腹腔镜和开腹胆囊切除术对老年人手术后应激反应和疲劳综合症影响的比较研究
|
摘要
目的比较腹腔镜与开腹胆囊切除术减轻老年病人术后应激反应和术后疲劳综合征的影响,为腹腔镜胆囊切除术治疗老年人胆囊结石是否具有微创优越性提供相关的客观依据。
方法筛选符合相关适应症的胆囊结石患者40例,年龄为60岁≤年龄≤70岁;随机分为两组,每组各20例(两组病人性别,年龄等无显著性差异)即腹腔镜胆囊切除术(laparoscopic cholecystectomy, LC)手术组和开腹胆囊切除术(tra- ditional open cholecystectomy, OC)手术组。于手术前1天(T_0)、术后第1天(T_1)、2天(T_2)、3天(T_3)作为观察点,分别检测手术前后白介素6(Inter- leukin-6,IL-6),白介素10(Interleukin-10,IL-10),C-反应蛋白(C-reactive protein,CRP),白细胞(white blood cell,WBC)计数及中性粒细胞(Neutropils)分类,皮质醇等指标;于术后第1天(T_1)、2天(T_2 )、3天(T_3)作为观察点,分别检测病人的术后疲劳评分指数,统计并比较两组的平均手术时间,术中出血量,术后镇痛用药率,术后发热天数,平均住院天数等方面做分析。
结果1.术前两组病人的IL-6浓度无显著性差异;术后两组病人的IL-6均明显升高,与T_0期相比有显著性差异,并且在T_1期达到高峰,在T_2, T_3期逐渐下降;术后T_1,T_2期LC手术组病人的IL-6浓度和OC手术组病人的相比较,LC手术组的均较OC手术组的低。2.术前两组病人的IL-10浓度相比无显著性差异;术后两组病人各期的IL-10浓度从T_1期开始降低;LC手术组病人的IL-10浓度在T_2期最低,在T_1、T_3期也低于术前;OC手术组病人的IL-10浓度在T_3期达到最低,在T_1、T_2期不同程度的降低;组间相比较,在T_2、T_3期LC手术组的值明显高于OC手术组的值。3.术前两组病人的CRP浓度无显著性差异;术后各期相比较,两组病人术后CRP水平均升高,在T_1期达到最高值,OC手术组除了术后各期CRP浓度明显高于LC手术组外,T_3期CRP仍然明显高于术前,但是LC手术组T_3期已经接近于正常;组间相比较,术后各期LC手术组较OC手术组CRP浓度低。4.术前两组病人WBC计数和中性粒细胞分类无显著性差异;术后OC组病人WBC计数T_1、T_2、T_3期均较术前升高,在术后T_1期达到高峰;LC组病人T_1、T_2期较术前升高,T_3期接近术前水平;组间相比较,OC手术组病人的WBC计数在术后各期较LC手术组病人的升高明显。5.术前两组病人的皮质醇浓度无显著性差异;术后LC手术组病人的皮质醇浓度T_1、T_2、T_3期均无明显升高,与T_0期相比无显著性差异;术后OC手术组病人的皮质醇浓度在T_1期升高,和T_0期相比有显著性差异,在T_2期开始回落到正常,组间相比较,在T_1期LC手术组的皮质醇浓度低于OC手术组的皮质醇浓度。6.两组病人术后各期的术后疲劳评分均升高,在术后T_1期评分值达到高峰,组间相比较,在术后各期的评分值OC手术组均高于LC手术组。
结论与开腹胆囊切除术相比,腹腔镜胆囊切除术治疗老年患者胆囊结石,可以明显的减少术后应激,减轻老年病人术后疲劳综合的征状,临床疗效可靠,有着较高的临床应用价值。
Objective:
T_o study whether the elderly patients’post-operative stress response and fatigue syndrome can be eased by laparoscopic cholecystectomy,trying to offer objective proof for the superiority of laparoscopic cholecystectomy in curing the elderly patients with gallbladder stone.
Methods:
In the beginning, forty elderly male and female gallbladder stone patients, aging from 60 to 70, have been under screening in terms of relevant indication. T_hen the selected patients were divided into 2 groups, and 20 patients with no significant differences of gender and no age in each group. T_he two groups were named as laparoscopic cholecystectomy operation group (L.C) and open–cholecystectomy operation group (O.C). Next, the day before the operation was marked T_0, the first day after operation T_1, the second day after operation T_2, the third day after operation T_3 . T_0, T_1, T_2, T_3 were chosen as the observation points. Later, various indicators, both in pre-operation and post-operation, were examined, such as Interleukin-6 (IL-6), Interleukin-10(IL-10), C-reactive protein (CRP), white blood cell (WBC), Neutropils and Cortisol etc. At last, from the observation points T_1, T_2, T_3 , some analysis were made, such as assessing the patients’post-operation fatigue, counting and comparing the two groups’average operation time, operation blood loss amount, post-operation analgesic using rate, the post-operation fever days, and the average length of hospitalization.
Results:
1. In pre-operation, there was no significant IL-6 density level distinction between the two groups. In post-operation, a significant IL-6 density level increase was detected in the two groups. And some significant IL-6 levels distinctions were revealed when compared with that of T_0. Besides, IL-6 level reaches its peak in the T_1 , then gradually declines in the T_2 and T_3 . In the T_1 and T_2 , in terms of IL-6 density levels, L.C’s were lower than O.C’s .
2. In pre-operation, there was no significant IL-10 density distinction between the two group’s patients. In post-operation, from T_1, the IL-10 density of patients in two groups begins to decline; IL-10 densities of the patients in L.C were at the lowest level in the T_2 and show a striking difference from O.C group. In addition, IL-10 densities in the T_1 and T_3 were lower than that of pre-operation; By contrast, for the O.C IL-10 density levels of the patients were at the lowest level in the T_3 after some declining in the T_1 and T_2. Comparing the two groups, in the T_2 and T_3 L.C’s IL-10 density levels were significantly higher than O.C’s.
3. In pre-operation, there was no significant CRP density distinction between the two group’s patients; in the different post-operation periods, CRP levels in both the two groups’patients rise and reach its peak in the T_1.Meanwhile, CRP density levels in O.C were significantly higher than those of LC. Besides, in the T_3CRP levels of O.C were significantly higher than that of pre-operation. By contrast, in the T_3, CRP level of patients in the L.C has already restored to the normal level. Comparing the two groups, in post-operation L.C’s CRP density levels were significantly lower than O.C’s.
4. In pre-operation, there was no significant distinction about WBC number, neutrophil category between the two group’s patients. In post-operation, WBC number of patients in the O.C group increases in the T_1, T_2, T_3 and reaches its peak in the T_1, By contrast, in the T_1 and T_2 the increasing WBC number of patients in L.C is detected, and it approaches to the normal level in the T_3. Comparing the two groups, O.C’s WBC number of patients reveals a more significant increase than L.C’s in post-operation periods. 5. In pre-operation, there was no significant distinction about cortisol densities between the two group’s patients. In post-operation, in terms of cortisol densities of the patients, no obvious increase in the T_1, T_2, T_3 was revealed in L.C group, and no significant difference from that of T_0 was presented. In post-operation cortisol densities of the patients in O.C increase in the T_1 before they restore to the normal in the T_2 , showing the significant differences from that of T_0 . Comparing the two groups, in the T_2 cortisol densities of the L.C patients were lower than O.C group’s. 6. In terms of post-operation fatigue syndrome levels of the two groups’patient, an increase in both the two groups was detected, and they both reach the peak in the T_1 .Comparing the two groups, the O.C’s post-operation fatigue syndrome levels were higher than L.C’s.
Conclusion:
In curing the elderly patients with gallbladder stone, compared with open–cholecystectomy, post-operative stress response and fatigue syndrome in the elderly patients can be satisfactorily eased by laparoscopic cholecystectomy. So it’s safe to conclude that the clinical value of laparoscopic cholecystectomy is reliable and significant.
方法筛选符合相关适应症的胆囊结石患者40例,年龄为60岁≤年龄≤70岁;随机分为两组,每组各20例(两组病人性别,年龄等无显著性差异)即腹腔镜胆囊切除术(laparoscopic cholecystectomy, LC)手术组和开腹胆囊切除术(tra- ditional open cholecystectomy, OC)手术组。于手术前1天(T_0)、术后第1天(T_1)、2天(T_2)、3天(T_3)作为观察点,分别检测手术前后白介素6(Inter- leukin-6,IL-6),白介素10(Interleukin-10,IL-10),C-反应蛋白(C-reactive protein,CRP),白细胞(white blood cell,WBC)计数及中性粒细胞(Neutropils)分类,皮质醇等指标;于术后第1天(T_1)、2天(T_2 )、3天(T_3)作为观察点,分别检测病人的术后疲劳评分指数,统计并比较两组的平均手术时间,术中出血量,术后镇痛用药率,术后发热天数,平均住院天数等方面做分析。
结果1.术前两组病人的IL-6浓度无显著性差异;术后两组病人的IL-6均明显升高,与T_0期相比有显著性差异,并且在T_1期达到高峰,在T_2, T_3期逐渐下降;术后T_1,T_2期LC手术组病人的IL-6浓度和OC手术组病人的相比较,LC手术组的均较OC手术组的低。2.术前两组病人的IL-10浓度相比无显著性差异;术后两组病人各期的IL-10浓度从T_1期开始降低;LC手术组病人的IL-10浓度在T_2期最低,在T_1、T_3期也低于术前;OC手术组病人的IL-10浓度在T_3期达到最低,在T_1、T_2期不同程度的降低;组间相比较,在T_2、T_3期LC手术组的值明显高于OC手术组的值。3.术前两组病人的CRP浓度无显著性差异;术后各期相比较,两组病人术后CRP水平均升高,在T_1期达到最高值,OC手术组除了术后各期CRP浓度明显高于LC手术组外,T_3期CRP仍然明显高于术前,但是LC手术组T_3期已经接近于正常;组间相比较,术后各期LC手术组较OC手术组CRP浓度低。4.术前两组病人WBC计数和中性粒细胞分类无显著性差异;术后OC组病人WBC计数T_1、T_2、T_3期均较术前升高,在术后T_1期达到高峰;LC组病人T_1、T_2期较术前升高,T_3期接近术前水平;组间相比较,OC手术组病人的WBC计数在术后各期较LC手术组病人的升高明显。5.术前两组病人的皮质醇浓度无显著性差异;术后LC手术组病人的皮质醇浓度T_1、T_2、T_3期均无明显升高,与T_0期相比无显著性差异;术后OC手术组病人的皮质醇浓度在T_1期升高,和T_0期相比有显著性差异,在T_2期开始回落到正常,组间相比较,在T_1期LC手术组的皮质醇浓度低于OC手术组的皮质醇浓度。6.两组病人术后各期的术后疲劳评分均升高,在术后T_1期评分值达到高峰,组间相比较,在术后各期的评分值OC手术组均高于LC手术组。
结论与开腹胆囊切除术相比,腹腔镜胆囊切除术治疗老年患者胆囊结石,可以明显的减少术后应激,减轻老年病人术后疲劳综合的征状,临床疗效可靠,有着较高的临床应用价值。
Objective:
T_o study whether the elderly patients’post-operative stress response and fatigue syndrome can be eased by laparoscopic cholecystectomy,trying to offer objective proof for the superiority of laparoscopic cholecystectomy in curing the elderly patients with gallbladder stone.
Methods:
In the beginning, forty elderly male and female gallbladder stone patients, aging from 60 to 70, have been under screening in terms of relevant indication. T_hen the selected patients were divided into 2 groups, and 20 patients with no significant differences of gender and no age in each group. T_he two groups were named as laparoscopic cholecystectomy operation group (L.C) and open–cholecystectomy operation group (O.C). Next, the day before the operation was marked T_0, the first day after operation T_1, the second day after operation T_2, the third day after operation T_3 . T_0, T_1, T_2, T_3 were chosen as the observation points. Later, various indicators, both in pre-operation and post-operation, were examined, such as Interleukin-6 (IL-6), Interleukin-10(IL-10), C-reactive protein (CRP), white blood cell (WBC), Neutropils and Cortisol etc. At last, from the observation points T_1, T_2, T_3 , some analysis were made, such as assessing the patients’post-operation fatigue, counting and comparing the two groups’average operation time, operation blood loss amount, post-operation analgesic using rate, the post-operation fever days, and the average length of hospitalization.
Results:
1. In pre-operation, there was no significant IL-6 density level distinction between the two groups. In post-operation, a significant IL-6 density level increase was detected in the two groups. And some significant IL-6 levels distinctions were revealed when compared with that of T_0. Besides, IL-6 level reaches its peak in the T_1 , then gradually declines in the T_2 and T_3 . In the T_1 and T_2 , in terms of IL-6 density levels, L.C’s were lower than O.C’s .
2. In pre-operation, there was no significant IL-10 density distinction between the two group’s patients. In post-operation, from T_1, the IL-10 density of patients in two groups begins to decline; IL-10 densities of the patients in L.C were at the lowest level in the T_2 and show a striking difference from O.C group. In addition, IL-10 densities in the T_1 and T_3 were lower than that of pre-operation; By contrast, for the O.C IL-10 density levels of the patients were at the lowest level in the T_3 after some declining in the T_1 and T_2. Comparing the two groups, in the T_2 and T_3 L.C’s IL-10 density levels were significantly higher than O.C’s.
3. In pre-operation, there was no significant CRP density distinction between the two group’s patients; in the different post-operation periods, CRP levels in both the two groups’patients rise and reach its peak in the T_1.Meanwhile, CRP density levels in O.C were significantly higher than those of LC. Besides, in the T_3CRP levels of O.C were significantly higher than that of pre-operation. By contrast, in the T_3, CRP level of patients in the L.C has already restored to the normal level. Comparing the two groups, in post-operation L.C’s CRP density levels were significantly lower than O.C’s.
4. In pre-operation, there was no significant distinction about WBC number, neutrophil category between the two group’s patients. In post-operation, WBC number of patients in the O.C group increases in the T_1, T_2, T_3 and reaches its peak in the T_1, By contrast, in the T_1 and T_2 the increasing WBC number of patients in L.C is detected, and it approaches to the normal level in the T_3. Comparing the two groups, O.C’s WBC number of patients reveals a more significant increase than L.C’s in post-operation periods. 5. In pre-operation, there was no significant distinction about cortisol densities between the two group’s patients. In post-operation, in terms of cortisol densities of the patients, no obvious increase in the T_1, T_2, T_3 was revealed in L.C group, and no significant difference from that of T_0 was presented. In post-operation cortisol densities of the patients in O.C increase in the T_1 before they restore to the normal in the T_2 , showing the significant differences from that of T_0 . Comparing the two groups, in the T_2 cortisol densities of the L.C patients were lower than O.C group’s. 6. In terms of post-operation fatigue syndrome levels of the two groups’patient, an increase in both the two groups was detected, and they both reach the peak in the T_1 .Comparing the two groups, the O.C’s post-operation fatigue syndrome levels were higher than L.C’s.
Conclusion:
In curing the elderly patients with gallbladder stone, compared with open–cholecystectomy, post-operative stress response and fatigue syndrome in the elderly patients can be satisfactorily eased by laparoscopic cholecystectomy. So it’s safe to conclude that the clinical value of laparoscopic cholecystectomy is reliable and significant.
引文
[1]李辉.老年急性结石性胆囊炎38例治疗体会[J].临床外科杂志,2005,13(5):328.
[2]宗瑞林.老年急性胆囊炎的特点及手术治疗分析[J].中外医疗,2009,10(3):72.
[3]Zou YP, Du JD, Li WM et al . Gallstone recurrence after successful percutaneous cholecystolithotomy :a 10 year followup of 439 cases[J]. Hepatobiliary Pancreat Dis Int,2007,6:199-203.
[4]Carrilho-Ribeiro L,Pinto-Correia A,Velosa J,et al. A ten-year prospective study on gallbladder stone recurrence after successful extracorporeal shock-wave lithotripsy[J]. Scand Gastroenterof,2006,41:338-342.
[5]赵普,唐传军,黄国增,等.腹腔镜胆囊切除术在急性胆囊炎中的临床探讨[J] .实用临床医药杂志,2007,11(1):85-86.
[6]刘衍民,文辉清.目前保留胆囊手术的几个问题[J].中华外科杂志,2008,46(10):721-723.
[7]朱义红.LC治疗巨大胆囊结石和充满型胆囊结石[J] .实用临床医药杂志,2009,13(16):66-67.
[8]Rubin GJ, Hotopf M. Systematic review and mera-analysis of interventions for postoperative fatigue[J]. Br J Surg, 2002;89(8):971.
[9] Christensen T,Bendix H,kehlet.Fatigue and cardiorespiratory function following abdominal surgery.Br.J.Sur,1982,69:417-419.
[10] Buttenschoen K ,Buttenschoen DC , Berger D , et al . Endotoxemia and acute-phase proteins in major abdominal surgery Am J Surg,2001,181:36-43.
[11]唐琦峰,季晓军,田家俊等.盆腔手术病人围手术期血清TNF-α,IL-6,IL-8,IL-10水平的变化.临床麻醉学杂志,2002;18:531-532.
[12] McMahon AJ ,O,Dwyer PJ Cruikshank AM et al ,comparison of metablic responses to laparoscopic and minlaparotomy cholecystctomy, Br J surg, 2003;80:1255.
[1]周宁新.机器人微创外科手术探索与实践[M].北京:人民军医出版社,2010.4
[2]邱秀玉.腹腔镜手术术期的护理[J].新疆医学,2010(6),140-141
[3]莫彩鲜.老年人微创手术麻醉并发症临床分析[J].微创医学,2010(5),475-477
[4]郑蓝鹏、梁丽英.泌尿外科微创手术围手术期护理[J].国际医药卫生导报,2010(21),2683-2685
[2]宗瑞林.老年急性胆囊炎的特点及手术治疗分析[J].中外医疗,2009,10(3):72.
[3]Zou YP, Du JD, Li WM et al . Gallstone recurrence after successful percutaneous cholecystolithotomy :a 10 year followup of 439 cases[J]. Hepatobiliary Pancreat Dis Int,2007,6:199-203.
[4]Carrilho-Ribeiro L,Pinto-Correia A,Velosa J,et al. A ten-year prospective study on gallbladder stone recurrence after successful extracorporeal shock-wave lithotripsy[J]. Scand Gastroenterof,2006,41:338-342.
[5]赵普,唐传军,黄国增,等.腹腔镜胆囊切除术在急性胆囊炎中的临床探讨[J] .实用临床医药杂志,2007,11(1):85-86.
[6]刘衍民,文辉清.目前保留胆囊手术的几个问题[J].中华外科杂志,2008,46(10):721-723.
[7]朱义红.LC治疗巨大胆囊结石和充满型胆囊结石[J] .实用临床医药杂志,2009,13(16):66-67.
[8]Rubin GJ, Hotopf M. Systematic review and mera-analysis of interventions for postoperative fatigue[J]. Br J Surg, 2002;89(8):971.
[9] Christensen T,Bendix H,kehlet.Fatigue and cardiorespiratory function following abdominal surgery.Br.J.Sur,1982,69:417-419.
[10] Buttenschoen K ,Buttenschoen DC , Berger D , et al . Endotoxemia and acute-phase proteins in major abdominal surgery Am J Surg,2001,181:36-43.
[11]唐琦峰,季晓军,田家俊等.盆腔手术病人围手术期血清TNF-α,IL-6,IL-8,IL-10水平的变化.临床麻醉学杂志,2002;18:531-532.
[12] McMahon AJ ,O,Dwyer PJ Cruikshank AM et al ,comparison of metablic responses to laparoscopic and minlaparotomy cholecystctomy, Br J surg, 2003;80:1255.
[1]周宁新.机器人微创外科手术探索与实践[M].北京:人民军医出版社,2010.4
[2]邱秀玉.腹腔镜手术术期的护理[J].新疆医学,2010(6),140-141
[3]莫彩鲜.老年人微创手术麻醉并发症临床分析[J].微创医学,2010(5),475-477
[4]郑蓝鹏、梁丽英.泌尿外科微创手术围手术期护理[J].国际医药卫生导报,2010(21),2683-2685