通信电台细微特征研究
详细信息    本馆镜像全文|  推荐本文 |  |   获取CNKI官网全文
摘要
通信电台个体识别是通信对抗领域的研究热点之一。通过对电台信号细微特征的研究,可以获得信息特征、信号格式和目标个体特征等诸多信息,是进行数据融合、破译解码、模式/目标识别与跟踪、态势分析的重要技术手段。长期以来,对通信信号指纹特征的识别不论在军事或民用领域都具有重要的意义。但与早一步发展起来的雷达信号识别不同,由于电台个体差异极小,特征提取困难,通信电台个体特征研究目前还处于初步研究阶段,识别效果不佳,与实际应用存在很大差距。
     本文摒弃电台个体识别研究中流行的暂态信号分析方法,重点对通信电台稳态信号进行分析,对电台信号的常规特征与高阶统计特征在分类中的重要度进行了系统地评估,提出一种有别于以往研究思路的基于高阶谱核函数的特征提取与分类算法,采用邻域粗糙集算法进行特征集的约简,以支持向量机作为分类器,构造了二类分类器和组合分类器。提出的所有方法都用外场实测数据做了仿真。由于扩频电台信号的分析与处理方式与一般信号有所区别,且难度更大,文中还特别对在军事通信中最为通用的跳频信号的细微特征研究进行了初探。
     本文的贡献主要包括以下几个方面:
     1)研究特征重要度评估方法。提出基于邻域粗糙集的特征评价法,对信号的常规特征(载频偏差、信号的调制参数、电台的杂散特征)和高阶统计特征分别作重要度分析,以所提取特征的实验数据为基础,得到各特征在分类中的重要度参数。这种方法证明了各特征的重要度有明显差别,在分类中应予以区别对待。与大多数研究不同,对各特征区别对待以及赋予权值的思想在文中的很多方面都有所体现。
     2)针对高阶谱用于分类时会引发“维数灾难”进而导致的性能和效率问题,提出一种基于高阶谱核函数的特征提取与分类算法,此方法与目前流行的双谱(主要是积分双谱和选择双谱)分析方法思路迥异,利用高阶谱核函数,将低维的不可分样本映射到高维空间,从而有效降低支持向量的个数,提高样本的可分性,达到提高识别率的目的,同时还兼顾了分类正确率和分类效率的平衡。此外,对高阶谱核函数中阶数的选择进行研究,通过实测数据的分析结果表明,分类器的正确率与高阶谱的阶数并不成正比,因而一味地提高高阶谱阶数是不明智的。通过特征评估结果与高阶谱阶数分析结果的一致性表明,特征评估可以作为高阶谱核函数阶数选择的一种参考方式,并基于这个思路构造了优化的加权高阶谱核函数。
     3)研究电台信号特征选择及分类器设计方法。引入基于邻域粗糙集的数据集约简算法,对文中所定义的细微特征集进行降维处理以获得优化特征子集。在SVM分类器设计中,将各特征重要度作为权值构造加权特征以提高识别率,并利用各特征的重要度设计加权投票组合分类器,实验结果表明,基于加权投票组合分类器的效果明显优于单个分类器,能够取得较为满意的分类结果。
     4)研究跳频信号细微特征。用小波包分解与重构的方式抑制WVD方法产生的交叉项,进而提取跳频信号的参数特征,并基于核函数的原理,提出小波变换核函数算法。通过实测信号的实验对相关参数的优化给出了说明。实验结果表明,小波抑制WVD交叉项法取得的跳频信号参数特征有一定的聚类性,且在参数选择合适时小波核函数用于跳频信号分类可以得到较高的正确率。
Identification of individual communication transmitters is one of the hotspots in the field of communication countermeasure. Researches on the subtle features of communication transmitters have gained some progress with the increasing of new techniques used in signal processing. Information such as signal features, types and individual features can be derived from the research on the subtle features maintained from the transmitters, which is an important measure of decoding, data fusion, pattern recognition, object tracking and situation analyzing. Analyzing of the subtle features from the individual transmitters has played an important role in either the military or civil field for a long time. However, differences of the technical parameters between individual transmitters are fine, thus analyzing of subtle features is rather difficult, which is a little different from that of radar.
     In this paper, the characteristics of stable signals, such as carrier frequency offset, modulation parameters and stray features of the transmitters, and their significances in the course of the identification are both studied systematically. Thereby, a novel feature extraction and classification algorithm based on polyspectral kernel function is presented, in which polyspectral theory and kernel technique are combined, and support vector machines (SVMs) are chosen as the classifiers. Feature sets are reduced by the neighborhood rough set algorithm. Furthermore, two-class classifiers and combined classifiers are designed based on the discussion above. The proposed algorithms are verified to be efficient using the measured radio data. Besides that, researches on the subtle features of the frequency-hopping spread spectrum signals are carried out.
     The main contributions of this paper are concluded as follows.
     1. Evaluation method of the significance of the features based on the neighborhood rough set is studied. General signal characteristics including carrier frequency offset, modulation parameters, and stray features, and high order statistical characteristics of the transmitters are studied in this paper. The results show that general signal characteristics play an important role in the signal identification. We can get the significance of every feature in classification on the basis of the experimental data. It is proved that the significance of every feature is obviously different, thus they should be treated distinctively. The distinctive treatments of every feature and thinking of the weight are well reflected in the paper.
     2. To address the curse of dimensionality caused by the higher order spectrum used in classification, a new feature extraction algorithm based on poly spectral kernel function is presented. The method can reduce the numbers of the support vectors effectively, and shorten the training and classifying time in comparison to the bispectral analysis (including integral bispectral and selected bispectral). Moreover, it can improve the identification rate.Then how to choose the order of the polyspectral kernels is studied. The neighborhood rough set theory is proposed for evaluating the significances of the order of the polyspectral kernels, which raises a novel weighted polyspectral kernel. The experiment shows that better and stable classification rate can be achieved.
     4. The selection of the signal feature and the design of the classifiers are discussed. Data set reduction algorithm based on the neighborhood rough set theory is proposed in the selection of the signal features. An optimized feature subset can be obtained through reducing the dimension of the subtle feature set defined in the paper. In the design of the SVM classifiers, the significance of every attribute is used as the weight to construct weighted feature in order to improve the identification rate. And the weighted voting combination of multi-classifiers are designed on the basis of the significance of every attribute. The experimental results show that the efficiency of the weighted voting multi-classifiers is better than the single classifier.
     5. Subtle features of the frequency hopping signals are studied. Wavelet packet decomposition and reconstitution are used to constrain the cross-term brought about by WVD method. Then the extraction of the feature from the frequency hopping signals is carried out. Wavelet kernels function algorithm is put forward based on the principle of kernel function. Relevant parameter optimizations are discussed through the experiments on the measured radio signals. The experimental results show that features of FH signals extracted by the way of Wavelet constrained WVD cross-term have a certain clustering performance. A pretty good identification can be achieved if the appropriate parameter is chosen.
引文
[1]J.Toonstra, W.Kinsner. Transient analysis and genetic algorithms for classification. IEEE WESCANEX Communications, Power, and Computing,1995,2: 432-437.
    [2]D.Shaw, W.Kinsner. Multifractal modelling of radio transmitter transients for classification. WESCANEX 97:IEEE Conference of Communications, Power and Computing,1997:306-312.
    [3]L.Sun, W.Kinsner, N.Serinken. Characterization and feature extraction of transient signals using multifractal measures. Proceedings of the 1999 IEEE Canadian Conference on Electrical and Computer Engineering Shaw Conference Center,1999, 2:781-785.
    [4]蔡忠伟.通信信号指纹识别技术研究.无线电工程,2004,34(1):46-49.
    [5]任春晖.通信电台个体特征分析[学位论文].电子科技大学,2006.
    [6]尹健.基于回归神经网络的雷达辐射源识别算法.电讯技术,2005,4:188-192.
    [7]郭小宾,王壮,胡卫东.基于贝叶斯网络分类器的雷达辐射源识别方法.火力与指挥控制,2006,31(2):36-39.
    [8]关欣,何友,衣晓.基于D-S推理的灰关联雷达辐射源识别方法研究.武汉大学学报,2005,30(3):274-277.
    [9]陈永光,李修和.雷达辐射源识别的多元信息融合算法研究.电子与信息学报,2007,29(10):2329-2332.
    [10]陈昌孝,何明浩,朱元清.基于多参数联合判决的雷达信号调制特征识别.中国电子科学研究院学报,2008,3(2):169-173.
    [11]曲长文,乔治国.雷达信号脉内特征的小波分析.上海航天,1996,5:15-19.
    [12]穆世强.雷达信号细微特征分析.电子对抗,1992,1:1-11.
    [13]魏东升,林象平.雷达信号脉内细微特征的时频分析.电子对抗,1993,4:7-19.
    [14]Li Mingquan, X.XianCi, L.Lemin, Cyclic spectral features based modulation recognition. Communications Technology Proceedings, International Conference, Beijing,1996,2:792-795.
    [15]W.P罗宾斯.相位噪声.北京:人民邮电出版社,1988
    [16]Wang Xianbin, Wu Yiyan, Caron B. Transmitter identification using embedded spread spectrum sequences. Proc. International Conference on Communication Technology, ICCT 2003,2:1517-1523.
    [17]Wang Xianbin, Wu Y, Caron B. Transmitter identification using embedded pseudo random sequences. IEEE Transactions on Broadcasting,2004,50(3):244-252.
    [18]H.Choe, C.E.Poole, A.M.Yu. Novel Identification of Intercepted Signals from Unknown Radio Transmitters. Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering,1995,2491:504-516.
    [19]C.D.Luigi, C.Jauffret. Estimation and Classification of FM Signals using Time Frequency Transforms. IEEE Trans. on Aerospace and Electronic Systems,2005, 41(2):421-437.
    [20]王伦文,王铭三,杨俊安等.电台“指纹”特征初探.计算机与网络,2001,10:29-30.
    [21]王伦文,钟子发.2FSK信号“指纹”特征的研究.电讯技术,2003,3:45-48
    [22]徐书华.基于信号指纹的通信辐射源个体识别技术研究[学位论文].华中科技大学,2007.
    [23]J.K.Tugnait. Detection of non-Gaussian Signals using Integrated Polyspectrum. IEEE Trans, on Signal Processing,1994,42 (12):3137-3149.
    [24]马君国,肖怀铁,李保国.基于局部围线积分双谱的空间目标识别算法.系统工程与电子技术,2005,27(8):1490-1493.
    [25]V.Chandran, S.L.Elgar. Pattern Recognition using Invariants Defined from Higher Order Spectra to One-dimensional Inputs. IEEE Trans. on Signal Processing, 1993,41 (1):205-212.
    [26]Shuhua Xu, Benxiong Huang, Lina Xu. Radio transmitter classification using a new method of stray features analysis combined with PCA. Military Communications Conference,2007.
    [27]Xian-Da Zhang, Yu Shi, Zheng Bao. A New Feature Vector Using Selected Bispectra for Signal Classification With Application in Radar Target Recognition. IEEE Trans, on Signal Processing,2001,49(9):1875-1885.
    [28]蔡忠伟,李建东.基于双谱的通信辐射源个体识别.通信学报,2007,28(2)75-79.
    [29]李勇智.图像特征提取方法及其在人脸识别中的应用[学位论文].南京理工大学,2009.
    [30]K.Fukunaga. Introduction to Statistical Pattern Recognition. New York: Academic Press, Inc.2nd Ed,1990.
    [31]A.Hyvarinen, J.Karhunen, E.Oja. Independent Component Analysis. New York: John Wiley,2001.
    [32]B.Scholkopf, A.Smola, K.R.Muller. Nonlinear component analysis as a kernel eigenvalue problem. Neural Computation,1998,10(5):1299-1319.
    [33]S.Mika, G.Ratseh, J.Weston. Fisher discriminant analysis with kernels. IEEE Neural Networks for Signal Processing Workshop,1999:41-48.
    [34]J.B.Tenenbaum, V.de Silva, J.C.Langford. A Global Geometric Framework for Nonlinear Dimenslonality Reduction. Science,2000,290:2319-2322.
    [35]S.T.Roweis, L.K.Saul. Nonlinear dimensionality reduction by locally linear embedding. Science,2000,290:2323-2326.
    [36]刘天羽.基于特征选择技术的集成学习方法及其应用研究[学位论文].上海大学,2006.
    [37]Z.Pawlak. Rough set theory and its application to data analysis. International Journal of Cybernetics and Systems,1998,29:661-688.
    [38]N.Ueda. Optimal Linear Combination of Neural Networks for Improving Classification Performance. IEEE Trans on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, 2000,22(2):207-215.
    [39]N.Cristianini, J.Shawe-Taylor. An introduction to support vector machines and other kernel-based methods. Cambridge University Press,2000.
    [40]R.R.Yager. The induced fuzzy integral aggregation operator, International Journal of Intelligent Systems,2002,17(11):1049-1065.
    [41]N.Ye. A Markov Chain Model of Temporal Behavior for Anomaly Detection. In: Proceedings of the IEEE Symposium on Security and Privacy,2000:171-174.
    [42]I.Guyon, A.Elissee. An introduction to variable and feature selection, Journal of machine learning research,2003,3:1157-1182.
    [43]Z.H.Sun, Z.H.Bebis. Object detection using feature subset selection. Pattern Recgnition,2004,37(3):2165-2176.
    [44]A.Jain, R.Duin. Statistical Pattern recognition:a review. IEEE transaction on Pattern analysis and machine intelligence,2000,22(1):4-37.
    [45]M.Kudo, J.Sklansky. Comparison of algorithms that select features for pattern classifiers. Pattern recognition,2000,33:25-41.
    [46]B.V.Dasarathy. Nearest Neighbor (NN) Norms:NN Pattern Classification Techniques.Los Alamitos, USA:IEEE Computer Society Press,1991.
    [47]B.E.Boser, I.M.Guyon, V.Vapnik. A training algorithm for optimal margin classifiers, Proceedings of the fifth annual ACM workshop on Computational Learning Theory, Pittsburgh, PA, USA,1992:144-152.
    [48]T.M Cover, P.E.Hart. Nearest neighbor pattern classification. IEEE Transactions on Information Theory,1967, 13(1):21-27.
    [49]S.Z.Li. Face recognition based on nearest linear combinations, Computer Vision and Pattern recognition,1998:839-844.
    [50]边肇棋,张学工等.模式识别,第二版.北京:清华大学出版社,1999.
    [51]J.A.Anderson. Logistic Discrimination, In:Handbook of Statistics. P. R. Krishnaiah,2 nd, New York:North-Holland,1981:169-191.
    [52]L.E.Baum, T.Petrie, G.Soules. A maximization technique occurring in the statistical analysis of Probabilistic function of Markov chains. Annals of Mathematical Statistics,1970,41(1):164-171.
    [53]R.A.Fisher. The use of multiple measurements in taxonomic problems. Annals of Eugenics,1936,7:178-188.
    [54]S.Mika, G.Ratsch, J.Weston, et al. Fisher discriminant analysis with kernels. In: Proceedings of IEEE Neural Networks for Signal Processing Workshop Madison, Wiscosin, USA,1999,9:41-48.
    [55]Kai Yu, Liang Ji, Xuegong Zhang. Kernel nearest-neighbor algorithm. Neural Processing Letters,2002(15):147-256.
    [56]M.Eric, M.L.Dukic, M.Obradovic. Frequency hopping signal separation by spatio-frequency analysis based on MUSIC method. Spread Spectrum Techniques and Applications,2000:78-82.
    [57]王斌,陈秋华,王翠柏.基于聚类的跳频信号分选.北京邮电大学学报,2009,32(2):80-84.
    [58]骆振兴,赵知劲.基于功放瞬态响应的跳频电台分选方法.杭州电子科技大学学报,2009,29(1):29-32.
    [59]许丹.辐射源指纹机理及识别方法研究[学位论文].国防科学技术大学,2008.
    [60]柳征.辐射源调制分类与个体识别技术研究[学位论文].长沙:国防科学技术大学,2005.
    [61]F.Camastra, A.Vinciareli. Intrinsic dimension estimation of data:An approach based on Grassber-Procaccia's algorithm. Neural Processing Letters,2001,14(1): 27-34.
    [62]D.Logan, J.Mahtew. Using the correlation dimension for vibration fault diagnosis of rolling element bearing-basic concepts. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, 1996,10(3):241-250.
    [63]O.H.Tekbas, O.Ureten, N. Serinken. Improvement of Transmitter Identification System for Low SNR Transients. Electronics Letters,2004,40(3):182-183.
    [64]任春晖.通信电台个体特征分析[学位论文].电子科技大学,2006.
    [65]O.H.Tekbas, N.Serinken. Transmitter Fingerprinting from Turn-on Transients. NATO Set Panel Symposium on Passive and LPI Radio Frequency Sensors,2001:1-4.
    [66]蔡权伟,多分量信号的信号分量分离技术研究[学位论文].电子科技大学,2006.
    [67]N.E.Hunag, Z.Shen, S.R.Long, et al. The empirical mode decomposition and the Hilbert spectrum for nonlinear and non-stationary time series analysis. Proc.R.Soc. Lond. A,1998,454:903-995.
    [68]H.T.Vincent, S.L.Hu, Z.Hou. Damage detection using empirical mode decomposition method and a comparison with wavelet analysis. Proc.of the 2nd international workshop on structural health monitoring,2000.
    [69]X.J.Liao, Z.Bao. Circularly integrated bispectra:novel shift invariant features for high-resolution radar target recognition. Electronics Letters,1998,34 (19):1879-1880.
    [70]时宇.特征估计与提取方法研究及在雷达目标识别中的应用[学位论文].清华大学,2000.
    [71]S.A.Kay. Fast and Accurate Single Frequency Estimator. IEEE Trans.on ASSP, 1998,37(12):1987-1990.
    [72]D.C.Rife, R.R.Bootstyn. Single-tone Parameter Estimation from Discrete-time Observation. IEEE Trans. on Information Theory,1974,20(5):591-598.
    [73]S.D.Casey, B.M.Sadle, Modifications of the Euclidean algorithm for isolating periodicities from a sparse set of noisy measurements, Proc. IEEE ICASS.P,1996, 44(9):2260-2272.
    [74]C.S.Ramalingam. On the equivalence of DESA-la and Prony method when the signal is a sinusoid. Signal Processing Letters, IEEE,1996,3(5):141-143.
    [75]S.A.Kay. Statistically/computationally efficient frequency estimation. Proc.IEEE ICASSP,1988,4:2292-2295.
    [76]O.Bessen, P.Stoica. Frequency Estimation and Detection for Sinusoidal Signals with Arbitrary Envelope:a Nonlinear Least-squares Approach. Proceedings of IEEE ICASSP'98,1998,4:2209-2212.
    [77]J.C.Imbeaux. Performances of the Delay-Line Multiplier Circuit for Clock and Carrier Synchronization in Digital Satellite Communications, IEEE Journal on Selected Areas in Communications,1983, SAC-1(1):82-92.
    [78]W.A.Wickert, R.L.Turcotte. Rate-Line Detection Using High-order Spectra, IEEE MILCOM'92,1992,3:1221-1225.
    [79]N.Delprat, B.Escudii, P.Guillemain, et al. Asymptotic wavelet and Gabor analysis:extraction of instantaneous frequencies. IEEE Transactions on Information Theory,1992,38(2):644-664.
    [80]Z.H.Yu, Y.Q.Shi, W.Su. Symbol-rate Estimation based on Filter Bank, ISCAS 2005,2:1437-1440.
    [81]李世雄,陈东方.信号瞬时参数计算方法评价.信号处理,2003,19(1):59-63.
    [82]罗明,杨绍全,郑文秀等.一种用于信号侦测的码元速率估计方法.电子对抗技术,2005,20(5):3-6.
    [83]N.E.Hunag, Z.Shen, S.R.Long, et al. The empirical mode decomposition and the Hilbert spectrum for nonlinear and non-stationary time series analysis. Proc. R. Soc. Lond.,1998,454:903-995.
    [84]吕铁军.通信信号调制识别研究[学位论文].电子科技大学,2000.
    [85]Y.Y.Tang, Y.Tao, E.Lam. New method for feature extraction based on fractal behavior, Pattern Recognition,2002,35(5):1071-1081.
    [86]Y.Tao, E.Lam, Y.Y.Tang. Feature extraction using wavelet and fractal, Pattern Recognition Letters,2001,22(3):271-287.
    [87]C.E.Priebe, J.L.Solka, R.A.Lorey. The application of fractal analysis to mammographic tissue classification, Cancer Letters,1994,77(2):183-189.
    [88]张葛祥,胡来招,金炜东.雷达辐射源信号脉内特征分析.红外与毫米波学报,2004,23(6):477-480.
    [89]Z.Pawlak. Rough Sets—Theoretical Aspects of Reasoning about Data. Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht,1991.
    [90]J.Wang, R.Wang, D.Q.Miao, et al. Data enriching based on rough set theory. Chinese Journal of Computers,1998,21 (5):393-400.
    [91]Y.Shi, Y.F.Sun, C.Zuo. Spatial Data Classification Based on Rough Set. Journal of Software,2000,11(5):673-678.
    [92]胡清华,于达仁,谢宗霞.基于邻域粒化和粗糙逼近的数值属性约简.软件学报,2008,19(3):640-649.
    [93]T.Y.Lin, Neighborhood systems and approximation in database and knowledge base systems. In:Proceedings of the Fourth International Symposium on Methodologies of Intelligent Systems, Poster Session,1989:75-86.
    [94]秦雪霏,韩立国,李巍.地震波多次散射波场的高阶谱统计分析.吉林大学学报(地球科学版),2007,37:91-94.
    [95]D.M.Yang, A.F.Stronach, P.Macconnell, et al. Third-order spectral techniques for the diagnosis of motor bearing condition using artificial neural networks. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing,2006,16(2,3):391-411.
    [96]李耀波,任志良,陈宏波.一种水下目标辐射噪声调制特征提取方法.鱼雷技术,2006,14(3):21-24.
    [97]F.R.Dwyer. Use of the kurtosis statistic in the frequency domain as an aid in detecting random signals. IEEE Journal of Oceanic Engineering,1984,9(2):85-92.
    [98]C.Ottonello, S.Pagnan. Modified frequency domain kurtosis for signal processing. Electronics Letters,1994,30(14):1117-1118.
    [99]牛龙,马建仓,王毅等.一种新的基于峰度的盲源分离开关算法.系统仿真学报,2005,17(1):185-188.
    [100]V.Vapnik. The Nature of Statistical Learning Theory. New York: Springer-Verlag,1995.
    [101]J.C.Burgos, A Tutorial on Support Vector Machines for Pattern Recognition. Data Mining and Knowledge Discovery,2nd,1998:121-167.
    [102]M.Dash, H.Liu. Feature selection for classification. Intelligent Data Analysis, 1997:131-156.
    [103]M.Dettling, P.Buhlmann. Finding predictive gene groups from microarray data. Journal of multivariate analysis,2004,90:106-131.
    [104]P.Mitra, C.A.Murthy, S.K.Pal. Unsupervised feature selection using feature similarity. IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence,2002, 24(3):301-312.
    [105]A.Webb. Statistical pattern recognition. Wiley,1999.
    [106]Y.Hamamoto, S.Uchimuar, et al. Evaluation of the branch and bound algorithm for feature selection. Pattern recognition letters,1990,24(7):681-684.
    [107]W.Siedlechi, J. Sklansky. A note on genetic algorithms for large-scale feature selection. Pattern Recognition Letters,1989,10:335-347.
    [108]Qinghua Hu, Daren Yu, Jinfu Liu, et al. Neighborhood rough set based heterogeneous feature subset selection. Information Sciences,2008,178:3577-3594.
    [109]C.F.Lin, S.D.Wang. Fuzzy support vector machines. IEEE Trans, on Neural Networks,2002,13(2):464-471.
    [110]范昕炜,杜树新,吴铁军.可补偿类别差异的加权支持向量机算法.中国图像图形学报,2003,8(9):1037-1042.
    [111]J. Kitler. Combining classifiers:A theoretical framework. Pattern Analysis and Applications,1998, 1(1):18-27.
    [112]S. Prabhakar, A. K. Jain. Decision-level Fusion in Biometric Verification. Pattern Recognition,2002,35(4):861-874.
    [113]李士进,郭跃飞,杨静宇.基于多分类器的人脸识别.数据采集与处理,2000,15(3):293-296.
    [114]J.Kitter, J.Matas, KJonsson, et al. Combining evidence in personal identity verification systems, Pattern Recognition Letters,1997:845-852.
    [115]D.Genoud, G.Gravier, F.Bimbot, et al, Combining methods to improve the p hone based speaker verification decision, Prop, Conf. Speech and Language P rocessing,1996,3:1756-1760.
    [116]G.Giacinto, R.Paolucci, F.Roli, Application of neural networks and statistical pattern recognition algorithms to earthquake risk evaluations, Pattern Recognition Letters,1997,18:1353-1362.
    [117]B.Parmanto, P.W.Munro, H.R.Doyle. Reducing variance of committee prediction with resampling techniques. Connection Science,1996,8:405-426.
    [118]Y.S.Huang, C.Y.Suen, A method of combining multiple experts for the recognition of unconstrained handwriting numerals, IEEE Trans. Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence,1995,117:90-94
    [119]T.K.Ho. Recognition of Handwritten Digits by Combining Independent Learning Vector Quantization. Proc.2nd ICDAR, Japan,1993.
    [120]J. Killter, M.Hatef, R.Duin, et al. On Combining Classifiers. IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence,1998,20(3):226-239.
    [121]A.Verikas, A.Lipnickas, K.Malmqvist, et al. Soft combination of neural classifiers:a comparative study. Pattern Recognition letters,1999,20 (4):429-444.
    [122]R.Rifkin, A.Klautau. Indefense of one-vs-all classfication, Journal of Machine Learning Research,2004,5:101-141.
    [123]L.W. Nemsiek, E. Geraniotis. Adaptive Multichannel Detection of Frequency Hooping Signals. Transactions on Communications,1992,40(9):1502-1511.
    [124]D.J. Torrieri. Frequency-hopping signal detection using partial band coverage. IEEE Trans. Aeros. Elec. Syst.1993,29(2):540-553.
    [125]S.Hinedi, A.Polydoros. DS/LPI autocorrelation detection in noise plus random-toneinterference. IEEE Transactions on Communications,1990:805-817.
    [126]C.D.Chung, A.Polydoros. Parameter Estimation of Random FH Signals using autocorrelation techniques. IEEE Trans.Comm.,1995,43(2-4):1097-1106.
    [127]S. Barbarossa. Parameter estimation of spread spectrum frequency hopping signals using time-frequency distributions, singal Processing Advances in wireless Communications, First IEEE Signal Proeessing Workshop on,1997:213-216.
    [128]姜园.通信对抗中的现代信号处理技术应用研究[学位论文],浙江大学,2004.
    [129]L.R.Rabiner, R.W.Schafer. Digital Processing of Speech Signal. Englewood Cliffs, NJ:Prentice- Hall Signal Proeessing Series,1978.
    [130]L.Cohen. Time-Frequency Analysis. Englewood Cliffs, NJ:Prentice- Hall, 1995.
    [131]李世雄.小波变换及其应用.北京:高等教育出版社,1997.
    [132]Y.Meyer. Wavelets algorithms and applications, Monographs on Mathematical Modeling and Computation. Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics Series, Philadelphia,1993.

© 2004-2018 中国地质图书馆版权所有 京ICP备05064691号 京公网安备11010802017129号

地址:北京市海淀区学院路29号 邮编:100083

电话:办公室:(+86 10)66554848;文献借阅、咨询服务、科技查新:66554700