关系契约与农产品交易稳定性研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
“公司+农户”作为一种在小规模生产基础上实现农业规模化经营的组织形态,通过龙头企业与农户间的长期稳定的契约关系,对合作剩余和风险的进行合理分配,能够解决“小农户”与“大市场”的联结问题,因而得到理论界的普遍认可和政府政策的广泛支持。实践中,这种组织模式虽不乏成功案例,但高违约率导致的农产品交易①契约的弱稳定性一直是农业产业化健康发展的主要障碍,提高契约稳定性是推动农业产业化发展的关键之一。
     提高农产品交易稳定性的根本在于农产品交易契约的选择和履约机制的优化。农产品交易高违约率的直接诱因是交易过程中双方的机会主义行为。但从根源上看,农产品交易弱稳定性源于交易中的高度不确定性(包括农户和企业面临的不确定性)②,而这种不确定性又源自于交易方的有限理性、信息不对称和信息不完全、双方交易地位(谈判力量)的不对称性,以及由此导致的机会主义行为。这种不确定性制约着交易剩余的实现及分配,从而影响农产品交易的稳定性。作为对不确定性进行适应的制度安排,关系契约是农产品交易的必然选择③。因此,不确定性到关系契约的逻辑自然成为研究农产品交易提升稳定性的基本出发点,而受制于第三方实施的困难,关系契约的自我实施机制是农产品交易治理的关键。
     基于上述考虑,本文以农产品交易的关系契约分析作为切入点,探讨农产品交易的稳定性问题,并尝试进行以下几个方面的研究:1)对农产品交易中的不确定性与相应的契约选择(关系契约)之间的逻辑关系进行分析,构建相应的契约模型;2)作为对不确定性进行适应的制度安排,关系契约仅给出农户和公司交易的一个简化框架,在交易环境发生变化时,交易剩余及其分配关系必然会发生改变,此时双方的争议不可避免。因而本文分析了关系契约中的争议解决机制问题;3)关系契约对农产品交易治理的基石是自我实施机制。本文分析了基于农户“风险厌恶”和“有限理性”假设下的农产品交易关系契约自我实施机制问题。4)通过问卷调查的数据,比较了支持不同专用性农产品交易的关系规范,并根据共性的关系规范,探讨基于互惠诱发信任农产品交易治理模式。
     具体来说,论文主要开展以下几个方面的研究工作:
     首先,识别农产品交易中可能存在的各种不确定性形式;分析这些不确定性的具体来源及其表现形式、对农产品交易产生的影响,以及农产品交易中的不确定性与相应的契约选择(关系契约)的逻辑联系。
     其次,将关系契约的相关理论及研究成果应用到中国农业产业化的具体实践中,在农户“风险厌恶”假设下,在Levin (2003)构建的模型的基础上,考虑农户关系专用投资、外部环境不确定性等因素,对其稳定契约的概念进行了修正,构建了基于事后保留收益等概念的关系契约模型,讨论了谈判能力及资产专用性对农产品交易关系契约结构和效率的影响。
     再次,比较了作为争议解决机制的正式价格契约和广义纳什谈判解(GNBS)各自的适用范围和局限。在分析正式固定价格契约对农产品交易治理的局限性的基础上,将广义纳什谈判解(GNBS)和正式价格契约引入到关系契约中,作为解决争议的途径,比较了二者在强化关系契约稳定性方面的功能,提供了一个解决重复交易下的双方机会主义问题的框架。
     最后,论证了基于重复博弈的契约自我实施机制在农产品交易中的局限性和非现实性,以及基于“关系规范嵌入性”的自我实施机制对我国农产品交易治理的现实性,并基于具体的调研数据,通过实证分析,寻找针对不同专用性农产品交易的关键关系规范,并据此提出基于互惠诱发信任的农产品交易关系治理思路。
     论文的创新之处主要体现在以下三个方面:
     ①本文在农户“风险厌恶”和“有限理性”假设下,基于农产品交易面临的不确定性到关系契约的逻辑关系的分析,考虑农户关系专用投资、外部环境不确定性等因素,构建了基于事后保留收益等概念的关系契约模型,讨论了谈判能力及资产专用性对龙头企业与农户间的关系契约结构和效率的影响,对稳定契约的概念进行了修正,从而拓展了Levin (2003)关系契约模型。并将广义纳什谈判解(GNBS)和正式价格契约作为交易争议解决机制引入到关系契约中,比较二者在促进关系契约自我实施的范围和条件,提供了一个解决重复交易下的双方机会主义问题的框架。现有文献注意到了关系契约对提升农产品交易契约稳定性的作用,但局限于对关系契约的特征、存在意义、关系规范的治理作用等层面的探讨。本文对农产品交易关系契约模型的构建、争议解决机制的探讨是对现有研究成果的深入和发展,具有创新意义。
     ②关系契约的本质在于可自我实施性。本文将关系契约自我实施机制归纳为基于重复博弈的机制和基于社会规范嵌入性的机制两类。在农户“有限理性”和“风险厌恶”假设下,论证了基于重复博弈的关系契约自我实施机制在农产品交易中的局限性,以及基于“关系规范嵌入性”的自我实施机制(社会学和管理学的视角)对农产品交易治理的现实性和有效性。国内现有文献侧重于对基于“重复博弈机制”的契约自我实施机制的探讨,对农户理性能力和风险态度的关注不足(这对农产品交易契约选择及自我实施至关重要)。因而,本文对农产品交易关系契约自我实施机制的探讨强化了关系契约的针对性和现实性。
     ③本文注意到了支持不同种类农产品契约的关系规范随着时间和情境而变化、发展,因而产生治理作用的关系规范因农产品类型的不同而不同,同一类农产品交易的关系契约也会随其所处的社会经济环境和参与者个体因素而发生变化,并根据专用性(外部选择大小)将农产品分为专用性较强和专用性较弱两类,并根据调研数据,比较支持不同专用性农产品交易的关系规范,为提升农产品交易稳定性提供了微观决策依据,据此给出了基于互惠诱发信任的农产品交易治理模型。现有多数相关文献从普遍意义上将关系规范的治理作用视为是固定不变。本文针对基于农产品专用性的探讨具有创新意义。
As an organization of scale business of agriculture under the condition of small-sized family production, the form of“Dragon Head Enterprise+Farmer”gained the supporting by the government’s policy and recognizing by the theoreticians because it facilitated the development of agricultural industrialization developing by linking the“small farmers”and“lagre market”together through the long lasting contract butweem Dragon Head Enterprise and farmers, and the reasonable allocating of exchange residuals and the related risks to the transaction. However, the weak stability of agricultural products transaction contract caused by high rate of contract breaching has long being the obstacle to the agricultural industrialization developing despite there were successful cases in practice, so upgrading the stability of transaction contract is the key to facilitate the development of agricultural industrialization.
     Upgrading the stability of transaction contract depends on contract choice and the optimizing of enforcing mechanism of contract. The high rate of contract breaching is motivated by the opportunistic behavior of the contract parties. This dissertation hold that the uncertainties in the agricultural products transaction①was the root of the weak stability of agricultural products transaction, the uncertainties in agricultural products transaction including the uncertainties that farmers and enterprises confronted with, which origined form“bounded rationality”of bargainers, asymmetric information, incomplete information and asymmetric station of bargainers (caused the asymmetric negotiation power). These uncertainties determined the stability of agricultural products transaction by restricting the achievement and allocation of exchange residuals.As an institutional arrangement to fit uncertainties, relational contract is inevitable for agricultural products transaction②. So the logic from uncertainties to relational contract is the logical starting point involuntarily, and due to the difficulty of the enforcing by the third party, the self-enforcement mechanisms of relational contract are the keys to agricultural products transaction governance.
     Accordingly, the agricultural products transaction relational contract is proper access to the research. This dissertation discuss the problem of weak stability of agricultural products transaction, and carry out the research including the following aspects: 1)Analysing the logic between the uncertainties in the agricultural products transaction and corresponding contract choice(relational contract), designing the corresponding model of contract;2)As the the institutional arrangements, relational contract give a terse framework of agricultural products transaction. The achievement and allocation of exchange residuals changed with the circumstance of transaction, and the disputes are inevitably. The dispute-settlement mechanism of relational contract was discussed following; 3)the governance of agricultural products transaction by relational contract through the self-enforcing mechanism. The dissertation analysed the self-enforcing mechanism of agricultural products transaction relational contract under the hypotheses that farmers are risk adverseness and bounded rationality; 4)Cmpared the relational forms supporting the transaction of agricultural products with different specificity based on suvery data, and the model of agricultural products transaction governance mode based on trust induced by reciprocity are also gived.
     Concretely, the following aspects were researched in this dissertation.
     Firstly, the uncertainties and their exhibit forms existing in agricultural products transaction were distinguished and analysed, their impacts upon the agricultural products transaction was analysed, and the corresponding contract choice problem was concluded.
     Sceondly, under the hypothesis that farmers are risk adverseness, based on the model made by Levin (2003), and take the relational specific investment by farmers, and circumstance uncertainties and so on into account, applied the relational contract theory to the pratices of chinese agricultural industrialization developing, modify the concept of stationary contract, conceive agricultural products transaction relational model based on ex-post retained earnings, and the influnces by negociation power and specific assets on the structure and the effectiveness of relational contract were also analysed .
     Thirdly, the applying scope and limitedness of GNBS and the fixed-price contract as the dispute-settlement mechanisms were compared. On the base of analyses the limitedness of fixed-price contract in agricultural products transaction, GNBS and the fixed-price contract were induced into the relational contract as the dispute-settlement mechanisms, and their function of enhancing the stability of relational contract, and their applying scope and limitedness were compared. So, a framework of settling the opportunism behaviors under repeat transaction was set up.
     Lastly, the limitation and fabulosity of self-enforcing mechanism based on repeated geme in governing the transaction of agricultural products is analysed. While the self-enforcing mechanism based on“relational forms embedness”can be the choice of governance of agricultural products transaction in China consequentially. An factor analysis based on the survey data to acquire the the critical relational forms supporting different sorts of agricultural products transaction were given, and the governance mode based on the trust inspired by reciprocity were given.
     In conclusion, the innovation of this dissertation can be summarized three aspects:
     ①Under the hypotheses of“risk averseness”and“bounded rationality”, and the basic of the logic of the uncertainties in agricultural products transaction, the dissertation designed the agricultural products transaction relational contract models based on ex-post retained earnings considering specific investment by farmer ande the uncertainties of surroundings confronted with farmer. The impacts on the structure and efficiency of relational contract by negotiation power and the specialty asset were analysed the concept of Stationary Contracts was modified, so the model conceived by Levin (2003) was developed.The dissertation also inducted the GNBS and formal fixed-price into the relational contract as the approaches to settle disputes, analysed their functions to strengthen the self–enforcement of relational contract, and their applied ranges and pre-conditions to strengthen the self–enforcing of relational contract, so a framework to settle the problem of opportunism was given. The existing related literatures noticed the stability-upgrading function of relational contract, whereas, they are focused on the analyses of the character, the significance, the relational forms’governance function, and so forth. The re-designingof the model of relational contract and the analyses of dispute settlement mechanisms have deepened and developed the researches of the existing literatures.
     ②The self–enforcement is the foundation of governance of agricultural products transaction by relational contract. The dissertation sorted the self–enforcement mechanisms of relational contract into two types, one is based on repeated game, the other is based on“social forms embedness”. Under the hypotheses of“risk averseness”and“bounded rationality”, the dissertation analysed the limitedness of mechanism based on repeated game ( in the view of economics), and the realism and validity of mechanism based on“social forms embedness”. The existing related literatures emphasized particularly on the mechanism based on repeated game, and did not paid enough attention to the farmers’rationality ability and attitude to the risk (which are critical to the chontract choice of agricultural products transaction). The probing into the mechanism of governance of agricultural products transaction by relational contract in this dissertation have strengthened the pertinency and reality of relational contract.
     ③The dissertation noticed the fact that critical forms supporting different sorts of agricultural products transaction changed and developed with circumstance, that is, the forms governing agricultural products transaction changed with the agricultural products sort, even the forms governing same type of agricultural products changed with the social and economic circumstance and the parties’individual factors. The datas for analyzing is sort into two types according to agricultural products’s specificity(the range of outside choice), so the key forms supporting different sorts of agricultural products are acquired as the gists to upgrade the stability of agricultural products transaction, and the model of agricultural products transaction governance based on trust inspired by reciprocity are also gived. The existing related literatures take the function of governance of relational forms as fixed and universal, so the research of key forms supporting different sorts of agricultural products transaction is innovative.
引文
[日本]青木昌彦,周黎安译. 2001.比较制度分析[M].上海远东出版社.
    [美国]科斯.哈特,斯蒂格利茨等著, [瑞典]拉斯·沃因,汉斯·韦坎德编,李风圣主译. 2003.契约经济学[M].经济科学出版社.
    Macneil著,雷西宁,潘勤译. 2004.新社会契约论[M].北京:中国政法大学出版社.
    [美]迈克尔·迪屈奇著,王铁生,葛立成译. 2000.交易成本经济学:关于公司的新的经济意义[M]. 经济科学出版社.
    [美]奥利佛.威廉姆森. 2008.交易成本经济学经典名篇选读[M].人民出版社.
    [美]克劳奈维根编,朱舟,黄瑞虹译. 2002.交易成本经济学及其超越[M].上海财经大学出版社.
    [南]斯韦托扎尔·平乔维奇著,蒋琳琦译. 2000.产权经济学:一种关于比较体制的理论[M].经济科学出版社.
    刘桂斌,刘勤著. 2007.产权经济学新论[M].人民出版社.
    喻卫斌. 2007.不确定性与网络组织研究[M].中国社会科学出版社.
    贾伟强. 2007.“公司+农户”组织模式的合作机制研究,江西人民出版社.
    帅萍. 2008.中美中小企业与供应商联盟比较.知识产权出版社.
    牛若峰. 1998.农业产业一体化经营的理论与实践[M].北京:中国农业科技出版社.
    徐忠爱. 2007.公司和农户契约选择与履约机制研究,中国社会科学出版社.
    宋洪远等. 2000.改革以来中国农业和农村经济政策的演变[M].中国经济出版社.
    刘东. 2003.公司网络论[M].中国人民大学出版社.
    郭红东. 2005.农业龙头企业与农户订单安排及履约机制研究——基于企业与农户行为的分析[D].浙江大学博士学位论文.
    黄少卿. 2005.经济转型中的合同执行[D].中国社会科学院博士学位论文.
    王艳慧. 2007.关系契约理论研究[D].黑龙江大学硕士学位论文.
    瞿珊珊. 2009.龙头企业与农户合作关系:治理,绩效与影响因素[D].华中农业大学硕士论文.
    安岗. 2007.关系交易,交易结构与经济绩效——东亚与中国经济解释的新视角[J].财经问题研究, 7: 33-39.
    本杰明.克莱因. 1999.契约与激励:契约条款在保证履约中的作用[J].载契约经济学,经济科学出版社: 184-204.
    陈灿,万俊毅,吕立才. 2007.农业龙头企业与农户间交易的治理——基于关系契约理论的分析[J].华中农业大学学报(社会科学版), 4: 42-45.
    陈悦明,葛玉辉. 2007.基于契约稳定性的农业产业化组织形式演进[J].商业时代, 23 :89.
    邓春平,毛基业. 2008.关系契约治理与外包合作绩效—对日离岸软件外包项目的实证研究[J].南开管理评论, 11 (4): 25-33.
    邓宏图,米献炜. 2002.约束条件下合约选择和合约延续性条件分析:内蒙古塞飞亚集团有限公司和农户持续签约的经济解释[J].管理世界, 12: 120-127.
    邓玉林,周海炜,张长征. 2010.基于关系契约的水利工程代建制激励机制研究[J].建筑经济, 3: 76-79.
    傅晨. 2000.“公司十农户”产业化经营的成功所在—基于广东温氏集团的案例研究[J].中国农村经济.2: 26-30.
    郭红东,楼栋,胡卓红,林迪. 2009.影响农民专业合作社成长的因素分析——基于浙江省部分农民专业合作社的调查[J].中国农村经济, 8: 24-33.
    郭晓鸣,廖祖君,孙彬.2006.订单农业运行机制的经济学分析[J].农业经济问题.11: 15-18.
    何亮,李小军. 2009.农业产业化经营中公司与农户契约稳定性分析[J].农村经营管理, 5: 12-13.
    黄洁. 2008.关系性契约及其治理机制述评[J].特区经济, 4: 255-256.
    黄祖辉,徐旭初,蒋文华. 2009.中国“三农”问题:分析框架、现实研判和解决思路[J].中国农村经济, 7: 4-11.
    黄祖辉,王祖锁. 2002.从不完全合约看农业产业化经营的组织方式[J].农业经济问题, 3: 28-31.
    霍学喜,毛飞,邵群. 2010.苹果种植户订单安排期望分析——基于陕西5个苹果主产县果农调查数据的分析[J].西北农林科技大学学报社会科学版, 1: 27-32.
    贾愚. 2009.再谈判与奶业契约稳定性分析商业财经[J].财贸研究, 2: 39-44.
    揭筱纹,里昕. 2007.产业链联盟视角下的农业产业化经营模式研究[J].软科学, 1 :55-58.
    林仲豪. 2008.系型契约的特征,内容及履约机制[J].改革与战略, 24(5): 9-11.
    李久鑫,郑绍濂. 2002.管理的社会网络嵌入性视角[J].外国经济与管理, 24(6): 2-5.
    刘东,汪德华,程雪垠,张捷.2003.论优于要素契约的商品契约[J].南京大学学报, 40(1): 23-31
    刘东,徐忠爱. 2004.关系型契约的特殊类型:超市场契约[J].经济理论与经济管理, (9): 54-59.
    刘莎. 2010.论经济法学的研究方法——从问题与主义出发[J].法制与社会, 2: 234-235.
    于开红. 2010.新制度经济学视野下的农业产业化经营——以“公司+农户”模式为例[J].中国商贸, 4: 202-203.
    马志雄,梁邦平. 2009.广东省农业龙头企业对农户带动效果研究——基于21市的截面数据实证分析[J].特区经济, 6: 34-41.
    孟枫平,尹云松. 2004.公司与农户间商品契约稳定性问题的进一步探讨[J].财贸研究, 6: 23-26.
    米运生,罗必良. 2009.契约资本非对称性、交易形式反串与价值链的收益分配:以“公司+农户”的温氏模式为例[J].中国农村经济, 8: 12-24.
    聂辉华. 2008.契约不完全一定导致投资无效率吗?——一个带有不对称信息的敲竹杠模型[J]. 经济研究, 2: 132-143.
    蒲勇健. 2007.植入“公平”博弈的委托——代理模型[J].当代财经, 3: 5-11.
    任旭,刘延平. 2010.基于信任观点的企业联盟治理机制演变机理研究[J].中国流通经, 3: 48-51.
    生秀东.2 009.订单农业的契约困境和组织形式的演进[J].中国农村经济, 12: 35-39.
    石淑华. 2009.论产权问题的几个认识误区[J].经济学动态. 1 :29-32.
    苏春艳. 2004.经济行动的社会建构——新经济社会学对经济行动的嵌入性分析[J].上海大学学报(社会科学版), 11(6) : 47-52.
    谭智心,孔祥智. 2009.新时期农业产业化龙头企业提供农业社会化服务的现状、问题及对策研究[J].学习论坛, 11: 44-47.
    汤洪源. 2008.公共服务民营化中的关系性契约——以美国廉租房民营化为例[J].宁波大学学报(人文科学版), (21)05: 91-96.
    万俊毅,彭斯曼,陈灿. 2009.农业龙头企业与农户的关系治理:交易成本视角[J].农村经济, 4 : 23-27.
    万俊毅. 2009.“公司+农户”的组织制度变迁:诱致抑或强制[J].改革, 1 :91-96.
    汪丁丁. 1995.从“交易费用”到博弈均衡[J].经济研究, 9: 77-78.
    王颖,王方华. 2007.关系治理中关系规范的形成及治理机理研究[J].软科学, 2: 67-70.
    王勇. 2002.完全契约与不完全契约两种分析方法的一个比较[J].经济学动态, 7: 22-26.
    王慧. 2005.“公司+农户”契约特点与履约障碍[J].经济视角, 11(B): 8-10.
    王志刚,李圣军,宋敏. 2005.农业收入风险对农户生产经营的影响:来自西南地区的实证分析[J].农业技术经济, 4: 46-50.
    吴秀敏,林坚. 2004.农业产业化经营中契约形式的选择:要素契约还是商品契约一种基于G-H-M模型的思考[J].浙江大学学报(人文社会科学版) , 34 (5): 13-19.
    吴德胜. 2008.农业产业化中的契约演进——从分包制到反租倒[J].农业经济问题, 2: 28-34.
    徐雪高,沈杰. 2010.订单农业履约困境的根源及发展方向——以黑龙江省某企业“期货+订单”为例[J].华中农业大学学报(社会科学版), 1: 45-49.
    杨明洪. 2002.农业产业化经营组织形式演进:一种基于内生交易费用的理论解释[J].中国农村经济, 10:33-38.
    杨光飞. 2009.家长式权威、关系契约和华人家族企业的组织成长[J].社会科学, 11 :41-47,188.
    杨其静. 2002.合同与企业理论前沿综述[J].经济研究, 1: 80-89.
    杨其静. 2005.企业与合同理论的新阶段:不完全合同理论——兼评Hart的企业,合同与财务结构[J].管理世界, 2: 162-171.
    易法敏,文晓巍. 2009.新经济社会学中的嵌入理论研究评述[J].经济学动态, 8 :130-134.
    尹云松,高玉喜,糜仲春. 2003.公司与农户间商品契约的类型及其稳定性考察——对5家农业产业化龙头企业的个案分析[J].中国农村经济, 8: 63-67.
    俞雅乖. 2008.农业产业化契约类型及稳定性分析——基于资产专用性视角[J].贵州社会科学, 218 (2): 99-105.
    臧得顺. 2010.格兰诺维特的“嵌入理论”与新经济社会学的最新进展[J].中国社会科学院研究生院学报, 1 :108-115.
    甄志宏. 2006.网络嵌入性到制度嵌入性——新经济社会学制度研究前沿[J].江苏社会科学, 3:21-28.
    张春勋. 2010.食品供应链中企业与农户短期合作交易契约设计[J].管理学报, 2:243-247.
    张春勋,刘伟,赖景生. 2009.基于GNBS和正式固定价格契约的农产品供应链关系契约模型[J]. 中国管理科学, 2: 93-101.
    张春勋. 2009.农产品交易的关系治理:对云南省通海县蔬菜种植户调查数据的实证分析[J].中国农村经济, 8:32-42.
    张闯,夏春玉,梁守砚. 2009.关系交换、治理机制与交易绩效:基于蔬菜流通渠道的比较案例研究[J].管理世界, 8:124-140,156,188.
    张闯,周洋,田敏. 2010.订单农业中的交易成本与关系稳定性:中间商的作用——以安徽某镇养鸡业流通渠道为例[J].学习与实践, 1 :30-37.
    张可成,王孝莹,李慧贞. 2006.我国农业产业化组织中契约制稳定性的博弈研究[J].山东科技大学学报(社会科学版), 8(3): 72-75.
    张肖虎. 2010.交易治理与经济效率:对威廉姆森经济思想的评述[J].云南财经大学学报, 1 :53-59.
    赵西亮,吴栋,左臣明. 2005.农业产业化经营中商品契约稳定性研究[J].农业经济, 3:42-44.
    赵晓飞,李崇光. 2007.“农户+龙头企业”的农产品渠道关系稳定性:理论分析与实证检验[J].农业技术经济, 5: 15-24.
    郑强国,李宁. 2005.农业产业化进程中公司与农户之间契约的稳定性研究[J].农村经济, 10: 33-35.
    周立群,邓宏图. 2004.为什么选择了“准一体化”的基地合约[J],中国农村观察, 20(3):2-11。
    周立群,曹利群. 2002.商品契约优于要素契约——以农业产业化经营中的契约选择为例[J].经济研究, 1 :14-19.
    Barzel Yoram. 2001. A Theory of the State:Economic Rights Legal Rights and the Scope of the State[M]. Cambridge University Press
    BewleyT F.1999. Why wage do not fall during a recession[M]. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
    Bolton, P. and Dewatripont, M..2005. Contract Theory[M]. The MIT Press.
    Brousseau Eric. Glachant, Michel.2002.The Economics of Contracts:Theories and Applications[M]. Cambridge University Press.
    Dore, R. 1987.Taking Japan Seriously[M]. Stanford University, Stanford.
    Eillis, F.1988.Peasant Economics[M]. Cambridge University Press.
    Ensminger Jean.1999.Making a Market: The Institutional Transformation of an African Society[M]. Cambridge University Press.
    Ensminger Jean.2004.Market Integration and Fairness: Evidence from Ultimatum, Dictator, and Public Goods Experiments in East Africa”in Cooperation, Reciprocity and Punishment: Experiments in 15 Small-Scale Societies[M], London: Oxford University press.
    Frank Cancian. 1980. Risk and Uncertainty in Agricultural Decision Making In Agricultural Decision Making: Anthropological Contributions to Rural Development[M]. Barlett, Peggy ed, Academic Press.
    Gambetta D.1993.The Sicilian Mafia: The Business of Private Protection[M]. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
    Grief Avner.1999.Genoa and The Maghribi Traders:Historical and Comparative Institutional Analysis[M]. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
    Macneil, I. R .974. The Many Futures of Contracts[M]. Southern California Law Review.
    North D.1990.Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance[M].Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
    Robert Ellickson.1991.Order without law; how neighbors settle disputes[M]. Cambridge, MA, Harvard University.
    Williamson Oliver.1985. The Economic Institutions of Capitalism:Firms, Markets, Relational Contracting [M]. Macmillan Free Press.
    A. Barkema. 1993.Reaching Consumers in the twenty-first century: the short way around the barn. [J]. American Journal of Agriculture. Econ,: 1126-1131.
    Akerlof, G A.1982. Laber conteacts as a partial gift exchange[J]. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 97 (4):543-569.
    Akerlof G A, Yellen J L.1988.Fairness and unemployment[J]. The American Economics Review,78(2): 44-49.
    Anderson E & Weitz BA.1989.Determinants of continuity in conventional industrial channel dyads[J]. Marketing Science,8:310-323.
    James C. Anderson and James A. Narus.1990. A model of distributor firm and manufacturer firm working artnerships[J]. Journal of Marketing,54(3):42–58.
    James E. Anderson.2006.Traders, cops and robbers[J]. Journal of International Economics, Elsevier, 70(1):197-215.
    A. Van de Ven, P. Ring, A. Zaheer, & R. Bachman.2006.Relying on Trust in Cooperative Inter- Organizational Relationships[J]. Handbook of Trust Research
    Barzel Yoram. 1998 .The State and the Diversity of Third Party Enforcers[M] . mimeo, University ofWashington.
    Bernheim B. D. & Whinston M. D. 1998 . Incomplete Contracts and Strategic Ambiguity[J]. American Economic Review , 88 (4): 902-932.
    Barr, Abigail and Pieter Serneels. 2004 .Wages and Reciprocity in the Workplace[W]. Workingpaper.
    Bardos et al. 2003.The Effect of Transzction Costs on the Structure of Total Supply Chain in Huangarian Beef Section[J]. Economics of Contract on Agriculture. 7:19-21.
    Beckmann, Volker and Boger, Slike. 2002.Contract Enforcement in Transition Agriculture Theory and Evidence From Poland[C], Annual Conference Paper of International Society for the New Institutional Economics, :27-29.
    Benjamin Klein & Andres V. Lerner & Kevin M. Murphy. 2002.he Economics of Copyright "Fair Use" in a Networked World[J]. American Economic Review, American Economic Association, 92(2):205-208.
    Berg, Joyce, John Dickhaut and Kevin McCabe. 1995. Trust, Reciprocity and Social History[J], Games and Economic Behavior, 10:122-42.
    Bogetoft, Peter and Olsen, Henirik. 2002. The Rules of Thumb in Contract Design:Lessons from Danish Agriculturep[J]. European Review of Agricultural Economics, 29(2): 185-204.
    Boger silke.2001. Quality and Contractal Choice:A Transaction Cost Approach to the Polish Hog Market [J], European Review of Agriculture Economics , 28 (3):241-262.
    Bradach J L, Eccles R G.1989.Price, Authority, and Trust: from Ideal Types to Plural Forms[J].Annul Reviews of Sociology, 15:97-118.
    Carpenter, Jeffrey, Stephen Burks and EricVerhoogen. 2004.Fairness and Freight-Handlers:A Test of Fair-Wage Theory in a Trucking Firm[W]. working paper. Claro , Danny Pimentel , Hagelaar , Geoffrey and Omta , Onno. 2003. The determinants of relational governance and performance : how to manage business relationship ?[J]. Industrial Marketing Management , 32:703– 716.
    David A. Hennessy.1999.The Taxpayer Relief Act, Estate Planning, and Resource Mobility in U. S. agriculture[J]. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 81(3): 534-543.
    Dixit, A. 2003.Arbitration and Information[W]. Working Paper, Princeton University.
    Doney, P. M, & Cannon, P. 1997. An Examination of the Nature of Trust in Buyer-Seller Relationships[J]. Journal of Marketing, 61 (2), 35-51.
    Doolin, B. , Dillon, S. , Thompson, F. , & Corner, J. L. 2005. Perceived risk, the Internet shopping experience and online purchasing behavior: A New Zealand perspective[J]. Journal of Global Information Management, 13 (2), 66-88.
    Dufwenberg, Martin, and Georg Kirchsteiger. 2004.A Theory of Sequential Reciprocity[J]. Game sandEconomic Behavior, (47)2: 268-298.
    Durlauf, Steven N. 2002. On the Empirics of Social Capital[J]. The Economic Journal, 112(483), 459-479.
    Dwyer, F. Robert; Paul H. Schurr; Sejo Oh. 1987. Developing Buyer-Seller Relationships[J]. Journal of Marketing, 51 (2):11-27.
    Dyer, J. H. 1997. Effective interfirm collaboration: How firms minmize transaction costs and maximize transaction value[J]. Strategic Management Journal , 18(7): 535-556.
    Emerson RM. 1962.Power-dependence relations[J]. American Sociological Review, 27 (2):31-41.
    Ernst Fehr, Simon Gachter, Georg Kirchsteiger. 1997.Reciprocity as a Contract Enforcement Device: Experimental Evidence[J]. Econometrica, 65 (4): 833-860.
    Falk, Armin and Urs Fischbacher.2006.A Theory of Reciprocity[J]. Games and Economic Behavior , 54(2): 293-315.
    Fehr E, Falk A. 1999. Wage rigidity in a incomplete contract market[J], Journal of Political Economy , 107(1):106-134.
    Fehr E, Schmidt KM.1999. A Theory of Fairness, Competition and Cooperation[J]. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 114(3): 817-868.
    Fehr E, Schmidt KM.2004.Fairness and Incentives in a Multi-task Principal-agent Model [J]. Scandinavian Journal of Economics . 106: 453-474.
    Fehr, Ernst & Kirchsteiger, Georg & Riedl, Arno. 1995. Gift Exchange and Reciprocity in Competitive Experimental Markets[w], Working Paper, Economics Series 14, Institute for Advanced Studies.
    Fehr E, Simon Gachter.2000.Fairness and Rataliation: The Economics of Reciprocity[J]. Journal of Economic Perspective, American Economic Association, 14(3):159-182.
    Fontenot, R. E. J. & Wilson, E. J. 1997. Relational Exchange: A Review of Selected Models for Prediction Matrix of Relationship Activities[J]. Journal of Business Research, 39(2), 5-12.
    Ganesan, S. 1994. Determinants of long-term orientation in buyer-seller relationships[J]. Journal of Marketing, 58(2):1-19.
    Ganovetter, M.1985. Economic Action and Social Structure: The Problem of Embeddedness[J] . American Journal of Sociology, 91(3): 481-510.
    Gary L. Frazier. 1999. Organizing and Managing Channels of Distribute[J]. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 27(2): 226-240.
    George Baker, Robert Gibbons & Kevin J. Murphy.2002. Relational Contracts And The Theory Of The Firm[J]. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 117(2):39-84.
    Grief Avner.1994.Cultural Beliefs and Organizations of Society: A Historical and Theoretical Reflection on Collectivist and Individual [J]. Journal of Political Economy , 102 (5):912-950.
    Grief Avner.2004.Impersona l ex change without impartial law;the community responsibility system[J] . Chicago Journal of International Law, 5(1): 107-136.
    Guth, W.1982.Schmittberger, R. , Schwarze, B. An experimental analysis of ultimatum bargaining[J]. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 3(4):376-388.
    Holmstrom B, Milgrom P.1991.Multitask Principal-Agent Analysis: Incentive Contracts, Asset Ownership, and Job Design [J]. Journal of Law, Economics and Organization, 7:24-52.
    Heide, J. B. , and John, G. 1992.Do norms matter in marketing relationships?[J]. Journal of Marketing, 56(2):32-44.
    Jarratt D & Morrison M. 2001.Dependence in major business relationships[W]. Working paper No. 9/01. School of marketing and management, Charles Sturt University, Bathurst.
    Karen Clay.1997.Tade without law:private-order institutions in Mexican California[J] . The Journal of Law, Economics & Organization,13(1):202-231.
    Kevin Zheng Zhou & Laura Poppo.2005.Relational Contracts in China:Relational Governance and Contractual Assurance[W]. working paper.
    Kirsten Foss and Nicolai J. Foss. 2000. Theory: Suppressing Margins and Entrepreneurship [J]. Journal of Economic Methodology, 7(3):313-339.
    Klein, Benjamin.1996.Why Hold-Ups Occur: The Self-Enforcing Range of Contractual Relationships[J]. Economic Inquiry, Oxford University Press, 34(3):444-463.
    Knack, S. and P. Keefer.1997.Does Social Capital Have an Economic Payoff? A Cross Country Investigation[J] . Quarterly Journal of Economics, 112(4):1251–1288.
    Kranton, R. and A. Swamy.1999.The Hazards of Piecemeal Reform: British Civil Courts and the Credit Market in Colonial India[J]. Journal of Development Economics, 58 (1 ):1-24.
    Levin.J.2003.Relational Incentive Contracts[J]. The American Economic Review, 93(3): 835-857.
    Levin.J.1999. Relational Contracts, Incentives and Information[D]. Dissertation, MIT.
    JS Li.2003.Relation-based versus rule-based governance:an explanation of the east asian miracle and asian crisis[J ] . Review of International Economics, 11 (4 ):651-673.
    Macaulay, Stewart.1963.Non-contractual relations in business: A preliminary study[J] American Sociological Review, 28(1), 55– 67.
    Milgrom. P, North. D, Weingast B.1990.The role of in stitutions in the revival of trade;the law merchant, private judges, and the champagne fairs[J]. Economics and Politics, 19 (1):1-23.
    Steven Y. Wu & Brian E.Roe.2007.Discretionary Latitude and Relational Contracting," IZA Discussion Papers 2879, Institute for the Study of Labor (IZA) .
    MacLeod, B. and Malcomson, J.1989.Implicit Contracts, Incentive Compatibility, and Involuntary Unemployment[J]. The Econometrica, 57(2):447-480.
    Macneil I. R.1978.Contracts: adjustment of long-term economic relations under classical, neo-classical and relational contract law[J]. Northwestern University Law Review, 72(6):854-905.
    Mentzer, J. T. , Min, S.& Zacharia, Z. G. 2000. The Nature of Interfirm Partnering in Supply Chain Management[J]. Journal of Retailing,76(4):549-568.
    Michael E. Sykuta Michael L. Cook. A.2001.New Institutional Economics Approach to Contracts and Cooperatives[W]. CORI Working Paper No. 01-04.
    Mohr JJ, Fisher R & Nevin JR.1996.Collaborative communication in interfirm relationships: Moderating effects of integration and control[J]. Journal of Marketing, 60 (3):103-117.
    Moorman C, Zaltman G & Deshpande R.1992.Relationships between providers and users of market research: The dynamics of trust within and between organizations[J]. Journal of Marketing Research, 29 (3):314-329.
    Morgan R. M. and Hunt S. D.1994. The Commitment-Trust Theory of Relationship Marketing[J]. Journal of Marketing,58 (3):20-38.
    Myoungki Lee, and Steven Wu.2005.Relational Contracts and Termination Damages[C], AAEA Selected Paper, AAEA Annual Meetings, Providence, RI. Nirvikar Singh.1997.Nash Bargaining with the Option to Wait[J]. Economics Letters, 55(1): 69-73.
    Oliver C.1990.Determinants interorganizational relationships: Integration and future directions[J]. Academy of Management Review,15(2):241-265.
    Oliver Hart & Bengt Holmstrom. 1987, The Theory of Contracts[M], Truman F. Bewley, Editor Cambridge University Press, 1987.
    Oriana Bandiera.2003.Land reform, the market for protection and the origins of the Sicilian Mafia; theory and evidence[J]. Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization, 19(1):218-244.
    Poppo L. Zenger T.2002.Do Formal Contracts and Relational Governance Function as Substitutes or Complements[J]. Strategic Management Journal,23(6):707-725.
    Rabin, Matthew.1993.Incorporating Fairness into Game Theory and Economics[J], The American Economics Review, 83(5): 1281-1302.
    Rachel E. Kranton.1996.Reciprocal Exchange:A Self-Sustaining System[J]. The American Economic Review,86(4):830-851.
    Richard E S.2000.The characteristics and challenges of relational contracts[J]. Northwestern University Law Review, 94(3):827-829 .
    Rogerson W.1985.The First-Order Approach to Principal-Agent Problems[J]. Econometrica, 53(6):1357-1368.
    Ryu S, Park J. E. & Min S.2007.Factors of determining long-term orientation in interfirm relationships[J]. Journal of Business Research, 60(12):1225-1233.
    Sérgio G.Lazzarini, Gary J.Miller,Todd R.Zenger.2004.Order with Some Law: Complementarity versus Substitution of Formal and Informal Arrangements [J]. The Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization,20(2):261-298.
    Simon H.A.1955. Behavioral Model of Rational Choice[J]. Quartly Journal of Economics, 59 :99-118.
    Simon H.A.1956.elationl Choice and Structure of the Enviroment[J]. Psychological Reviews, 63:129-138.
    Simon H.A.1964.n the concept of organizational goal [J]. Administrative Science Quarterly, 8:1-22.
    Smith KG,Carroll SJ & Ashford SJ. 1995.ntra-and interorganizational cooperation: Toward Toward a research agenda[J]. Academy of Management Review, 38(1):7-23.
    Stuart D.Frank, Dennis R.Henderson.1992. Transaction Costs as Determinants of Vertical Coordination in the U. S. Food Industries[J]. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 74 (4) : 941-950.
    Swedbergr, Granovetter M. 1992.The Sociology of Economic Life[C. Boulder : Westview. Tregurtha, N.L and N. Vink.2002 Trust and Supply Chain Relationship: a South African Case Study[C]. Annual Conference Paper of International Society for the New Institutional Economics, September:27-29.
    Uzzi, Brain.1997.Social Structure and Competition in Interfirm Networks: The. Paradox of Embeddedness[J] . Administrative Science Quarterly,42(1): 35-67.
    Williamson O. E.1979.Transaction Cost Economics: The Governance of Contractual Relations. Journal of Law and Economics, 22(10): 233-262.
    Williamson O. E. 2002.The theory of the firm as governance structure:from choice to contract[J]. Journal of Economic Perspectives,16(3):171-195.
    Wilkinson IF & Young LC.1989.The role of trust and co-operation in marketing channels: A Preliminary Study[J]. European Journal of Marketing, 23 (2):109-122.
    Woodruff C.2002.Establishing Confidence in Business Partners: Courts , Networks , and Relationships as Pillars of Support[W]. Working Paper.
    Xiaohua YU.2008.Dancing with the Dragon Heads:Enforcement, Innovations and Efficiency of Contracts between Agricultural Processors and Farmers in China[C]. American Agricultural Economics Association Annual Meeting, Orlando, FL, July:27-29.
    Zylbersztajn, Decio. 2003.Tomatoes and Courts: Strategy of the Agro-industry Facing weak Contract Enforcement[W].Worker Paper
    Zhang C.S.T. CavusgiL and A.S.Roath.2003.Manufacturer governance of foreign distributor relationships: Do relational norms enhance competitiveness in the export market?[J]. Journal of International Business Studies, 34 (6):550–66.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700