从系统角度研究现代经济组织的道德演变和道德建设
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
我国的改革开放已走过了三十年,我国的市场经济正在飞速发展并创造着日新月异的经济建设成果,但同时我国的道德建设正面临着许多严峻考验:许多领域的道德失范,企业或个人诚信缺失的不良现象仍普遍存在。不道德行为产生的不良后果将严重阻碍社会的发展和进步。进一步加强公民道德建设,改善社会道德风气具有突出的重要性和紧迫性。
     如何深刻认识现代社会经济系统中行为人的道德属性以及现代社会经济系统道德演变的规律,从而进一步深入认识不同阶段道德建设的关键,找到推进社会道德建设的有效切入点,变得越来越具有现实意义,这正是本文研究的主题。
     本文的研究工作始终是围绕着现代经济组织的道德演变和道德建设问题展开的,力图从系统科学的角度定量地研究不同道德属性的行为人对其所在经济组织其它行为人和道德环境的影响,并通过目前最先进的系统仿真工具深入探讨动态复杂经济系统的道德演变情况,发现现代经济组织的道德演变和道德建设规律,结合案例分析的方法对推演的理论结果进行验证,从而为现代社会和经济组织推进道德建设提供有借鉴意义的参考依据。
     本文以系统科学理论为指导,综合运用经济学、博弈论、Swarm仿真分析理论、可持续发展和网格化等多学科领域的最新研究成果,根据研究主题的需要,采用了“微观──宏观──微观”、“方法──方法论──方法”、“定性──定量──定性”、“理论──系统仿真──理论”的旋进研究模式。
     本文的主要内容是:
     首先,回顾并点评了古今中外经济学、伦理学、博弈论、管理学、生物学等多领域对道德行为研究的文献,指出了前人在定量地研究社会经济组织的道德演变和道德建设领域尚存在空白点,并引出了本文的研究主题。其次,对经济组织中不同道德属性的行为人进行了分类和定义,并构建了“由生产者和消费者构成的经济系统模型”、“多类型行为人构成的经济组织道德演变稳定性判据模型”及“道德污染对经济系统道德环境的影响模型”,通过对模型的定量分析和推演,获得了揭示道德演变和道德建设规律的重要结论。再次,构建了一个由多个A类(俗称“好人”)、B类(俗称“坏人”)、C类(俗称“普通人”)行为人组成的动态复杂经济系统,分析了不同道德类型行为人的初始人数占比对经济系统道德演变结果的影响,指出了经济系统的道德演变具有自组织性,并推演出了影响系统道德演变结果的临界点及其变化曲线,探讨了行为人作恶收益、行为人交往密度和行为人影响力这三个重要因素对道德演变自组织临界点的影响情况,从而得出了多个对道德演变和道德建设有意义的结论。最后,结合本文关于道德演变和道德建设的结论,从方法论的角度阐述了基于旋进原则的道德建设策略,分析了网格化管理对道德建设的重要意义,并对“一家大型企业集团通过实施集团化解决信用缺失问题的案例”和“淘宝网进行网络诚信建设的案例”进行了详细分析和点评,印证了经济组织的道德演变具有自组织性,网格化管理对降低道德建设难度和推动道德建设具有重要意义。
     本文的贡献和创新之处主要在以下3个方面:
     1.定量地研究了现代经济组织的道德演变和道德建设问题,指出了道德演变具有自组织性,并推演出了道德演变的临界点及其变化曲线。本文从系统科学角度,从分析不同道德类型行为人的行为演变入手,运用当前最先进的Swarm系统仿真工具构建了由多个A类、B类、C类行为人组成的动态复杂经济系统,提出不同道德类型行为人的人数占比和占比的变化即可代表系统的道德水平和道德演变的状况,经济系统的道德演变具有自组织性,并有多个影响道德演变结果的临界点存在。当A类行为人的初始占比超过临界点后,A类人将主导系统道德演变方向。行为人作恶收益、交往密度和行为人的影响力都是影响道德演变临界点的重要因素。
     2.提出了道德污染的概念,构建了道德环境建设可持续发展模型,得出了道德建设三要素。本文依据不道德行为如环境污染一样具有外部性的特点,将可持续发展理论对环境污染等问题的研究成果引入道德研究领域,提出了道德污染的概念,并构建了道德环境可持续发展模型,提出经济系统道德环境稳定与否和行为人对道德环境的质量要求高低、行为人对未来道德环境的重视程度以及道德环境监管的力度有关。在道德环境建设中,建立针对行为人的道德监控体系是基础,德治促成的合作态度是关键,法治建设是根本。三者之间相互影响,共同决定道德环境建设的效果。
     3.对道德建设进行了案例分析,提出了网格化管理可降低道德演变的临界点,对现代经济组织的道德建设具有重要意义。本文将网格化理论和旋进策略引入到了道德建设策略研究中,通过分析网格的特征,深入分析了网格化管理对现代经济组织道德建设的重要意义,通过对“一家大型企业集团通过实施集团化解决信用缺失问题的案例”和“淘宝网进行网络诚信建设的案例”进行分析,证实了本文理论的正确性,并揭示了网格化管理可降低道德演变的临界点,对道德建设具有重要意义。
China’s market economy is keeping fast development and creating extraordinary achievements as the thirty years’reform and opening-up. However, China’s ethical construction is facing severe challenge such as lack of moral regulation and short of enterprise and personal faith. Immoral behaviors will impede social development. So it is necessary and urgent to enhance citizen ethical construction and improve social moral atmosphere.
     It has real meaning to know about the people’s moral property and its development rule in modern social economic system. This has become the key to realize the internal entity of the ethical construction in different stages, and is the main topic for this dissertation.
     Research work of this dissertation is around the moral evolution and ethical construction in modern economy organization. Quantitative methods based on system science are used to study the affection of person’s moral property to others and moral environment. The moral evolution and construction laws of modern economic organization are found and verified by means of modern system simulation tools and case study after discussing the moral evolution status in dynamic complex economic system. The results of the dissertation could be supplied as basis to promote ethical construction for modern society and economic organization.
     The dissertation applies the updating research outcomes of economics, game theory, Swarm simulation theory, sustainable development theory and grid theory based on the system science. The spiral propulsion principle of research mode as“micro to macro to micro”,“methods to methodology to methods”,“qualitative to quantitative to qualitative”,“theory to system simulation to theory”has been used.
     The main contents of this dissertation are:
     Firstly, relative literatures in the field of economics, ethics, game theory, management and biology are reviewed. The blanket points in the research area of moral evolution in social economic organization by quantitative methods are presented. Then the main topic of the dissertation is showed. Secondly, persons of different moral property in economic organization are classified and defined.“Social economic model consists of producer and consumer,” “stability judgment model of moral evolution in economic organization composed by people of different types”,“model of affection of moral pollution to moral environment of economic system”are established. By means of quantitative analysis to these models, the important conclusions about moral evolution and ethical construction are gained. Thirdly, the dynamic complex economic system composed of many agents of A type (good people), agents of B type (bad people) and agents of C type (general people) is constructed. The affection of the initial number of persons of different moral types to moral evolution outcomes is analyzed and the self-organized property of moral evolution in economic system is pointed. The critical points and variation curve to affect the system moral evolution outcomes are deduced. The affection of person’s evil payoff, communicated density and its affection to the critical points of self organization in moral evolution is discussed. The meaningful conclusions to moral evolution and ethical construction are gained. Finally, ethical construction strategies and the meaning for grid management to ethical construction are proposed from view of methodology based on the above conclusions. Two cases of“solutions to the problem of short of faith for a large scale enterprise by means of grouping”and“network faith construction of Taobao.com”are analyzed. The results verify the self-organization property of moral evolution in economic organization and the important meaning of grid management to reduce the difficulty of ethical construction and promote it.
     The contributions and innovations of the dissertation are following:
     1. Moral evolution and ethical construction problems are studied quantitatively. The self-organization property of moral evolution, its critical points and variation curve are deduced. The dissertation applies Swarm system simulation tools to construct the dynamic complex economic system composed by many A, B and C types of agents from their behavior development based on system science. The conclusions that the number of persons and its ratio variation could represent the moral level and moral evolution in the system are made. The self organization property and many critical points affecting moral evolution orientation are gained. When the ratio of A type of agents exceeds the critical point, A type of agents will dominate the evolution of the system. The important factors to the critical points are persons’evil payoff, communicated density and ability of the impact to environment.
     2. The concept of moral pollution is proposed. The sustainable development model for moral environment construction is made and three main factors for ethical construction are gained. The dissertation believes that immoral behavior has external features as environment pollution. The research outcomes of sustainable development theory to environment pollution are introduced to the field of moral field. The concept of moral pollution is proposed. The sustainable development model for moral environment construction is made. Whether economic system moral environment is stable or not is related to the request to the quality of moral environment, attention to ethical construction and moral environment regulation. In the construction of moral environment, moral surveillance system is base, the corporation between moral and regulation is the key and construction of law is entity. These three aspects are affected with each other, and decide the outcomes of moral environment construction.
     3. Cases study of ethical construction is made. Grid management can decrease the condition of the critical points and has important meaning to ethical construction of modern economic organization. The grid management theory and spiral propulsion strategy are introduced to the ethical construction. The importance of grid management to ethical construction of modern economic organization is analyzed based on the features of grid. Two cases of“solutions to the problem of short of faith for a large scale enterprise by means of grouping”and“network faith construction of Taobao.com”are analyzed to verify the correctness of the theoretical conclusions of this dissertation. The importance of grid management to decrease the condition of the critical points of moral evolution and ethical construction is proposed.
引文
[1] A. Chervenak et al, 2000,“The Data Grid: Towards an Architecture for the Distributed Management and Analysis of Large Scientific DataSets”, Journal of Network and Computer Applications, 23(3), pp. 187– 200.
    [2] A. S. Grimshaw et al, 1994,“Legion: The next logical step toward a nationwide virtual computer”, Technical Report CS-94-21, University of Virginia.
    [3] Amartya Sen, 1987, On Ethics & Economics, Blackwell Publishers Ltd, pp. 6– 89.
    [4] Arrow, 1982, Risk Perception in Psychologe and Economics, Economic Inquiry, (20), pp. 67– 88.
    [5] Bergstrom, Theodore C. and Stark, Oded, 1993,“How Altruism Can Prevail in an EvolutionaryEnvironment”, American Economic Review (Papers and Proceedings), 83(2), May, pp. 149– 155.
    [6] Bergstrom, 1986,“On the Private Provision of Public Goods”, Journal of Public Economics, 29, pp. 25– 49.
    [7] Bester, Helmut and Werner Guth, 1998,“Is Altruism Evolutionarily Stable”, J. Economic. Behavior, Organization. 34, pp. 193– 209.
    [8] Chung K.H., 1981, Organizational Behavior, Harper and Row Publishers.
    [9] D.North, 1990, Institution,Institutional Change and Economic Performance, New York: Cambridge University Press.
    [10] D.North, 1987,“Institutions、Transaction Costs and Economic Growth”, Economic Inquiry, 25, pp.419– 428.
    [11] E.Dockner and V.Long, 1993,“International Pollution Control: Cooperative Versus Noncooperative Strategies”, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 24: pp. 13– 29
    [12] E.Elbasha and T.Roe, 1996,“On Endogenous Growth:the Implications of Environmental Externalities”, Journal of Environment Economics and Management, 31: pp. 240– 268.
    [13] Edgeworth Francis Y, 1994, American Economic Review, 84(3), June, pp.482– 497.
    [14] Edgeworth, Francis Y., 1981, Mathematical Physics, London: P. Kegan.
    [15] G.S.Amacher and A.S.Malik, 1996,“Bargaining in Environmental Regulation and the Ideal Regulator”, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 30(2), pp. 233– 253.
    [16] Grid Forum [EB/OL]. http://www.gridforum.org/, 2004.5
    [17] H. Kreger, IBM Software Group, Web Services Conceptual Architecture (WSCA 1.0) [EB/OL]. http://www-3.ibm.com/software/solutions/webservices/pdf/WSCA.pdf, 2001.11
    [18] H. Zhuge, 2002,“A Knowledge Grid Model and Platform for Global Knowledge Sharing”, Expert Systems with Applications, 22(4), pp. 313– 320.
    [19] H. Gradus and S. Smulders, 1993,“the Trade-off Between Environmental Care and Long– term Growth– pollution in Three Prototype Growth Models”, Journal of Economics, 58, pp. 25– 51.
    [20] Hammerstein, Peter and Selten, Reinhard, 1994,“Game Theory and Evolutionary Biology”, Chapter 28 in Handbook of Game Theory with Economic Applications, Vol. 2,edited by Robert J. Aumann and Sergiu Hart, Amsterdam: Elsevier, pp. 929– 993.
    [21] Hampton D.R., 1987, Organizational Behavior and the Practice of Management, Scott, Foresman Company.
    [22] I. Foster and C. Kesselman (Eds), 1998, The Grid: Blueprint for a New Computing Infrastructure, Morgan Kaufmann Publishers.
    [23] I. Foster and C. Kesselman, 1997,“Globus: A Metacomputing Infrastructure Toolkit”, International Journal of Supercomputer Applications, 11(2), pp. 115– 128.
    [24] I. Foster and C. Kesselman,“The Globus Project: A Status Report”, Proc. IPPS/SPDP '98 Heterogeneous Computing Workshop, pp. 4-18, 1998.
    [25] I. Foster, C. Kesselman, J. Nick and S. Tuecke, 2002,“Grid Services for Distributed Systems Integration”, IEEE Computer, 35 (6), pp. 37– 46.
    [26] I. Foster, C. Kesselman, J. Nick and S. Tuecke, 2002, The Physiology of the Grid: An Open Grid Services Architecture for Distributed Systems Integration, January.
    [27] I.Foster, C.Kesselman and S.Tuecke, 2001,“The Anatomy of the Grid: Enabling Scalable Virtual Organizations”, Journal of Supercomputer Applications, 15(3), pp. 200– 222.
    [28] J.D.Farmer, 1998,“Market force, ecology, and evolution”, santa Fe Inst, Working paper 98-12-117, SFI, Santa Fe, N.M..
    [29] Jake,[EB/OL]. http://www.swarmagents.com/javaclass/pdceluar.htm 2003.04.10.
    [30] Jeremy Bentham, 1970, An introduction to the prin ciples of morlas and legislation, London: athlone press, pp. 12– 254.
    [31] John O.S. Kennedy, 1995,“Changes in Optimal Pollution Taxes as Population Increase”, Journal of Environment Economics and Management, 28, pp. 19– 33.
    [32] Kivl Hamilton, 1995,“Sustainable Development,the Hartwick Rule and Optimal Growth”, Environmental and Resource Economics, 5, pp. 393– 411.
    [33] Kydland F., 1995,“Non-cooperative and dominant player solutions in discrete dynamic games”, International Economic Review, 16(2), pp. 321– 335.
    [34] L. Smarr, C. Catlett, 1992,“Metacomputing”. Communication of the ACM, 35, pp. 44– 52.
    [35] Levine, J. and L.B. Resnick, 1993,“Social Foundations of Cognition”, Annual Review of Psychology, 44, pp. 585– 612.
    [36] Lyster Petal, 1992,“CASA Gigabit Supercomputing Network: CALCRUST three– dimensional real– time multi– dataset rendering”, Proceedings of Supercomputing 92.
    [37] M.Bac, 1996,“Incomplete Information and Incentives to Free Ride on International Environmental Resources”, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 30(3), pp. 301– 315.
    [38] M.Toman and J.Pezzey et al., 1995,“Neoclassical Economic Growth Theory and Sustainability”, The Handbook of Environmental Economics, Basil Blackwell.
    [39] Marcus Daniels. Integrating Simulation Technologies with Swarm[EB/OL]. http: //www. santafe. edu/~mgd/anl/anlchicago.html 1999. 15-16.
    [40] Marcus Daniels. Writing FastModels in Swarm[EB/OL]. http: //www. santafe. edu/~mgd/swarmfest2000 /performance. htm,l 2000.pp.11-13.
    [41] Myerson R.B., 1991, Game Theory: Analysis of Conflict, Harvard University Press.
    [42] Nakayama, 1981,“Nash Equilibria and Pareto Optimal Income Redistribution”, Econometrica, (12), pp. 57– 63.
    [43] O.Tahvonen, 1996,“Trade with Polluting Nonrenewable Resources”, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 30(1), pp. 1– 17.
    [44] Paul Johnson,et al. Swarm UserGuide[EB/OL]. ftp: //ftp. swarmorg/pub/swarm /docs/swarmdocs/userbook-0. 9-htm.l tar. gz.
    [45] Pigou, 1932, Economics of Welfare, Macmillan, London.
    [46] Roger Burkhart. The Swarm Multi-Agent Simulation System [EB/OL]. http: //www. swarm. org/archive/oopsla94. htm,l 1994-09-07.
    [47] Rogers, Alan R., 1994,“Evolution of Time Preference by Natural Selection”, American Economic Review, 84(3), pp. 460– 481.
    [48] Ronald Coase, 1960,“The Problem of Social Cost”, Journal of Law and Economics, 3.
    [49] Schelling, Thomas C., 1987,“Altruism, Meanness, and Other Potentially Strategic Behaviors”, American Economic Review (Papers and Proceedings) 68(2), May, pp. 229– 230.
    [50] Swarm Development Group. Brief Overview of Swarm [EB/OL].ftp: //ftp. swarm. org/pub/swarm /docs/swarmdocs/overbook-2. 1. 1-htm.l tar. gz, 2000-07.
    [51] Swarm Development Group. Heatbugs [EB/OL]. http://www.swarm. org/examples-heatbugs. htm.l
    [52] Swarm Development Group. Swarm 2. 1. 1 Reference Guide [EB/OL]. ftp: //ftp. swarm. org/pub/swarm /docs/swarmdocs/refbook-Java-2. 1. 1-htm.l tar. gz.
    [53] Swarm DevelopmentGroup. A Tutorial Introduction to Swarm [EB/OL]. http: //www. swarm. org/csss-tutorial/frames. htm,l 2000-06.
    [54] T.Ohashi, H.Nakamura, J.Minatodani, 2000,“State transition rate based reinforcement learning”, System, Man, and Cybernetics, IEEE International Conference on, Volume 1, 8– 11 Oct., pp. 236– 241.
    [55] Tullock, 1983,“Teritorial boundaries an economic view”, The American Naturalist, (3):121.
    [56] V.Kaitala and M.Pohjola, 1995,“Sustainable International Agreement on Greenhouse Warming—a Game Theory Study”, Theoretic Models of the Environmental, C.Carlo, pp. 67– 87.
    [57] Von Neumann and O.Morgenstern, 1953, Theory of Games and Economic Behavior, Princeton University Press.
    [58] Wang Huanchen, 1993,“A kind of Systems Methodology– the SPIPRO Principle”, Chinese Journal of Systems Engineering and Electronics, Vol.4, pp. 35– 39.
    [59] Wilson. Sociobiologe, the new synthesis [M] Harvard Belknap Press, 1975
    [60] Z. Xu, W. Li, H. Fu and Z. Zeng, 2002,“The Vega Grid and Grid-Based Education”, The 1st International Conference on Web-Based Learning, HK, China, pp. 228-240.
    [61] Z. Xu, W and Li. 2002,“The Research on Vega Grid Architecture”, Journal of Computer Research and Development, 39 (8), pp. 923– 929.
    [62]阿马蒂亚?森,《以自由看待发展》,北京:中国人民大学出版社,2002
    [63]艾克斯罗德,《对微中的制胜之道—合作进化》,上海:上海人民出版社,1996
    [64]奥尔森,《集体行动的逻辑》,上海人民出版社,1995.4
    [65]保罗?A?萨缪尔森、威廉?D?诺德豪斯,《经济学》,北京经济学院出版社,1996
    [66]保罗?贝纳塞拉夫、希拉里?普特南,《数学哲学》,北京:商务印书馆,2003
    [67]彼得?科斯洛夫斯基,《伦理经济学原理》,中国社会科学出版社,1997
    [68]边沁,《道德与立法原理》,伦敦,1781
    [69]宾默尔,《博弈论与社会契约》,上海:上海财经大学出版社,2002
    [70]曹鸿强,《基于多经济智能主体的计算网格资源管理》,国防科学技术大学博士学位论文,2000.10
    [71]曹慕昆、冯玉强,《基于多Agent计算机仿真实验平台Swarm的综述》,《计算机应用研究》,2005.9
    [72]曹荣湘,《走出囚徒困境—社会资本与制度分析》,上海:上海三联书店,2003
    [73]陈霖生,《道德经的实用价值》,宏大印刷设计公司(香港),1993
    [74]陈鹏威,《道德与经济关系研究》,复旦大学博士论文,2004
    [75]陈郁,《企业制度与市场组织:交易费用》,上海人民出版社,2006.3
    [76]陈泽环,《功利?奉献?生态?文化—经济伦理引论》,上海社会科学出版社,1999
    [77]陈增圭,《重视网格应用打造数字银行—再论网格技术在金融业的应用》,《中国金融电脑》,2004.7,pp.38-39
    [78]《辞源》,商务印书馆1982
    [79]戴汝为,《从定性到定量的综合集成技术,模式识别与人工智能》,Vol.4,No.1,1991 pp.5-10
    [80]德姆赛茨.H,《竞争的经济、法律和政治制度》,上海三联书店,1992
    [81]杜振吉,《关于诚信建设的伦理学思考——诚信问题研究综述》,《伦理学研究》,2004.5
    [82]段远鹏,《建立以诚信为核心的企业伦理体系》,《中国市场》2008.8 pp.1
    [83]樊纲,《不道德”的经济学》,《读书》1998.6 pp.50-55
    [84]费正清,《剑桥中国史》,北京:中国社会科学出版社,1999
    [85]费正清,《中国:传统与变迁》,北京:世界知识出版社,2002
    [86]付秀华,《社会主义市场经济的伦理辩护》,《长白学刊》,2003.05; pp.49-51
    [87]高兆明,《社会和谐:契约精神与历史精神》,《哲学动态》,2005.6
    [88]格雷夫,《新制度经济前沿》,北京:经济科学出版社,2003
    [89]龚剑玲,《论经济诚信建设中的伦理道德机制》,《财贸研究》,2008.Vol.19 No.6
    [90]龚群,《论道德与利益》,《中国德育》,2008 .7
    [91]关蓉晖,《诚信体系建设理论浅析》,《理论界》,2008.12
    [92]郭广银、赵华,《企业伦理与和谐社会建设》,《思想政治工作研究》,2007. 6
    [93]国家高性能计算环境[EB/OL]. http://www.grid.org.cn, 2004.5
    [94]韩德强,《萨缪尔森经济批判--竞争经济学》,北京:科学技术出版社,2002
    [95]贺卫、王浣尘从经济人到效用人——经济学中人性假设的飞跃,《山西财经大学学报》,2000.03
    [96]贺卫《寻租经济学》,北京:中国发展出版社1999
    [97]胡海鸥,《道德行为的经济分析》,上海:复旦大学出版社,2003,pp.158
    [98]黄斌,《略论市场经济下公共政策的执行----兼谈“上有政策、下有对策”现象》,《福州大学学报》(社会科学版)Vol.11, No.1, 1997
    [99]黄采金,《可持续发展中环境管理理论与政策的系统研究》,上海交通大学博士论文,1999
    [100]黄少安,《产权经济学导论》,济南:山东人民出版社,1995
    [101]加里?s?贝克尔,《家庭论》,北京:商务印书馆,1998,1
    [102]加里?s?贝克尔,《人类行为的经济学分析》,上海:上海三联书店,上海人民出版社,1995
    [103]蒋昌俊等,《交通信息网格的研究》,《计算机研究与发展》,2003(40),12 pp.1677-1682
    [104]金武,《激励理论及其应用研究》,华中理工大学博士论文,1994
    [105]科斯,《企业、市场与法律》,上海:上海三联书店,1990
    [106]莱宾斯坦,《微观经济学与X效率理论《经济理论的危机》》,上海:上海译文出版社,1985
    [107]李建中,《数据网格管理概述》,http://grid.cs.tsinghua.edu.cn/ 2004.06.13.
    [108]李清,《卢湾区推进环境管理网络化、网格化和信息化》,http://www.shanghai.gov.cn, 2003.1
    [109]李伟、徐志伟、唐志敏、谢向辉、肖依,《国家高性能计算环境的设计与实现》,中国科学院计算技术研究所,2003
    [110]李泽厚,《中国古代思想史》,北京:人民出版社,1986
    [111]里查德?道金斯,《自私的基因》,长春:吉林人民出版社,1998
    [112]厉以宁,《经济学的伦理问题》,北京:三联书店,1995
    [113]林毅夫,《关于制度变迁的经济学理论:诱致性变迁与强制性变迁,《财产权利与制度变迁》》,上海:上海三联书店,上海人民出版社,1994
    [114]刘光明,《经济活动伦理研究》,中国人民大学出版社1999.5
    [115]刘广海,《网格技术应用的经济前景》,《江苏商论》,2003,11,pp. 40-41.
    [116]刘鹤玲,《互惠利他主义的博弈论模型及其形而上学预设》,《自然辩证法通讯》,1999.6 pp.6-13
    [117]刘华志、李连、朱爱红、孟庆梅,《网格技术综述》,《微型机与应用》,2003.11
    [118]刘娟娟,《基于多智能体的演化博弈模型仿真研究》,《计算机与数字工程》,2007, Vol.35 No.4
    [119]刘鹏,《网格应用现状与分析》,http://www.chinagrid.net/ 2004.11.12.
    [120]刘鹏,《网格概念的界定》,http://grid.cs.tsinghua.edu.cn/ 2003.03.02.
    [121]刘世锦,《经济体制效率分析导论》,上海:上海三联书店,1993
    [122]刘伟、梁钧平,《冲突与和谐的结合———经济与伦理》,北京教育出版社,1999
    [123]陆晓禾,《走出丛林--当代经济伦理学漫话》,湖北教育出版社,1999
    [124]罗伯特?艾克斯罗德,《对策中的制胜之道》,中译本,上海人民出版社,1996
    [125]《马克思选集》,人民出版社1972 Vol.1
    [126]马斯洛,《人的潜能的价值》,华夏出版社,1987
    [127]迈克尔?波特,《竞争优势》,华夏出版社,1998
    [128]茅于轼,《中国人的道德前景》,广州:暨南大学出版社,1997,pp.279
    [129]牟彤华,《论基于网格的电子商务模式》,《商业时代》,2003.14,pp.63-64
    [130]诺斯,《制度、制度变迁与经济绩效》,上海:上海三联书店,1994
    [131]诺斯,《经济史中的结构与变迁》,上海:上海三联书店,2003
    [132]欧阳卫民,《儒家文化与中国经济》,西南财经大学出版社,1995
    [133]钱学森、于景元、戴汝为,《一个科学新领域──开发复杂巨系统及其方法论》,《自然杂志》,Vol.13,No.1,1990 pp.9-10
    [134]钱学森,《再谈开放的复杂巨系统》,《模式识别与人工智能》,Vol.4,No.1,1991 pp.1-4
    [135]乔洪武,《从改革开放的进程看我国经济伦理的历史性飞跃》,《当代经济管理》,2008,Vol.30 No.11
    [136]秦树理、张承凤,《构建与社会主义市场经济相适应的诚信机制》,《郑州大学学报:哲学社会科学版》,2004,Vol.37 No.4
    [137]盛洪,《道德、功利及其他》,《读书》,1998(7),pp.118-125
    [138]盛庆、王来,《功利主义新论》,上海:上海交通大学出版社,1996
    [139]施颖,《以经济学为基础的政治决策——读布坎南的《自由、市场和国家》》,《企业家天地》,2008.04
    [140]石磊、钱勇,《论中国传统社会超稳定结构中的道德博弈和生存博弈》,《上海财经大学学报》,Vol.7 No.1 2005. 2
    [141]苏东水、苏江明,《诚信之道与诚信社会》,《当代财经》,2003.1
    [142]苏东水,《东方管理》,山西经济出版社,2003
    [143]苏东水,《管理心理学》,复旦大学出版社,1998
    [144]孙建、叶民强,《SWARM在博弈论中的仿真分析研究》,《计算机工程与应用》,2003,39(33):58-72.
    [145]汪丁丁,《谈谈市场经济的道德基础问题》,《在哲学与经济学之间》,中国社会科学出版社,1996,pp.104-162
    [146]王浣尘,《集约型增长与可持续发展》,《系统工程理论方法应用》,Vol.5,No.4,1996
    [147]王浣尘,《经济发展与生态环境的系统协同──兼谈旋进模式》,《生态经济与能力开发》Vol.2,1995:pp.7-8
    [148]王浣尘,《可持续发展与系统集成方法论》,第一届中国软科学学术年会论文,1996
    [149]王浣尘,《难度自增殖系统及其方法论》,《上海交通大学学报》,Vol.26,No.5,1992 pp.5-11
    [150]王浣尘,《系统策划》,《系统工程理论方法应用》,Vol.3,No.2,1994,pp.1-5
    [151]王浣尘,《系统策划与旋进原则》,《策划与策划支持系统》,中国经济出版社,1994
    [152]王浣尘,《旋进原则方法论》,上海科学技术文献出版社,1995
    [153]王浣尘,《一种系统方法论-旋进原则》,《系统工程》,Vol.12, No.5, 1994
    [154]王浣尘,《总体与整体》,《系统工程理论与实践》,No.4, 1986
    [155]王浣尘,《关于“网格化管理”的若干理论思考》,网格化管理研讨学术论文,Workingpaper, No.G2006-19,2006
    [156]王强、潘文灏、王浣尘,《基于旋进原则的可持续发展战略研究》,《科技导报》,Vol.9,1997,pp.55-57
    [157]王晓云,《诚信是家族企业中持续发展的灵魂》,《集团经济研究》,2006年10X期
    [158]王意洁等,《数据网格及其关键技术研究》、《计算机研究与发展》,2002.8 pp.943-948
    [159]王在坤,《论我国信用建设的缺失和对策》,《时代教育:教育教学刊》,2008.10
    [160]威廉?西尼尔,《政治经济学大纲》,北京:商务印书馆,1986
    [161]吴灿新、叶忠明,《以诚信道德建设推进市场经济的有效运行》,《南方论刊》,2004.12
    [162]吴潜涛、赵爱玲,《论构建社会诚信机制》,《齐鲁学刊》,2004.2
    [163]西蒙,《现代决策理论的基石》,北京:北京经济学院出版社,1991
    [164]夏伟东,《小康社会、和谐社会与道德建设》,《江苏社会科学》2005.4
    [165]向松祚、张五常,《经济学》,朝华出版社,2005
    [166]肖侬,数据网格研究现状[EB/OL],http://www.chinagrid.net/ 2002.10
    [167]肖群忠,《人性与道德关系新探》,《伦理学(人大复印资料)》,2002(5).
    [168]心理学百科全书编辑委员会,《心理学百科全书》,杭州:浙江教育出版社,1995
    [169]许启贤,《社会主义市场经济需要雷锋精神》,《高校理论战线》2004.3
    [170]亚当?斯密,《国民财富的性质和原因的研究》,上卷,商务印书馆,1996
    [171]严广乐、王浣尘,《旋进原则方法论的一些模型与判据》,《华东工业大学学报》,Vol.19,No.3,1997 pp.15-20
    [172]杨冬菊,《异构集群管理系统的关键技术研究》,西北工业大学博士学位论文,2002.6
    [173]姚卉,《企业信用缺失与治理对策》,《决策与信息:财经观察》,2008.5
    [174]叶航,《囚徒困境中的人类理性与道德》,《经济学消息报》,1999-04-16(4)
    [175]叶航,《盛洪与他的道德功利说》,《经济学消息报》,1999-03-12(4)
    [176]叶航,《经济学视野中的人类道德-现状假说模型》,《学术月刊》,2001.2
    [177]叶航,《ESS与人类道德的起源》,《经济学消息报》,1999-04-23第4版
    [178]叶航,《超越经济理性的人类道德》,《经济学家》,2000.5 PP.79-83
    [179]余达淮、银娟,《道家思想对东亚经济的影响及其伦理价值》,《南通师范学院学报:哲学社会科学版》,2004 Vol.20 No.4
    [180]约翰?穆勒,《功利主义》,上海:商务印书馆,1957
    [181]约翰?穆勒,《政治经济学原理》,北京:商务印书馆,1991
    [182]岳学军、范洪俊,《互联网中网格技术的发展及我国的对策》,《科技进步与对策》,2003.10 pp.144-146
    [183]张鸿翼,《儒家经济伦理》,湖南教育出版社,1989
    [184]张曙光,《道德缺失使制度陷于尴尬》http://jztu.bokee.com/297927.html
    [185]张曙光,《经济学家如何讲道德》,《读书》,1999.1pp.75-84
    [186]张维迎,《博弈论与信息经济学》,上海:上海三联书店、上海人民出版社,1996
    [187]张震,《市场经济道德建设与社会诚信机制研究”理论研讨会综述》,《道德与文明》2003.6
    [188]张钟俊,《综合即创造(创刊词)》,《系统工程》,Vol.1,No.1,1983 pp.1-2
    [189]赵长胜,《解决市场经济建设中诚信缺失问题的对策分析》,《焦作师范高等专科学校学报》2008 Vol.24 No.4
    [190]赵汀阳,《学问中国》,江西出版社1998
    [191]郑士源、徐辉、王浣尘,《网格及网格化管理综述》,《系统工程》,2005 Vol.23, No. 3,pp.1-7
    [192]郑晓彬、王浣尘,《股票市场价格行为的复杂性研究》,上海交通大学博士论文,2002
    [193]《公民道德建设实施纲要》2001
    [194]周颂南,《关于建立乌鲁木齐地区实时清算计算机网格系统的思考》,《新疆金融》,1996.12 pp.30-31
    [195]朱家祯,《孔子思想与现代企业管理》,广西人民出版社,1999
    [196]朱林、陈泽环,《功利与奉献--社会主义市场经济论理学引论》,漓江出版社,1996

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700