中国房地产市场与宏观经济运行的关联性研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
房地产市场不仅与我国经济发展息息相关,并且与国民经济各部门的发展都有着至关重要的联系。房地产价格对于房地产市场具有显著影响,不仅关系到人民生活水平,也对国民经济的稳定发展具有十分重要的作用。我国房地产投资增长率不仅远高于固定资产投资增长率和GDP增长率,同时我国房地产增加值占国民经济总量的比重也在逐年增加,房地产开发投资额占全社会固定资产投资的比重也呈现出日益增长的趋势,房地产业已经成为我国国民经济的支柱性产业之一。
     本文运用了许多动态经济计量和时间序列分析方法研究房地产市场相关变量与宏观经济运行之间的关联性问题。我们首先通过对我国房地产价格在经济增长过程中存在的结构转变来了解我国房地产市场的走势及其与我国经济增长之间的对应关系。我们构建双变量结构转变模型,结果发现我国商品房销售价格指数与我国GDP增长率双变量结构转变模型是显著的,从模型的估计结果可以看出我国商品房销售价格指数与我国GDP增长率双变量结构转变模型存在显著的结构转变点。由结构转变点可以将总样本区间划分为4个子样本区间,我们采用子样本区间参数估计方法分别对4个子样本区间分别进行参数估计,发现截距估计值在第一个子样本区间内最大,在第四个子样本区间内最小,随时间发展呈现出逐级递减的趋势,斜率估计值在第一个子样本区间和第四个子样本区间为负数,而在第二个子样本区间和第三个子样本区间为正数,而可以看出解释能力在第三个子样本区间内解释能力最强,在第一个子样本区间内我国商品房销售价格指数对GDP增长率解释能力最弱。
     接下来我们应用单位根检验、VAR模型、Granger因果关系检验、脉冲响应函数和方差分解等计量经济学方法,对我国房地产市场与经济增长之间的相互关系,从多方面、多视角进行进一步的综合实证检验与分析,从而试图探寻我国房地产市场与经济增长之间的关联性和影响程度。我们使用GDP增长率和工业增加值增长率两种变量来表征我国经济增长,以商品房销售额同比增长率数据来表征我国房地产市场的发展水平。通过检验我们发现,我国商品房销售额增长率对GDP增长率序列具有较为显著的影响作用,而GDP增长率对商品房销售额增长率的影响则并不十分显著。通过我国商品房销售额增长率与GDP增长率的趋势成分以及波动成分之间的相互影响关系检验我们都发现,我国商品房销售额增长率能够显著影响GDP增长率,而GDP增长率对我国商品房销售额增长率的影响程度依然相对较为微弱。而我们以工业增加值增速来表征经济增长时,得到了相同的结论。
     其次,我们通过对我国房地产价格以及通货膨胀率的波动过程对比来了解我国房地产市场的走势及其与我国通货膨胀率之间的对应关系。我们通过利用马尔科夫区制转移模型对我国商品房价格同比增长率数据与我国通货膨胀率数据分别进行计算检验,以判别我国房地产市场和通货膨胀之间的关联与区别。估计结果表明我国商品房价格的月度同比增长率存在明显的两区制特征,即高增长区制和低增长区制,我国商品房价格月度同比增长率在低增长区制的平均持续期为5.1867个月,而在高增长区制的平均持续期为18.1159个月。我国通货膨胀率滞后1阶的马尔科夫区制转移模型的估计结果也表明我国通货膨胀率存在明显的两区制特征,我国通货膨胀率在低增长区制的平均持续期为14.8588个月,而在高增长区制的平均持续期为15.2672个月。可见我国通货膨胀率数据区制转移的次数较少,而在每个区制的持续期则较长。
     然后,我们对我国房地产市场与主要宏观经济变量之间的相互关系分别进行实证检验与分析。我们通过检验发现通货膨胀率对我国商品房销售价格增长率的影响较弱,名义利率对我国商品房价格的影响具有一定程度的滞后性,贷款增长率对我国商品房销售价格增长率的影响非常显著,但商品房销售价格增长率对贷款增长率的影响系数较小。方差分解结果表明贷款增长率对商品房销售价格增长率序列的贡献率始终保持在28%左右。投资增长率对我国商品房销售价格增长率的影响较小,Granger因果关系检验表明投资增长率序列不能Granger影响我国商品房销售价格增长率序列,方差分解结果表明我国投资增长率序列对商品房销售价格增长率序列的贡献率很小。我国商品房销售价格增长率对消费增长率的影响系数较小,而消费增长率对我国商品房销售价格增长率的影响较显著。方差分解结果表明消费增长率序列对商品房销售价格增长率序列的贡献率在第10期为4.7799%。
     最后,我们对我国房地产市场与我国其他主要市场之间的相互关系分别进行实证检验与分析,从而探寻我国房地产市场与我国其他主要市场之间的关联性和影响程度。我们首先检验我国商品房销售价格与股票市场之间的相关关系,发现滞后一阶和滞后二阶的股票市场对我国商品房销售价格增长率的影响都非常微弱,股票市场对商品房销售价格增长率序列的贡献率也较小。债券市场对我国商品房销售价格增长率的影响较小,债券市场序列能够略微Granger影响我国商品房销售价格增长率序列,方差分解结果表明债券市场对商品房销售价格增长率序列的贡献率在第10期才上升至1.9242%。汇率增长率对我国商品房销售价格增长率具有一定的影响,方差分解结果表明汇率增长率对商品房销售价格增长率序列的贡献率到第10期上升为3.3153%。货币增长率对我国商品房销售价格增长率没有影响,方差分解结果表明货币市场对商品房销售价格增长率序列的贡献率在第2期为0.0601%,然后逐渐下降。商品房销售价格增长率对汽车产量增长率的影响系数非常显著,而汽车产量增长率对我国商品房销售价格增长率几乎没有影响。
Real estate market is closely related not only to economic development and thedevelopment of national economy sectors have a vital link. For the real estate marketreal estate prices have a significant impact, not only to the people's living standards,but also the stable development of the national economy has a very important role.China's real estate investment growth rate is not only much higher than the fixed assetinvestment growth and GDP growth, while accounting for the added value of our realestate economy is also growing proportion of the total real estate development andinvestment accounted for in fixed asset investment also showed the proportion of thegrowing trend, real estate has become a pillar industry of China is one of the nationaleconomy.
     In this paper, a number of dynamic econometric and time series analysis of thereal estate market-related variables and the relationship between macroeconomicissues. We first of our real estate prices in the process of economic growth, structuralchanges to the existing understanding of China's real estate market trends andeconomic growth in China's correspondence. We constructed two-variable model ofstructural change and found that sales of commercial housing price index for GDPgrowth of two-variable model of structural change is significant, estimated from themodel results show that sales of commercial housing price index and the structure ofChina's GDP growth rate of two-variable significant changes in the structure of modeltransition point. By the structural change point total sample interval can be dividedinto4sub-sample interval, we use the sub-sample interval estimation methods aresub-sample interval of4to estimate the parameters, respectively, and found that theintercept estimates range in the first sub-sample of the largest in the The fourthsub-sample of the smallest interval, step by step over time showing a decreasing trend,the slope estimates range in the first and fourth sub-sub-sample of the sample interval is negative, the sample interval in the second and third sub-sub-sample interval ispositive, it can be seen in the third sub-sample explanatory power to explain thestrongest interval, sample interval in the first sub-housing sales price index of GDPgrowth to explain the weakest.
     Next, we applied unit root test, VAR model, Granger causality test, impulseresponse function and variance decomposition econometric methods, and therelationship between economic growth and the real estate market, in many ways,multi-angle further Comprehensive empirical testing and analysis, which attempts toexplore the real estate market and the relationship between economic growth andimpact. We use the GDP growth rate and growth rate of industrial added value of twovariables to characterize China's economic growth to year growth rate of real estatesales data to characterize the development level of China's real estate market.Through testing we found that our rate of growth of the GDP growth rate of realestate sales sequence has more significant influence, while the growth rate of GDPgrowth rates of real estate sales are not very significant. Through our real estate salestrend growth rate and GDP growth volatility component composition and therelationships between the test we found that growth rates of real estate sales cansignificantly affect the GDP growth rate, while the GDP growth rate of real estatesales in China influence the growth rate is still relatively weak. The growth rate ofindustrial added value to our characterization of economic growth, have the sameconclusion.
     We adopted our real estate prices and the volatility of inflation compared to theprocess of understanding the trend of the real estate market and its relationship withChina the correspondence between the rate of inflation. We use Markov regimeswitching model year growth rate of house price inflation data and the data of testswere calculated to determine the real estate market and the relationship betweeninflation and difference. Our estimation results show that the monthly house pricegrowth year on year there are obvious characteristics of the two-district system, thatsystem of high-growth areas and low-growth areas in the system, my monthly houseprice growth in the low-growth year on year, the average duration of the districtsystem was5.1867months, high-growth areas in the system, the average duration is 18.1159months. China's inflation rate lagged1-order Markov regime switchingmodel estimation results also show that China's inflation rate system there areobvious characteristics of the two areas, China's inflation rate in the low-growth areas,the average duration of the system was14.8588months high-growth areas in thesystem, the average duration is15.2672months. Our data shows the rate of inflationless the number of regime switching, and in the duration of each district system islonger.
     We study our real estate market and the main macroeconomic variables,respectively, the relationship between the empirical test and analysis. We test showedthat the rate of inflation on real estate sales prices of the impact of weaker growth inthe nominal interest rate of commercial housing prices in China have a certain degreeof lag, the loan growth rate of prices of the impact of sales of commercial property isvery significant, but growth rate of commercial housing sales price impact of loangrowth coefficient is small. Variance decomposition results show that the loan growthrate of real estate sales prices contributed the sequence is always maintained at about28%. Investment growth rate on real estate sales prices of the impact of lower growth,Granger causality test showed that the growth rate of investment is not Grangersequence of growth of commercial housing sales price series, the variancedecomposition results show that the sequence of investment growth rate of real estatesales prices sequence of a small contribution. Growth rate of real estate sales priceson consumption growth rate of the coefficient is small, while the consumption growthrate of real estate sales prices of the impact of more significant growth. Variancedecomposition results show that the consumption growth rate series of real estatesales prices in the contribution rate of the sequence is4.7799%.
     Finally, our real estate market and other major markets of the relationshipbetween the empirical test and analysis were to explore the Real Estate Market andother major markets in China and the relationship between the degree of influence.We first examined the sales price of real estate and stock market correlation betweenthe found behind the first and second lag of stock market prices of real estate sales arevery weak growth rate of the stock market to real estate sales price growth sequencecontribution rate is also smaller. Bond market growth rate of commercial housing sales price less affected, the bond market can be a little Granger sequence of growthof commercial housing sales price series, the variance decomposition results showthat the bond market, the price growth rate series of real estate sales in thecontribution rate was rose to1.9242percent. Exchange rate on the growth ofcommercial housing sales price has some effect, the exchange rate variancedecomposition results show that the rate of growth of real estate sales pricescontributed to the sequence rose to3.3153%. Money growth rate on the sales price ofreal estate did not affect the variance decomposition results show that the moneymarket rate series of real estate sales prices in the contribution rate is0.0601%, andthen gradually declined. Sales of commercial vehicle production growth rate of pricegrowth in the influence of significant factors, and vehicle production growth rate ofChina's real estate sales prices had little impact.
引文
[1] Abraham, J. and Hender shott, P. H.,“Bubbles in metropolitan housing markets”, J. HousingRes,1995, pp6,191-207.
    [2] A. F. Burns,“Long Cycles in Residential Construction”, Economic Essays in Honor of WesleyClair Mitchell.(New York,1935), pp.63-104;
    [3] Allen, F., Morris, S.,“A. Finite bubbles with short sale constraints and asymmetricinformation”, Journal of Economic Theory, vol.61,1993, pp.206-229.
    [4] Allen, F. and Gale, D,“Optimal Financial Crises”, Journal of Finance, vol.53,1998, pp.1245-1284.
    [5]Allen, F. and D. Gale,“Comparing Financial Systems”, MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts(forthcoming),1999.
    [6]Allen, F. and Gale, D,“Bubble and Crises”, Economic Journal, vol.110,2000, pp236-255.
    [7]Alexander Ludwig, A. and T. Sl?k(2002),“The Impact of Changes in Stock Pricesand HousePrices on Consumption in OECD Countries”, IMF Working Papers, No. WP/02/1.
    [8]Bertrand Reynaud,“The1985-1994Global Real Estate Cycle: Its Causes and Consequences”,Policy Research Working Paper of the World Bank,1995.
    [9]Bernake, Ben S and Mark Gertler,“Monetary policy and asset price volatility”, FederalReserve Bank of Kansas City Economic Review,2000, vol84, p17-51.
    [10]Bernake, Ben S,“Asset price bubbles and monetary policy”, speech given before theNewYork Chapter of the National Association four Business Economists,2002,15October.
    [11]Blanchard, O. and Waston,“Bubbles, Rational Expectations and Financial Makers. In theEconomic and Financial Structure”, ed. P. Wachtel, Lexington, Mass: Health,1982.
    [12]Blanchard, Oliver J. and Stanley Fisher,“Lectures on Macroeconomics”, the MIT Press,1989.
    [13]Boone, L., N. Girouard(2002),“The Stock Market, The Housing Market And ConsumerBehaviour”, OECD, Economics Department, Working Papers, No.35
    [14]Bordo, Michael and Oliver Jeanne,“Boom-busts in asset prices, economic instability, andmonetary policy”, NBER working paper, no8966.
    [15]Born, W. L. and S. A. Pyhrr.“Real Estate Valuation: The Effect of Market and PropertyCycles”, Journal of Real Estate Research,1994,9:4,455–85.
    [16]Brown G. R.,“Duration and Risk”, Journal of Real Estate Research,2000,20(3):337-356.
    [17]Burns, AF.,“Long Cycles in Residential Construction”, Economic Essays in Honor of WesleyClair Mitchell[M], Columbia University Press, NY,1935.
    [18]Campbell, J. Y. and Kyle, A. S.,“Smart money, Noise Trading, and Stock Price Behavior”,NBER Technical Working Paper72.
    [19]Carey, Mark S.,“Feeding the Fad: the Federal Land Banks, Land Market Efficiency, and theFarm Credit Crisis”, Ph. D. dissertation, University of California at erkeley,1990.
    [20]Case, K. E., and Shiller, R. J.,“The efficiency of the market for single-family homes”, Am.Econ. Rev.79,1989, pp.125-137.
    [21]Case KE.,“The Real Estate Cycle and the Economy: Consequences of the MassachusettsBoom of1984-87”. Urban Studies,1992,29(2):171-183
    [22]Case, Karl;Quigley, John and Shiller, Robert,“Comparing Wealth Effects: the stock marketversus the housing market”, National Bureau of Economic Research, Working Paper,2001,no.8606, November.
    [23]Charles Collyns and Abdelhak,“Senhadji Lending Booms, Real Estate Bubbles and TheAsian Crisis”. IMF Working Paper, January,2002,1-46.
    [24]Clayton J.,“Market Fundamentals, Risk and the Canadian Property Cycle: Implications forProperty Valuation and Investment Decision”, Journal of Real Estate Research,1996,12(3):347-367.
    [25]Davis, Philip and Haibin Zhu,“Bank leading and commercial property cycles: somecrosscountry evidence”, BIS Working Papers, no.150.
    [26]Delong, J. B., Shleifer, A., Summers, L. H. and Waldmann, R. J.,“Positive FeedbackInvestment Strategies and Destabilizing Rational Speculation”, The Journal of Finance, Vol.45,1990, p379-395.
    [27]Dynarski, M., and S. M. Sheffrin.,“Housing purchases and transitory income: A study withpanel data”, Review of Economics and Statistics,1985,67(2):195-204.
    [28]Feiger, G.,“What is Speculation?”, Quarterly Journal of Economics,1976,90:667-687.
    [29]Flood. Robert P. and Peter M. Garber,“Market Fundamentals versus Price-level Bubbles: TheFirst Tests”, Journal of political Economy,1980,88, pp.745-770.
    [30]Fred E. Case,“A Systematic Introduction(Los Angeles: California Association)”, Real EstateEconomics:1974, pp.102-105.
    [31]Froot, K. A., Obstfeld, M.,“Intrinsic bubbles: The case of stock prices”, American EconomicReview,1991,81,1189–1214.
    [32]Garber Peter M(1990),“Famous First Bubbles,”Journal of Economic Perspectives,14, no.2,pp.35-54.
    [33]Grebler L.;Burns LS1. Source,“Real Estate Economics”, June1982, vol.10, no.2, pp.123-151(29).
    [34]Goodhart, C. A. E. and B. Hoffmann,“Do Asset Prices Help Predict Consumer Price”,2000.
    [35]Grebler, Leo and Leland Burns,“Construction Cycles in the United States Since World WarII”, Journal of the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association,1982,10:123-151.
    [36]Hamilton, J.,“On Testing for Self-fulfilling Speculative Price Bubbles”, InternationalEconomic Review,1986, l.27:545-552.
    [37]Hamilton, J. and C. Whiteman,“The Observable Implications of Self-fulfilling”, Expectations,Journal of Monetary Economics,1985,16:353-373.
    [38]Harrison, J M.,&Kreps, D M.,“Speculative Invester Behaviour in a Stock Market withHeterogeneous Expectation”, Quaterly Journal of Economics,1978,92:323-336.
    [39]Haurin, Donald R.,“Income Variability, Homeownership, and Housing Demand”, Journal ofHousing Economics,1991,1:60-74.
    [40]Hausman, Jerry A.,“A Specification Test for Speculative Bubble”, Quarterly JournalofEcomomics,1987, August.
    [41]Hekman, John,“Rental Price Adjustment and Investment in the Office Market”, Journal ofthe American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association,1985,13(1):32-47.
    [42]Helbling, ThomasF,“Housing Price Bubbles-A Tale Based on Housing Price Booms andBusts”, This paper draws on Chapter II of the April2003World Economic Outlook, IMF,2003.
    [43]Herring, Richard and Susan Wachter,“Real estate booms and banking busts: an internationalperspective”, The Wharton Financial Institutions Center,1999, WP9927.
    [44]Herring, Richard and Susan Wachter,“Bubbles in Real Estate Markets”, Zell Lurie RealEstate Center Working Paper402, March2002.
    [45]Henrik, L., Michael, T.,“Flexibility and Uncertainty in the Housing Market”, InternationalReview of Law and Economics,1999,18:419-431.
    [46]Hilbers, Paul, Qin Lei and Lisbeth Zacho,“Real estate marker developments and financialsector soundness”, IMF Working Papers,2001.
    [47]Hicks, John R.,“Value and Capital”,2nd. ed., New York: Oxford University Press,1939.
    [48]Hofmann, Boris,“The determinants of private sector credit in industrialized countries: doproperty prices matter?”,2001, BIS Working Papers, no.108.118
    [49]Homer Hoyt,“A Method for Measuring the Value of Imports into an Urban Community”,Land Economics, Vol.37, No.2(May,1961), pp.150-161.
    [50]Jean Tirole,1982,"On the Possibility of Speculation under Rational Expectations",Econometrica, Vol.50, No.5, pp.1163-1182.
    [51]Kaiser R.,“The Long Cycle in Real Estate”. Jour-nal of Real Estate Research,1997,14(3):233-257.
    [52]Kindleberger, C. P., Manias,“Panics and Crashes: A Hisory of Financial Crises”, Basic Books,New York,1996.
    [53]Krugman, P.,“Bubble, Boom, Crash: Theoretical Notes on Asia”s Crises”, Workingpaper,MIT, Cambridge, Massachussetts,1998.
    [54]Kummerow, M.,“A System Dynamics Model of Cyclical Office Over supply”, Journal ofReal Estate Research,1999,18(1):233-255.
    [55]Levin, E. J., Wright, R. E.,“The impact of speculation on house prices in the UnitedKingdom”, Econ. Modell.1997,14,567-585.
    [56]Lynn Elaine Browne,“U. S. Economic Performance: Good Fortune, Bubble, or New Era?”,New England Economic Review,1999, May/June.
    [57]Mishkin, H. P.,“The Financial Instablity Hypothesis, In Financila Crisis: Theory, Historyand Policy”, ed. C. P. Kindleberger and J. P. Laffargue, Cambridge University Press,1982.
    [58]Mishkin, Federic S.,“The Transmission Mechanism and the Role of Asset Prices in MonetaryPolicy,”NBER, Working Paper,2001, NO.867.
    [59]Muellbauer, J., Murphy A.,“Booms and busts in the UK housing market”, Centre forEconomic Policy Research Discussion Paper,1997, No.1615.
    [60]Mueller, G. R.,“Real Estate Rental Growth Rates at Different Points in the Physical MarketCycle”, Journal of Real Estate Research,1999,18(1):131-150.
    [61]Mueller, G. R, S. Laposa.,“Rent Distributions Under Alternative Market Cycles”, Paperpresented at the Twelfth Annual Meeting of the American Real Estate Society, South LakeTahoe, CA, March28,1996
    [62]Muth, J. F.,“Rational Expectations and The Theory of Price Movements”, Econometrica29,July1961, p315-335.
    [63]Okina, Kunio, Masaaki and Shigenori Shiratsuka,“The asset price bublle and monetarypolicy: experience if Japan”s economy in the late1980s and its lessons”, Monetary andEconomic Studies, Bank of Japan,2001, p395-450.
    [64]Patric, H. H. and Robert J. H.,“On Measuring Real Estate Risk”, Real Estate Finance(RFN),Vol.18, Iss.4, Winter2002, p35-40
    [65]Pritchett, Clayton,“Forecasting the Impact of Real Estate Cycles on Investment”, Real EstateReview,1984, Vol.13, No.4, pp.85-89.
    [66]Quigley, John M,“Real Estate and the Asian Crisis”, Program on Housing and Urban PolicyWorking Paper Series,2001, Working No. W99-008.
    [67]Salge, M.,“Rational Bubbles—Theoretical Basis, Economic Relevance, and EmpiricalEvidence with a Special Emphasis on the German Stock Market”, Published bySpringer-Verlag,1996.
    [68]Samuelson, P. A.,“Indeterminacy of Development in a Heterogeneous Capital Model withConstant Saving Propensity”, In Shell, Karl, ed., Essays on the Theory of Optimal EconomicGrowth. Cambridge: MIT Press,1967.
    [69]Shiller, R. J.,“Speculative Prices and Popolar Models”, Journal of Economic Perspectives,Vol.4, No.2, p55-65,1990.
    [70]Shiller, R. J.,“Rational expectations and the dynamic structure of macroeconomic models: Acritical review”, Journal of Monetary Economics,1997,5,1–44.
    [71]Stigliz, Joseph E.,“Symposium on Bubbles”, Journal of Economic Perspectives,1990, Vol4,no.2.
    [72]Stephen A. Stephen E. Roulac, Waldol. Born,“Real Estate Cycles and Their StrategicImplications for Investors and portfolio Managers in the Global Economy,”Journal of RealEstate Research,1999, Volume18, Number1,7-68.
    [73]Takatoshi, I., Tokuo, I.,“Expaining Asset Bubbles in Japan”, NBER, working paper,1995, No.5358.
    [74]Taylor, M. P., Sarno, L.,“Capital flows to developing countries: long-and short-termdeterminants”, World Bank Economic Review,1995,11,451–470.
    [75]Wheaton, William,“The Cyclical Behavior of the National Office Market”, Journal of theAmerican Real Estate and Urban Economics Association, pp.281-299.
    [76]Wong Kar-jiu,“Housing Market Bubbles and Currency Crisis: The Case of Thailand,Presented at the International Conference on “The Asia Crisis: The Economics Front” Held inSeattle”, December29-30,1998.
    [1]包宗华,关于泡沫经济与房地产业[J],中国房地产,2003(9)。
    [2]鲍小飞,房地产市场泡沫的形成和预警[D],复旦大学博士论文,2005。
    [3]曹振良,房地产泡沫与泡沫经济[J],中国房地产,2000(2)。
    [4]曹振良,泡沫理论分析框架与中国房地产相关实证[J],贵州财经学院学报,2006(5)。
    [5]曹振良、傅十和,房地产泡沫及其防范[J],中国房地产,2000(2)。
    [6]曹振良、李晟,论房地产业在我国产业结构调整中的战略地位[J],南开经济研究,1995(6)。
    [7]陈守东、马辉、才元,中国房地产业投资与经济增长的实证研究[J],未来与发展,2006(5)。
    [8]陈则明,房地产泡沫、房地产热与景气周期的学术观点辨析[J],理论探索与争鸣,2004(1)。
    [9]丁烈云,房地产周期波动成因分析[J],华中科技大学学报(社会科学版),2003(2)。
    [10]丰雷、朱勇、谢经荣,中国地产泡沫实证研究[J],管理世界,2002(10)。
    [11]关涛,房地产经济周期的微观解释:行为经济学方法与实证研究[D],复旦大学博士论文,2005。
    [12]桂荷发,信贷扩张资产价格泡沫与政策挑战[J],财贸经济,2004(7)。
    [13]郭丽芬,中国房地产业周期研究[D],西安建筑科技大学硕士论文,2003。
    [14]郝丁,我国房地产经济波动与金融风险防范研究[D],西南财经大学博士论文,2006。
    [15]何国钊、曹振良、李晟,中国房地产周期研究[J],经济研究,1996(12)。
    [16]何虹,城市地价高涨及地价稳定措施研究[D],华东师范大学博士论文,2006。
    [17]洪开荣,房地产泡沫的形成、吸收与转化[J],中国房地产金融,2001(8)。
    [18]胡健颖等,中国房地产价格有几成泡沫[J],统计研究,2006(1)。
    [19]胡瑾卿、张大亮,房地产泡沫测评体系研究[J],城市开发,2004(6)。
    [20]黄浩,我国房地产周期实证研究[D],厦门大学博士论文,2003。
    [21]黄平,我国房地产财富效应与货币政策关系的实证检验[J],上海金融,2005(6)。
    [22]黄清,关于廉租住房供应体系建立的难点与设想[J],中国房地产金融,1999(8)
    [23]黄正新,关于泡沫经济及其测度的几个理论问题[J],世界经济与政治,2002(1)。
    [24]黄忠华,吴次芳,杜雪君,房地产投资与经济增长—全国及区域层面的面板数据分析[J].财贸经济,2008,(08)。
    [25]瞿强,资产价格泡沫与信用扩张[J],金融研究,2005(3)。
    [26]孔煜,城市住宅价格变动的影响因素研究[D],重庆大学博士论文,2006。
    [27]李斌,社会排斥理论与中国城市住房改革制度[J],社会科学研究,2002(3)。
    [28]李国柱,中国房地产市场价格波动数量研究[D],西南财经大学博士论文,2004。
    [29]李海波,从经济周期看中国房地产发展[J],经济问题,2006(9)。
    [30]李宏瑾,房地产市场、银行信贷与经济增长——基于面板数据的经验研究[J],国际金融研究2005(7)。
    [31]李宏瑾.房地产市场、银行信贷与经济增长—基于面板数据的经验研究[J].国际金融研究,2005,(07)。
    [32]李龙等,浅析影响我国房地产价格上涨的因素[J],哈尔滨商业大学学报(自然科学版),2004(4)。
    [33]李实等,中国居民财产分布不均等及其原因的经验分析[J],经济研究,2005(6)。
    [34]李维哲,曲波,地产泡沫预警指标体系与方法研究[J],山西财经大学学报,2002(2)。
    [35]李晓西,虚拟经济、泡沫经济与实体经济[J],财贸经济,2000(6)。
    [36]李艳双,房地产业与国民经济的协调发展研究[D],天津大学博士论文,2003。
    [37]梁桂,中国不动产经济波动与周期的实证研究[J],经济研究,1996(7)。
    [38]梁荣中国房地产业发展规模与国民经济总量关系研究[M].经济科学出版社,2005。
    [39]梁云芳,高铁梅,贺书平,房地产市场与国民经济协调发展的实证分析[J].中国社会科学,2006(03)。
    [40]刘洪玉,郑思齐,沈悦,中国房地产市场中的“泡沫”与“过热”问题分析[J],建筑经济,2003(2)。
    [41]刘洪玉、沈悦房,地产价格变化规律的经济学分析[J],建筑经济,2004(9)。
    [42]刘琳,房地产泡沫测度系数的编制方法[J],中国房地产,2003(6)。
    [43]刘琳,房地产泡沫的测度系数研究[J],价格理论与实践,2002(3)。
    [44]刘水杏,房地产业与相关产业关联度的国际比较[J],财贸经济,2004(4)。
    [45]刘水杏.房地产业关联特性及带动效应研究[M].北京:中国人民大学出版社,2006年。
    [46]刘霞辉,资产价格波动与宏观经济稳定[J],经济研究,2002(4)。
    [47]刘学成,国内房地产周期研究综述[J],中国房地产,2001,5。
    [48]刘学成,国外房地产周期研究综述[J],中国房地产,2001(4)。
    [49]刘元元,城市发展中的房地产泡沫[D],对外经济贸易大学博士论文,2005。
    [50]卢卫,对我国房地产泡沫论争的综述[J],经济学动态,2003(6)。
    [51]鲁桂华、皮舜,商业银行行为与资产市场泡沫——个基于中国制度背景的均衡模型[J],财经研究2005(2)。
    [52]陆磊、李世宏,微观决策与经济体制:房地产泡沫下的居民—金融部门破产[J],金融研究,2004(9)。121
    [53]马辉,股票市场、房地产市场对消费行为的影响[D],吉林大学硕士论文,2006。
    [54]南建党,房地产市场的财富效应[J],经济导刊,2007年10月12日,http://www1.cfi.net.cn/。
    [55]聂名华,浅析房地产价格变动的影响因素[J],中国房地产,1998(10)。
    [56]皮舜,中国房地产市场与金融市场的Granger因果关系分析[J],系统工程理论与实践2004(12)。
    [57]皮舜、鲁桂华、武康平,中国房地产市场与金融市场关系改进的机制设计[J],当代财经,2004(11)。
    [58]皮舜、武康平,房地产市场发展和经济增长间的因果关系——对我国的实证分析[J],管理评论,2004(3)。
    [59]平新乔、陈敏彦,融资、地价与楼盘价格趋势[R],北京大学中国经济研究中心讨论稿系列,2004-3。
    [60]齐淮钧,我国房地产市场发展状况分析[J],市场周刊商务,2004(9)。
    [61]秦凤鸣、张中楠,房地产价格膨胀对金融震荡的警示[J],山东大学学报,2007(4)。
    [62]邵谦谦,日本房地产泡沫的成因分析及对我国的经验借鉴[J],中国房地产金融,2003(5)。
    [63]深圳房地产研究所,深圳市房地产预警体系研究[R],课题报告,2003。122
    [64]沈悦,刘洪,房地产价格与宏观经济指标关系的研究[J],价格理论与实践,2002(6)。
    [65]沈悦,刘洪玉.中国房地产开发投资与GDP的互动关系[J].清华大学学报(自然科学版),2004,(09)。
    [66]沈悦,刘洪玉.住宅价格与经济基本面:1995一2002年中国14城市的实证研究[J].经济研究,2004,(06)。
    [67]沈悦、刘洪玉,房地产资产价值与国家财富的关系研究[J],清华大学学报,2004(1)。
    [68]沈悦、刘洪玉,中国房地产开发投资与GDP的互动关系[J],清华大学学报(自然科学版),2004(9)。
    [69]沈悦、刘洪玉,住宅价格与经济基本面1995—2002年中国14城市的实证研究[J],经济研究,2004(6)。
    [70]施灿彬,我国房地产价格波动行为分析及对策研究[J],价格理论与实践。
    [71]时筠仑,房地产波动规律研究[D],同济大学博士论文,2005。
    [72]史永东,杜两省,资产定价泡沫对经济的影响[J],经济研究,2001(10)。
    [73]孙俊峰,我国城市房地产管理的立法问题浅析[J],今日科苑,2007(4)。
    [74]孙志诚、扬继瑞住宅经济学[M].成都:四川大学出版社,1992。
    [75]谭刚,房地产周期冲击——传导模型及其主要因素分析[J],建筑经济,2002(6)。
    [76]谭刚,房地产周期冲击——传导模型及其主要因素分析[J],建筑经济,2002(7)。
    [77]谭刚,深圳房地产周期波动研究[J],建筑经济,2001(8)。
    [78]谭小芬,欧洲房地产周期与金融稳定[J],国际经济评论,2007(5)。
    [79]唐茂华、陈丹,房价飙升成因及其治理[J],房地产市场,2004(8)。
    [80]佟克克,中国房地产周期波动理论和对策研究[D],北京交通大学博士论文,2006。
    [81]汪利娜,房地产泡沫的生成机理与防范措施[J],财经科学,2003(1)。
    [82]汪利娜,房地产泡沫与银行金融风险防范[J],城乡建设,2003(11)。
    [83]汪利娜,房地产业发展与宏观调控[J],经济学动态,2004(8)。
    [84]汪利娜,住宅空置率上升之谜[J],城乡建设,2003(6)。
    [85]王国刚(中国社会科学院金融研究所住宅金融课题组),提高供给能力,推进房地产市场健康发展[R],2005。
    [86]王国军,刘水杏.房地产业对相关产业的带动效应研究[J]经济研究,2004(8)。
    [87]王国军、刘水杏,房地产业对相关产业的带动效应研究[J],经济研究,2004(8)。
    [88]王金明、高铁梅,对我国房地产市场需求和供给函数的动态分析[J],中国软科学,2004(4)。
    [89]王维安、贺聪,房地产价格与货币供求经验事实和理论假说[J],财经研究,2005(5)。
    [90]王维安、贺聪,房地产市场区域性风险扩散机制研究[J],财经研究,2005(1)。
    [91]吴老二、祝平衡,房地产价格与房地产投资来源结构[J],当代经济科学,2006(1)。
    [92]吴强、刘石承,我国房地产周期波动的拐点预期[J],统计与决策,2007(6)。
    [93]武康平、皮舜、鲁桂华,中国房地产市场与金融市场共生性的一般均衡分析数量经济技术经济研究[J],2004(10)。
    [94]项卫星、李宏瑾,银行信贷扩张与房地产泡沫:对东亚金融危机教训的反思[J],东北亚论坛,2005,14(2)。
    [95]项卫星、李宏瑾、白大范,银行信贷扩张与房地产泡沫:美国、日本及东亚各国和地区的教训[J],国际金融研究,2007(3)。
    [96]谢百三、王巍,我国商业银行在房地产热潮中的两难选择[J],国际金融研究,2005(3)。
    [97]谢家谨,当前房地产市场形势与走向[J]中国房地产信息2005(6)。
    [98]徐滇庆,遏制房地产金融风险势在必行[J],中国改革,2007(9)。
    [99]闫强、刘尔烈,中国房地产泡沫特点与成因[J],内蒙古农业大学学报(社会科学版),2006(2)。
    [100]严金海,中国的房价与地价:理论、实证和政策研究[J],数量经济技术经济研究,2006(1)。
    [101]杨朝军,廖士光,孙洁.房地产业与国民经济协调发展的国际经验及启示[J].统计研究,2006(9)。
    [102]杨胜刚、吴立源,住宅房地产消费的非理性泡沫[J],消费经济,2007(6)。
    [103]杨文武,房价收入比指标研究[J],统计研究,2003(1)。
    [104]易宪容,我国房地产市场过热与风险预警[J],财贸经济,2005(1)。
    [105]袁志刚、樊潇彦,房地产市场理性泡沫分析[J],经济研究,2003(3)。
    [106]张建伟,泡沫经济的实证分析与制度分析[J],经济学动态,1997(3)。
    [107]张启振,房地产泡沫形成原因与防治探析[J],中共福建省委党校学报,2005(12)。
    [108]张涛、龚六堂、卜永祥,资产回报住房按揭贷款与房地产均衡价格[J],金融研究,2006(2)。
    [109]张晓晶、孙涛,中国房地产周期与金融稳定[J],经济研究,2006(1)。
    [110]赵龙节、张辉、张吉法,日本房地产业与国民经济周期波动对我国的启示[J],经济科学,2007(1)。
    [111]赵振全、于震,论中国经济增长的新阶段[J],经济学动态,2004(3)。
    [112]周爱民,股市泡沫及其检验方法[J],经济科学,1998(5)。
    [113]周京奎,房地产价格波动与投机行为——对中国14城市的实证研究[J],当代经济科学,2005(4),P19-24。
    [114]周京奎,货币政策、银行贷款与住宅价格——对中国4个直辖市的实证研究[J],财贸经济2005(5)。
    [115]周京奎、曹振良,中国房地产泡沫与非泡沫——以投机理论为基础的实证分析[J],山西财经大学学报,2004(1)。
    [116]朱海波等,90年代马来西亚房地产泡沫的产生、破灭及防范措施[J],亚太经济,2000(6)。
    [117]朱骏、张红,基于时间序列与人工神经网络的房地产周期识别[J],清华大学学报(自然科学版),2006(6)。

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700