股指期货标的指数选择研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
在我国即将推出股指期货之际,管理层最大的顾虑是股指期货对市场可能带来的风险。在股指期货交易风险控制的多种角度和措施中,股指期货标的指数的选择是交易风险控制的基础问题。在这种背景下,如何选择适合中国特色的股指期货标的指数,是本文所关心的问题。
     本文首次将博弈论技术引入股指期货标的指数的选择中,指出大力发展套期保值者和套利者,是管理层有效提高投机者操纵成本,抑制投机者操纵市场,同时又不提高监管成本的有效措施。分析只有同时有利于套期保值者、套利者和投机者的股指期货品种,才是能有效控制风险的品种。
     本文在第四章分析了股指期货的主要参与人及其博弈的规则,建立他们之间博弈的基本模型。
     第五章通过对海外市场推出股指期货前后,现货市场的波动性、流动性、和估值标准的变化情况实证分析,指出期货的出现并不能改变现货市场固有特征,从而支持本文建立在未推出股指期货前的市场上的分析结论是有指导意义的。
     第六章为“从套期保值角度看我国股指期货标的指数选择”,分为我国现阶段投资者构成、国内A股市场系统风险分析、用套期保值理论模型和绩效衡量指标,对我国现各类指数的套保效果实证分析结果,共3部分。
     第七章为“从套利角度看我国股指期货标的指数选择”,主要从指数成分股分红预测、和成分股流动性分析两方面,比较在套利者眼里各指数的优劣。
     第八章为“从投机角度看我国股指期货标的指数选择”,主要从各指数市场代表性、波动性和可操纵性几方面,比较在投机者眼里各指数的优劣,并给出反过度投机的措施。
     第九章在综合前面几章节分析结论的基础上,给出了适合我国股指期货标的指数需要具备的几项要素,并对我国合约设计和制度设计提出了建议。
Before the establishment of index futures in China, the biggest issue people may concern is that the index futures might increase the riskiness of the market. We might have different visions and different methods of trading risk control of the market, however choosing an optimal underlying index act the most important and fundamental role in risk control. Therefore, an appropriate selection of the underlying index for the Chinese market is the key argument of this article.
     First of all, game theory methodology will be introduced into the selection of underlying index, and we try to explain why hedgers and arbitragers are crucial to the index futures market in China. The reasons to encourage these two kinds of investors are that, they will increase speculators’transaction cost as well as restricting speculators from destabilizing the market. However, they would not affect the cost of regulation management. Therefore, an optimal index futures product with efficiently risk control must be benefit for hedgers, arbitragers and speculators.
     In chapter 4, we focus on the participators in index futures market, and the role of the game theory, thus establish a game theory model which connect with players in the futures market.
     In chapter 5, we investigate on the change in volatilities, liquidity and estimation of the spot market after the accomplishment of index futures in oversea markets. We conclude that the issue of index futures does not essentially change the feature of the spot market. Therefore, the analysis of this report on futures index is evidently significant.
     In chapter 6, we discuss the choosing of underlying index for hedging purpose in China, including the structure of investors in China, A-share systematic risk analysis, hedging theoretical models and their measure of performance, for testing the hedging performance of existing indices in China.
     In chapter 7, we discuss the choosing of underlying index for arbitraging purpose in China. This includes three parts, the dividend expectation of index components, the liquidity of index components, and comparing the advantage and disadvantage of different indices for arbitrage.
     In chapter 8, we discuss the choosing of underlying index for speculating purpose in China. This mainly research on indices volatilities, market-representative properties and operational properties. Finally we compare the advantage and disadvantage of different indices for speculating purpose and thus find a method to restrict them from over-speculating.
     In chapter 9, according to the argument from above chapters we find appropriate and essential factors for choosing an optimal underlying index and the suggestion for index futures contract design and construction.
引文
[1] Allen Franklin, Douglas Gale, Stock Price Manipulation, Review of Financial Studies, 1992
    [2] Allen Franklin, Gorton Gary, Stock Price Manipulation, Market Microstructure and Asymmetric Information, European Economic Review, 1992
    [3] Antoniou, A., and Holmes P, 1995 ,“Futures Trading, Information and Spot Price Volatility: Evidence for the FTSE-100 Stock Index Futures Contract Using GARCH,”Journal of Banking & Finance
    [4] Arnott, Robert D., Jason C. Hsu and Philip Moore,“Fundamental Indexation,”Financial Analysts Journal, v. 61, No. 2, 2005.
    [5] Aumann, R.,“Nash-Equilibria are not Self-Enforcing”, 1990, Economic Decision Making: Games, Econometrics and Optimization.
    [6] Baillie, R. T. and R. Myers, Bivariate GARCH estimation of the optimal commodity futures hedge, Journal of Applied Econometrics, 1991, 6: 109-124.
    [7] Becketti, S. and D.J. Roberts ,1990,“Will Increased Regulation of Stock Index Futures Reduce Stock Market Volatility?”, Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City Economic Review
    [8] Bell, D.E. and Krasker, W.S., Estimating Hedge Ratios, Financial Management, 1986, 15:34-39.
    [9] Benston and Kaufman, The Appropriate Role of Bank Regulation, Economic Journal, 106,688-97, 1996.
    [10] Bessembinder R., Seguim G. W., 1996,“Pricing Stock Index Futures with Stochastic Interest Rates”, Journal of Futures Markets
    [11] Black, D., Success and Failure of Futures Contracts: Theory and Evidence, NYU Business School Monograph Series in Finance and Economics, 1986.
    [12] Board, John; Sutcliffe, Charles,1995,“The relative volatility of the markets in equities and index futures”,Journal of Business Finance & Accounting
    [13] Bollerslev, T. (1986), Generalized Autoregressive Conditional Heteroskedasticity, Journal of Econometrics
    [14] Boot A W, Thakor, Anjan,“Self-interested bank regulation”, 1993, American Economic Review, Vol. 83:206-213.
    [15]Campbell T, Chan Y S, Marino A,“An incentive based theory of bank regulation”, 1992, Journal of Financial Intermediation, Vol. 2:255-276.
    [16] Chou, W. L., Fan, K. K., & Lee, C. F., Hedging with the Nikkei index futures: The conventional model versus the error correction model, Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance, 1996, 36: 495–505.
    [17] Cornell, B, K.R. French,“The Pricing of Stock Index Futures”, 1983a, The Journal of Futures Markets, 3(1), pp.1-14.
    [18] Cornell, B., K.R. French,“Taxes and the Pricing of Stock Index Futures”, 1983b, Journal of Finance, 38(3), pp.675-694.
    [19] Cox, J.C., J.E., Jr Ingersoll, and S.A. Ross,“The Relation between Forward Prices and Futures Prices”, 1981, Journal of Financial Economics 9, pp.321-346.
    [20] Cuny, C. J., The role of liquidity in futures market innovations. Review of Financial Studies, 1993, 6, 57-78.
    [21] Damodaran, A. (1990)“Index Futures and Stock Market Volatility,”Review of Futures Markets, 9, pp. 442-457.
    [22] Ederington, L. H., The Hedging Performance of the New Futures Markets, The Journal of Finance, 1979, XXXIV (1), 157-170.
    [23] Edwards, F. ,1988a,“Does futures trading increase stock market volatility?,”Financial Analysts Journal
    [24] Fama, E. ,1965,“The Behavior of Stock Market Prices”, Journal of Business
    [25] Fama, Eugene, and Kenneth French. 1973.“The Cross-Section of Expected Returns.”Journal of Finance, vol. 47, no. 2(June):427–465.
    [26] Finnerty, J.E. and Park, H.Y., 1987, Stock index futures: Does the tail wag the dog? A technical note, Financial Analyst Journal
    [27] Freris, A. F.,“The Effects of the Introduction of Stock Index Futures on Stock Prices: the Experience of Hong Kong 1984-1987”, 1990, Pacific Basin Capital Market Research, 409-416.
    [28] Gerety M, Mulherin J. ,1994,“Price Formation on Stock Exchanges: The Evolution of Trading within the Day”, Review of Financial Studies
    [29] Ghosh, A., Hedging with stock index futures: estimation and forecasting witherror correction model, Journal of Futures Markets, 1993, 13: 743-752.
    [30] Harris, L. E.,1989,“The October 1987 S&P500 Stock-index-futures Basis,”The Journal of Finance
    [31] Harry M. Markowitz,Market Efficiency: A Theoretical Distinction and So What? CFA Institute,2005
    [32] Harsanyi, J.,“Games with Incomplete Information Played by Byesian Players Parts 1, 2 and 3”, 1967, Management Science, 14, 159-182.
    [33] Hodgson, Allan; Nicholls, Des ,1991,“THE IMPACT OF INDEX FUTURES MARKETS ON AUSTRALIAN SHAREMARKET VOLATILITY”,Journal of Business Finance & Accounting
    [34] Jack Treynor,Why Market-Valuation-Indifferent Indexing Works,Financial Analysts Journal Volume 61,Number 5 ?2005, CFA Institute
    [35] Joost M.E. Pennings,Raymond M. Leuthold(2001),”A Behavioral Approach towards Futures Contract Usage”, Mansholt Papers
    [36] Joskow, Paul L,“Inflation and Environmental Concern: Structural Change in the Process of Public Utility Price Regulation”, 1974, Journal of Law & Economics, University of Chicago Press, Vol. 17(2), 291-327.
    [37] Kane, Foundations of Financial Regulation, mimeo, Boston College, January 1997.
    [38] Kee-Hong Bae, Kalok Chan, Yan-Leung Cheung,“The profitability of index futures arbitrage: Evidence from bid-ask quotes”, 1998, Journal of Futures Markets, Volume 18, Issue 7, 743-763
    [39] Keeley, M.C.,“Deposit Insurance, Risk, and Market Power in Banking”, 1990, American Economic Review, Vol. 80:1182 - 1200.
    [40] Kempf, A.,“Short selling, unwinding, and mispricing”, 1998, The Journal of Futures Markets, forthcoming.
    [41] Keynes, J.M.,“A Treatise on Money”, 1930, London: Macmillan.
    [42] Klemkosky, R. C., Lee, J. H,“The intraday ex post and ex ante profitability of index arbitrage”, 1991, The Journal of Futures Markets, 11(3), 291-311.
    [43] Kook,Kwon,Lee and Choe(1992),Selection of underlying index for stock index futures in Korea, Pacific Basin Capital Markets Research,vol.3,North-Holland,Amsterdam,pp427-440
    [44] Kreps, Wilson, Reputation and Imperfect Information, Journal of EconomicTheory, 1982
    [45] Kuserk, G. J., & Locke, P. R. (1996). Market making with price limits. Journal of Futures Markets,
    [46] Lee, S.B., and Ohk, K.Y.,1992,“Stock and Index Futures Listing and Structure Change in Time-Varying Volatility,”Journal of Futures Markets
    [47] Lien, D., Luo, X.,“Estimating Extended Mean-Gini Coefficient for Futures Hedging”, 1993, Journal of Futures Markets, 13: 665-676.
    [48] Lockwood, L. and S. Linn, 1990,“An Examination of Stock Market Return Volatility During Overnight and Intraday Periods: 1964-1989”, Journal of Finance
    [49] Luke Bortoli, Alex Frino, Elvis Jarnecic, David Johnstone,“Limit order book transparency, execution risk, and market liquidity: Evidence from the Sydney Futures Exchange”, 2006, Journal of Futures Markets, Volume 26, Issue 12, 1147-1167
    [50] MacKinlay, C., Ramaswamy, K.,“Program trading and the behavior of stock index futures prices”, 1988, Review of Financial Studies, 1, 137-158.
    [51] Mandelbrot, B.,1963,“the Variation of Certain Speculative Prices”, Journal of Business
    [52] Manne,Henry, Insider Trading and The Stock Market, New York: The Free Press,Collier Macmillan, 1966.
    [53] Merton, Robert C.,“Financial innovation and the management and regulation of financial institutions”, 1995, Journal of Banking & Finance, Vol. 19(3-4), 461-481.
    [54] Milgrom, Robert, Predation Reputation and Entry Deterrence, Journal of Economic Theory, 1982
    [55] Miller, M. H. ,1990,“International competitiveness of U. S. futures markets”, Journal of Financial Service Research
    [56] Modest, D., Sundaresan, M.,“The relationship between spot and futures prices in stock index futures markets: Some preliminary evidence”, 1983, The Journal of Futures Markets, 3(1), 15-41.
    [57] Modest, D.M.,“On the Pricing of Stock Index Futures”, 1984, Journal of Portfolio Management, Summer, pp.51-57.
    [58] Moriarty, Eugene J. and Paula Tosini., 1985, "Futures Trading and the Price Volatility of GNMA Certificates - Further Evidence," Journal of FuturesMarkets
    [59] Myers, R.J. and Thompson, S.R., Generalized optimal hedge ratio estimation, American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 1989
    [60] Myers, R.J. and Thompson, S.R., Generalized optimal hedge ratio estimation, American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 1989
    [61] Myerson,“Game theory: Analysis of conflict, 1991, Harvard University Press.
    [62] Myerson, R.,“Game Theory: Analysis of Conflict”, 1991, Harvard University Press
    [63] Neal, R. A.,“Direct tests of index arbitrage models”, 1996, Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 31(4), 541-562.
    [64] Pericli, A., and Koutmos, G. ,1997,“Index Futures and Options and Stock Market Volatility,”Journal of Futures Markets
    [65] Pope, P. F., Yadav, P. K.,“The impact of short sales constraints on stock index futures prices: Evidence from FT-SE 100 futures”, 1994, Journal of Derivatives Summer, 15-26.
    [66] Robert Arnott, Jason Hsu, Phil Moore,,Redefining Indexation, 2004 Research Affiliates, LLC. 2004
    [67] Robinson.G.,1993,“The effect of future trading on cash market volatility: evidence from london stock exchange”, Bank of England Working Paper
    [68] Savage, L. J.,“The Foundations of Statistics”, 1954, New York: Wiley.
    [69] Schelling, T. C.,“The Strategy of Conflict”, 1960, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press
    [70] Schwartz, Anna J.,“The Effects of Regulation on Systemic Risks”, 1988, roceedings from a Conference on Bank Structure and Competition, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, 28-34
    [71] Sephton, P. S.,“Optimal Hedge Ratios at the Winnipeg Commodity Exchange”, 1993, The Canadian Journal of Economics, Vol. 26, No. 1,175-193
    [72] Silber, W., Innovation, competition, and new contract design in futures markets. Journal of Futures Markets, 1981, 1 (2), 123–155.
    [73]Simon, H. A.,“invariants of Human Behavior”, 1990, Annual Review Psychology,41, 1-19
    [74] Sobel, Joel, A Theory of credibility, Review of Economic Studies, 1985.
    [75] Stigler G. J.,“The theory of economic regulation”, 1971, The Bell journal of Economics and Management, Vol. 23-21.
    [76] T.J. Brailsford, A.J. Cusack,“A comparison of futures pricing models in a new market: The case of individual share futures”, 1997, Journal of Futures Markets, Volume 17, Issue 5, 515-541
    [77] Telser, L. G., Why there are organized futures markets? Journal of Law & Economics, 1981, 24, 1–22.
    [78] Thiripalraju(1997),selection of an index futures: the Indian Case, presented for 1997 Ninth PACAP Finance Conference,Shanghai
    [79] Thomson, J.,“Using Market Incentives to Reform Bank Regulation and Federal Deposit Insurance”, 1990, Economic Review (Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland), 26:28-32
    [80] Tim Bollerslev,Ray Y. Chou and Kenneth F. Kroner, ARCH Modeling in Finance:A Review of the Theory and Empirical Evidence,Econometrics, 1992, Vol.52:5-59
    [81] Walsh, Carl E.,“Optimal Contracts for Central Bankers”, 1995, American Economic Review, 85(1), 150-167
    [82] Yadav, P. K., Pope, P. F.,“Stock index futures arbitrage: international evidence”, 1990, The Journal of Futures Markets, 10(6), 573-603.
    [83] Young, H. P.,“Individual Learning and Social Rationality”, 1998, European Economic Review, 52, 651-663
    [84]艾里克·拉斯缪森(美):博弈与信息—博弈论概论[M],北京:北京大学出版社,生活·读书·新知三联书店,2003
    [85]曹红辉:中国资本市场效率研究[M],北京:经济科学出版社,2002
    [86]陈晗、张晓刚、鲍建平,股票指数期货理论、经验与市场运作构想,上海远东出版社,2001
    [87]陈启欢、杨朝军,上证180指数是否合适充当标的指数,数量经济技术经济研究,2004年第5期
    [88]花俊洲、吴冲锋、刘海龙、邹炎,期铜套期保值有效性实证研究,系统工程理论方法应用,2003.9,204-208。
    [89]黄长征,期货套期保值决策模型研究,数量经济技术经济研究,2004.7,96-102。
    [90]黄德春,2002,股指期货合约设计的实证分析,财政金融
    [91]李存修、陈俊霖、朱世逸:“股价指数期货上市对股市成交量之影响:香港之经验与实证”,《证券市场发展》,1998.1
    [92]李庚,利用多空指数交易系统增加期货投机的收益率,对外经济贸易大学,硕士论文
    [93]林爱诺、郑文堂、李从珠,2003,套期保值理论及其在股指期货中的应用初探,北方工业大学学报
    [94]林国春,博弈论在金融领域的应用述评,经济学动态,2001.12
    [95]林翔,对中国证券咨询机构预测的分析,经济研究,2000.2
    [96]穆瑞田(2001),中国流通A股市场基本数据衍生信息研究,南开大学博士研究生毕业(学位)论文
    [97]齐明亮,套期保值比率与套期保值的效绩,华中科技大学学报,2004.2
    [98]邱沛光,范秀荣,关于证券市场操纵行为的理论综述,中国流通经济,2006.8
    [99]屈国俊,中国证券市场监管:基于博弃论视角的分析,西北大学,博士学位论文
    [100]施东晖,1996,上海股票市场风险性实证研究,经济研究
    [101]宋逢明、朱世武,2002,中国股票市场风险测度的实证研究,中国货币市场
    [102]孙培源,施东晖,基于CAPM的中国股市羊群行为实证研究,经济研究,2002.7
    [103]吴冲锋王海成吴文锋著,金融工程研究,上海:上海交通大学出版社,2000.2
    [104]吴冲锋、钱宏伟、吴文锋,期货套期保值理论与实证研究(I),系统工程理论方法应用,1998.7,20-27。
    [105]吴齐华,刘景,饶刚,持股集中度与股价波动关系的实证分析,证券市场导报,2001.6
    [106]吴勇超,股指期货标的指数设计的国际比较与借鉴,北方经贸,2003年第11期
    [107]肖条军,博弈论及其应用,上海三联书店,2004年7月第1版
    [108]谢建军,章飙,彭艳(2000),中国股票指数期货市场设计——标的指数设计,2000年证券市场金融创新课题
    [109]谢识予,股市投机的群体行为博弈和系统科学分析,数量经济技术研究,2002.7
    [110]徐国祥,檀向球,全国统一股价指数编制研究———指数期货标的物选择实证分析,统计研究,2001年第9期
    [111]徐国祥,檀向球,指数期货套期保值实证研究,统计研究,2004年第4期
    [112]应望江、张永京、徐华康,2001,从台湾实践看股指期货对现货市场的影响,证券市场导报
    [113]张维迎:博弈论与信息经济学[M],上海:上海三联书店,上海人民出版社,1996
    [114]张永鹏,邱沛光,市场操纵过程的进化博弈分析,系统工程理论方法应用,2005.3
    [115]赵沂蒙,中国股指期货标的指数的实证分析,上海财经大学学报,2003年8月
    [116]朱·弗登博格,让·梯若尔,博弈论[M],中国人民大学出版社,2002年第1版
    [117]庄忠柱,2001,现货、近月期与近季期股价指数期货市场间价格与价格波动性的信息传递:台湾的早期经验管理学报

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700