基于旅游业外部性的公共景区定价研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
旅游业作为与人民群众密切相关的现代服务业,正逐渐成为国民经济的战略性支柱产业。但是,近年来关于公共景区是否该按照市场需求进行大幅提价,还是兼顾公共资源和区域整体经济发展要求而大幅降价,始终没有一个统一而明确的结论。尤其是杭州西湖景区全面免费开发模式,尽管博得全社会的“叫好”声,但是却始终没有其他地区效仿成功的案例。本研究将“门票经济”的核心经济学命题定位为公共旅游资源的最优定价问题,尝试从公共经济学角度对公共景区定价高低及其适用条件给出合理的解释。
     有别于传统的成本收益定价模型,本研究在公共定价的框架下,从区域可持续发展的角度出发,以外部性为分析视角,考虑景区旅游所带来的直接门票收入和由游客消费所带来的经济正外部性两种收益,并分别研究在拥挤外部性和环境外部性两种负外部性作用下,景区的最优定价问题。
     本研究首先在理论文献的基础上,对公共景区定价的经济学性质进行了剖析与阐述,并结合杭州西湖景区逐步免费开放过程的监测数据,指出了由于存在外部性,景区免费开放的经济效应存在很大的不确定性。在此基础上,本研究构建了偏好异质性游客离散选择的理性预期均衡模型,将景区旅游的需求内生化,并以此确定门票价格与游客人数和游客总消费之间的关系。基于此模型,本研究根据景区的不同特点和决策部门的不同目标函数,分别研究了拥挤外部性与景区定价的关系,以及环境外部性与景区定价的关系。最后,本研究基于数理模型研究结论,针对其中的拥挤效应这一关键问题,结合心理学和行为学理论,设计了一项旅游价格变化与拥挤感知和旅游意愿的准实验,并通过网络,对全国216位潜在游客进行了调查,进一步确定了拥挤外部性在景区定价和游客决策中所起到的关键作用。
     本研究获得如下结论:
     1)提高景区定价,确实使得游客人数减少,但是在考虑了拥挤外部性之后,这种下降的程度会被放缓。景区定价与游客在当地消费总量之间的关系是模糊的,不一定是单调关系,即,当游客人数过多,导致拥挤的负效用很大时,适当
price and the number of tourists and tourists' consumption. Based on these relationships, we cope with the multiple externalities present in tourism, and determine the optimal pricing decisions for public tourism resources, which vary according to the different features of the scenic areas and different objects of local governments. Finally, with the aid of a quasi-experimental research, we examine the relationship between the externality of crowdedness and the pricing decision empirically.
     We reach the following conclusions:
     (1) The number of tourists decreases with the ticket price, however, in the presence of the externality of crowdedness, the decrease in the number will be smaller. The relationship between the price and the total consumption of the tourists is ambiguous, that is, when there are too many tourists in the area, the externality of crowdedness exerts large negative impacts on the individual tourist's utility. In this case, a higher price may help to distinguish tourists with high willingness to consume, from those with low willingness to consume, therefore increase the total amount of consumption. The results of the quasi-experiment show, when facing the tradeoff between the price effect and the crowded effect, a tourist who is different in choosing a particular scenic area and others behaves quite randomly, which drives the relationship between the change of the price and the tourism revenue nonlinear.
     (2) If the negative externality imposed on the environment by tourism, is related directly with the number of the tourists, then raising the price helps to protect the environment, whether the externality of crowdedness exists or not. However, when the environmental externality is mainly cause by the tourists' consumption in the area, and the externality of crowdedness is in presence, raising the entry fee cannot guarantee the total amount of the tourists' consumption will decrease. In fact, in some cases it may even increase, therefore will do a greater harm to the environment.
     (3) When the environmental system in the scenic area repairs itself so easily, that the environmental externality imposed by the tourism can be neglected, and the externality of crowdedness does not exist, under some special functional forms, the object of direct tourism revenue coincides with that of local economic growth. In this case, the decision maker will choose the lowest price (or even for free) which induces all the potential consumers to choose this particular area as their destination. However, in general, if the decision maker only cares about the direct tourism revenue, he will choose a higher price than that chosen by a decision maker who cares about the development of local economy.
     In sum, for different types of public scenic areas, to determine a reasonable price, we should take into account the heterogeneity in the tourists'preferences, the presence of the externality of crowdedness, and the extent of the enrivonmental externality imposed by tourism, and maximize the sum of the direct tourism revenue and the positive effect on the local economic growth, net of the cost imposed on the environment.
     This paper not only provides a more reasonable answer based on public economics, to the recent argument over whether public scenic areas should be admission-free to the public, but also offers new insights and solutions to the pricing decisions of public scenic areas which aim to develop tourism.
引文
[1]Altman, I., The environment and social behavior. California:Brooks/Cole Publishing Company,1975,22-41.
    [2]APEC Tourism Working Group, World Travel & Tourism Council. The Economic Impact of Travel and Tourism Development in the APEC Region [M].1998.
    [3]Becker, G. S., A Note on Restaurant Pricing and Other Examples of Social Influences on Price[J], Journal of Political Economy 1991(99):1109-1116.
    [4]Becker, R. H. Social carrying capacity and user satisfaction:An experimental function. Leisure Science,1978,1(3):241-257.
    [5]Beladi, H., Chao, C. and Hazari, B. Tourism and the Environment, Working Paper, 2007.
    [6]Bell, F. and Leeworthy V., Recreational Demand by Tourists for Saltwater Beach Days[J], Journal of Environmental Economics and Management.1990(18): 189-205.
    [7]Blackwell, R., P. Miniard, and J. Engel, Consumer Behavior[M], The Dryden Press.2001.
    [8]Blakely, E.J., Planning Local Economic Development:Theory and Practice.[M], United State:J. Blakely.1994.
    [9]Bockstael E. N. and Catherine L. K., Value environmental quality:weak complementarity with sets of goods [J], American Journal of Agricultural Economics,1988,70(3):654-662.
    [10]Burkart, A. J. and Medlik, S., Tourism:Past, Present, and future[M], London: William Heinemann Ltd.1974.
    [11]Cesario, F. J. Value of time and recreation benefit studies[J], Land Economics, 1976,52(1):32-41.
    [12]Chao, C. C., Hazari B. R. and Sgro P. M., Tourism, Globalization, Social Externalities and Domestic Welfare, Research in International Business and Finance,2004(18):141-149.
    [13]Chao, C. C., Hazari B. R. and Sgro P. M., Tourism and Economic Development in a Cash-in-advance Economy, Research in International Business and Finance, 2005(19):365-373.
    [14]Chao, C. C., Hazari, B. R., Laffargue, J. P., Sgro, P. M. and Yu, E. S. H., Tourism, Dutch Disease and Welfare in an Open Dynamic Economy, The Japanese Economic Review,2006(57):501-515.
    [15]Choi, S. C., Mirjafari, A. and Weaver, H. B., The concept of crowding:A critical review and proposal of an alternative approach. Environment and Behavior,1976, 8 (3):345-362.
    [16]Chou.C, Shy, O., Do consumers gain or lose when more people buy the same brand[J], European Journal of Political Economy,1996,12:309-330.
    [17]Chu, W., Gerstner, E. and Hess,J. D., Costs and Benefits of Hard-Sell[J], Journal of Marketing Research,1995.32(1):97-102.
    [18]Cohen, E., The Sociology of tourism:approaches, issues,and findings[J], Annual Review of Sociology,1984.10(3):373-392.
    [19]Colton, C. W., Leisure, recreation, tourism- A symbolic interactionism view[J], Annals of Tourism Research,1987.14(3):345-360.
    [20]Copeland, B. R., Tourism, Welfare and De-industrialization in a Small Open Economy, Economica,1991(58):515-529.
    [21]Crompton, J. Motives of visitors attending festival events. Annals of Tourism Research,1997,24 (2):425-439.
    [22]Crouch, G. I., Effect of Income and Price on International Tourism[J], Annals of Tourism Research,1992.19(3):643-664.
    [23]Ditton, R. B., Fedler, A. J., and Graefe, A. R. Factors contributing to recreation crowding. Leisure Science,1983,5 (4):273-288.
    [24]Driver, B. and Toncher, S. R., Elements of Outdoor Recreation Planning[M], Ann Arbor, The University of Michigan Press.1974.
    [25]Dumazedier, J., Sociology of Leisure, Amsterdam[M], Elsevier.1974.
    [26]Ellerbrock, M., Some straight talk on user fees[J], Parks and Recreation,1982(1): 59-62.
    [27]Fedler, A. J., Introduction:are leisure, recreation, and tourism interrelated? [J] Annals of tourism Research,1987.14(3):311-313.
    [28]Foa, U. G., Resource theory:explorations and applications, San Diego:Academic Press.1993.
    [29]Gartner,W. C., Tourism development:principles, processes, and policies[M], U.S.A:Copyright Clearance Center.1996.
    [30]Graefe, A. R., Vaske, J. J., and Kuss, F. R. Social carrying capacity:An integration and synthesis of twenty years of research. Leisure Scicence,1984,6 (4):395-431.
    [31]Gramann, J. H. Toward a behavioral theory of crowding in outdoor recreation:An evaluation and synthesis of research. Leisure Science,1982,5 (2):109-126.
    [32]Grossman, Sanford J. and Stiglitz, J. E., On the Impossibility of Informationally Efficient Markets [J], American Economic Review, American Economic Association, vol.70(3), pages 393-408, June.1980.
    [33]Godbey, G, Leisure in Your Life[M], Philadelphia:Saunders.1981.
    [34]Gooroochurn, N. and Sinclair, M. T., The Economics of Tourism Taxation[J], working paper,2004.
    [35]Goeldner,C. R. and J.R.Ritchie, Tourism:Principles, Practices, Philosophies [M], New York:John Wiley and Sons, Inc.2002.
    [36]Gray, D. and D. Pellegrion, Reflections on the Recreation and Park Movement[M], Dubuque:Brown.1973.
    [37]Hardin, G, The Tragedy of the Commons[J], Science,1968(162):1243-1248.
    [38]Hazari, B., and Ng, A., An Analysis of Tourists'Consumption of Non-Traded Goods and Services on the Welfare of the Domestic Consumers [J]. International Review of Economics and Finance.1993,2(1):43-58.
    [39]Healy, R. G, The'Common pool'Problem in Tourism Landscapes, Annals of Tourism Research,1994.21(3):596-611.
    [40]Helson, H. Adaptation level theory[M], New York:Harper and Row.1964.
    [41]Huang, Y. Y. and Huang,D. S., On the Policies of Ecotourism[J],Taiwanese Agricultural Economic Review,2006(112):267-308.
    [42]Jacoby, J., Chestnut, R., Weigl K. and Fisher, W.. Pre-purchase information acquisition:Description of a process methodology[M], In:Anderson, B.,(ed.)Advances in consumer research. Cincinnati, OH:Association for Consumer Reserch,1976:306-314.
    [43]Jansen, V. M. and Dietvorst, A., Leisure, recreation, tourism:a geographic view on integration[J], Annals of tourism Research,1987.14(3):361-375.
    [44]Jonathan, G, Service Economy After Industrial Society, The Emerging Self-service Economy[M], The Macmillan Press Ltd, London.1978.
    [45]Karl, A. and Ron. Z.,Service America[M], Warner Books Edition.1985.
    [46]Kelly, J. Leisure[M], Englewood Cliffs, N.J.:Prentice Hall.1982.
    [47]Klar, L. and Rodman, C., Budgetary and administrative impacts of tax-limiting legislation on municipal recreation and parks departments[J], Journal of Park and Recreation Administrative,1984.2(4):31-44
    [48]Lan, L. W. and Kanafani, A., Economics of Park-and-Shop Discounts[J], Journal of Transport Economics and Policy,1993.27(3):291-303.
    [49]Lan, L. W., Principles and Methods of Parking Pricing[J], Transportation Planning Journal,1980.9(3):311-326.
    [50]Lawson, R., Gnoth, J. and Paulin, K., Tourists' Awareness of Prices for Attractions and Activities [J], Journal of Travel Research,1995.36(1):3-10.
    [51]Leal, D. R.Q., Should national parks financial their operations through user fees[J], Insight on the News,1998,14(45), Dec 7:24-28.
    [52]Lew, A. A., The Asia-Pacific ecotourism industry:putting sustainable tourism into practice In Sustainable Tourism, A Geographical Perspective[M], Longman, Essex,1998.
    [53]London, M., Crandall, R. and Fitzgibbons, D., The psychological structure of leisure:activities, needs, people[J], Journal of Leisure Research,1977.9(4): 252-263.
    [54]Loudon, D. Consumer behavior. New York:Me Graw-Hill Press,1993,78-90.
    [55]Manning, R. E. Studies in outdoor recreation. Oregon:Oregon State University Press,1986,90-111.
    [56]Manning, R. and Baker, S., Discrimination through user fees:Fact or fiction?, Parks and Recreation[J],1981.16(9):70-74.
    [57]Manning, R., Callinan, E., Echelberger, E., Koemann, E. and McEwen, D., Differential fees:Raising revenue, distributing demand[J], Journal of Recreation and Park Administrative,1984.2(1):20-38.
    [58]Mathieson, A. and Wall, G, Tourism:Economic, Physical, and Social Impacts[M], New York:Longman Inc.1982.
    [59]McCarville, R., Driver, B. and Crompton, J., Persuasive communication and the pricing of public leisure services, In Influencing human behavior:Theory and applications in recreation, tourism, and natural resources management[M], Champaign, IL. Sagamore.1992.
    [60]Michael D.B. and Loomis, J. B., A note on the use of travel cost models with unequal zonal population[J], Land economics,1982.58(3):395-399.
    [61]Michael, Lockwood, Tracy, Kathy. Nonmarket economic valuation of an urban recreation park[J], Journal of Leisure Research,1995,27(2):155-167.
    [62]Middleton V.T.C., Marketing in Travel and Tourism,2nd edition, Heinemann, London,1988:13.
    [63]Monroe, K., Pricing:Making profitable decisions [M], New York:McgrawHill Company.1979.
    [64]Muth, J. F., Rational Expectations and the Theory of Price Movements[J], Econometrica.1961(29):315-335.
    [65]Nowak J. J., Sahli M., and Pasquale M. S., Tourism, Trade and Domestic Welfare, Pacific Economic Review, Blackwell Publishing,2003,8(3):245-258.
    [66]Owen, P. L., Rural leisure and recreation research:A retrospective evaluation [J], Progress in Human Geography,1984.8(2):157-187.
    [67]Parker, S.R., The future of work and Leisure [M]. London:Mac Gibbon and Kee. 1971.
    [68]Pearce, D. G. Tourist time-budget. Annals of Tourism Research,1987,15 (1): 106-121.
    [69]Poor P. J. and Jamie M. S. Travel cost analysis of a cultural heritage site:the case of Historic St. Mary's City of Maryland[J]. Journal of Cultural Economics, 2004(28):217-229.
    [70]Przeclawski, K., Tourism Research:Critiques and Challenges[M], Routledge: London and New York.1993.
    [71]Robert Inman, Managing the Service Economy Prospects and Problem[M], Cambridge University Press.1985.
    [72]Rosenthal, D. H., Loomis, J. B. and Peterson, G. L., Pricing for Efficiency and Revenue in Public Recreation Areas[J], Journal of Leisure Research,1984.16(3): 195-208.
    [73]Roy, K. and Tisdell, C. Tourism in India[M], Nova Science Publishers, Commack, New York.1998.
    [74]Rosenthal, D. H., Loomis, J. B. and Peterson, G. L., Pricing for Efficiency and Revenue in Public Recreation Areas[J], Journal of Leisure Research.1984,16(3): 195-208.
    [75]Rusell L., The New Service Industry[M], Longman Group Limited,1973.
    [76]Schreyer, R., and Roggenbuck, J. W., The influence of experience expectations and social-psychological carrying capacities. Leisure Science,1978,1(4): 373-394.
    [77]Schroeder, T. D. and Fesenmaier, D. R. Pricing Policies in Outdoor Recreation:A Study of State Park Financing in Oklahoma[M], In Recreation planning and management, Lieber, Stanley R. and Danial R. Fesenmaier(ed.), USA:Venture. 1983.
    [78]Sharpe, S., The effect of consumer switching costs on prices:a theory and its applications to bank deposit market[J]. Review of Industrial Organization,1997, 12:79-94.
    [79]Shelby, B. Crowding models for backcountry recreation. Land Economics,1980, 56 (1):43-55.
    [80]Sherman, P.B. and Dixon, J.A., Nature Tourism-Managing for the Environment Whelan, Washington,D.C.:Island Press.1991.
    [81]Sinclair, M. T., Tourism and economic development:A survey[J], The journal of Development Studies.1998 (6).
    [82]Stevenson, S., A Test of Peak Load Pricing on Senior Citizen Recreationists:A Case Study of Steamboat Lake State Park[J], Journal of Park and Recreation Administration,1989.7(1):58-68.
    [83]Stokols, D., The experience of crowding in primary and secondary environment. Environment and Behavior,1976,8 (1):49-86.
    [84]Swarbrooke J., The Development And Management Of Visitor Attractions [M], Second Edition, Dongbei University of Finance and Economics Press,2005, 第二版,东北财经大学出版社,2005年版:9
    [85]Taylor O. and Smith V, Environment Amenities as a Source of Market Power[J], Land Economics,2000.76(4):550-568.
    [86]The Internation Ecotourism Society[R], Ecotourism Statistical Fact Sheet,2000.
    [87]The University of Vermont, The Impact of the Tourism Sector on the Vermont Economy:The Input-Output Model,1999:73-74.
    [88]Torkildsen, G. Leisure and Recreation Management[M], New York:E and FN SPON.1992.
    [89]Uysal, M.,Wei L. and Reid, L.M., Development of international tourism in P.R. of China[J], Tourism Management.1986.7(2):113-119.
    [90]Walsh, R., Recreation economic decisions[M], State College, PA:Venture.1986.
    [91]Walsh-Heron, J. and Stevens, T., The management of visitor attractions and events, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N J (1990).
    [92]Warren, R. and Rea, P., Fee-supported parks:Promoting success[J], Park and Recreation,1998.33(1):80-88.
    [93]Yang, Tsung-Tai, Price Competition and Business Strategy in Ecotourism: Theoretical Models, doctoral dissertation.2004.
    [94]Zvi Griliches, Output Measurement In the Service Sectors[M]. The University of Chicago Press.1992.
    [95]A·迈里克·弗里曼着,曾贤刚译,环境与资源价值评估——理论与方法[M],北京:中国人民大学出版社,2002年.
    [96]蔡雄,旅游扶贫的乘数效应与对策研究[J],社会科学家,1997年.
    [97]陈凯俐,林云雀,不同旅游需求函数设定下之旅游效益比较—以宜兰县为例[J],农业与经济,2005(34):91-120.
    [98]曹国新,解析中国旅游商品的市场失灵[J],江苏商论,2006(1):107-108.
    [99]曹三强,潘秋玲,中外旅游景区门票价格的比较研究[J],价格理论与实践,2007(1):57-58.
    [100]陈水源.拥挤与户外旅游关系研究——社会心理层面的探讨.博士学位论文,台湾大学,1988.
    [101]楚义芳:《旅游的空间经济分析》[M],陕西人民出版社,1992年.
    [102]段治平,李佳,我国旅游景区门票价格研究综述,2007(9):8-10.
    [103]龚云,黄洁,论需求弹性在旅游市场价格机制中的运用[J],商场现代化,2005(9):165-166.
    [104]杭州市物价局.免费西湖带动相关产业大发展[J].价格理论与实践,2005(4).
    [105]何光伟(编),中国旅游业50年[M],中国旅游出版社,1999年版.
    [106]胡蓉蓉,陶卓民,旅游景区门票价格的初步探讨[J],价格月刊,2005(9):20-21.
    [107]胡卫华,景区门票价格上涨的深层次思考[J],中国物价,2005(5):40-44.
    [108]黄金秋,王艺洁,李明东,卢鹏,我国旅游地区收入分析及对策探讨[J],生态经济,2006(6):99-102.
    [109]黄葵.世遗景区门票涨价问题的思考—北京“世遗”门票涨价事件感想[J].重庆邮电学院学报,2005,6:886-888.
    [110]姜若愚,旅游景区服务与管理[M],大连:东北财经大学出版社,2003:2-3.
    [111]焦彦.基于旅游者偏好和知觉风险的旅游者决策模型分析.旅游学刊,2006,21(5):42-47.
    [112]李光勤,倪羽,杨晓霞,旅游景区(点)门票价格的博弈分析[J],价格月刊,2006(4):20.
    [113]李坚作,消费者评价的旅游需求与旅游市场对应关系实证[J],求索,2006(6):45-47.
    [114]李江帆、李美云,旅游产业与旅游增加值的测算[J],旅游学刊,1999年第5期.
    [115]李志青,旅游业产出贡献的经济分析——上海市旅游业的产出贡献和乘数效应[J],上海经济研究2001(12):66-69.
    [116]厉新建,张辉,旅游经济学--理论与发展[M],东北财大,2002,12.
    [117]梁江川.沪杭甬居民旅游偏好及产品开发策略.旅游科学,2006,20(6):47-51.
    [118]刘琦,张小盟.旅游黄金周景点门票涨价的经济学观察[J].经济纵横,2007(3).
    [119]刘细良,杨榕桦,刘正桥,试论价格听证中消费者代表的独立性——以调整武陵源核心景区门票价格听证会为例[J],消费经济,2006(6):92-94.
    [120]鲁明勇,邻近区域旅游企业合作的博弈分析——以张家界和凤凰为例[J],科学技术与工程,2006.6(21):3451-3454.
    [121]罗名义,旅游经济学[M],南开大学出版社,2005年.
    [122]马梅,公共产品悖论—国家公园旅游产品生产分析[J],旅游学刊,2003(4):44.
    [123]彭德成,肖澎,周梅,我国旅游资源和景区研究的几个前沿问题[J],旅游学刊,2003(6):54-56.
    [124]牛亚菲,谢丽波,刘春凤.北京市旅游客流时空分布特征与调控对策.地理研究,2005,24(2):283-292.
    [125]齐子鹏,黄昆,从价格竞争到价格联盟:旅行社业存在的一个博弈均衡解 [J],数量经济技术经济研究,2003(06):112-114.
    [126]邱沛光,苏继伟,用计量经济模型分析旅游市场的广阔前景[J],中国市场,2006(40):94-95.
    [127]苏建军,黄解宇,我国旅游景区门票价格研究的问题及进展[J],哈尔滨商业大学学报(社会科学版),2008(6):40-41.
    [128]沈进成,吕明纯,陈妤婷,国内旅游需求结构及所得弹性之研究[J],http://www.nhu.edu.tw/-tourism/document/article/20020401_02.pdf
    [129]唐凌,对旅游景区产品性质的重新界定[J],统计与决策,2005,1999(10):159-160.
    [130]陶卓民,卢亮,景区门票价格上涨的形成机理与对策探讨[J],价格理论与实践,2005(6):22-23.
    [131]田勇,国外旅游景区门票价格特征及其启迪[J],价格月刊,2003(5).
    [132]田勇,孙艳梅,旅游景区门票价格模型确立研究[J],价格月刊,2007(2):16-18.
    [133]王湘、李凌鸥,论旅游业的投入产出问题[J],北京第二外国语学院学报,1999(4).
    [134]魏小安,旅游目的地发展实证研究[M].北京:中国旅游出版社.2002:68.
    [135]吴兰桂,任黎秀,涂玮,谢雯.福建省牛姆林风景区生态旅游环境容量研究.福建林业科技,2005,32(3):119-123.
    [136]吴忠军,旅游景区规划与开发[M1,北京:高等教育出版社,2003:1-3.
    [137]向荣,关于景区门票定价机制的几点思考与建议[J],价格理论与实践,2005(10).36-37.
    [138]燕珍,生态旅游营销中的价格策略研究[J],生态经济,2005(3):107-111.
    [139]杨旸,旅游需求理论与模型简介,http://cotsa.com/TBBS/upload/799.pdf
    [140]杨美霞,景区门票价格上调对旅游客源市场的影响——以张家界武陵源景区为例[J],价格理论与实践,2006(6):31-32.
    [141]依绍华,对景区门票涨价热的冷思考[J],价格理论与实践2005(11):18-19.
    [142]依绍华,民营企业进行旅游景区开发的现状分析及对策[J],旅游学刊,2003(4):47-51.
    [143]余丹,确定景区门票价格的因素[J],价格理论与实践,2006(1):44-45.
    [144]余丹,确定景区门票价格的因素[J],价格月刊,2006(4):21-22.
    [145]张海燕,伍孝勇.旅游景区门票价格上涨现象探析[J].科技资讯,2006(4).
    [146]张辉,旅游经济论[M],旅游教育出版社,2005年出版.
    [147]张捷雷,对我国景区门票价格制定的思考[J],价格理论与实践,2005(7):48-49.
    [148]张嘉宇.游客面对旅游区拥挤所采取的调节机制研究——以剑湖山主题公园为例[D].硕士学位论文,1997,台湾南华大学.
    [149]张俊彦.旅游规划中游客拥挤知觉的分析[D].硕士学位论文,台湾大学,1986.
    [150]张凌云,旅游业乘数效应的几个问题[J],南开经济研究,1988(3).
    [151]张鹏,唐善茂,丘萍,广西贺州市生态旅游的投入——产出分析[J],林业经济问题,2007(6):530-534
    [152]张文建,阚廷磊,上海市旅游产业关联和产业波及分析[J],社会科学,2003(8):78-83.
    [153]张小利,西部旅游扶贫的乘数效应分析[J],商业时代,2007(7):89-91.
    [154]张春兴,杨国枢.心理学.台北:三民书局,1984,189-211.
    [155]张滢:旅游经济效应的理论与实证研究——以乌鲁木齐市为例[D],新疆大学,博士论文,2006.
    [156]钟契夫、乌家培、邵汗青、张守一、陈锡康、李秉全编[M],投入产出原理及其应用,中国社会科学出版社,1982.
    [157]周慧滨,左旦平,旅行成本法在我国应用中存在的几个问题[J],自然资源学报,2006(3),:489-499.
    [158]周建梅,文秋红.关于景区门票涨价现象的思考[J],价格月刊,2006(5).
    [159]祝学东,毕燕,旅游景区门票设置现状及对策研究[J],价格月刊,2007(3).35-38.
    [160]朱迪.丽丝,自然资源:分配、经济学政策[M].北京:商务印书馆,2002(345).
    [161]左冰,旅游的经济效应分析、旅游管理倾士论文文库——2000[D].旅游教育出版社,2001.
    [162]左冰.中国旅游产出乘数及就业乘数的初步测算[J].云南财贸学院学报,2004,18(2).

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700