企业高新技术创新项目R&D绩效测度与评价研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
研究与开发(Research and Development,R&D)不仅是企业技术创新的核心环节,也是企业竞争优势的源泉与持续发展的动力。企业高新技术创新项目R&D活动在企业发展中具有举足轻重的作用,同时也是一项高风险、高收益的投资活动。近年来,无论是政府还是企业自身都纷纷加大了对企业高新技术创新项目R&D活动的投资力度,由于风险大,成功率不高,使企业高新技术创新项目R&D投资绩效成为关注的焦点之一,而如何有效地测度与评价(测评)企业高新技术创新项目R&D绩效也成为当前亟待解决的问题。
     对企业高新技术创新项目R&D绩效进行测评是高新技术创新项目实施后期工作的关键,科学地测评企业高新技术创新项目R&D绩效,对降低企业高新技术创新项目R&D投资风险、提高经济效益具有重要意义。本文主要针对以下几个方面进行了研究:
     系统综述了R&D绩效测度与评价理论方法的相关研究成果;阐析了企业高新技术创新项目R&D绩效测评的现状,指出了存在的问题与不足;提出了包含R&D效率和R&D效力的企业高新技术创新项目R&D绩效评价的内容体系,并分析了二者的区别和联系,据此构建了包含R&D效率和R&D效力的企业高新技术创新项目R&D绩效评价指标体系;运用解释结构模型(ISM)建立了企业高新技术创新项目R&D效率和R&D效力的关联耦合模型;运用数据包络分析(DEA)的基本原理,构建了两阶段-DEA的企业高新技术创新项目R&D效率评价模型,考虑到时间因素,将Malmquist指数引入企业高新技术创新项目R&D效率变动评价,构建了基于等产量线的企业高新技术创新项目R&D技术变动预测模型;针对企业高新技术创新项目R&D效力测评中存在的主观性和不确定性,运用未确知数学的基本原理,与未确知数学中盲数相结合,建立了不确定结论合成模型和企业高新技术创新项目R&D效力的未确知测度评价模型;利用调研数据对调研企业高新技术创新项目R&D绩效进行综合评价,并对企业高新技术创新项目R&D效率和R&D效力进行关联检验;结合我国企业高新技术创新项目R&D活动的实际,从R&D、企业和政府三个层面提出了提高企业高新技术创新项目R&D绩效水平的对策和建议,为提升企业高新技术创新项目R&D绩效水平、增强企业核心竞争力提供发展思路。
     本论文的研究具有重要的理论意义和实践价值。本论文的研究不仅丰富和完善企业高新技术创新项目R&D绩效评价的内容体系,拓展了企业高新技术创新项目R&D绩效评价方法与模型,促进R&D绩效测评理论和方法的科学性和规范性,而且有利于政府、企业甚至R&D部门准确掌握企业高新技术创新项目R&D活动的总体趋势,识别企业高新技术创新项目R&D活动的优劣势,从而能够制定出有效的企业高新技术创新项目R&D发展政策,提高R&D能力,增强企业的竞争优势。
Research and Development (R&D) is not only the core tach of technology innovation, but also the headspring of enterprises' competitive advantage and drive of continuous development. Enterprise high-tech innovative project R&D plays an important role in enterprise development, which is also a high-risk and high-profit activity. In recent years, government and enterprises themselves have paid more attention to the investment of enterprise high-tech innovative project R&D, which is of greater risk and lower success rate, and that results in that enterprise high-tech innovative project R&D investment performance has naturally highlighted the attention, and that how to measure and evaluate enterprise high-tech innovative project R&D performance effectively becomes an urgent problem to solve.
     How to accurately measure and evaluate enterprise high-tech innovative project R&D performance is the key issue of post-implementation of high-tech innovation projects. Accurate measurement and evaluation R&D performance is of great value for reducing the risk of enterprise high-tech innovative project R&D and increasing economic benefits. This dissertation has deeply studied these aspects purposefully:
     This dissertation systematically summarizes the theory and method of R&D performance measurement and evaluation. Then, this dissertation defines R&D performance content of enterprise high-tech innovative project, and based on this establishes enterprise high-tech innovative project R&D performance index system, which includes two aspects, namely R&D effectiveness and R&D efficiency. And then, this dissertation establishes the coupling mechanism of enterprise high-tech innovative project R&D effectiveness and R&D efficiency using the method of Interpretative Structural Modeling (ISM), which provided a scientific basis of theory and practice to improve the performance of R&D strategy from inside. Next, this dissertation adopts Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) method to establish a two-stage DEA enterprise high-tech innovative project R&D efficiency evaluation model, which include two aspects, namely R&D process efficiency and R&D result traslation, to ensure the comprehensiveness of R&D efficiency evaluation. Taking into account the time factor, this dissertation introduces Malmquist index into enterprise high-tech innovative project R&D efficiency change evaluation, and establishes a R&D technical movement prediction model based on eqo-quanlity line. Aiming at the problems of objeveness and uncertainty of R&D performance measurement and evaluation of enterprise high-tech innovative project, this dissertation uses the principle of unascertained mathmatics and builds a synthetic model combined uncertain number. On the other hand, this dissertation combines blind data, which ensures the results of unascertained model more scientific, and is contributed to the accuracy and precision of enterprise high-tech innovative project R&D effectiveness. Using the data and method, this dissertation makes a comprehensive experiential analysis. Finaly, this dissertation puts forward the countermeasures to improve the level of enterprise high-tech innovative project R&D performance from three aspects, namely internal R&D, enterprise and government, which provides some new thought for enhancing R&D performance level and enterprise core competitiveness.
     In this dissertation, the study has important theoretical and practical value, which not only enriches and consummates the content of R&D performance evaluation, and develops the methods and models of R&D performance evaluation, which are redounds to the scientificalness and standardization, but also helps govement, enterprises and R&D departments to know the main condition and recognize the dis- and advantages of enterprise high-tech innovative project R&D, which contributes to make the development policies of enterprise high-tech innovative project R&D, and helps to increase R&D capability and competitiveness of enterprises.
引文
[1]Sivathanu A.P.,Joshi A.and Srinivasa K.R.,Performance measurement of R&D projects in a multi-project,concurrent engineering environment,Project Management,2002,20(2):165-177
    [2]Steven V.,Inge Kerssens-van Drongelen,Petra W.N.and James R.,Design of a research performance measurement system:the case of NIAB,Creativity and Innovation Management,2001,10(4):259-269
    [3]Keller R.T.and.Holland W.E.,The measurement of performance among research and development professional employees:a longitudinal analysis,Engineering Management,1982,29(2):54-58
    [4]陈伟,刘井建.中外企业R&D发展模式与管理的比较与借鉴[J].科技管理研究.2007(11):25-27
    [5]Juliana H.M.,Portfolio management of R&D projects:implications for innovation management,Technovation,2001(21):423-435
    [6]Chruster C.,Robert F.,Markku H.and Peter M.,A fuzzy approach to R&D project portfolio selection,International Journal of Approximate.Reasioning,2007(44):93-105
    [7]Juite W.and Hwang H.L.,A fuzzy set approach for R&D portfolio selection using a real options valuation model,Omega,2007(35):247-257
    [8]席酉民,杨列勋.R&D项目评估整体模型研究[J].系统工程理论与实践.2002(10):105-112
    [9]刘德学,何勇.企业R&D项目效率评价指标体系及其模糊评价[J].科技进步与对策.2003(10):108-110
    [10]马庆喜,王丽萍,张立新.技术创新项目组合优化投资决策研究[J].学术守流.2007(9):88-91
    [11]Wayne G.B.and Noah P.B.,Utilizing the balanced scorecard for R&D performance measurement,R&D Management,2004,34(3):229-238
    [12]Chiesa V.,Coughlan P.,Voss C.A.and Development of a technical innovation audit,Journal of Product Innovation Management,1996,13(2):105-136.
    [13]Inge Kerssens-van Drongelen,Bill Nixon and Alan Pearson,Performance measurement in industrial R&D,Management Reviews,2000,2(2):111-143
    [14]Albert N.Link,On the classification of industrial R&D,Research Policy,1996,25(3):397-401
    [15]张凌,傅毓维.企业技术创新项目评价方法的比较[J].经济师.2005(7):31-33
    [16]张凌,刘井建.基于DEA的工业企业技术创新能力的综合评价[J].科技导报.2005(9):50-52
    [17]陈伟,刘井建.基于DEA的高新技术企业R&D绩效评价研究[J].科技进步与对策.2008(4):57-59
    [18]Montoya-Weiss and Calantone,R.J.,Determinants of new product performance:a review and meta-analysis.Journal of Product Innovation Management,1994,11(5):397-417
    [19]Christoph L.et al.Measuring development performance in the Electronics Industry,Journal of Production Innovation Management,13(1996):3-20
    [20]陈伟,刘井建.企业R&D绩效测度系统研究[J].科技进步与对策.2008(6):57-59
    [21]Mark G.B.and Raynold A.S.,Measuring R&D productivity,Research Technology Management,1998,41(6):30-35
    [22]Griffin A.,Page A.L.,An interim report in measuring product development success and failure,Journal of Product Innovation Management,1993,10(4),291-308
    [23]Kerssens-van D.C.,Cook A.,Design principles for the development of measurement for research and development process,R&D Management,1997,27(4):345-357
    [24]Wayne G.,Bremser and Noah P.B.,Utilizing the balance scorecard for R&D performance measurement,R&D Management,2004,2(2):111-143
    [25]Harel E.,Boaz G.and Avraham S.,R&D project evaluation:an integrated DEA and balanced scorecard approach,Omega,2006,5(2):1-18
    [26]Manfred P.,Thorsten P.and Randolf S.,Real options valuation:the new frontier in R&D project evaluation? R&D Management,1999,29(3):255-269
    [27]Dean A.P.and Guest Editor,Introduction to real R&D options,R&D Management,2001,31(2.):109-113
    [28]Eduardo S.S.,Patents and R&D as reak options,Economic Notes by Banca Monte dei Paschi di Siena SpA,2004,33(1):23-54
    [29]Simon C.,Philip L.,Paul I.and John H.,An R&D options selection model for investment decisions,Technovation,2005(25):183-193
    [30]Marcus H,and Ali H.,Application of real options analysis for pharmaceutical R&D project valuation-Empirical results from a survey,Research Policy,2006(36):342-354
    [31]Nancy A.N.,Scientific Management at Merck:an Interview with CFO Judy Lewent,Harvard Business Review,1994,72(1):89-99
    [32]Ellis L.W.and Curbs C.C.,Measuring Customer Satisfaction,Research Technology Management,1995,38(5):45-48
    [33]Luke G.and David R.,Evaluation technology programs:tools and methods,Research Policy,2000,29(4):657-678
    [34]吴源鸿.企业创新与产品研发管理[M].广州:中山大学出版社.2000
    [35]Wittorio C.and Cristina M.,Searching for an effective measure of R&D performance,Management Decision,1996,34(7):49-57
    [36]Inge C.Kerssens-van D.and Jan B.,R&D performance measurement:more than choosing a set of metrics,R&D Management,1999,29(1):35-46
    [37]Sivathanu P.A.,Joshi A.and Srinivasa R.K.,performance measurement of R&D projects in a multi-project,concurrent engineering environment,international Journal of Project Management,2002(20):165-177
    [38]Gary H.J.et al.,R&D performance in Chinese industry,Econ.Innov.New Technology,2006,14(4/5):345-366
    [39] Tipping et al., Assessing the value of your technology, Research Technology Management, 1995, Sep-Oct, pp.22-39
    [40] Ronald D., Robert S.W. and Vincent A., Evaluating R&D performance using the cost savings metric, Research Technology Management, 1999, Mar-Apr, 13-14
    [41] Kerssens-van Drongelen, Jan Bilderbeek, R&D performance measurement: more than choosing a set of metrics, R&D Management, 1999, 29(1): 35-46
    [42] Mario Coccia, A basic model for evaluation R&D performance: theory and application in Italy, R&D management, 2001, 31(4): 453-165
    [43] Poh K.L., Ang B.W. and Bai F., A comparative analysis of R&D project evaluation methods, R&D Management, 2001, 31(1): 63-75
    [44] Louis Y.Y. and John S.L., R&D in China: an empirical study of Taiwanese IT companies, R&D Management, 2004, 34(4): 453-465
    [45] Feng Y.J., H. Lu, K. Bi, An AHP/DEA method for measurement of the efficiency of R&D management activities in universities, International Federation of Operational Research Societies, 2004, 11(2): 181-191
    [46] Armelle, G. and Klas, E.S. Use and impact of performance measurement results in R&D and NPD: an exploratory study. R&D management, 2004, 34(2): 191-219
    [47] Mario Coccia, New model for measuring the R&D performance and identifying the productivity of public research institutes, R&D Management, 2004, 34(3): 267-280
    [48] Kuang-Hua Hsu, Using balanced Scorecard and fuzzy DEA for multinational R&D project performance assessment, The Journal of American Academy of Business, Cambridge, 2005, 7(1): 189-196
    [49] Yoshitaka O. and Yoshiyuki Y, Proposal of industrial research and development performance indices, R&D Management, 2005, 35(4): 455-461
    [50] Eric C.W., R&D efficiency and economic performance: a cross-sountry analysis using the stochastic frontier approach, Journal of Policy Modeling, 2007(29):345-360
    [51]李强,韩伯棠,翟立新,李晓轩.公益类科研机构绩效评价测度体系研究[J].科学学与科学技术管理.2005(11):18-21
    [52]邓一华,吴贵生.技术创新活动的几种测度方法综述[J].科技进步与对策.2002(7):66-67
    [53]王伟光,唐晓华.技术创新能力测度方法综述[J].中国科技论坛.2003(7):39-43
    [54]徐笑君,许庆瑞,陈劲.企业绩效测量研究[J].科研管理.1998,19(4):37-40
    [55]曾德明,王贵生,秦吉波.高新技术企业R&D绩效测度系统的开发[J].运筹与管理.2003(2):87-92
    [56]周青,曾德明,秦吉波高新技术企业R&D绩效测度与实证分析[J].科学学与科学技术管理.2003(11):13-14.
    [57]曾德明,周青,秦吉波.高新技术企业R&D绩效测度系统设计方法[J].山西财经大学学报.2003(2):36-40
    [58]秦吉波.高新技术企业R&D绩效测度与控制的研究[D].湖南大学.2003
    [59]许庆瑞.研究与开发(R&D)绩效评价在中国:实践与趋势[J].科研管理.2002,23(1):46-53
    [60]杨观聪.企业R&D绩效的研究[J].技术经济与管理研究.2003(1):26-27
    [61]杨列勋.R&D项目评估的理论与方法[D].西安交通大学.2001
    [62]桂萍,熊伟,何山.行业R&D资源利用的相对有效性评价[J].科研管理.2002(11):54-60
    [63]张运生,曾德明,秦吉波,张利飞.基于主成分分析的R&D绩效评价系统[J].研究与发展管理.2004(4):1-6
    [64]曾德明,王贵军.研究与开发(R&D)项目评估方法的一种比较分析[J].科技与管理.2002(4):34-38
    [65]梁莱歆,刘剑秋.高新技术企业R&D绩效评价方法探索[J].科学学与科学技术管理.2004(11):29-32
    [66]梁莱歆.谈高新技术企业R&D绩效评价中应重视的几个问题[J].科技 管理研究.2005(3):68-70
    [67]列勋.R&D评估实践研究[J].研究与发展管理.2001(12):18-24
    [68]闰宏,朱启超,匡兴华.我国R&D绩效评估研究现状述评[J].科技管理研究.2004(1):109-112
    [69]Bill N.Research and development performance measurement:a case study,Management Accounting Research,1998,9(3):329-355
    [70]Nixon,B.,Accounting treatment of R&D expenditure:views of UK company accountants,European Accounting Review,1997,6(2):265-277
    [71]熊彼特.经济发展理论[M].北京:商务印书馆.1990
    [72]傅家骥.技术创新学[M].北京:清华大学出版社.1998
    [73]冯之浚.国家创新系统的理论与政策[M].北京:经济科学出版社.1999
    [74]李京文.迎接知识经济新时代[M].上海:上海远东出版社.1999
    [75]柳卸林.技术创新经济学[M].北京:中国经济出版社.1993
    [76]詹姆士·奎因.创新爆炸[M].吉林:吉林人民出版社.1999
    [77]曹伟,朱建业.基础研究导致重大技术创新的类型及规律研究[J].科学学研究.2002(8):22-28
    [78]刘胜福,刘国新.浅析当代技术创新的特点、发展规律及其影响[J].科技与管理.2003(3):39-42
    [79][美]克里斯托弗.梅耶著.梁淑玲译.创新增长--硅谷的启示[M].吉林人民出版社,1999
    [80]王伟强.组合创新研究[D].杭州:浙江大学管理科学研究所.1998
    [81]魏江,许庆瑞.企业技术能力的概念、结构与评价[J].科学学与科学技术管理.1998,16(9)):29-33
    [82]Vijay K.Jolly.新技术的商业化[M].北京:清华大学出版社.2001
    [83]孙连英,张德政,钮文良.创新理论原理及其扩展应用[J].北京联合大学学报(自然科学版).2005(6):11-14.
    [84]Bin X.,Multinational enterprises,technology diffusion,and host country productivity growth.Journal of Development Economics,2000,62(2):477-493
    [85]冯之浚.国家创新系统的理论与政策[M].北京:经济科学出版社.1999
    [86]孟祥红.王业企业技术创新测度理论与实践研究[D].天津:天津大学.2004
    [87]毕克新.中小企业技术创新测度与评价研究[M].北京:科学出版社.2006
    [88]Brown M.G.,Svenson R.A.,Measuring R&D productivity,Research Technology Management,1988,31(4):11-15
    [89]Kerssens-van Drongelen,R&D performance measurement:more than choosing a set of metrics,R&D Management,1999,29(1):35-46
    [90]Bourne M.,Mills J,Wilcox M.,Neely A.and Platts K.,Designing,implementing and updating performance measurement systems,International Journal of Operational and Production Management,2000,20(7):754-771
    [91]Waggoner D.B,Neely A.D.and Kennerley M.P.,The forces that shape organizational performance measurement systems:an interdisciplinary review.International Journal of Production Economics,1999,60(1):53-60
    [92]Begemann C.,Dynamics of performance measurement systems,International Journal of Operations and Production management,2000,20(6):692-704
    [93]理查德·威廉姆斯.组织绩效管理[M].北京:清华大学出版社.2002
    [94]杨列勋.R&D项目评估的理论与方法西安[D].西安:西安交通大学.2002
    [95]杨列勋.研究与开发项目评估及应用[M].北京:科学出版社.2002
    [96]刘武,蔡业泉.综合性科技计划评估的方法与实践[J].科研管理.1999(6):50-55
    [97]马晓光.R&D计划评级的基本方法[D].北京:中国科学院科技政策与管理研究所.2000
    [98]Jonathan D.L.,Steven T.W.and Joseph M.,Analysis,ranking and selection of R&D projects in a portfolio,R&D Management,2002,32(2):139-148
    [99]肖利.科技项目评估的必要前提[J].科学学研究.2004(3):291-293
    [100]Porter J.,Post audits and aid to research planning,Research Management, 1978,11(1):28-30
    [101]Mitchell G,Hamilton W,Managing R&D as a strategic option,Research Technology Management,1988,31(3):5-22
    [102]张晓云,谭静,张铀,李成标.指标设置与测度方法--工业R&D项目绩效评价综述[J].科技管理研究.2004(4):43-46
    [103]Feltham GA,,Xie J.Performance measure congruity and diversity in multi-task principal-agent relations.The Accounting Review,1994,69(3):429-453
    [104]Busby J.S.and Williamson A.,The appropriate use of performance measurement in non-production activity,Operations and Production Management,2000,20(3):336-358
    [105]Kerssens-van Drongelen I.C.and-Bilderbeek J.,R&D performance measurement:more than choosing a set of metrics.R&D Management,1999,29(1):35-46
    [106]John R.H.,Zettelmeyer F.Metrics to evaluate R,D&E,Research Technology Management,1997,40(4):32-37
    [107]Kerssens-van Drongelen,The use of performance measurement tools for balancing short- and long-term NPD performance.International Journal of Innovation Management,1999,3(4):397-426
    [108]John R.H.,Metrics thermostat,Product Innovation Management,2001,18(3):134-153
    [109]Max V.Z.,Post-project reviews in R&D,Research Technology Management,2003,46(5):43-49
    [110]王国平.现代企业行为论[M].上海:上海财经大学出版社.2004
    [111]阿迪德吉·B·巴迪鲁,P·施铭·巴拉特.项目管理原理[M].北京:清华大学出版社.2003
    [112]彭宇文,吴林梅.基于三大研发主体、三大研发活动的国内外R&D经费配置比较[J].湖南涉外经济学院学报.2007,7(3):8-12
    [113]杨德林,张庆锋.钢铁企业技术创新过程中R&D/生产制造界面管理研究[J].中国科技论坛.2003(9):56-60
    [114]官建成,罗艳.北京地区R&D市场营销界面管理的实证比较研究[J].管理工程学报.2000(12):55-59
    [115]李敦瑞,唐智鑫,王代敬.我国科技成果转化的制度环境约束分析[J].科技与管理.2005(6):95-98
    [116]张悦,胡朝阳.论我国科技成果转化的法律环境[J].科技与经济.2006(3):8-11
    [117]周亚庆,许为民.我国科技成果转化的障碍与对策:基于环境的研究[J].中国软科学.2000(7):59-62
    [118]王雄元,严艳.强制性信息披露的适度问题[J].会计研究.2003,(2):13-18
    [119]薛云奎,王志台.R&D的重要性及其信息披露方式的改进[J].会计研究.2001,(3):20-26
    [120]胡立新,齐帅星。高新技术上市公司R&D信息批露抽样分析[J].中国管理信息华.2007.(11):64-65
    [121]朱朝晖.信息不对称与R&D活动的信息披露[J].科技进步与对策.2005(9):87-88
    [122]梁莱歆,熊艳.我国上市公司R&D费用披露现状及其改进建议[J].财务与会计.2005(10):22-23
    [123]邹一峰,邹欣.中外投资项目评价[M].南京:南京大学出版社.1998
    [124]黄擎明.技术评估理论方法与实践[M].杭州:浙江大学出版社.1990
    [125]Bean A.S.,Why some R&D organizations are more productive than others.Research Technology Management,1999,38(1):25-29
    [126]Umit S.Bititci,Trevor T.and Carsten B.,Dynamic of performance measurement systems,International Journal of Operation Production Management,2000,20(6):692-704
    [127]Kerssens D.and Cook,The study about impractical factor of R&D project performance measurement,R&D Management,1999,29(3):243-251
    [128]Leroy D.,Project management practices in French organizations:a state of the art,in the Frontiers of Project Management Research,2002,pp.187-200
    [129]Cleland D.I.,Measuring success:the owner's and project viewpoint, Proceedings of the 18~(th) Annual Seminar/Symposium, Montreal, Canada, 1986, pp.6-12
    [130] Munns A.K. and Bjeirmi B.F., The role of project management in achieving project success, International Journal of Project Management, 1996, 14(2): 81-87
    [131] Shenhar A.J., and Levy O. and Dvir D., Mapping the dimensions of project success, Project Management Journal, 1997,28(5): 5-13
    [132] Sink S., The IE as change master, IIE Solution, 1998, 30(10): 36-42
    [133] Bigelow D., Does your organization have a CPO? PM Network, 2003, 17(9): 20
    [134] Grundy T. Strategy implementation and project management, International Journal of Project Management, 1998, 16(4): 43-50
    [135] Shenhar A.J., Dvir D., Levy O. and Maltz A.C., Project success: a multidimensional strategic concept, Long Range Planning, 2001, 34(6): 699-725
    [136] Wateridge J., How can IS/IT projects be measures for success? International Journal of Project Management, 1998, 16(1): 59-63
    [137] Clarke A., A practical use of key success factors to improve the effectiveness of project management, International Journal of Project Management, 1999, 17(3): 139-145
    [138] Hayes D.S., Evaluation and application of a project charter template to improve the project planning process, Project Management Journal, 2000, 31(1): 14-23
    [139] Jiang J., Klein G. and Chen H., The relative influences of IS project implementation polices and project leadership on eventual outcomes, Project Management Journal, 2001(18): 235-241
    [140] Lynn G.S. and Reilly R.R., Measuring team performance, Research Technology Management, 2000,43(2): 48-56
    [141] Wall Street Journal, New-product troubles have firms cutting back, The Wall Street Journal, 1997, January 13, pp.B1
    [142]Treacy M.and Wiersema F.,The discipline of market leaders[M],Cambridge,1995,pp.47-63
    [143]Ittner C.and Larcker D.,Non-financial performance measures:what works and what doesn't,Financial Times' Mastering Management,2000
    [144]Dasher G.T.,The interface between systems engineering and program management,Engineering Management,2003,15(3):11-14
    [145]安迪·尼利.企业绩效评估[M].北京:中信出版社.2004
    [146]查尔斯·汉迪.效率与效力[J].解读大师.2007(11):98-100
    [147]Leibenstein H.and Maital S.,The organizational foundations of X-efficiency:a game-theoretic interpretation of Argyris' model of organizational learning,Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization,1994,23(3):251-268
    [148]闫冰,冯根福,基于随机前沿生产函数的中国工业R&D效率分析[J].当代经济科学.2005,27(6):14-19
    [149]刘超,侯军岐.高校人力资本产权界定与激励机制研究[J].西北农林科技大学学报(社会科学版).2004(9):108-110
    [150]费显政.资源依赖学派之组织与环境关系理论评介[J].武汉大学学报(哲学社会科学版).2005(7):451-455
    [151]Mette A.,Joseph C.P.,David N.R.and Fai T.,Measuring overall efficiency and effectiveness using DEA,European Journal of Operational Research,2006,1(1):1-17
    [152]Morrison J.and Brown C.,Project management effectiveness as a construct:A conceptual study,Business Manage,2004,35(4):73-95
    [153]石善冲.科技成果转化评价指标体系研究[J].科学学与科学技术管理.2003(6):31-33
    [154]潘安娥,杨青.科技成果转化风险的模糊评价[J].武汉理王大学学报(信息与管理工程版).2004(6):137-148
    [155]杨斯博,李敏强,宗毅.新型科技成果评价方法的研究与实践[J].天津人学学报(社会科学版).2005(7):266-270
    [156]郑策.关于科技成果转化评价指标的思考[J].技术经济与管理研 究.2001(4):51
    [157]马胜杰.企业技术创新能力及其评价指标体系[J].数量经济技术经济研究.2002(12):5-8
    [158]孙细明,刘霞.企业技术创新能力的评价指标[J].企业天地.2003(10):101-103
    [159]傅毓维,杨贵彬,尹航.民技军用中技术评价指标体系的构建[J].科技进步与对策.2006(8):159-160
    [160]翟欣翔,越国杰.融入可持续发展观的技术评价指标体系构建[J].科学学与科学技术管理.2004(8):92-95
    [161]曹崇延,王淮学.企业技术创新能力评价指标体系研究[J].预测.1998(2)66-68
    [162]张国政,杨瑞海,梅志敏.技术创新能力评价指标体系及其模糊评判方法[J].科技进步与对策;2005(5):125-127
    [163]汤永林,阎立,冯俊文.R&D型企业技术创新能力测度模型[J].江苏商论.2005(8):152-155
    [164]李金海,张录法,魏彦莉.企业创新能力(度)分析与评估[J].河北工业大学学报.2000(12):55-59
    [165]王海威,朱建忠,许庆瑞.技术创新能力及其测度指标研究综述[J].中国地质大学学报(社会科学版).2005(9):26-29
    [166]王海霞,高平,刘家顺,初建宇.R&D项目影响因素的筛选及优化分析[J].科技进步与对策.2005(7):49-52
    [167]Flor M.L.and Oltral M.J.,Identification of innovating firms through technological innovation indicators:an application to the Spanish ceramic tile industry,Research Policy,2004,33(2):323-326
    [168]赵艳丽,顾基发.东西方评价方法论对比研究[J].管理科学学报,2000(3):87-93
    [169]周若鹏.创新与企业竞争力[J].科学管理研究.1999(4):10-12
    [170]谢福泉,任浩,李峰.财政R&D项目绩效后评估体系研究[J].财经论丛.2006(7):42-47
    [171]Hinloopen and Jeroen.,R&D efficiency gains due to cooperation,Journal of Economics,2003,80(2):107-125
    [172]Eric C.W.,R&D efficiency and economic performance:a cross-country analysis using the stochastic frontier approach,Journal of Policy Modeling,2007,29(2):345-360
    [173]Eric C.W.and Weichiao H.,Relative efficiency of R&D activities:a cross-country study accounting fox environmental factors in the DEA approach,Research Policy,2007,36(2):260-273
    [174]Sánchez,Angel M.,Pérez and Manuela,R&D project efficiency management in the Spanish industry,International Journal of Project Management,2002,20(7):545-561
    [175]窦艳,师萍.基于DEA的企业R&D投入绩效分析[J].工业技术经济.2006(5):63-65
    [176]吴和成.地区R&D相对效率评价科技管理研究[J].2005(1):54-56
    [177]张浩,孟宪忠.不同机构类型的R&D效率DEA评价与比较[J].科学学与科学技术管理.2005(12):78-82
    [178]于瑛英.我国区域R&D效率评价研究[J].经济论坛.2006(24):21-24
    [179]Roy Santanunu,Nagpaul P.S.and Mohapatra Patap K.J.,Development a model to measure the effectiveness of research units,International Journal of Operations and Production Management,2003,23(11):1514-1531
    [180]Szakonyi and Robert,Measuring R&D effectiveness-Ⅰ,Research Technology Management,1994,37(2):27-32
    [181]Szakonyi and Robert,Measuring R&D effectiveness-Ⅱ,Research Technology Management,1994,37(3):44-55
    [182]Quinn,James Brian and Mueller,James A.,Transferring research results to operations,Harvard Business Review,1963,69(1):49-66
    [183]Rubenstein,A.H.and Ettlie,J.E.,Innovation among suppliers to automobile manufacturers:an exploratory study of barriers and facilitators,R&D Management,1979,9(2):65-76
    [184]Foster,Richard N.,Linden,Lawrence H.,Whiteley,Roger L.,and Kantrow,Alan M.,Improving the return on R&D-Ⅱ,Research Management, 1985(28):13-22
    [185]Schmitt and Roland W.,The strategic measure of R&D,Research Technology Management,1991,34(6):13-16
    [186]McGrath,Michael E.,R&D effectiveness is increasing,Electronic Business,1998,24(6):19-20
    [187]Purdon and William A.B.,Increasing R&D effectiveness:researches as business people,Research Technology Management,1996,39(4):39-43
    [188]Foster and Ted M.,Making R&D more effectiveness at Westinghouse,Research Technology Management,1996,39(1):39-42
    [189]Grath M.,Michael E.,Romen and Michael N.,The R&D effectiveness index:a metric for product development performance,Journal of Product Innovation Management,1994,11(3):213-213
    [190]Teresa G.V.and Eva M.M.,Content validation of a measure of R&D.effectiveness,R&D Management,2005,35(3):311-331
    [191]汪应洛.系统工程理论方法与应用[M].北京:高等教育出版社.1998
    [192]应纪来,李炳军.解释结构模型在投入产出表结构分析中的应用[J].河南财政税务高等专科学校学报.2003(12):24-26
    [193]吴振奎.解释结构模型与层次分析法等的注记[J].天津商学院学报.1998(5):44-51
    [194]Cooper,W.W.,Seiford,L.M.and Tone,K.(eds.),Data Envelopment Analysis:A Comprehensive Text with Models,Applications,References,and DEA-Solver Software,Kluwer Academic Publishers,Boston,2000
    [195]魏权龄.评价相对有效性的DEA方法-运筹学的新领域[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社.1988
    [196]盛昭瀚.DEA理论、方法与应用[M].北京:科学出版社.1996
    [197]魏权龄.数据包络分析[M].北京:科学出版社.2004
    [198]吴文江.数据包络分析及其应用[M].北京:中国统计出版社.2002
    [199]Mark W.R.,Enhancing the balanced scorecard with scale-DEA,Washington State University,2003
    [200]郭奇,李亚.未确知测度模型在环境工程中的应用[J].河北建筑科技 学院学报.2001(6):44-47
    [201]王瑜.基于未确知测度的多目标决策方法及其应用[J].火力与指挥控制.2003(10):35-37
    [202]滕海文,霍达,夏明进.未确知有理数在结构可靠性分析中的应用[J].数学的实践与认识.2005(4):127-130
    [203]丁述理,贾东亮.未确知测度模型在膨胀土判别分类中的应用[J].辽宁工程技术大学学报.2006(12):861-863
    [204]王光远.未确知信息及其数学处理[J].哈尔滨建筑工程学院学报.1990(4):22-26
    [205]刘开第,吴和琴.不确定性信息数学处理及其应用[M].武汉:华中理工大学出版社.1998
    [206]Small I.and Swann P.,R&D performance of UK companies,Business Strategy Review,1993,4(3):41-51
    [207]模燕.区域R&D绩效评价[J].科研管理.2004(1):114-117
    [208]金虹博,吕本富.R&D绩效评及和平衡记分卡[J].应用研究.2004(5):35-38
    [209]陈伟,刘井建.基于多标准多目标线性DEA绩效评价研究[J].哈尔滨工程大学学报.2007(7):825-828
    [210]陈伟,刘井建.基于DEA的高新技术企业R&D绩效综合评价研究.科技进步与对策.2008(4)
    [211]梁文艳,胡咏梅.高校合并后科研效率动态变化的Malmquist指数分析[Z].中国教育经济学年会会议论文.2006
    [212]邓利方,余甫功.广东全要素生产率的测算与分析:1980-2004--基于面板数据的Malmquist DEA[J].广东社会科学.2006(5):39-44
    [213]张越,胡华清.基于Malmquist生产力指数的我国民用机场运营效率分析[J].系统工程.2006(12):40-45
    [214]吴丹,王娅莉.基于生产率指数的投入对制造业影响评价[J].管理学报.2006(9):580-585
    [215]程炜,陈湛匀,张爽.企业研发两面性与上海市生产率增长--基于DEA的Malmquist生产率分析[J].当代经济.2007(1):54-55
    [216]袁鹏,陈圻,胡荣.我国区域创新绩效动态变化的Malmquist指数分析[J].科学学与科学技术管理.2007(1):44-49
    [217]赵家敏,康鹏.对我国财产保险业生产率的评价与分析--基于Malmquist指数的研究[J].商场现代化.2005(11):81
    [218]王国顺,谷金花.湖南制造业全要素生产率变动的实证研究[J].统计与决策.2005(5):63-66
    [219]郭庆旺,张旭明,贾俊雪,肖建明.我国公共基础设施行业经济表现评估[J].中国人民大学学报.2005(2):70-75
    [220]Carlos P.B.and Calos A.,An empirical analysis of productivity growth in a Portuguese retail chain using Malmquist productivity index,Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services,2004,11(5):269-278
    [221]James Odeck,Identifying traffic safety best practice:an application of DEA and Malmquist indices,Omega,2006,34(1):28-40.
    [222]Jiing S.H.and Jui K.S.,Productivity changes of pulp and paper industry in OECD countries,1991-2000:a non-parametric Malmquist approach,Forest Policy and Economics,2005,7(3):411-422
    [223]Malmquist S.,Index numbers and indifference surfaces,Trabajos de Estatistica,1953,4(1):209-242
    [224]Fare R.,Grosskopf S.,Lindgren B.and Roos P.,Productivity change in Swedish pharmacies 1980-1989:A nonparametric Malmquist approach,Journal of Productivity Analysis,1992,3(3):85-102
    [225]Fare R.,Grosskopf S.,Norris,M.and Zhang Z.,Productivity growth,technical change and efficiency change in industrialized countries.American Economic Review,1994,84(1):66-83
    [226]陈伟,刘井建.基于DEA-Malmquist指数的企业创新效率变动研究[J].科技进步与对策.2008
    [227]陈伟,刘井建.电子行业15家上市企业的创新效率变动研究[J].统计与决策.2007(6):86-88
    [228]陈伟,刘井建.基于DEA-Malmquist指数的企业创新效率变动研究[J].科技进步与对策.2008(4)
    [229]聂辰席,聂玮.河北省各市工业竞争力的未确知测度模型研究[J].河北建筑科技学院学报.2005(9):1-3
    [230]曹庆奎,任向阳,刘琛,刘历波.基于粗集-未确知测度模型的企业技术创新能力评价研究[J].系统工程理论与实践.2006(4):67-72
    [231]刘开第,庞彦军,孙光勇.城市环境质量的未确知测度评价[J].系统工程理论与实践.1999(12):52-58
    [232]刘开第,庞彦军,姚立根.大气环境质量评价的未确知测度模型[J].环境科学.2005(21):11-15
    [233]李怀祖.管理研究方法论[M].西安:西安交通大学出版社.2004
    [234]卢纹岱.SPSS for Windows统计分析(第2版)[M].北京:电子工业出版社.2002
    [235]荣泰生.企业研究方法[M].北京:中国税务出版社.2005
    [236]黄铭芳.结构方程模式:理论与应用[M].北京:中国税务出版社.2005
    [237]马庆国.管理统计-数据获取、统计原理、SPSS工具与应用研究[M].北京:科学出版社.2003
    [238]Martin K.,Lars T.and Elfstrom B.O.,Measuring R&D productivity:complementing the picture by focusing on research activities,Technovation,2004,24(3):179-186
    [239]Grifell T.E.and Lovell C.A.K.,(1999) Profits and productivity,Management Science,45(9),1177-1193
    [240]安提·维尔.高科技企业成功的因素[J].发展研究.2001(6):17
    [241]童纪新,程书萍.基于绩效的企业研发文化建设[J].科技进步与对策.2004(12):96-97
    [242]龚艳萍,曾德明,张运生.基于绩效测度与控制的R&D团队治理机制研究[J].研究与发展管理.2004(2):17-23
    [243]唐晓华,唐要家,苏梅梅.技术创新的资源与激励的不匹配性及其治理[J].中国工业经济.2004(11):25-31
    [244]李俊霞.新兴技术企业的研发(R&D)人员管理[J].科技管理研究.2007(2):107-109
    [245]曾德明,张运生.高新技术企业内外部学习策略选择对R&D绩效影响 的比较分析[J].科学管理研究.2003(10):59-63
    [246]曾德明,张运生,陈立勇.高新技术企业内外部学习的契合机制研究[J].软科学.2003(6):93-96
    [247]杨德林,史海锋.R&D项目组知识创造影响因素的实证研究[J].科学学与科学技术管理.2005(7):92-96
    [248]赵晓庆,许庆瑞.技术能力积累途径的螺旋运动过程研究[J].科研管理.2006(1):40-46
    [249]杨洵,师萍.基于企业知识积累的研发人员激励[J].西安电子科技大学学报(社会科学版).2006(1):29-34
    [250]李南,田慧敏,邓丹.团队知识学习的网络建模及分析[J].中国机械工程.2006(11):2366-2369
    [251]田慧敏,李南,邓丹.弱连接在促进隐藏隐性知识转移中的作用[J].科技进步与对策.2005(6):18-20
    [252]王明安,彭培兰.隐性知识对企业技术创新研究开发(R&D)的作用[J].云南科技管理.2006(3):39-42
    [253]杜伟.完善R&D激励机制方略[J].财经问题研究.2004(3):47-50
    [254]龚艳萍,曾德明,张运生.基于绩效测度与控制的R&D团队治理机制研究[J].研究与发展管理.2004(2):17-23
    [255]岳春凤,邵庆,刘文秀.R&D部门员工绩效评价与激励机制设计[J].重庆工学院学报.2006(1):34-36
    [256]郭斌,王端旭.高技术公司R&D部门员工绩效评价[J].科研管理,2003,(2):23-25
    [257]陈海声,曹晓丽,钟琳.企业R&D人员的激励机制设计与业绩评价指标[J].企业经济.2006(8):40-42
    [258]王荣,武博.R&D与中国企业核心竞争能力[J].华东船舶工业学院学报(社会科学版).2001(3):1-7
    [259]任翔.技术创新的主要投入因素对创新成果的影响[J].数量经济技术经济研究.2001(11):19-22
    [260]梁莱欲.高新技术企业融资策略与方法[M].北京:经济科学出版社.2003
    [261]张玉明.资本结构优化与高新技术企业融资策略[M].上海:上海三联出版社.2003
    [262]陈海声.研究与开发项目投资风险与融资结构的相关性探微[J].财会月刊.2005(1):16-17
    [263]黄鲁成,陈曦.国外研发产业主体运行机制分析--以MR&D公司为例[J].科学学与科学技术管理.2006(5):10-14
    [264]郗永勤.企业技术创新的有效运行机制与途径[J].科学学与科学技术管理.2002(4):32-36
    [265]Fernand M.,The economic impact of Canadian university R&D,Research Policy,1998(27):677-687
    [266]Alfreso D.M.and Erasmo P.,R&D and the growth of firms:empirical analysis of a panel of Italian firms,Research Policy,2003(32):1003-1014
    [267]Francesco A.and Paola C.,R&D spillovers and productivity growth:evidence from Italian manufacturing microdata,Applied Economics Letters,2005(12):625-631
    [268]胡宝民,于新凯,王丽丽.地方政府R&D投入对经济增长影响的DEA 分析[J].科技进步与对策.2005(2):121-123
    [269]李志宏.R&D、R&D溢出、内生增长和内生收敛[J].当代经济科学.2006(1):1-11
    [270]汪荣敏,任静.R&D的经费投入与经济增长关系的实证研究[J].学术研究.2006(9):84
    [271]刘丹鹤,杨舰.R&D投入、经济增长与科技管理[J].科学学与科学技术管理.2006(9):14-18
    [272]程华,陈贤平.国外激励企业R&D的财政政策趋势研究[J].科学学与科学技术管理.2006(3):32-35
    [273]张洁,苏多坚.美、日、德促进活动的比较研究[J].研究与发展管理.2006(4):97-103

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700