服务消费中顾客不当行为研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
服务业和社会公共服务事业在当今社会中具有越来越重要的作用。近年来,中国对服务业及社会服务事业的发展非常重视,在商贸、旅游餐饮、金融保险、交通运输、邮电通信、电子内容提供、政府服务等方面有了长足发展。服务产品与制造产品相区别的最大特性是顾客参与性,在顾客参与的过程中,顾客的社会行为会有遵守和违反社会规范的判断。违反消费情境中可接受的行为规范,并且破坏消费秩序的顾客行为被称为顾客不当行为,如拥挤、喧哗、随处弃物、违背习俗礼仪、顺手牵羊等等。随着人与人之间交互增加和公共活动空间扩大,服务业顾客不当行为现象越来越突出。顾客不当行为不但会对服务员工造成短期情绪困扰或长期心理影响,还会破坏同属顾客的消费经历,给服务组织带来间接或直接的经济损失。防范和控制顾客不当行为,维护服务秩序是非常重要的。为此,本文着眼于顾客不当行为理论研究的空白点,揭示顾客不当行为的影响效应、关键前因变量,检验管理措施的有效性,以期为管理顾客不当行为提供理论支持和实践指导。主要研究工作有以下几个方面:
     (1)顾客不当行为对同属环境顾客影响研究。运用关键事件法,对零售、餐饮、交通和旅游业消费者进行调查,分析归纳顾客不当行为类型及其对同属顾客服务经历造成的影响。研究发现,违反道德性规范、契约性规范和行政性规范的顾客不当行为均有发生并且对同属顾客的服务经历产生负面影响,其中违反道德性规范行为尤为突出。顾客不当行为会使同属顾客产生郁闷、烦躁、愤怒、对企业不满等主要情绪反应以及抱怨、终止服务甚至效仿等行为反应。另外,企业常常疏于对顾客不当行为的管理,多数企业处于无反应状态是顾客不当行为发生和传播的关键原因之一。
     揭示其他顾客不当行为对同属顾客的服务满意及行为倾向的影响机理,并检验关系质量的调节作用。研究表明,顾客与企业的不同关系质量会改变顾客对其他顾客不当行为的归因,以及随后的满意感知和行为倾向。在其他顾客实施不当行为的情况下,相对于低关系质量的顾客,高关系质量顾客的感知企业责任对满意的负面影响更小,感知员工努力对满意的正面影响更大,低满意度带来的离开倾向更小。加强关系质量相当于在一定程度上增强了服务组织削弱顾客不当行为影响的行为能力。增强员工应对和处理顾客不当行为的能力和技巧是管理顾客不当行为的重要措施。
     (2)顾客道德信念研究。道德信念是顾客实施道德或不道德行为的关键前因变量。实证研究表明,顾客道德信念具有多因子结构,包含了5个因子,即“主动获利”、“被动获利”、“无伤害行为”、“侵权”以及“环保和做好事”。顾客道德信念在年龄和教育程度上差异不显著,在性别、职业和收入上有比较显著的差异。研究结果可以使服务企业更好地理解顾客行为决策的道德信念准则,结合顾客特征采取恰当措施防范和控制消费者不道德行为。
     (3)服务业社会规范标识对顾客不当行为和满意的影响研究。在访谈和预实验的基础上,通过以零售业为行业背景的情景模拟实验检验不同特征的社会规范标识的有效性。以大学生随机样本为研究对象,方差分析结果表明:社会规范标识使顾客有更强的遵守社会规范的行为意图;引导型社会规范标识比阻止型社会规范标识会使顾客有更强的遵守社会规范行为意图和满意度;语气委婉的阻止型标识比语气生硬的阻止型标识会使顾客有更强的遵守社会规范行为意图和满意度。研究结果为服务企业设计有效的社会规范标识提供理论支持。
     (4)顾客不当行为管理策略研究。从服务企业、政府和教育部门三方面视角提出顾客不当行为的管理与教育策略建议。服务企业应转变传统营销观念,恰当对待顾客;传递企业价值观,强化顾客道德信念;合理规划服务设计,完善标识等规范实据;恰当展示服务内容和程序;审视市场细分,加强顾客兼容性管理;规范接触员工行为,提高不当行为管理技巧;开展顾客社会规范教育与疏导。政府及相关部门应完善《消费者权益保护法》,明确规定消费者义务,并逐步出台法律、法规规范各类消费者不当行为。各级教育部门应将消费者教育尤其是消费者义务和社会责任、伦理教育纳入课程体系中,使消费者树立社会规范意识,形成和谐消费的观念。
     最后,总结了本文的主要结论,并指出了本文研究的局限性及进一步研究方向。
Service and social public service in today's society has played more and more important role. In recent years, China has pay more attention to the development of service and social public service industry, commerce, tourism, catering, finance, insurance, transportation, communication, electronic content and government services have made significant development. Services, different from manufacturing goods, involve customer conducts that have the property of following or violating social norms. Customer misbehavior may be defined as behavioral acts by consumers, which violate the generally accepted norms of conduct in consumption situations, and thus disrupt the consumption order, such as crowding, noising, abandoned property anywhere, against the customs, shoplifting and so on. With the increasing interactions among people and extended public space, customer misbehavior become more and more prominent。Customer misbehavior would not only result in service staffs short-term or long-term psychological pressure, but also spoilt other consumer's service experience and bring direct or indirect economic loss to service organization. Prevention and control of customer misbehavior maintenance order is very important. Therefore, this article focuses on the gap of customer misbehavior theoretical research; reveal the effects of customer misbehavior, critical antecedent variables, testing the effectiveness of management measures in order to provide theoretical support and practical guidance for the management of customer misbehavior.
     The main research of this dissertation is as follows:
     (1) The impact of customer misbehavior on the customer in the same environment. Using the Critical Incident Technique, survey the customer during retailing, catering, transportation and tourism industries, summarize the type of customer misbehavior and the impact on other customer. The founding shows that customer misbehavior concludes the violation of moral norms, contractual norms and administrative norms. Customer misbehaviors have negative impact on the other customers. The negative impact on the other customers is reflected in for depression, irritability, anger, resentment and other enterprises to follow the main emotions and behavior. Survey shows that companies often neglect the management of customer misbehavior. One of the key reasons of customers misbehavior occurred and spreading is that most enterprises in disregard of state and no remedies.
     Analyze the impact of other customer misbehavior on customer service satisfaction and behavioral intentions, testing the moderating effect of relationship quality. The founding demonstrates that relationship quality between customer and service enterprises will change customer's attribution of other customer misbehavior, and the subsequent of satisfaction and behavioral intentions. Under the condition of other customer misbehavior, relative to the low-relationship quality customer, high-relationship quality customer's perceptions of enterprise responsibility has lower negative effect on satisfaction, perceived employee effort has higher positive effect on satisfaction, and satisfaction has lower negative effect on departure tendency. Based on these conclusions, strengthen the quality of relationship is equivalent to enhance the organization capacity to weaken the negative effect of customer misbehavior, and enhance employee's ability and skills to responds to and deal with customer misbehavior is the fundamental measure.
     (2) The customer ethical beliefs. Ethical belief is the key antecedent variables of consumer moral or immoral behavior. The result shows that five dimensions of consumer ethical beliefs were retained, that is,"actively benefiting, passively benefiting, questionable action, no harm, doing good/recycling". Consumer ethical beliefs' differences were not statistically significant on age and education and were statistically significant on gender, occupation and income. The findings should benefit service enterprises in understanding the ethical decision rules of consumers and adopting methods to deterrent and control consumer unethical behaviors.
     (3) The impact of Social norms signs on customer behavior intention and satisfaction. On the basis of interviews and preliminary experiments, the retail industry background scenario simulation experiment was conducted to identify social norm sign's validity. With the object of random sample of university students, the result of ANOVA shows that:social norm signs have a significant effects on customer behavior intention to comply with social norms; social norms signs of guiding have stronger effects on social norms behavior intention and satisfaction than the signs of preventing; for the preventing signs, signs written in softness tone have stronger effects on social norms behavior intention and satisfaction than the signs written in crudeness tone. These findings provide theoretical support to design effective social norms signs for the service companies.
     (4) Management strategy of customer misbehavior. Provide the management and education strategy recommendations from the perspective of service business, government and education departments. Service enterprises should change the traditional marketing concept, rational treatment of customers; convey the company value, and strengthen ethical beliefs; rational design planning services, improve the social norm evidence; exhibit service content and procedure; examine the market segments, strengthen Customer Compatibility Administrator; specification access to employee behavior, improve the management skills of customer misbehavior; conduct customer education and ease the social norms. Government and related departments should improve the "Consumer Protection Law" clearly provides consumers' obligation, and gradually introduced laws and regulations regulate all kinds of consumer misbehavior. Consumer education at all levels, particularly in the education sector should be the consumer obligations and social responsibility, ethics education into the curriculum system, so that consumers establish awareness of social norms, the concept of the formation of a harmonious consumption.
     At the end of the dissertation, it summarizes the main conclusions, points out the limitations of this study and further research direction in the future.
引文
[1]Fitzsimmons J A, Fitzsimmons M J. Service Management:Operations, Strategy and Information Technology [M]. The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc 3rd ed. 2001,4-5.
    [2]夏杰长.中国服务业三十年:发展历程、经验总结与改革措施[J].首都经济贸易大学学报,2008,6,42-52.
    [3]何德旭.中国服务业发展报告[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社,2007,3-4.
    [4]国家自然科学基金委员会管理科学部,管理科学发展战略[M].北京:科学出版社,2006.
    [5]Ma Q H, Tseng M M, Yen B. A Generic Model and Design Representation Technique of Service Products [J].Technovation,2002,22(1):15-39.
    [6]Ma Q H, Liu R P, Liu Z D. Customer social norm attribute of services:why does it matter and how do we deal with it [J]? International Journal of Services Technology and Management,2009,12(2):175-191.
    [7]Fullerton R A, Punj G. Repercussions of promoting an ideology of consumption: consumer misbehavior [J] Journal of Business Research,2004, 57(11):1239-1249.
    [8]刘汝萍,马钦海,范广伟.透视消费者不道德行为的背后:消费者道德信念[J].营销科学学报,2009,5(1):101-112.
    [9]Harris L C, Reynolds K L. The consequences of dysfunctional customer behavior [J]. Journal of Services Research,2003,6(2):144-61.
    [10]Babakus E, Cornwell T B, Mitchell V. Reactions to unethical consumer behavior across six countries[J]. Journal of Consumer Marketing,2004,21(4):254-263.
    [11]Steenhaut, Kenhove. An Empirical Investigation of the Relationships among a Consumer's Personal Values, Ethical Ideology and Ethical Beliefs [J]. Journal of Business Ethics,2006,64 (2):137-155.
    [12]Vitell S J. Consumer ethics research: review, synthesis and suggestions for the future [J]. Journal of Business Ethics,2003,43:33-48.
    [13]Belk R W, Devinney T and Eckhardt G. Consumer ethics across cultures [J]. Consumption Markets and Culture,2005,8(3):275-289.
    [14]Solomon R M, Czepiel J A and Evelyn G G. A role Theory perspective on dyadic Interactions:the service encounters [J] Journal of Marketing,1985,49 (6): 99-111.
    [15]Shostack G L. Planning the service encounter [M]. Lexington MA:Lexigton Books,1985,243-254.
    [16]Moore R, Moore M L and Capella M. The impact of customer-to-customer interactions in a high personal contact service setting [J]. Journal of Service Marketing,2005,19(7):482-491.
    [17]Bitner M J, Bernard H B and Lois A M. Critical Service Encounters:The Employee's Viewpoint [J]. Journal of Marketing,1994,58:95-106.
    [18]Grove S J, Fisk R P. The impact of other customers on service experiences:a critical incident examination of'getting along'[J]. Journal of Retailing,1997, 73(l):63-85.
    [19]Martin C L. Consumer-to-consumer relationships:satisfaction with other consumers' public behavior [J]. Journal of Consumer Affairs,1996, 30(1):146-69.
    [20]Wen-Hsien Huang. The impact of other-customer failure on service satisfaction [J]. International Journal of Service Industry Management,2008,19(4):521-536.
    [21]张春兴.现代心理学[M].上海:上海人民出版社,1997.
    [22]Gregoire Y, Fisher R J. The Effects of Relationship Quality on Customer Retaliation [J]. Marketing Letters,2006,17 (1):31-46.
    [23]Muncy J A, Vitell S.J. Consumer ethics:an investigation of the ethical beliefs of the final consumer [J]. Journal of Business Research,1992,24:297-311.
    [24]Chan A, Wong S and Leung P. Ethical beliefs of Chinese consumers in Hong Kong [J]. Journal of Business Ethics,1998,17(11):1163-1170.
    [25]Hunt S D, Vitell S J. A general theory of marketing ethics [J] Journal of Macromarketing,1986,8:5-16.
    [26]Levin A M, Conway D M and Rhee K. Money for nothing and hits for free; the ethics of downloading music from peer-to-peer websites [J]. Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice,2004,12:1-13.
    [27]Sarah S. An empirical investigation of the relationships among a consumer's personal values, ethical ideology and ethical beliefs [J] Journal of Business Ethics,2006,64(2):137-155.
    [28]Comte A. Introduction to Positive Philosophy [M]. Paris:Carillian-Goeury and Dalmot,1988.
    [29]Babbie E. The basics of Social Research [M].北京大学出版社,2005,111-114.
    [30]Reynolds K L, Harris L C. Dysfunctional Customer Behavior Severity:An Empirical Examination [J]. Journal of Retailing,2009,85(3):321-335.
    [31]Ford, Robert C and Woodrow D R. Ethical Decision Making:A Review of Empirical Literature [J]. Journal of Business Ethics,1994,13:205-221.
    [32]Kallis J M, Dinoo J V. Consumer Shoplifting:Orientations and Deterrents [J]. Journal of Criminal Justice.1985,13(5):459-473.
    [33]Longo, Tracey. At Stores, Many Unhappy Returns [J]. Kiplinger's Personal Finance Magazine,1995,20:239-255.
    [34]Hart, Christopher W L. Extraordinary Guarantees:A New Way to Build Quality Throughout Your Company and Ensure Satisfaction for Your Customers [M]. New York: AMACOM.1993.
    [35]Lovelock, Christopher. Product Plus:How Product and Service= Competitive Advantage [M]. McGraw Hill:USA,1994.
    [36]Fullerton R A, Sam D T and Ghosh B C. A Cross-Cultural Examination of Attitudes Toward Aberrant Consumer Behavior in the Marketplace:Some Preliminary Results from the USA, New Zealand and Singapore [J]. Market intelligence and Planning,1997,15(5):208-212.
    [37]Fullerton R A, Punj G. Choosing to Misbehave:a Structural Model of Aberrant Consumer Behavior [J]. Advances in Consumer Research,1993,20:570-574.
    [38]Moschis G P, Dena C. Deviant Consumer Behavior [J]. Advances in Consumer Research,1989,16:732-737.
    [39]David S, Vitell S J and Pelton L E. How Consumers May Justify Inappropriate Behavior in Market Settings:An Application on the Techniques of Neutralization [J]. Journal of Business Research,1994,30 (3):253-60.
    [40]Swee H A, Peng S C, Elison A C and Siok K T. Spot the difference:consumer responses towards counterfeits [J]. Journal of Consumer Marketing,2001,18(3): 219-235.
    [41]Hoffman K D, Kelley S W and Rotalsky H M. Tracking service failures and employee recovery efforts [J]. Journal of Services Marketing,1995,9(2):49-61.
    [42]Leonard L, Berry, Kathleen S. Serving unfair customers [J]. Business Horizons, 2008,51(1):29-37.
    [43]Albers-Miller, Nancy D. Consumer Misbehavior: Why People Buy Illicit Goods [J]. Journal of Consumer Marketing,1999,16(3):273-287.
    [44]Tonglet, Michele. Consumer Misbehavior: An Exploratory Study of Shoplifting [J]. Journal of Consumer Behavior,2002,11(4):336-354.
    [45]Freestone, Oliver and Vincent W M. Generation Y Attitudes Towards Eethics and Internet-related Misbehaviours [J]. Journal of Business Ethics,2004,54:121-128.
    [46]Harris L C, Reynolds K L. Jaycustomer behavior: an exploration of types and motives [J]. Journal of Services Marketing,2004,18(5):339-357.
    [47]Jolson, M A. Consumers as offenders [J]. Journal of Business Research,1974, 1(2):89-98.
    [48]Mills M K, Bonoma T V. Deviant consumer behavior: new challenge for marketing research [C]. Educators Conference Proceedings, American Marketing Association, Chicago, IL,1979,445-449.
    [49]Moore R H. Shoplifting in Middle America: patterns and motivational correlates [J]. International Journal of Offender therapy and Comparative Criminology, 1984,28(1):53-64.
    [50]McShane F, Noonan B A. Classification of shoplifters by cluster analysis [J]. International Journal of Offenders Therapy and Comparative Criminology,1993, 37(1):29-40.
    [51]Cameron, M O. The Booster and the Snitch:Department Store Shoplifting [M]. Free Press of Glencoe, New York,1964.
    [52]Bernstein P. Cheating-the new national pastime [J]? Business,1985,10:24-33.
    [53]Huefner J C, Hunt K H. Consumer retaliation as a response to dissatisfaction [J]. Journal of Consumer Satisfaction, Dissatisfaction and Complaining Behavior, 2000,13:61-82.
    [54]Van V W. Vandalism:an assessment agenda [M]. Levy-Leboyer, C. (Ed.), Vandalism:Behaviour and Motivations, North-Holland, Amsterdam,1984.
    [55]Stacey M, James W G and Terri L R. Building Understanding of the Domain of Consumer Vulnerability [J]. Journal of Macromarketing,2005,25(2):128-139.
    [56]Friedman M. Consumer Boycotts:Effecting Change Through the Marketplace and the Media [M]. Routledge, New York,1999.
    [57]Richins M L. An analysis of consumer interaction styles in the marketplace [J]. Journal of Consumer Research,1983,10(6):73-82.
    [58]Hirschman, E C. The consciousness of addiction:toward a general theory of compulsive consumption [J]. Journal of Consumer Research,1992, 19(9):155-79.
    [59]Gill M, Moon C, Seaman P and Turbin V. Security management and crime in hotels [J]. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management,2002, 14 (2):58-64.
    [60]Jones P, Groenenboom K. Crime in London hotels [J]. Tourism and Hospitality Research,2002,4(1):21-35.
    [61]Withiam G. Customers from hell:what do they do [J]? The Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administrative Quarterly,1998,39(5):11-15.
    [62]Grandey, Alicia A., David N. D. and Hock-Pen S. The Customer Is 'Not' Always Right:Customer Aggression and Emotion Regulation of Service Employees [J].Journal of Organizational Behavior,2004,25(3):397-418.
    [63]Hui M K, Bateson J G. Perceived control and the effects of crowding and consumer choice on the service experience [J] Journal of Consumer Research, 1991,18(2):174-84.
    [64]Cox D, Cox A D and Moschis G P. When consumer behavior goes bad:an investigation of adolescent shoplifting [J]. Journal of Consumer Research,1990, 17:149-59.
    [65]Caruana A, Ramaseshan B and Ewing M T. Anomia and deviant behaviour in marketing: some preliminary evidence [J]. Journal of Managerial Psychology, 2001,16 (5):322-38.
    [66]Mills, Michael K. Deviance and Dissatisfaction: An Exploratory Study [J]. Advances in Consumer Research,1981,8:682-686.
    [67]Parasuraman A, Zeithaml V A and Berry L L. Refinement and reassessment of the SERVQUAL scale [J]. Journal of Retailing,1991,67(4):420-50.
    [68]Hartline M D, Ferrell O C. The management of customer-contact service employees:an empirical investigation [J]. Journal of Marketing,1996,60(10): 52-70.
    [69]Andrew S, Stephen F .When Do Customer Contact Employees Satisfy Customers [J]? Journal of Service Research,2000,3(1):18-34.
    [70]Richins M L. An analysis of consumer interaction styles in the marketplace [J]. Journal of Consumer Research,1983,10(6),73-82.
    [71]Godwin B F, Patterson P G and Johnson L W. Consumer coping strategies with dissatisfactory service encounter: a preliminary investigation [J]. Journal of Consumer Satisfaction, Dissatisfaction and Complaining Behavior,1999,12: 145-154.
    [72]Rose RL, Neidermeyer M. From rudeness to roadrage:the antecedents and consequences of consumer aggression [J]. Advances in Consumer Research, 1999,26:12-17.
    [73]金立印.基于服务公正性感知的顾客不良行为模型研究[J].营销科学学报,2006,2(1):1-17.
    [74]赵宇飞,穆泉伶.浅析服务企业问题顾客的管理[J].企业活力,2008,12,30-31.
    [75]Tittle C R. Sanctions and social deviance [M]. New York, NY: Praeger,1980.
    [76]董敏志.关于社会道德控制的几个问题[J].社会科学,1996,2:45-49.
    [77]俞国良.品德与社会性[J].教育科学研究,2003,5:43-46.
    [78]刘光杰,刘峻.论消费社会性与科学消费[J].消费经济,2006,5:41-44
    [79]郑晓明.异文化圈社会规范层次结构模型的比较研究[M].北京:经济科学出版社,2003.
    [80]夏玉珍.社会规范是维持社会秩序的基本手段[J].理论与实践,2002,(2):48-49.
    [81]韦森.习俗的本质与生发机制探源[J].中国社会科学,2000,5:39-50.
    [82]凌文辁,郑晓明,方俐洛.社会规范的跨文化比较[J].心理学报,2003,35(2):246-254.
    [83]郑晓明,方俐洛,凌文辁.社会规范研究综述[J].心理学动态,1997,5(4):16-21.
    [84]童星,罗军.社会规范的三种形式及其相互关系[J].江海学刊,2001,(3):50-55.
    [85]何怀宏.契约理论与社会正义—罗尔斯正义论中的历史与理性[M].中国人民大学出版社,1993.
    [86]Cialdini R B, Kallgren C A and Reno R R. A focus theory of normative conduct [J]. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology,1991,24:201-234.
    [87]Jackson J. Structural characteristics of norms [J]. Current Studies in Social Psychology, New York:Holt,1965.
    [88]Redmond W H. On Institutional Rationality [J]. Journal of Economic Issues, 2004,38(1):173-190.
    [89]文崇一.中国人的价值观[M].台湾:东大图书公司,1989.
    [90]Bailey J J, Nofsinger J R and Neill M. Retirement Plan Contribution Decision Factors:The Role of Social Norms [J]. Journal of Business and Management, 2004,9(4):327-344.
    [91]Elster J. Social Norms and Economic Theory [J]. The Journal of Economic Perspectives (1986-1998),1989,3(4):99-117.
    [92]Hofstede G. Culture's consequences:International differences in work-related values [M]. Beverly Hills, CA:Sage Publications,1984.
    [93]Nozick R. On Austrian methodology [J].Synthese,1977,36:353-392.
    [94]Talcott P. The Theories of Society, Foundation of Modem Sociological Theory [M], The Free Press Glencoe, Inc,1961.
    [95]王二平,工作社会规范观念的心理学研究与跨文化比较[D].博士论文,1991.
    [96]马钦海,关志民.基于全顾客经历的服务产品结构化概念[J].管理评论,2004,16(1).
    [97]麻美英.规范、秩序与自由[J].浙江大学学报(人文社会科学版),2000,30(6):25-31.
    [98]Bitner M J, Booms B H and Tetreault M S. The service encounter: diagnosing favorable and unfavorable incidents [J]. Journal of Marketing,1990,54(1): 71-84.
    [99]Berry, Parasuraman and Zeithaml. The Service-Quality Puzzle [J]. Business Horizons,1988,21(9):35-43.
    [100]Bitner M J. Servicescapes:The impact of physical surroundings on customers and employees [J]. Journal of marketing,1992,56(2):57-71.
    [101]Parasuraman, Zeithaml and Berry. A Conceptual Model of Service Quality and Its Implications for Future Research [J]. Journal of Marketing,1985,49(3): 41-50.
    [102]Parasuraman, Zeithaml and Berry. SERVQUAL:A Multiple-Item Scale for Measuring Customer Perceptions of Service Quality [J]. Journal of Retailing, 1988,30(1):12-40.
    [103]Binter M J, Brown S W and Meuter M L. Technology Infusion in Service Encounters [J]. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,2000, 28(4):138-149.
    [104]Dabholkar P A, Bagozzi R P. An Attitudinal Model of Technology-Based Self-Service:Moderating Effects of Consumer Traits and Situational Factors [J]. Academy of Marketing Science Journal,2002,30(3):184-201.
    [105]Meuter M L, Ostrom A L, Roundtree R I and Bitner M J. Self-Service Technologies:Understanding Customer Satisfaction with Technology-Based Service Encounters [J]. Journal of Marketing,2000,64(3):50-64.
    [106]Langeard E, John E G, Lovelock C H and Eigler P. Marketing of service:new insights from consumer and managers [M]. Cambridge, MA:Marketing Science Institute,1981.
    [107]Grove, Stephen J and Raymond P F. The service experience as theater [J].Advances in Consumer Research,1992,19(1):455-461.
    [108]Baker, Julie, Dhruv G and Parausuraman A. The influence of store environment on quality inferences and store image [J]. Journal of Academy of Marketing Science,1994,22(4):328-339.
    [109]Lehtinen, Uolevi and Jarmo R L. Two approach to service quality [J]. The Service Industry Journal,1991, 11(7):287-303.
    [110]Lovelock, C.H.服务营销(第三版)[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2001:44-46.
    [111]Smith A K, Bolton R N and Wagner J. A model of customer satisfaction with service encounters involving failure and recovery [J]. Journal of Marketing Research,1999,34 (8):356-370.
    [112]Hays J M, Hill A V. The market share impact of service failures [J]. Production and Operations Management,1999,8(3):208-220.
    [113]Parasuraman A, Leonard L, Berry V A and Zeithaml. Understanding customer expectations of service [J]. Sloan Management Review,1991,32 (3):39-48.
    [114]于志华.基于顾客关系视角的服务补救理论、模型与实证[D].山东大学,2007.
    [115]Hoffman K D, Kelley S W and Rotalsky H M. Tracking service failures and employee recovery efforts [J]. Journal of Services Marketing,1995,9(2):49-61.
    [116]金立印.基于关键事件法的服务失败原因及补救战略效果定性分析[J].管理科学,2005,18(4):63-70.
    [117]Gronroos C. Service quality: The six criteria of good perceived service quality [J]. Review of Business,1988,9(3):10-13.
    [118]Tax S S, Brown S W and Chandrashekaren M. Customer evaluations of service complaint experierces:Implications for relationship marketing [J].Journal of Marketing,1998,60(2):60-76.
    [119]Hart C W, Heskett J L and Sasser W E. The profitable art of service recovery [J]. Harvard Business Review,1990,68(4):148-156.
    [120]Johnston T C, Hewa M A. Fixing service failures [J].Industrial Marketing Management,1997,26:467-73.
    [121]Secngoog W, Beatty S E and Jones M A. The impact of service failure severity on service recovery evaluations and post-recovery relationships [J].The Journal of Service Marketing,2004,18(2):133-145.
    [122]Kelley S W, Davis M A. Antecedents to customer expectations for service recovery [J].Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,1994,22(1):52-61.
    [123]Colgate M R, Norris, M. Developing a comprehensive picture of service failure [J]. International Journal of Service Industry Management,2001, 12(3):215-233.
    [124]Maxham J G, Netemeyer R G. A Longitudinal study of Complaining Customers Evaluations of Multiple Service Failure and Revo very Efforts [J].Journal of Marketing,2002,86(10):7-71.
    [125]韦福祥.对服务补救若干问题的探讨[J].天津商学院学报,2002(1):24-26.
    [126]陈忠卫,董晓波.服务理论述评[J].中外企业家,2005,(4):86-91.
    [127]Kelley S W, Hoffman K D and Davis M A. A typology of retail failures and recoveries [J].Journal of Retailing,1993,69(6):429-452.
    [128]Blodgett J G, Stephen S T. The effects of distributive and interactional justice on complaints repatronage intentions and negative word-of-mouth intentions [J]. Journal of Consumer Satisfavtion, Dissatisfaction an Complaining Behavior, 1993, (6):100-110.
    [129]Goodwin G, Ivan R. Consumer responses to service failures:Influence of procedural and interactional fairness perceptions [J]. Journal of Business Research,1992,25(2):149-163.
    [130]高兆明.伦理学理论与方法.[M].人民出版社,2005,8-9.
    [131]王海明.伦理学方法[M].北京:商务印书馆,2004,4.
    [132]Malhotra N K, Miller G L. An Integrated Model for Ethical Decisions in Marketing Research [J]. Journal of Business Ethics,1998,17:263-280.
    [133]Murphym, Patrick E and Gene R L. Marketing Ethics:A Review with Implications for Managers, Educators and Researchers[C]. Ben M. Enis and Kenneth J. Roering (eds.), Review of Marketing (American Marketing Association, Chicago),1981,251-266.
    [134]何怀宏.伦理学是什么?[M]北京大学出版社,2002,8-12.
    [135]Kyoko Fukukawa. A Theoretical Review of Business and Consumer Ethics Research: Normative and Descriptive Approaches [J].The Marketing Review, 2003,3:381-401.
    [136]Sarah S. An empirical investigation of the relationships among a consumer's personal values, ethical ideology and ethical beliefs [J].Journal of Business Ethics,2006,64(2):137-155.
    [137]Wilkes R E. Frauduling behavior by consumers [J].Journal of Marketing,1978, 10:67-75.
    [138]Davis R M. Comparison of consumer acceptance of right and responsibility[C].Ackerman N M. Proceedings of 25th Annual Conference of the American Council on Consumer Interests,1979:68-70.
    [139]Lascu, Danna-Nicoleta. Assessing Consumer Ethics:Scale Development Considerations for International Marketing [C].In:Rajan Varadarajan and Bernard,Jaworski (eds.),Proceeding of the American Marketing Association Winter Educators'Conference,1993,57-61.
    [140]Rawwas, Mohammed Y A, Gordon P and Michael K. Consumer Ethics in Cross Cultural Settings [J]. European Journal of Marketing,1995,29(7):62-78.
    [141]Rawwas, Mohammed Y A. Culture, Personality and Morality:A Typology of International Consumers'Ethical Beliefs [J]. International Marketing Review 2001,18(2):188-209.
    [142]Polonsky M J, Pedro Q B, Jorge P and Nicola H K. Consumer ethics in the European Union:a comparison of Northern and Southern Views [J] Journal of Business Ethics,2001,31 (2):117-130.
    [143]张怀承.论道德传统的创造与超越[J].广州社会主义学院学报,2004(2):3-6.
    [144]黄济.中国伦理道德传统述要[J].中国教育学刊,2005(7):21-24.
    [145]罗国杰.继承和发扬中华民族优良道德传统,创造出人类先进的精神文明[J].道德与文明,1993(4):14-17.
    [146]阎孟伟.“道德危机”及其社会根源[J].道德与文明,2006(2):45-48.
    [147]曹劲松.网络道德初探[J].道德与文明,2002,2:63-66.
    [148]张小红.网络伦理问题研究综述[J].中国电化教育,2006(9):19-22.
    [149]毛蔚兰.关于消费的道德思考[J].河南商业高等专科学校学报,2005(5):13-15.
    [150]王学锋.浅谈家庭消费的道德原则[J].桂海论丛,2007(1):49-51.
    [151]李素云.大学生不良消费现状及消费道德之重构[J].商场现代化,2007(32):38-39.
    [152]何国清.关于当代大学生消费行为的思考[J].湖北经济学院学报,2007(4):20-21.
    [153]陈勇,黄嫱.试论可持续消费的伦理观[J].伦理学研究,2005,6:61-66.
    [154]孙卫华.节俭性消费的理论基础及现实意义[J].理论与实践,2006,2:86-88.
    [155]蒋柳萍.绿色消费的伦理价值[J].上海师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2002,1:1-7.
    [156]Rawwas M Y A. Consumer ethics:an empirical investigation of the ethical beliefs of Austrian consumers [J]. Journal of Business Ethics, 1996,15(9):1009-1019.
    [157]Rawwas M Y A, Singhapakdi A. Do consumers'ethical beliefs vary with age? A substantiation of Kohlberg's typology in marketing [J]. Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice,1998,6:26-38.
    [158]Erffmeyer R C, Keillor B D and LeClair D T. An empirical investigation of Japanese consumer ethics [J].Journal of Business Ethics,1999,18(1):35-50.
    [159]Swaidan Z, Rawwas M Y A. Consumer ethics:moral ideologies and ethical beliefs of a micro-culture in the US [J]. International Business Review,2004, 13(6):749-761.
    [160]Babakus E, Cornwell T B, Mitchell V, Schlegelmilch B. Reactions to unethical consumer behavior across six countries[J]. Journal of Consumer Marketing, 2004,21(4):254-263.
    [161]Rallapalli, Kumar C, Scott J V, Frank A W and James H B. Consumer Ethical Beliefs and Personality Traits:An Exploratory Analysis [J]. Journal of Business Ethics,1994,13(7):487-495.
    [162]Vitell S J. Consumers'ethical beliefs:the Roles of money, religiosity and attitude toward business [J] Journal of Business Ethics,2007,73(4):369-379.
    [163]Rawwas, Mohammed Y A, Vitell S J and Al-Khatib J. Consumer Ethics:The Possible Effects of Terrorism and Civil Unrest on the Ethical Values of Consumers [J]. Journal of Business Ethics,1994,13(3):223-231.
    [164]Swaidan Ziad. Consumer Ethics and Acculturation: The Case of the Muslim Minority in the U.S. [D]. University of Mississippi.1999.
    [165]Chiou Jyh-Shen, Pan-Yun Lee. The Impact of Social Darwinism Perception, Status Anxiety, Perceived Trust of People, and Cultural Orientation on Consumer Ethical Beliefs [J]. Journal of Business Ethics,2008,78(4):487-501.
    [166]赵宝春.中国消费者伦理行为研究:基于社会性的视角[D].华中科技大学,2008.
    [167]Steenhaut, Sarah S. Relationship Commitment and Ethical Consumer Behavior in a Retail Setting:The Case of Receiving Too Much Change at the Checkout [J]. Journal of Business Ethics,2005,56 (4):335-353.
    [168]Michele Tonglet. Consumer misbehaviour:An exploratory study of shoplifting [J]. Journal of Consumer Behaviour,2001,1(4):336-354.
    [169]Johannes B, Patrick L. Understanding Insurance Customer Dishonesty: Outline of a Moral-Sociological Approach [J]. Journal of Business Ethics,2006,66: 177-195.
    [170]Aron M. Levin. Money for nothing and hits for free:the ethics of downloading music from peer to peer web sites [J]. Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice,2004,11(2):105-117.
    [171]郭朝阳.我国青少年强迫性购买倾向研究—基于消费者社会化的视角[J].经济管理,2009,31(5):95-102.
    [172]曾伏娥.消费者非伦理行为形成过程:理论构建与机理探讨[J].营销科学学报,2006,2(4):51-71.
    [173]曾伏娥,甘碧群.消费者伦理信念及关系质量对消费者非伦理行为的影响[J].经济管理,2007,18:33-39.
    [174]Walker S, Truly E L. The Critical Incident Technique:Philosophical and Methodological Contributions to Marketing Research[C]. In Proceedings of the American Marketing Association's Winter Educator's Conference, Chris T. Allen et al., eds., Chicago, IL:American Marketing Association,1992, 270-275.
    [175]Flanagan J C. The Critical Incident Technique [J]. Psychological Bulletin,1954, 51 (7):327-357.
    [176]Gremler D D. The Critical Incident Technique in Service Research [J]. Journal of Service Research,2004,7:65-89.
    [177]风笑天.社会学研究方法[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2005,314-315.
    [178]Kenhouse, Patrick V, Kristof D W and Sarah S. The Relationship between Consumers' Unethical Behavior and Customer Loyalty in a Retail Environment [J]. Journal of Business Ethics,2003,44:261-278.
    [179]Richins M L. An Analysis of Consumer Interaction Styles in the Marketplace [J]. Journal of Consumer Research,1983,10(6):73-82.
    [180]Azar O H. What sustains social norms and how they evolve? The case of tipping [J]. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization,2004,54(1):49-64.
    [181]Mohr L A, Bitner M J. Mutual understanding between customers and employees in service encounters. Advances in Consumer Research,1991,18: 611-617.
    [182]Folkes V S. Consumer reactions to product failure:an attributional approach [J]. Journal of Consumer Research,1984,10,398-409.
    [183]Weiner B. Human Motivation [M]. New York:Holt, Rinehart & Winston,1980.
    [184]Weiner B. Attributional thoughts about consumer behavior [J]. Journal of Consumer Research,2000,27(3):382-387.
    [185]Hess R L, Ganesan S and Klein N M. Service failure and recovery:the impact of relationship factors on customer satisfaction [J] Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,2003,31(2):127-45.
    [186]Mirjam G, Joost W M and Verhoeven. Service validity and service reliability of search, experience and credence services:A scenario study [J]. International Journal of Service Industry Management,2006,17(3):271-283.
    [187]Mattila A S, Patterson P G. The impact of culture on consumers' perceptions of service recovery efforts [J]. Journal of Retailing,2004,80(3):196-206.
    [188]Oliver R L. A cognitive model of the antecedents and consequences of satisfaction decisions [J] Journal of Marketing Research,1980,17,460-469.
    [189]Poon P, Hui M and Au K. Attributions on dissatisfying service encounters [J]. Europe Journal of Marketing,2004,38(12):1527-1540.
    [190]Sunmee C and Mattila A S. Perceived controllability and service expectations: Influences on customer reactions following service failure [J]. Journal of Business Research,2008,61:24-30.
    [191]McCollough M A, Berry L L and Yadav M S. An empirical investigation of customer satisfaction after service failure and recovery [J]. Journal of Service Research,2000,3(2):121-137.
    [192]Hess R L, Ganesan S and Klein N M. Service failure and recovery:the impact of relationship factors on customer satisfaction [J] Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,2003,31(2):127-45.
    [193]Swanson S R, Kelley S W. Attributions and outcomes of the service recovery process [J]. Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice,2001,9 (4):50-65.
    [194]Guenzi P. and Pelloni O. The impact of interpersonal relationships on customer satisfaction and loyalty to the service provider [J]. International Journal of Service Industry Management,2004,15(4),365-84
    [195]Mohr L A and Bitner M J. The role of employee effort in satisfaction with service transactions [J]. Journal of Business Research,1995,32(3):239-52
    [196]McCullough K.,Chris Rachal, Steven J., and Sandage, Everett L. Interpersonal Forgiving in Close Relationship:Theoretical Elaboration and Measurement [J].Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,1998,75 (2):1586-1603
    [197]Gregoire Y, Thomas M. Tripp and Renaud Legoux. When customer love turn into lasting hate:the effects of relationship strength and time on customer revenge and avoidance [J]. Journal of Marketing,2009,73(4):18-32.
    [198]Wade, James C and Amy L O. Complaining to the masses:the role of protest framing in customer-created complaint web sites [J]. Journal of consumer research,2006,33(11)220-230.
    [199]Gregoire Yany and Robert J. Fisher. The Effects of Relationship Quality on Customer Retaliation [J].Marketing Letters,2006,17(1):31-46.
    [200]Singh J. Consumer complaint intentions and behavior: definitional and taxonomical issues [J]. Journal of Marketing,1988,52(1):93-107.
    [201]Crosby Lawrence A, Evans Kenneth R. and Cowles Deborah. Relationship quality in services selling:an interpersonal influence perspective [J]. Journal of Marketing,1990,54 (3):68-81.
    [202]Hennig-Thurau, Thorsten and Klee Alexander. The Impact of customer satisfaction and relationship quality on customer retention:a critical reassessment and model development [J]. Psychology & Marketing,1997,14 (8):737-765.
    [203]Amy W, Amrik S. Customers'perspectives on service quality and relationship quality in retail encounters [J].Managing Service Quality,2002,12(6):424-433.
    [204]Crosby L A. Exploding some Myths about Customer Relationship Management [J]. Managing Service Quality, Bedford,2002,12(5):271.
    [205]Oliver, Richard L., Balakrishnan P.V., Sundar, Barry and Bruce. Outcome Satisfaction in Negotiation: A Test of Expectancy Disconfirmation [J]. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, New York,1994, 60(2):252.
    [206]Moorman, R H. The Influence of Cognitive and Affective Based Job Satisfaction Measures on the Relationship between Satisfaction and Organizational Citizenship Behavior [J]. Human Relations,1993,46(6):759.
    [207]Mattila A. S. The impact of service failures on customer loyalty: the moderating role of affective commitment [J]. International Journal of Service Industry Management,2001,15(2):134-149.
    [208]范秀成,刘建华.顾客关系、信任与顾客对服务失败的反应[J].南开管理评论,2004,7(6):9-14.
    [209]Berry L. L. Relationship marketing of service—Growing interest, emerging perspective [J]. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 1995,23,236-245
    [210]彭军峰,景奉杰.关系品质对服务补救效果的调节作用[J].南开管理评论,2006,9(4):8-15
    [211]Jooyeon H, Soo C J. Perceived justice in service recovery and behavioral intentions:The role of relationship quality [J]. International Journal of Hospitality Management,2009,28:319-327.
    [212]严浩仁,贾升华.顾客满意向顾客忠诚的转换机理研究综述[J].山西财经大学学报,2003,25(6):65-68.
    [213]马钦海,李艺.服务消费顾客满意与顾客忠诚关系调节因素的实证研究[J].管理科学,2007,20(5):48-59.
    [214]Shamdasani P N, Balakrishnan A A. Determinants of relationship quality and loyalty inpersonalized services [J]. Asia Pacific Journal of Management, 2000,17(3):399-422.
    [215]Hair J F, Rolph E, Anderson, Ronald L, and Tatham W C. Multivariate Data Analysis [M].5th ed. Upper Saddle River, NJ:Prentice Hall,1998,117.
    [216]吴明隆SPSS统计应用实务:问卷分析与应用统计[M].北京:科学出版 社,2003,42-58.
    [217]陈晓萍,徐淑英,樊景立.组织与管理研究的实证方法[M].北京:北京大学出版社,2008,109.
    [218]Schermelleh E K, Moosbrugger H and Miiller H. Evaluating the Fit of Structural Equation Models:Tests of Significance and Descriptive Goodness-of-Fit Measures [J]. Methods of Psychological Research Online, 2003,8(2):23-74.
    [219]Posdakoff P, Mackencie S B. Organizational Citizenship Behaviors and Scales Unit Effectiveness [J]. Journal of Marketing Research,1994,31(3):351-363.
    [220]侯杰泰,温忠麟,成子娟.结构方程模型及其应用[M].北京:教育科学出版社,2005,154-161.
    [221]温忠麟,侯杰泰.隐变量交互效应分析方法的比较与评价[J].数理统计与管理,2004,23(3):37-42.
    [222]吴明隆.结构方程模型——AMOS的操作与应用[M].重庆大学出版社,2009.
    [223]Vitell S J.Consumers'ethical beliefs:the Roles of money, religiosity and attitude toward business [J]. Journal of Business Ethics,2007,73(4):369-379.
    [224]Vitell S J, Muncy J A. The Muncy-Vitell consumer ethics scale:a modification and application [J].Journal of Business Ethics,2005,62(3):267-275.
    [225]Fornell C, Larcker D F. Evaluating structural equation models with unobservable variables and measurement error [J]. Journal of Marketing Research,1981,27:39-50.
    [226]Chevalier, Michel. Increase in Sales Due to In-Store Display [J]. Journal of Marketing Research,1975,12(2):426-431.
    [227]张黎,范亭亭,王文博.降价表述方式与消费者感知的降价幅度和购买意愿[J].南开管理评论,2007,10(3),19-28.[243]
    [228]何兆熊.语用学概要[M],上海外语教育出版社,1989,77-90.
    [229]Youjae Y, Taeshik G. The effects of customer justice perception and affect on customer citizenship behavior and customer dysfunctional behavior [J]. Industrial Marketing Management,2008,37(2):767-783.
    [230]Shwu-Ing W. The Impact of Attitude, Subjective Norm and Involvement on Online Behavioral Intention: A Structural Model Examination [J]. Journal of International Marketing Research,2005,30(2):67-91.
    [231]Westbrook R A, Oliver R L. The dimensionality of consumption emotion patterns and consumer satisfaction, Journal of Consumer Research,1991, 18(6):84-91.
    [232]朱建平.语气与礼貌原则[J].湘潭师范学院学报,1999,20(5):105-108.
    [233]周日安,郭水华,朱少红.社会用语学崛起的先声[J].语言文字应用,1992,3,67-70.
    [234]刘汝萍,马钦海,刘锐,张跃先.中国文化背景下消费者服务个人价值观研究[J].东北大学学报(自然科学版),2009,30(1):149-152.
    [235]冯启海,纪光欣.美国企业价值观及其启示[J].石油大学学报,2001,(6):11-15.
    [236]孙友祥.现代企业价值观探析[J].湖北大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2000,(9):24-27.
    [237]林哲.从商家的“选择权”看公民平等权的保护[J].政治与法律,2002,(5):16-19.
    [238]覃有土,晏宇桥.论消费者之义务[J].中南财经政法大学学报,2004,(1):13-15.
    [239]王继远.论经营者之权利[J].黑龙江社会科学,2008,3:158-161.
    [240]应晓琼.欧洲学校消费者教育[D].华东师范大学,2007.
    [241]张超.挪威消费教育及对我国中小学的启示[J].海南师范大学学报(社会科学版),2008,21,(1):149-153.
    [242]龚萍.香港消费维权的基本经验与借鉴[J].工商行政管理,2007,6:56-58.
    [243]张立杰.当代日本学校消费者教育研究[D].华东师范大学,2009.
    [244]王伟婉.试论中国新时期的消费者教育[J].社科纵横,2009,24(3):13-17.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700