建筑节能服务市场培育的政府行为研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
我国是能源消耗量巨大的国家,而在总耗能中,建筑能耗占到了接近30%,无论是新建建筑还是既有建筑的能耗居高不下,建筑的节能改造工作已经刻不容缓。我国政府为解决这一难题,引进了在发达国家发展相对成熟的基于市场化、全新的节能新机制——合同能源管理,我国政府尤其注重运用价格、财政、税收、金融等经济激励政策试图用市场机制来加快我国建筑节能改造的步伐,并因此而取得了一定的成果,建筑节能服务市场已初具规模。但是由于节能服务领域属于非纯公共物品,加之全社会的节能服务意识薄弱,以及政府制定的激励政策落实受阻、激励资金使用不当,同时,受到精力、财力以及政绩的制约,往往会过分注重总产值、投资额等硬性指标等原因,使得建筑节能服务市场在供需两端都存在问题,需要政府改革以往的单一培育方式,引入新机制来应对上述问题。因此,如何以高效、规范的政府市场培育行为为保证节能服务市场资源的有效、合理配置,解决供需问题,成为了具有重大意义的科学问题。
     本文立足于我国建筑节能服务市场发展的现实状况,深度挖掘建筑节能服务市场培育政府行为的动因及行为机理,系统研究了基于监督和基于文化建设的建筑节能服务市场培育政府行为。本文主要目的是在探索政府当前市场培育模式下市场参与人行为及政府自身行为机理的基础上,将基于监督和基于文化建设的政府培育行为嵌入到现有模式中,改善原有培育模式中供需问题,并为建筑节能服务市场培育政府行为提供理论依据,推动建筑节能服务市场的可持续发展。
     在研究现有研究成果的基础上,本文围绕着建筑节能服务市场培育政府培育行为这一主题,分别从市场供需两端的政府市场培育问题展开研究,明确政府培育建筑节能服务市场的动因,构建了政府培育行为模式的理论框架,并在此基础上提出政府市场培育的两个关键行为,即基于监督和基于文化建设的政府市场培育行为。
     基于监督和基于文化建设的政府市场培育行为是分别解决建筑节能节能服务市场供应与需求的政府培育行为。在定性分析其行为产生的制度原因基础上,运用博弈论、群体选择理论等相关知识构建了基于监督和基于文化建设的市场培育政府行为模型,阐释了基于监督和基于文化建设的建筑节能服务市场培育的政府行为,并在此基础上,运用委托-代理理论,设计了基于监督的建筑节能服务市场培育政府行为合约,分析了各参数对模型的影响,提出了相应的治理措施,为促进我国建筑节能服务市场的可持续发展奠定基础。
     通过行为模型建立及合约设计,本文进一步提出了可行的基于监督与文化建设的建筑节能服务市场培育政府的行为模式。即,将监督和文化建设嵌入到以建筑节能服务市场激励机制为核心的政府培育行为当中,以基于监督和文化建设的政府培育行为促进建筑节能服务市场健康有序发展。
     为验证基于监督和文化建设政府行为模型的有效性,运用元胞自动机的相关理论知识,对基于监督和文化建设的政府行为进行仿真研究,通过建立仿真模型,设计仿真实验,实现了对政府培育行为的仿真,清晰直观地观察到了政府培育行为的演化过程,验证了各参数对建筑节能服务市场培育政府行为的影响,并有针对性地提出建筑节能服务市场培育政府行为的对策建议。
     本文针对当前我国建筑节能服务市场培育方面存在的问题,围绕建筑节能服务市场培育政府行为进行研究,可以进一步丰富我国建筑节能服务市场培育的理论和方法,其中基于监督和文化建设政府行为模型对建筑节能服务市场培育具有一定的借鉴意义。
Our country is the nation that has huge energy consumption and especiallythat the building energy consumption accounts for nearly30%in the total energyconsumption, whether new or existing buildings, which is the urgent work thatshould be solved right now. The new and market-based energy efficiencymechanism introduced from relatively mature in the developed countries, calledEnergy Performance Contracting, is began to work out to solve this problem byour government. And comprehensive using of legal, economic, technical andnecessary administrative means, based on specific needs of our government,issued a series of policies and measures to promote energy efficiency market,especially with particular emphasis on the use of price, finance, taxation,banking and other economic incentives trying to use market mechanisms toaccelerate the pace of building energy efficiency, and the energy efficiencyservices market has taken to great achievements. However, due to energyefficiency are non-pure public goods, coupled with weak energy efficiencyawareness of the whole society and incentive policies implementation obstacle,incentive funds inefficient using, and at the same time, the government tend toover-focus on hard targets, as output, investment, restricted by the energy,financial and government performance, there are many problems in the supplyand demand of building energy efficiency services market, which needsgovernment reform in single nurturing way of the past, and introducing of newmechanisms to deal with these issues. Therefore, how to efficiently andstandardized government behavior to cultivate energy efficiency services marketto ensure the effective and rational allocation, to solve the problem of supply anddemand, has become a significant scientific problems.
     This article has been deeply excavated building energy services marketcultivation government behavior and its motivation mechanisms based on thedevelopment of building energy efficiency service market realities, andsystematically research the market cultivation government behavior based onsupervision and cultural construction. Main purpose of this article is to embedgovernment behavior as supervision and cultural construction into the existingmodel to improve the existing supply and demand issues, based on the explosionof the government and participants’ behavior mechanism in the current marketmode cultivation of the market. This would provide a theoretical basis topromote building energy efficiency services market development sustainably.
     Based on existing research, this paper revolved around the subjects of thebuilding energy efficiency services market government cultivation behavior,researching respectively from market development issues of the supply anddemand of the market cultivation. It cleared the government motivation ofbuilding energy efficiency services market, and proposed theoretical framework.On this basis of analysis, the government behavior based on supervision andcultural construction are two key markets cultivation behavior.
     The government cultivation behavior based on supervision and culturalconstruction is addressed separately the supply and demand building energysaving service market. On the basis qualitative analysis of the institutionalreasons, the use of game theory, group selection theory and other relatedknowledge constructed government behavior model based on supervision andcultural construction, which explained the government behavior, and thendesigned market cultivation government behavior contracts based on agency byagreement and analyzed the influence of various parameters on the model, to putforward the corresponding control measures to promote construction energyservices market development healthily and orderly.
     Feasible building energy services market cultivation government behaviorpatterns is proposed further, which is, the behaviors based on the supervision andcultural construction embedded into the core of government incentives tomonitor and promote the building energy services market healthy development.
     To validate effectiveness of the mode of government cultivation behaviorbased on supervision and cultural construction, by relative theory of CellularAutomata, government cultivation behavior based on supervision and culturalconstruction is simulated. The evolutionary process of government cultivationbehavior based on supervision and cultural construction and the influence of eachparameter to government behavior are observed clearly and directly so that thesuggestion to regulate the government behavior is proposed pertinently.
     In this paper, focus on current energy efficiency service market developmentproblems and surround the research of the building energy services marketcultivation government behavior, which can further enrich our energy efficiencyservice market cultivation theory and method, in which the supervision andcultural construction of the government behavioral model will be certainsignificance for the building energy efficiency services market.
引文
[1]卢志坚,孙元欣.国外合同能源管理研究及其在中国促进建议[J].科技管理研究,2012,2:38-42.
    [2]沈龙海.“EPC”助推中国节能服务产业发展[J].供热制冷,2011,6:52-53.
    [3]吕荣胜,王建.基于节能服务公司视角的合同能源管理(EPC)应用研究[J].华北电力大学学报(社会科学版),2011,3:1-5.
    [4]解国珍,高原.合同能源管理方法与建筑节能关系探讨[J].化工学报,2008,59(S2):215-218.
    [5] Okay E,Okay N,Konukman A E S,Akman U. Views on Turkey’sImpending ESCO Market: Is It Promising?[J]. Energy Policy,2008,36:1821-1825.
    [6] Bertoldi P,Rezessy S. Energy Service Companies in Europe. Status report2005[R]. Ispra, Italy: European Commission DG Joint Research Center;2005. www.managenergy.net/products/R1742.htm.
    [7] Vine E. An International Survey of the Energy Service Company (ESCO)Industry[J]. Energy Policy,2005,33:691-704.
    [8] Goldman C. Overview of U.S. ESCO Industry: Recent Trends and HistoricPerformance[C]. International Workshop “Energy Efficiency ServicesIndustries”,2003,1-33.
    [9] Patlitzianas K. D.,Psarras J. Formulating a Modern Energy Companies’Environment in the EU Accession Member States Through a DecisionSupport Methodology[J]. Energy Policy,2007,35:2231-2238.
    [10]周伏秋.“十二五”节能服务产业发展前景与趋势[J].中外能源,2011,16(7):26-29.
    [11] Vine E,Nakagami H,Murakoshi C. The Evolution of the US EnergyService Company (ESCO) Industry: From ESCO to Super ESCO[J].Energy,1999,24:479-492.
    [12] Vine E L, Murakoshi C, Nakagami H. International ESCO BusinessOpportunities and Challenges: A Japanese Case Study[J]. Energy,1998,23:439-447.
    [13]韩青苗,张洋,占松林,刘长滨.我国建筑节能服务市场供给分析[J].建筑经济,2008,12:89-92.
    [14]韩青苗,梁俊强,张洋,占松林.我国建筑节能服务市场需求分析[J].建筑经济,2009,2:87-91.
    [15]张佳丽,杨旭彬.合同能源管理引导供热计量与节能改造走出困境[J].建设科技,2013,22:42-44.
    [16]张鑫,冯俊小;.合同能源管理新进展及在工业炉领域的发展建议[J].冶金能源,2013,32(6):3-6.
    [17] Biermann A. ESCOs in the Liberalised Domestic UK EnergyMarkets-Barriers to Establishing ESCOs and Possibilities to OvercomeThem in the UK Energy markets[C]. Proceedings of the2001ECEEESummer Study. Paris, France:European Council for an Energy-EfficientEconomy,2001:437-446.
    [18] Bertoldia P,Berrutto V,Renzio M. How are EU ESCOs Behaving and Howto Create a Real ESCO Market[C]. Proceedings of the2003ECEEESummer Study. Paris, France:European Council for an Energy-EfficientEconomy,2003:909-916.
    [19] Fraser, M. What makes the Canadian ESCO Industry Unique[C].Proceedings of the1996Summer Study on Energy Efficiency in Buildings.Washington (DC):American Council for an Energy Efficient Economy,1996:39-45.
    [20] Poole A,Geller H. The Emerging ESCO Industry in Brazil[R]. AmericanCouncil for Energy Efficient Economy.1997:15-21.
    [21] Murakoshi C, Nakagami H. Present Condition of ESCO Business forCarrying out Climate Change Counter Measures in Japan[C]. Proceedingsof the2003ECEEE Summer Study. Paris, France:European Council for anEnergy-Efficient Economy,2003:885-892.
    [22] Murakoshi C,Nakagami H,Sumizawa T. Exploring the Feasibility of ESCOBusiness in Japan: Demonstration by Experimental Study[C]. Proceedingsof the2000Summer Study on Energy Efficiency in Buildings. Washington(DC):American Council for an Energy Efficient Economy,2000:231-241.
    [23]梁昌祝.合同能源管理在建筑节能改造中应用存在的主要问题及建议[J].墙材革新与建筑节能,2014,3:60-62.
    [24] Davies H A,Chan E K S. Experience of Energy Performance Contracting inHong Kong[J]. Facilities,2001,19:261-268.
    [25] Evan Millsa,Steve Kromerb,Gary Weissc,et al. From Volatility to Value:Analyzing and Managing Financial and Performance Risk in EnergySavings Projects[J]. Energy Policy,2006,34(2):188-199.
    [26] Patlitzianas K D,Doukas H,Psarras J. Designing an Appropriate ESCOs’Environment in the Mediterranean[J]. Management of EnvironmentalQuality,2006,17:538-554.
    [27]马唯婧,郭玥,杨卫红.合同能源管理(EMC)项目风险分析及应对策略[J].中外能源,2014,19(1):92-95.
    [28]尚天成,潘珍妮.合同能源管理项目评价方法[J].中国人口资源与环境,2008,18(3):135-138.
    [29]孙金颖,梁俊强,刘长滨.建筑节能服务市场投融资模式设计与风险分析[J].暖通空调,2007,37(10):7-11.
    [30]吕石磊,武涌.北方采暖区既有建筑节能改造的目标识别和障碍分析[J].暖通空调,2007,9:20-24.
    [31]刘玉明,刘长滨.采暖区既有建筑节能改造外部性分析及应用[J].同济大学学报,2009,11:1521-1525.
    [32]韩青苗,刘长滨,王洪波,梁俊强.基于交易费用理论的建筑节能服务市场分析[J].暖通空调,2007,36(10):1-6.
    [33]贾洪毅,王传良.基于市场机制的建筑节能法律制度思考[J].现代商贸工业,2011,2:225.
    [34] Steve Sorrell et al. The Economics of Energy Efficiency: Barriers toCost-Effective Investment[M]. Massachusetts: Edward Elgar PublishingLimited,2004:275-279.
    [35]荀毅,李颖谦,吴晓红.促进节能服务产业发展的软环境建设研究[J].四川建筑,2011,31(3):16-17.
    [36]祁雪瑞.发展节能服务业的原则与制度[J].企业活力,2007,5:66-68.
    [37]周伏秋,许文,熊华文,等.促进节能服务产业发展的财税政策模式[J].中外能源,2009,14(4):16-22.
    [38]张淑惠.促进节能服务公司发展的税收政策研究[J].税务研究,2008,11:49-50.
    [39]王昕.构建节能服务产业发展支持体系探讨[J].中外能源,2009,14(10):15-19.
    [40]沈超红,谭平,李敏等.合约安排与节能服务项目的市场拓展[J].管理学报,2010,7(11):1660-1664.
    [41] Shireley J Hansen. How Performance Contracting Helps Finance EnergyProjects[J]. Buildings,2008,102(4):72-74.
    [42] Nicole Hopper,Charles Goldman. A Survey of the U.S. ESCO Industry:Market Growth and Development from2000to2006[M]. Environmentalenergy technologies division,2007:25-40.
    [43] Andrew Satchwell,Charles Goldman,Peter Larsen,et al. A Survey of theU.S. ESCO Industry: Market Growth and Development from2008to2011[M]. Environmental energy technologies division,2010:25-40
    [44] Mark J Kaiser,Williams O Olatubi,Allan G Pulsipher. Economic, energy,and environmental impact of the Louisiana Energy Fund[J]. Energy Policy,2005,33(7):873-883.
    [45] Charles Goldman,Nieole C Hopper,Julie G. Osborn. Review of US ESCOIndustry Market Trends: An Empirical Analysis of Project Data[J]. EnergyPolicy,2005,33(3):387-405.
    [46]唐敬春,张琪.促进EPC发展的税收政策分析[J].涉外税务,2009,7:32-35.
    [47] Steve Sorrell. The Economies of Energy Service Contracts[J]. EnergyPolicy,2007,5(1):507-521.
    [48]林伯强.能源合同管理:节能减排的市场化模式[J].环境经济,2008,5:36-40.
    [49]孙鹏程,刘应宗,梁俊强等.建筑节能领域的政府失灵及其对策[J].建筑科学,2007,23(12):1-6.
    [50]金占勇,武涌,刘长滨.基于外部性分析的北方供暖地区既有居住建筑节能改造经济激励政策设计[J].暖通空调,2007,37(9):14-19.
    [51] Paolo Bertoldia,Silvia Rezessyb,Edward Vine. Energy Service CompaniesIn European Countries: Current Status and a Strategy to Foster TheirDevelopment[J]. Energy Policy,2006,34:1818-1832.
    [52]柳晓雷,杨莹,李晓丹等.北京市合同能源管理发展现状[J].节能与环保,2008,4:18-20.
    [53]张舒怡,黄志烨.关系型贷款在中小型节能服务公司融资中应用[J].工程管理学报,2010,24(2):220-225.
    [54] Paolo Bertoldia,Silvia Rezessyb,Edward Vine. Energy Service CompaniesIn European Countries: Current Status and a Strategy to Foster TheirDevelopment[J]. Energy Policy,2006,34:1818-1832.
    [55] Poole A D,Stoner T H. Alternative Financing Models for Energy EfficiencyPerformance Contracting[C]. Workshop:“developing the business ofenergy efficiency performance contracting”,2003. http://3countryee.org/Perform-Contract/.
    [56] Hamada Y,Nakamura M,Ochifuji K,et al. Development of a Database ofLow Energy Homes around the World and Analyses of Their Trends[J].Renewable Energy,2003,28(2):321-328.
    [57] Henri L F de Groot,Erik T Verhoef,Peter Nijkamp. Energy Saving by Firms:Decision-making, Barriers and Policies[J]. Energy Economics,2001,23(6)717-740.
    [58] Andrew J Friedland,Tillman U Gerngross,Richard B Howarth. PersonalDecisions and Their Impacts on Energy Use and the Environment[J].Environmental Science&Policy,2003,6(2)175-179.
    [59] William H Golove,Joseph H Eto. Market Barriers to Energy Efficiency: Acritical Reappraisal of the Rationale for Public Policies to Promote EnergyEfficiency[M]. Berkeley,California:Energy&Environment Division,1996:27-34.
    [60] Effrey A Drezner. Designing Effective Incentives for Energy Conservationin the Public Sector[D]. California:Doctor Dissertation of the ClaremontGraduate University.1999:74-88.
    [61] N. W. A. Lidula,N. Mithulananthan,W. Ongsakul,et al. ASEAN towardsClean and Sustainable Energy: Potentials, Utilization and Barriers[J].Renewable Energy,2006,31(6)1-11.
    [62] Joe Huang. Incentive Programs to Go Beyond Building EnergyStandards[C]. Proceedings of the International Workshop on BuildingEnergy Efficiency Policy,2006,3:80-114.
    [63] Roger W Amstalden,Miehael Kost,Carston Nathani. Economic Potential ofEnergy-Efficient Retrofitting in the Swiss Residential Building Sector: TheEffects of Policy Instruments and Energy Price Expectations[J]. EnergyPolicy,2007,35:1819-1829.
    [64] Jonas Nassen,Franees Sprei,John Holmberg. Stagnating energy efficiencyin the Swedish Building Sector-Economic and OrganizationalExplanations[J]. Energy Policy,2008,36:3814-3822.
    [65] Marianne Ryghaug,Knut H. S rensen. How energy efficiency fails in thebullding industry[J]. Energy Policy,2009,37:984-991.
    [66] Jonathan G Koomeya,Carrie A Webbera,Celina S Atkinsona. AddressingEnergy-Related Challenges for the US Buildings Sector: Results from theClean Energy Futures Study[J]. Energy Policy,2001,29:1209-1221.
    [67] Holmstrom B and P Milgrom. Aggregation and Linearity in the Provision ofIntertemporal Incentives[J]. Econometrica,1987,55(2):303-328.
    [68] Core J and W Guay. Stock option Plans for Non-executive Employees[J].Journal of Financial Economics,2001,61:253-287.
    [69] Prendergast C. The Tenuous Trade-off between Risk and Incentives[J].Journal of Political Economy,2002,110:1071-1102.
    [70] Jean Jacques Laffont,David Martimort. The Theory of Incentives: ThePrincipal-Agent Model[M]. UK:Princeton university press,2002:187-302.
    [71]韩青苗,刘长滨,张洋,金占勇.非对称信息下既有建筑节能改造经济激励合约设计[J].土木工程学报,2009,8:29-133.
    [72]龙惟定.民用建筑怎样实现降低20%能耗的目标[J].暖通空调,2006,36(6):35-41.
    [73] Nic Rivers,Mark Jaccard. Choice of Environmental Policy in the Presenceof Learning by Doing[J]. Energy Economics,2006,28(3):223-242.
    [74] Milou Beerepoot,Niels Beerepoot. Government Regulation as an Impetusfor Innovation: Evidence from Energy Performance Regulation in the DutchResidential Building Sector[J]. Energy Policy,2007,35(10):4812-4825.
    [75] Elhanan He1pman,Laffont Jearl-Jacques. On Moral Hazard in GeneralEquilibrium Theory[J]. Journal of Economies Theory,1975,10:8-23.
    [76] Rothschild M,Stiglitz J. Equilibrium in Competitive Insurance Market[J].Quarterly Journal of Economics,1976,90:629-649.
    [77] Lazear E,S. Rosen. Rank Order Tournaments as optimal Labor Contracts[J].Journal of Political Economy,1981,89:84-864.
    [78]何丹,邓瑛鹏,王聪.重庆推动建筑绿色化创新机制研究与实践[J].建设科技,2013,24:26-30.
    [79]徐振强.我国省级地方政府绿色建筑激励政策研究与顶层政策设计建议[J].建设科技,2014,2:56-64.
    [80]白洋.外部性理论与促进低碳经济发展的财税政策[J].经济师,2014,1:82-83.
    [81]郁聪,康艳兵.国内外节能政策的回顾及强化我国节能政策的建议[J].中国能源,2003,25(10):4-14.
    [82]谢治国,胡化凯.关于节能项目经济评价方法的分析与修正[J].系统工程学报,2007,22(3):323-327.
    [83]龙惟定,白玮,马素贞,等.我国建筑节能服务体系的发展[J].暖通空调,2008,38(7):36-43.
    [84]王洪波,梁俊强,刘长滨.建筑节能服务公司的信息传递博弈模型[J].暖通空调,2007,37(10):12-16.
    [85]张仕廉,蔡贺年,朴国峰.合同能源管理项目信用缺失及对策研究[J].建筑经济,2009,1:55-58.
    [86]冯小平,李少洪,龙惟定.既有建筑节能改造应用合同能源管理的模式分析[J].建筑经济,2009,3:54-57.
    [87] Jessica Henryson,Teresa Hakansson,Jurek Pyrko. Energy Efficiency inBuildings Through Information-Swedish Perspective[J]. Energy Policy,2000,28:169-180.
    [88] Luis Lopes,Shuichi Hokoi,Hisashi Miura. Energy Efficiency and EnergySavings in Japanese Residential Buildings-Research Methodology andSurveyed Results[J]. Energy and Buildings,2005,37:698-706.
    [89]李宝琴.行为经济学述评[J].新疆师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2003,24(4):150-153.
    [90]乔洪武,刘国华.行为经济学与主流经济学:两个基本概念辨析[J].武汉大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2006,59(1):62-68.
    [91]肖斌.经济学与心理学的融合——行为经济学述评[J].当代经济研究,2006,7:23-26.
    [92]于全辉.基于有限理性假设的行为经济学分析[J].经济问题探索,2006,7:20-23.
    [93] Kenneth J. Arrow et al. The Rational Foundations of Economic Behavior[C],Proceedings of International Economic Association Conference Volumes,Turin, Italy,1996:213-306.
    [94] Arrow K J. Methodological individualism and social knowledge[J]. TheAmerican Economic Review,1994,84(2):1-9.
    [95] Coase R. H. The Problem of Social Cost[J]. Journal of Law andEconomics,1960,3:1-44.
    [96]刘尊棋,吉布尼等.简明不列颠百科全书[M].北京:中国大百科全书出版社,1985:47-66.
    [97] The International Commission for the Study of Communications Problems(McBride Commission). Many Voices, One World (The McBride Report)
    [R]. United Nations Educational Scientifical Cultural Organization,1981:4-20.
    [98]张俊伟.极简管理:中国式管理操作系统[M].北京:机械工业出版社,2013:115-178.
    [99]茵明杰.产业经济学[M].上海:上海财经大学出版社。2005:54-55.
    [100]Porter M E. Competitive Strategy[M]. Free Press.2004:53-188.
    [101]Londregan J. Entry and Exit over the Industry Life Cycle[J]. The RandJournal of Economics,1990:446-458.
    [102]Myles G D. Public Economics[M]. UK:Cambridge University Press,1995:58-70.
    [103]孙洁.城市基础设施的公私合作管理模式研究[D].同济大学.2005:34-39.
    [104]万冬君.小城镇基础设施投融资政府行为研究[D].哈尔滨工业大学.2006:21-22.
    [105]亨廷顿,周琪等译.文明的冲突与世界秩序的重建[M].北京:新华出版社,2002:63-65.
    [106]Taylor P D, Jonker L B. Evolutionarily Stable Strategy and GameDynamics[J].Math Biosci,1978,40:145-156.
    [107]张维迎.博弈论与信息经济学[M].上海:上海人民出版社,2004:54-124.
    [108]Friedman D.Evolutionary game in economics[J]. Econometrics,1991,5:637-666.
    [109]George A Akerlof. The Market for “Lemons”: Quality Uncertainty and theMarket Mechanism[J]. The Quarterly Journal of Economics,1970,84(3),488-500.
    [110]Bierly, P E and Hamalainen, T. Organizational learning and strategy[J].Scandinavian Journal of Management,1995,11(3):209-224.
    [111]Hedberg B. How Organizations Learn and Unlearn[M], in Nystrom, P C,Starbuck, W H (Eds), Handbook of Organizational Design, OxfordUniversity Press,Oxford,1981,3-27.
    [112]Fiol C M and Lyles M A. Organizational Learning[J]. Academy ofManagement Review,1985,10(4):803-813.
    [113]Ploanyi M. The Tacit Dimension[M]. University Of Chicago Press,2009:31-49.
    [114]Collins C J and Smith K G. Knowledge Exchange and Combination: TheRole of Human Resource Practices in the Performance of High-technologyFirms[J]. Academy of management Review,2006,49(3):544-560.
    [115]Henrich J. Cultural Transmission and the Diffusion of Innovations:Adoption dynamics indicate that biased cultural transmission is thepredominate force in behavioral change and much of socioculturalevolution[J]. American Anthropologist,2001,103:992-1013.
    [116]Sober, E, Wilson D S et al. Unto Others: The Evolution and Psychology ofUnselfish Behavior[M]. Harvard Univ. Press,Cambridge,MA,1998,279-377.
    [117]]Wilson D S and Sober E. Re-introducing Group Selection to the HumanBehavioral Sciences[J]. Behavioral and Brain Sciences,1994,17:585-654.
    [118]Zywicki T J. Was Hayek Right About Group Selection After All?. ReviewEssay of Unto Others: The Evolution and Psychology of Unselfish Behavior,by Elliott Sober and David Sloan Wilson[J]. Review of AustrianEconomies,2000,13:81-95.
    [119]Cowan R, Jonard N and Zimmermann J B. Evolving Networks ofInventors[J]. Journal of Evolutionary Economics,2006,16(1):155-174.
    [120]Bastien Chopard and Maichel Droze. Cellular Automata Modeling ofPhysical Systems[M]. Cambridge Univ Press,1998:245-263.
    [121]Wolfram S. Cellular Automata as Models of Complexity[M]. Nature,1984,311(4):419-424.
    [122]Wolfram S. Universality and Complexity in Cellular automata[J]. PhysicaD,1984,10:1-35.
    [123]来向红,王文平.基于元胞自动机的知识型组织中知识传播过程仿真研究[J].管理学报,2006,5:514-518.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700