非线性框架下中国股票市场价格收益率特征分析
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
经典资本市场理论基本上都是以有效市场假定作为研究基石,理性投资者、市场有效和随机游走过程这三个核心前提假设决定了经典资本市场理论是建立在线性范式上,但线性研究范式下发展而来的经典资本市场理论对股票市场许多现象不能给出合理解释,国内外许多实证研究都佐证了有效市场假定的失效,对股票市场价格行为的研究,客观上需要用非线性角度进行。用非线性方法对我国股票市场价格收益率的研究对于丰富股票价格及收益率行为的认识、管理层对股票市场的规范及管理及未来我国不断推出的基于股票价格的金融衍生产品定价都具有一定的理论与实践意义。
     本论文以沪深股票市场为研究对象,在非线性研究框架下,运用R/S分析法、频谱分析、ARMA模型、异方差模型、因子分析、分形及混沌理论以及其它各种非线性检验方法对我国股票市场价格收益率的分布特征、相关性与持续性、周期性、异方差性、复杂性等特征进行了全面的实证分析,并且探讨了非线性方法对股票市场的风险衡量、交易制度对股价波动的影响、消息对股价影响的不对称性及股价的可预测性等股票实践问题,主要结论与成果有:
     (1)传统线性理论不能很好解释沪深股票市场,我国股票市场价格收益率行为不符合有效市场假定,收益率分布存在明显尖峰胖尾行为,收益间存在长期相关性与持续性。
     (2)我国股票市场价格收益率行为存在周期性现象,具有一定数量的非规则周期。
     (3)异方差模型在我国股票市场能得到很好的拟合,好坏消息对两指数收益率变化的冲击是不对称的,交易成本的上调对股票市场价格波动性有明显的影响,而下调则影响甚微。
     (4)如果把股票市场视为一个复杂性系统,分形与混沌等理论检验表明我国股票市场价格收益率具有明显非线性特征,最少可用4个状态变量建立沪深两市大盘指数价格序列系统模型。
     (5)两市股价波动具有明显的时变性、簇集性及共动性,风险与收益间关系不显著;用ARIMA模型对我国股票市场收益率波动预测效果一般。
     文章最后提出了相应的政策建议及进一步的研究方向。
Many classical capital market theories, which are developed on the basis of Efficient Market Hypothesis, are established under the linear framework, for EMH is established on the following three core presuppositions: rational investor, efficient market and random walk process. Nevertheless, Many empirical studies, home and abroad, show the limitation of EMH and many phenomenona in the stock market can not be reasonably explained by classical capital Market theories. So it's an inevitable selection to study capital market in nonlinear method instead. The study on the price & return rate of China's stock market under non-linear framework is very meaningful to enrich the knowing of stock price and return rate behavior, to standardize and supervise the stock market, to measure price for the near future derivative securities.
     As concerned above, under the non-linear framework, the dissertation gives an empirical analysis to the distribution, correlation and persistence, periodicity, heteroskedasticity, complexity of China's stock market by some non-linear model, such as R/S analysis, frequency spectrum, ARMA model, ARCH model, and factor analysis, fractal and chaos theories and other non-linear methods. Also some practical concerns such as risk measurement, the influence to the price volatility of the trade institute, the unbalance of price shock under new information and the price predictability, have been discussed using non-linear methods. The main results are listed as follows:
     (1)China's stock Market can not be reasonably explained by classical capital theories. The behavior of stock price & return rate, which shows long memory and persistence and thin peak and heavy-tailed feature in the distribution picture, is not conform to EMH.
     (2)There are some periodical phenomenona, with some unregular periods, in the price & return rate behavior of China's market.
     (3)The volatility of China's stock market can been well estimated by AHCH model. The empirical study by AHCH model series shows that: the shock to the price & return rate is unsymmetrical between good and bad news, the volatility of China's stock market can been great disturbed by the increase of trade cost ,whereas only little influence by the decrease of trade cost.
     (4)Regarding stock market as a complicated system and examining through fractal and chaos theories , there are distinct non-linear features in the price & return rate of China's stock market. The system of Shanghai and Shenzhen index series can be established by at least 4 variables.
     (5)The volatility in China's stock market varies timely, jointly and assembly. The relation between risk and return rate is not distinct and the performance is not very good in the prediction of return rate volatility by ARIMA model.
     Some policy suggestions and the further research trend have been pointed out in the last chapter of the dissertation.
引文
[1]该部分描述参考:刘文财《中国股票市场价格行为复杂性研究》,天津大学博士学位论文,2002。
    [2]本章主要非线性理论原理参考:约翰·Y.坎贝尔,安德鲁·W.罗,艾·克雷格·麦金雷《金融市场计量经济学》,上海财经大学出版社,2003年4月第1版。
    [3]样本数据均来源于国泰安信息技术所提供的CSMAR数据库。
    [4]该部分理论定义主要来源于:特伦斯·C·米尔斯,《金融时间序列的经济计量学模型》,经济科学出版社,2002年7月,第一版。
    [5]R/S分析法描述资料来源:Peters E E.Chaos and order in the capital market.second edition.New York,1991.
    [6]部分文献也把“长期相关性”称为“长期记忆性”。
    [7]谱分析原理参考:陈兆国《时间序列及谱分析》,北京:科学出版社,1988.7。
    [8]ARCH类模型形式参考资料:易丹辉《数据分析与EVIEWS应用》,北京:中国统计出版社,2002.10。
    [9]有关分形与混沌的理论描述参考资料:仪垂祥《非线性科学及其在地学中的应用》,北京:气象出版社,1995。
    [10]Peters对主要国际股票指数的相关维计算结果资料来源:Peters E E.Chaos and order in the capital market.second edition.New York,1991.
    [11]预期收益率与风险水平之间的关系部分国外研究综述参考资料:钟蓉萨,顾岚《中国股票市场实证统计分析》,北京:中国财政经济出版社,1999.10。
    [1]Arbel, A.and P. J. Strebel. Pay attention to neglected firms Journal of Portfolio Management, 1983.
    
    [2]Arbel ,A. An old product in a new package. Journal of Portfolio Management .Summer,1985.
    
    [3]Ariel,R.A. A monthly effect in stock returns.Journal of Financial Economics, 1989.
    
    [4]Ambrose et al., Fractal structure in the capital markets revisited, Financial Analysis Journal, 1993, May/June: 73-77.
    
    [5]Aydogan, K., & Booth, G.G., Are there long cycles in common stock returns? Southern Economic Journal, 1988,55:141-149.
    
    [6]Ball,R. and P.Brown. An empirical evaluation of accounting income numbers Journal of Accounting Research ,1969.
    
    [7]Banz, R. The relationship between return and market value of common stocks.Journal of Financial Economics,9,1981.
    
    [8]Barclay Michael J.Eugene Kandel and Leslie M.Marx, 1998,The Effects of Transaction Cost on Stock Prices and Trading VolumeJournal of Financial Intermediation 7,130-150.
    
    [9]Bollerslev,T.,Generalized Autoregressive Conditional Heteroskedasticity, Journal of Econometrics,1986,31,307-327.
    
    [10]Bachelier, Louis. The random character of stock market prices. M.I.T. Press.Cambridge .Mass, 1964.
    
    [11]Black,Fisher,and Scholes.Marion.The Pricing of Options and Corporate Liabilities.Journal of Political Economy,1965.
    
    [12]Brock., W. ,W.Dechert, and J. Scheinkman, A Test for Independence Based on the Correlation Dimension,unpublished paper,1987.
    
    [13]Brown , P. ,D. D. Keim, A. W. Kleidon ,and T. A. Marsh .Stock return seasonalities and the tax-loss selling hypothesis:analysis of the Arguments and Australian evidence Journal of Financial Economics ,12,1965.
    
    [14]ChenPing, A Random Walk or Color Chaos on the Stock Market? Time-Frequency Analysis of S&P Index. Studies in Nonlinear Dynamics and Econometrics, 1996,1(2):87~103.
    [15]Engle, R. Autoregressive Conditioal Heteroskedasticity with Estimates of the Variance of UK Inflation, Econometrica,1982,50,987-1008.
    
    [16]Foster ,G. Stock market reaction to estimates of share by corporate officials.Journal of Accounting Research , ll,Spring, 1973.
    
    [17]French , K. Stock returns and the weekend effect.Journal of Financial Economics , 8, March, 1980.
    
    [18]Friedman, J.,and W. Stuetzle, Projection Pursuit Regression, Journal of the American Statistical Association,1981,76(376).
    
    [19]G.Galle. Chaotic Dynamics Theory and Application to Economics. Cambridge University, 1992.
    
    [20]Gian Italo Bischi and Vincenzo Valori, Nonlinear effects in a discrete-time dynamic model of a stock market, Chaos, Solitons and Fractals, 2000,11: 2103-2121.
    
    [21]Gibbons , M. and P. Hess . Day of the week effects and asset returns. Journal of Business, 54, 1981.
    
    [22]Goetzmann,W., Patterns in three centuries of stock market prices, Journal of Business, 1993, 66(2): 249-270.
    
    [23]Granger,C.WJ.and R.Joyeux., An introduction to long-memory time series models and fractional differencing, Journal of Time Series Analysis, 1980,1:15-39.
    
    [24]Granger,C.WJ., Long memory relationships and the aggregation of dynamics models, Journal of Econometrics,1980,14:227~238.
    
    [25]Grassberger,P., and I. Procaccia, 'Measuring the Strangeness of Strange Attractors, Physica, 1983,9D,189-208.
    
    [26]Hamilton ,J. D. Time Series Analysis .Princeton University Press, 1994.[27]Hosking,J.R.M., Fractional differencing,Biometrika,1981,68:165~176.
    
    [28]Hsieh,D.,Testing for Nonlinear Dependence in Daily Foreign Exchange Rates,Journal of Business,1989,62,339-368.
    
    [29]Hu, Shing-yang."The Effects of the Transaction on the Stock Market-experiences from Markets."Pacific-Basin Finance Journal, 1998,6, PP. 347-364.
    [30]H. W. Lorenz .Nonlinear. Dynamical Economics and Chaos Motion, 1989.
    [31]J.A.Schumpeter. The theory of economic development. Cambrign. Mass:Havard V.V.Press, 1994.
    
    [32]Jensen ,M. C. The performance of mutual funds in the period 1945-64 .Journal of Finance ,23 ,May,1968.
    
    [33]Kantelhardt J W, Zschiegner. S A, et al. Multifractal detrended fluctuation analysis of nonstationary time series .Physica. 2002,316 :87-114.
    
    [34]Kaplan, R. S. and R. Roll .Investor evaluation of accountiong information: some empirical evidence . Journal of Business, 45 ,April. 1972.
    
    [35]Keim ,D. B. Size related anomalies and stock return seasonality: further empirical evidence. Journal of Financial Economics ,12, June, 1972.
    
    [36]Kendall ,Maurice. The analysis of economic time series .part l:price Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, 96,1953.
    
    [37]Kim,T. An assessments of the performance of mutual fund management: 1969-1975.Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis ,13 .September ,1978.
    
    [38]Kon ,S.J. and F. C. Jen. The investment performance of mutual funds: an empirical investigation of timing, selectivity and market efficiency.Journal of Business ,52,1979.
    [39]Kupiec, Paul H.Noise Traders,a Securities Transactions Tax.. Excess Volatility,Working paper of Feds Number; 95-26, 1997.
    
    [40]Lan T Henry. Long memory in stock returns: Some international evidence .Applied Financial Economics. 2002, (12) :725~729 .
    
    [41]Liu M. Modeling long memory in stock market volatility .Journal of Econometrics. 2000, 99 :139-171.
    
    [42]Lindgren R. and Westlund A.,1990,How did transaction costs on the Stockholm stock exchange influence trade and price volatility?Sknadianviska Enskilda Banken Quarterly Review,2,pp.30-35.
    
    [43]Lintner,John .The Valuation of Risk Assets and the Selection of Risky Investments in Stock Portfolios and Capital Budgets.Review of Economics and Statistics,1965.
    [44]Lo,A., Long-term memory in stock market prices, Econometrica, 1991, 59(5): 1279~1313.
    [45]Lorenz,E.,1963,Deterministic Aperiodic Flow,Journal of Atmospheric Sciences, 1963, 20, 130-141.
    
    [46]Loretan,M.and Phillips,P.C.B.,Testing the Covariance Stationarity of Heavy-Tailed Time Series.Journal of Time Series Analysis,1985,6,35-52.
    
    [47]Mandelbort,B., The variation of certain speculative prices, The Journal of Business,1963b, 394-419.
    
    [48]Mandelbort,Bv The variation of some other speculative prices, The Journal of Business, 1967, 40(4): 393-413.
    
    [49]Mike K P So. Long term memory in stock market volatility .Applied Financial Economics. 2000, (10) :519~529.
    
    [50]Mossin,J. Equilibrium in a Capital Asset Market. Econometrica,1966.
    
    [51]Panas E. Long memory and chaotic models of prices on the London metal Exchange .Resources Policy. 2001, (27) :235~246.
    
    [52]Peters,E E. Fractal Market Analysis,John Wiley&Sons, Inc.,1994.
    
    [53]Peters E E. Chaos and order in the capital market.second edition.New York,1991.
    
    [54]Priestley,M.,Non-Linear and Non-Stationary Time Series Analysis,Academic Press,San Diego,1988.
    
    [55]Pettit ,R. R. Dividend announcements, security performance, and capital market efficiency.Journal of Finance ,27,1972.
    
    [56]Ross.Stephen A. The Arbitrage Theory of Capital Asset P-ricing,Journal of Economic Theory,1976.
    
    [57]Rozeff, M. S. and M. A. Zaman. Market efficiency and insider trading: new evidence . Journal of Business, 61,1988.
    
    [58]Rozeff , M. S., and W. R. Kinney. Capital market seasonality: the case of stock returns. Journal of Financial Economics ,6,1976.
    
    [59]Saporta V.and K., The Effects of Stamp Duty on Level and Volatility of UK Equity Price ,Bank of England,Working paper,1977.
    
    [60]Scheinkman, Jose A & LeBaron, Blake., Nonlinear Dynamics and Stock Returns,Journal of Business, 1989, 62 (3): 311-317.
    
    [61]Schmitt,F. et al., Multifractal analysis of foreign exchange data. Applied Stochastic Models and Data Analysis, 1999,15:29-53.
    
    [62]Sharpe.W. Capital Asset Price-A Theory of Market Equilibrium Under Conditions of Risk Journal of Finance,1964. ——:Portfolio Theory and Capital Markets,McGraw-Hill,1970.
    [63]Terasvirta,T.,D.Tjostheim,and C.Granger,Aspects of Modelling Nonliner Time Series,Handbook of Econometrics,Vol.Ⅳ,Elsevier,Amsterdam,1994.
    [64]Tobin,J."On the Efficiency of the Financial System." Lloyd's Bank Review,1984,Vol.153,pp.1-15.
    [65]Tong,H.,Non-Liner Time Series:A Dynamic System Approach,Oxford University Press,Oxford.1990.
    [66]Umlauf,S."Transaction Taxes and the Behavior of the Swedish Stock Market.Journal of Financial Economics,1993,Vol.33,pp 227-240.
    [67]Vautard,R.,& Ghil,M.,Singular spectrum analysis in nonlinear dynamics with applications to paleoclimatic time series,Physica D,1989,35:395-424.
    [68]Volterra,V.,Theory of Functional and of Integro-Differential Equations,Dover,New York,1959.
    [69]ZhuanXin Ding,et al.,A Long Memory Property of Stock Market Returns and a New Model,Journal of Empirical Finance,1993,83-106.
    [70]陈赣洪,一种新的股市技术分析方法.马尔科夫预测法,改革新思维,1993,(3)。
    [71]陈浪南,黄杰鲲,中国股票市场波动非对称性的实证研究,金融研究,2002,(05)。
    [72]陈磊,任若恩,张金宝,基于GARCH模型的风险价值蒙特卡罗模拟,系统工程,2006,(07)。
    [73]陈梦根,中国股市长期记忆效应的实证研究,经济研究,2003,(3),70-78。
    [74]戴国强,陆蓉,中国股票市场的周未效应检验,金融研究,1999,(4),48-54。
    [75]段虎,任炜,王海铭,股市混沌现象中分形维及最大Lyapunov指数计算方法研究,数量经济技术经济研究,2002,(10)。
    [76]封建强,上海证券市场收益率分布的对称性研究,统计研究,2001,(7),29-33。
    [77]范南,王礼平,我国印花税变动对证券市场波动性影响实证研究,金融研究,2003,(6),38-45。
    [78]高安秀树,分数维(中译本),北京:地震出版社,1989。
    [79]高红兵,潘瑾,陈宏民,.深圳成份指数收益率序列的分形维,预测,2000,(6)。
    [80]康进,中国股票市场周划研究,数量与技术经济研究,1997,(12),33-35。
    [81]理查德·H·戴,混沌经济学,上海:上海译文出版社,1996。
    [82]李红刚,上海股市价格指数变动随机性及其与市场效益关系研究,数量经济技术经济研 究,1995,(11),70-72。
    [83]李进江,我国股市协整检验及周期波动,统计与决策,2005,(11),102-104。
    [84]凌士勤,杨波,袁开洪,凌云,基于高频数据的分类信息混合分布GARCH模型研究,数量经济技术经济研究,2005,(03)。
    [85]柳会珍,顾岚,股票收益率分布的尾部行为研究,系统工程,2005,(02)。
    [86]刘少波,崔萍,资本市场定价理论的非线性经济学方法,经济学动态,2002,(6)。
    [87]刘勇,周宏,上海股票市场时变的风险收益关系研究,会计研究,2005,(12)。
    [88]陆蓉,徐龙炳,牛市和熊市对信息的不平衡性反应研究,经济研究,2004,(3)。
    [89]罗登跃,王玉华,上海股市收益率和波动性长记忆特征实证研究,金融研究,2005,(11),109-116。
    [90]罗恩屯波等著,黄向阳等译,风险规则。北京:中国人民大学出版社,2000。
    [91]施锡铨,艾克凤.股票市场风险的多重分形分析,统计研究,2004,(09)。
    [92]史永东,中国证券市场股票收益持久性的经验分析,世界经济,2000,(11)。
    [93]史永东,蒋贤锋,中国证券市场印花税调整的效用分析,世界经济,2003,(8)。
    [94]史永东,上海证券市场的分形结构,预测,2000,(5),78-80。
    [95]孙广振,王劲松,深圳股市混沌现象和辨识及其讨论,数量经济技术经济研究,1994,(1)64-67。
    [96]宋颂兴,金伟根,上海股市市场有效性实证研究,经济学家,1995,(4)。
    [97]汤果,何晓群,顾岚,FIGARCH模型对股市收益率长记忆性的实证分析,统计研究,1999,(7),39-42。
    [98]唐齐鸣,陈键,中国股市的ARCH效应分析,世界经济,2001,(3),29-36。
    [99]陶亚民,蔡明超,杨朝军,上海股票市场收益率分布特征的研究,预测,1999,(2)。
    [100]王春峰,张庆翠,李刚,中国股票市场收益的长期记忆研究,系统工程,2003,(1)。
    [101]汪灵枝,吴建生,吴春梅,偏最小二乘回归的贝叶斯正则化神经网络集成模型在证券分析预测中的应用,数学的实践与认识,2007,(14)。
    [102]王聪,我国证券市场交易成本制度研究,暨南大学博士论文,2002。
    [103]王聪,段西军,中国证券市场佣金制度研究-关于中国证券市场的SCP分析框架,《经济研究》,2002,(5)。
    [104]魏权龄,数量经济学,北京:中国人民大学出版社,1998。
    [105]魏巍贤,周晓明,中国股票市场波动的非线性GARCH预测模型,预测, 1999,(5),47-49。
    [106]吴世农,上海股票市场效率的分析与评价,投资研究,1994,(8),44-47。
    [107]吴世农,韦绍永,上海股市投资组合规模和风险关系的实证研究,经济研究,1998,(4)。
    [108]吴喜之,王兆军,非参数统计方法,北京:高等教育出版社,1996。
    [109]伍海华,李道叶,金融创新论,呼和浩特:内蒙古大学出版社,2001。
    [110]伍海华,李道叶,股票市场系统动力学分析:以上海股票市场为例,当代经济科学,2001,(6)。
    [111]伍海华,李道叶,高锐,论证券市场的分形与混沌,世界经济,2001,(7)。
    [112]伍海华,李道叶,资本市场复杂性,北京:经济科学出版社,2003。
    [113]夏南新,基于分形R/S技术的中国股市非规则周期性研究,统计研究,2006,(2),28-31。
    [114]许冰,陈娟,沪深股市大盘指数收益率分布尾部的实证研究,数学的实践与认识,2006,(09)。
    [115]徐剑刚,上海和深圳股市股票报酬的条件异方差和周末效应,统计研究,1995,(6)。
    [116]徐龙炳,陆蓉,R/S分析探索中国股票市场的非线性,预测,1999,(2),59-62。
    [117]徐前方,上证指数的奇异吸引子,数量经济技术经济研究,1994,(2),23-26。
    [118]徐绪松,陈彦斌,深沪股市分形维实证研究,数量经济技术经济研究,2000,(11),59-61。
    [119]仪垂祥,线性科学及其在地学中的应用.北京:气象出版社,1995。
    [120]闫冀楠,张维,上海股市EMH实证检验,系统工程学报,1997,(12),49-56。
    [121]俞乔,市场有效、周期异常与股份波动,经济研究,1994,(9)。
    [122]余卫军,张新生,上证指数收益率分布的拟合,经济数学,2004,(01)。
    [123]张本祥,资本市场的复杂性,中国高等科学技术中心CCAST复杂性问题研讨会,北京,2001。
    [124]张德贤,陈中慧,非线性动态经济学—分支与混沌,青岛:青岛海洋大学出版社,1995。
    [125]张尧庭,金融市场的统计分析,南宁:广西师范大学出版社,1998。
    [126]张嗣瀛.复杂系统与复杂性科学简介.青岛大学学报工程技术版,2001,(4):25-28。
    [127]张维,黄兴,沪深股市的R/S实证分析,系统工程,2001,(19)。
    [128]张亦春,周颖刚,中国股市弱式有效吗,金融研究,2001,(3),34-40。
    [129]张亦春,周颖刚,中国股市弱式有效研究综述,当代财经,2001,(08)。
    [130]钟蓉萨,顾岚,中国股票市场实证统计分析,北京:中国财政经济出版社,1999。

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700