可持续发展城市住区公共空间的“培育型”规划策略研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
在城市住区空间结构当中,公共空间体系作为住区功能网络结构的“关节和枢纽”,在提高居住生态环境品质和公共设施服务水平、促进邻里交往和地域文化的发展、展示城市风貌等方面发挥巨大的作用。对城市住区公共空间体系规划的深入研究是当代建设城市和谐人居环境的需要。传统住区规划单纯注重空间形态控制的“蓝图式”和“最终状态”的规划设计模式,在实施过程中暴露出对社会发展变化适应性差、系统协调性差的缺点。“培育型规划”概念的提出是基于这样一种认识,即城市规划的目标不是为了使城市空间发展达到某种设想的终极状态,而是使城市建立起有利于城市空间科学发展的经营、管理、辅助机制,使在此基础上建立起的城市空间体系能够适应城市多样化发展的要求以及不断发展变化的需求,使城市社会具有持续发展的活力。
     “培育型”住区公共空间规划策略是建立在住区整体发展多重目标体系之下,全面采取住区公共空间规划、软环境建设策略群,以培育具有可持续发展特征的住区公共“空间容器”和敏感、高效的社区经营管理机制为目标的规划模式。“培育型”城市住区公共空间规划策略(或称策略群)由三大部分组成:①空间策略—构建开放的城市社区;②“软环境”建设策略—建立地域多方参与的社区公共事务决策和管理机制;③规划编制、实施策略—敏感设计模式的建立。
     论文首先通过对国外近现代城市住区的建设发展过程和思想演变进行分析,归纳总结了当代国外城市住区公共空间发展和住区“软环境”建设的策略;然后从天津市城市住区发展的历史和现状入手,分析了天津城市住区空间发展存在的普遍问题和新、旧区发展的重点问题,寻找解决天津城市住区公共空间发展问题的关键性切入点;进而以天津近郊新城组团为例,明确提出了建立“培育型”住区公共空间体系和社区发展机制的具体策略;最后通过作者参与的天津市静海团泊新城总体城市设计项目,探讨可持续发展的城市住区公共空间规划策略和措施在规划实践当中的应用途径。
In the space structure of an urban residential community, the public open space system functioning as joints and hubs of a functional network, highly contributes to the quality of the eco-system, the public service, the neighborhood communication, the urban scene and the development of the local culture. The traditional planning model merely focuses on thetraditional blue print style and final state style community planning which often leads to lack of flexibility of adapting the community to the changing social development and lack of harmony in the system itself. The cultivation-oriented community planning is basedon a concept that the aims of urban planning are not to reform the city to reach an assumed ultimate state, but to establish a system that can operate, manage, and assist the city development towards a sustainable state. Such cultivation would enable the urban public space to adapt itself to oncoming new needs and changing circumstances, and to meet the need of the development of urban diversification.
     The strategies of open space planning for cultivation-orientedcommunity are based on the purposes of community development in its entirety. By adopting the comprehensive-space and soft-policy, the cultivation-oriented community planning strategies areto establish the community public open space as a container or holder of sustainable neighborhood development. The strategies of open space planning of cultivation-oriented community contain three parts:space strategy aiming at forming an open community structure;soft-environment strategy for establishing a local multi-stakeholderdecision-making and governing system for public affairs and community service; plan making and implementing strategy for sensitive design.
     The thesis takes Tianjin as an example, analyses its general problemsin urban community development and its own problem of new and old communities. By identifying its key problems, the thesis gives some advice,concerning the new Tianjin sub-rural large-scale residential communities,on how Tianjin should develop its urban community sustainable developmentstrategies both for space and soft-environment development based on its social condition and context. In the last part, the case of the Tuanbo New Town Development Project is illustrated as an attempt of real-life application, and a further discussion is then put forward on how the cultivation-oriented community open space planning strategies should be properly applied in reality.
引文
[1]大卫·路德林,尼古拉斯·福克,营造21世纪的家园——可持续的城市邻里社区,王健,单建华译,北京:中国建筑工业出版社,2005: 171,175,259~276
    [2]张春和,人·开场空间·城市:跨世纪城市规划师的思考,北京:中国建筑工业出版社,1990
    [3]迈克·詹克斯,紧缩城市:一种可持续发展的城市形态?,周玉鹏等译,北京:中国建筑工业出版社,2004:13~34
    [4]天津市城市规划志编撰委员会,天津市城市规划志,天津:天津科学技术出版社,1994
    [5]滕韶华,荆其敏,天津建筑风格,北京:中国建筑工业出版社,2002:19,68,260,266,278
    [6]根特城市研究小组,城市状态:当代大都市的空间、社区和本质,敬东译,北京:中国水利水电出版社,知识产权出版社,2005:96~101
    [7]缪朴,亚太城市的公共空间——当前的问题与对策,司玲等译,北京:中国建筑工业出版社,2007:198
    [8] C·亚历山大等,城市设计新理论,陈治业等译,北京:知识产权出版社,2002:2
    [9]尼格尔·泰勒,1945年后西方城市规划理论的流变,李白玉等译,北京:中国建筑工业出版社,2006:42~43
    [10]陈继凯,适应型城市设计——一种实效的城市设计理论及应用,北京:中国建筑工业出版社,2004,36~46
    [11]道格拉斯·凯尔博,共享空间——关于邻里与区域设计,吕斌等译,北京:中国建筑工业出版社,2007:231
    [12]日本土木学会编,滨水景观设计,孙逸增译,大连:大连理工大学出版社,2002:17
    [13]小泉信一,集合住宅小区,王宝刚等译,北京:中国建筑工业出版社,2001
    [14]克里夫·芒福汀,绿色尺度,陈贞高文艳译,北京:中国建筑工业出版社,2004:160
    [15]约翰·彭特,美国城市设计指南——西海岸五城市的设计政策与指导,庞玥译,北京:中国建筑工业出版社,2006:81~98
    [16]赵民,赵蔚编著.社区发展规划——理论与实践.北京:中国建筑工业出版社. 2003:258
    [17] Andres Duany, Elizabeth Plater-Zyberk. Town and Town-making Principles. Rizzoli International Publications Inc, 1991
    [18] Cristopher Alexander. A Pattern Language: The Timeless Way of Building. Oxford University Press, 1977
    [19] Rob Cowan. The Connected City. London: Urban Initiatives,1997
    [20] Rob Cowan. The Cities Design Forgot. London: Urban Initiatives,1995
    [21] Ivor Samuels. Urban Forms: The Death and Life of The Urban Block. Oxford: Architectural Press, 2004: 8,56,121,176
    [22] Mark Deakin, Developing Sustainable Communities in Edinburgh’s South East Wedge: The Settlement Model and Design Solution, Journal of Urban Design, 2003, 9(2):137~148
    [23] Takehito Takano. Development of Healthy Cities. In: Takehito Takano. Healthy cities and Urban Policy Research. London and Newyork : Spon Press, 2005: 45
    [24] Cliff Euis. The New Urbanism: Critiques and Rebuttals. Journal of Urban Design, 2003, 7(3): 261~291
    [25] Matthew Carmona, Tim Heath, Taner Oc, Steven Tiesdell. Public Places-Urban Spaces. Architectural Press. 2005
    [26] PETR/CABE, By Design: Urban Design in the Planning System: Towards Better Practice, 2000a:8
    [27] Tridib Banerjea and William C.Baer. Beyond the Neighberhood Unite: Residential Envirenments and Public Policy. Newyork: Plenum Press, 1984
    [28] David Walfers. Design community: Charrettes, master plans and form-based codes. Architectural Press, 2007
    [29] Smith, George and James Taylor. Achieving Sustainability: Exploring links Between Sustainability Indicators and Public Involvement for Rural Communities. Landscape Journal, 2000, Vol. 19, Numbers 1&2: 179~190
    [30] Virginia W. Maclaren. Developing indicators of urban sustainability: a focus on the Canadian experience. ICURR Express, Toronto, January 1996:7~8
    [31] Ivan Mu?iz, Anna Galindo, Urban form and the ecological footprint of commuting:The case of Barcelona, Ecological Economics, 2005,55: 499~514
    [32] Michael Crilly, Adam Mannis. Sustainable Urban Management System. In:Katie Williams, Elizabeth Berton, Mike Jenks. Achieving Sustainable Urban Form. London and Newyork: Spon Press. 2000:212~214
    [33] Stephen M.Wheeler, Timothy Beatley, The Sustainable Urban Development Reader , The Routledge Urban Reader Series, 2004
    [34] Simon Bell, Catharine Ward Thompson, Penny Travlou, Contested views of freedom and control: Children, teenagers and urban fringe woodlands in Central Scotland, Urban Foresty&Urban Green, 2003(2): 87~100
    [35] American Planning Association, Planning and Urban Design Standards, Hoboken:John Wiley&Sons Inc,2006
    [36] IA: RM Plan Group (Nashville) and City of Ames , City of Ames Land Use Policy Plan, Ames, 1986
    [37] EDUARDO ALCA? NTARA DE VASCONCELLOS, The Use of Streets: A Reassessment and Tribute to Donald Appleyard, Journal of Urban Design, 2004, 9(1) :3~22
    [38] Pu Miao, Deserted Streets in a Jammed Town: The Gated Community in Chinese Cities and Its Solution, Journal of Urban Design, 2003, 8(1):45~66
    [39] Milos Bobic, The Role of Time Function in City Spatial Structures: Past and Present, 1990
    [40] Colin Fudge. Health and sustainability gains from urban regeneration and development. In : Takehito Takano .Healthy cities and Urban Policy Research.London and Newyork: Spon Press .2005: 45
    [41] Bruce Haden, Urban Design Panels in British Columbia: An Insiders View, Canadian Architect, 2005: 12-13
    [42]卢济威郑正,城市设计及其发展,建筑学报,1997(4):6
    [43]戴慎志江毅罗晓霞.城市住区空间安全防卫规划与设计.规划师,2002,18(2):27~34
    [44]苏振民等.城市居住空间分异控制:居住模式与公共政策.城市规划,2007,31(2):45~49
    [45]石崧,城市空间结构演变的动力机制分析,城市规划汇刊,2004,1:50~52
    [46]卜雪旸,当代西方城市可持续发展空间理论研究热点和争论,城市规划学刊,2006,164(4):107
    [47]林仲煜等,住区交通的人性化思想与设计,城市规划,2006,30(6):44~47
    [48]金磊,中国安全社区建设模式与综合减灾规划研究,中国公共安全(学术版),2007(1):5~10
    [49]游壁菁,从都市防灾探讨都市公园绿地体系规划——以台湾地区台北市为例,城市规划,2004(5):74~79
    [50]叶嘉国,武汉市居民居住环境问题的社会学思考,城市发展研究,2000(1):28~31
    [51]叶炜,英国社区自助建设对我国社区更新的启示,规划师,2006(3):61~63
    [52]卜雪旸曾坚,城市居住区规划中的抗震防灾问题研究,建筑学报,2009(1):83-85
    [53]于文波,王竹.“深绿色”理念与住区建设可持续发展策略研究.华中建筑,2004,22(5) :123~124
    [54]裘鸿菲等,现代居住区规划的审美价值取向,规划师,2006,22(2):98~100
    [55]于勇等,“开放街区”规划理念及其对中国城市住宅建设的启示,规划师,2006(2):101~104
    [56]周俭,住宅区用地规模及规划设计问题探讨,城市规划,1999(1):38
    [57]缪朴,城市生活的癌症——封闭式小区的问题及对策,时代建筑,2004(5):46~49
    [58]朱小地,北京边缘住区发展的问题研究,建筑学报,2005(6):9~12
    [59]陈云松,从“行政社区”到“公民社区”——由中西比较分析看中国城市社区的走向,城市发展研究,2004,11(4):1~4
    [60]杜晓燕等,我国城市社区管理中的权利协调问题,城市发展研究,2006,13(2):72~75
    [61]杨连娣,城市生活环境规划中的群体划分和设计依据,城市规划,2000,24(9):43~44
    [62]李慧栋等,社区规划的发展进程与多维透视,城市发展研究,2006,13(6):26~30
    [63]涂志群等,居民参与居住环境建设的基本模式,城市发展研究,2002(1):44~47
    [64]肖达,多元化居住社区的规划应对,现代城市研究,2002(6):13~16
    [65]王承慧,从住区规划建设中的误区谈起——兼论可持续发展理念在住区规划中的运用于落实,规划师,2001,17(3):19~21
    [66]顾朝林,论城市管制研究,城市规划,2000,24(9):7~9
    [67]王剑云等,从城市社区的组织管理新模式谈居住区规划结构,规划师,2003,19(7):60~62
    [68]吴光芸等,社会资本视角下的社区治理,城市发展研究,2006,13(4):25~29
    [69]李殿生,“城市设计”理念在城市住区规划中的应用:[硕士学位论文],沈阳:沈阳建筑工程学院,2003
    [70]史晓华,新时期中国大城市郊区住区营建的调控策略研究:[硕士学位论文],武汉:华中科技大学, 2004
    [71]刘海滨,城市住区公共空间研究:[硕士学位论文],成都:西南交通大学,2005
    [72]庄丽,城市居住区抗震防灾规划的研究与应用:[博士研究生论文],青岛:中国海洋大学,2007
    [73]李蕊芳,北京市就业和居住空间结构的演变和发展研究:[硕士学位论文],北京:清华大学建筑学院,2005
    [74]卢丹梅,城市健康住区环境构成及评价指标研究:[硕士学位论文],武汉:华中科技大学, 2004
    [75]江毅,城市住区安全防卫规划研究:[硕士学位论文],上海:同济大学,2002
    [76]中华人民共和国建设部,GB 50413-2007,《城市抗震防灾标准》,中华人民共和国国家标准,北京:中国建筑工业出版社,2007-04-13
    [77]中华人民共和国建设部,GB 50180-93,《城市居住区规划设计规范》,中华人民共和国国家标准,北京:中国建筑工业出版社,1993-07-16
    [78] www2.ville.montreal.qc.ca/plan-urbanisme/en/index.shtm
    [79] Http://news.nankai.edu.cn/zhxw/system/2009/01/13/000021304.shtml南开新闻网时间:2009-1-13
    [80]建设部2005年12月颁布、自2006年4月开始执行的《城市规划编制办法》。资料来源:http://www.cin.gov.cn/law/depart/2006021404.htm

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700