异质性劳动力流动与中国地区收入差距:理论与实证
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
劳动力空间流动与区域收入差距之间的关系,是经济学研究的一个重要论题。迄今国内外围绕这个论题的研究成果,大多都有个或明或暗的假定条件,即假定流动劳动力之间没有任何差异。现实世界并非如此,现实世界中,流动劳动力的异质性是个普遍现象,流动劳动力之间不仅存在性别、年龄、体力与智力等差异,而且存在文化程度、劳动技能乃至观念等差异,后者无疑会引出流动劳动力的制度约束以致区域流动模式的差异,进而通过区域经济的空间分化影响地区之间的收入差距。本文目的,就在于引入流动劳动力的异质性条件,就劳动力流动对地区收入差距的影响进行理论分析与实证检验。这样一种研究的理论及现实意义在于,通过构建异质性劳动力流动与地区收入差距的空间均衡模型,系统地梳理出两者之间的内在作用机理,以便在新经济地理学框架下进一步拓展研究空间。从劳动力流动与地区收入差距的内生关系入手,可望就有关的政府政策措施提出若干评判。
     理论分析构成本文的基础部分,基于新经济地理学的分析框架以及人力资本的外部性,本文构建了一个反映异质性劳动力流动、产业集聚与地区收入差距三个变量之间内生关系的模型。由于引入流动劳动力的异质性,模型修正了以往关于劳动力流动与产业集聚的空间均衡条件,并由此引出地区收入差距论题。借助于这个模型,本文对以下几个变量的关系做了理论分析:首先是异质性劳动力流动与产业集聚的关系。由于存在规模报酬递增、不完全晚争市场以及人力资本的外部性,高技能劳动力流动所引致的集聚向心力大于低技能劳动力流动。当运输成本不断下降时,高技能劳动力流动可率先获得集聚的动力,产业向某个地区集聚起来,这时集聚地区工资水平不断上升,市场容量不断增大,产业集聚水平提高,形成核心—外围的稳定均衡。随着运输成本的进一步下降,低技能劳动力流动也可引发产业集聚效应;其次是产业集聚与地区收入差距的关系。对不同均衡状态的福利分析表明,核心地区收入水平高于外围地区,核心与外围地区之间存在一定的收入差距。当运输成本下降时,产业布局由最初的均匀对称分布向完全集聚演变,这种空间均衡状态的变化与社会福利最大化基本保持一致。而在完全集聚的核心—外围结构中,核心地区由于可享有多样化的工业消费品以及低运输成本,人均收入水平高于外围地区,核心与外围地区之间存在一定的收入差距;最后分析了异质劳动力的流动性与地区收入差距的关系。如果限制低技能劳动力区域流动,高技能劳动力的流动将促进地区产业集聚,同时这种局部集聚将扩大地区之间的收入差距;如果限制高技能劳动力区域流动,低技能劳动力流动仅能导致较低水平的产业集聚,但是可以缓解地区之间的收入差距。
     实证研究利用中国的省域数据主要考察了异质性劳动力流动、产业集聚与地区收入差距几个变量之间的关系。首先将异质性劳动力流动所引致的循环累积因果效应分解成两种易于检验的关联效应——前向关联效应和后向关联效应,具体地说就是检验劳动力迁移是否受地区市场容量的影响、地区异质性劳动力的工资水平是否由该地区市场容量所决定,地区市场容量可通过市场潜力指数反映。其次,通过纵向考察我国近年来工业集聚以及地区收入差距的变动趋势,对产业集聚与地区收入差距进行相关性分析。
     实证分析得出的主要结论是:中国劳动力流动受到地区市场潜力以及地区高技能劳动力存量的双重影响,市场潜力指数越大、高技能劳动力存量越大的地区,劳动力迁入的概率越高,从而证实异质性劳动力流动与产业集聚存在前向关联效应;异质性劳动力流动与产业集聚的后向关联效应也得到证实,而且这种效应有逐步增强的趋势。市场潜力指数越大、需求越高的地区,劳动力工资水平也越高。与低技能劳动力相比,高技能劳动力工资水平与地区市场潜力的关联效应更强;我国工业尤其是高技术产业向东部沿海地区集聚程度不断加深,同时沿海与内陆地区之间的收入差距有逐步扩大之势,收入差距的主要来源是沿海与内陆之间的差距,产业集聚程度与地区收入差距之间表现为显著的相关性。
     最后对我国异质性劳动力流动与地区收入变化的前景作出判断,并针对可能存在的问题提出相应的对策和建议。
The relationship between migration and regional income disparity has been an important topic for the economic research. So far, most of the literature on this topic has made the same assumption that is the labor homogeneity. However, that is not the case. In reality, labor heterogeneity is a common phenomenon. Labor heterogeneity lies in gender, age, physical force, mentality and concept, as well as education and skill. These differences undoubtly would cause the differences in the institutions and regional migration patterns that the migrating labor face, which affects the regional income disparity through the regional economic spatial disparity. This paper attempts to analyze the effect of the heterogeneous labor migration on the regional income disparity theoretically and empirically by introducing the labor homogeneity. The theoretical meaning of this paper is to illustrate the internal mechanisms between the heterogeneous labor migration and the regional income disparity by constructing a spatial equilibrium model of them. The research area about the new economic geography is developed. The empirical meaning of this paper is to properly understand the internal relationship between the heterogeneous labor migration and the regional income disparity and provide some policy instructions to the government on the regional economic plan and labor migration.
     Theoretical research is the basis of this paper. Based on the new economic geography, this paper constructs an endogenous model about the heterogeneous labor migration, agglomeration and regional income disparity. Due to the introduction of labor heterogeneity, the spatial equilibrium condition which was in previous studies for the heterogeneous labor migration and agglomeration has changed and cased the regional disparity. Based on this model, this paper analyzes the following relationships: First, the relationship between the heterogeneous labor migration and agglomeration is analyzed. The skilled migration generates stronger agglomeration forces than the unskilled. When the transport cost reduces, due to increasing return, monopolistic competition and human capital externalities, the skilled obtain the agglomeration forces in the first place and the industry agglomerates in the same place. The wage in this place increases and the market potential rises as well, which in turn promotes the industrial agglomeration and eventually become a core-periphery equilibrium. With the transport cost reducing, the unskilled can also generate the agglomeration effects. Second, the relationship between agglomeratin and regional income disparity is analyzed. The welfare analysis on different equilibriums conditions shows that the income in the core is higher than the periphery and there exists the income distance between the core and the periphery. When the transport cost reduces, the industrial distribution changes from the symmetry to the agglomeration, which is consistent with the social welfare maximum. While under the core-periphery condition, because of the variety of the manufacturing products and low transport cost, the income per worker is higher in the core than in the periphery and there exists the income gap between the core and the periphery. Third, this paper also analyzes the effect of the heterogeneous labor migration on the regional income disparity. If the unskilled mobility is prohibited, then the skilled migration will result in local agglomeration and widens the regional income disparity. On the contrary, if the skilled mobility is prohibited, then the unskilled migration will result in the low-level agglomeration and alleviate the regional income disparity.
     Empirically, this paper examines the relationship between the heterogeneous labor migration, agglomeration and the regional income disparity by using the provincial level data in China. Firstly, we divide the circular effects caused by the heterogeneous migration into forward and backward linkage effects. This is aims to analyze whether the migration is affected by the regional market size and whether the heterogeneous labor wage level is determined by the regional market size, which can be measured by the local market potential index. Secondly, through examining the recent trend of the industrial agglomeration and regional income disparity in China, we conduct a relevant analysis of the industrial agglomeration and regional income disparity.
     The main empirical results are following. The Chinese migration is affected both by the local market potential and the human capital stock. The higher the market potential index and the human capital stock, the higher labor inflow probabilities. This confirms the forward linkage between the heterogeneous migration and agglomeration. The backward linkage between the heterogeneous migration and agglomeration is also confirms. And such effect is on a rising trend. The higher the market potential index and local market demand, the higher labor wages. The linkage between the skilled wage level and the local market potential is stronger than the unskilled wage level. Moreover, more and more industries, especially the hi-tech industries, agglomerate in the East. And the income disparity between the inland and the coast is increasing. The main source of this disparity is the gap between the inland and the coast. The industrial agglomeration and the regional disparity appear to be highly correlated.
     Finally, this paper illustrates the general trends of heterogeneous migration and regional income, and also provides some policy implications and suggestions.
引文
[1] Almeida P. and Kogut B., Localization of Knowledge and the Mobility of Engineers in Regional Networks [J]. Management Science, 1999, Vol.45(7), 905-917.
    
    [2] Arrow, K. J., Economic welfare and the allocation of resources for invention [C]. In The rate and direction of inventive activity: Economic and social factors, 1962, vol. 13, ed. R. R. Nelson, 609-25. NBER Special Conference Series. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
    [3] Au, Chun-Chung; Henderson, J. Vernon, How Migration Restrictions Limit Agglomeration and Productivity in China [J]. Journal of Development Economics, 2006, Vol. 80 (2), 350-388.
    [4] Audretsch, D. B., and Feldman, M. P., R&D Spillovers and the Ggeography of Innovation and Production [J]. American Economic Review, 1996, Vol.86, No.3, 630-640.
    [5] Baldwin, R., R. Forslid, P. Martin, G.Ottaviano and F. Robert-Nicoud, Economic Geography and Public Policy [M], Princeton: Princeton University Press. 2003.
    [6] Baldwin, R.E. and P. Martin, Agglomeration and regional growth, in V. Henderson and J.F. Thisse, eds., Handbook of Regional and Urban Economics: Cities and Geography, North-Holland, Amsterdam. 2003.
    [7] Barham, B. and S. Boucher, Migration, Remittances, and Inequality: Estimating the Net Effects of Migration on Income Distribution [J], Journal of Development Economics, 1998, 55:307-331.
    
    [8] Barro, R. and X. Sala-i-Martin. Economic growth [M], Cambridge: McGraw-Hill, 1995.
    [9] Bauer T. and K. Zimmermann. 'Causes of International Migration' in Gorter C., P.Nijkamp and J.Poot, Crossing Borders: Regional and Urban Perspectives on International Migration [M],Ashgate,Aldershot, 1999.
    [10] Becker G., Investment in Human Capital: A Theoretical Analysis [J]. Journal of Political Economy, 1962, 70(1): 9 - 49.
    
    [11] Beine, M., Docquier, F., Rapoport, H., Brain drain and economic growth: theory and evidence [J]. Journal of Development Economics, 2001,64: 275-289.
    [12] Beine, M., Docquier, F., Rapoport, H., Brain drain and LDCs' growth: winners and losers, Discussion Paper No 819, IZA, Berlin, 2003.
    [13] Bellante D, The North-South Differential and the Migration of Heterogeneous Labor [J], The American Economic Review, 1979, Vol.69, No.1: 166-175.
    [14] Bhagwati, J. N., Hamada, K., The brain drain, international integration of markets for professionals and unemployment [J]. Journal of Development Economics, 1974, 1: 19-42.
    [15] Bhide, A., How entrepreneurs craft strategies that work [J]. Harvard Business Review, 1994, 72, no. 2: 150-61.
    [16] Borjas, G. J., Self-Selection and the Earnings of Immigrants [J], American Economic Review, 1987, 77(4):531-53.
    [17] Borjas, G. J., Friends or strangers: The impact of immigrants on the U.S. economy [M], New York: Basic Books, 1990.
    [18] Borjas, G.J., Bratsberg, B., Who leaves? The outmigration of the foreign-born [J]. Review of Economics and Statistics, 1996, 78: 165-176.
    [19] Borjas, G.J., Heaven's Door: Immigration Policy and the American Economy [M], Princeto, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1999.
    [20] Brakman, S. and B.J. Heijdra, eds., The monopolistic competition revolution in retrospect [M], Cambridge University Press, 2004.
    [21] CiccOne A.and Hall R., Productivity and the density of economic activities [J]. American Economic Review, 1996, 86: 54-70 .
    [22] Combes, P-P. and H. Overman, The spatial distribution of economic activities in the European Union. In Handbook of Regional and Urban Economics, V. Henderson and J-F. Thisse (eds.), vol. 4, Amsterdam: Elsevier, 2004.
    [23] Coniglio, N., Regional Integration and Migration: an Economic Geography Model with Heterogeneous Labour Force [M], 2001, December, University of Glasgow manuscript.
    [24] Crozet M., Do migrants follow Market Potentials? An Estimation of a new Economic Geography Model [J], Journal of Economic Geography, 2004,4:439-458.
    [25] Dapeng Hu, Trade, rural-urban migration, and regional income disparity in developing countries: a spatial general equilibrium model inspired by the case of China [J], Regional Science and Urban Economics 32(2002): 311-338.
    [26] Davis, D., Weinstein, D., Economic geography and regional production structure: an empirical investigation [J]. European Economic Review, 1999,43 (2): 379 - 407.
    [27] Dixit, A. and J. Stiglitz, Monopolistic Competition and Optimum Product Diversity [J], American Economic Review, 1977,67(3): 297-308.
    [28] Dunlevy, J. A., Factor Endowments, Heterogeneous Labor and North-South Migration [J], Southern Economic Journal, 1985, 52(2): 446-59.
    [29] Ellison, G.and E. Glaeser, Geographic concentration in US manufacturing industries: A dartboard approach [J], Journal o Political Economy, 1997, 105: 889-927.
    [30] Feldman, M. P., and Audretsch, D. B., Science-based diversity, specialization, localized competition and innovation [M], Mimeo, 1996.
    [31] Feldman, M. P., The New Economics of Innovation, Spillovers and Agglomeration: A Review of Empirical Studies [J]. Econ. Innov. New Techn., 1999, Vol.8: 5-25.
    [32] Filer, R. K., Gylfason, T., Jurajda, S. and Mitchell, J., Markets and growth in the post-communist world [C], Global Development Network, Washington, DC, Mimeo, 2001.
    [33] Fujita M, Krugman PR, Venables AJ. The Spatial Economy: Cities, Regions and International Trade [MJ. Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press, 1999.
    [34] Fujita, M. and P. Krugman, The new economic geography: Past, present and future [J], Regional Science, 2004, 83:139-164.
    [35] George J. Borjas, The Econimics of Immigration [J], Journal of Economic Literature, 1994, Vol. 32, No. 4, pp: 1667-1717.
    [36] Glaeser, E., J. Scheinkman and A. Shleifer, Economic growth in a cross-section of cities [J], Journa of Monetary Economics, 1995,36, pp: 117-143.
    [37] Gould, D. M., Immigrant links to the home country: empirical implications for US bilateral trade flows [J]. Review of Economics and Statistics, 1994, 76, pp: 302-316.
    [38] Hagerstrand, T., 'Migration and area' [C], in Hannerberg, D. et al.(eds), Migration in Sweden, 1957, pp.27-158, Lund Studies in Geography, 13B.
    [39] Haaland, J., H-J. Kind and K.-H. Midelfart Knarvik, What determines the economic geography of Europe?, CEPR Discussion Paper 207.2, 1999.
    [40] Hanson, G. H., Market potential, increasing returns, and geographic concentration [J], Journal of International Economics, 2005,67(1): 1-24.
    [41] Harris, C. D., The Market as a factor in the Localization of Industry in the United States [J], Annals of the Association of American Geographer, 1954, 44, pp: 315-348.
    [42] Harris, John R.; Todaro, Michael P., Migration Unemployment and Development: a Two Sector Analysis [J], American Economic Review, 1970, Vol. 60(1), pp: 126-142.
    [43] Head, K. and T. Mayer, The empirics of agglomeration and trade. In V. Henderson and J.-F. Thisse (eds.) Handbook of Regional and U ban Economics, 2004, vol. 4, Amsterdam: Elsevier.
    [44] Head, K., Mayer, T., Regional Wage and Employment Responses to Market Potential in the EU [J]. Regional science and Urban Economics, 2006, 36, pp: 573 - 594.
    [45] Helpman, E., 'The Size of Regions' In D. Pines, E. Sadka, and I. Zilcha, eds., Topics in Public Economics, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998.
    [46] Hicks, J., The Theory of Wages [M], Macmillan, London, 1932.
    [47] Hu D., Trade, rural-urban migration, and regional income disparity in developing countries: a spatial egeneral equilibrium model inspired by the case of China [J], Ragional Science and Urban Economics, 2002,32, pp: 311-38.
    [48] Jaffe, A., The real effects of academic research [J]. American Economic Review, 1989, 79, pp: 957-970.
    [49] Jaffe, A. and Henderson, R.., Geographical Localization of Knowledge Spillovers as Evidenced by Patent Citations [J]. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 1993, 108, pp: 577-598.
    [50] Justin Y Lin; Gewei Wang; Yaohui Zhao, Regional Inequality and Labor Transfers in China, Economic Development and Cultural Change; Apr 2004; 52, 3; ABI/INFORM Global, pp: 587-603.
    [51] Kanbur R. and Rapoport H., Migation selectivity and the Evolution of Spatial Inequality [J]. Journal of Economic Geography, 2005, 5, pp.43-57.
    [52] Kim, S., Expansion of markets and the geographic distribution of economic activities: The trends in US regional manufacturing structure, 1860-1987 [J], Quarterly Journal of Economics, 1995, 110, pp: 881-908.
    [53] Knight J;, L. Song and J. Huaibin, Chinese rural migrants in urban enterprises [J], Journal of Development Studies, 1999, 35, 3, pp: 73-104.
    
    [54] Kottis A., Mobility and Human Capital Theory: The Education, Age, Race, and Income Characteristics of Migrants [J]. The Annals of Regional Science, 1972, pp: 41-60.
    [55] Krugman, Paul R., Increasing returns and economic geography [J], Journal of Political Economy, 1991,99, pp: 483-499.
    [56] Krugman, Paul R., Venables, A. J., Globalization and the Inequality of Nations [J], Quarterly Journal of Economics, 1995,110, pp: 857-880.
    [57] Krugman, Paul R., 1998a, Space: The final frontier [J], Journal of Economic Perspectives 12, 161-174.
    [58] Krugman, Paul R., 1998b, What's New About the New Economic Geography? [J] Oxford Review of Economic Policy 14(2) ,7-17.
    [59] Larramona G.and Sanso M., Migration dynamics, growth and convergence [J]. Journal of Economic Dynamics & Control, 2006,30, pp: 2261-2279.
    [60] Larry H. Long, Migration Differentials by Education and Occupation: Trends and Variations [J], Demography, May 1973, pp: 245.
    [61] Lipton, M., Migration from Rural Areas of Poor Countries: The Impact on Rural Productivity and Income Distribution [J], World Development, 1980, 8 (1), pp: 1-24.
    [62] Lucas R. E. B., Stark O., Motivations to remit: the case of Botswana [J], Journal of Political Economy, 1985, 93(5), pp: 901-918.
    [63] Lucas R., Emigration to South Africa's Mines [J], The American Economic Review, 1987, 77, pp: 313-330.
    [64] Lucas, R. E. Jr., On the mechanics of economic development [J], Journal of Monetary Economics, 1988,22(1), pp: 3-42.
    [65] Lucas, R. E., 'Internal Migration in Developing Countries', in M. Rosenzweig and O. Stark (eds.), 'Handbook of Population and Family Economics, vol. 1B', Amsterdam: Elsevier Science Publishing, 1997.
    [66] Martin, R., The new 'geographical turn' in economics: Some critical reflections [J], Cambridge Journal of Economics, 1999, vol. 23, no. 1, pp: 65-91.
    [67] Martin, P. and G.Ottaviano, Growing Locations: Industry Location in a Model of Endogenous Growth [J], European Economic Review, 1999,43, pp: 281-302.
    [68] McKenzie D., Beyond remittances: the effects of migration on Mexican households, in International Migration, Remittances and the Brain Drain [J], Ozden and Schiff eds., the World Bank and Palgrave Macmillan, 2005, pp: 123-47.
    [69] Mion, G., Spatial Externalities and Empirical Analysis: The Case of Italy [J], Journal of Urban Economics, 2004, 56, pp: 97-118.
    [70] Mφen, J., Is Mobility of Technical Personnel a Source of R&D Spillovers? [J], Journal of Labor Economics, 2005, Vol. 23(1), pp:81-114.
    [71] Neal L. and Uselding P., Immigration: A Neglected Source of American Economic Growth, 1790 to 1912 [J]. Oxford Economic Papers, 1972, 24, pp: 68-88.
    [72] Oded Stark; David E. Bloom, The New Economics of Labor Migration [J], The American Economic Review, 1985, Vol. 75, No. 2, pp: 173-178.
    [73] Ottaviano, G.I.P., Regional policy in the global economy: Insights from new economic geography, HWWA, Discussion Paper 211,2002.
    [74] Owen, D. and Green, A., 'Migration Patterns and Trends' in Champion, T. and Fielding, T. (Eds), Migration Processes and Patterns - Volume 2 Research Progress and Prospects, Belhaven Press, London, 1992.
    [75] Pakes, A., and S. Nitzan, Optimum contracts for research personnel, research employment, and the establishment of "rival" enterprises [J]. Journal of Labor Economics, 1983, 1, pp: 345-65.
    [76] Pissarides, C. and J. Wadsworth, Unemployment and the Inter-regional Mobility of Labour [J]. Economic Journal, 1989,99(397), pp: 739-755.
    [77] Psacharopoulos, G, Returns to investment in Education: A Global Update [J]. World Development, 1994, 22(9), pp: 1325-1343.
    [78] Psacharopoulos, G., A. Patrinos, Returns to investment in Education: A Further Update [J]. Education Economics, 2004,12(2), pp: 111-134.
    [79] Poirine B, A Theory of Remittances as an Implicit Family Loan Arrangement [J], World Economy, 1997, 25, pp: 589-611.
    [80] Pryor, R. J., "Laws of Migration?"-the experience of Malaysia and other countries, Grographica (Kuala Lumpur), 1969, 5, pp: 65-76.
    [81] Puga, D., The rise and fall of regional inequalities [J], European Economic Review, 1999, vol. 43, pp: 303-334.
    
    [82] Rauch, J., Economic development, urban underemployment, and income inequality [J]. Canadian Journal of Economics XXVI, 1993, pp: 901 - 918.
    [83] Rauch, J. E., Trindade, V., Ethnic Chinese networks in international trade [J], Review of Economics and Statistics, 2002, 84,1, pp: 116-30.
    [84] Redding S., Anthony J. Venables, Economic geography and international inequality [J], Journal of International Economics, 2004,62, pp: 53-82.
    [85] Roberts K., The determinants of job choice by rural labor migrants in Shanghai [J], China Economic Review, 2001, 12, pp: 15-39.
    [86] Roos M., Wages and Market Potential in Germany, University of Dortmund Working Paper No. 00-09, 2000.
    [87] Roseman, C. C., Migration as a spatial and temporal process [J], Annals, Association of American Geographers, 1971, 61, pp: 589-598.
    [88] Rosen, S., Learning and experience in the labor market [J]. Journal of Human Resources, 1972, 7, no. 3, pp: 326-42.
    [89] Rosenthal S. and Strange W., The determinants of agglomeration [J]. Journal of Urban Economics, 2001, 50, pp: 191~229.
    [90] Roy, A. D., The Distribution of Earnings and of Individual Output [J], The Economic Journal, 1950, Vol. 60, No.239. (Sep., 1950), pp: 489-505.
    [91] Rozelle S., Taylor J. and A. deBrauw, Migration, remittances, and agricultural productivity in China [J], American Economic Review, 1999, 89, pp: 287-91.
    [92] Sattinger, M., Assignment Models of the Distribution of Earnings [J], Journal of Economic Literature, 1993, Vol. 31, No.2., pp: 831-880.
    [93] Schultz, T. W., Investment in Human Capital [J], American Economic Review, 1961, 51, pp: 1-17.
    [94] Scully, G. W., Interstate Wage Differentials: A Cross Section Analysis [J], The American Economic Review, 1969, Vol. 59, No.5. pp: 757-773.
    [95] Sjaastad L.A., The Costs and Returns of Human Migration [J], The Journal of Political Economy, 1962, vol. 70(5), pp: 80-93
    
    [96] Stark, O., The migration of labor [M]. Cambridge: Blackwell, 1991.
    [97] Stark O., E. Taylor and S. Yitzhaki, Remittances and inequality [J], Economic Journal, 1986, 96, pp: 722-740.
    [98] Taylor, J. E., Undocumented Mexico-U.S. Migration and the Returns to Households in Rural Mexico [J]. American Journal of Agricultural Economics. Aug., 1987, 69(3), pp: 629-638.
    [99] Taylor, J. E. and P. L. Martin., Human capital: migration and rural population change. In: Gardener, B. L. and G. L. Rausse (eds.). Handbook of Agricultural Economics (1A). Agricultural Production. 2001, pp: 459-511.
    [100] Tirado, D. A., Pons, J., Paluzie, E., Silvestre, J., Migrants and market potential in Spain over the XXth century: a test of the New Economic Geography. Working Paper, 2006.
    [101] Todaro M.P., A model of Labour Migration and Urban Unemployment in Less Developed Countries [J], American Economic Review, 1969, vol. 59(1), pp: 138-148.
    [102] Tolnay, S. E., Educational Selection in the Migration of Southern Blacks, 1880-1990 [J], Social Forces, 1998, 77(3), pp: 485-514.
    [103] Venables, Anthony J., International Location of Economic Activity, Economic integration and the location of firms [J], The American Economic Review, 1995, 85(2), pp: 296-300.
    [104] Venables, Anthony J., Equilibrium locations of vertically linked industries [J], International Economic Review, 1996, 37, pp: 341-359.
    [105] Venables, Anthony J., Geography and international inequalities: The impact of new technologies [C], paper prepared for the World Bank Annual Conference on Development Economics, Washington, May 2001.
    [106] Whalley J. and S. Zhang, Inequality change in china and (Hukou) labor mobility restrictions, National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper 10683, 2004.
    [107] White, P. E., Woods, R. I., The Geographical Impact of Migration [M], New York: Longman, 1980.
    [108] William J. Carrington, Enrica Detragiache, and Tara Vishwanath. Migration with Endogenous Moving Costs [J], The American Economic Review, 1996, 86(4), pp: 909-930.
    [109] Yang, Dennis Tao and Zhao Hano, Rural-Urban Disparity and Sectoral Labor Allocation in China [J], Journal of Development Studies, 1999, 35(3), pp: 105-133.
    [110] Zhao, Yaohui, Labor Migration and Earnings Differences : The Case of Rural China [J], Economic Development and Cultural Change, 1999 ,47 (4), pp: 767-782.
    
    [111] Zucker, L. G., and Darby, M. R., Star Scientists and Institutional Transformation: Paterns of Invention and Innovation in the Formation of the Biotechnology Industry[J].Proceedings of the National Academy of Science,1996,93(12),pp:709-716.
    [112]Zucker,L.G.,and Darby,M.R.,Individual Action and the Demand for Institutions:Star Scientists and Institutional Transformation[J].The American Behavioral Scientist,1997,40(4),pp:502-513.
    [113]敖荣军,制造业集中、劳动力流动与中部地区的边缘化[J],南开经济研究,2005(1):61-66.
    [114]白南生,农村劳动力外出就业对农业影响的实证研究,摘自蔡防、白南生主编的《中国转轨时期劳动力流动》,社会科学文献出版社,2006年6月。
    [115]布雷克曼,盖瑞森,马勒惠克著,地理经济学(译)[M],西南财经大学出版社,2004年。
    [116]蔡昉,中国城市限制外地民工就业的政治经济学分析[J],中国人口科学,2000年第4期:1-10。
    [117]蔡昉,劳动力迁移的两个过程及其制度障碍[J],社会学研究,2001(4):44-51。
    [118]蔡昉.农村剩余劳动力流动的制度性障碍分析[J].经济学动态,2005(1):35-39。
    [119]蔡昉,为什么劳动力流动没有缩小城乡收入差距?[J],理论前沿,2005(20):18-20。
    [120]蔡昉、都阳,经济转型过程中的劳动力流动-长期性、效应和政策[J],学术研究,2004(6):16-22。
    [121]蔡昉、都阳、王美艳,户籍制度与劳动力市场保护[J],经济研究,2001(12):41-49。
    [122]蔡昉、王德文,中国经济增长可持续性与劳动贡献[J],经济研究,1999(10):62-68。
    [123]蔡昉、王德文、都阳,劳动力市场扭曲对区域差距的影响[J],中国社会科学,2001(2):4-14。
    [124]曹光章,如今孔雀飞向哪里--国内人才流动趋势分析[J],江淮,2004(4):18。
    [125]都阳、朴之水,迁移与减贫-来自农户调查的经验证据[J],中国人口科学,2003(4):56-62。
    [126]都阳、朴之水,劳动力迁移收入转移与贫困变化[J],中国农村观察,2003(5):2-9。
    [127]范剑勇、王立军、沈林洁,产业集聚与农村劳动力的跨区域流动[J],管理世界,2004(4):22-29。
    [128]何宪,历史的选择:从计划统包统配到市场双向选择--人才资源配置五十年回顾 [J],中国人才,1999年:7-9。
    [129]何雄浪,专业化产业集聚、要素流动与区域工业化[J],财经研究,2007(2):16-25。
    [130]胡鞍钢、程永宏、杨韵新等,扩大就业与挑战失业—中国就业政策评估(1949-2001)[M],中国劳动社会保障出版社,2002年11月。
    [131]胡士华,教育对我国农村劳动力流动影响研究[J],经济问题,2005(10):40-42。
    [132]黄仲熙,当前人才流动中存在的难题及对策[J],发展研究,2007(9):90-92。
    [133]格罗斯曼和赫尔普曼著,何帆、牛勇平、唐迪译,全球经济中的创新与增长[M],中国人民大学出版社,2003年。
    [134]国家统计局课题组,我国区域经济发展差距的实证分析[J],中国国情国力,2004(3):4-8。
    [135]李建民,中国劳动力市场多重分隔及其对劳动力供求的影响[J],中国人口科学,2002(2):1-7。
    [136]李建伟,王树和.人力资本积累对我国地区经济发展差距的影响[R],国务院发展研究中心调查研究报告,2005年2月21日。
    [137]李强,中国外出农民工及其汇款之研究[J],社会学研究,2001(4):64-76。
    [138]李善同、侯永志,中国大陆:划分八大社会经济区域[J],经济前沿,2003(5):12-15。
    [139]李实.中国农村劳动力流动与收入增长和分配[J],中国社会科学,1999(2):16-33。
    [140]李实、王亚柯,中国东西部地区企业职工收入差距的实证分析[J],管理世界,2005(6):16-26。
    [141]李文勇,基于人才流动分析的山东省人才环境优化研究[C],天津大学硕士学位论文,2004年。
    [142]梁琦,产业集聚论[M],商务印书馆,2004年4月。
    [143]林理升,王晔倩,运输成本、劳动力流动与制造业区域分布[J],经济研究,2006(3):115-125。
    [144]林毅夫,解决农村贫困问题需要有新的战略思路—评世界银行新的“惠及贫困人口的农村发展战略”[J],北京大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2002(5):5-8。
    [145]刘强,中国经济增长的收敛性分析[J],经济研究,2001(6):70-77。
    [146]刘夏明、魏英琪、李国平,收敛还是发散?—中国区域经济发展争论的文献综述[J],经济研究,2004(7):70-81。
    [147]陆铭,陈钊,城市化、城市倾向的经济政策与城乡收入差距[J],经济研究,2004(6): 50-58。
    [148]罗伯特J.巴罗,哈维尔.萨拉伊马丁.经济增长[M](译).中国社会科学出版社,2000年3月。
    [149]罗浩,中国劳动力无限供给与产业区域粘性[J],中国工业经济,2003(4):53-58。
    [150]罗勇,曹丽莉,中国制造业集聚程度变动趋势实证研究[J],经济研究,2005(8):106-115,127。
    [151]世界银行,2020年的中国:新世纪的发展挑战[M],中国财政经济出版社,1998年。
    [152]沈坤荣、唐文健,大规模劳动力转移条件下的经济收敛性分析[J],中国社会科学,2006(5):46-57。
    [153]宋洪远、黄华波、刘光明,关于农村劳动力流动的政策问题分析[J],管理世界,2002(5):55-65。
    [154]孙自铎,农民跨省务工对区域经济发展的影响研究[J],中国农村经济,2004(3):28-33。
    [155]孙自铎.农民异地就业对区域发展和居民收入影响的研究与思考[J].管理世界,2005(5):91-95。
    [156]王春超,收入差异、流动性与地区就业集聚-基于农村劳动力转移的实证研究[J],中国农村观察,2005(1):10-17。
    [157]王德文,吴要武,蔡昉,迁移、失业与城市劳动力市场分割--为什么农村迁移者的失业率很低?[J],世界经济文汇,2004(1):37-52。
    [158]王奋宇、赵延东,中国劳动力市场建设与劳动力流动[J],管理世界,2002年第3期:74-79,100。
    [159]王桂新、沈建法,上海外来劳动力与本地劳动力补缺替代关系研究[J],人口研究,2001(1):9-19。
    [160]王通讯,宏观人才学[M],人民出版社,1986年。
    [161]王小鲁、樊纲,中国地区差距的变动趋势和影响因素[J],经济研究,2004(1):33-44。
    [162]王子龙,谭清美,许箫迪,产业集聚水平测度的实证研究[J],中国软科学,2006(3):109-116。
    [163]伍旭川,汪守宏,中国房地产市场发展的历史路径[J],银行家,2005(7):94-95。
    [164]亚当.斯密,国民财富性质与原因的研究(上卷)[M],商务印书馆,1972年版。
    [165]杨云彦、徐映梅、向书坚,就业替代与劳动力流动:一个新的分析框架[J],经济研 究,2003(8):70-75。
    [166]姚枝仲、周素芳,劳动力流动与地区差距[J],世界经济,2003(4):35-44。
    [167]袁志刚,中国的乡—城劳动力流动与城镇失业:一个经验研究[J],管理世界,2006(8):28-35。
    [168]张车伟,人力资本回报率变化与收入差距:“马太效应”及其政策含义[J],经济研究,2006(12):59-70。
    [169]张永丽,黄祖辉,新一代流动劳动力的特征及流动趋势[J],中国人口科学,2008(2):80-87。
    [170]张照新、宋洪远,中国农村劳动力流动国际研讨会主要观点综述[J],中国农村观察,2002(1):75-79。
    [171]赵伟等著,中国区域经济开放:模型与趋势[M],经济科学出版社,2005年8月。
    [172]赵伟、李芬,区际开放与劳动力区际流动——浙江与广东的比较研究[J],技术经济,2006(12):10-13。
    [173]赵伟、李芬,异质性劳动力流动与区域收入差距:新经济地理学模型的扩展分析[J],中国人口科学,2007(1):27-35。
    [174]“中国城镇劳动力流动”课题组,中国劳动力市场建设与劳动力流动[J],管理世界,2002(3):74-79。
    [175]朱镜德,中国三元劳动力市场格局下的两阶段乡—城迁移理论[J],中国人口科学,1999(1)。
    [176]朱农,离土还是离乡?—中国农村劳动力地域流动和职业流动的关系分析[J],世界经济文汇,2004(1):53-63。

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700