航空运输业演化研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
航空运输业的历史已近百年。从最初少数人“能负担”的交通方式,到成为我们出行的基本选择。航空运输业百年的历史中,呈现了独特的演变历程。从产业政策看,主要航空运输大国基本从发展初期的严格管制到辅以反垄断监管的放松管制,国际航空运输由严格的双边协定体制到“天空开放”和区域航空一体化。从依托的主要生产工具看,从活塞螺旋桨飞机到喷气式飞机再到大型化、高速化新一代运输飞机的出现。从企业组织形式和产业发展看,从运营简单的点对点航线的航空公司,到运营中枢轮辐射式航线网络的航空公司占主导,再到运营点对点航线的低成本航空公司再度兴起,以及航空公司跨国联盟的形成。通过对航空运输业演变历程中繁杂表现的梳理,剥离出其内的演化机制,用规范的经济学方法给予解释,既可从理论上丰富产业经济学的研究方法,对正处于快速发展期的中国航空运输业,如何及时调整政策,也可以提供理论上的支持。
     论文以演化经济学分析方法为主要工具,融合产业组织理论和运输经济学研究成果,从历史、动态的视角剖析航空运输演化的内在机制。
     首先,论文梳理了经济学发展过程的演化思想与演化经济学的形成发展,总结了演化经济学分析的基本理论范式;对产业组织研究中演化分析方法的应用进行了跟踪,提出演化动力机制、产业演化路径选择机制和产业演化的刻画与描述是产业演化研究的主要内容;在对运输经济学的学术研究框架进行归纳的基础上识别了运输经济学不同于其他产业的技术经济特点。
     第二,在以上研究基础上,论文构建了航空运输业的演化模型。论文认为航空运输产品、资源、网络经济的特殊性恰是航空运输业区别于其他产业的技术经济特点,是其演化的基本“遗传”信息,而航线网络是这些“遗传”信息的载体,是航空运输业演化中的基因对应物。航空运输业发展过程中,需求、技术和制度则构成了航空运输演化的外部制约与选择环境。
     航空运输业的演化是基于环境的变化,航空公司根据自身资源,通过网络调整,以有效方式提供满足需求的产品的过程。航空运输业的演化过程中,需求是产业演化的基础,技术创新是基础性的推动力量,需求变化与技术创新提供了制度创新和产业系统累积式变迁的根本诱因、基础平台和渐进动力;而制度变迁则为系统激进式变迁提供了激励结构以及航空公司组织惯例突变的内生机制和外部压力,是航空运输业演化的关键。需求、技术与制度的变化通过影响航空运输业的产品、资源和网络经济性,带来了机会集合的变化。航空公司在变化的环境中,通过组织的创新,提供满足需求的产品,取得比较优势,实现组织生存与壮大。航空运输业产业演化过程也是学习和知识累积过程。在与环境的动态适应过程中,缺乏生命力的组织形式被逐步放弃和退化,更有效的组织形式被保留、发展并被模仿,适应、学习与模仿结果的宏观涌现最终表现为航空运输业的产业演化,也即居主导地位的不同运营模式航空公司的出现和变化。
     第三,为了进一步论证模型的有效性,论文从理论和实证方面对模型进行了多角度的检验。从理论上分析航空运输产品的异质性与航空公司运营模式的内在联系,证明了需求是航空运输业演化的基础,提供满足需求的产品是航空运输业演化的最终结果与表现。考察了美国航空运输业的演化历程,着重分析了需求、技术变化对美国航空运输制度变迁的影响及制度变迁的实现,从航空公司视角着重分析了环境变化后航空公司构建中枢轮辐式航线网络的动因与航空公司采取的行动,通过一个简单的“价格挤压”模型分析了技术发展对航空公司的影响。此外,通过论文构建的演化模型证明,国际航空运输业中制度安排的变化、资源的约束、全球化的航空运输需求,使得在国际航空运输中航空公司通过战略联盟构建全球网络成为理性的选择。
     第四,论文分析了我国航空运输业的演化。论文研究建立的演化模型对中国航空运输业二十年的演化过程也给予了很好的解释。现阶段中国航空运输业在快速发展的同时,出现了航空公司运营模式的同质化,航空运输产品供给的多样性不足等问题,空域、机场、专业人员等资源制约和制度环境的不适应开始凸现。
     最后,论文基于研究结论对中国航空运输业的发展从优化演化环境角度提出了政策建议。我国航空运输业已进入了制度变革的机遇期,建议进行更趋向自由化的制度安排调整,以产品多样化来提升我国航空运输业产业结构的高度化。形成行业管理部门与国家相关部门的有效配合机制,鼓励技术创新和优化制度环境,提高航空运输业发展的资源丰裕度。行业管理思路要从单纯注重行业发展,转向注重行业发展与消费者利益并重。同时,在放松经济规制的同时,要完善反垄断监管,维护市场的竞争格局,确保经济的自然选择对产业演化发展的正向作用。
Airline industry has nearly one century history. It is a basic option to travel for us today, but in the former it's only an "afforded" manner for some people. During the last one hundred years, the industry has appeared special development characters. In the industry policies aspect, deregulation policies accompanied with antitrust arrangements has replaced strict regulation in the main countries. In the international air transportation, strict Air Service Agreements have been replaced by "open skies" agreements and region aviation integration. In the aircraft aspect, it has gone through piston aircrafts, jet aircrafts and new generation bigger and speeder aircrafts. In the enterprise organization aspect, there are airlines with different operation characters appeared in sequence, from simply operated point-to-point air route airlines to hub-and-spoke network carriers and then to low cost carriers, finally alliances. To get the point of the evolution mechanism of airline industry with normative economy methods, that will enhance Industries Economics methodology and will provide theories support for China airline industry policies adjustment.
     The paper uses Evolutionary Economics Methodology and the achievements in Industries Economics and Transport Economics, to analyze and study the evolution of airline industry in historic and dynamic angle to get the inner mechanism.
     First of all, the paper summarizes the spark evolutionary thinking during the development of the economics and the formation of Evolutionary Economics to get the theory paradigm of Evolutionary Economics. After traced the research development of Industries Economics, the paper summarizes that dynamical mechanism, evolution path and description of industry evolution are the main contents of industry evolution research. On the basic of summarization research frameworks of Transport Economics, the paper indentifies the technology and economic characters of transport industry.
     Secondly, the paper constructs the evolutional model of airline industry. The products, resources and Economies of network of airline industry are the unique characters that distinguish air transport with other industries. These characters are also the basic inheritable information. The network of airline that just likes the gene is the carrier of the inheritable information. Demand, technology and institution compose the external restricted environment and selected environment of the airline industry evolution.
     Actually, the evolution of airline industry is the process that airlines adjust network with the restriction of usable resources to provide the products to meet the demand in the changed environment. In this process, demand is the basic of industry evolution and technology innovation is the impetus. The changes of demand and technology provide the incentive of institutional transition. The institutional transition provides incentive structure for the system change and the external pressure to airlines organization routines change. The institutional transition is the key factor of airline industry evolution. The changes of demand, technology and institution will bring the change of opportunity sets that will affect the action of airlines. In the dynamic environment, some airlines which adopt correct actions will get advantages and then survive and get growing. The evolution of airline industry is also a learning and knowledge assumption process. During this process, the failure organization models will be abandoned while the more effective models survive, grow and be copied. The result of this process is just the appearance of airline industry evolution.
     Thirdly, the paper use theories and empirical approach to testify validity of constructed Airline Industry Evolutional Model. Through theories analysis of the internal relation between heterogeneity of air transport products and operation model of airlines, the paper testified demand is the basic of evolution. To provide the products to meet the demand is the final result and appearance of industry evolution. Then the paper reviews the history of America airline industry. Particularly, the paper examines changes of demand and technology how to affect institutional transit of America airline industry and the process of institutional transit. The paper pays attention to analyses the motive of airlines to construct hub-and-spoke network and how they acted. Through a Price Squeeze model, the paper examines technology development how to affect airlines operation. In addition, the constructed Model also testifies alliances in international air transport are the rational choices of airlines while they operated in a dynamic environment which institution changed, demand increased with globalization and single airline has restricted resources.
     Fourthly, the paper examines the evolution of China airline industry. The constructed Model is proved to be a good instrument to explain how China airline industry changed. At present, some problems have emerged while the industry in China has achieved noticeable development. The most serious one is homogeneous operation model of airlines that result in the insufficiency air transport products supply. Capacity restricted in airspaces, airports and professional human resource scarcity are also need to be solved while the institutional environment can not suit to the industry development.
     Finally, some suggestions that how to optimize industry environment are raised in the last part of the paper based the study conclusions. The industry in China already got into the institutional transit phase. More liberalization institution arrangements should be introduced into the industry that will encourage airlines to diversify their products. So, that will helpful to optimize the industry structural. To enhance cooperation of the industry regulator and other involved ministries, to encourage technology innovation and to optimize the institution environment that will improve the industry resources affluently. The thoughts of regulating the industry should transfer from only pay attention to the development to pay more attention to consumer. Antitrust arrangements should be enhanced while the industry deregulation that will assure the environment has the positive affection to the industry evolution.
引文
[1]Air Transport Association Annual Report(1937-2010)
    [2]Akihiko Matsui. Best response dynamics and socially stable strategies. Journal of Economic Theory.1992; 52(2):343-362.
    [3]Alderighi M, Cento A.European airlines conduct after September 11. J Air Transport Man agent,2006(10):97-107.
    [4]Andrei Shleifer. Implementation Cycles. The Journal of Political Economy,1986,94(6): 1163-1190.
    [5]Andrew R. Goetz, Timothy M. Vowles. The good, the bad, and the ugly:30 years of US airline deregulation, Journal of Transport Geography,2009(17):251-263.
    [6]Antonious, A. Economies of scale in the airline industry:the evidence revisited.Logistics and Transport Review,1991(27):159-184.
    [7]Armen Albert Alchian. Uncertainty, Evolution and Economic Theory. Journal of Political Economy.1950,58(3):211-215.
    [8]Bain,J.S. Industrial Organization.New York:Harvard University Press.1959.
    [9]Bain,J.S. Barriers to New Competition, New York:Harvard University Press.1956.
    [10]Barry C. Smith, John F. Leimkuhler, Ross M. Darrow.Yield Management at American Airlines. Interfaces,1992,22(1):8-31.
    [11]Barney, J.B. Strategic factor markets:Expectations, luck, and business strategy, Expectations, luck, and business strategy.Management Science.1986.32(10):1231-1240.
    [12]Barney,J.B. Firm Resource and Sustained Competitive Advantage. Journal of Sustained Competitive Advantage. Journal of Management,1991,17(1):99-120.
    [13]Bijan Vasigh, Ken Fleming,Thomas Tacker. Introduction to Air Transport Economics.Ashgate.2007.
    [14]Barla, Philippe. Demand Uncertainty and Airline Network Morphology with Strategic Interactions.1999. Working Paper
    [15]Borenstein, Severin. Hubs and high Fares:Dominance and Market Power in the US Airline Industry. Rand Journal of Economics. Autumn 1989,20,344-65
    [16]Carroll, Christopher D. Buffer Stock Saving and the Life Cycle/Permanent Income Hypothesis. The Quarterly Journal of Economics.1997,112(1):1-57.
    [17]Caves, Christensen, Tretheway. The Economics of Density Vs. Economics of Scale:Why Trunk and Local Service Airline Costs Differ. Rand Journal of Economics.1984, 15(4):471-489.
    [18]Cento, A. The Airline Industry:Challenges in the 21st Century, Heidelberg,2009.
    [19]Chamberlin, J. C.Dasychernes inquilines from the nest of meliponine bees in Colombia (Arachnida:Chelonethida). Ent. News,1929,40:49-51.
    [20]Chapman, K. Industry evolution and interactional dispersal:The fertilizer industry. Geo forum.2000.31(3):371-384.
    [21]Coase R.H. The Nature of the Firm, Economica.1937.4 (16):386-405.
    [22]Darin Lee. Concentration and price trends in the US domestic airline industry 1990-2000.Journal of Air Transport Management.2003 (9):91-101
    [23]Demsetz, H., Industry Structure. Market Rivalry and Public Policy. Journal of Law and Economics,1973(16):1-10.
    [24]DLR.Airline Bussiness Model:Analyses of the European air transport market.http://www.dlr.de/fw.2008
    [25]Doganis R. The airline business in the 21st Century. Routledge. London.2001.
    [26]Eldad Ben-Yosel.The Evolution of the US Airline Industry. Spriner.2005
    [27]F. H. Hahn. Some Adjustment Problems. The Econometric Society,1970,38(1):1-17.
    [28]Frank Hyneman Knight. On the History and Method of Economics:Selected Essays (Phoenix Books).Univ of Chicago Pr.1956.
    [29]Franke M. Competition between network carriers and low-cost carriers—retreat battle or breakthrough to a new level of efficiency? J Air Transport Manage.2004(10):15-21.
    [30]Friedman, Milton. A Monetary and Fiscal Framework for Economic Stability, American Economic Review.1948.38(3):pp.245-264.
    [31]GAO, USA, AIRLINE DEREGULATION——Changes in Airfares, Service, and Safety at Small, Medium-Sized, and Large Communities.1996.
    [32]Gautan Gowrisankaran.Competition and Regulation in the Airline Industry.FRBSF Economic Letter.http://www.frbsf.org
    [33]Gary S. Becker. A Theory of the Allocation of Time. Economic Journal.1965.75 (299): 493-517.
    [34]Heimer, O. and O. Shy. Code-Sharing Agreements, Frequency of Flights and Profits under Parallel Operation.in Darin Lee, ed., Advances in Airline Economics.2006. vol.1. Elsevier: 163-181.
    [35]Hodgson, G., ed. Economics and Biology. Cheltenham, UK:Edward Elgar Publishing Company.1995.
    [36]Hodgson, Geoffrey M.. Evolutionary and Institutional Economics as the New Mainstream? Evolutionary and Institutional Economics Review.2007.4(1):7-25.
    [37]Hussein Kassim; Handley Stevens. Air Transport and the European Union——Europeanization and its Limits. Palgrave Macmillan.2010.
    [38]J. M. Clark. Toward A Concept of Workable Competition. American Economic Review, 1940.30(2):241-256
    [39]James M Utterback & William J Abernathy. A dynamic model of process and product innovation. Omega.1975.3(6):639-656.
    [40]James M Utterback & William J Abernathy. Patterns of Industrial Innovation. Technology Review.1978.80(7):40-47.
    [41]James W. Brock., Miami University., Ohio. Structure of American Industry. Prentice Hall. 2001.
    [42]J. Bain. Industrial Organization. John Wiley & Sons.Inc.Press.1959.
    [43]Joskow, Paul L. Vertical Integration and Long-term Contracts:The Case of Coal-burning Electric Generating Plants.Journal of Law, Economics and Organization. Oxford University Press.1985(1)33-80.
    [44]John Ozment. Assessing Transportation Contributions to the Economic Performance of Developing Countries.2006
    [45]Joseph T. Mahoney & J. Rajendran Pandian. The resource-based view within the conversation of strategic management. Strategic Management Journal.1992.13(5):363-380.
    [46]J. Tirole. The Theory of Industrial Organization. Cambridge:MIT Press.1988.
    [47]Kai Hiischelrath,Kathrin Muller. Low Cost Carriers and the Evolution of the U.S. Airline Industry. ZEW Centre for European Economic Research Discussion Paper No.11-051. 2011.
    [48]Katz, Michael and Carl Shapiro. Network Externalities, Competition and Compatibility. American Economic Review.vol.1985.75(3):424-440.
    [49]Katz, Michael and Carl Shapiro. Systems Competition and Network Effects. Journal of Economic Perspectives.1994,8(2):93-115
    [50]Kenneth Button, Does the theory of the 'core' explain why airlines fail to cover their long-run. Journal of Air Transport Management.2003(9):5-14
    [51]K.Boulding. A Preface to Grants Economics:The Economy of Love and Fear. New York: Praeger.1981.
    [52]Keeler, J.P. and Formby, J.P. Cost Economics and Consolidation in the U.S. Airline Industry. International Journal of Transport Economics.1994,21(1):21-45.
    [53]Lancaster, Kelvin. A New Approach to Consumer Theory. Journal of Political Economy. 1966.74(2):132-157.
    [54]Lancaster, Kelvin. Variety, Equity, and Efficiency:product variety in an industrial society.New York. NY:Columbia University Press.1979.
    [55]Lancaster, Kelvin. Intra-industry Trade under Monopolistic Competition. Journal of International Economics.1980.10(2):151-175.
    [56]Levine, M.E. Airline Competition in Deregulated Markets:Theory, Firm Strategy and Public Policy. Yale Journal on Regulation.1987(4),393-494.
    [57]Mintel. Low cost Airlines, International. Mintel International Group. USA.Mintel.2006.
    [58]Michael Gort, Steven Klepper. Time Paths in the Diffusion of Product Innovations.1982. 92(367):630-653.
    [59]Morrison, S.A., C. Winston.An Economic Analysis of the Demand for Intercity Passenger Transportation. Research in Transportation Economics.1985 (2):213-37.
    [60]Nawal K Janeja美国国际航空政策.北京:人民交通出版社.1989:1-32
    [61]Nawal K.Taneja,航空公司生存之道.北京:中国民航出版社.2007:23-45,92-93
    [62]Nelson R.R. Resent evolutionary theorizing about economic change. Journal of Economic Literature.1995(18):48-90
    [63]North D. C. Location Theory and Regional Economic Growth, Journal of Political Economy.1955.63(3):243-258.
    [64]North,Wallis. Integrating Institutional Change and Technical Change in Economic History: A Transaction Cost Approach. Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics.1994.150:609-624
    [65]Oliver E. Williamson. The Economics of Organization:The Transaction Cost Approach. The American Journal of Sociology.1981.87 (3):548-577.
    [66]Pat Hanlon. Global Airlines, Third Edition:Competition in a Transnational Industry.Butterworth-Heinemann.2007.
    [67]Paul A. Samuelson.Probability, utility, and the independence axiom, Economtrica.1952. 50(4):670-678.
    [68]Paul Samuelson, William Nordhaus. Economics 16th Ed. The McGraw-Hill Companies, lnc.1998.
    [69]Perteraf MA.The Cornerstones of Competitive Advantage:A Resource-Based Competitive Advantage.Strategic Management Journal.1993(14):179-191
    [70]Peter Morrel. Airlines within airlines:An analysis of US network airline responses to Low Cost Carriers.Journal of Air Transport Management.2005 (11):303-312
    [71]Posner R. A. Theories of Economic Regulation.Bell Journal of Economics.5th.1974: 335-358.
    [72]Rigas Doganis.The Airline Business.2 edition Taylor & Francis.2007.(First published 2000 by Routledge)
    [73]Rigas Doganis.Flying off Course The economics of international airlines.Third editon.2002.(First published 1985 by HarperCollins Academic)
    [74]Ryan Wiser, Kevin Porter, Steve Clemmer. Emerging Markets for Renewable Energy:The Role of State Policies during Restructuring. The Electricity Journal.2000.13(1):13-24.
    [75]Robert windle,Martin Dresner. Competitive Responses to Low Cost Carrier Entry.Transportation Research Part E35 (1999):59-75
    [76]Robinson J. The Economics of Imperfect Competition.London:Macmillan.1933.
    [77]Salop, S.C. Monopolistic Competition with Outside Goods Bell.Journal of Economics.1979 (10):141-156.
    [78]Scherer, F. M. The Economics of Market Dominance. Basil Blackwell:Oxford, in International Journal of Industrial Organization.1988(6):517-518.
    [79]Scherer.F. M. Industry Structure, Strategy and Public Policy.1st edition. Boston:Addison Wesley.1997.
    [80]Schmalensee, R. Industrial Economics:An Overview.Economic Journal.1988(98): 643-681.
    [81]Schumpeter, J.A经济发展理论..北京:商务印书馆.1991.
    [82]S.C. Salop, L.J. White, F. M. Fisher & R. Schmalensee. Symposium:Horizontal Mergers and Antitrust. Journal of Economic Perspectives.1987(1):3-54.
    [83]Sergio Jara-Diaz.Transport Economic Theory.Amsterdam:Elsevier Science Ltd.2007.
    [84]Steven Berry, Michael Carnall, Pablo T. Spiller.Airline Hubs:Costs, Markups and the Implications of Customer Heterogeneity.NBER Working Papers 5561.National Bureau of Economic Research, Inc.1996.
    [85]Stephen Holloway. Straight and Level:Practical Airline Economics. Ashgate Publishing Limited.2008.
    [86]Steven Klepper,Elizabeth Graddy. The Evolution of New Industries and the Determinants of Market Structure. The RAND Journal of Economics.1990.21(1):27-44.
    [87]Stirling, A. Diversity and ignorance in electricity supply investment:Addressing the solution rather than the problem. Energy Policy.1994.22(3):195-216.
    [88]Steven A. Morrison and Clifford Winston.The evolution of the airline industry.Washington, D.C.:The Brookings Institution,1995.
    [89]Steven A. Morrison,Clifford Winston. Airline Deregulation and Public Policy. Science. 1989(245):707-711
    [90]Stigler, G.J产业组织与政府管制.上海:上海三联书店.1996.
    [91]Stigler, G. J. A Note on Portability, Competition, and Concentration. The Organization of Industry. Homewood, Ⅲ:Richard D. Irwin.1968.
    [92]Silke Januszewski Forbes and Mara Lederman.The Role of Regional Airlines in the U.S. Airline Industry, in:Darin Lee (ed.).Advances in Airline Economics, Vol. Ⅱ, Elsevier 2007.
    [93]The Air Transport Association of America Annual Report(1937-2010)
    [94]Tirole, J. The Theory of Industrial Organization. Cambridge. MA:M.I.T. Press.1988.
    [95]US General Accounting Office.Airline Service Trends at Small Communities since October 2000.GAO-02-432.Washington, DC.March,2002.
    [96]US Government Accountability Office. Bankruptcy and Pension Problems are Symptoms of Underlying Structural Issues. GAO-05-945. Washington, DC. September,2005.
    [97]Vromen, J. J. Evolutionary Economics:Precursors,Paradigmatic Propositions,Puzzles and Prospects. Economics and Evolution.Edward Elgar Publishing Limited.1997.46.
    [98]Wemerfelt,B. A resource-based view of the firm. Strategic Management Journal.1984. 5(2):171-180.
    [99]William A. Jordan. Airline Entry Following US Deregulation:The Definitive List of Startup Passenger Airline,1979-2003.The George Washington University.Working paper.2005.
    [100]Wiser, R.,J. Fang,K. Porter,A.Houston. Green Power Marketing in Retail Competition. An Early Assesment.1999.
    [101]柏明国.航空公司航线网络优化设计问题研究[博士学位论文].南京航空航天大学.2006
    [102]曹云敏.演化经济学分析框架的重新概念化.云南社会科学.2007(5):79-83
    [103]曹钟勇.关于我国铁路和其他运输方式发展速度稳定值的研究.1995(2):1-8.
    [104]陈卫.《开普敦公约》对我国民航业经济性影响分析.北京交通大学学报(社会科学版).2010(1):111-115
    [105]大卫.c.莫厄里,理查德.R.纳尔逊.领先之源—七个行业的分析.北京:人民邮电出版社.2003:3-15,339-354
    [106]丹尼斯.卡尔顿,杰弗里.佩罗夫.现代产业组织理论.上海:上海三联书店.上海人民出版社.1997:83-103
    [107]顾修权,彭金梅.企业能力的新视角:分形企业能力.管理评论.2007(4):35-42
    [108]弗罗门.经济演化.经济科学出版社.2003年第一版.
    [109]福斯特,梅特卡夫.演化经济学前沿:竞争、自组织与创新政策.北京:高等教育出版社.2005.
    [110]富兰克.H.奈特.风险、不确定性和利润.北京:中国人民大学出版社.2005
    [111]葛扬,李晓蓉.西方经济学说史.南京:南京大学出版社.2003
    [112]耿淑香.航空公司运营管理方略.北京:中国民航出版社.2000:98-108
    [113]哈耶克.自由秩序原理(上、下).邓正来译,生活、读书、新知三联书店.2003年第二版.
    [114]韩彪.各种运输方式之间的发展关系分析.北方交通大学学报.1994(3):13-18.
    [115]胡斌.物流组织与专业化分工(网络型基础产业经济学丛书).经济科学出版社.2002年第一版.
    [116]胡瑞娟.中国民航运输市场结构和竞争绩效研究[博士学位论文].对外经济贸易大学.2005
    [117]胡志群.航空公司战略联盟合作伙伴选择与合作管理研究[博士学位论文].中南大学.2007
    [118]霍奇逊.经济学是如何忘记历史的:社会科学中的历史特性问题.北京:中国人民大学出版社.2008.
    [119]霍奇逊.制度与演化经济学现代文选:关键性概念.北京:高等教育出版社.2005
    [120]黄海波.电信管制:从监督垄断鼓励竞争.经济科学出版社.2002年第一版.
    [121]黄凯南.企业和产业共同演化理论研究[博士学位论文].山东大学.2007.
    [122]黄凯南.演化博弈与演化经济学.经济研究.2009(2):132-145
    [123]贾根良.演化经济学:现代流派与创造性综合.学术月刊2002(12):13-19
    [124]贾根良.理解演化经济学.中国社会科学.2004(2):33-41.
    [125]贾根良,黄阳华.施穆勒纲领与演化经济学的起源.南开学报(哲学社会科学版).2007(4):102-109
    [126]库尔特.多普非.演化经济学纲领与范围.北京:高等教育出版社.2004:40-81.
    [127]匡旭娟.演化视角下的快递业网络形态研究[博士学位论文].北京交通大学.2008
    [128]黎群.论航空公司的战略联盟.经济科学出版社,2003年第一版.
    [129]李福娟.基于航线决策的航班计划优化研究[博士学位论文].同济大学.2007
    [130]李艳伟.航空公司竞争力研究[博士学位论文].天津大学.2007
    [131]李怡靖.企业能力理论综述.云南财贸学院学报.2003(10):36-40
    [132]廖刚.中国航空运输业市场化改革竞争研究[博士学位论文].上海交通大学.2007
    [133]刘功仕.航空运输理论和实践.北京:中国民航出版社.1995:125-176
    [134]陆瑾.产业组织演化研究-对主流经济理论的批判[博士学位论文].复旦大学,2005.
    [135]逯笑微,原毅军.基于组织变革的产业演化过程.大连理工大学学报.2008,29(4):32-34.
    [136]吕先竞.企业信息资源的内涵特征与构成体系.西华大学学报(哲学社会科学版):2008(10),76-79
    [137]马歇尔.经济学原理.北京:商务印书馆,1981.
    [138]马国旺.演化经济学范式与马克思主义经济学研究方法的新取向.理论与现代化.2008(2):17-21
    [139]马尔科姆.卢瑟福.经济学中的制度:老制度主义和新制度主义.北京:中国社会科学出版社.1999
    [140]纳尔逊,温特.经济变迁的演化理论.北京:商务印书馆.1997.
    [141]聂正安.企业成长动力研究的若干视角.经济学动态.2007(4):77-81
    [142]欧国立,运输产品性质论,中国铁路,2004(10):33-34.
    [143]彭璧玉.组织生态学理论述评.经济学家.2006(5):111-117
    [144]平狄克,鲁宾费尔德.微观经济学.北京:中国人民大学出版社,2000
    [145]任力,王宁宁.演化经济学的形成与发展.西南师范大学学报(人文社会科学版).2006(1):111-116
    [146]荣朝和.论运输化:交通运输与经济发展关系的理论分析[博士学位论文].北方交通大学.1990:20-21.
    [147]荣朝和.关于运输业规模经济和范围经济问题的探讨.中国铁道科学.2001(8):97-104
    [148]荣朝和.从运输产品特性看铁路重组的方向.北方交通大学学报(社会科学版),2002(9):13-18.
    [149]荣朝和.《西方运输经济学》(网络型基础产业经济学从书).北京:经济科学出版社.2002年第一版.2008年第二版.
    [150]荣朝和.关于运输经济研究基础性分析框架的思考.北方交通大学学报(社会科学版).2009(2):1-9
    [151]荣朝和.交通-物流时间价值及其在经济时空分析中的作用.经济研究.2011(8):133-146.
    [152]盛昭瀚,蒋德鹏.演化经济学动态与综述.经济学动态.2000(7):61-65
    [153]盛昭瀚,蒋德鹏.演化经济学.上海:上海三联出版社,2002.
    [154]孙晓华,周玲玲.不同需求结构条件的企业技术创新与市场细分改革,2011(3),108-113.
    [155]王志伟.现代西方经济学流派.北京:北京大学出版社,2004:349.
    [156]王欣,靖继鹏.信息产业演化的动力机制研究,情报科学,2009(12):62-64.
    [157]王永红.企业信息资源研究的认知范式及其基本要素.2008(5):691-694
    [158]汪静农.放松管制后的中美航空运输业比较研究[博士学位论文].复旦大学.2005
    [159]韦森,经济理论与市场秩序.上海:格致出版社,2009.
    [160]魏际刚.中国运输结构变化的制度分析:以铁路市场份额变化为例.数量经济技术经济研究.2003(8):30-33.
    [161]卫志民.20世纪产业组织理论的演进与最新前沿.国外社会科学.2002(5):17-24
    [162]沃尔特.亚当斯,詹姆斯.W.布罗克.美国产业结构.北京:中国人民大学出版社.2003:194-218
    [163]吴艳文.基于制度和技术的产业组织协同演化研究[博士学位论文].上海社会科学院,2008.
    [164]邬爱其,贾生华.国外企业生成理论研究框架探析.外国经济学与管理.2002(12):2-23
    [165]武爱.演化经济学的方法论:从个体发育到系统自组织.大连理工大学学报(社会科学版).2003(3):46-50
    [166]西蒙.管理行为(原书第四版).北京:机械工业出版社,2004.
    [167]谢作诗,李平.弗里德曼的《实证经济学方法论》:缘起、内容与再解读.世界经济.2007(12):64-74
    [168]项保华,钱辉.从需求演化的角度看我国房地产企业发展模式变化.商业研究.2004(18):161-163.
    [169]谢雄标,严良.产业演化研究述评.地质大学学报.2009,9(6):6-12.
    [170]亚当.斯密.国富论.北京:华夏出版社.2004:327.
    [171]杨虎涛.经济演化思想的演进与走向.学术研究.2006(4):51-57
    [172]杨虎涛.论演化经济学的前景与困境.经济评论.2007(4):86-91
    [173]杨宏力.演化经济学的兴起:一种拟议的综合分析.山东经济.2008(1):33-39
    [174]袁春晓.产业组织演化论[博士学位论文].四川大学,2002.
    [175]姚建华.基于企业家创新的产业演化研究[博士学位论文].暨南大学.2009.
    [176]于军.铁路重组的理论与实践.经济科学出版社.2003年第一版.
    [177]张宝贵,刘东.企业能力:理化与实证研究文献综述.经济评论.2006(6):147-151
    [178]张会恒.论产业生命周期理论,财贸研究,2004(6):7-11.
    [179]张燕.产业组织变迁的演化研究[博士学位论文].西北大学.2006.
    [180]张兴无.演化经济学对主流经济学的批判.石家庄经济学院学报.2003(10):615-617
    [181]郑军.企业边界变迁的产业组织演化,财经科学.2007,229(4):88-95.
    [182]赵坚.企业能力理论、假定与模型.北京交通大学学报(社会科学版).2004(12):6-15
    [183]赵玉秋.产业技术演化路径与作用机制分析[硕士学位论文].山东大学.2010.
    [184]郑世卿.中国旅游产业组织演化研究(1978-2008)[博士学位论文].上海社会科学院.2008.
    [185]植草益.产业组织论.北京:中国人民大学出版社.1988
    [186]中国民航统计年鉴(1988-2011).中国民用航空局编
    [187]中国统计年鉴(2008-2011).北京:中国统计出版社
    [188]中国民航局.中国民航改革开放三十年.北京:中国民航出版社.2009
    [189]朱成全.经济学方法论.大连:东北财经大学出版社.2003

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700