摘要
工程实际中广泛存在一类旋转周期结构。为保证该类结构安全可靠地工作并提高其动态特性,需要深入研究该类结构的动力学问题,揭示基本参数与动力学响应之间的映射关系,进而为其动态设计提供理论依据。本文工作为国家自然科学基金《基于相位调谐的永磁电机减振降噪机理研究》(编号:50705062)的一部分。论文以永磁电机定子为基本原型,系统研究了旋转周期结构的动力学响应特征,主要内容如下:
1.采用哈密顿原理建立了环状旋转周期结构的通用动力学模型,其中结构的基本对称单元可为点单元或面单元。论文采用弹性结构的质量及刚度算子描述结构的模态,进而提出了模态摄动分析的两种一般方法,还给出了各自的适用范围。2.研究了含点对称单元的环状周期结构的模态解析问题,揭示了基本参数与模态特性之间的映射关系,并对其进行了仿真验证。还研究了该类结构的随机失谐问题,并给出了模态特性的统计分布规律和解析形式的数字特征。
3.分析了含面对称单元的环状旋转周期结构的模态特性。采用单位阶跃函数表示面对称单元构型,应用摄动法分析了固有频率分裂和振型耦合规律,并分析了单元周向几何尺寸对模态的影响。还研究了多重旋转周期结构的模态问题,揭示了单元之间的夹角及单元个数等特征参数与动力学响应之间的映射关系。
4.探讨了环状旋转周期结构的受迫振动响应问题。采用摄动方法得到了系统稳态响应的解析结果,分析了共振响应的波动性质,并给出了抑制响应的一般方法。还借助现有文献提供的实验数据对其进行验证。最后以永磁电机的齿槽配合为例,给出了基于旋转周期结构动力学理论的齿槽配合基本原则。
There exist a large number of rotationally periodic structures in engineering. The relationships between the basic parameters and the dynamics of the structures should be studied to present the theoretical foundation for the dynamic design of the structures. This work is a part of the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Investigations on the mechanism of noise and vibration reduction of permanent machines based on phase tuning, Grant No. 50705062). Motivated by the magnetic motor stators, the thesis studied the dynamic response of the rotational periodic structures. And the main contents are:
1. The general dynamic model of the annular-rotational-periodic structures (ARPS) was developed by the Hamilton's principle, in which the basic symmetric element can be point or area element. Two methods for the perturbation analysis of the mode properties were presented according to the mass and stiffness operators, and the application range of the two methods are also given.
2. Closed-form solution to the ARPS with point element was presented. The relationships between the basic parameters and the modal properties are given. The simulation analysis was also carried out to verify the relationships. In addition, the random mistuning of this structure was investigated, and the statistical distribution and the closed-form statistics characteristics of the modal response were also obtained.
3. The modal properties of the ARPS with area element modeled as unit step function were studied. The natural frequency splitting and the mode contamination were analyzed by using the perturbation analysis. And the relationship between the configuration of the area element and the modal response was investigated. Furthermore, the modal properties of the multi-rotationally periodic structures were also studied, and the corresponding relationship between the basic parameters, such as the element number and the position angle between two adjacent elements, and the dynamic response was presented.
4. The closed-form solution to the forced vibration of the ARPS was obtained by using the perturbation method. The method for the wave vibration suppression was also given. The main results were verified by the experimental results given by existing literature. Finally, the basic principle of the slot/pole combination of the magnetic motors was presented based on the rotationally periodic structure dynamics.
引文
[1]胡海岩,对振动学及其发展的美学思考,振动工程学报,2000,13(2):161~169
[2]陈伟民,孙东昌,王大钧等,重复结构振动控制的降维方法,应用数学和力学,2006,27(5):564~570
[3]张锦,刘晓平,叶轮机振动模态分析理论及数值方法,北京:国防工业出版社,2001
[4]肖勇,环形可展开大型卫星天线结构设计与研究[硕士学位论文],西安:西北工业大学,2001
[5] http://www.njsyslj.cn
[6] http://www.ihi-sullair.cn
[7] http://www.htc.com.cn
[8] http://www.chilun.org
[9] Kim M, Moon J, Wickert J A, Spatial modulation of repeated vibration modes in rotationally periodic structures, Journal of vibration and Acoustics, Transactions of the ASME, 2000, 122(1): 62~68
[10] Thomas D L, Dynamics of rotational periodic structures, Internat J Numer Methods Engrg, 1979, 14: 81~102
[11]邱凯,张义忠,王尚锦,回转周期结构动力问题中复Hermite矩阵特征值的子空间迭代解法,机械强度,1999,21(4):252~253,257
[12]邱凯,徐自力,王尚锦,采用复约束旋转模态子结构法分析离心叶轮振动特性,西安交通大学学报,1999,33(5):33~37
[13]赵宁,刘更,高平等,计算循环对称结构振动特性的新方法,机械科学与技术,1996,15(5):706~710
[14]赵宁,刘更,方宗德等,复约束方法计算斜齿圆柱齿轮结构特征值问题,航空动力学报,1996,11(3):133~137
[15]刘恩泽,赵宁,刘更,循环对称结构特征值问题的复数域子空间迭代法,航空动力学报,1996,11(2):211~214
[16]赵宁,刘更,刘恩泽等,用改进的复约束方法计算齿轮结构的特征值,机械科学与技术,1997,16(5):823~826
[17]赵宁,方宗德,刘更,求解循环对称结构特征值问题的新方法,机械科学与技术,2003,22(6):906~909
[18]周传月,邹经湘,闻雪友等,旋转对称转子、轮盘和叶片系统耦合振动分析,哈尔滨工业大学学报(增刊),1998,30:38~42
[19]周传月,闻雪友,刘雪义等,燃气轮机转子动力特性分析的旋转对称有限元模型,航空动力学报,1999,14(2):175~178
[20]周传月,邹经湘,闻雪友等,旋转对称结构振动特性计算的新方法,哈尔滨工业大学学报,2000,32(5):24~28,33
[21]胡海岩,程德林,循环对称结构固有模态特征的探讨,应用力学学报,1988,5(3):1~3
[22]王文亮,杜作润,盘-叶系统模态分析的群论辅助子结构技术,复旦学报(自然科学版),1989,28(1):73~77
[23]王文亮,杜作润,Cn群上对称结构的双协调模态综合,复旦学报(自然科学版),1990,29(2):121~128
[24]王文亮,环向圈连带冠叶片的动态分析,复旦学报(自然科学版),1991,30(1):73~77
[25]张方春,汤红卫,混合界面模态综合法在C3群对称结构中的应用,振动、测试与诊断,1998,18(3):211~215
[26]张方春,孙仙山,循环对称结构的模态参数计算方法,上海力学,1998,19(3):275~280
[27]张方春,循环对称结构中的混合界面模态综合法,山东工业大学学报,1998,28(4):343~347
[28]刘岭,杨海天,基于拉格朗日乘子法和群论的具有任意位移边界条件的旋转周期对称结构有限元分析,计算力学学报,2004,21(4):425~429
[29]张锦,陈向均,王文亮,转动盘—片系的循环对称模综,固体力学学报,1992,13(3):225~234
[30]卿光辉,胡宇达,汽轮发电机定子系统固有频率新算法,大电机技术,2001,(6):1~5,10
[31]黄海鹰,王建明,新型高推比涡轮风扇发动机盘叶耦合振动分析,北京航空航天大学学报,1994,20(2):169~173
[32]唐委校,郑效忠,上机架—定子系统振动分析的群论方法,大电机技术,1999,(3):10~14
[33]唐委校,郑效忠,梁志强,风机叶轮振动分析的群论方法,振动、测试与诊断,1999,19(3):196~201
[34]蔡承武,吴福光,旋转周期结构的振动问题,中山大学学报(自然科学版),1983,22(3):1~9
[35]蔡承武,旋转周期结构的分析解,中山大学学报(自然科学版),1986,25(2):64~72
[36]刘济科,杨怡,蔡铭等,结构分析中的U变换法,中国振动工程学会,2002年全国振动工程及应用学术会议论文集,上海,2002,822~826
[37]王玲华,王锡平,具有微小差异的循环对称结构的振动分析,山东工业大学学报,1993,23(3):77~80
[38]王文亮,胡海昌,重特征值的小参数法,复旦学报(自然科学版),1993,32(2):168~176
[39]胡海昌,参数小变化对本征值的影响,力学与实践,1981,3(2):29~30
[40]王文亮,刘玉民,特征值组的摄动法,机械强度,1995,17(3):44~47
[41]刘满,陈塑寰,复模态矩阵摄动法,吉林工业大学学报,1986,16(3):1~9
[42]陈塑寰,刘中生,韩万芝,关于复模态矩阵摄动法的一些问题的讨论,吉林大学学报,1993,23(1):1~6
[43]刘济科,张宪民,孟光,对复模态矩阵摄动法的补充,航空动力学报,1996,11(1):97~99
[44]刘济科,高磊,张宪民,大型机械动力学设计的复模态矩阵摄动法,机械科学与技术,1998,17(1):8~10
[45]徐伟华,刘济科,阻尼系统振动分析的复模态矩阵摄动法,中山大学学报(自然科学版),1998, 37(4):50~54
[46] Liu Jike, Perturbation technique for non-selfadioint systems with repeated eigenvalues,AIAA Journal, 1999, 37 (2) : 222~226
[47]徐伟华,刘济科,复模态摄动问题的一种通用方法,中山大学学报(自然科学版),1999,38 ( s1 ):13~17
[48]刘济科,徐伟华,蔡承武,一种通用的复模态矩阵摄动法,应用数学和力学,2001,22(3):314~320
[49]陈塑寰,连续系统振动特征值问题的摄动法,吉林大学学报(工学版),1982,(4):1~7
[50]陈塑寰,弹性结构振动特征值问题摄动法的一般理论,吉林大学学报(工学版),1983,(4):1~12
[51]刘济科,蔡铭,吕中荣,连续系统振动特征值摄动问题的统一解法,中山大学学报(自然科学版),2003,42(4):1~3
[52]楼梦麟,任志刚,Timoshenko简支梁的振动模态特性精确解,同济大学学报,2002,30(8):911~915
[53]楼梦麟,沈霞,弹性地基梁振动特性的近似分析方法,应用力学学报,2004,21(3):149~152
[54]楼梦麟,严国香,李建元,求解复杂轴扭振动力特性的一种近似分析方法,机械工程学报,2005,41(1):226~229
[55]楼梦麟,白建方,FRP加固梁模态分析的摄动解法,建筑科学与工程学报,2005,22(2):21~24
[56]楼梦麟,洪婷婷,预应力梁横向振动分析的模态摄动方法,工程力学,2006,23(1):107~111
[57]楼梦麟,牛伟星,复杂变截面梁的轴向自由振动分析的近似方法,振动与冲击,2002,21(4):27~30
[58]刘保国,张新州,王威,锅炉给水泵转子动力学参数的一、二阶摄动识别研究,实验力学,2004,19(2):188~193
[59]刘保国,徐芸,殷学纲,锅炉给水泵转子动力学参数的二阶摄动识别,振动、测试与诊断,2004,24(3):206~209
[60] Suryatama D, Bernitsas, Topology and performance redesign of complex structures by large admissible perturbations, Struct Multidisc Optim, 2000, 20 (2): 138~153
[61] Wong C N, Zhu W D, Xu G Y, On an iterative general-order perturbation method for multiple structural damage detection, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 2004, 273 (1~2): 363~386
[62] Yu L, Cheng L, Yam L H, Yan Y J, Application of eigenvalue perturbation theory for detecting small structural damage using dynamic responses, Composite Structures, 2007, 78 (3): 402~409
[63]吕振华,结构动力学修改重分析方法的发展,计算结构力学及其应用,1994,11(1):85~91
[64]邵长健,孙涛,沈允文等,基于结构动力学修改重分析的齿轮系统减振研究,航空动力学报,1998,13(3):305~349
[65] Kim M, Moon J, Wickert J A, Spatial modulation of repeated vibration modes in rotationally periodic structures , Journal of vibration and Acoustics, Transactions of the ASME, 2000, 122 (1): 62~68
[66]付娜,王三民,郭伟超,某燃气轮机叶片—轮盘耦合振动特性研究,汽轮机技术,2005,47(5):362~364
[67]周传月,邹经湘,闻雪友等,燃气轮机带冠叶片耦合振动分析,哈尔滨工业大学学报,2001,33(1):129~133
[68]王锡平,程德林,李舜酩,循环对称结构的受迫响应,山东工程学院学报,1992,6(2):11~16
[69]王锡平,郑效忠,程德林,循环对称结构在外力作用下的模态特征及位移特征,山东工业大学学报,1991,21(3):18~23
[70]秦飞,张晓峰,白洁等,循环对称结构动应力计算的一种工程处理方法,北京工业大学学报,2006,32(增刊):64~67
[71] Chang J Y, Wickert J A, Response of modulated doublet modes to traveling wave excitation , Journal of Sound and Vibration, 2000, 242 (1): 69~83
[72] Chang J Y. Wickert J A, Measurement and analysis of modulated doublet mode response in mock bladed disks , Journal of Sound and Vibration, 2002, 250 (3): 379~400
[73] Kenyou J A, Griffin J H, Kim N E, Sensitivity of tuned bladed disk response to frequency veering, American Society of Mechanical Engineers, Journal of Engineering for Gas Turbines and Power, 2005, 127 (4): 835~842
[74] Kenyou J A, Griffin J H, Feiner D M, Maximum bladed disk forced response from distortion of a structural mode, American Society of Mechanical Engineers, Journal of Turbomachinery, 2003, 125 (2): 352~363
[75]王建军,李其汉,朱梓根,失谐叶片—轮盘结构系统振动局部化问题的研究进展,力学进展,2000,30(4):517~528
[76]姚宗健,于桂兰,失谐循环周期结构振动模态局部化问题的研究,科学技术与工程,2005,5(21):1615~1622
[77]王晶,于桂兰,直线型失谐周期结构中局部化现象的研究进程和现状,科学技术与工程,2008,8(4):983~988
[78]李凤明,胡超,黄文虎,失谐周期结构中弹性波与振动的局部化,力学与实践,2003,25(3):35~38
[79] Kuang J H, Huang B W, The effect of blade crack on mode localization in rotating bladed disks, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 1999, 227 (1): 85~103
[80] Anderson P W, Absence of diffusion in certain random lattices, Physical Review, 1958, 109 (5): 1492~1505
[81] Hodges C H, Confinement of vibration by structural irregularity, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 1982, 82 (3): 411~ 424
[82] Hodges C H, Woodhouse J, Vibration isolation from irregularity in nearly periodic structures:theory and measurement, Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 1983, 74: 894 905
[83] Xie W C, Localization of vibration propagation in two-dimensional systems, Chaos, Solitons and fractals, 2000, 11 (10): 1505~1518
[84] Xie W C, Vibration mode localization in two-dimensional systems with multiple substructural modes, Chaos, Solitons and fractals, 2001, 12 (3): 551~570
[85] Xie W C, Vibration mode localization in two-dimensional systems with multiple substructural modes, Journal of Applied Mechanics, Transactions ASME, 2003, 70 (1): 119~128
[86] Pierre C, Mode localization and eigenvalue loci veering phenomena in disordered structures, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 1988, 126 (3): 485~502
[87] Happawana G S, Nwokah O D I, Bajaj A K, Azene M, Free and forced response of mistuned linear cyclic systems: a singular perturbation approach, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 1998, 211 (5): 761~789
[88] Kuang J H, Huang B W, Mode localization of a cracked blade disk, ASME Journal of Engineering for Gas Turbines and Power, 1999, 121 (2): 335~341
[89] Huang B W, Kuang J H, Mode localization in a rotating mistuned turbo disk with Coriolis effect, International Journal of Mechanical Sciences, 2001, 43 (7): 1643~1660
[90] Kuang J H, Huang B W, The effect of blade crack on mode localization in rotating bladed disks, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 1999, 227 (1): 85~103
[91] Xie W C, Ariaratnam S T, Vibration mode localization in disordered cyclic structures,I: single substructure mode, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 1996, 189 (5): 625~645
[92] Xie W C, Ariaratnam S T, Vibration mode localization in disordered cyclic structures II: multiple substructure modes, Journal of Sound and vibration, 1996, 189 (5): 647~660
[93] Xie W C, Chen R Z H, Vibration mode localization in rib-stiffened plates with misplaced stiffeners in one direction, 2002, 14 (2): 311~333
[94] Krzyzynski T, Popp K, Sextro W, On some regularities in dynamic response of cyclic periodic structures, Chaos, Solitons and Fractals, 2000, 11 (10): 1597~1609
[95]周传月,邹经湘,闻雪友等,燃气轮机失调叶盘系统的振动特性分析,燃气轮机技术,2000,13(3):42~46
[96] Shahruz S M, Elimination of vibration localization in mistuned periodic structures, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 2005, 281 (1~2): 452~462
[97] Shahruz S M, Elimination of vibration localization: a mathematical justification, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 2005, 283 (1~2): 449~458
[98]王建军,姚建尧,李其汉.刚度随机失谐叶盘结构概率模态特性分析,航空动力学报,2008,23(2):256~262
[99]贺尔铭,余仕侠,王红建.随机失谐叶盘系统受迫振动响应的统计特性研究,机械强度,2007,29(1):20~24
[100]秦飞,陈立明,失调叶片—轮盘系统耦合振动分析,北京工业大学学报,2007,33(2):126~128
[101]吴立言,刘更,王步灜,可靠性分析的三参数法,航空学报,1995,16(3):376~380
[102]宁方立,吴立言,基于结构体动态问题的概率有限元法研究,机械工程学报,2001,37(8):88~90
[103]刘岚,刘更,吴立言等,循环对称结构动态响应问题的可靠性分析,机械工程学报,2002,38(12):29~33
[104]陈塑寰,随机参数结构的振动理论,长春:吉林科学技术出版社,1992
[105]陈塑寰,随机参数结构的随机特征值分析,吉林工业大学学报,1987,(4):12~18
[106]陈塑寰,张宗芬,结构固有频率的统计特性,振动工程学报,1991,4(1):90~96
[107]刘相秋,王聪,王威远等,失谐大型天线结构的振动模态局部化研究,宇航学报,2008,29(6):1756~1760,1803
[108]铁摩辛柯S,杨D H,小韦孚W,工程中的振动问题,胡人礼译,北京:人民铁道出版社,1978
[109]王宏祥,王红静,何勍,一类轴对称圆环的弯曲振动分析,辽宁工学院学报,2004,24(2):30~31,44
[110]殷学纲,王亚,多刚体离散方法在圆环振动分析中的应用,重庆大学学报,1990,13(4):74~83
[111]周延泽,王春洁,陆震,高速滚动轴承保持架自由振动特性研究,北京航空航天大学学报,2001,27(5):596~599
[112]邱家骏,弹性体非线性振动多重共振的能量法,力学学报,1990,22(6):753~758
[113] Detinko F M, Free vibration of a thick ring on multiple supports, International Journal of Engineering Science, 1989, 27 (11): 1429~1438
[114] Allaei D, Soedel W, Yang T Y , Natural frequencies and modes of rings that deviate from perfect axisymmetry, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 1986, 111 (1): 9~27
[115] Wu Xionghua, Parker R G, Vibration of rings on a general elastic foundation, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 2006, 295 (1~2): 194~213
[116] Fox C H J, A simple theory for the analysis and correction of frequency splitting in slightly imperfect rings, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 1990, 142 (2): 227~243
[117] Hwang R S, Fox C H J, McWilliam S, The in-plane vibration of thin rings with in-plane profile variations part I: general background and theoretical formulation, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 1999, 220 (3): 497~516
[118] Fox C H J, Hwang R S, McWilliam S, The in-plane vibration of thin rings with in-plane profile variations part II: application to nominally circular rings, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 1999, 220 (3): 517~539
[119] Hwang R S, Fox C H J, McWilliam S, Freevibrations of elliptical rings with circumferentially variable thickness, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 1999, 228 (3): 683~699
[120] Eley R, Fox C H J, McWilliam S, Anisotropy effects on the vibration of circular rings made from crystalline silicon, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 1999, 228 (1): 11~35
[121] Chang Chia-Ou, Chang Guo-En, Chou Chan-Shin, et al, In-plane free vibration of a single-crystal silicon ring, International Journal of Solids and Structures, 2008, 45 (24): 6114~6132
[122] Wake R N, Burdess J S, Evans J T, Changes in the natural frequencies of repeated mode pairs induced by cracks in a vibration ring, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 1998, 214 (4): 761~770
[123] Hong Jin Sun,Lee Jang Moo, Vibration of circular rings with local deviation, ASME, Journal of Applied Mechanics, 1994, 61 (2): 317~322
[124] Yoon Y J, Lee J M, Yoo S W, et al, A new method for in-plane vibration analysis of circular rings with widely distributed deviation, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 2002, 254 (4): 787~800
[125] Park Han Gil, Lee Jang Moo, Kang Yeon June, et al, A study on the mode pair of a slightly asymmetric circular ring with multiple deviations, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 2008, 310 (1~2): 366~380
[126] Rourke A K, McWilliam S, Fox C H J, Multi-mode frequency trimming of imperfect rings, Journal of Sound and Vibration 2001, 248 (4): 695~724
[127] Rourke A K, McWilliam S, Fox C H J, Multi-mode trimming of imperfect rings using masses at pre-selected locations, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 2002, 256 (2): 319~345
[128] Rourke A K, McWilliam S, Fox C H J, Frequency trimming of a vibrating ring-based multi-axis rate sensor, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 2005, 280 (3~5): 495~530
[129] Metrikine A V, Steady-state vibrations of an elastic ring under a moving load, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 2000, 232 (3): 511~524
[130] Rougui Mohamed, Karimin Abdellah, Belhaq Mohamed, Nonlinear flexural vibrating of a circular ring. A single mode approach, Chaos, Solitons and Fractals, 2008, 37 (4): 1143~1152
[131]曹志远,板壳振动理论,北京:中国铁道出版社,1989
[132]陈塑寰,结构振动分析的矩阵摄动理论,重庆:重庆出版社,1991
[133] Liang Q W, Rodriguez C G, Egusquiza E, et al, Numerical simulation of fluid added mass effect on a francis turbine runner, Computers & Fluids, 2007, 36 (6): 1106-1118
[134]杨通强,斜齿行星传动动力学研究[博士学位论文],天津:天津大学,2003
[135]梁冯珍,宋占杰,张玉环,应用概率统计,天津:天津大学版社,2004
[136]梁晋文,陈林才,何贡,误差理论与数据处理,北京:中国计量出版社,1989
[137] Lin J, Parker R G, Structured vibration characteristics of planetary gears with unequally spaced planets, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 2000, 233 (5): 921~928
[138] Bianchi N, Bolognani S, Design techniques for reducing the cogging torque in surface-mounted PM motors, IEEE Transactions on industry applications, 2002, 38 (5): 1259~1265
[139] Dosiek L, Pillay P, Cogging torque reduction in permanent magnet machines, IEEE Transactions on industry applications, 2007, 43 (6): 1565~1571
[140]温激鸿,郁殿龙,王刚等,周期结构细直梁弯曲振动中的振动带隙,机械工程学报,2005,41(4):1~6
[141]王刚,温激鸿,刘耀宗等,一维粘弹性材料周期结构的振动带隙研究,机械工程学报,2004,40(7):47~50
[142]王世宇,基于相位调谐的对称式机构动力学分析新方法概论[博士后出站报告],天津:天津大学,2007
[143] Ben uang, Albert Hartman, High speed ten pole/twelve slot D. C. brushless motor with minimized net radial force and low cogging torque, US Patent 5675196
[144]唐任远,现代永磁电机理论与设计,北京:机械工业出版社,1997
[145] Sang-Moon Hwang, Jae-Boo Eom, Yoong-Ho Jung, et al., Various design techniques to reduce cogging torque by controlling energy variation in permanent magnet motors, IEEE Transactions on magnetics, 2001, 37 (4): 2806~2809
[146] Zhu Z Q, Howe D, Influence of design parameters on cogging torque in permanent magnet machines, IEEE Transactions on energy conversion, 2000, 15 (4): 407~412
[147] Chen S X, Low T S, Lin H, et al., Design trends of spindle motors for high performance hard disk drives, IEEE Transactions on magnetics, 1996, 32 (5): 3848~3850
[148] Chao Bi, Quan Jiang, Song Lin, Unbalanced-magnetic-pull induced by the EM structure of PM spindle motor, Electrical Machines and Systems, 2005, 1: 183~187
[149]谭建成,三相无刷直流电动机分数槽集中绕组槽极数组合规律研究,微电机,2007,40(12):72~77, 86
[150]宋志环,韩雪岩,陈丽香等,不同极槽配合永磁同步电动机振动噪声分析,微电机,2007,40(12):11~14
[151]高宏伟,张千帆,阿部一雄等,无刷直流电动机极槽配合及低噪音驱动技术,哈尔滨工业大学学报,2007,39(1):124~127
[152]王秀和,丁婷婷,杨玉波等,自起动永磁同步电动机齿槽转矩的研究,中国电机工程学报,2005,25(18):167~170