中国水果出口贸易影响因素的实证分析
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
水果是我国重要的经济作物,水果产业的发展和贸易在国民经济中具有重要地位。自1978年中国实行农业产业结构调整政策以来,中国的水果产业得到快速发展,1997年一跃成为世界第一水果生产大国。水果产量从1978年的657万吨增长至1997年的5089.3万吨,到2006年,中国水果产量已达9599.2万吨,占世界水果产量的18.1%。水果产业的发展也带动了水果出口贸易,水果出口额从1992年的2.83亿美元增长至2006年的12.84亿美元。然而,与世界主要水果出口国相比,中国水果出口还存在着很大差距。中国水果出口量仅占世界的2%,出口量也仅占产量的2%左右;这表明中国虽然是世界水果生产大国,但却不是贸易强国。中国水果出口远未实现其应有的潜力。影响水果出口的因素多种多样,针对影响水果出口的主要因素进行深入的研究,对挖掘中国水果出口的潜力,把中国从世界水果生产大国转变为水果贸易强国,具有重大的现实意义。
     本文应用国际贸易理论中的比较优势理论、产业内贸易理论、竞争力理论、区域经济一体化理论和贸易保护理论,在全球水果贸易竞争的背景下,对中国水果贸易流量和流向的影响因素进行分析;对中国水果在世界市场,以及在东盟、日本、欧盟、俄罗斯和美国市场出口变化的原因进行深入研究;对中国主要出口水果:苹果、柑橘和梨的国际竞争力进行研究;分析技术性贸易壁垒对中国水果出口的影响。本文的研究内容和主要结论如下:
     第一,研究了世界水果贸易的发展、主要水果进出口市场及其特点、世界水果贸易政策,以明确中国水果出口所面临的国际环境。研究结果表明,自1992年以来,世界水果贸易呈现出不断增长的趋势;世界水果贸易市场主要包括三大区域:欧盟、北美自由贸易协定区域和亚洲区域。三大区域的贸易又包括区域内部的贸易以及三大区域与赤道和南半球国家之间的贸易。内部贸易具有十分重要的地位,但是,内部贸易在三大区域的重要性又具有不同的特点。世界水果贸易政策主要包括关税壁垒和非关税壁垒,技术性贸易壁垒日益成为非关税壁垒的重要形式。在国际水果贸易环境变化的同时,中国的水果出口贸易环境也发生了巨大的变化,这主要表现在中国于2001年加入WTO以及中国与东盟签订的自由贸易协定。
     第二,对1992年以来中国水果国际贸易的变化进行研究,结果表明,2000年以来,中国水果贸易呈现出进出口均快速增长的趋势。中国水果贸易的市场结构表现出较为单一的特点,主要出口市场为东盟、日本和欧盟市场。在各市场内部,中国水果出口又呈现出此消彼长的特征,主要表现在东盟市场份额的快速增长,在欧盟市场份额的稍有增长以及在日本、俄罗斯市场份额的下降。中国水果出口的品种结构表现出较为单一的特点,主要集中在苹果和梨、其它坚果、柑橘以及冷冻水果和坚果上。中国水果贸易存在着产业内贸易和产业间贸易两种方式。从总量上看,以产业间贸易为主,但产业内贸易呈现增长趋势。从产业内贸易细分来看,垂直型产业内贸易占据优势地位。
     第三,运用贸易引力模型对中国水果贸易流量和流向变化的影响因素进行分析,结果表明,进口国的GDP、中国的农业产值、中国与各进口国之间的距离、双方的实际汇率以及双方是否为APEC成员国等是中国水果出口流量和流向的主要影响因素。中国与东盟签订自由贸易协定有利地促进了中国水果出口。运用贸易引力模型对中国水果出口的潜力进行了研究,结果表明中国水果出口“贸易过度”的国家有:印度尼西亚、马来西亚、荷兰和俄罗斯;“贸易不足“的国家是是澳大利亚、法国、日本和新加坡。
     第四,运用恒定市场份额模型,首先对中国水果在世界市场出口变化的原因进行分析;然后对中国水果在东盟市场、日本市场、俄罗斯市场、欧盟市场以及美国市场出口变化的原因进行了分析。结果表明,2001年以来,中国水果出口在世界市场快速增长的主要原因是中国水果竞争力的增强和国际市场需求的增长,其贡献份额分别达63%和40.2%。2001年以来,中国水果在东盟市场出口的增长主要是由于竞争力的增强和出口产品结构的改善,其贡献份额分别达43.4%和30.3%。中国水果在日本市场出口的增长主要是由于中国水果竞争力的增强。在俄罗斯市场,中国水果出口增长主要是由于出口产品结构的改善,其贡献份额达82.6%。在美国市场,2000-2005年,中国水果出口增长主要是由于中国水果竞争力的增强,其贡献份额达73.1%。2002-2006年,在中国水果对欧盟出口值的增长中,中国水果国际竞争力的提升与出口产品结构的改善几乎占有相同的重要地位。
     第五,对中国水果的国际竞争力进行了分析,结果表明,中国水果仅在苹果和梨上具有国际竞争力;但与主要竞争对手相比,中国苹果和梨的国际竞争力还有不小的差距。中国水果具有价格竞争力,但中国水果的非价格竞争力较弱,主要表现在产品质量和市场营销上。
     第六,分析了贸易壁垒对中国水果出口的影响。结果表明,欧盟、美国和日本等国的贸易壁垒主要包括关税壁垒和技术性贸易壁垒。技术性贸易壁垒又主要包括食品安全法规、产品合格标准及其认证以及植物检疫措施。这些贸易壁垒对中国的水果出口造成了较大的影响。
     通过以上六部分,较为全面地分析了中国水果出口贸易的影响因素,提出了对策建议,主要包括:建立与国际接轨的水果安全标准,积极申请国际认证;提高中国水果的国际竞争力;按照国际市场的需求,结合我国水果的生产优势,调整生产结构;实施市场结构多元化措施,减小市场风险;实施水果的品牌营销;协调发展产业间贸易和产业内贸易;充分利用WTO规则,积极参与WTO事务;参加区域性贸易合作,推动APEC进程;加强与其它国家在植物检验检疫方面的合作,建设水果生产的非疫区,改善中国水果出口的市场准入条件等。
Fruit is an important economic crop of China, the development and trade of fruit industry has a significant position in China's economy. Since the adjustment of agricultural structure in 1978, China's fruit industry gains rapid development.Since 1997, China has been the largest fruit production contry. Output of fruit has been increased from 6,570,000 ton in 1978 to 50,893,000 ton in 1997, China's fruit output has reached 95,992,000 ton in 2006, and it has reached 18.1% of the world fruit production.The development of China's fruit industry has also promoted fruit export, the export value of fruit has increased from 283 million $ in 1992 to 1284 million.However, compared with other major fruit exporting countries in the world, great gap still exists between China and them.The export volume of China's fruit accounts for about 2 percent of output, about 2 percent of world's total export volume.It shows although China is a large fruit producing country, it is not a big exporting country.Various factors which influences China's fruit export exist, carrying out a deep analysis on the major influential factors has great significance in exploiting the full potentiality of China's fruit export, and turning China from a large fruit producing country to a great fruit exporting country.
     Applying the comparative advantage theory, intra-industry theory and competitiveness theory of international trade theory, this dissertation carries out a research on the major influential factors of China's fruit export from the perspective of world competition.It also carries out a reason analysis of the change of China's fruit export to Asian, Japan, EU, and USA.It studies the competitiveness of China's major exporting fruit: apple, orange and pear.And it studies on the influence of technical barriers to China's fruit export.And the dissertation gets the following conclusion.
     Firstly, through the analysis on the development of world fruit trade, characteristics and trade policy of international fruit trade, it illustrates the international background that China's fruit exporting industry faces.The result is as the following: Since 1992, fruit trade in the world shows a characteristics of export volume increasing.The world fruit market includes 3 parts: ie, EU, NAFTA and ASIA.The trade among them includes the intra-trade of three parts and extra-trade between the three parts and the southern hemisphere.Intra-trade is important, while the importance of the intra-trade is different in the three parts.The trade policy of world fruit trade includes tariff barrier and non-tariff barrier, and the technical barrier has become an important part of non-tariff barrier.At the same time when the trade environment of the world fruit trade changes, China's fuit trade environment also changes, which is mainly shown in China's joining WTO in 2001 and China's signing a free-trade agreement with Asian.
     Secondly, through the analysis of the change of China's fruit export, the following conclusion was reached, both of the export and import value shows an increasing trend since 2000.The trade structure shows monotonous varieties and the market is concentrated in mainly in Asian, Japan, EU and Russia.The change of China's fruit export is different in various markets: The share of the export value increases rapidly in Asian market, increase somewhat in EU market, decends in Japan and Russian market.The variety structure of fruit export is comparatively monotonous, mainly concentrating on apples , pears and oranges, etc.and the the structure is concentrating more on apples and pears.There are two ways of China's fruit trade:inter-industry trade and intra-industry trade. Generally, the inter-industry takes an overwhelming part, while the intra-industry trade shows an increasing trend.From the angle of sub-division of inter-industry trade, the vertical inter-industry trade has a dominating position.
     Thirdly, through the use of the gravity model, this dissertion carries out an analyisis on the influential factors of China fruit export's trade flow, the result shows that GDP of the importing country, China's agricultural GDP, the distance between China and the importing country, the real exchange rate and whether the two belongs to APEC are all the major influential factors of China's fruit export trade.The free trade agreement that China signs with Asian promotes China's fruit export to Asian.Through the research on the potentiality of China's fruit export, it shows that countries that China has not carried out its potentiality are Australia, France, Japan and Singapore, and countries that China has over-traded are Indonesia, Malasia, Netherland and Russia.
     Fourthly, using the CMS model, this paper carries a reason analysis on the change of China's fruit export on the world market and Asian, Japan, Russian,EU and USA markets.The result shows that the rapid development of China's fruit export in the world market since 2001 is because of the increase of China's fruit competitiveness and the increase of the world demand, the contributive percentage of which are 63% and 40.2%.Since 2001, the development of China's fruit export in Asian market is bacause of the increase of China's competitiveness and the improvement of China's fruit export structure, with the improvement of China's fruit export structure is the major reason of the increase of China' fruit export.While in USA market, the the increase of China's competitiveness contributes most in the development of the China's fruit export.In EU market, increase of China's competitiveness and the improvement of China's fruit export structure nealy contributes equallly in the development of China's fruit export.
     Fifthly, using the RCA and MS index, this paper measuring the competitiveness of China's fruit , the result shows that apple and pear is competitive in the world market, but compared with other major exporting countries, great gap still exists. China's fruit is price competitive, but it lacks in non-price competitiveness, mainly shown in quality and marketing.
     Sixly, it carries out an analysis on the influence of the trade barrier on China's fruit trade, the result shows that the import tariff of EU and Japan, the non-tarriff barrier, including the food safetyt regulations, standards and authentication, and quarantine requirements.Trade barriers have significant influence on China's fruit export trade.
     Upon the above six part, counter-measures are put forward, the key part including:establishing standards which meets requiement of international standards, taking an active part in the application of authentication; adjusting the variety structure, adopting the policy of market pluralism; participating actively in WTO affairs, promoting the process of APEC, and joining the regional cooperation; strengthening the government cooperation with other countries, establishing the non-quarantine region, etc.
引文
[1]Akgungor,S.R.& Funda,B.Competitivenesss of the turkish fruit and vegetable processing Industry in the European Union market Russian and EAST[J].European Finance and Trade,38(3):34-53
    [2]Angirasa,A.K.& Davis,B.Horticultural trade under NAFTA:will it hurt Us farm business?[J].Agribusiness,1996,12(1):15-25
    [3]Athukorala,P.C.Processed food exports from developing countries:patterns and determinants[J].Food Policy,1998,23(1):41-54
    [4]Baier,S.L.& Bergstrand,J.H.Do free trade agreements actually increase members' international trade[J].Journal of International Economics,2007,71:72-95
    [5]Berdegue,J.A.,Balsevich,F.,Flores,L.,et al.Central American supermarkets'private standards of quality and safety in procurement of fresh fruits and vegetables[J].Food Policy,2005,30:254-269
    [6]Bergstrand,J.H.The generalized gravity equation,monopolistic competition and the factor-propotions theory in international trade[J].Review of economics and statisitics,1989,71:143-153
    [7]Bergstrand,J.H.The gravity equation in international trade:Some microeconomic foundations and empirical evidence[J].Review of Economics and Statistics,1985,67:474-481
    [8]Beverland,M.Creating value through brands:the ZESPRI kiwifruit case[J]British Food Journal,2001,103(6):383-399
    [9]Bruelhart,M.Marginal intra-industry trade:measurement and relevance for pattern of industrial adjustment.Weltwirtschaflliches Archive,1994,130
    [10]Calvin,L.,Krissoff,B.& Foster,W.Measuring the costs and trade effects of phytosanitary protocols:A U.S.-Japanese apple example[J].Review of Agricultural Economics,2007,30(1):120-135
    [11]Campbell,H.The rise and rise of EurepGAP:European invention of colonial food relations?[J].International Journal of Sociology of Food and Agriculture,2005,13(2):1-19
    [12]Carrere,C.Revisiting the effects of regional trade agreements on trade flows with proper specification of the gravity model[J].European Economic Review,2006,50:223-247
    [13]Chen,K.Ex-post Competitiveness of China's export in agri-food Products:1980-1996[J].Agribusiness,2000,16(3):281-293
    [14]Chen,C.L.,Yang,J.& Findlay,C.Measuring the effect of food safety standards on China's agricultural exports[J].Review of World Economics 2008,144(1):83-106
    [15]Cioffi,A.& dell' Aquila,C.The effects of trade policies for flesh fruit and vegetables of the European Union[J].Food Policy,2004,29:169-185
    [16]Dascal,D.,Mattas,K & Tzouvelekas,V.An analysis of EU wine trade:a gravity model approach[J].Iaer,2002,8(2):135-147
    [17]Eita,J.H.& Jordaan,A.C.South Africa's wood export potential using a gravity model approach[EB/OL].http://www.up.ac.za/up/web/en/academic/economics/index.html,2007,10
    [18]Ellison,G.& Glaeser,E.L.Geographic concentration as a dynamic process[J].The Review of Economics and Statistics.2002,84(2):193-204
    [19]Esterhuizen,D.& Van-Rooyen,C.J.An inquiry into factors impacting on the competitiveness of the south African wine industry[J].Agrekon,2006,45(4):467-485
    [20]Filippini,C.& Molini,V.The determinants of east Asian trade flows:a gravity equation approach[J].Journal of Asian Economics,2003,14:695-711
    [21]Fogarasi,J.Hungarian and Romanian Agri-food trade in the European Union[J].Management,2008,3(1):3-13
    [22]Fotopoulos,C.& Krystallis,A.Quality labels as a marketing advantage-the case of the "PDO Zagora" apples in the Greek market[J].European Journal of Marketing,2003,37(10):1350-1374
    [23]Gibbon,P.Value-chain governance,public regulation and entry barriers in the global fresh fruit and vegetable chain into the EU[J].Development Policy Review,2003,21(5-6):615-625
    [24]Goddard,E.W.The impact of the FTA and NAFTA on the Canadian Fruit and Vegetable Sector[J].Canadian Journal of Agricultttral Economics,1994,42(4):463-472
    [25]Guillotreau,P.& Peridy,N.Trade barriers and European imports of seafood products:a quantitativeassessment[J].Marine Policy,2000,24:431-437
    [26]Halliburton,K.& Henneberry,S.R.The effectiveness of US nonprice promotion of almonds in the Pacific Rim[J].Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics,1995,20(1):108-121
    [27]Hasha,G.European Trading Arrangements in Fruits and Vegetables.USDA.ERS.2004.
    [28]Henson,S.& Jaffee,S.Understanding developing country strategic responses to the enhancement of food safety standards[J].The World Economy,2008,31(4):548-568
    [29]Henson,S.& Loader,R.Barriers to agricultural exports from developing countries:The role of sanitary and phytosanitary requirements[J].World Development, 2001,29(1):85-102
    [30]Henson,S.,Brouder,A.M.& Mitullah W.Food safety requirements and food exports from developing countries:The case of fish exports from Kenya to the European Union[J].American Journal of Agricultural Economics,2000,82(5):1159-I169
    [31]Iturrieta,L.T.& Cortes,T.C.Evalution of the kiwifruits competitiveness from New Zealand and Chile in the USA market between years1994-2004[J].Idesia,2006,24(3):27-31
    [32]Jaeger,S.R.,Rossiter,K.L.,Wismer,W.V.,et al.Consumer-driven product development in the kiwifruit industry[J].Food Quality and Preference,2003,14:187-198
    [33]Jayasinghe,S.& Sarker,R.Effects of regional trade agreements on trade in agrifood products:evidence from gravity modeling using disaggregated data[J].Review of Agicultural Economics,2007,30(1):61-81
    [34]Koo,W.W.,Karemera,D.& Taylor,R.A.gravity model analysis of meat trade policies[J].Agricultural Economics,1994(10):81-88
    [35]Kumar,C.N.& Muraleedharan,V.R.SPS regualtions and competitiveness:an analysis of Indian Spices exports[J].South Asia Economic Journal,2007,8(2):335-346
    [36]Malaga,J.E.Williams,G.W.& Fuller,S.W.US-Mexico fresh vegetable trade:the effects of trade liberalization and economic growth[J].Agricultural Economics,2001,(26):45-55
    [37]Martinez,M.G & Banados R Impact of EU organic product certification legislation on Chile organic exports[J].Food Policy,2004,29:1-14
    [38]Myeongjoo,K.US wood products and regional trade:a gravity model approach[D].PHD,the Graduate Faculty of Auburn University,2003
    [39]Okello,J.J.& Swinton,S.M.Compliance with international food safety standards in Kenya's green bean industry:comparison of a small and a large-scale farm producing for export[J].Review of Agricultural Economics,2006,29(2):269-285
    [40]Onunkwo,I.M.& Epperson,J.E.Export demand for US pecans:Impacts of US export promotion programs[J].Agribusiness,2000,16(2):253-265
    [41]Otsuki,T.Wilson,J.S & Sewadeh,M.What price precaution?European Harmonisation of aflatoxin regulations and African groundnut exports[J].European Review of Agricultural Economics,2001,28(2):263-283
    [42]Otsuki,T.Wilson,J.S.& Sewadeh,M.Saving two in a billion:quantifying the trade effect of European food safety standards on African export[J].Food Policy, 2001,26:495-514
    [43]Poyhonen,R A.tentative model for the volume of trade between countries[J].Archives,1963,Band 90:93-100
    [44]Qiu,H.G,Yang,J.,Huang,J.K.,et al.Impact of China-Asean free trade area on China's international agricultural trade and its regional development[J].China &World Economy,2007,15(4):77-90
    [45]Rose,A.K.Does the WTO make trade more stable?[J].Open economies review,2005,16:7-22
    [46]Sarker,R.& Jayasinghe,S.Regional trade agreements and trade in agri-food products:evidence for the European Union from gravity modeling using disaggregated data[J].Agricultural Economics,2007,37:93-104
    [47]Swinbank,A.& Ritson,C.The impact of the GATT agreement on EU fruit and vegetable policy[J].Food Policy,1995,20(4):339-357
    [48]Wainio,J.& Krissoff,B.Tariff and non-tariff measures affecting market access for fresh and processed fruits and vegetables conference paper,2005
    [49]Wilson,J.S.& Otsuki,T.To spray or not to spray:pesticides,banana exports,and food safety[J].Food Policy,2004,29:131-146
    [50]Wilson,J.S.,Otsuki,T.& Majumdsar,B.Balancing food safety and risk:do drug residue limits affect international trade in beef?.[J].The journal of international trade & economic development,2003,12(4):377-402
    [51]Wu-Huang,S.Global Trade Patterns in Fruits and Vegetables[EB/OL].http://ww.ers.usda.gov,2004-04-06
    [52]曹亮.区域经济一体化视角下的国际农产品贸易研究[J].农业经济问题,2007(10):22-28
    [53]陈益娥.向优势区域集中,做精做强苹果产业[J].陕西农业科学,2006(3):106-110
    [54]邓烈,吴厚玖,周常勇等.世界柑桔鲜果市场分析[J].柑桔与亚热带果树信息,2005,21(2):1-4.
    [55]董银果,侯军歧.SPS措施对中国猪肉贸易的影响[J].农业技术经济,2005(2):47-51
    [56]董银果.SPS措施对猪肉贸易的影响及中国遵从方略研究[D].博士学位论文,西北农林科技大学,2005
    [57]方成泉,林盛华,李连文等.中国梨生产现状及主要对策[J].中国果树,2003(1):47-50
    [58]谷克鉴.国际经济学对引力模型的开发和应用[J].世界经济,2001(2):14-25
    [59]顾国达,牛晓婧和张钱江.技术壁垒对国际贸易影响的实证分析-以中日茶叶贸易为例[J].国际贸易问题,2007(6):74-80
    [60]顾江和杨红利.SPS措施对出口产品成本因素影响的经济分析[J].农业经济问题,2003,12:35-37
    [61]郭芳,王咏红和高瑛.技术壁垒影响中国水产品出口的实证分析[J].中国农村经济,2007(11):45-51
    [62]郭洪海,岳方彤,吴波等.山东省主要粮油作物区域比较优势分析[J].中国农业资源与区划.2004,25(4):12-15
    [63]郭权.世界水果生产与贸易[J].世界农业,2001(4):13-15
    [64]韩礼星,黄贞光,李明等.加入WTO后中国猕猴桃产业的发展策略[J]果树学报,2003,20(3):218-223
    [65]韩礼星,李明,黄贞光等.世界猕猴桃进出口概况[J].世界农业,2004(3):27-28
    [66]何秀荣.我国农产品国际贸易研究方面的问题及建议[J].农业经济问题2003(2):23-25
    [67]胡浩,唐震.中国水果比较优势和出口竞争力分析-兼与亚洲主要水果生产国的比较[J].南京农业大学学报(社会科学版),2005,4(5):50-55
    [68]黄贞光.中国水果适宜总规模的探讨[J].果树学报,2001,18(1):43-48
    [69]纪秋颖,陈春慧.日本技术性贸易壁垒对我国农产品出口影响及对策研究[J].商业研究,2007,360(4):157-160
    [70]姜书竹,张旭昆.东盟贸易效应的引力模型[J].数量经济技术经济研究,2003(10):53-57
    [71]柯炳生.提高农产品竞争力:理论、现状与政策建议[J].农业经济问题,2003(2):34-39
    [72]孔媛.世界水果贸易比较优势与产业内贸易研究[J].国际贸易问题,2006(1):18-24
    [73]李艾宇,田志宏,任爱荣等.我国大陆农产品出口台湾地区的变动分析[J]中国农业大学学报,2004,9(5):88-92
    [74]李芳芳,冷传惠和王燕青.肯定列表制度对辽宁省水产品出口贸易的影响.[J].国际贸易问题,2006(8):78-83
    [75]李海鹏,张俊飚,朱信凯等.我国蔬菜出口的增长效应分析[J].国际贸易问题,2007(2):24-28
    [76]李慧峰,吕德国,秦嗣军等.我国苹果产业现状及其可持续发展对策[J].沈阳农业大学学报:社会科学版,2005,7(2):203-204
    [77]李绍华.世界果树生产状况及提高中国果品市场竞争力对策[J].中国农业大 学学报,2003,8(1):7-13
    [78]李秀梅.中国.欧盟农产品贸易结构分析[J].国际贸易问题,2005(8):35-40
    [79]李玉举.区域贸易安排与出口潜力:引力模型结论的调适[J].财经研究,2005,31(6):86-95
    [80]廖凡.构建更加公平的国际贸易体制-对WTO互惠原则的再思考[J].国际贸易,2007(6):62-65
    [81]刘汉成,易法海.中国水果出口特征及国际竞争力分析[J].农业现代化研究,2007,28(4):450-453
    [82]刘汉成.中国水果供给结构性变化的实证研究[J].农业现代化研究,2005,26(4):313-316
    [83]刘李峰,张照新和张晴.加入WTO后中国水果贸易的发展特征及趋势[J].农业展望,2006,(9):9-12
    [84]刘李峰.中国-东盟水果贸易现状及展望[J].中国农村经济,2004(6):61-66
    [85]刘晓光,方天和周荧.中日两国苹果产业国际竞争力的比较分析[J].农业经济,2006(6):79-80
    [86]刘晓光,葛立群.中国水果产业国际竞争潜力评价及提升途径[J].沈阳农业大学学报(社会科学版),2006,8(4):599-603
    [87]刘晓光.用现代营销手段提高中国水果的国际竞争力[J].沈阳农业大学学报(社会科学版),2006,8(2):184-186
    [88]刘英杰.发挥比较优势,推动产业发展.我国苹果产业发展对策研究[J].农业经济问题,2003(10):44-48
    [89]楼军文.中国柑桔产业的经济分析与政策研究[D].硕士学位论文,中国农业大学,2005
    [90]陆文聪和梅燕.中国.欧盟农产品贸易增长的原因:基于CMS模型的实证分析.农业经济问题,2007(12):15-19
    [91]麻茵萍.加入世界贸易组织对我国水果业的影响及对策分析.中国农村经济,2000(5):33-37
    [92]毛凤霞和冯宗宪.新贸易格局下我国农产品竞争力研究[J].国际贸易问题,2007(6):45-49
    [93]潘金娥.“早期收获”方案对中越农产品贸易的影响[J].当代经济,2004(7):37-41
    [94]潘伟光.中韩两国水果业生产成本及价格竞争力的比较-基于苹果、柑橘的分析[J].国际贸易问题,2005(10):49-53
    [95]庞守林,田志宏.中国苹果国际贸易结构比较分析与优化[J].中国农村经济,2004(2).38-43
    [96]彭可贸,祁春节和雷海章.中国与新西兰水果及加工品贸易竞争性与互补性测算[J].商业研究,2006,23(3):152-154
    [97]祁春节.入世与中国水果业:影响及应对措施[J].国际贸易问题,2001(1):6-10
    [98]祁春节.中国柑桔产业的经济分析与政策研究[D].博士学位论文,华中农业大学,2001
    [99]祁春节.中国入世后美国柑橘准入机会及我们的对策[J].国际贸易问题,2001(9):10-15
    [100]乔娟,颜军林.中国柑桔鲜果国际竞争力的比较分析[J].中国农村经济,2002(11):30-36
    [101]荣静,杨川.中国与东盟农产品贸易竞争和贸易互补实证分析[J].国际贸易问题,2006,(8):45-49
    [102]沙莉.加强原产地域产品保护与扩大农产品出口.以苹果产业为例[J].对外经贸实务,2006(3):7-11
    [103]尚杰和姜国刚.内生比较优势与我国农产品对外贸易研究[J].农业经济问题,2006(1):71-74
    [104]盛斌,廖明中.中国的贸易流量与出口潜力:引力模型的研究[J].世界经济,2004(2):3-8
    [105]史朝兴,顾海英.我国蔬菜出口贸易流量和流向.基于行业贸易引力模型的分析[J].新疆大学学报(社会科学版),2005(3):5-8
    [106]史朝兴,顾海英.引力模型在国际贸易中应用的理论基础研究综述[J].南开经济研究,2005(2):39-44
    [107]帅传敏,程国强,张金隆等.中国农产品国际竞争力的估计[J].管理世界,2003(1):97-103
    [108]孙东升,孙雯静和周锦秀.欧盟农药最大残留限量(MRLs)对中国茶叶出口的影响[J].农业技术经济,2007(1):63-71
    [109]谭向勇,李鹏和郑妍.加入世贸组织前后中国农产品生产及进出口变化情况的实证分析[J].中国农村经济,2006(5):4-9
    [110]谭向勇和辛贤.中国主要农产品市场分析[M].北京:中国农业出版社,2001:248-267
    [111]田东文和叶科艺.安全标准与农产品贸易:中国与主要贸易伙伴的实证研究[J].国际贸易问题,2007(9):108-113
    [112]汪良驹,章镇,姜卫兵等.加入WTO后中国果树业发展对策[J],果树学报,2001,18(5):295-299
    [113]王保利和姚延婷 如何评估农产品品牌竞争力[J].统计与决策,2007(1):47-50
    [114]王川.中国柑橘生产与消费现状分析[J].农业展望,2006(1):8-12
    [115]王金政,单守明,张安宁.欧洲有机水果生产概况[J],世界农业,2005(3):33-36
    [116]王伟东,王文辉,杨振锋等.入世后中国梨产业形势与发展对策[J].世界农业,2003(4):14-16.
    [117]王文先.WTO规则与案例[M].北京:清华大学出版社,2006:106-108
    [118]王宇霖.从世界苹果、梨生产及发展趋势与国际贸易看中国苹果、梨产业存在的问题[J].果树学报,2001,18(3):127-132
    [119]王珍.WTO与农产品国际竞争力[M].北京:中国经济出版社,2004:15-42
    [120]王志本.我国传统名特优农产品的地理标志保护[J].农业经济问题,2005(4):54-57
    [121]王志明,袁建新.技术性贸易壁垒的影响及中国的对策[J].世界经济,2003(7):31-34
    [122]翁鸣.中国农产品质量与国际竞争力[J].中国农村经济,2003(4):20-26
    [123]吴厚玖.加入WTO后我国柑桔业的发展对策[J].中国南方果树,2000,29(4):22-23
    [124]吴秀敏,林坚.技术性贸易壁垒对中国农产品出口的消极影响分析[J].国际贸易问题,2004(12):29-34
    [125]肖长惜,马成武.WTO框架下国际蔬菜市场准入与贸易壁垒[J].农业经济问题,2006(12):61-64
    [126]辛培刚等.论中国落叶果树生产结构的调整与优化[J].落叶果树,2000(6):3-6
    [127]辛毅和李宁.农产品国际竞争力的“橄榄”模型分析.以中国渔业为例[J].农业经济问题,2007(5):12-17
    [128]徐海晶和于冷.我国苹果出口贸易的实证分析[J].农业技术经济,2006(2):43-47
    [129]徐磊和张峭.欧盟水果市场供应链体系研究[J].世界农业,2007(8):19-21
    [130]徐小彪.新西兰的猕猴桃业[J].世界农业,2002(8):31-32
    [131]徐晔和韩宇.中国水果产业链管理的实践研究[J].世界农业,2007(3):16-19
    [132]许国权和陈春根.基于RCA和“国家钻石”模型对我国茶叶国际竞争力的分析[J].国际贸易问题,2007(11):38-43
    [133]许琳和贾宪威.四川省水果龙头企业营销竞争力分析[J].农村经济,2006(4):47-49
    [134]许咏梅和高启杰.技术壁垒影响我国茶叶出口的实证分析[J].国际贸易问 题,2006(5):86-93
    [135]薛亮.提高我国农业竞争力的战略思考[J].管理世界,2003(3):83-87
    [136]薛亮.推进优势农产品区域布局,提高农业国际竞争力[J].农业经济问题,2003(1):34-36
    [137]杨莲娜.中国对欧盟农产品出口增长的影响因素分析[J].国际贸易问题,2007(10):41-46
    [138]姚蕾和田志宏.我国农机产品出口市场份额研究[J].国际贸易问题,2006(3):46-50
    [139]姚黎,孔令梅.葡萄酒地理标志保护制度探析[J].国际贸易问题,2004(11):87-91
    [140]尤建强,崔岩.对我国水果进出口贸易的思考[J].国际贸易问题,2006(6):26-31
    [141]詹晶.入世后中国农产品贸易的跟踪分析与应对策略[J].国际贸易问题,2005(5):5-10
    [142]张长梅.关于入世后我国水果出口竞争力的思考[J]国际贸易问题,2002(6):7-11
    [143]张吉国.日本肯定列表制度对山东蔬菜出口的影响及对策[J].农业经济问题,2007(4):63-66
    [144]张林森,李丙智,韩明等.苹果出口的门槛-欧盟良好农业操作规范[J]果农之友,2005(11):43-44
    [145]张玫,霍增辉和易法海.加入WTO前后我国水产品出口变化及其影响因素的实证分析[J].中国农业大学学报(社会科学版),2007,24(1):164-171
    [146]张青青和王海华.对我国水产品进出口贸易的影响与对策分析[J].渔业经济研究,2005(6):8-12
    [147]张文兵.政府行为与产业国际竞争力:一个分析框架[J].商业经济与管理2006,175(5):36-40
    [148]张文兵.中国奶业国际竞争力:基于RCA和“钻石”模型的分析[J].农业经济问题,2005(11):36-40
    [149]张晓涛.中国热带水果产业的基本状况和前景.中国农村经济,2004(7):18-22
    [150]张翼和李崇光.中国水果业的国际竞争力分析[J].农村经济,2003(2):9-11
    [151]赵政阳,戴军和王雷存.陕西苹果产业现状及国际竞争力分析[J].西北农业学报,2002,ll(4):108-111
    [152]赵政阳,冯宝荣,王雷存等.中国苹果产业向优势区域集中的战略思考[J].西北农业学报,2004,13(4):195-199
    [153]郑风田.中国农产品走出国门的现实困境与对策-苹果业出口个案分析[J].农 业经济问题,2002(10):16-19
    [154]郑风田和李茹.中国柑桔国际竞争力的比较优势分析[J].国际贸易问题,2003(4):13-18
    [155]郑凤田,赵淑芳.农产品国际品牌建设经验及启示-智利果品国际品牌建设的实证分析[J].农业经济,2005(7):3-6
    [156]郑有国.福建省水果出口面临的技术性贸易壁垒分析及对策[J].国际贸易问题,2005(12):55-59
    [157]郑云.中国农产品出口贸易与农业经济增长-基于协整分析和Granger因果检验[J].国际贸易问题,2006(7):26-31
    [158]钟钰,华树春和靖飞.中国农产品贸易进口波动因素分析[J].南京农业大学学报,2005,5(4):6-10
    [159]周广文,杨改河.西北地区果树区域布局调整与优化研究[J].西北农林科技大学学报(自然科学版),2006,134(8):82-86
    [160]周锦秀和孙东升.非关税壁垒的重要形式.中国农产品及食品出口受阻的技术壁垒分析[J].国际贸易,2005(5):16-19
    [161]周井娟,林坚.中国水产品出口增长的源泉分析[J].国际贸易问题,2008,(8):14-18
    [162]周曙东,胡冰川和崔奇峰.多哈回合农产品关税减让谈判与中国的谈判方案选择.基于CGE模型的视角[J].中国农村经济,2006(9):4-12
    [163]周应恒,宋海英.中泰农产品协议对农产品贸易的影响分析[J].农业经济问题,2004(1):59-62
    [164]朱晶.贸易保护、市场准入与农产品竞争力[J].国际贸易问题2004,(2):34-39
    [165]邹明宏,陆超忠和林家丽.中国东盟自由贸易区的建立对中国热带水果产业的影响及对策[J].热带农业科学,2006,26(5):41-45

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700