摘要
随着拱坝建设的发展,我国目前正向技术难度更大、使用要求更高的300 m级的混凝土高拱坝迈进,拱高305m的锦屏拱坝就是一例。这一级别的拱坝超越了现有世界水平,对高拱坝稳定分析的研究就显得尤为重要。本文基于大型有限元仿真软件ANSYS,结合锦屏一级水电工程的科研项目“锦屏一级双曲拱坝开裂及坝肩抗滑稳定分析与安全评价”,运用三维弹塑性有限元仿真计算方法,对锦屏一级高拱坝坝体破坏及坝肩岩体的稳定性展开了系统的研究。
论文首先介绍了非线性问题和弹塑性分析基本理论,在此基础上进一步深入介绍非线性有限元计算方法。
接着,对岩土工程材料常用的屈服准则,Drucker—Prager准则等进行深入的理论研究,探讨各种条件下参数α、κ与c、φ间的关系。用数值计算方法来研究像拱坝这样复杂结构的稳定性问题,难点在于如何判断结构的整体破坏。本文分别采用收敛法、塑性区贯通法和位移突变法作为破坏判据。
然后,在ANSYS中模拟基岩的初始地应力场,采用三维非线性有限元法,以自重和设计水压为基本荷载,利用超载法、降强法和抗滑稳定方法分析了锦屏高拱坝的失稳破坏过程,得到锦屏拱坝的整体稳定安全系数。
最后,作者就一些需要进一步解决的问题提出展望
Jinping is a huge project located on Yalong River in China. Its dam is concrete arch dam with Max height of 305.0m, which surpass Ingury and Xiaowan, and will be the highest arch dam in the world. The stability analysis of super-high arch dams is very important in this project. The paper is based on ANSYS, a big FEM simulation software. Integrated with a project of Jinping Water Power Station, the failure state and abutment stability are studied systematically with 3D elastic-plastic finite element method in this paper.
First, the basic theory and method of elastic-plastic and nonlinear in FEM simulation analysis in rock engineering and water conservancy engineering are studied.
The criterion of failure state is still a difficult problem, especially in the numerical analysis. In this thesis, based on the detailed introduction about these methods used at present time, the failure state is analyzed in theory, and then the two methods that are the limitative strain and plastic limit analysis are discussed. According to the calculation and analysis of those arch dams, the relation between the displacement jump method and plastic zone juncture method is discussed, and the displacement jump method is considered to be more convenient and effective.
Then, the initial geological stress of dam site is simulated in ANSYS. Using three-dimensional nonlinear FEM and considering accumulative gravity and water pressure as initial load, overload method and margin of safety method are adopted to analyze the failure process of JinPing arch dam, and the safety factors of integral stability and characters of failure are acquired.
Finally, some problems needed to be studied further are discussed.
引文
[1] 范景伟,岩石力学论文集[M],成都:成都科技大学出版社,1991.
[2] 黄润秋,王士天等,澜沧江小湾水电站高拱坝坝基重大地质问题研究[M],成都:西南交通大学出版社,1996.
[3] 陈志伟,溪洛渡高拱坝结构特性及坝肩稳定性三维非线性有限元分析(硕士论文)[J],四川大学2002:1-2.
[4] 吴世勇,锦屏一级水电站建设在雅碧江流域水电资源开发中的地位和作用[J],四川水力发电,2004.3:15-17.
[5] 祁庆和等,水工建筑物[M],北京:中国水利水电出版社,1998.
[6] 肖伟荣,基于有限元ANSYS的拱坝体形优化(硕士论文)[J],昆明理工大学,2005:1-3.
[7] 黎展眉,拱坝[M],北京:水利电力出版社,1982.
[8] 丁晓唐,高拱坝结构稳定转异和体形优化分析理论和方法(博士论文)[J],河海大学,2005:3-4.
[9] 贾金生,袁玉兰,李铁洁,2003年中国及世界大坝情况[C],中国水利,2004(13):25-33.
[10] 陈宗梁,世界超级拱坝[M],北京:中国电力出版社,1998.
[11] 朱诗鳌,坝工技术史[M],北京:水利电力出版社,1995.
[12] Kollgaard. E. B, Chadwick. W L, Development of dam engineering in the united states [M], Pergamon Press, 1988.
[13] Icold, The World Register of Dams. 4th edition Paris[J], 1988: 1-4.
[14] Veltrop, J. A. "Concrete Arch Dams", Sec. 3, Development of Dam Engineering in the United States [M], US Committee on Large Dams, 1988.
[15] Copen, M. D. Rouse and Wallace. GB. European Practice in Design and Construction of ConcreteDams [J], US Bureau or Reclamation, 1962: 45-53.
[16] Hollingworth. F, Druyts. RH , Rollcrete. W and M. Some Applications to Dams in South Africa [M], WaterPower and Dam Construction, 1986.
[17] 柴军瑞,刘浩吾,高拱坝研究新进展[J],水利水电科技进展,2001,21(6):1-4.
[18] 潘家铮,陈式慧,关于高拱坝建设中若干问题的讨论[J],科技导报,1997(2):17-19
[19] 潘燕芳,复杂结构拱坝的有限元仿真分析方法研究(硕士论文)[J],武汉大学,2004:3-8
[20] 朱伯芳,高季章,陈祖熠,厉易生,拱坝设计与研究[M],北京:中国水利水电出版社,2002
[21] 董福品,朱伯芳,沈之良,葛楠,国内外高拱坝应力分析概况[J],北京:中国水利水电科学研究院学报,2003.12:35-39
[22] rock foundations for dams, [M], Bulletion ofthe International Commission on large dams Paris Londe P. 1993.
[23] 邹丽春,刘伟,高拱坝坝基稳定研究[J].水利发电,2001(8):63-65.
[24] 周维垣,陈欣.锦屏双曲拱坝坝整体稳定分析[J].华北水利水电学院学报,2001,22(3):31-34。
[25] 周维垣,杨若琼,高拱坝的有限元分析方法和设计判据研究[J].水利学报,1997.8:37-40
[26] 周维垣,杨若琼,混凝土拱坝整体三维有限元非线性分析[J],北京清华大学水利系,1998:15-20
[27] 顺冲时.有限元法在分析拱坝坝肩稳定中的应用[J].大坝观测与土工测试,1996, 20(3):36-38.
[28] 田斌,夏颂佑.高拱坝坝踵开裂非线性有限元分析[J].人民长江,1997,28(5):16-24.
[29] 陈健云,林皋,李静.高拱坝的非线性开裂静动力响应分析[J].世界地震工程,2001,17(3):15-22
[30] 苏超,余天堂,姜弘道.基于有限单元的高拱坝动力优化设计方法及其应用[J].河海大学学报,2002.1:30-34
[31] 崔玉柱,张楚汉,金峰,王光纶.拱坝一地基模型破坏的数值模型与溃坝仿真[J],水利学报,2002(6):1-8.
[32] 卓家寿,章青.不连续介质力学问题的界面元法[M].科学出版社,20000
[33] 武清玺,王德信.拱坝坝肩三维稳定可靠度分析[J].岩土力学1998,19(1):45-49.
[34] 武清玺,吕泰仁.拱坝坝肩整体稳定静力动力可靠度分析[J].岩土学报,1995.3:27-31.
[35] 刘世煌,拉西瓦拱坝建基面的模糊评判[J],西北水电,1996.4:34-37
[36] 梁爱虎,陈厚群,候顺载.混凝土拱坝抗震设计中动力可靠度分析方法的探讨田.水利学报,1995.5:36-41
[37] 魏群.散体单元法的基本原理数值方法及程序[M].北京:科学出版社,19910
[38] 王泳嘉,邢纪波.离散单元法及其在岩体力学中的应用[M].沈阳:东北工业学院出版社,1991.
[39] 毛坚强.接触问题的一种有限元计算方法及其在岩土工程中的应用[J],西南交通大学博士学位论文 2002.3:12-13
[40] 任青文编著.非线性有限单元法[M].南京:河海大学,2003.10.
[41] 陈国荣.有限单元法补充讲义[M].南京:河海大学,1998.3
[42] 朱伯芳.有限单元法原理与应用(第2版)[M],北京:中国水利水电出版社,1998.
[43] 卓家寿.弹性力学中的有限元法[M],北京:高等教育出版社,1987.9.
[44] 李咏偕,施泽华.塑性力学[M],北京:水利电力出版社,1987.6
[45] Bathe K J and Cimento A P. Some Practical Procedures for the Solution of Nonlinear Finite Element Equations [J], Computer Methods in Appl. Mech. And Eng, 1980, 22: 59-85.
[46] Fielding K. Algorithm 387, Function Minization and Linear Search [J], 1970, 13: 509-510.
[47] 蒋有谅编著.非线性有限元[M],北京:北京工业学院出版社,1988.6.
[48] 龙驭球.有限元法概论(上,下册)[M],北京:高等教育出版社,1991.10.
[49] 张汝清.詹先义编著.非线性有限元分析[M],重庆:重庆大学,1990.1
[50] 翟利军.复杂地基上拱坝的可视化建模和有限元仿真分析[J],河海大学硕士学位论文,2003.3.
[51] Hertz, H, Uber die beruhrung fester elastlscher korPer[J], J. Reine and Angewandte Mathematik, 1882, 92: 156—171.
[52] Francavil la A. and Zienkiewicz O. C., A note on numerical computation of elastic contact problems [J], Int. J Num. Meth. Eng. 1975. 9: 913-924
[53] Fredriksson B. et al. Numerical solutions to contact, friction and crack problems with applications, Eng. Comput. 1994. 1: 133-143
[54] 王爱林,陆晓敏.拱坝稳定分析方法的总结与探讨[J].西部探矿工程,2005.7:40-44
[55] 向能武,徐清忠.有限元法在拱坝变形稳定计算中的应用[J].长江工程职业技术学院学报,2005.3:35-37
[56] J. Ergatandis,B.M.Irons, O.C.Zienkiewicy, Three-dimensional analysis of arch dams and their foundations [C], Proc. Symb. Arch Dams, Inst. Cive. Engng, London, 1968: 37-50
[57] 任重编著.ANSYS实用分析教程[M],北京:北京大学出版社,2003.3.
[58] ANSYS基本过程指南[M],ANSYS中国,2000.1.
[59] ANSYS建模及分网指南[M],ANSYS中国,2000.1.
[60] ANSYS, Inc. ANSYS Operations Guide [M]. ANSYS 7.0 HTML Online Documentation. 2002.
[61] ANSYS, Inc. ANSYS Basic Analysis Procedures Guide [M]. ANSYS 7.0 HTML Online Documentation, 2002.
[62] ANSYS, Inc. ANSYS Advanced Analysis Techniques Guide. ANSYS 7. 0 HTML Online Documentation, 2002.
[63] 黄国军,拱坝整体稳定的物理模型和数学模型研究[J],河海大学硕士学位论文,2004.3:55-62
[64] 郝文化编著,ANSYS土木工程应用实例[M],北京:中国水利水电出版社,2005.1.