仿真在配送中心设计中的参与模式及方法研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
在仿真技术广泛应用于配送中心设计的今天,大量的实践经验和文献研究表明,仿真作为一种“事后验证”仅发生在配送中心设计后期,以至于仿真在发现配送中心设计细节漏洞、提供设计提示等方面的功能被制约,且存在仿真数据可靠性低、仿真建模系统性差等问题。本文主要对配送中心设计中仿真的传统应用模式进行改革,提出一套旨在提前仿真参与时间、扩大仿真参与范围、体现仿真参与主动性、提升仿真参与系统性的仿真参与框架。从仿真在配送中心设计中的全程性参与、主导性参与和系统性参与三个方面研究仿真参与模式和方法问题。
     在仿真的全程性参与方面,论文结合文献和项目经验整理了配送中心设计的主要步骤和主要流程,在此基础上进行了设计流程阶段和作业模块划分。提出了仿真在配送中心设计的整体设计阶段开始的各个步骤、各个阶段及各作业模块中的应用方案和实例。
     在仿真的主导性参与方面,论文针对传统设计方法中仿真参与存在弊端提出了仿真主导配送中心设计的理念,并依照离散事件系统仿真的基本特征和思想,提出了基于仿真模型分析的配送中心设计提示方法,并以实例说明了仿真主导的配送中心设计的实施要点。
     在仿真的系统性参与方面,论文强调配送中心设计中仿真全面性参与同主导性参与的结合,并从仿真模型实施时模型复用性、逼真度管理等方面考虑仿真在配送中心设计中对仿真成本的把握。
     最后结合上述三方面的研究提出包含七个仿真参与步骤的配送中心设计仿真参与框架,并通过某配送中心设计实例对该框架做出了实施说明和评价。
     本文从工程实践、项目经验及文献、案例调研出发,针对仿真在配送中心设计中应用的常见问题,提出区别于传统方法的仿真应用体系,并通过大量实例进行理论和方法说明,以期为仿真发现设计漏洞、指导、启发设计等作用的更好发挥,为仿真数据可靠性提高、仿真成本合理控制等方面做出贡献。
According to extensive industry practice and research literature, simulation application is restricted to late stage of the design course as a post-event verification tool. Consequently, its function as a design flaw detector and a design inspiration supplier are limited, and input data reliability as well as modeling systematicness are compromised. This paper focuses on reforming traditional application mode of simulation in distribution center design. An application framework aimed at earlier, wider, positive and systematic involvement of simulation in distribution center design is proposed. Simulation application mode and method are discussed in three aspects including simulation full participation, simulation-oriented design and simulation systematic participation.
     As for full participation of simulation, distribution center design steps and procedure are investigated through literature review and project experience. Design phases and operation modules are studied. Simulation proposal and cases on design steps, phases and modules are given as examples.
     As for simulation-oriented design, procedures led by simulation are developed to solve the problems in traditional application of simulation in distribution center design. Simulation analysis method based on design flow chart is explored and illustrated.
     As for simulation systematic participation, a combination of simulation full participation and simulation-oriented design is highlighted. Reusability and fidelity management of simulation model are considered for simulation cost control.
     Integrating the three aspects above, simulation application framework in distribution center design is developed. A mechanic distribution center is employed at last for application introduction.
     Aimed at solving common problems in traditional mode, this paper presents a set of application methodologies of simulation in distribution center design which is illustrated through specific industrial cases. Under the guidance of this framework, functions of simulation in design flaw detection and design inspiration can be fully used; simulation data reliability and simulation cost management can be effectively improved.
引文
[1]Van der Berg, Jeroen P.1999. A literature survey on planning and control of warehousing systems.IIE Transactions.31(8):751-762.
    [2]Gu, Jinxiang, Marc Goetschalckx and Leon F. McGinnis.2010. Research on warehouse design and performance evaluation:A comprehensive review. European Journal of Operational Research 203:539-549.
    [3]Rouwenhorst, B. et al,.2000. Warehouse design and control:Framework and literature review. European Journal of Operational Research 122:515-533.
    [4]De Koster, Rene, Tho. Le-Duc and Kees Jan. Roodbergen.2007. Design and control of warehouse order picking:A literature review. European Journal of Operational Research 182: 481-501.
    [5]Goetschalckx, M. and J. Ashayeri.1989. Classification and design of order picking. Logistics World. June 1989:99-106.
    [6]Baker, P. and M. Canessa.2009. Warehouse design:a structured approach. European Journal of Operational Research 193:425-436.
    [7]Dallari, Fabrizio, Gino Marchet and Marco Melacini.2009. Design of order picking system. International Journal of Advanced Manufacture Technology 42:1-12.
    [8]工转,程国全.配送中心系统规划.第一版.中国物资出版社,2003:1-70.
    [9]胡燕祝,吕宏义.物流配送中心的规划与管理.包装工程.第8卷.第5期.2007.05:24-27.
    [10]工转,贺文文.基于订单资料分析的配送中心规划及应用.机械工程学报.2007年第4期:
    [11]储雪俭.物流配送中心规划方案探讨.物流技术.2005年第9期:210-213.
    [12]Cerda, Carlos B. Ramirez.1995. Performance evaluation of an automated material handling system for a machining line using simulation. Proceedings of the 27th conference on winter simulation:881-888.
    [13]Ashayeri, J. and L. F. Gelders.1985. Warehouse design optimization. European Journal of Operational Research 21:285-294.
    [14]王春峰,张春娜,蔡平,张沂泉.物流系统建模与仿真研究综述.物流科技.2007年第1]期:37-39.
    [15]石伟,郑晓海.物流配送中心的系统仿真.物流技术与应用.第12期.2006:86-90.
    [16]赵宁等.基于三阶段仿真法的AS/RS物流系统规划.第29卷第10期.2007:1054-1058.
    [17]Ko, Hyun Jeung, Chang Seong Ko and Taioun Kim.2006. A hybrid optimization/simulation approach for a distribution network design of 3PLS. Computers & Industrial Engineering.50(4). August 2006:440-449.
    [18]Pulat, P. S. and B. M. Pulat.1989. Throughput analysis in an automated material handling system. Simulation 52(5):195-198.
    [19]Armour, Gordon C. and Elwood S. Buffa.1963. A Heuristic Algorithm and Simulation Approach to Related Location of Facilities. Management Science 9(2):294-309.
    [20]Roll, Y., M. J. Rosenblatt. and D. Kadosh.1989. Determining the size of a warehouse container. International Journal of Production Research.27(10). October 1989:1693-1704.
    [21]Wang, Shay-Ping T.1985. Animated graphic simulation of an automated guided vehicle system (AGVS). Proceedings of the 17th conference on winter simulation:252-256.
    [22]Sharp, G. P., R. Kittell and K. Hollender.1991. Conveyor input/output systems for pallet AS/RS. Technical Report. MHRC-TR-89-02. Georgia Institute of Technology. Atlanta, GA. 1991.
    [23]Van der Zee, D.J. and J. G. A. J. van der Vorst.2005. A Modeling Framework for Supply Chain Simulation:Opportunities for Improved Decision Making. Decision Sciences 36(1):65-95.
    [24]Linn, R. J. and Xiaodong Xie.1993. A simulation analysis of sequencing rules for ASRS in a pull-based assembly facility. International Journal of Production Research 31(10):2355-2367.
    [25]Roll, Y. and M. J. Rosenblatt.1983. Random versus grouped storage policies and their effect on warehouse capacity. Material Flow 1:199-205.
    [26]Tagaras, George and Morris A. Cohen.1992. Pooling in Two-Location Inventory Systems with Non-Negligible Replenishment Lead Times. Management Science 38(8) Aug.1992: 1067-1083.
    [27]Bozer, Y. A., M.A. Quiroz and G.P. Sharp.1988. An evaluation of alternative control strategies and design issues for automated order accumulation and sortation systems. Material Flow 4: 265-282.
    [28]Meller, R.D., and A. Mungwattana.2005. AS/RS dwell-point strategy selection at high system utilization:a simulation study to investigate the magnitude of the benefit. International Journal of Production Research 43(24):5217-5227.
    [29]Karagiannaki, Angeliki, loannis Mourtos, Katerina Pramatari.2007. Simulating and evaluating the impact of RFID on warehousing operations:a case study. Proceedings of the 2007 summer computer simulation conference. NO.34
    [30]Arundhati Kumar, Peng Si Ow and Michael J. Prietula. Organizational Simulation and Information Systems Design:An Operations Level Example.Management Science, Vol.39, No. 2 (Feb.,1993), pp.218-240.
    [31]Duffuaa, S. O. and A. Raouf.1992. A simulation model for determining maintenance staffing in an industrial environment. SIMULATION 59(2):93-99.
    [32]Mason, Andrew J., David M. Ryan and David M. Panton.1998. Integrated Simulation, Heuristic and Optimisation Approaches to Staff Scheduling. Operations Research 46(2): 161-175.
    [33]Ito, Teruaki and S. M. Mousavi Jahan Abadi.2002. Agent-based material handling and inventory planning in warehouse. Journal of Intelligent Manufacturing 13(3):1572-8145.
    [34]Gagliardi, Jean Philippe, Jacques Renaud and Angel Ruiz.2007. A simulation model to improve warehouse operations. Proceedings of the 39th conference on Winter simulation: 2012-2018.
    [35]Ramaswamy, S. and K. P. Valavanis.1994. Modeling, analysis and simulation of failures in a materials handling system with extended Petri nets. IEEE transactions on systems, man, and cybernetics.24(9):1358-1373.
    [36]Hwang, H., W. Baek and M.-K. Lee.1988. Clustering algorithms for order picking in an automated storage and retrieval system. International Journal of Production Research 26(2): 189-201.
    [37]薛松.医药物流中心设计及仿真研究.硕士学位论文.华中科技大学.2006年10月.武汉.
    [38]Holloway, L. E., B. H. Krogh and A. Giua.1997. A Survey of Petri Net Methods for Controlled Discrete Event Systems. Discrete Event Dynamic Systems.7(2):151-190.
    [39]Baines, T. S. and D. K. Harrison.1999. An opportunity for system dynamics in manufacturing system modeling. Production Planning & Control 10(6):542-552.
    [40]Kim, Byung-In, Robert J. Graves, Sunderesh S. Heragu and ART St. ONGE.2002. Intelligent agent modeling of an industrial warehousing problem. IIE Transactions.34(7):601-612.
    [41]Ross, Anthony and Vaidyanathan Jayaraman.2008. An evaluation of new heuristics for the location of cross-docks distribution centers in supply chain network design. Computers and Industrial Engineering 55(1):64-79.
    [42]Van Oudheusden, D.L. and W. Zhu.1992. Storage layout of AS/RS racks based on recurrent orders. European Journal of Operational Research 58(1):48-56.
    [43]Lee, Loo Hay and Ek Peng Chew.2005. A dynamic joint replenishment policy with auto-correlated demand. European Journal of Operational Research 165(3):729-747.
    [44]R. Sinha, V.C. Liang, C.J.J. Paredis, and P.K. Khosla. Modeling and Simulation Methods for Design of Engineering Systems. Journal of Computing and Information Science in Engineering. Vol.1, pp.84-91,2001.
    [45]Mark S. Shephard et al. Toward simulation-based design. Finite Elements in Analysis and Design. Volume 40, Issue 12, July 2004:1575-1598.
    [46]Xiaoping Du, Wei Chen. Methodology for Managing the Effect of Uncertainty in Simulation-Based Design. AIAA Journal. Vol.38, no.8, Aug.2000:1471-1478.
    [47]Natalia M. Alexandrov and Robert Michael Lewis. Addressing the Challenges of Simulation-Based Design Optimization. SIAM Conference on Computational Science and Engineering.8-13 February 2003.
    [48]C.J.J. Paredis, A. Diaz-Calderon, R. Sinha, and P.K. Khosla. Composable Models for Simulation-Based Design. Engineering with Computers.2001. Vol.17:112-128.
    [49]Karangelen Nicholas E. and NgocDung T Hoang.1994. Simulation Based Design for Large Complex Computer Based Systems. Proceedings of Tutorial and Workshop on Systems Engineering of Computer-Based Systems. Stockholm, Sweden:116-123.
    [50]工克明,熊光楞.复杂产品的协同设计与仿真.计算机集成制造系统-CIMS.第9卷.2003年12月:15-19.
    [51]工庆,张以都,景武.基于仿真的机械产品设计系统.沈阳航空工业学院学报.第24卷第3期.2007年6月:13-16.
    [52]潘军等.基于仿真的虚拟产品设计若干关键要素研究.系统仿真学报.第16卷第6期.2004年6月:1300-1304.
    [53]马玉敏等.基于仿真的车间作业计划优化设计.系统仿真学报.第19卷第19期.2007年10月:4548-4552.
    [54]马玉敏等.基于仿真的生产线的规划设计.制造业自动化.第26卷第10期.2004年10月:17-19.
    [55]粱海峰等.基于仿真的自动化钢料加工车间设计及生产效率评价.造船技术.2005年第3期(总第265期):27-30.
    [56]黄超,徐向阳.基于仿真的车间设备布局优化设计.东北电力大学学报.第28卷第2期.2008年4月:53-56.
    [57]吴哲辉.Petri网导论.机械工业出版社.第一版.2006.4.pp:1-44.
    [58]袁崇义.Petri网原理与应用.电子工业出版社.第一版.2005.3.pp:225-258.
    [59]Wil van der Aalst, Kees can Hee. Workflow Management Models:methods and systems.1st Edition. MIT Press. January 1.2002.
    [60]张晓萍,刘玉坤,石伟.物流系统仿真原理与应用.中国物资出版社.2005年:7-107.
    [61]Avninder Gill. Determining loading dock requirements in production-distribution facilities under uncertainty. Computers & Industrial Engineering. Volume 57, Issue 1, August 2009, Pages 161-168.
    [62]Govindaraj, T., Blanco, E. E., Bodner, D. A., Goetschalckx, M., McGinnis, L. F.,& Sharp, G. P. (2000). Design of warehousing and distribution systems:An object model of facilities, functions and information. In Proceedings of the IEEE international conference on systems, man, cybernetics, Nashville, Tennessee.pp:1099-1104.
    [63]Armour, Gordon C. and Elwood S. Buffa.1963. A Heuristic Algorithm and Simulation Approach to Related Location of Facilities. Management Science 9(2):294-309.
    [64]Rosenblatt, M. J. and Y. Roll.1984. Warehouse design with storage policy consideration. International Journal of Production Research 22 (5):809-921.
    [65]Caron, F., G. Marchet and A. Perego.1996. Design of picking systems through simulation. Proceedings of the 8th European Simulation Symposium. Genoa:456-460.
    [66]Caron, F., G. Marchet and A. Perego.2000. Layout design in manual picking system:a simulation approach. Integrated Manufacturing Systems 11(2):94-104.
    [67]Palekar, Udatta S, Rajan Batta, Robert M. Bosch and Sharad Elhence.1992. Modeling uncertainties in plant layout problems. European Journal of Operational Research.63(2): 347-359.
    [68]Charles G. Petersen Ⅱ, (1999) "The impact of routing and storage policies on warehouse efficiency", International Journal of Operations & Production Management, Vol.19 Iss:10, pp.1053-1064
    [69]郭磊,兰洪杰.基于Petri网的冷链配送流程仿真优化研究.物流科技.2010年02期.9-14
    [70]张文诺.基于Petri网的汽车生产物流流程仿真优化研究.硕十学位论文.吉林大学.2007.09.
    [71]韩飞.龙运物流园区物流作业流程仿真及优化研究.硕士学位论文.东北林业大学.2009.09.
    [72]袁罕,罗亚波.基十Flexsim的工艺流程仿真和优化.硕十学位论文.湖北工业大学学报.2007年03期:61-62.
    [73]Balagopal Gopakumar et al. A SIMULATION BASED APPROACH FOR DOCK ALLOCATION IN A FOOD DISTRIBUTION CENTER. Proceedings of the 2008 Winter Simulation Conference:2750-2755.
    [74]McWilliams, Douglas L.2005. Simulation-based scheduling for parcel consolidation terminals: a comparison of iterative improvement and simulated annealing. Proceedings of the 37th conference on winter simulation:2087-2093.
    [75]McWilliams, Douglas L., Paul M. Stanfield and Christopher D. Geiger.2005. The parcel hub scheduling problem:a simulation-based solution approach. Computers and Industrial Engineering 49(3). Nov.2005:393-412.
    [76]Eslayed, E.A., Elayat, H, and Ragals, A.M.1978. Simulation of conveyor systems with dual inputs. Simulation 31(8):97-103.
    [77]Potrc, I., Lerher, T., Kramberger, J., and Sraml, M. (2004), Simulation model of multishuttle automated storage and retrieval systems. Journal of Materials Processing Technology. No 157: 236-244.
    [78]Masel, Dale and David Goldsmith.1997. Using a simulation model to evaluate the configuration of a sortation facility. Proceedings of the 29th conference on winter simulation: 1210-1213.
    [79]Han, M.-H., L. F. McGinnis, J. S. Shieh, J. A. White.1987. On sequencing retrievals in an automated storage/retrieval system. IIE Transactions 19(1):56-66.
    [80]Schwarz, L. B., S. C. Graves and W.H. Hausman.1978. Scheduling policies for automatic warehousing systems:Simulation results. IIE Transactions 10(3):260-270.
    [81]Antonio Rizzi, Roberto Montanari, Andrea Volpi and Massimo Tizzi. Reengineering and Simulation of an RFID Manufacturing System. Dynamics in Logistics 2008, Part 7,211-219
    [82]McGregor, Ian.2002. Equipment interface:the relationship between simulation and emulation. Proceedings of the 34th conference on Winter simulation:1683-1688.
    [83]Medina, Lourdes A. et al,.2009. Simulation for predictive control of a distribution center. Proceedings of the 2009 Winter Simulation Conference:2426-2435
    [84]Petersen, C. G., G. Aase and D.R. Heiser.2004. Improving orderpicking performance through the implementation of class based storage. International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management 34 (7):534-544.
    [85]Vrgoc, M., and V. Ceric.1988. Investigation and design of parcel sorting systems in postal centers by simulation. Computers in Industry 10(2):137-145.
    [86]Bozer, Y. A. and G. P. Sharp.1985. An empirical evaluation of general purpose automated order accumulation and sortation system used in batch picking. Material Flow 2:111-113.
    [87]Petersen, C. G.1997. An evaluation of order picking routeing policies. International Journal of Operations & Production Management 17(11):1098-1111.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700