普通大学生最大摄氧量测评的比较研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
研究目的:本研究通过运用跑台对32名普通高校男大学生的Vo_(2max)进行直接测定,并以此为标准,对国内目前较常用的PWC_(170)法、Astrand列线图法、Fox法、12min跑法和国人自己设计的丁振平法、陈文堉法6种方法预测Vo_(2max)的有效性、准确性和相关性进行比较性研究,旨在选出较为准确、有效、又适合我国国情的普通高校男大学生Vo_(2max)的间接测试方法,为我国大学生体质研究中大规模测定Vo_(2max)、评价有氧运动能力和心血管机能水平提供参考依据。
     研究方法:将32名男性大学生志愿者随机分为7组,采用交叉作业的测试方式,相互间隔时间为2周,利用直接测定法和6种间接测定法测得Vo_(2max)。
     研究结果:(1)用6种间接测定法所测定的Vo_(2max)与直接测定法测定的结果进行比较,经统计学处理,结果发现,其中有3种方法(Astrand列线图法、Fox法和陈文堉法)推测结果较实测值高,2种方法(丁振平法和PWC_(170)法)较实测值低,差异都具有统计学意义。12 min跑法的推测结果虽然不同程度地高于实测值,但差异无统计学意义(P>0.05)。
     (2)用6种间接测定法推算出的Vo_(2max)值与直接测定法Vo_(2max)值进行相关分析,结果表明1 2 min跑法测得Vo_(2max)的相关系数最大,为0.89(P<0.01);Astrand列线图法的相关系数最小,为0.61(P<0.01)。
     研究结论:(1)将6种间接测定法所测定的结果与直接测定法测定结果进行标准关联效度分析,仅12 min跑法的相关系数1=0.89(P<0.01),且推测结果与实测值的差异无统计学意义(P>0.051,因而认为,12min跑法有效性、准确性高,是一种适合推测我国普通大学生Vo_(2max)的间接方法。
     (2)Fox法与直接测定法相关程度虽较高,且具有统计学意义,但推测结果较实测值高。建议用它推算普通大学生Vo_(2max)时应慎重。
     (3)Astrand列线图法和丁振平法不仅相关系数较小,推测结果高于或低于实测值,且差异具有统计学意义。不大适合用它们推测普通大学生Vo_(2max)。
Intention: Mensurating 32 male college students' Vo_(2max) directly with paotai firstly, then take it as a criterion, and research the forecast ofVo_(2max) with the methods of PWC_(170)、Astrand in line chart、Fox、12 minutes running、Ding zhenping and Chen wenyu comparatively. Toobtain more scientifical Vo_(2max) test methods and indirect calculate formula which suit for Chinese male college students, and provide a reference to evaluate aerobic exercise capacity and cardiovascular function, while do research in mass of mensurations to the physique of college students.
     Method: Dividing 32 volunteers of male college students into 7 groups randomly, adopting the cross test-operation and the mutualinterval is two weeks, utilize the direct method and six kinds of indirectmethod to measure Vo_(2max).
     Results: (1) Comparing with the result of Vo_(2max) by the method of the six kinds of indirect method and the direct method, After the statistical analysis and found that: The result which is speculated by the three kinds of method(Astrand in line chart、Fox、Chen wenyu ) is more higher than the actual value, the result which is speculated by the two kinds of method (Ding zhenping、PWC_(170)) is more lower than the actual value, there have a statistically significant difference too. The result which is speculated by the method of 12 minutes running is more higher than the actual value, but no statistically difference (P> 0.05).
     (2) The results of Vo_(2max) by the method of the six kinds of indirect method and the direct method are taking related analysis, and showed that:The Vo_(2max) indirectly be calculated by the method of 12 minutes running is highest correlative to that mensurated directly, and the correlationcoefficient is 0.89 (P <0.01); The Vo_(2max) indirectly be calculated by themethods of Astrand in line chart is lowest correlative to that mensurated directly, and the correlation coefficient is 0.61 (P <0.01).
     Conclusion: (1)The results of Vo_(2max) by the method of the six kinds of indirect method and the direct method are taking related analysis, and showed that: 12 minutes running method's correlation coefficient is 0.89 (P <0.01) only, and The result which is speculated by the method of 12 minutes running is more higher than the actual value, but no significant difference (P> 0.05).So consider that the method of 12 min running iseffective、exact, and is a suitable indirect method to speculate Vo_(2max) forChinese college students.
     (2)The correlative degree between the method of Fox and the direct method is more higher, and have statistical significance, but the result of speculation is higher than the actual value. So we propose that we will becareful to speculate college students' Vo_(2max) by the method of fox.
     (3)The correlation coefficient of the methods of Astrand in line chart and Ding zhenping is not only smaller, but also the speculation is higher or lower than the actual value , and the difference have statisticalsignificance. So the two methods are not suitable to speculate Vo_(2max) for college students.
引文
[1]Howley ET , et al . Criteria for maximal oxygen uptake.Med. Sci. Sports Exerc.1995:27(9):1292-1301
    
    [2]Robison, el, New records in human power [J],Science,1985:409-410,1937.
    
    [3]宋刚,许春艳.应用心率表间接测定的最大摄氧量[J],中国临床康复杂志,2005,9(43):27.
    
    [4]李新宁,萧志奇,郭伟.由台阶试验推算儿少最大吸氧量的分段追踪观察[J],北京体育 大学学报,2001,(1):54-5
    
    [5]肖国强,邓树勋,吴婵清.不同负荷方式对大学生最大吸氧量和无氧阈的影响[J],天津 体育学院学报,1998,13(1):1-7
    
    [6]Anderson GS,A comparison of predictive tests of aerobic capacity[J],Can J Sport Sci, 1992, (4):304-8.
    
    [7]于可红.国家中小学生体育与健康教育个体评价标准的研究[M],杭州:浙江大学出版社, 2000,9
    
    [8]陈明达.实用体质学[M],北京:北京医科大学、中国协和医科大学联合出版社,1993.12
    
    [9]陈元武,宋高晴.几种估测最大吸氧量方法的比较研究[J],湖北体育科技,1995,58(4): 52-54
    
    [10]李见刚.PWC_(170)对评价少年儿童有氧工作能力的有效性研究[J],山东体育科技,1996, 18(2):35-38
    
    [11]于可红.构建中小学生台阶试验指数标准的实验研究[J],中国学校体育,2001,(4):10
    
    [12]Shahnawaz.H,Influence of Limb Length on a stepping exercise[J],Appl Physiol, 1978, 44(3):346-9
    
    [13]船川潘夫.对用台阶实验测定学龄儿童耐力的探讨[J],沈阳体育学院学报,1952,(4): 98-100
    
    [14]杨锡让.探讨台阶负荷试验的准确性[A],中国运动医学学术会议论文摘要汇编, 1983-1984:34.
    
    [15]马英华.最大吸氧量间接测定方法初步探讨[J],中国体育科技,1982,(5)
    
    [16]李绍荣.部分大学生体质评定的初步探讨[J],体育科学,1982,(2)
    
    [17]陆绍中.径赛运动员机能实验[J],中国体育科技,1982.(5):1
    
    [18]刑文华.体育测量与评价[M],北京.北京体育学院出版社,1985
    
    [19]邱少霖,敖运忠,向宗明.PWC_(170)台阶实验、15min跑和12min跑与间接推算Vo_(2max)的研究 [J],北京体育大学学报,2001,(1):52-53.
    
    [20]黄津虹,齐玉刚,任勇等.大学生耐力素质测试方法与评价标准的比较研究[J],天津体??育学院学报,2002,(3):63-5.
    
    [21]朱继华,程梅玲.对“12min跑”取代1000m跑提高健身效果的研究[J],天津体育学院学 报,2001,15(3):79-80
    
    [22]Paliczka VJ,el.A multi-stage shuttle run as a predictor of running performance and maximaloxygen uptake in adults[J],Br J Sports Med, 1987,(4): 163-5.
    
    [23]Leger LA,el.The multistage 20-metre shuttle run test for aerobic fitness[J],J Sports Sci,1988,(2):93-101.
    
    [24] Boreham CA,el.A comparison of the PWC170 and 20-MST tests of aerobic fitness inadolescent schoolchildren[J],J Sports Med Phys Fitness, 1990,(1): 19-23.
    
    [25]Mahoney C,20-MST and PWC_(170) validity in non-Caucasian children in the UK[J],Br J Sports Med, 1992,(1):45-7.
    
    [26]蔡秋,王步标,龚正伟.12分钟跑与20米往返跑预测最大吸氧量的比较研究[J],体育 学刊,1997,(2):37-40
    
    [27]蔡秋,朱力娅.20米往返跑预测最大吸氧量的可靠性研究[J].广东教育学院学报,1995, (2):104-107
    
    [28] Swain DP, el,Validation of a new method for estimating VO_(2max) based on VO2 reserve [J],Med Sci Sports Exerc,2004,36(8):1421
    
    [29]周明远,陆绍中.12-23岁大、中学男生最大吸氧量年龄变化特征的研究[J],中国运动 医学杂志,1986,5(4):383-93
    
    [30]陈文堉,樊建信,彭平权等.运动员最大摄氧量间接测定法及其适用性的研究[J].中国 运动医学杂志,1985.4(2):75-80.
    
    [31]季叶成,林琬生,张玉青等.10-19岁男性青年最大有氧活动能力的间接测定[J],中国 运动医学杂志,1993,12(4):383-93
    
    [32]侯颖.Fox和陈文墒最大摄氧量间接测定法比较[J],四川体育科学,2006,(2):37-39
    
    [33]尚久华,马超英.几种最大吸氧量间接测定法的比较研究[J],齐齐哈尔师范学院学报(自 然科学版),1995,15(2):47-49
    
    [34]李伟,何叙,沈国芹.少年部分项目运动员几种VO_(2max)间接测定法准确性研究[J],冰雪运动,1999,(3):62-64
    
    [35]丁振平.用台阶负荷时心率和体重推测最大摄氧量的研究[J],中国运动医学杂志,1985.4 (4): 204-208
    
    [36]Cooper KH. A means of assessing maximal oxygenintake. JAMA, 1986, 303: 135
    
    [37]孙振球主编.医学统计学(第二版)[M],北京:人民卫生出版社,2007:757
    
    [38]R J.Shephard等著,陈殉译.体质评价[M],北京:文化教育出版社,1984:1-12
    
    [39]浦钧宗.最大吸氧量的测定及其应用(医务监督第8讲)[J],中国运动医学杂志,1988, 7(3): 120-125
    
    [40]凌月红.湖南省二、四年级大学生的最大吸氧量及体育行为[J],体育学刊,2002,9(1): 36-39
    
    [41]王步标,华明.运动生理学[M],北京:高等教育出版社,2006:287
    
    [42]王步标,肖泽亮,王翔.9-18岁学生最大吸氧量的纵向研究[J],体育学刊,1995(2):58-61
    
    [43]国家教委,体委,卫生部等.中国学生体质与健康调研报告[M],北京:人民教育出版 社,1985.
    
    [44]邢文华.1985-1995年中国汉族学生身体形态、机能和素质十年动态分析冲国学生体质 与健康调研报告[M],长春:吉林科学出版社,1995.
    
    [45]国家体育总局群体司.2000年国民体质监测报告[M],北京:北京体育大学出版社,2002.
    
    [46]全国学生体质健康调研组.2005年全国学生体质与健康调研结果[J],中国学校体育, 2006,10:6-8
    
    [47]黄美好.1985至2000年广东省学生体能素质测试结果的比较分析[J],体育学刊,2002, 9(6):106-108
    
    [48]朱寒笑,周瑶,胡琪.北京市中小学生1985-2000年身体素质监测结果分析[J],北京体 育大学学报,2006.29(12):1663-1665
    
    [49]王素平.关于我国青少年体能素质和肺活量15年下降的思考[J],浙江体育科学,2005, 27(6):62-64
    
    [50]刘晓军.影响1985-2000年陕西省三地市中小学生体质健康状况的因素分析[J],北京体 育大学学报,2005,28(11):1521-1523
    
    [51]LegerL. A indirect continuous tunning multistage field tes[J]. Can. J. Sport Sci, 1980, (5): 77
    
    [52]邹似刚,熊曼丽,孙洪涛等.湖南省大学生有氧耐力评价标准研究[J],中国体育科技, 2003,39(3):54-55
    
    [53]王健,邓树勋.台阶试验质疑[J].中国体育科技,2003.39(2):61-64
    
    [54]蒋冠琳.三分钟台阶试验及评定方法[J],中国运动医学杂志,1985,4(1):23-29
    
    [55]Petrella RJ,Wight D. An office-based instrument for ex-ercise counseling and prescription in primary care-The Step Test Exercise Prescription(STEP). Archive of family medicine,2000,9 (4):339-344.
    
    [56]李纪江,庄洁,陈佩杰等.台阶试验与功率自行车VO_(2max)测试法相关性研究[J],体育 科学,2007,27(5):65-68
    
    [57]陈嵘.三种心肺功能运动负荷测试的评价效度研究[J],体育科学,2005,25(6):52-54
    
    [58]沈国琴,周永平,王健.台阶试验研究进展[J],浙江体育科学,2003,25(4):19-21
    
    [59]Baum Gartner T A, Zuidema M A, Factor analysis of physical fitness test[J]. ResQ,1972,43:443-450
    
    [60]Brohua,L.N. W. Fradd and B.M. Savage. Studies in physical efficiency of college studeaits,??Res Quart,1944,15:221-224.
    
    [61]Benestad, A,M. Trainability of old men. Acta Med Scand, 1965,178:321-327.
    
    [62]Ruffer,W.A.A study of extreme physical activity groups of young men.Res Quart,1965,36:183-196.
    
    [63]王健,邓树勋.台阶试验质疑[J],中国体育科技,2003.39(2):61-64
    
    [64] Sloan, A. W. Physical fitness and body build of young men and women[J].Ergonomics, 1969,12:25 -32.
    
    [65]Astrand,P.O. Human physical fitness with special reference to sex and age[J].Physiol Rev,1956,36:307-335.
    
    [66]Meyers C. R. A study of the reliability of Harvard step test[J].Res Quart, 1969,40:423.
    
    [67]黄玉山.应用PWC_(170),VO_(2max)及RPQ评价运动处方健身效果的研究[J],体育科学,1992, 12(1): 54-56
    
    [68]陆绍忠.PWC_(170)机能试验[J],体育科技资料,1979,(23-24):44
    
    [69]曹志发.9-17岁男孩的PWC_(170)水平及最大吸氧量的估测[J],体育科学,1989,9(2):56
    
    [1]Howley ET.et al,Criteria for maximal oxygen uptake.Med. Sci. Sports Exerc.1995:27(9):1292-1301
    
    [2] Robison, el, New records in human power [J],Science,1985:409-410,1937.
    
    [3]Taylor HI et al,Maximal oxygen uptake as an objective measure of cardiorespiratoryperformance.. J. Appl. Physiol. 1955 (8 ):73-80
    
    [4]浦均宗.最大吸氧量的测定及其应用[J],中国运动医学杂志,1988(2):120
    
    [5]那兰、刘波、荣兴友.普通大学生最大吸氧量、无氧功率、肌纤维成分测查及相关分析[J],体育学刊,1996,4:26
    
    [6]王步标,肖泽亮,王翔.9-18岁学生最大吸氧量的纵向研究[J],体育学刊,1995(2):58-61
    
    [7]曲绵域,于长隆.实用运动医学[M],北京:北京大学医学出版社,2003
    
    [8]曲绵域,高云秋,浦钧宗等.实用运动医学[M].北京:北京科技出版社,1996,135-141.
    
    [9]季叶成,林琬生,张玉青等.10-19岁男性青年最大有氧活动能力的间接测定[J],中国运 动医学杂志,1993,12(4):383-393
    
    [10]Sutton JR. Limitations to maximal oxygen uptake[J].Sports Medicine,1992 ,13 (2 ):127-133.
    
    [11]王步标,华明.运动生理学[M].北京:高等教育出版社.2006:294
    
    [12]马力宏、陈家琦.用双生法探讨遗传因素对通气敏感度及女子最大耗氧量的影响程度[J], 天津体育学院学报,1986(1):8-17
    
    [13]Bouchard C, Rankinen T, et al. Genomic scan for maximal oxygen uptake and its response toraining in the Heritage Family Study. J Appl Physiol 2000 ,88(2):551-559
    
    [14]lesage G Familial resemblance in maximal heart rate,blood lactate and aerobicpoower[J],Hum Hered, 1985,35:182-189
    
    [15]Lortie G,Simoneau JA,Hamel P,et al. Reponses of Maximal Aerobic Power and Capacity toAerobic Training[J].Int J Sports Med,1984,(5):232-236.
    
    [16] Bouchard H.U Strastructure and biochemical function of skeletal muscle in twins [J] AnnHuman Biol.l976(3):220-224
    
    [17]林琬生,张玉青,季成叶等.儿童最大有氧活动能力的发展特征[J],人类学学报,1993, 12(2):383-393
    
    [18]Sid Robinson.Expesimental Study of physical fitness in relation to age. Arbeits physiologic,1938
    
    [19]Astrand I. Aerobic work capaaty in men and women. Acta physiologica scandinavica, Vol.49supplementum 169,Stockhohn 1960
    
    [20]猪饲道夫.身体运动的生理学,杏林书院
    
    [21]林琬生,季成叶,张玉青等.性发育对女性最大吸氧量的影响[J],人类学学报,1995, 14(2): 162-168
    
    [22]王健、邴强、叶伟.人体有氧运动能力的测量与评价[J],华北工学院学报(社科版),2001 年增刊:41-48
    
    [23]Mriwald RL, Bailey DA. Longitudinal comparison of aerobic power inactive and inactiveboys aged 7.0 to 17.0 years. Ann Hum Biol,1981, 8(5):405-414
    
    [24]Kobayashi.K, Kitamura K, Miura M etal Aerobic power as related to body growth andtraining in Japanese boys:a longitudinal study. J Appl Physiol, 1978,44(5): 666-672
    
    [25]Falgairette G et al, Bioenergetic characteristics in prepubertal swimmers compairson withactive boys Int J Sports Med, 1993,14(8):444-448.
    
    [26]Sprynarova S,The influence of training on physical and functional growth before, during andafter puebrty Eur J Appl Physiol, 1987,56:719-726
    
    [27]李之俊,姬静宜,王绍宏.运动对无氧阈、最大吸氧量的影响与心功能的关系[J],天津 体育学院学报,1995,10(3):1-5
    
    [28]关明杰,林琬生,张玉青等.游泳训练对儿童最大有氧活动能力的影响[J],人类学学报, 1997,16(1):22-30
    
    [29]Burke E.J.Physiological effects of similar training programs in males and females.Res.Quart,1977,V. 48:510
    
    [30]Hickson R.C,et al.Linear increse in aerobic power induced by an strenuous program ofendurance exercise.J. Appl. physial,1974,42(3):372
    
    [31]Nikolic Z,Ilic N.Maximal oxygen uptake in trained and untrained 15-year-old boys. Br JSoprts Med,1992,26(1):36-38
    
    [32]Blataci G,Ergun N.Maximal oxygen uptake in well-trained and untrained 9-11 year-oldchildren.PediatrRehabil,1997,1(3):159-162
    
    [33]Mercier,et al.Effect of aerobic training quantity on the VO_(2max) of the circumpubertal swimmers.Int J Soprts Med,1987,8(1):26-30
    
    [34]翁庆章,钟伯光.高原训练的理论与实践[M],北京:人民体育出版社.2002:371
    
    [35] Mirwald RL,Bailey DA,longitudinal comparison of aerobic power inactive and inactive boys aged 7-17 years[J].Annals of Human Biology, 1981,8(5 ):405-414
    
    [36]万文君、郝选明.运动员有氧能力的测试与评价[J],广州体育学院学报,2006,26(3): 108-110
    
    [37]陈元武,宋高晴.几种估测最大吸氧量方法的比较研究[J],湖北体育科技,1995(4):52-54

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700