摘要
本文根据汽车外覆盖件上经常出现的表面凹陷与畸变的产生特点,设计了壹套包含四种反拉延形状的冲压试验模具,用来分析表面凹陷与畸变产生的规律及机理。同时为了监测表面缺陷产生时,在试件“A”表面上产生缺陷区域的应变及位移变化规律,本文设计了两套测量系统,即在线适时测量应变与位移的动态测量系统与静态测量系统。通过冲压试验,在本文所设计的冲压试件“A”级表面上,成功地复制了汽车外覆盖件上经常产生的表面凹陷与畸变的缺陷。通过对试验结果与数值仿真结果的分析,研究了反拉延形状的三种特征尺寸变量对表面凹陷与畸变的影响规律,分析了冲压试件在成形过程中试件“A”级表面上应力分布及变化趋势,研究了表面凹陷与畸变产生的机理。
0.Preface
Fierce market competition has driven automotive manufacturers to improve the quality of their cars and trucks in every aspect The Class "A" surface,i.e.the exposed surface of a vehicle's outer panel,determines the appearance of the vehicle and needs to be clean. However,many defects such as die mark,draw line,skid line,loose metal,surface low, distortion,etc are frequently introduced into the Class "A" surface during the manufacturing process.In plants,time-consuming and costly die rework and manual panel finishing are required to clean up these defects.Among them,the surface distortion and skid line are the two most challenging problems,and difficult to resolve in physical tryouts.Up to date the origins of these defects have not been well understood.These two categories of surface defects can be generated in draw die operations or trim/flange die operations.Surface low and distortions are surface irregularities that deviate from the nominal design.The deviation may be caused by incomplete forming,insufficient stretching,buckling in the panel,or spring-back.The resolution of surface distortion can be achieved by revising product design or die development(binder,addendum and draw bead),or through adjusting binder travel and binder pressure etc.However,without a clear understanding of the root cause,all these remedies can only be performed on a trial-and-error basis.
In this paper our study was based on the project of National Natural Science Funds "the basic theory,calculation method and key technique of stamping and die design" and General Motor Grant "investigate and correct class "A" surface defects through experiments(draw die related surface low and distortion)".We designed a serious of experiments dies which represented the surface distortion and low of auto panel.Moreover,we also designed dynamic and stable measuring system.We analyzed the root-cause and mechanism of surface distortion based on stamping tests and numerical simulation.
1.Technical details of the experiment die
We designed experimental dies containing representative automobile outer panel product features that usually cause surface low and distortion.Prior to designing the dies,we collected and reviewed the typical product features in automotive outer panels.The geometry of a typical depression feature can be described by five design variables: Depression Depth(H),Upper Sectional Radius(R_U),Lower Sectional Radius(R_L),Plan View Radius(R_P) and Plan View Angle(α_p).The values of the five design variables vary from part to part.In practice,however,only the Plan View Radius Rp,Plan View Angleα_P and Depth H vary in a wide range.For example,the plan view angle can be anywhere from 60°to 240°.The upper sectional radius R_U and lower sectional radius R_L do not vary as much. In our design of the experiment,for simplicity,we considered variation of Rp,α_P and H while keeping R_U and R_L constant.To reduce material and construction costs through utilizing common die components,we made die inserts for these product features.The plan view angle of each insert takes one of four values(α_P=60°,90°,120°,240°) and the plan view radius has four variations(R_P=10mm,20mm,30mm,40mm) in each insert(exact values to be determined).There different depression depths have been experimented.
2.Stamping test and numerical Simulation
We did stamping test of the four different redrawing characters.The surface defects can be seen around the corner of finish panels after fiction of oilstone.The preliminary tryout on these experimental dies was carried using CR4 steel,a typical material for exterior panels. Various static measurements and dynamic measurements were performed.The measurement results have shown that the designed experimental dies successfully replicated the surface distortion phenomena,which are very common in automotive surface panels.These results suggested the experimental dies,which we designed can replicate the surface defects phenomena,which are very common in automobile's outer panel.
3.Correct test correct simulation of surface defects
We designed three types of test and simulations calculations about correct solution for the surface distortion.The first method was no gap between die and panel after stamping. The results of simulation and examination showed that the surface low has been improved but there was still micro-distortion on the die.The surface distortion can be removed by the second correct solution according the results of experiment and simulation.We only did the simulation of the third solution,and the simulation results showed the low and distortion reduced obviously.
引文
[1]胡平,王成国,庄茁.KMAS软件系统与冲压模具虚拟制造技术[C],虚拟工程与科学,(中国科协青年科学家论坛)文集,2001年5月,北京.
[2]胡平.大型覆盖件冲压成形CAE软件系统,《走向21世纪的中国力学》,中国科协第九次“青年科学家论坛”报告文集[R],清华大学出版社,1996.
[3]胡平,柳玉起,李运兴.板材成形缺陷及其数值仿真[J],应用基础与工程科学学报,7卷1期,1999:39.
[4]胡平,连建设,李运兴.弹塑性有限变形的拟流动理论[J].力学学报,26(3),1994.
[5]申国哲,胡平,王锦程.改进的速度迭代弹塑性大变形动力半显式算法[J].固体力学学报,2003年,24卷,4期:463-468.
[6]阮雪榆.21世纪数字化塑性成形技术与科学[J].模具技术,2003(2):3-8
[7]林忠钦.车身覆盖件冲压成形仿真[M].北京:机械工业出版社,2004
[8]李顺平,李硕本.盒形件冲压成形的有限元模拟的研究[J].锻压技术,1991,6:15-20
[9]邓陟.金属板料压延过程的数值计算分析[J].机械工程学报,1989,25:33-40
[10]董湘怀.轴对称及三维金属板料成形过程的有限元模拟[D].武汉:华中理工大学博士学位论文,1991
[11]徐康聪.汽车车身覆盖件成形过程的计算机数值分析与应用研究[D].长沙:湖南大学博士学位论文,1995
[12]Coubough G J,Matlock D K,Tyne C J Van.Formability of type 304 stainless steel sheet[J].SAE Trans of Material & Manufacturing,1993,No.930814:968-978
[13]C Weidemann.The blankholder action of drawbeads[C].In:Preceedings of 10th biennial IDDRG congress,1978.79-85
[14]钟志华,李光耀.薄板冲压成形过程的计算机仿真与应用[M].北京:北京理工大学出版社,1998
[15]P.Hu,H.P.Liu,Y.Q.Liu,Numerical study on flanging and spring-back of stamped thick metal plate[J].ACTA MECHANICA SOLIDA,Vol.14,No.4,2001.
[16]吴诗淳,何声健.冲压工艺学[M].西安:西北工业大学出版社,1987
[17]毓勋.板料与型材弯曲回弹控制原理与方法[M].北京:国防工业出版社,1990
[18]陈炎嗣,郭景仪.冲压模具设计与制造技术[M].北京:北京出版社,1991
[19]Hiroshi Kimura,Takahiko Ogura,Kinoshita Masayuki et al.Effect of Microstructures on formability in hot rolled high strength steel sheets[J].SAE Trans of Materials & Manufacturing,1993,No.930283:393-402
[20]Itami Atsushi,Koyama Kazuo,Ishii Yoshi et al.Extremely formable cold rolled sheet steel with ultra-high Lankford and n values-metallurgy and formabilities[J].SAE Trans of Material & Manufacturing,1993,No.90783:877-885
[21]Shirasawa H,Mimura K,Yokio T,et al.Formabiliy of TS590 N/mm2 "Tri-phase"hot rolled steel[J].SAE Trans of Material & Manufacturing,1993,No.930284:403-408
[22]Shi Ming F,Meuleman David J.An evaluation of interface friction in different forming models for coated steel sheets[J].SAE Technical Paper Series,No.920633:135-142
[23]Andy P Lee,Materman Neil.The development of a channel test for evaluating galvanneal flaking performance[J].SAE Trans of Material & Manufacturing,1993,No.930813:962-967
[24]胡轶敏.桑塔纳2000型车侧框冲压成形过程的仿真与试验研究[D].汽车工程,1999,6
[25]Keeler Stuart P.Circular gird system-a valuable aid for evaluating sheet metal formability[J].SAE Trans,1968,No.680092:371-379
[26]Goodwin Gorton M.Application of strain analysis to sheet metal forming problems in the press shop[J].SAE Trans,1968,No.680093:380-387
[27]Thompson R.The LDH test to evaluate sheet metal formability-final report of the LDH committee of the North American Deep Drawing Research Group[J].SAE Trans of Materials & Manufacturing,1993.No.930815:979-989
[28]Narasimhan K,Miles M P,Wagoner R H.A better sheet-formability test[M].In:Proc of NUMISHEET'93 Numerical Simulation of 3-D Sheet Metal Forming Processes Verification of Simulation with Experiment.Tokyo,1993.385-394
[29]Alejandro F G,Izworski Norbert.Industrial implementation of practices for LDH stability[J].SAE Trans of Materials & Manufacturing,1993,No.930816:990-995
[30]Wilczynski J S,Gregoire C A,The effects of die materials and electro-etching on frictional characteristics of automotive sheet steels[J].SAE Trans of Material &Mamufacturing,1992,No.920635:535-543
[31]Havvranek.Wrinking limiting of Tapered pressing[J].JAust Inst Met 1975,20(2):114-119
[32]L fratini,F Micari.Investigation effective blankholder force paths to improve the maximum component height in deep drawing process[M].Numisheet'99
[33]S Yossifon,K Sweeney,M Ahmetoglu and T Altan.On the acceptable blank-holder force range in the deep-drawing process[J]. Journal of Materials Processing Technology,1992(33): 175-194
[34] M A Ahmetoglu, A Coremans, G L Kinzel and T Altan. Improving drawability by using variable blank holder force and pressure in deep drawing of round and non-symmetric parts[J]. SAE Trans of Materials & Manufacturing, 1993, No.930287
[35] S Thiruvarudchelvan, F W Travis et al. On the deep drawing of cups with punch and blank-holder forces proportional to a hydraulic pressure[J]. Journal of Materials Processing Technology, 1999, 88:92-93
[36] Y Hirose, Y Hishida, T Furubayashi et al. Research on techniques for controlling body wrinkling by controlling the blank holding force[C]. Proceedings of the fourth Symposium of the Japanese society for technology of plasticity. Tokyo, 1990
[37] Yu-wei Wang, S Ali Sacedy, S A Majlessi and J E Beard Strain path effects on the modified FLD caused by variable blank holder force[J]. SAE Trans of Material &Manufacturing, 1995, No.950695:522-531
[38] Lars Gunnarsson, Nader Asnafi, Erik Schedin. In-process control of blank holder force in axisymmetric deep drawing with degressive gas springs[J], Journal of Materials Processing Technology, 1989(73), 89-96
[39] R Kergen, P Jodogne. Computerized control of the blankholder pressure on deep drawing presses[R]. Society of Automotive Engineers technical paper, No.920433,Warrendale, PA, 1992
[40] R Kergn. Closed loop control of blankholder force based on deep drawing parameters: its laboratory and industry applications[C]. IDDRG 1993, International Deep Drawing Research Group Working Group, Linz, Austria, 1993
[41] Azunari Kiril, M Shinabe, Y Hirabayshi and M Akiyama. Binding force control of uni-pressure cushion in automobile panel stamping[J]. SAE Trans of Material & Manufacturing, 1995, No.950916:845-849
[42] J M Van der Hoeven, C D eMare, K Lundgren et al. Avoiding surface deflections on an automobile rear fender[C]. International Deep Drawing Research Group Working group 1,Pisa, Italy 1991
[43] K Kirii, M Shinable, Y Hirabayashi et al. Binding force control of uni-pressure cushion in automobile panel stamping[R]. Society of Automotive Engineers Technical Paper,No: 950916, Warrendale. PA, 1995
[44] K W Blumel, G Hartmann, P Heldbuchel. Computer driver variable blandholder[C].International Deep Drawing Research Group Working group 1, Pisa, Italy, 1991
[45]M Ahmetoglu et al.Improving drawbility of round and non-symmetric part[C].Society of Automotive Engineers Technical Paper,1993,No930287
[46]D H Lloyd.Sheet metal industry[M],1966,43:434
[47]P Chabrand,F Dubois,JC Gelin,Modeling drawbeads in sheet forming[J].International Journal of Mechanical Science,1996,38(1)59-77
[48]H L Cao,C Teodosiu.Numerical simulation off drawbeads for axisymmetric deep-drawing process[C].Numerical method in industrial forming processed,1992.439-448
[49]John A Schey.Geometric factors affecting results form the drawbead simulation(DBS) test[J].Journal of the society of tribologists and lubrication engineers.1993.6:255-260
[50]P.Hu,Y.Q.Liu and J.C.Wang,Numerical study of the flange earring of deep-drawing sheets with stronger anisotropy[J].Int.J.Mech.Sci.,Vol.43,No.1,2001:279-298.
[51]C Weidemann.The blankholder action of drawbeads[C].In:Proceedings of 10th biennial IDDRG congress,1978.79-85
[52]N M Wang.A mathematical model of drawbead forces in sheet metal forming[J].Journal of applied metal working,1982,2(3):193-199
[53]R Hill.A theory of the yielding and plastic flow of anisotropic metals[C].Proc Roy Soc.London,A193,1948.193-281
[54]H D Nine.Drawbead force in sheet metal forming.In:Koistinen D P,Wang N M,etc.Mechanics of sheet metal forming[C].New York:Plenum Press,1978.179-211
[55]H D Nine.New drawbead concepts for sheet metal forming[J].Journal of applied metal working,1982,2(3):185-192
[56]H D Nine.The applicability of coulomb's friction law to drawbeads in sheet metal forming[J].Journal of Applied Metal Working,1982,2(3):200-210
[57]N.M.Wang and B.Budiansky.Analysis of sheet metal stamping by a finite-element method[J].J.App.Mech.,1978(45):73-82.
[58]N.M.Wang and S.C.Tang.Analysis of bending effects in sheet forming operations[C],Proc.NUMIFORM'86 Conf.,1986:71-76.
[59]N.M.Wang,A rigid-plastic rate-sensitive finite element method for modeling sheet metal forming processes[J].Proc.Num.Analysis Form.,Eds Piftman JFT,Zienkiewicz O C and et al.,John Wiley and Sons,1984:117-164.
[60]杨玉英.大型薄板成形技术[M].北京:国防工业出版社,1996
[61]Shuhui Li,Youxia Bao,Zhongqin Lin.An improved equivalent drawbead model and its application[J].Journal of Material Processing Technology,2002.121
[62]包文霞.车身覆盖件冲压成形中拉深筋的优化设计方法研究[D].上海交通大学博士学位论文,2000
[63]F C Chen,J H Liu.Analysis of an equivalent drawbead model for the finite element simulation of a stamping process[J].International journal of maching tools and manufacture,1997,37(4):409-423
[64]B D Carleer,M EM Louwes,J Huetink.Modeling drawbeads in 3D finite element simulation of the deep drawing process[R].Simulation of material processing:theory,methods and application,1995,681-684
[65]T Menders,H J M Geijselaers,H Huetink.Implementation of plastic thickness strain in an equalent drawbead model based on a penalty constraint method[R].Simulatiion of materials processing:therry,methods and applications,1998.911-916
[66]梁炳文,孙孝戴,王志恒.板金成形性能[M].北京:机械工业出版社,1999
[67]邓陟,王先进,陈鹤峥.金属薄板成形技术[M].北京:兵器工业出版社,1993
[68]李尧臣.金属板料冲压成形的有限元模拟[J].力学学报,1995,27(3):351-364
[69]Ishigaki,H okamoto:Analysis of growth and disappearance of surface deflection in press forming of large-sized autobody panels[J].International Journal of Vehicle Design,6(2):240-256,1985
[70]Shimomura,Yoshida T.:Study of surface deflection in door outer panel[C].13th Biennial Congress-International Deep Drawing Research Group:Efficiency in Sheet Metal Forming,1984 Sponsored by:Int Deep Drawing Research Group,46-53,1984
[71]Satoh,Taichi:Study of the growth mechanism and removal techniques of surface deflection observed in autobody outer panels[C].13th Biennial Congress-International Deep Drawing Research Group:Efficiency in Sheet Metal Forming,1984 Sponsored by:Int Deep Drawing Research Group,54-61,1984
[72]Anderson,A.,Evaluation and visualization of surface defects-a numerical and experimental study on sheet-metal parts[C].NIMISHEET 2005 Conference Proceedings,AIP,pp.113-118,2005
[73]Park,C.D.,Chung,W.J.and Kim,B.M.,A numerical and experimental study of surface deflections in automobile exterior panels[J].Journal of Materials processing Technology,187-188:99-102,2007
[74]Yoshida,K.,Hayashi,J.,Niyauchi,K.,Hirata,M.,Hira,T.and Ujihara,S.,Assessment of fitting behaviour and shape fixation by Yoshida Buckling Test - a way to overall formability[C].International symposium on new aspects of sheet metal forming ISIJ, Tokyo,Japan,125-148,1981
[75]Yoshida K.Purpose and feature of Yoshida buckling test(YBT)[J].Journal of the Japan Society for Technology of Plasticity.24:901,1983.
[76]Hisashi H.,Takeo N.:Recent trends in sheet metals and their formability in manufacturing automotive panels[J].Journal of Materials Processing Technology,46:455-487,1994
[77]Zhengchun Fu,Xiaoqiang Han,Ping Hu,Haipeng Liu.Numerical Study of the Auto Body Panel's Dent Resistance.International Conference on Enhancement and Promotion of Computational Methods in Engineering Science and Mechanics 2006.185-190
[78]Zhengchun Fu,Ping Hu,Haipeng Liu.Investigation on the numerical simulation of panel dent resistance by using finite element.Journal of plasticity engineering.2008vo1.15(5):136-141
[79]崔令江.汽车覆盖件冲压成形技术[M].北京:机械工业出版社,2003
[80]王勖成,邵敏.有限单元法基本原理与数值方法[M].北京:清华大学出版社,1997
[81]胡平,李春光,张向奎,基于扫描面的汽车覆盖件工艺补充设计[J],机械工程学报,V01.42,No.1,2006:117-120.
[82]胡平,刘海鹏,柳玉起,厚钣金件压弯翻边与回弹的数值研究[J],固体力学学报,Vol.23,No.1,2002:72-80.
[83]李春光,胡平,郭威,汽车覆盖件深拉延有限元仿真过程中的材料塑性与失效模型[J],吉林大学学报(工学版),2005,35卷3期:277-281
[84]E.Nakamachi,Computer aided simulation of sheet metal forming processes by thin shell finite element analysis[C].Proc.3rd ICTP,1990:1745.
[85]蒋友谅.非线性有限元法[M].北京工业大学出版社,1988.
[86]Balum T,Tang S C,Chappuis L Bet al.Application of mechanical methods to evaluation of forming and process design[J].SAE Trans of Materials & Manufacturing,1993.No.930521:727-733
[87]Nakamachi E.Development of FEA of sheet metal forming with arbitrarily shaped tools[J].Advanced Technology of Plasticity,1990,3:1128-1134
[88]Wang Chuantao,Wagoner R H.Square punch forming:section analysis and bending study[J].SAE Trans of Materials & Manufacturing,1991,No.710772:742-750
[89]Zhou D,Wagoner R H.Development and application of sheet-forming simulation[C].In:Proc of NUMISHEET'93 Numerical Simulation of 3-D Sheet Metal Forming Processes-Verification of Simulation with Experiment.Tokyo,1993.1-16
[90]Ni Chi-Mou.Stamping and hydroforming process simulation with a 3D finite element code[J].SAE Trans of Materials & Manufacturing,1994,No.940753:512-534
[91]Fukutomi Kouichiro,Maruyama Manabu,Kudo Masaru et al.Verification of finite element method applied to automobile body panels[J].SAE Trans of Materials &Manufacturing,,1993,No.930520:720-726
[92]唐荣锡.CAD/CAM技术[M].北京:北京航空航天大学出版社,1994
[93]郭春生,汤宝骏,孙继明.汽车大型覆盖件模具[M].北京:国防工业出版社,1993
[94]徐伟力,林忠钦,刘罡等.冲压仿真的现状和发展趋势[M].北京:机械工业出版社,2001
[95]李淑慧,林忠钦等.拼焊板在车身覆盖件冲压成形中的研究进展[M].北京:机械工业出版社,2002
[96]Mehta H S,Kodayashi S.Finite element analysis and experimental investigation of stheet metal stretching[J].Journal of Applied Mechanics,1973,40:874-880
[97]Iseki H,Jimma T Murota T.Finite element method of analysis of hydrostatic bulging of a sheet metal(Part 1)[C].Bulletin of The JSME,1974,12(112):1240-1246
[98]Schweizerhof,K.and Hallquist.J.O.VDI BERICHTE NR.,1991,894:405
[99]Schweizerhof,K.and Hallquist,J.O.Explicit integration schemes and contact formulations for thin sheet metal forming[J].VDI,BERICHTE,1991,894:405-439.
[100]Nakamachi,E.and Makinouchi,A.Development of process simulation system for autobody panel forming by using FE analysis and laser atercolithography techniques[C].17th Biennial Congress of IDDRG,1992:235-242.
[101]Belytschko,T.,Lin,J.L.and Tsay,C.S.Explicit algorithms for the nonlinear dynamics of shell[J].Comput.Meths.Appl.Mech.Engng.,1984,42:225-251.
[102]柳玉起.板材成形塑性流动规律及起皱回弹的数值研究[D],博士学位论文,吉林工业大学,1996
[103]Hill,R.The mathematical theory of plasticity[M].Clarendon Press,Oxford,1950.