研),2006(9).
[65]杨英.元认知理论与中学数学教学[D]:[硕士学位论文].长春:东北师范大学,2002.
[66]毛松军.中学生数学元认知研究[D]:[硕士学位论文].长沙:湖南师范大学,2004.
[67]王葵.4-6岁幼儿的元认知水平对简单加法计算策略的影响研究[D]:[硕士学位论文].重庆:西南师范大学,2004.
[68]吕凯.影响幼儿能力评价的内外部因素研究[D]:[硕士学位论文].上海:华东师范大学,2006:47.
[69]陆丽华.幼儿体验的研究[D]:[硕士学位论文].南京:南京师范大学,2006.
[70]张磊.数学元认知研究现状的综述[D]:[硕士学位论文].长春:东北师范大学,2006.
[71]杨蕾.大班幼儿加减法运算策略选择的研究[D]:[硕士学位论文].上海:华东师范大学,2006.
[72]李凌.幼儿能力自我知觉的发展研究[D]:[博士学位论文].上海:华东师范大学,2002.
[73]邹晓燕.3—5岁儿童独立性发展特点与影响因素研究[D]:[博士学位论文].大连:辽宁师范大学,2004.
[74]Flavell.J.H.Metacognitive aspects of problem solving [C].In:LB Resnick ed.The Nature of Intelligence.Hillsdale,NJ:Erlbaum,1976:232.
[75]Flavel.J.H..Metacognition and cognitive monitoring:A new area of cognitive-developmental inquiry.American Psychologist,1979(34):906-911.
[76]Baker.L,Brown A.L.Metacognitive skills and reading[M].New York:Longman,1984:353-387.
[77]J.D.Day & Borowski.J.G.The concept of intelligence in diagnosis,theory construction and educational practice.In J.D.Day&J.G.Borkowski (Eds.),Intelligence and exceptionality:New directions for theory,assessment,and instructional practices.Norwood,NJ:Ablex Publishing Corporation.1987:3-18.
[78]J.G.Borkowski &Murtukrishna,N.Moving metacognition into the classroom:“Working models”and effective strategy teaching.In M.Pressley,K.R.Harris,& J.T.Guthrie (Eds.),Promoting academic literacy:Cognitive research and instructional innovation.Orlando,FL:Academic Press.1992:477-501.
[79]T.O.Nelson.Consciousness and metacognition.American Psycholgist,1996(51):102-116.
[80]Guajardo.N.R,Turley-Ames.K.J,Preschoolers’generation of different types of counterfactual statements and theory of mind understanding.Cognitive Delevepment.2004(19):53-80.
[81]Turley-Ames.K.J,Whitfield.M.Working memeory and controlled processing of counterfactuals.Paper presented at the lst Annual Meeting of the Society for Personality and Social Psychology,Nashville,TN,2000.
[82]G.riffin,Building number sense with Nunber Worlds Amathematics program for young children.Early Childhood Research Quarterly.2004(19):173-180.
[83]Parault.S.J.& Schwanflugel P.J,The development of conceptual categories of attention during the elementary school years.Journal of Experimental Child Psychology,2000(75):245-262.
[84]Schneider.W,Vise.M,Lockl.K,Developmental trends in children’s memory monitoring:Evidence from a judgment-of-learning task Cognitive Development,2000(15).
[85]Siegler.R.S.Five Generalizations about Cognitive Development.American Psychologist.193:(38).
[86]Siegler.R.S,Conscious and unconscious strategy discoveries:amicrogenetic analysis.Journal of Experiment Psychology General,1998,127(4).
[87]Siegler,R.S,Strategic development.Trends in Cognitive Science,1999,3(11).
[88]Flavell.J,friedrichs.A& hoyt.J,Developmental changes in memorization processes.cognitive psychology 1970(1):324-340.
[89]Tiger,L.optimism:The biology of hope.In Peterson C.The Future of Optimism,American Psychologist,2000(55):44-55.
[90]Stipek.D.J,Young children’s performance expectations:Logical analysis or wishful thinking?IN J.G.Nicholls(ed.),the development of achievement motivation Greenwich,Conn.JAI Press.
[91]Fisher,Robert.Thinking About Thinking:Developing Metacognition in Children.Early Child Development and Care.1998(41 ):l-13.
[92]Spinath,Birgit & Spinath,Frank.M,Longitudinal analysis of the link between learning motivation and competence beliefs among elementary school children.Learning & Instruction,Apr 2005,Vol.15 Issue2,p87,16p.
[93]Desoete.A,Roeyers.H,Buysse.A,Metacognition and mathematical problem solving in grade 3.Journal of Learning Disabilities,2001(34):435-44.